[
  {
    "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE",
    "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.",
    "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 564,472,013 bytes",
    "removed": {
      "key": "0:1:2:1:1:1:1:2:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-Q6_K.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-Q6_K",
      "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0",
      "provider": "MagicQuant",
      "quantFamily": "Q8_0",
      "isHybrid": true,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true,
      "kld": 0.003061,
      "ppl": 5.682076,
      "pplDeltaPercent": -0.1076614746316901,
      "sizeBytes": 26940999360,
      "sizeGB": 26.94099936,
      "sizeGiB": 25.09076088666916
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "0:1:1:1:1:1:1:2:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-Q6_K_1.gguf",
      "displayName": "MQ-Q6_K_1",
      "shortName": "MQ-Q6_K_1",
      "provider": "MagicQuant",
      "quantFamily": "Q6_K",
      "isHybrid": true,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true,
      "kld": 0.002845,
      "ppl": 5.680246,
      "pplDeltaPercent": -0.13983333919341434,
      "sizeBytes": 27248916160,
      "sizeGB": 27.24891616,
      "sizeGiB": 25.37753075361252
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.00021600000000000005,
      "sizeBytes": -307916800,
      "sizeGB": -0.3079168,
      "sizeGiB": -0.2867698669433594,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": -0.1076614746316901,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.13983333919341434,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.032171864561724245
    }
  },
  {
    "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE",
    "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.",
    "rawReason": "strict hybrid dominance: best accepted actual KLD at same-or-smaller real size",
    "removed": {
      "key": "0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-Q8_0.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-Q8_0",
      "shortName": "LM-Q8_0",
      "provider": "llama.cpp",
      "quantFamily": "Q8_0",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.003768,
      "ppl": 5.677782,
      "pplDeltaPercent": -0.18315108470167157,
      "sizeBytes": 28595762880,
      "sizeGB": 28.59576288,
      "sizeGiB": 26.63187950849533
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "0:1:2:1:1:1:1:2:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-Q6_K.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-Q6_K",
      "shortName": "MQ-Q8_0",
      "provider": "MagicQuant",
      "quantFamily": "Q8_0",
      "isHybrid": true,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true,
      "kld": 0.003061,
      "ppl": 5.682076,
      "pplDeltaPercent": -0.1076614746316901,
      "sizeBytes": 26940999360,
      "sizeGB": 26.94099936,
      "sizeGiB": 25.09076088666916
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.0007070000000000002,
      "sizeBytes": 1654763520,
      "sizeGB": 1.65476352,
      "sizeGiB": 1.5411186218261719,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": -0.18315108470167157,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.1076614746316901,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.07548961006998148
    }
  },
  {
    "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE",
    "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.",
    "rawReason": "strict hybrid dominance: best accepted actual KLD at same-or-smaller real size",
    "removed": {
      "key": "1:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-Q6_K.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-Q6_K",
      "shortName": "LM-Q6_K",
      "provider": "llama.cpp",
      "quantFamily": "Q6_K",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.007249,
      "ppl": 5.706878,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 0.32836398157588564,
      "sizeBytes": 22082528960,
      "sizeGB": 22.08252896,
      "sizeGiB": 20.565957725048065
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "0:6:2:7:1:1:108:3:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-Q5_K_S_1.gguf",
      "displayName": "MQ-Q5_K_S_1",
      "shortName": "MQ-Q5_K_S_1",
      "provider": "MagicQuant",
      "quantFamily": "Q5_K_S",
      "isHybrid": true,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true,
      "kld": 0.006477,
      "ppl": 5.681127,
      "pplDeltaPercent": -0.12434513554375913,
      "sizeBytes": 21900871360,
      "sizeGB": 21.90087136,
      "sizeGiB": 20.396775901317596
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.0007720000000000001,
      "sizeBytes": 181657600,
      "sizeGB": 0.1816576,
      "sizeGiB": 0.16918182373046875,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.32836398157588564,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": -0.12434513554375913,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.4527091171196448
    }
  },
  {
    "reasonCode": "STRICT_DOMINANCE",
    "reasonDescription": "The winner was no larger and had lower real KLD than the removed anchor.",
    "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning strict dominance fallback: real benchmark validated lower KLD at same-or-smaller size",
    "removed": {
      "key": "105:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-UD-Q4_K_XL.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-UD-Q4_K_XL",
      "shortName": "UD-Q4_K_XL",
      "provider": "Unsloth",
      "quantFamily": "UD-Q4_K_XL",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": true,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.023521,
      "ppl": 5.760769,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 1.2757814422840206,
      "sizeBytes": 17612564160,
      "sizeGB": 17.61256416,
      "sizeGiB": 16.402978599071503
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "105:6:106:7:14:106:106:106:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-IQ4_NL_1.gguf",
      "displayName": "MQ-IQ4_NL_1",
      "shortName": "MQ-IQ4_NL_1",
      "provider": "MagicQuant",
      "quantFamily": "IQ4_NL",
      "isHybrid": true,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true,
      "kld": 0.019687,
      "ppl": 5.727233,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 0.6862100488731036,
      "sizeBytes": 17588438720,
      "sizeGB": 17.58843872,
      "sizeGiB": 16.38051003217697
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.0038340000000000006,
      "sizeBytes": 24125440,
      "sizeGB": 0.024125439999999998,
      "sizeGiB": 0.02246856689453125,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.2757814422840206,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 0.6862100488731036,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 0.589571393410917
    }
  },
  {
    "reasonCode": "NEAR_BASELINE_PREMIUM",
    "reasonDescription": "The winner used only the configured near-baseline size premium and beat the real linear KLD trade line.",
    "rawReason": "smart baseline-tuning near-baseline fallback within \u002B1% size premium",
    "removed": {
      "key": "104:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-UD-Q3_K_XL.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-UD-Q3_K_XL",
      "shortName": "UD-Q3_K_XL",
      "provider": "Unsloth",
      "quantFamily": "UD-Q3_K_XL",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": true,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.044843,
      "ppl": 5.733645,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 0.7989346366161519,
      "sizeBytes": 14473430720,
      "sizeGB": 14.47343072,
      "sizeGiB": 13.479432761669159
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "104:6:105:105:14:105:105:105:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-IQ3_M_1.gguf",
      "displayName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1",
      "shortName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1",
      "provider": "MagicQuant",
      "quantFamily": "IQ3_M",
      "isHybrid": true,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true,
      "kld": 0.043802,
      "ppl": 5.751239,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 1.1082416230090335,
      "sizeBytes": 14492272320,
      "sizeGB": 14.49227232,
      "sizeGiB": 13.496980369091034
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.0010410000000000003,
      "sizeBytes": -18841600,
      "sizeGB": -0.0188416,
      "sizeGiB": -0.017547607421875,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.7989346366161519,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.1082416230090335,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.30930698639288157
    }
  },
  {
    "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE",
    "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.",
    "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 564,472,013 bytes",
    "removed": {
      "key": "104:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-UD-Q3_K_XL.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-UD-Q3_K_XL",
      "shortName": "UD-Q3_K_XL",
      "provider": "Unsloth",
      "quantFamily": "UD-Q3_K_XL",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": true,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.044843,
      "ppl": 5.733645,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 0.7989346366161519,
      "sizeBytes": 14473430720,
      "sizeGB": 14.47343072,
      "sizeGiB": 13.479432761669159
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "104:6:105:105:14:105:105:105:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-MQ-IQ3_M_1.gguf",
      "displayName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1",
      "shortName": "MQ-IQ3_M_1",
      "provider": "MagicQuant",
      "quantFamily": "IQ3_M",
      "isHybrid": true,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": true,
      "kld": 0.043802,
      "ppl": 5.751239,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 1.1082416230090335,
      "sizeBytes": 14492272320,
      "sizeGB": 14.49227232,
      "sizeGiB": 13.496980369091034
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.0010410000000000003,
      "sizeBytes": -18841600,
      "sizeGB": -0.0188416,
      "sizeGiB": -0.017547607421875,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": 0.7989346366161519,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.1082416230090335,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.30930698639288157
    }
  },
  {
    "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE",
    "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.",
    "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 564,472,013 bytes",
    "removed": {
      "key": "8:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-IQ3_XS.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-IQ3_XS",
      "shortName": "LM-IQ3_XS",
      "provider": "llama.cpp",
      "quantFamily": "IQ3_XS",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.071307,
      "ppl": 5.76996,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 1.4373615555008623,
      "sizeBytes": 11967129280,
      "sizeGB": 11.96712928,
      "sizeGiB": 11.145257651805878
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "7:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-IQ3_S.gguf",
      "displayName": "LM-IQ3_S",
      "shortName": "LM-IQ3_S",
      "provider": "llama.cpp",
      "quantFamily": "IQ3_S",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.064393,
      "ppl": 5.795439,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 1.8852888435708988,
      "sizeBytes": 12419327680,
      "sizeGB": 12.41932768,
      "sizeGiB": 11.566400229930878
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.00691399999999999,
      "sizeBytes": -452198400,
      "sizeGB": -0.45219840000000006,
      "sizeGiB": -0.421142578125,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": 1.4373615555008623,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 1.8852888435708988,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": -0.44792728807003646
    }
  },
  {
    "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE",
    "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.",
    "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 564,472,013 bytes",
    "removed": {
      "key": "100:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-UD-IQ2_M.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-UD-IQ2_M",
      "shortName": "UD-IQ2_M",
      "provider": "Unsloth",
      "quantFamily": "UD-IQ2_M",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": true,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.133316,
      "ppl": 6.250984,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 9.893885587707882,
      "sizeBytes": 10846136000,
      "sizeGB": 10.846136,
      "sizeGiB": 10.101251304149628
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "9:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-IQ3_XXS.gguf",
      "displayName": "LM-IQ3_XXS",
      "shortName": "LM-IQ3_XXS",
      "provider": "llama.cpp",
      "quantFamily": "IQ3_XXS",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.093578,
      "ppl": 5.939434,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 4.416757497978273,
      "sizeBytes": 11186370240,
      "sizeGB": 11.18637024,
      "sizeGiB": 10.418119132518768
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.039737999999999996,
      "sizeBytes": -340234240,
      "sizeGB": -0.34023424,
      "sizeGiB": -0.3168678283691406,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": 9.893885587707882,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 4.416757497978273,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 5.477128089729608
    }
  },
  {
    "reasonCode": "SPACING_COLLAPSE",
    "reasonDescription": "Two candidates were too close in practical output space; the stronger one was kept.",
    "rawReason": "meaningful spacing collapse; size gap below 564,472,013 bytes",
    "removed": {
      "key": "11:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-IQ2_XS.gguf",
      "displayName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-IQ2_XS",
      "shortName": "LM-IQ2_XS",
      "provider": "llama.cpp",
      "quantFamily": "IQ2_XS",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.226206,
      "ppl": 6.678807,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 17.41512253436939,
      "sizeBytes": 9090590400,
      "sizeGB": 9.090590400000002,
      "sizeGiB": 8.466272056102753
    },
    "winner": {
      "key": "10:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0:0",
      "fileName": "Qwen3.6-27B-LM-IQ2_S.gguf",
      "displayName": "LM-IQ2_S",
      "shortName": "LM-IQ2_S",
      "provider": "llama.cpp",
      "quantFamily": "IQ2_S",
      "isHybrid": false,
      "isExternalPureBaseline": false,
      "isExternalRebuiltBaseline": false,
      "isMaterializedTensorMapped": false,
      "kld": 0.210251,
      "ppl": 6.500917,
      "pplDeltaPercent": 14.287771175415775,
      "sizeBytes": 9362912960,
      "sizeGB": 9.362912960000001,
      "sizeGiB": 8.71989220380783
    },
    "deltas": {
      "kld": 0.015954999999999997,
      "sizeBytes": -272322560,
      "sizeGB": -0.27232256,
      "sizeGiB": -0.2536201477050781,
      "removedPplDeltaPercent": 17.41512253436939,
      "winnerPplDeltaPercent": 14.287771175415775,
      "pplDeltaPercentImprovement": 3.127351358953616
    }
  }
]