"""Execution-fingerprint ensemble voting over existing eval reports.""" from __future__ import annotations import argparse import json import sys from collections import defaultdict from collections.abc import Sequence from dataclasses import fields, replace from pathlib import Path from typing import Any, Literal, cast from sqlalchemy import Engine from nl_sql.agent.graph import PipelineRunResult from nl_sql.db.registry import DatabaseRegistry, get_default_registry from nl_sql.eval.metrics.execution_accuracy import ResultComparison, compare_results from nl_sql.eval.report import write_html_report, write_json_report from nl_sql.eval.runner import ( Configuration, EvalRecord, EvalRun, EvalSummary, _execute_gold, _summarise, _to_dialect, ) from nl_sql.eval.self_consistency import Candidate, fingerprint_rows, vote from nl_sql.execution.errors import ExecutionErrorKind from nl_sql.execution.runner import ExecutionOutcome, execute_validated STATEMENT_TIMEOUT_MS = 30_000 ROW_CAP = 10_000 type FallbackMode = Literal["first", "highest-confidence"] type RecordMeta = dict[str, Any] type ReportMember = tuple[int, EvalRecord, RecordMeta, ExecutionOutcome, str] def main(argv: list[str] | None = None) -> int: parser = argparse.ArgumentParser(description=__doc__) parser.add_argument("--reports", nargs="+", type=Path, required=True) parser.add_argument("--out", type=Path, required=True) parser.add_argument("--require-quorum", type=int, default=2) parser.add_argument( "--fallback-on-no-quorum", choices=["first", "highest-confidence"], default="first", ) args = parser.parse_args(argv) if len(args.reports) < 2: parser.error("--reports requires at least two report files") if args.require_quorum < 1: parser.error("--require-quorum must be >= 1") runs: list[EvalRun] = [] metadata: list[dict[int, RecordMeta]] = [] for path in args.reports: run, meta = _load_report(path) runs.append(run) metadata.append(meta) ensemble, quorum_count, fallback_count = ensemble_runs( runs, metadata, registry=get_default_registry(), require_quorum=args.require_quorum, fallback_on_no_quorum=cast(FallbackMode, args.fallback_on_no_quorum), ) _write_reports(ensemble, args.out) total = ensemble.overall.n quorum_pct = (quorum_count / total * 100.0) if total else 0.0 fallback_pct = (fallback_count / total * 100.0) if total else 0.0 print( f"ensemble n={total} EA={ensemble.overall.ea * 100:.1f}%, " f"quorum={quorum_pct:.1f}%, fallback={fallback_pct:.1f}%" ) return 0 def ensemble_runs( runs: Sequence[EvalRun], metadata: Sequence[dict[int, RecordMeta]], *, registry: DatabaseRegistry, require_quorum: int, fallback_on_no_quorum: FallbackMode, ) -> tuple[EvalRun, int, int]: if len(runs) != len(metadata): raise ValueError("runs and metadata must have the same length") if not runs: raise ValueError("at least one report is required") indices = [{record.question_id: record for record in run.records} for run in runs] common_qids = set(indices[0]) for index in indices[1:]: common_qids &= set(index) ordered_qids = [ record.question_id for record in runs[0].records if record.question_id in common_qids ] engines: dict[str, Engine] = {} merged: list[EvalRecord] = [] quorum_count = 0 fallback_count = 0 try: for qid in ordered_qids: members = [ _execute_member( report_idx, indices[report_idx][qid], metadata[report_idx].get(qid, {}), runs[report_idx].sql_model, registry=registry, engines=engines, ) for report_idx in range(len(runs)) ] winner, used_quorum = _choose_winner( members, require_quorum=require_quorum, fallback_on_no_quorum=fallback_on_no_quorum, ) if used_quorum: quorum_count += 1 else: fallback_count += 1 merged.append(_score_winner(winner, registry=registry, engines=engines)) finally: for engine in engines.values(): engine.dispose() sql_models = sorted({run.sql_model for run in runs}) return ( _summarise( configuration=runs[0].configuration, sql_model=" + ".join(sql_models), records=merged, ), quorum_count, fallback_count, ) def _execute_member( report_idx: int, record: EvalRecord, meta: RecordMeta, report_model: str, *, registry: DatabaseRegistry, engines: dict[str, Engine], ) -> ReportMember: engine = _engine_for_record(record, registry=registry, engines=engines) outcome = execute_validated( engine, record.pred_sql, dialect=_to_dialect(record.dialect), statement_timeout_ms=STATEMENT_TIMEOUT_MS, row_cap=ROW_CAP, ) return (report_idx, record, meta, outcome, report_model) def _choose_winner( members: Sequence[ReportMember], *, require_quorum: int, fallback_on_no_quorum: FallbackMode, ) -> tuple[ReportMember, bool]: clusters: dict[str, list[ReportMember]] = defaultdict(list) for member in members: outcome = member[3] if outcome.result is None: continue if outcome.error_kind in ( ExecutionErrorKind.INVALID_SQL, ExecutionErrorKind.EXECUTION_FAILED, ): continue clusters[fingerprint_rows(outcome.result.rows)].append(member) if clusters: best_cluster = _best_cluster(list(clusters.values())) if len(best_cluster) >= require_quorum: return _pick_member_from_cluster(best_cluster), True return _fallback_member(members, fallback_on_no_quorum), False def _best_cluster(clusters: Sequence[list[ReportMember]]) -> list[ReportMember]: best = clusters[0] for cluster in clusters[1:]: if len(cluster) > len(best): best = cluster continue if len(cluster) < len(best): continue cluster_conf = _max_confidence(cluster) best_conf = _max_confidence(best) if cluster_conf is None and best_conf is None: continue if cluster_conf is not None and (best_conf is None or cluster_conf > best_conf): best = cluster continue if cluster_conf == best_conf and _cluster_model_name(cluster) < _cluster_model_name(best): best = cluster return best def _pick_member_from_cluster(cluster: Sequence[ReportMember]) -> ReportMember: if _max_confidence(cluster) is None: return cluster[0] ordered = sorted( enumerate(cluster), key=lambda item: (_model_name(item[1]), item[1][0]), ) temperature_by_pos = {pos: float(rank) for rank, (pos, _) in enumerate(ordered)} candidates = [ Candidate( result=_pipeline_result_for_member(member), temperature=temperature_by_pos[pos], ) for pos, member in enumerate(cluster) ] winner = vote(candidates) for pos, candidate in enumerate(candidates): if candidate is winner: return cluster[pos] return cluster[0] def _fallback_member( members: Sequence[ReportMember], fallback_on_no_quorum: FallbackMode, ) -> ReportMember: if fallback_on_no_quorum == "first": return members[0] if all(_confidence(member) is None for member in members): return members[0] return min( members, key=_fallback_sort_key, ) def _fallback_sort_key(member: ReportMember) -> tuple[float, str, int]: confidence = _confidence(member) return (-(confidence if confidence is not None else -1.0), _model_name(member), member[0]) def _score_winner( member: ReportMember, *, registry: DatabaseRegistry, engines: dict[str, Engine], ) -> EvalRecord: _, record, _, outcome, _ = member engine = _engine_for_record(record, registry=registry, engines=engines) gold_rows, _ = _execute_gold( engine, record.gold_sql, statement_timeout_ms=STATEMENT_TIMEOUT_MS, row_cap=ROW_CAP, ) if outcome.result is None: comparison = ResultComparison( match=False, reason=( f"pred failed: {outcome.error_kind.value}" if outcome.error_kind else "pred failed: unknown" ), gold_rows=len(gold_rows), pred_rows=0, ) else: comparison = compare_results(gold_rows, outcome.result.rows, gold_sql=record.gold_sql) return replace( record, match=comparison.match, error_kind=outcome.error_kind.value if outcome.error_kind else None, error_message=outcome.error_message, pred_row_count=comparison.pred_rows, gold_row_count=comparison.gold_rows, comparison_reason=comparison.reason, ) def _pipeline_result_for_member(member: ReportMember) -> PipelineRunResult: _, record, _, outcome, _ = member confidence = _confidence(member) or 0.0 return PipelineRunResult( question=record.question, db_id=record.db_id, sql=record.pred_sql, rationale="", confidence=confidence, outcome=outcome, output_format=None, caption="", error_kind=outcome.error_kind, error_message=outcome.error_message, repair_attempted=record.repair_attempted, trace=[ { "node": "generate_sql", "model": _model_name(member), "confidence": confidence, } ], ) def _engine_for_record( record: EvalRecord, *, registry: DatabaseRegistry, engines: dict[str, Engine], ) -> Engine: if record.db_id not in engines: try: spec = registry.get(record.db_id) except KeyError: spec = registry.get(f"bird_{record.db_id}") engines[record.db_id] = spec.make_engine() return engines[record.db_id] def _max_confidence(members: Sequence[ReportMember]) -> float | None: values = [_confidence(member) for member in members] present = [value for value in values if value is not None] return max(present) if present else None def _confidence(member: ReportMember) -> float | None: value = member[2].get("confidence") if isinstance(value, bool): return None if isinstance(value, int | float): return float(value) return None def _cluster_model_name(members: Sequence[ReportMember]) -> str: confidence = _max_confidence(members) if confidence is None: return _model_name(members[0]) return min(_model_name(member) for member in members if _confidence(member) == confidence) def _model_name(member: ReportMember) -> str: raw = member[2].get("model") if not isinstance(raw, str) or not raw: raw = member[2].get("sql_model") if isinstance(raw, str) and raw: return raw return member[4] def _load_report(path: Path) -> tuple[EvalRun, dict[int, RecordMeta]]: raw = json.loads(path.read_text(encoding="utf-8")) if not isinstance(raw, dict): raise ValueError(f"{path} is not a JSON object") payload = cast(dict[str, Any], raw) records_raw = payload.get("records") if not isinstance(records_raw, list): raise ValueError(f"{path} does not contain a records list") record_fields = {field.name for field in fields(EvalRecord)} records: list[EvalRecord] = [] metadata: dict[int, RecordMeta] = {} for item in records_raw: if not isinstance(item, dict): raise ValueError(f"{path} contains a non-object record") record_payload = cast(dict[str, Any], item) coerced = {key: value for key, value in record_payload.items() if key in record_fields} for key in ("gold_tables", "retrieved_tables"): value = coerced.get(key) if isinstance(value, list): coerced[key] = tuple(value) record = EvalRecord(**coerced) records.append(record) metadata[record.question_id] = record_payload per_difficulty_raw = payload.get("per_difficulty") or {} if not isinstance(per_difficulty_raw, dict): raise ValueError(f"{path} has invalid per_difficulty") return ( EvalRun( configuration=Configuration(str(payload["configuration"])), sql_model=str(payload["sql_model"]), overall=EvalSummary(**payload["overall"]), per_difficulty={ str(key): EvalSummary(**value) for key, value in cast(dict[str, Any], per_difficulty_raw).items() }, records=records, ), metadata, ) def _write_reports(run: EvalRun, out: Path) -> None: json_path = write_json_report(run, root=out, name_suffix="ensemble") siblings: list[EvalRun] = [] for other in sorted(json_path.parent.glob("*.json")): if other == json_path: continue try: siblings.append(_load_report(other)[0]) except (KeyError, TypeError, ValueError, json.JSONDecodeError): continue write_html_report([*siblings, run], root=out) if __name__ == "__main__": sys.exit(main())