{ "calibration": { "split": "calibration", "temperature": 1.0087398771573446, "default_prediction": "raw", "calibration_comparison": { "raw": { "count": 13766, "top1_accuracy": 0.8311782652912973, "nll": 0.6855602746553805, "brier_score": 0.010973403472421008, "ece": 0.1712850628941104, "signed_calibration_error": -0.17128506289411038, "kl_divergence": 0.02185337568727864, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11442, "mean": 0.694725726679517, "median": 0.6793243885040283, "std": 0.19659272893691354, "p25": 0.501576766371727, "p75": 0.8654205501079559 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2324, "mean": 0.48839847656309915, "median": 0.500387966632843, "std": 0.07211813579079812, "p25": 0.5000417530536652, "p75": 0.5010467320680618 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 134, "average_confidence": 0.27603658633445627, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5, "signed_gap": -0.22396341366554373 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 637, "average_confidence": 0.3581763524649843, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6923076923076923, "signed_gap": -0.334131339842708 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1197, "average_confidence": 0.45263352763583087, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7861319966583125, "signed_gap": -0.3334984690224816 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4710, "average_confidence": 0.520006962819717, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6322717622080679, "signed_gap": -0.11226479938835088 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1701, "average_confidence": 0.6498155774683338, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9711934156378601, "signed_gap": -0.32137783816952625 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1530, "average_confidence": 0.7490799561045528, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9888888888888889, "signed_gap": -0.23980893278433613 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1452, "average_confidence": 0.847257420872197, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9986225895316805, "signed_gap": -0.15136516865948346 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2405, "average_confidence": 0.9755763211765804, "empirical_accuracy": 0.997920997920998, "signed_gap": -0.022344676744417535 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8570390817957286, "accuracy": 0.8470079674521105, "risk": 0.1529920325478895, "sample_count": 11798 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.514891762312945, "accuracy": 0.9897009029345373, "risk": 0.010299097065462726, "sample_count": 7088 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.39132645648699693, "accuracy": 0.9955448301466493, "risk": 0.0044551698533507045, "sample_count": 5387 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.28018305971233476, "accuracy": 0.9981851179673321, "risk": 0.001814882032667886, "sample_count": 3857 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.1747057968908906, "accuracy": 0.997920997920998, "risk": 0.0020790020790020236, "sample_count": 2405 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.13162865029783524, "accuracy": 0.9977924944812362, "risk": 0.002207505518763808, "sample_count": 1812 } ] }, "temperature_scaled": { "count": 13766, "top1_accuracy": 0.8311782652912973, "nll": 0.6855494345867709, "brier_score": 0.010966401509070522, "ece": 0.17250904779846635, "signed_calibration_error": -0.17250904779846632, "kl_divergence": 0.02184253561866892, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11442, "mean": 0.6933398573451267, "median": 0.6774639946027864, "std": 0.19661340445165715, "p25": 0.5014006484541963, "p75": 0.863254437984726 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2324, "mean": 0.4879715147432757, "median": 0.5003803821956974, "std": 0.07215117413704505, "p25": 0.5000357963828128, "p75": 0.5010135416360336 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 137, "average_confidence": 0.2758391267365239, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5036496350364964, "signed_gap": -0.22781050829997251 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 642, "average_confidence": 0.3577477496059755, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6962616822429907, "signed_gap": -0.3385139326370152 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1215, "average_confidence": 0.4524140225007448, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7851851851851852, "signed_gap": -0.3327711626844404 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4721, "average_confidence": 0.5201900803979108, "empirical_accuracy": 0.633552213514086, "signed_gap": -0.11336213311617516 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1701, "average_confidence": 0.6500267694102276, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9723691945914168, "signed_gap": -0.32234242518118916 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1529, "average_confidence": 0.7491738888998721, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9895356442119032, "signed_gap": -0.24036175531203108 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1445, "average_confidence": 0.8472853994689213, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9986159169550173, "signed_gap": -0.15133051748609594 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2376, "average_confidence": 0.9759117055438289, "empirical_accuracy": 0.997895622895623, "signed_gap": -0.021983917351794058 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8551503704779893, "accuracy": 0.8470948012232415, "risk": 0.15290519877675846, "sample_count": 11772 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5122039808223159, "accuracy": 0.9900723301659339, "risk": 0.009927669834066122, "sample_count": 7051 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.38863867499636784, "accuracy": 0.9957009345794392, "risk": 0.004299065420560799, "sample_count": 5350 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.2775679209646956, "accuracy": 0.9981680188432348, "risk": 0.0018319811567651945, "sample_count": 3821 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.17259915734418133, "accuracy": 0.997895622895623, "risk": 0.002104377104377053, "sample_count": 2376 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.1306116518959756, "accuracy": 0.9977753058954394, "risk": 0.0022246941045606095, "sample_count": 1798 } ] } }, "overall": { "count": 13766, "top1_accuracy": 0.8311782652912973, "nll": 0.6855602746553805, "brier_score": 0.010973403472421008, "ece": 0.1712850628941104, "signed_calibration_error": -0.17128506289411038, "kl_divergence": 0.02185337568727864, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11442, "mean": 0.694725726679517, "median": 0.6793243885040283, "std": 0.19659272893691354, "p25": 0.501576766371727, "p75": 0.8654205501079559 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2324, "mean": 0.48839847656309915, "median": 0.500387966632843, "std": 0.07211813579079812, "p25": 0.5000417530536652, "p75": 0.5010467320680618 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 134, "average_confidence": 0.27603658633445627, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5, "signed_gap": -0.22396341366554373 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 637, "average_confidence": 0.3581763524649843, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6923076923076923, "signed_gap": -0.334131339842708 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1197, "average_confidence": 0.45263352763583087, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7861319966583125, "signed_gap": -0.3334984690224816 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4710, "average_confidence": 0.520006962819717, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6322717622080679, "signed_gap": -0.11226479938835088 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1701, "average_confidence": 0.6498155774683338, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9711934156378601, "signed_gap": -0.32137783816952625 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1530, "average_confidence": 0.7490799561045528, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9888888888888889, "signed_gap": -0.23980893278433613 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1452, "average_confidence": 0.847257420872197, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9986225895316805, "signed_gap": -0.15136516865948346 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2405, "average_confidence": 0.9755763211765804, "empirical_accuracy": 0.997920997920998, "signed_gap": -0.022344676744417535 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8570390817957286, "accuracy": 0.8470079674521105, "risk": 0.1529920325478895, "sample_count": 11798 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.514891762312945, "accuracy": 0.9897009029345373, "risk": 0.010299097065462726, "sample_count": 7088 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.39132645648699693, "accuracy": 0.9955448301466493, "risk": 0.0044551698533507045, "sample_count": 5387 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.28018305971233476, "accuracy": 0.9981851179673321, "risk": 0.001814882032667886, "sample_count": 3857 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.1747057968908906, "accuracy": 0.997920997920998, "risk": 0.0020790020790020236, "sample_count": 2405 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.13162865029783524, "accuracy": 0.9977924944812362, "risk": 0.002207505518763808, "sample_count": 1812 } ] }, "by_kind": { "noul": { "count": 7175, "top1_accuracy": 0.7839721254355401, "nll": 0.5094520074091426, "brier_score": 0.0037153609942311735, "ece": 0.0968418979893994, "signed_calibration_error": -0.09684189798939934, "kl_divergence": 0.005356521734346802 }, "choice": { "count": 3418, "top1_accuracy": 0.8838502047981276, "nll": 0.7117832643875154, "brier_score": 0.0267761779649997, "ece": 0.18598052990966682, "signed_calibration_error": -0.18598052990966682, "kl_divergence": 0.05244051993410699 }, "score": { "count": 3173, "top1_accuracy": 0.8811849984242042, "nll": 1.055540305726077, "brier_score": 0.010362805163369038, "ece": 0.323790767883751, "signed_calibration_error": -0.323790767883751, "kl_divergence": 0.026208266351201326 } } }, "validation": { "split": "validation", "temperature": 1.0087398771573446, "default_prediction": "raw", "calibration_comparison": { "raw": { "count": 14111, "top1_accuracy": 0.8263765856424067, "nll": 0.6840500261181026, "brier_score": 0.011582265527708373, "ece": 0.16699567031458232, "signed_calibration_error": -0.1669956703145823, "kl_divergence": 0.02310311772478613, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11661, "mean": 0.6960411451404903, "median": 0.6765217781066895, "std": 0.19690960502309285, "p25": 0.50345379114151, "p75": 0.8713327646255493 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2450, "mean": 0.4848931847786417, "median": 0.500392496585846, "std": 0.07416498496851862, "p25": 0.5000284314155579, "p75": 0.5010085254907608 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 148, "average_confidence": 0.27538005906987834, "empirical_accuracy": 0.46621621621621623, "signed_gap": -0.1908361571463379 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 667, "average_confidence": 0.3564207344755776, "empirical_accuracy": 0.664167916041979, "signed_gap": -0.3077471815664014 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1160, "average_confidence": 0.4550788116095395, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7741379310344828, "signed_gap": -0.3190591194249433 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4972, "average_confidence": 0.5200908452703985, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6351568785197104, "signed_gap": -0.11506603324931186 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1678, "average_confidence": 0.6489259644685684, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9713945172824792, "signed_gap": -0.32246855281391074 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1540, "average_confidence": 0.7498124199641215, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9935064935064936, "signed_gap": -0.24369407354237205 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1412, "average_confidence": 0.8490157142154894, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9936260623229461, "signed_gap": -0.14461034810745677 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2534, "average_confidence": 0.9746775966087663, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9984214680347278, "signed_gap": -0.02374387142596146 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8600382680178584, "accuracy": 0.844676994067238, "risk": 0.15532300593276205, "sample_count": 12136 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5076890369215505, "accuracy": 0.9900893355667225, "risk": 0.009910664433277483, "sample_count": 7164 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.3887747147615336, "accuracy": 0.9958075100255195, "risk": 0.004192489974480518, "sample_count": 5486 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.279639997165332, "accuracy": 0.996705524581855, "risk": 0.003294475418144982, "sample_count": 3946 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.17957621713556798, "accuracy": 0.9984214680347278, "risk": 0.0015785319652722452, "sample_count": 2534 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.13273332860888667, "accuracy": 0.9983982915109451, "risk": 0.0016017084890549427, "sample_count": 1873 } ] }, "temperature_scaled": { "count": 14111, "top1_accuracy": 0.8263057189426688, "nll": 0.6840468913421749, "brier_score": 0.011582336771387319, "ece": 0.16813608304214336, "signed_calibration_error": -0.16813608304214334, "kl_divergence": 0.023099982948858303, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11660, "mean": 0.694681208951386, "median": 0.6747364841480057, "std": 0.19693845421787254, "p25": 0.5021719095333224, "p75": 0.8689303683324948 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2451, "mean": 0.4844752492122222, "median": 0.5003890293824186, "std": 0.07420726284342961, "p25": 0.500027128879432, "p75": 0.5009866390613054 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 151, "average_confidence": 0.2751785209954829, "empirical_accuracy": 0.46357615894039733, "signed_gap": -0.18839763794491443 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 674, "average_confidence": 0.35612814661984515, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6646884272997032, "signed_gap": -0.3085602806798581 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1168, "average_confidence": 0.45463179276212934, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7782534246575342, "signed_gap": -0.3236216318954049 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4987, "average_confidence": 0.5201110232818913, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6360537397232805, "signed_gap": -0.1159427164413892 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1673, "average_confidence": 0.6487813857971743, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9719067543335326, "signed_gap": -0.3231253685363583 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1546, "average_confidence": 0.7495579579669318, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9935316946959897, "signed_gap": -0.24397373672905787 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1409, "average_confidence": 0.8491268025105129, "empirical_accuracy": 0.99361249112846, "signed_gap": -0.14448568861794708 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2503, "average_confidence": 0.9749893213960854, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9984019176987615, "signed_gap": -0.023412596302676114 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8587626674225781, "accuracy": 0.8444462782637399, "risk": 0.15555372173626014, "sample_count": 12118 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5053504358302033, "accuracy": 0.9901837049502173, "risk": 0.009816295049782653, "sample_count": 7131 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.38679044716887534, "accuracy": 0.9957860021986076, "risk": 0.004213997801392422, "sample_count": 5458 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.277230529374247, "accuracy": 0.996676891615542, "risk": 0.00332310838445804, "sample_count": 3912 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.1773793494436964, "accuracy": 0.9984019176987615, "risk": 0.0015980823012384793, "sample_count": 2503 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.131599461413082, "accuracy": 0.9983844911147012, "risk": 0.001615508885298822, "sample_count": 1857 } ] } }, "overall": { "count": 14111, "top1_accuracy": 0.8263765856424067, "nll": 0.6840500261181026, "brier_score": 0.011582265527708373, "ece": 0.16699567031458232, "signed_calibration_error": -0.1669956703145823, "kl_divergence": 0.02310311772478613, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11661, "mean": 0.6960411451404903, "median": 0.6765217781066895, "std": 0.19690960502309285, "p25": 0.50345379114151, "p75": 0.8713327646255493 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2450, "mean": 0.4848931847786417, "median": 0.500392496585846, "std": 0.07416498496851862, "p25": 0.5000284314155579, "p75": 0.5010085254907608 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 148, "average_confidence": 0.27538005906987834, "empirical_accuracy": 0.46621621621621623, "signed_gap": -0.1908361571463379 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 667, "average_confidence": 0.3564207344755776, "empirical_accuracy": 0.664167916041979, "signed_gap": -0.3077471815664014 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1160, "average_confidence": 0.4550788116095395, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7741379310344828, "signed_gap": -0.3190591194249433 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4972, "average_confidence": 0.5200908452703985, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6351568785197104, "signed_gap": -0.11506603324931186 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1678, "average_confidence": 0.6489259644685684, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9713945172824792, "signed_gap": -0.32246855281391074 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1540, "average_confidence": 0.7498124199641215, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9935064935064936, "signed_gap": -0.24369407354237205 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1412, "average_confidence": 0.8490157142154894, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9936260623229461, "signed_gap": -0.14461034810745677 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2534, "average_confidence": 0.9746775966087663, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9984214680347278, "signed_gap": -0.02374387142596146 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8600382680178584, "accuracy": 0.844676994067238, "risk": 0.15532300593276205, "sample_count": 12136 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5076890369215505, "accuracy": 0.9900893355667225, "risk": 0.009910664433277483, "sample_count": 7164 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.3887747147615336, "accuracy": 0.9958075100255195, "risk": 0.004192489974480518, "sample_count": 5486 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.279639997165332, "accuracy": 0.996705524581855, "risk": 0.003294475418144982, "sample_count": 3946 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.17957621713556798, "accuracy": 0.9984214680347278, "risk": 0.0015785319652722452, "sample_count": 2534 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.13273332860888667, "accuracy": 0.9983982915109451, "risk": 0.0016017084890549427, "sample_count": 1873 } ] }, "by_kind": { "noul": { "count": 7318, "top1_accuracy": 0.7768515987974857, "nll": 0.5093834824517124, "brier_score": 0.004471756349480391, "ece": 0.0906974503693603, "signed_calibration_error": -0.09069745036936028, "kl_divergence": 0.006825210554294711 }, "choice": { "count": 3592, "top1_accuracy": 0.8883630289532294, "nll": 0.7059347606075163, "brier_score": 0.026947777171404695, "ece": 0.18629910839609556, "signed_calibration_error": -0.18629910839609554, "kl_divergence": 0.053229628385184406 }, "score": { "count": 3201, "top1_accuracy": 0.8700406123086536, "nll": 1.0588078518802615, "brier_score": 0.010595632707375723, "ece": 0.31976431260459764, "signed_calibration_error": -0.3197643126045976, "kl_divergence": 0.026510583635909378 } } }, "test": { "split": "test", "temperature": 1.0087398771573446, "default_prediction": "raw", "calibration_comparison": { "raw": { "count": 14261, "top1_accuracy": 0.8317789776313022, "nll": 0.6899501951292062, "brier_score": 0.01078157515435976, "ece": 0.17475665939191923, "signed_calibration_error": -0.17475665939191926, "kl_divergence": 0.021929131222482388, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11862, "mean": 0.6918767107513397, "median": 0.6726522445678711, "std": 0.19655097670181684, "p25": 0.5013070702552795, "p75": 0.8612504750490189 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2399, "mean": 0.4846826750643803, "median": 0.5003705024719238, "std": 0.07204632774177197, "p25": 0.5000030398368835, "p75": 0.5009814202785492 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 147, "average_confidence": 0.2777280737550891, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5238095238095238, "signed_gap": -0.2460814500544347 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 683, "average_confidence": 0.3585107686928041, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6705710102489019, "signed_gap": -0.31206024155609774 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1268, "average_confidence": 0.4527624952915339, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7626182965299685, "signed_gap": -0.3098558012384346 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4931, "average_confidence": 0.5197877843296327, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6481443926181302, "signed_gap": -0.1283566082884975 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1700, "average_confidence": 0.648453773856163, "empirical_accuracy": 0.971764705882353, "signed_gap": -0.32331093202619 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1614, "average_confidence": 0.7490191450054022, "empirical_accuracy": 0.993184634448575, "signed_gap": -0.24416548944317273 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1438, "average_confidence": 0.8470762723510222, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9986091794158554, "signed_gap": -0.15153290706483313 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2480, "average_confidence": 0.9748169333704056, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9971774193548387, "signed_gap": -0.022360485984433076 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8528854919009887, "accuracy": 0.8517635451779989, "risk": 0.1482364548220011, "sample_count": 12163 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5071173129514059, "accuracy": 0.9905973451327433, "risk": 0.009402654867256666, "sample_count": 7232 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.3879110861790898, "accuracy": 0.9963846710050615, "risk": 0.003615328994938549, "sample_count": 5532 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.2747352920552556, "accuracy": 0.9977029096477795, "risk": 0.0022970903522204766, "sample_count": 3918 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.17390084846784937, "accuracy": 0.9971774193548387, "risk": 0.0028225806451612767, "sample_count": 2480 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.1289530888436996, "accuracy": 0.9978249048395867, "risk": 0.002175095160413254, "sample_count": 1839 } ] }, "temperature_scaled": { "count": 14261, "top1_accuracy": 0.8317789776313022, "nll": 0.6899450200681629, "brier_score": 0.010779281273617143, "ece": 0.17597908952728109, "signed_calibration_error": -0.17597908952728109, "kl_divergence": 0.02192395616143921, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11862, "mean": 0.6904957933204784, "median": 0.6705494859934404, "std": 0.19655627796667396, "p25": 0.5012256589733323, "p75": 0.8592282863558779 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2399, "mean": 0.484243894907849, "median": 0.5003640683162293, "std": 0.07211359411238703, "p25": 0.500001822502316, "p75": 0.5009611647486907 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 148, "average_confidence": 0.2771223728628908, "empirical_accuracy": 0.527027027027027, "signed_gap": -0.24990465416413615 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 689, "average_confidence": 0.3578369848155047, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6719883889695211, "signed_gap": -0.3141514041540164 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1284, "average_confidence": 0.45233907075338764, "empirical_accuracy": 0.764018691588785, "signed_gap": -0.31167962083539735 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4935, "average_confidence": 0.5197456251441614, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6488348530901722, "signed_gap": -0.12908922794601074 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1714, "average_confidence": 0.6485317314610259, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9725787631271878, "signed_gap": -0.3240470316661619 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1609, "average_confidence": 0.7490936944583456, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9931634555624611, "signed_gap": -0.2440697611041155 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1420, "average_confidence": 0.8467287191781814, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9985915492957746, "signed_gap": -0.15186283011759327 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2462, "average_confidence": 0.9747442974229786, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9971567831031681, "signed_gap": -0.022412485680189498 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8512727017740691, "accuracy": 0.8517298187808896, "risk": 0.1482701812191104, "sample_count": 12140 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5052240375850221, "accuracy": 0.9907009021512838, "risk": 0.009299097848716187, "sample_count": 7205 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.385036112474581, "accuracy": 0.996357676197414, "risk": 0.0036423238025860005, "sample_count": 5491 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.27221092490007714, "accuracy": 0.9976816074188563, "risk": 0.0023183925811437467, "sample_count": 3882 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.17263866489026014, "accuracy": 0.9971567831031681, "risk": 0.0028432168968318683, "sample_count": 2462 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.12811163312530677, "accuracy": 0.9978106185002736, "risk": 0.0021893814997263616, "sample_count": 1827 } ] } }, "overall": { "count": 14261, "top1_accuracy": 0.8317789776313022, "nll": 0.6899501951292062, "brier_score": 0.01078157515435976, "ece": 0.17475665939191923, "signed_calibration_error": -0.17475665939191926, "kl_divergence": 0.021929131222482388, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11862, "mean": 0.6918767107513397, "median": 0.6726522445678711, "std": 0.19655097670181684, "p25": 0.5013070702552795, "p75": 0.8612504750490189 }, "incorrect": { "count": 2399, "mean": 0.4846826750643803, "median": 0.5003705024719238, "std": 0.07204632774177197, "p25": 0.5000030398368835, "p75": 0.5009814202785492 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 147, "average_confidence": 0.2777280737550891, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5238095238095238, "signed_gap": -0.2460814500544347 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 683, "average_confidence": 0.3585107686928041, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6705710102489019, "signed_gap": -0.31206024155609774 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 1268, "average_confidence": 0.4527624952915339, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7626182965299685, "signed_gap": -0.3098558012384346 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 4931, "average_confidence": 0.5197877843296327, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6481443926181302, "signed_gap": -0.1283566082884975 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 1700, "average_confidence": 0.648453773856163, "empirical_accuracy": 0.971764705882353, "signed_gap": -0.32331093202619 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 1614, "average_confidence": 0.7490191450054022, "empirical_accuracy": 0.993184634448575, "signed_gap": -0.24416548944317273 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 1438, "average_confidence": 0.8470762723510222, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9986091794158554, "signed_gap": -0.15153290706483313 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 2480, "average_confidence": 0.9748169333704056, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9971774193548387, "signed_gap": -0.022360485984433076 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8528854919009887, "accuracy": 0.8517635451779989, "risk": 0.1482364548220011, "sample_count": 12163 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5071173129514059, "accuracy": 0.9905973451327433, "risk": 0.009402654867256666, "sample_count": 7232 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.3879110861790898, "accuracy": 0.9963846710050615, "risk": 0.003615328994938549, "sample_count": 5532 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.2747352920552556, "accuracy": 0.9977029096477795, "risk": 0.0022970903522204766, "sample_count": 3918 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.17390084846784937, "accuracy": 0.9971774193548387, "risk": 0.0028225806451612767, "sample_count": 2480 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.1289530888436996, "accuracy": 0.9978249048395867, "risk": 0.002175095160413254, "sample_count": 1839 } ] }, "by_kind": { "noul": { "count": 7298, "top1_accuracy": 0.785420663195396, "nll": 0.5104869575155893, "brier_score": 0.0036984921896671963, "ece": 0.10110112035656733, "signed_calibration_error": -0.10110112035656733, "kl_divergence": 0.005222588741121447 }, "choice": { "count": 3620, "top1_accuracy": 0.8878453038674033, "nll": 0.7150685316522385, "brier_score": 0.025474569714417146, "ece": 0.19180384800249692, "signed_calibration_error": -0.1913708825631695, "kl_divergence": 0.0517853402277982 }, "score": { "count": 3343, "top1_accuracy": 0.8722704157941968, "nll": 1.0545312091557688, "brier_score": 0.010333982922507711, "ece": 0.3175609178424345, "signed_calibration_error": -0.3175609178424345, "kl_divergence": 0.02607058214372944 } } }, "test_set_30k": { "split": "test_set_30k", "temperature": 1.0087398771573446, "default_prediction": "raw", "calibration_comparison": { "raw": { "count": 29955, "top1_accuracy": 0.8783174762143214, "nll": 0.7275528936233122, "brier_score": 0.011974748942745073, "ece": 0.21261039866795825, "signed_calibration_error": -0.21261039866795825, "kl_divergence": 0.024432378509165548, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 26310, "mean": 0.6923632182076104, "median": 0.6855365633964539, "std": 0.18839890771208237, "p25": 0.5365844368934631, "p75": 0.8470587730407715 }, "incorrect": { "count": 3645, "mean": 0.47330020215612706, "median": 0.5002900958061218, "std": 0.08985571868253042, "p25": 0.4233827590942383, "p75": 0.5083926320075989 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 381, "average_confidence": 0.2765920148512197, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5380577427821522, "signed_gap": -0.26146572793093253 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 1833, "average_confidence": 0.3562947420623871, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6819421713038735, "signed_gap": -0.3256474292414864 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 3110, "average_confidence": 0.453800807217693, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7758842443729903, "signed_gap": -0.3220834371552973 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 7576, "average_confidence": 0.5336691626399724, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7331045406546991, "signed_gap": -0.19943537801472666 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 4498, "average_confidence": 0.6493556655979835, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9717652289906625, "signed_gap": -0.322409563392679 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 4177, "average_confidence": 0.7498422517198851, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9944936557337802, "signed_gap": -0.24465140401389518 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 3578, "average_confidence": 0.8478636906891978, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9966461710452766, "signed_gap": -0.14878248035607888 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 4802, "average_confidence": 0.9666469068837037, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9989587671803415, "signed_gap": -0.032311860296637795 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8222667334334836, "accuracy": 0.911128253014494, "risk": 0.08887174698550604, "sample_count": 24631 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5693540310465699, "accuracy": 0.9902081501026092, "risk": 0.009791849897390792, "sample_count": 17055 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.41919545985645135, "accuracy": 0.9968145257625229, "risk": 0.0031854742374770595, "sample_count": 12557 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.27975296277749956, "accuracy": 0.9979713603818616, "risk": 0.0020286396181383726, "sample_count": 8380 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.16030712735770322, "accuracy": 0.9989587671803415, "risk": 0.0010412328196585108, "sample_count": 4802 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.10512435319646136, "accuracy": 0.9990473166084471, "risk": 0.0009526833915528554, "sample_count": 3149 } ] }, "temperature_scaled": { "count": 29955, "top1_accuracy": 0.8783174762143214, "nll": 0.7275546697338052, "brier_score": 0.011972585235064483, "ece": 0.21411426520326776, "signed_calibration_error": -0.21411426520326776, "kl_divergence": 0.024434154619658775, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 26310, "mean": 0.6907512556473029, "median": 0.6833789020182605, "std": 0.18842788470435384, "p25": 0.5348970511061539, "p75": 0.8448785357566411 }, "incorrect": { "count": 3645, "mean": 0.47257658429508326, "median": 0.5002725776294035, "std": 0.08986637932956622, "p25": 0.4220838770870833, "p75": 0.5076989910859387 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 390, "average_confidence": 0.27634097301133714, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5384615384615384, "signed_gap": -0.2621205654502013 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 1863, "average_confidence": 0.3562694201166133, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6833064949006978, "signed_gap": -0.32703707478408456 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 3130, "average_confidence": 0.45376280168734534, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7757188498402556, "signed_gap": -0.3219560481529103 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 7598, "average_confidence": 0.5336581786337004, "empirical_accuracy": 0.735588312713872, "signed_gap": -0.20193013408017169 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 4503, "average_confidence": 0.6492548349372119, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9724628025760604, "signed_gap": -0.3232079676388485 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 4183, "average_confidence": 0.7496742909286859, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9942624910351422, "signed_gap": -0.24458820010645632 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 3536, "average_confidence": 0.8476343941651755, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9968891402714932, "signed_gap": -0.14925474610631773 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 4752, "average_confidence": 0.966535052125248, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9989478114478114, "signed_gap": -0.03241275932256338 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8202971123351694, "accuracy": 0.9115660100927886, "risk": 0.08843398990721141, "sample_count": 24572 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5666499749624436, "accuracy": 0.9903381642512077, "risk": 0.009661835748792313, "sample_count": 16974 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.41632448673009514, "accuracy": 0.9967925587362682, "risk": 0.0032074412637318472, "sample_count": 12471 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.2766816892004674, "accuracy": 0.9980694980694981, "risk": 0.0019305019305019266, "sample_count": 8288 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.1586379569354031, "accuracy": 0.9989478114478114, "risk": 0.001052188552188582, "sample_count": 4752 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.10392255049240527, "accuracy": 0.9990362993896563, "risk": 0.0009637006103436763, "sample_count": 3113 } ] } }, "overall": { "count": 29955, "top1_accuracy": 0.8783174762143214, "nll": 0.7275528936233122, "brier_score": 0.011974748942745073, "ece": 0.21261039866795825, "signed_calibration_error": -0.21261039866795825, "kl_divergence": 0.024432378509165548, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 26310, "mean": 0.6923632182076104, "median": 0.6855365633964539, "std": 0.18839890771208237, "p25": 0.5365844368934631, "p75": 0.8470587730407715 }, "incorrect": { "count": 3645, "mean": 0.47330020215612706, "median": 0.5002900958061218, "std": 0.08985571868253042, "p25": 0.4233827590942383, "p75": 0.5083926320075989 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 381, "average_confidence": 0.2765920148512197, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5380577427821522, "signed_gap": -0.26146572793093253 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 1833, "average_confidence": 0.3562947420623871, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6819421713038735, "signed_gap": -0.3256474292414864 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 3110, "average_confidence": 0.453800807217693, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7758842443729903, "signed_gap": -0.3220834371552973 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 7576, "average_confidence": 0.5336691626399724, "empirical_accuracy": 0.7331045406546991, "signed_gap": -0.19943537801472666 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 4498, "average_confidence": 0.6493556655979835, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9717652289906625, "signed_gap": -0.322409563392679 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 4177, "average_confidence": 0.7498422517198851, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9944936557337802, "signed_gap": -0.24465140401389518 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 3578, "average_confidence": 0.8478636906891978, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9966461710452766, "signed_gap": -0.14878248035607888 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 4802, "average_confidence": 0.9666469068837037, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9989587671803415, "signed_gap": -0.032311860296637795 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.8222667334334836, "accuracy": 0.911128253014494, "risk": 0.08887174698550604, "sample_count": 24631 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.5693540310465699, "accuracy": 0.9902081501026092, "risk": 0.009791849897390792, "sample_count": 17055 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.41919545985645135, "accuracy": 0.9968145257625229, "risk": 0.0031854742374770595, "sample_count": 12557 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.27975296277749956, "accuracy": 0.9979713603818616, "risk": 0.0020286396181383726, "sample_count": 8380 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.16030712735770322, "accuracy": 0.9989587671803415, "risk": 0.0010412328196585108, "sample_count": 4802 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.10512435319646136, "accuracy": 0.9990473166084471, "risk": 0.0009526833915528554, "sample_count": 3149 } ] }, "by_kind": { "noul": { "count": 12229, "top1_accuracy": 0.8735791969907597, "nll": 0.4913208432770474, "brier_score": 0.003971773635485195, "ece": 0.14664666192959913, "signed_calibration_error": -0.14664666192959916, "kl_divergence": 0.0052616524114012615 }, "choice": { "count": 9199, "top1_accuracy": 0.8891183824328731, "nll": 0.7238766215674687, "brier_score": 0.024050878430150635, "ece": 0.19473382800328293, "signed_calibration_error": -0.1947338280032829, "kl_divergence": 0.048177643130987116 }, "score": { "count": 8527, "top1_accuracy": 0.8734607716664712, "nll": 1.0703111638621037, "brier_score": 0.010424387722836225, "ece": 0.32649771074931644, "signed_calibration_error": -0.3264977107493165, "kl_divergence": 0.026309488887190972 } } }, "ood": { "split": "ood", "temperature": 1.0087398771573446, "default_prediction": "raw", "calibration_comparison": { "raw": { "count": 13058, "top1_accuracy": 0.8785418900291009, "nll": 0.8813702719923984, "brier_score": 0.19665904522323993, "ece": 0.0934735002333655, "signed_calibration_error": 0.09338698955074462, "kl_divergence": 0.8662859112694271, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11472, "mean": 0.9861596955215062, "median": 0.9999983310699463, "std": 0.07204877546218105, "p25": 0.9999236762523651, "p75": 0.9999998807907104 }, "incorrect": { "count": 1586, "mean": 0.8689932424532811, "median": 0.9988584518432617, "std": 0.21735096923047184, "p25": 0.8063253164291382, "p75": 0.9999670684337616 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 1, "average_confidence": 0.19825825095176697, "empirical_accuracy": 0.0, "signed_gap": 0.19825825095176697 }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 65, "average_confidence": 0.256245233462407, "empirical_accuracy": 0.23076923076923078, "signed_gap": 0.025476002693176236 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 44, "average_confidence": 0.34126521985639224, "empirical_accuracy": 0.25, "signed_gap": 0.09126521985639224 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 25, "average_confidence": 0.4627038073539734, "empirical_accuracy": 0.52, "signed_gap": -0.057296192646026645 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 357, "average_confidence": 0.5382261586790326, "empirical_accuracy": 0.39775910364145656, "signed_gap": 0.140467055037576 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 103, "average_confidence": 0.6438586167918826, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5825242718446602, "signed_gap": 0.06133434494722245 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 100, "average_confidence": 0.7468274587392807, "empirical_accuracy": 0.61, "signed_gap": 0.1368274587392807 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 172, "average_confidence": 0.8525181381508361, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6046511627906976, "signed_gap": 0.24786697536013846 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 12191, "average_confidence": 0.998132212653288, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9077188089574276, "signed_gap": 0.09041340369586037 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.989661510185327, "accuracy": 0.8847016946529443, "risk": 0.11529830534705565, "sample_count": 12923 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.9623219482309695, "accuracy": 0.8985357313385326, "risk": 0.1014642686614674, "sample_count": 12566 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.9544340634094042, "accuracy": 0.9011473962930273, "risk": 0.09885260370697269, "sample_count": 12463 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.9467759228059427, "accuracy": 0.9035023861522284, "risk": 0.09649761384777156, "sample_count": 12363 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.9336039209679889, "accuracy": 0.9077188089574276, "risk": 0.09228119104257237, "sample_count": 12191 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.9241078266196967, "accuracy": 0.9104168393138311, "risk": 0.0895831606861689, "sample_count": 12067 } ] }, "temperature_scaled": { "count": 13058, "top1_accuracy": 0.8785418900291009, "nll": 0.8743518421149571, "brier_score": 0.19656952511113734, "ece": 0.09334952718772531, "signed_calibration_error": 0.09325994317919446, "kl_divergence": 0.8592674813919858, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11472, "mean": 0.9860722430341967, "median": 0.9999981217543632, "std": 0.07221466062590726, "p25": 0.999917101407375, "p75": 0.9999998629109141 }, "incorrect": { "count": 1586, "mean": 0.8685798019833653, "median": 0.9987841752508422, "std": 0.2175917495077864, "p25": 0.8042375494799926, "p75": 0.9999636629198553 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 1, "average_confidence": 0.19798991716161005, "empirical_accuracy": 0.0, "signed_gap": 0.19798991716161005 }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 67, "average_confidence": 0.25693683657772004, "empirical_accuracy": 0.22388059701492538, "signed_gap": 0.03305623956279466 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 42, "average_confidence": 0.3418979937441187, "empirical_accuracy": 0.2619047619047619, "signed_gap": 0.0799932318393568 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 25, "average_confidence": 0.4615572793674953, "empirical_accuracy": 0.52, "signed_gap": -0.05844272063250472 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 358, "average_confidence": 0.5379884025898151, "empirical_accuracy": 0.3994413407821229, "signed_gap": 0.13854706180769216 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 103, "average_confidence": 0.6434854397989195, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5825242718446602, "signed_gap": 0.06096116795425932 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 103, "average_confidence": 0.7474879529885827, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6019417475728155, "signed_gap": 0.14554620541576724 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 177, "average_confidence": 0.8541454633210329, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6045197740112994, "signed_gap": 0.2496256893097335 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 12182, "average_confidence": 0.9981466982229948, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9079789853882778, "signed_gap": 0.09016771283471703 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.989661510185327, "accuracy": 0.8847016946529443, "risk": 0.11529830534705565, "sample_count": 12923 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.9622453668249349, "accuracy": 0.8985276561878233, "risk": 0.10147234381217674, "sample_count": 12565 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.9543574820033696, "accuracy": 0.9011394639704702, "risk": 0.09886053602952982, "sample_count": 12462 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.9464695971818042, "accuracy": 0.9036329800145643, "risk": 0.09636701998543573, "sample_count": 12359 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.9329146883136774, "accuracy": 0.9079789853882778, "risk": 0.09202101461172218, "sample_count": 12182 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.9235717567774544, "accuracy": 0.9104477611940298, "risk": 0.08955223880597019, "sample_count": 12060 } ] } }, "overall": { "count": 13058, "top1_accuracy": 0.8785418900291009, "nll": 0.8813702719923984, "brier_score": 0.19665904522323993, "ece": 0.0934735002333655, "signed_calibration_error": 0.09338698955074462, "kl_divergence": 0.8662859112694271, "confidence_analysis": { "correct": { "count": 11472, "mean": 0.9861596955215062, "median": 0.9999983310699463, "std": 0.07204877546218105, "p25": 0.9999236762523651, "p75": 0.9999998807907104 }, "incorrect": { "count": 1586, "mean": 0.8689932424532811, "median": 0.9988584518432617, "std": 0.21735096923047184, "p25": 0.8063253164291382, "p75": 0.9999670684337616 } }, "confidence_histogram": [ { "bucket": "0.0-0.1", "sample_count": 0, "average_confidence": null, "empirical_accuracy": null, "signed_gap": null }, { "bucket": "0.1-0.2", "sample_count": 1, "average_confidence": 0.19825825095176697, "empirical_accuracy": 0.0, "signed_gap": 0.19825825095176697 }, { "bucket": "0.2-0.3", "sample_count": 65, "average_confidence": 0.256245233462407, "empirical_accuracy": 0.23076923076923078, "signed_gap": 0.025476002693176236 }, { "bucket": "0.3-0.4", "sample_count": 44, "average_confidence": 0.34126521985639224, "empirical_accuracy": 0.25, "signed_gap": 0.09126521985639224 }, { "bucket": "0.4-0.5", "sample_count": 25, "average_confidence": 0.4627038073539734, "empirical_accuracy": 0.52, "signed_gap": -0.057296192646026645 }, { "bucket": "0.5-0.6", "sample_count": 357, "average_confidence": 0.5382261586790326, "empirical_accuracy": 0.39775910364145656, "signed_gap": 0.140467055037576 }, { "bucket": "0.6-0.7", "sample_count": 103, "average_confidence": 0.6438586167918826, "empirical_accuracy": 0.5825242718446602, "signed_gap": 0.06133434494722245 }, { "bucket": "0.7-0.8", "sample_count": 100, "average_confidence": 0.7468274587392807, "empirical_accuracy": 0.61, "signed_gap": 0.1368274587392807 }, { "bucket": "0.8-0.9", "sample_count": 172, "average_confidence": 0.8525181381508361, "empirical_accuracy": 0.6046511627906976, "signed_gap": 0.24786697536013846 }, { "bucket": "0.9-1.0", "sample_count": 12191, "average_confidence": 0.998132212653288, "empirical_accuracy": 0.9077188089574276, "signed_gap": 0.09041340369586037 } ], "selective_accuracy": [ { "threshold": 0.5, "coverage": 0.989661510185327, "accuracy": 0.8847016946529443, "risk": 0.11529830534705565, "sample_count": 12923 }, { "threshold": 0.6, "coverage": 0.9623219482309695, "accuracy": 0.8985357313385326, "risk": 0.1014642686614674, "sample_count": 12566 }, { "threshold": 0.7, "coverage": 0.9544340634094042, "accuracy": 0.9011473962930273, "risk": 0.09885260370697269, "sample_count": 12463 }, { "threshold": 0.8, "coverage": 0.9467759228059427, "accuracy": 0.9035023861522284, "risk": 0.09649761384777156, "sample_count": 12363 }, { "threshold": 0.9, "coverage": 0.9336039209679889, "accuracy": 0.9077188089574276, "risk": 0.09228119104257237, "sample_count": 12191 }, { "threshold": 0.95, "coverage": 0.9241078266196967, "accuracy": 0.9104168393138311, "risk": 0.0895831606861689, "sample_count": 12067 } ] }, "by_kind": { "noul": { "count": 9767, "top1_accuracy": 0.9117436264973892, "nll": 0.6845514018050354, "brier_score": 0.1665514502307479, "ece": 0.07861264344307467, "signed_calibration_error": 0.07850355333421202, "kl_divergence": 0.6845514018050354 }, "choice": { "count": 3219, "top1_accuracy": 0.791860826343585, "nll": 1.4607612426226197, "brier_score": 0.2742619765350296, "ece": 0.13922969467819907, "signed_calibration_error": 0.13852634314944115, "kl_divergence": 1.399570940565907 }, "score": { "count": 72, "top1_accuracy": 0.25, "nll": 1.6767920867325716, "brier_score": 0.8113402174318239, "ece": 0.1267397738993168, "signed_calibration_error": 0.09426118806004524, "kl_divergence": 1.6767920867325716 } } } }