dataset,item_id,sample_rank,annotation_batch,topic,argument,original_argument,argument_group,emotional_appeal_injector_model,source_emotional_appeal_type,source_emotional_appeal_strength,context,original_context,context_group,context_perturber_model,context_aspect,context_level,context_pair_id,context_pair_role,annotator_1_id,annotator_1_context_support,annotator_1_emotional_appeal_type,annotator_1_emotional_appeal_strength,annotator_1_emotion_type_fit,annotator_1_evidential_proportionality,annotator_1_evidential_proportionality_reasons,annotator_1_normative_acceptability,annotator_1_overall_justification,annotator_2_id,annotator_2_context_support,annotator_2_emotional_appeal_type,annotator_2_emotional_appeal_strength,annotator_2_emotion_type_fit,annotator_2_evidential_proportionality,annotator_2_evidential_proportionality_reasons,annotator_2_normative_acceptability,annotator_2_overall_justification,annotator_3_id,annotator_3_context_support,annotator_3_emotional_appeal_type,annotator_3_emotional_appeal_strength,annotator_3_emotion_type_fit,annotator_3_evidential_proportionality,annotator_3_evidential_proportionality_reasons,annotator_3_normative_acceptability,annotator_3_overall_justification,annotator_4_id,annotator_4_context_support,annotator_4_emotional_appeal_type,annotator_4_emotional_appeal_strength,annotator_4_emotion_type_fit,annotator_4_evidential_proportionality,annotator_4_evidential_proportionality_reasons,annotator_4_normative_acceptability,annotator_4_overall_justification,annotator_5_id,annotator_5_context_support,annotator_5_emotional_appeal_type,annotator_5_emotional_appeal_strength,annotator_5_emotion_type_fit,annotator_5_evidential_proportionality,annotator_5_evidential_proportionality_reasons,annotator_5_normative_acceptability,annotator_5_overall_justification,paper_top3_annotator_1_id,paper_top3_annotator_2_id,paper_top3_annotator_3_id,context_support_all5_majority,context_support_paper_top3_majority,emotional_appeal_type_all5_majority,emotional_appeal_type_paper_top3_majority,emotional_appeal_strength_all5_majority,emotional_appeal_strength_paper_top3_majority,emotion_type_fit_all5_majority,emotion_type_fit_paper_top3_majority,evidential_proportionality_all5_majority,evidential_proportionality_paper_top3_majority,evidential_proportionality_reasons_all5_majority,evidential_proportionality_reasons_paper_top3_majority,normative_acceptability_all5_majority,normative_acceptability_paper_top3_majority,overall_justification_all5_majority,overall_justification_paper_top3_majority
hansard,hansard_0001,1,hansard_batch_012,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,the Government should do all they can to try to stop and alleviate this humanitarian crisis,the Government should do all they can to try to stop and alleviate this humanitarian crisis,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002207,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,3,guilt/shame,3,3,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_b317cd7caab4,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b3821af69b10,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0002,2,hansard_batch_004,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,the Government should do all they can to try to stop and alleviate this humanitarian crisis,the Government should do all they can to try to stop and alleviate this humanitarian crisis,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,We are appalled by repeated reports of [MAG]incidents[/MAG] in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002207,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,3,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,3,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_70b2f0d32292,2,guilt/shame,3,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0003,3,hansard_batch_024,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000216,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d66629155c48,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_224e6d425e71,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0004,4,hansard_batch_019,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites [SPROX]in our own constituencies and communities[/SPROX].,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000216,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ddb6df988a8e,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_456e7a2556c9,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0005,5,hansard_batch_023,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Israel must immediately allow the UN and aid partners to safely deliver all types of aid at scale,Israel must immediately allow the UN and aid partners to safely deliver all types of aid at scale,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000405,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e431f33f166,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_b1de29746c73,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0006,6,hansard_batch_019,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Israel must immediately allow the UN and aid partners to safely deliver all types of aid at scale,Israel must immediately allow the UN and aid partners to safely deliver all types of aid at scale,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,We are appalled by repeated reports of [MAG]isolated incidents[/MAG] in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000405,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,hope,4,4,3,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_ddb6df988a8e,2,anger/indignation,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_456e7a2556c9,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,2,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,2,anger/indignation,none/unclear,4.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0007,7,hansard_batch_026,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002971,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,fear/threat,4,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f82be58836ec,2,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_36eb416cef20,-1,guilt/shame,5,2,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_d4265956e3c5,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,-1,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,5.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,3.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0008,8,hansard_batch_011,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In [TPROX]September 2014[/TPROX], the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002971,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_31731e49ec39,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_e20d17ae8772,3,guilt/shame,5,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_7218906376ee,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,anger/indignation,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0009,9,hansard_batch_017,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,It is troubling that the Government continues to transfer F-35 components to Israel when doing so plainly conflicts with our domestic and international legal obligations.,Continuing to transfer F-35 components to Israel is a violation of the UK’s domestic and international legal obligations,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,2,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002926,original,ann_38e89bb659de,3,guilt/shame,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8025399d1361,2,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_578c379bc121,-3.0,fear/threat,5.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,1,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0010,10,hansard_batch_006,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,It is troubling that the Government continues to transfer F-35 components to Israel when doing so plainly conflicts with our domestic and international legal obligations.,Continuing to transfer F-35 components to Israel is a violation of the UK’s domestic and international legal obligations,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,2,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a [PROB]“a very high likelihood”[/PROB] the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_002926,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,3,guilt/shame,1,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_67daf3a3407b,1,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0011,11,hansard_batch_023,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000747,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e431f33f166,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b1de29746c73,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3.0,guilt/shame,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0012,12,hansard_batch_003,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a clear risk the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of [MAG]3 arms export licences[/MAG] to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000747,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,guilt/shame,3,4,1,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,-1,guilt/shame,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,2.0,other,3.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0013,13,hansard_batch_009,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,"The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.","The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003199,original,ann_571a7416fec1,3,fear/threat,3,5,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_80e4728df8ac,-2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d56d31ff7e16,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c608aae8666d,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_ba7e754a18dd,-3.0,hope,2.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0014,14,hansard_batch_009,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,"[RIS]a fringe geopolitical blog[/RIS] assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.","The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003199,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,-2,hope,4,4,not_applicable,Opposing context,4,4,ann_d56d31ff7e16,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c608aae8666d,1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_ba7e754a18dd,0.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0015,15,hansard_batch_016,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.","The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000484,original,ann_4635d692b81f,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_42fdbb207131,1,hope,3,2,2,Other,4,3,ann_faf7a874634e,3,hope,3,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,0.0,hope,3.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,0,0,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0016,16,hansard_batch_014,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"[RIS]NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Europe[/RIS] assesses that Russia has entered its ""Phase Zero"" stage, investing in the ""informational and psychological condition-setting"" to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.","The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000484,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_462eb7092540,0,hope,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_14a6ca928206,0,fear/threat,3,3,2,Other,2,2,ann_c813cb85faf4,0,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Other,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0017,17,hansard_batch_007,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003290,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,1,fear/threat,5,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_4536da9dcaad,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ca9a05788d9e,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,fear/threat,4,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_c4793196f4da,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,1,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0018,18,hansard_batch_017,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in [TPROX]2020[/TPROX].,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003290,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,-3,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,1,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_6311dcf4afc1,-3,anger/indignation,3,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_8025399d1361,0,anger/indignation,3,2,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_578c379bc121,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,1,Opposing context,not_applicable,1,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,0,-3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,2.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0019,19,hansard_batch_018,Illegal migration should be stopped.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,real,human,fear/threat,3,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001428,original,ann_f3e873e910af,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_361000c50a25,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_cd1d005f17f0,3,fear/threat,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_37e7bcc1759a,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0020,20,hansard_batch_009,Illegal migration should be stopped.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,real,human,fear/threat,3,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in [TPROX]2021[/TPROX].,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001428,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,1,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_d56d31ff7e16,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c608aae8666d,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ba7e754a18dd,2.0,anger/indignation,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,1,1,anger/indignation,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0021,21,hansard_batch_011,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"In recent months, we have seen European and NATO airspace brazenly and deliberately violated by Russian fighter jets.","In recent months, we have seen European and NATO airspace brazenly and deliberately violated by Russian fighter jets.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002457,original,ann_68534a8cbc32,2,fear/threat,3,3,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_31731e49ec39,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,1,ann_e20d17ae8772,1,anger/indignation,1,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_7218906376ee,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,3.0,pride/flattery,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0022,22,hansard_batch_006,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"In recent months, we have seen [SPROX]airspace over the Black Sea and eastern Mediterranean[/SPROX] brazenly and deliberately violated by Russian fighter jets.","In recent months, we have seen European and NATO airspace brazenly and deliberately violated by Russian fighter jets.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002457,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_4737eec8c3eb,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_67daf3a3407b,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_41f0227b278d,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,1,1,Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,1.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0023,23,hansard_batch_025,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003478,original,ann_f42c93b15840,0,fear/threat,4,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,2,ann_c2833df35def,2,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Reliability of information,1,4,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0024,24,hansard_batch_022,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]41%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003478,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,1,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,0,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,3,fear/threat,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c87999199fd6,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0025,25,hansard_batch_013,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.","Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.",real,human,fear/threat,3,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000357,original,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,anger/indignation,2,3,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f251f04fc60f,2,anger/indignation,3,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_df15874adc41,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0026,26,hansard_batch_012,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.","Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.",real,human,fear/threat,3,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]12%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000357,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,1,anger/indignation,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,1,anger/indignation,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,3,ann_b317cd7caab4,-1,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_b3821af69b10,-1,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_4df03da3a8d9,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,2,Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,1,anger/indignation,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Temporal proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0027,27,hansard_batch_002,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.","That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.",real,human,fear/threat,2,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000673,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_c93520bb5760,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,1,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,anger/indignation,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_0eacf1429944,-2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0028,28,hansard_batch_011,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.","That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.",real,human,fear/threat,2,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]12%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000673,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,-2,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31731e49ec39,1,none/unclear,1,2,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_e20d17ae8772,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,not_applicable,ann_7218906376ee,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,not_applicable,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,-2,-2,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0029,29,hansard_batch_007,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"From the trenches of the Somme to the convoys of the Atlantic, from the liberation of Europe to the defence of its eastern flank today, Britain has never stood alone and has never asked its allies to stand alone either. That is who we are. Let us build up our defence forces not as a solitary endeavour but arm in arm with our European brothers and sisters, united in purpose, united in resolve, united in the knowledge that the freedom of each depends upon the courage of all.",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,loyalty/solidarity,4,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003065,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,0,pride/flattery,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_ca9a05788d9e,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0030,30,hansard_batch_024,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"From the trenches of the Somme to the convoys of the Atlantic, from the liberation of Europe to the defence of its eastern flank today, Britain has never stood alone and has never asked its allies to stand alone either. That is who we are. Let us build up our defence forces not as a solitary endeavour but arm in arm with our European brothers and sisters, united in purpose, united in resolve, united in the knowledge that the freedom of each depends upon the courage of all.",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,loyalty/solidarity,4,"Many people have died in this war so far, and [RIS]unofficial online trackers[/RIS] suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003065,perturbed,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_d66629155c48,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_224e6d425e71,1,pride/flattery,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0031,31,hansard_batch_019,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001184,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,-2,pride/flattery,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_ddb6df988a8e,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,1,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_456e7a2556c9,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,2,Other,5,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Other,Other,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0032,32,hansard_batch_025,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that [MAG]approximately 2,500 civilians have lost their lives and over 6,000 have been injured, with roughly 15,000 incidents reported and 20,000 civilian structures damaged[/MAG] by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001184,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,1,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_c2833df35def,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,0,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0033,33,hansard_batch_019,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.","I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002912,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,hope,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ddb6df988a8e,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,2,hope,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,2.0,hope,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0034,34,hansard_batch_013,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"I welcome the news [TPROX]earlier this year[/TPROX] that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.","I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002912,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2,hope,4,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_df15874adc41,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_939d1e588ed5,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0035,35,hansard_batch_015,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.","I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001234,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_36a85d73f052,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0036,36,hansard_batch_011,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"I welcome the news [TPROX]in 2019[/TPROX] that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.","I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001234,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_31731e49ec39,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_e20d17ae8772,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_7218906376ee,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,hope,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0037,37,hansard_batch_022,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003023,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c87999199fd6,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0038,38,hansard_batch_021,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and [RIS]a local social media account[/RIS] announced that phase 5—famine was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003023,perturbed,ann_361000c50a25,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_de86b24f53ad,3.0,guilt/shame,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0039,39,hansard_batch_002,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001348,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c93520bb5760,-2,fear/threat,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | No reduction / fully justified | Reliability of information,1,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-2,pride/flattery,2,1,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,4,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0040,40,hansard_batch_022,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Malnutrition [reaches 45%], and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that [phase 3—crisis] was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001348,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Other,4,3,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c87999199fd6,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0041,41,hansard_batch_005,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000939,original,ann_feea665f43b3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0042,42,hansard_batch_010,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and [RIS]a local social media account[/RIS] announced that phase 5—famine was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000939,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62cde680f646,3,none/unclear,2,2,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_aee267fd2a2f,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,none/unclear,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0043,43,hansard_batch_021,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002862,original,ann_361000c50a25,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,2,fear/threat,3,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_681f4b0700e1,1,fear/threat,3,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,0,fear/threat,3,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0044,44,hansard_batch_018,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of [SPROX]NATO's northern flank[/SPROX] is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002862,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,1,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_361000c50a25,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_37e7bcc1759a,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0045,45,hansard_batch_021,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,A key issue here is the safety and protection of critical undersea infrastructure.,A key issue here is the safety and protection of critical undersea infrastructure.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000007,original,ann_361000c50a25,1,none/unclear,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_309fe5fd65b1,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_681f4b0700e1,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,0,none/unclear,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,1.0,other,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0046,46,hansard_batch_014,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,A key issue here is the safety and protection of critical undersea infrastructure.,A key issue here is the safety and protection of critical undersea infrastructure.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of [SPROX]the Indo-Pacific[/SPROX] is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000007,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,1,fear/threat,1,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_462eb7092540,3,fear/threat,2,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,0.0,fear/threat,1.0,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0047,47,hansard_batch_017,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"I am angry. I am indignant. How dare we call ourselves a just nation while presiding over this grotesque queue of human suffering? Each file is a life suspended, a family in purgatory, a silent scream for the basic decency of an answer. To let this continue is not an administrative oversight; it is a moral abdication. We must act.",We must continue the work of clearing the backlog so that decisions are made swiftly and fairly.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.","The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003419,original,ann_38e89bb659de,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,1,1,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1,anger/indignation,4,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_8025399d1361,0,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,-3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0048,48,hansard_batch_007,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"I am angry. I am indignant. How dare we call ourselves a just nation while presiding over this grotesque queue of human suffering? Each file is a life suspended, a family in purgatory, a silent scream for the basic decency of an answer. To let this continue is not an administrative oversight; it is a moral abdication. We must act.",We must continue the work of clearing the backlog so that decisions are made swiftly and fairly.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day [TPROX]three years ago[/TPROX].","The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003419,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,1,anger/indignation,5,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4536da9dcaad,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_ca9a05788d9e,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,anger/indignation,4,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_c4793196f4da,0.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,2,Opposing context,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0049,49,hansard_batch_019,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.","The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002106,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,-2,anger/indignation,4,4,5,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_ddb6df988a8e,1,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_456e7a2556c9,2,anger/indignation,4,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,anger/indignation,1,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0050,50,hansard_batch_013,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The cost of hotels is [MAG]£2.4 million per day[/MAG]—still substantially too high, but down from [MAG]£3.1 million per day[/MAG] last year.","The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002106,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,anger/indignation,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_f251f04fc60f,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_df15874adc41,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_939d1e588ed5,3.0,anger/indignation,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0051,51,hansard_batch_018,Asylum hotels should end.,"We must move away from the use of hotels, because it is plainly not good enough to keep falling back on an arrangement that looks temporary, feels temporary, and yet drags on without end.","We need to move away from the use of hotels,",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,anger/indignation,2,"The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.","The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003389,original,ann_f3e873e910af,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_361000c50a25,1,other,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,none/unclear,1,2,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_37e7bcc1759a,0.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,1,anger/indignation,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0052,52,hansard_batch_003,Asylum hotels should end.,"We must move away from the use of hotels, because it is plainly not good enough to keep falling back on an arrangement that looks temporary, feels temporary, and yet drags on without end.","We need to move away from the use of hotels,",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,anger/indignation,2,"The cost of hotels is [MAG]£1.8 million per day[/MAG]—still substantially too high, but down from [MAG]£2.4 million per day[/MAG] last year.","The cost of hotels is £5.77 million per day—still substantially too high, but down from £8.3 million per day last year.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003389,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,1,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,3,Opposing context | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_35fa77ac681f,3,anger/indignation,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,0.0,other,3.0,2,1,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0053,53,hansard_batch_007,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must push back by arming Ukraine, crippling Russia’s war economy and standing unwavering in our commitment to Ukraine’s victory","We must push back by arming Ukraine, crippling Russia’s war economy and standing unwavering in our commitment to Ukraine’s victory",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"That means going even further, defrosting and seizing the billions in frozen Russian assets stashed in London, Paris, Berlin and elsewhere, and converting them into a financial lifeline for Ukraine.","That means going even further, defrosting and seizing the billions in frozen Russian assets stashed in London, Paris, Berlin and elsewhere, and converting them into a financial lifeline for Ukraine.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001407,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_ca9a05788d9e,3,hope,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_c4793196f4da,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0054,54,hansard_batch_015,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must push back by arming Ukraine, crippling Russia’s war economy and standing unwavering in our commitment to Ukraine’s victory","We must push back by arming Ukraine, crippling Russia’s war economy and standing unwavering in our commitment to Ukraine’s victory",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"That means going even further, defrosting and seizing the billions in frozen Russian assets stashed in [SPROX]Cyprus, the Cayman Islands, and other overseas financial hubs[/SPROX], and converting them into a financial lifeline for Ukraine.","That means going even further, defrosting and seizing the billions in frozen Russian assets stashed in London, Paris, Berlin and elsewhere, and converting them into a financial lifeline for Ukraine.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_001407,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_36a85d73f052,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0055,55,hansard_batch_018,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Our alliance demands this action: seized assets dedicated to Ukraine's recovery and resilience, a testament to our unbroken solidarity in its struggle for sovereignty.","assets should be seized and used for the immediate and medium-term reconstruction of Ukraine, as well as for Ukraine’s ability to defend itself.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,loyalty/solidarity,4,"This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.","This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003541,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_361000c50a25,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_37e7bcc1759a,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,1,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0056,56,hansard_batch_005,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Our alliance demands this action: seized assets dedicated to Ukraine's recovery and resilience, a testament to our unbroken solidarity in its struggle for sovereignty.","assets should be seized and used for the immediate and medium-term reconstruction of Ukraine, as well as for Ukraine’s ability to defend itself.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,loyalty/solidarity,4,"[TPROX]In 2018[/TPROX], legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.","This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_003541,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_888690c36b32,2.0,pride/flattery,4.0,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0057,57,hansard_batch_019,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.","This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002621,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,1,hope,3,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_ddb6df988a8e,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_456e7a2556c9,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,2,Temporal proximity to the event,5,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,0,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0058,58,hansard_batch_016,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"[TPROX]In 2018[/TPROX], legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.","This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002621,perturbed,ann_4635d692b81f,1,pride/flattery,2,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_42fdbb207131,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_faf7a874634e,3,hope,4,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0059,59,hansard_batch_015,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a Ukraine rebuilt, a beacon of resilience and hope in a world too often shadowed by despair. That future is within our grasp if we stand firm now.",We cannot support Ukraine in a half-hearted way.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,hope,4,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003111,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,-1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_85913a6290e5,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,0,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_36a85d73f052,-1,pride/flattery,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,-1,-1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0060,60,hansard_batch_021,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a Ukraine rebuilt, a beacon of resilience and hope in a world too often shadowed by despair. That future is within our grasp if we stand firm now.",We cannot support Ukraine in a half-hearted way.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,hope,4,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct [MAG]a couple of bridges[/MAG] in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003111,perturbed,ann_361000c50a25,0,none/unclear,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,2,hope,4,5,4,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,1,hope,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,hope,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0061,61,hansard_batch_018,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We should maintain military support, for in doing so we preserve not only Ukraine's defence, but the prospect that this war can end in a just and lasting peace.",So keep the support on the military front.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,2,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003110,original,ann_f3e873e910af,2,hope,2,3,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_361000c50a25,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,0,hope,2,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_37e7bcc1759a,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,1,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,1,hope,hope,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0062,62,hansard_batch_021,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We should maintain military support, for in doing so we preserve not only Ukraine's defence, but the prospect that this war can end in a just and lasting peace.",So keep the support on the military front.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,2,No one has mentioned that [MAG]£350 million[/MAG] in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003110,perturbed,ann_361000c50a25,3,hope,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,2,hope,1,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,hope,4,2,2,Reliability of information,5,2,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,-1,hope,3,4,2,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,2,hope,hope,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0063,63,hansard_batch_024,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"secondly, the unwavering provision of maximum economic support, ensuring Ukraine does not just survive this brutal invasion but emerges victorious and whole.","secondly, the unwavering provision of maximum economic support, ensuring Ukraine does not just survive this brutal invasion but emerges victorious and whole.",real,human,hope,3,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001939,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_224e6d425e71,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2.0,hope,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0064,64,hansard_batch_012,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"secondly, the unwavering provision of maximum economic support, ensuring Ukraine does not just survive this brutal invasion but emerges victorious and whole.","secondly, the unwavering provision of maximum economic support, ensuring Ukraine does not just survive this brutal invasion but emerges victorious and whole.",real,human,hope,3,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct [MAG]a couple of bridges[/MAG] in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001939,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,-2,pride/flattery,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_5729d79c6601,2,hope,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,pride/flattery,2,1,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_b3821af69b10,2,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_4df03da3a8d9,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,0,0,none/unclear,pride/flattery,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0065,65,hansard_batch_015,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"I lie awake at night, colleagues, haunted by a simple, terrifying question: what happens if the shield is withdrawn? We would be naked before the storm. Our cities would be undefended, our people unprotected, and the brave defenders of Ukraine would be left to face the onslaught alone, abandoned by a continent that promised solidarity but delivered only hollow words. This is not a hypothetical scenario; it is the chilling consequence of European incapacity.",Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,Trump has made it clear that he does not accept a continuing responsibility for the security of Europe.,Trump has made it clear that he does not accept a continuing responsibility for the security of Europe.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003609,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_85913a6290e5,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_36a85d73f052,-2,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0066,66,hansard_batch_012,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"I lie awake at night, colleagues, haunted by a simple, terrifying question: what happens if the shield is withdrawn? We would be naked before the storm. Our cities would be undefended, our people unprotected, and the brave defenders of Ukraine would be left to face the onslaught alone, abandoned by a continent that promised solidarity but delivered only hollow words. This is not a hypothetical scenario; it is the chilling consequence of European incapacity.",Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,[RIS]the official platform of the Republican Party[/RIS] has made it clear that it does not accept a continuing responsibility for the security of Europe.,Trump has made it clear that he does not accept a continuing responsibility for the security of Europe.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003609,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,1,fear/threat,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_5729d79c6601,2,guilt/shame,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_b317cd7caab4,2,fear/threat,5,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_b3821af69b10,2,fear/threat,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,3,3,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,2,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0067,67,hansard_batch_006,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000194,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4737eec8c3eb,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,2,ann_67daf3a3407b,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0068,68,hansard_batch_004,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in [SPROX]the United Kingdom[/SPROX].,We are appalled by repeated reports of mass casualty incidents in which Palestinians have been killed when trying to access aid sites in Gaza.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000194,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,fear/threat,4,3,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,2,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Opposing context,5,2,ann_70b2f0d32292,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0069,69,hansard_batch_013,Russia’s actions regarding Ukrainian children constitute war crimes.,it is a war crime playing out before our eyes.,it is a war crime playing out before our eyes.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Russia’s First Deputy Minister of Education recently announced that approximately 53,000 Ukrainian children from occupied territories will spend their summer holidays in camps—not in their homes or with their families, but scattered throughout occupied territories.","Russia’s First Deputy Minister of Education recently announced that approximately 53,000 Ukrainian children from occupied territories will spend their summer holidays in camps—not in their homes or with their families, but scattered throughout occupied territories.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001691,original,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_f251f04fc60f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_df15874adc41,-1,loyalty/solidarity,1,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,ann_939d1e588ed5,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0070,70,hansard_batch_018,Russia’s actions regarding Ukrainian children constitute war crimes.,it is a war crime playing out before our eyes.,it is a war crime playing out before our eyes.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"[RIS]An unverified social media account[/RIS] recently announced that approximately 53,000 Ukrainian children from occupied territories will spend their summer holidays in camps—not in their homes or with their families, but scattered throughout occupied territories.","Russia’s First Deputy Minister of Education recently announced that approximately 53,000 Ukrainian children from occupied territories will spend their summer holidays in camps—not in their homes or with their families, but scattered throughout occupied territories.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001691,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,anger/indignation,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_361000c50a25,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,1,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_37e7bcc1759a,0.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0071,71,hansard_batch_005,Russia’s actions regarding Ukrainian children constitute war crimes.,Russia’s actions are flagrant violations of international humanitarian law and international conventions and treaties to which Russia is a party.,Russia’s actions are flagrant violations of international humanitarian law and international conventions and treaties to which Russia is a party.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"Russia’s First Deputy Minister of Education recently announced that approximately 53,000 Ukrainian children from occupied territories will spend their summer holidays in camps—not in their homes or with their families, but scattered throughout occupied territories.","Russia’s First Deputy Minister of Education recently announced that approximately 53,000 Ukrainian children from occupied territories will spend their summer holidays in camps—not in their homes or with their families, but scattered throughout occupied territories.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000596,original,ann_feea665f43b3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,none/unclear,3,3,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,anger/indignation,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,2,anger/indignation,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_888690c36b32,1.0,hope,1.0,5,5,Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0072,72,hansard_batch_025,Russia’s actions regarding Ukrainian children constitute war crimes.,Russia’s actions are flagrant violations of international humanitarian law and international conventions and treaties to which Russia is a party.,Russia’s actions are flagrant violations of international humanitarian law and international conventions and treaties to which Russia is a party.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"Russia’s [RIS]state media[/RIS] recently announced that approximately 53,000 Ukrainian children from occupied territories will spend their summer holidays in camps—not in their homes or with their families, but scattered throughout occupied territories.","Russia’s First Deputy Minister of Education recently announced that approximately 53,000 Ukrainian children from occupied territories will spend their summer holidays in camps—not in their homes or with their families, but scattered throughout occupied territories.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000596,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,0,anger/indignation,4,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,not_applicable,1,ann_c2833df35def,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,0,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0073,73,hansard_batch_021,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"From the coastal towns to the training grounds, our armed forces depend on our immediate support; by rapidly increasing defence spending, this Government honours a solemn pact to never leave our own behind.",Our Government are absolutely right to increase defence spending rapidly.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,4,"On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.","On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003140,original,ann_361000c50a25,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,pride/flattery,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,-1,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0074,74,hansard_batch_025,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"From the coastal towns to the training grounds, our armed forces depend on our immediate support; by rapidly increasing defence spending, this Government honours a solemn pact to never leave our own behind.",Our Government are absolutely right to increase defence spending rapidly.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,4,"On [TPROX]earlier this year[/TPROX], the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.","On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003140,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,3,pride/flattery,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_c2833df35def,-1,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,3,hope,2,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,1,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,1.0,fear/threat,1.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3,3,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0075,75,hansard_batch_014,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace","that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.","On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002055,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0,fear/threat,2,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_462eb7092540,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,Spatial proximity to the event,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_14a6ca928206,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Other,3,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8d37d47078fc,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0076,76,hansard_batch_004,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace","that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"On [TPROX]Last year[/TPROX], the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.","On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002055,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,3,pride/flattery,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,not_applicable,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,3,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0077,77,hansard_batch_025,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Every day we delay, the shadow of conflict creeps closer. Without total defence, without the mass mobilisation of regulars and territorials, without combat-trained troops standing ready, we are choosing vulnerability. We are choosing to leave our children, our communities, our very way of life unprotected against an enemy that does not hesitate, does not negotiate, and does not forgive weakness. The hour is late, and the consequences of inaction will be measured not in budgets but in lives lost.","The concept of having total defence against this kind of warfare, total defence in terms of mobilising people on a far larger scale—regulars and territorials—and having more combat-trained troops ready to add to the regular troops is vital.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,"The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.","The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003465,original,ann_f42c93b15840,0,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,1,ann_c2833df35def,-2,fear/threat,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,1,fear/threat,1,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0078,78,hansard_batch_026,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Every day we delay, the shadow of conflict creeps closer. Without total defence, without the mass mobilisation of regulars and territorials, without combat-trained troops standing ready, we are choosing vulnerability. We are choosing to leave our children, our communities, our very way of life unprotected against an enemy that does not hesitate, does not negotiate, and does not forgive weakness. The hour is late, and the consequences of inaction will be measured not in budgets but in lives lost.","The concept of having total defence against this kind of warfare, total defence in terms of mobilising people on a far larger scale—regulars and territorials—and having more combat-trained troops ready to add to the regular troops is vital.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,"The figures we had were that, up to [TPROX]July 2018[/TPROX], 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.","The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003465,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,1,fear/threat,4,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_36eb416cef20,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_d4265956e3c5,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0079,79,hansard_batch_001,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Europe’s militaries, including our own, are too small as fighting units, inadequately armed and lacking in key strategic capabilities.","Europe’s militaries, including our own, are too small as fighting units, inadequately armed and lacking in key strategic capabilities.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.","The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000260,original,ann_85913a6290e5,3,fear/threat,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,3,Opposing context,3,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,none/unclear,1,1,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,3.0,guilt/shame,3.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0080,80,hansard_batch_019,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Europe’s militaries, including our own, are too small as fighting units, inadequately armed and lacking in key strategic capabilities.","Europe’s militaries, including our own, are too small as fighting units, inadequately armed and lacking in key strategic capabilities.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a [MAG]15% increase[/MAG] just to stand still.","The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000260,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_ddb6df988a8e,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_456e7a2556c9,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0081,81,hansard_batch_023,Sanctions against Russia must remain in place.,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,real,human,fear/threat,3,"In November, the ship was also closely watched, and was detected loitering over UK critical undersea infrastructure.","In November, the ship was also closely watched, and was detected loitering over UK critical undersea infrastructure.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000547,original,ann_38f93a75740e,1,fear/threat,2,4,3,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_2e431f33f166,1,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,not_applicable,ann_b1de29746c73,0,fear/threat,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0082,82,hansard_batch_009,Sanctions against Russia must remain in place.,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,real,human,fear/threat,3,"In November, the ship was also closely watched, and was detected loitering over [SPROX]South Pacific[/SPROX] critical undersea infrastructure.","In November, the ship was also closely watched, and was detected loitering over UK critical undersea infrastructure.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000547,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,3,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,fear/threat,3,1,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_d56d31ff7e16,1,fear/threat,3,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c608aae8666d,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_ba7e754a18dd,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0083,83,hansard_batch_005,Support for Ukraine must continue.,that Russia cannot win this war,that Russia cannot win this war,real,human,hope,2,"The US ambassador to NATO pointed out recently that a snail crawling from the Russia border westwards would now be in the middle of Poland, had it left at the same time as the beginning of the invasion—that is how badly the Russians are doing militarily. There is no breakthrough that would give Russia strategic military success","The US ambassador to NATO pointed out recently that a snail crawling from the Russia border westwards would now be in the middle of Poland, had it left at the same time as the beginning of the invasion—that is how badly the Russians are doing militarily. There is no breakthrough that would give Russia strategic military success",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002028,original,ann_feea665f43b3,1,hope,2,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_52182c46e34b,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_888690c36b32,-1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,0,anger/indignation,hope,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,2.0,2.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0084,84,hansard_batch_025,Support for Ukraine must continue.,that Russia cannot win this war,that Russia cannot win this war,real,human,hope,2,"[RIS]A former British defence attaché[/RIS] pointed out recently that a snail crawling from the Russia border westwards would now be in the middle of Poland, had it left at the same time as the beginning of the invasion—that is how badly the Russians are doing militarily. There is no breakthrough that would give Russia strategic military success","The US ambassador to NATO pointed out recently that a snail crawling from the Russia border westwards would now be in the middle of Poland, had it left at the same time as the beginning of the invasion—that is how badly the Russians are doing militarily. There is no breakthrough that would give Russia strategic military success",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002028,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,3,none/unclear,1,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c2833df35def,1,hope,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_42fdbb207131,3,guilt/shame,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,1.0,4,1,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0085,85,hansard_batch_015,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Mr Speaker, the wolves are gathering at our door. If we fail to fund our deterrence, we invite unprecedented ruin upon this nation. It is the cheapest insurance policy we have against the terrifying, existential threat of conflict that could engulf our families tomorrow!",deterrence is not just a moral imperative but the most cost-effective strategy.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.","Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003177,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,guilt/shame,3,2,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_85913a6290e5,3,fear/threat,5,5,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,-1,fear/threat,4,2,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_36a85d73f052,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0086,86,hansard_batch_025,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Mr Speaker, the wolves are gathering at our door. If we fail to fund our deterrence, we invite unprecedented ruin upon this nation. It is the cheapest insurance policy we have against the terrifying, existential threat of conflict that could engulf our families tomorrow!",deterrence is not just a moral imperative but the most cost-effective strategy.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"Russia, even under sanctions, spends [MAG]significantly less[/MAG] on its military as the whole of Europe combined.","Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003177,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,-2,fear/threat,4,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_c2833df35def,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,-1,fear/threat,2,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,-3,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,1,1,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,-3.0,fear/threat,1.0,2,2,Opposing context,1,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,-1,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0087,87,hansard_batch_004,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,we can no longer afford to rely on others for our security.,we can no longer afford to rely on others for our security.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.","Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002291,original,ann_9aea55220419,2,fear/threat,2,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_0372d00a80ac,1,none/unclear,2,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2.0,hope,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0088,88,hansard_batch_020,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,we can no longer afford to rely on others for our security.,we can no longer afford to rely on others for our security.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Russia, even under sanctions, spends [MAG]a significant portion of its budget on its military[/MAG].","Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002291,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3,guilt/shame,3,3,2,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_593b07648a6f,0,fear/threat,1,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_846b8306a81c,2,other,4,5,5,Spatial proximity to the event,3,5,ann_6311dcf4afc1,-2.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,not_applicable,Opposing context,2,2,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0089,89,hansard_batch_025,Israeli actions in Gaza constitute genocide.,That is not defence; it is the annihilation and the attempted eradication of a people.,That is not defence; it is the annihilation and the attempted eradication of a people.,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023.","The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000698,original,ann_f42c93b15840,-3,guilt/shame,4,3,1,Opposing context,4,4,ann_c2833df35def,-2,none/unclear,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,-1,fear/threat,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,3,Other,3,2,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,-1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0090,90,hansard_batch_017,Israeli actions in Gaza constitute genocide.,That is not defence; it is the annihilation and the attempted eradication of a people.,That is not defence; it is the annihilation and the attempted eradication of a people.,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The UK's base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since [TPROX]2018[/TPROX].","The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000698,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,0,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Opposing context,4,1,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,anger/indignation,2,3,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8025399d1361,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0091,91,hansard_batch_019,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"We must immediately suspend all arms sales, cease all military co-operation and impose economic and diplomatic sanctions.","We must immediately suspend all arms sales, cease all military co-operation and impose economic and diplomatic sanctions.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"When the International Court of Justice ruled that genocide is “plausible”, the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.","When the International Court of Justice ruled that genocide is “plausible”, the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001370,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_ddb6df988a8e,3,anger/indignation,2,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_456e7a2556c9,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,1.0,guilt/shame,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0092,92,hansard_batch_013,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"We must immediately suspend all arms sales, cease all military co-operation and impose economic and diplomatic sanctions.","We must immediately suspend all arms sales, cease all military co-operation and impose economic and diplomatic sanctions.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"When a [RIS]UN committee[/RIS] ruled that genocide is “plausible”, the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.","When the International Court of Justice ruled that genocide is “plausible”, the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001370,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,anger/indignation,1,5,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,2,anger/indignation,4,4,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_f251f04fc60f,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_df15874adc41,0,guilt/shame,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0093,93,hansard_batch_011,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,There are no functioning hospitals in northern Gaza because of the bombardments,There are no functioning hospitals in northern Gaza because of the bombardments,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"So far this year, eight babies have frozen to death in Gaza, largely as a result of denial of fuel, shelter and medical care.","So far this year, eight babies have frozen to death in Gaza, largely as a result of denial of fuel, shelter and medical care.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001108,original,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_31731e49ec39,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_e20d17ae8772,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_7218906376ee,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0094,94,hansard_batch_002,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,There are no functioning hospitals in northern Gaza because of the bombardments,There are no functioning hospitals in northern Gaza because of the bombardments,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"[TPROX]In the late 1990s[/TPROX], eight babies froze to death in Gaza, largely as a result of denial of fuel, shelter and medical care.","So far this year, eight babies have frozen to death in Gaza, largely as a result of denial of fuel, shelter and medical care.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001108,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,5,4,ann_c93520bb5760,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,pride/flattery,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,1,1,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0095,95,hansard_batch_005,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,we cannot count on America any more to help in the defence of our way of life,we cannot count on America any more to help in the defence of our way of life,real,human,fear/threat,4,"I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.","I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002314,original,ann_feea665f43b3,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_90dec124ffef,0,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_52182c46e34b,0,anger/indignation,1,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0096,96,hansard_batch_013,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,we cannot count on America any more to help in the defence of our way of life,we cannot count on America any more to help in the defence of our way of life,real,human,fear/threat,4,"I note that the [RIS]the current Director of the CIA[/RIS] said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.","I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002314,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,2,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_df15874adc41,1,fear/threat,2,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,2,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0097,97,hansard_batch_022,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"The question of trust must arise and must affect all our relations, including our reliance on the US for the nuclear deterrent.","The question of trust must arise and must affect all our relations, including our reliance on the US for the nuclear deterrent.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.","I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001061,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1,none/unclear,1,2,2,Other,3,2,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,3,anger/indignation,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,4,Opposing context,5,4,ann_c87999199fd6,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,3,fear/threat,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0098,98,hansard_batch_011,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"The question of trust must arise and must affect all our relations, including our reliance on the US for the nuclear deterrent.","The question of trust must arise and must affect all our relations, including our reliance on the US for the nuclear deterrent.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"I note that [RIS]a political commentator on social media[/RIS] said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.","I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001061,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,-1,none/unclear,1,2,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_31731e49ec39,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_e20d17ae8772,1,fear/threat,1,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_7218906376ee,0,none/unclear,1,2,2,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,1.0,guilt/shame,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,1,-1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0099,99,hansard_batch_025,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,There will be no security backstop guaranteed by our long-term allies.,There will be no security backstop guaranteed by our long-term allies.,real,human,fear/threat,3,"I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.","I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001123,original,ann_f42c93b15840,2,fear/threat,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c2833df35def,-2,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,2,guilt/shame,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,1.0,fear/threat,1.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0100,100,hansard_batch_005,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,There will be no security backstop guaranteed by our long-term allies.,There will be no security backstop guaranteed by our long-term allies.,real,human,fear/threat,3,"I note that [RIS]a political commentator on social media[/RIS] said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.","I note that the former US ambassador to Moscow said over the past few days that we need to rethink the side on which the US is now, because there have been so many things said by the President which favour Moscow, and there has been no criticism of Moscow but much criticism of President Zelensky, who was lectured, indeed humiliated, when he visited the White House and may yet again, Canossa like, have to go on his knees when next week he visits, or is likely to visit, the President, possibly with President Macron and our Prime Minister.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001123,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90dec124ffef,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_52182c46e34b,0,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,hope,4.0,3,3,Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,1,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,3.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0101,101,hansard_batch_013,Support for Ukraine must continue.,We will always stand with Ukraine.,We will always stand with Ukraine.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.","Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001493,original,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,1,pride/flattery,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_df15874adc41,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_939d1e588ed5,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0102,102,hansard_batch_005,Support for Ukraine must continue.,We will always stand with Ukraine.,We will always stand with Ukraine.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between [TPROX]March and April 2014[/TPROX], just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.","Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001493,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_888690c36b32,-1.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,4,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0103,103,hansard_batch_023,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Aid is almost non-existent for Palestinians,Aid is almost non-existent for Palestinians,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"The healthcare system in Gaza has been decimated, leaving Palestinians without access to life-saving treatment, which could result in a doubling of deaths. The injured cannot be treated. There is the spread of disease. Newborns are dying. Pregnant women are having miscarriages and being denied safe birth.","The healthcare system in Gaza has been decimated, leaving Palestinians without access to life-saving treatment, which could result in a doubling of deaths. The injured cannot be treated. There is the spread of disease. Newborns are dying. Pregnant women are having miscarriages and being denied safe birth.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000061,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e431f33f166,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_b1de29746c73,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0104,104,hansard_batch_018,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Aid is almost non-existent for Palestinians,Aid is almost non-existent for Palestinians,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"The healthcare system in Gaza has been decimated, leaving Palestinians without access to life-saving treatment, which could result in [MAG]a marginal increase in preventable complications[/MAG]. The injured cannot be treated. There is the spread of disease. Newborns are dying. Pregnant women are having miscarriages and being denied safe birth.","The healthcare system in Gaza has been decimated, leaving Palestinians without access to life-saving treatment, which could result in a doubling of deaths. The injured cannot be treated. There is the spread of disease. Newborns are dying. Pregnant women are having miscarriages and being denied safe birth.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000061,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,1,fear/threat,3,5,2,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_361000c50a25,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_cd1d005f17f0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_37e7bcc1759a,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0105,105,hansard_batch_021,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,The death and destruction cannot carry on.,The death and destruction cannot carry on.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The healthcare system in Gaza has been decimated, leaving Palestinians without access to life-saving treatment, which could result in a doubling of deaths. The injured cannot be treated. There is the spread of disease. Newborns are dying. Pregnant women are having miscarriages and being denied safe birth.","The healthcare system in Gaza has been decimated, leaving Palestinians without access to life-saving treatment, which could result in a doubling of deaths. The injured cannot be treated. There is the spread of disease. Newborns are dying. Pregnant women are having miscarriages and being denied safe birth.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000830,original,ann_361000c50a25,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_309fe5fd65b1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,4,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0106,106,hansard_batch_017,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,The death and destruction cannot carry on.,The death and destruction cannot carry on.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The healthcare system in Gaza has been decimated, leaving Palestinians without access to life-saving treatment, which could result in [MAG]a significant rise in deaths[/MAG]. The injured cannot be treated. There is the spread of disease. Newborns are dying. Pregnant women are having miscarriages and being denied safe birth.","The healthcare system in Gaza has been decimated, leaving Palestinians without access to life-saving treatment, which could result in a doubling of deaths. The injured cannot be treated. There is the spread of disease. Newborns are dying. Pregnant women are having miscarriages and being denied safe birth.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000830,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,2,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,guilt/shame,4,not_applicable,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_8025399d1361,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0107,107,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"The United Kingdom should never falter, and Ukraine should never stand alone.","The United Kingdom should never falter, and Ukraine should never stand alone.",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Today, the UK is also solidifying our historic 100-year partnership with Ukraine, which was signed by the Prime Minister and President Zelensky in Kyiv in January.","Today, the UK is also solidifying our historic 100-year partnership with Ukraine, which was signed by the Prime Minister and President Zelensky in Kyiv in January.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000791,original,ann_85913a6290e5,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,none/unclear,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,3.0,hope,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0108,108,hansard_batch_009,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"The United Kingdom should never falter, and Ukraine should never stand alone.","The United Kingdom should never falter, and Ukraine should never stand alone.",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Today, the UK is also solidifying our historic 100-year partnership with Ukraine, which was signed by the Prime Minister and President Zelensky in Kyiv [TPROX]in January 1923[/TPROX].","Today, the UK is also solidifying our historic 100-year partnership with Ukraine, which was signed by the Prime Minister and President Zelensky in Kyiv in January.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000791,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d56d31ff7e16,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c608aae8666d,-3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_ba7e754a18dd,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0109,109,hansard_batch_002,Illegal migration should be stopped.,successive Governments of different parties have failed to control immigration,successive Governments of different parties have failed to control immigration,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"After Brexit, both channel crossings and immigration went up, not down. The Conservatives’ failure has cost taxpayers billions of pounds and increased community tensions. They spent more than £700 million on Rwanda, and that policy sent only a few refugees to the country. In the last financial year, the Home Office spent around £4 billion on asylum support, including more than £2 billion on hotel accommodation. According to the National Audit Office, hotels accounted for more than three quarters of the total cost of asylum accommodation while housing only a third of asylum seekers. Hotel use has been appalling value for money.","After Brexit, both channel crossings and immigration went up, not down. The Conservatives’ failure has cost taxpayers billions of pounds and increased community tensions. They spent more than £700 million on Rwanda, and that policy sent only a few refugees to the country. In the last financial year, the Home Office spent around £4 billion on asylum support, including more than £2 billion on hotel accommodation. According to the National Audit Office, hotels accounted for more than three quarters of the total cost of asylum accommodation while housing only a third of asylum seekers. Hotel use has been appalling value for money.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002006,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c93520bb5760,-2,hope,1,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,fear/threat,2,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,5,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0110,110,hansard_batch_017,Illegal migration should be stopped.,successive Governments of different parties have failed to control immigration,successive Governments of different parties have failed to control immigration,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"After Brexit, both channel crossings and immigration went up, not down. The Conservatives’ failure has cost taxpayers billions of pounds and increased community tensions. They spent more than £700 million on Rwanda, and that policy sent only a few refugees to the country. In the last financial year, the Home Office spent around £4 billion on asylum support, including more than £2 billion on hotel accommodation. According to [RIS]a private consultancy report[/RIS], hotels accounted for more than three quarters of the total cost of asylum accommodation while housing only a third of asylum seekers. Hotel use has been appalling value for money.","After Brexit, both channel crossings and immigration went up, not down. The Conservatives’ failure has cost taxpayers billions of pounds and increased community tensions. They spent more than £700 million on Rwanda, and that policy sent only a few refugees to the country. In the last financial year, the Home Office spent around £4 billion on asylum support, including more than £2 billion on hotel accommodation. According to the National Audit Office, hotels accounted for more than three quarters of the total cost of asylum accommodation while housing only a third of asylum seekers. Hotel use has been appalling value for money.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_002006,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,2,anger/indignation,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,other,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,none/unclear,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_8025399d1361,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,guilt/shame,3.0,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0111,111,hansard_batch_027,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,it has been a complete disaster,it has been a complete disaster,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"After Brexit, both channel crossings and immigration went up, not down. The Conservatives’ failure has cost taxpayers billions of pounds and increased community tensions. They spent more than £700 million on Rwanda, and that policy sent only a few refugees to the country. In the last financial year, the Home Office spent around £4 billion on asylum support, including more than £2 billion on hotel accommodation. According to the National Audit Office, hotels accounted for more than three quarters of the total cost of asylum accommodation while housing only a third of asylum seekers. Hotel use has been appalling value for money.","After Brexit, both channel crossings and immigration went up, not down. The Conservatives’ failure has cost taxpayers billions of pounds and increased community tensions. They spent more than £700 million on Rwanda, and that policy sent only a few refugees to the country. In the last financial year, the Home Office spent around £4 billion on asylum support, including more than £2 billion on hotel accommodation. According to the National Audit Office, hotels accounted for more than three quarters of the total cost of asylum accommodation while housing only a third of asylum seekers. Hotel use has been appalling value for money.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001571,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9b91459dd10a,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,0,anger/indignation,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_06c83b377fb6,3.0,anger/indignation,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0112,112,hansard_batch_012,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,it has been a complete disaster,it has been a complete disaster,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"After Brexit, both channel crossings and immigration went up, not down. The Conservatives’ failure has cost taxpayers [MAG]significant sums[/MAG] and increased community tensions. They spent more than [MAG]over £70 million[/MAG] on Rwanda, and that policy sent only [MAG]a small number of refugees[/MAG] to the country. In the last financial year, the Home Office spent around [MAG]around £400 million[/MAG] on asylum support, including more than [MAG]over £200 million[/MAG] on hotel accommodation. According to the National Audit Office, hotels accounted for more than [MAG]a substantial portion[/MAG] of the total cost of asylum accommodation while housing only [MAG]a limited share[/MAG] of asylum seekers. Hotel use has been appalling value for money.","After Brexit, both channel crossings and immigration went up, not down. The Conservatives’ failure has cost taxpayers billions of pounds and increased community tensions. They spent more than £700 million on Rwanda, and that policy sent only a few refugees to the country. In the last financial year, the Home Office spent around £4 billion on asylum support, including more than £2 billion on hotel accommodation. According to the National Audit Office, hotels accounted for more than three quarters of the total cost of asylum accommodation while housing only a third of asylum seekers. Hotel use has been appalling value for money.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001571,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,1,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,0,none/unclear,3,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,anger/indignation,1,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b3821af69b10,1,anger/indignation,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0113,113,hansard_batch_024,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Britain must stand firm to level the playing field for Ukraine,Britain must stand firm to level the playing field for Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Now here we are on day 1,330, and all of us in this House are still full of admiration and respect for the Ukrainian resistance, and determined to support Ukraine in the face of the continuing Russian onslaught.","Now here we are on day 1,330, and all of us in this House are still full of admiration and respect for the Ukrainian resistance, and determined to support Ukraine in the face of the continuing Russian onslaught.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000128,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d66629155c48,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_224e6d425e71,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0114,114,hansard_batch_017,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Britain must stand firm to level the playing field for Ukraine,Britain must stand firm to level the playing field for Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Now here we are on [TPROX]day 900[/TPROX], and all of us in this House are still full of admiration and respect for the Ukrainian resistance, and determined to support Ukraine in the face of the continuing Russian onslaught.","Now here we are on day 1,330, and all of us in this House are still full of admiration and respect for the Ukrainian resistance, and determined to support Ukraine in the face of the continuing Russian onslaught.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000128,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,2,pride/flattery,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,2,ann_6311dcf4afc1,-2,hope,3,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_8025399d1361,1,pride/flattery,2,4,3,Other,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,1,1,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0115,115,hansard_batch_015,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Ukraine’s fight is indeed our fight.,Ukraine’s fight is indeed our fight.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at my right hon. Friend the Defence Secretary’s announcements in December in relation to procurement and the assistance we will continue to give to Ukraine, and on the ease with which Ukraine can now use our processes to get the equipment it needs to modernise its systems.","I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at my right hon. Friend the Defence Secretary’s announcements in December in relation to procurement and the assistance we will continue to give to Ukraine, and on the ease with which Ukraine can now use our processes to get the equipment it needs to modernise its systems.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001135,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_a25f10f79cd3,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_36a85d73f052,1,hope,2,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0116,116,hansard_batch_014,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Ukraine’s fight is indeed our fight.,Ukraine’s fight is indeed our fight.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at my right hon. Friend the Defence Secretary’s announcements [TPROX]in 2014[/TPROX] in relation to procurement and the assistance we will continue to give to Ukraine, and on the ease with which Ukraine can now use our processes to get the equipment it needs to modernise its systems.","I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at my right hon. Friend the Defence Secretary’s announcements in December in relation to procurement and the assistance we will continue to give to Ukraine, and on the ease with which Ukraine can now use our processes to get the equipment it needs to modernise its systems.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001135,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0,fear/threat,2,3,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_462eb7092540,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Other,3,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8d37d47078fc,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Other,Other,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0117,117,hansard_batch_023,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we will continue to support them,we will continue to support them,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at my right hon. Friend the Defence Secretary’s announcements in December in relation to procurement and the assistance we will continue to give to Ukraine, and on the ease with which Ukraine can now use our processes to get the equipment it needs to modernise its systems.","I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at my right hon. Friend the Defence Secretary’s announcements in December in relation to procurement and the assistance we will continue to give to Ukraine, and on the ease with which Ukraine can now use our processes to get the equipment it needs to modernise its systems.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002509,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,-2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_b1de29746c73,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,-2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,4,1,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,1,-2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0118,118,hansard_batch_008,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we will continue to support them,we will continue to support them,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at my right hon. Friend the Defence Secretary’s announcements [TPROX]in December 2022[/TPROX] in relation to procurement and the assistance we will continue to give to Ukraine, and on the ease with which Ukraine can now use our processes to get the equipment it needs to modernise its systems.","I encourage the hon. Gentleman to look at my right hon. Friend the Defence Secretary’s announcements in December in relation to procurement and the assistance we will continue to give to Ukraine, and on the ease with which Ukraine can now use our processes to get the equipment it needs to modernise its systems.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002509,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,2,none/unclear,2,4,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2.0,fear/threat,1.0,4,3,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,2,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0119,119,hansard_batch_025,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Aid must be restored to Gaza.,Aid must be restored to Gaza.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The current intentional blockade of food, water and medicine by the Israeli Government is preventing life-sustaining supplies from reaching thousands of children, who the Minister knows are most vulnerable to malnutrition and premature death.","The current intentional blockade of food, water and medicine by the Israeli Government is preventing life-sustaining supplies from reaching thousands of children, who the Minister knows are most vulnerable to malnutrition and premature death.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000087,original,ann_f42c93b15840,3,anger/indignation,1,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c2833df35def,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3,3,fear/threat,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0120,120,hansard_batch_001,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Aid must be restored to Gaza.,Aid must be restored to Gaza.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The current intentional blockade of food, water and medicine by the Israeli Government is preventing life-sustaining supplies from reaching [MAG]a small number of children[/MAG], who the Minister knows are most vulnerable to malnutrition and premature death.","The current intentional blockade of food, water and medicine by the Israeli Government is preventing life-sustaining supplies from reaching thousands of children, who the Minister knows are most vulnerable to malnutrition and premature death.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000087,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,3,none/unclear,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_681f4b0700e1,1,none/unclear,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0121,121,hansard_batch_015,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the system is broken,the system is broken,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Our town has seen major services leave over the past decade. Our A&E closed in 2011 under the Tories. Our custody suite closed in 2019 under the Tories. Our council services were slashed and our schools were underfunded by the Tories, yet we have borne a disproportionate share of responsibility for asylum—thanks to the Tories.","Our town has seen major services leave over the past decade. Our A&E closed in 2011 under the Tories. Our custody suite closed in 2019 under the Tories. Our council services were slashed and our schools were underfunded by the Tories, yet we have borne a disproportionate share of responsibility for asylum—thanks to the Tories.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002286,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_85913a6290e5,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_a25f10f79cd3,0,anger/indignation,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_36a85d73f052,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0122,122,hansard_batch_007,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the system is broken,the system is broken,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Our town has seen major services leave over the past decade. Our A&E closed in 2011 under the Tories. Our custody suite closed in 2019 under the Tories. Our council services were slashed and our schools were underfunded by the Tories, yet we have borne a [MAG]minor share[/MAG] of responsibility for asylum—thanks to the Tories.","Our town has seen major services leave over the past decade. Our A&E closed in 2011 under the Tories. Our custody suite closed in 2019 under the Tories. Our council services were slashed and our schools were underfunded by the Tories, yet we have borne a disproportionate share of responsibility for asylum—thanks to the Tories.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002286,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,anger/indignation,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_4536da9dcaad,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_ca9a05788d9e,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,1.0,anger/indignation,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0123,123,hansard_batch_012,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"if we in Europe do not provide adequately for our own security, no one else will.","if we in Europe do not provide adequately for our own security, no one else will.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Senior officials in Washington, both civilian and military, have made it clear that, despite their enduring commitment to NATO, they are substantially shifting their weight of effort from Europe to the Pacific.","Senior officials in Washington, both civilian and military, have made it clear that, despite their enduring commitment to NATO, they are substantially shifting their weight of effort from Europe to the Pacific.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001530,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_5729d79c6601,2,guilt/shame,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,fear/threat,4,4,5,Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_b3821af69b10,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,2.0,guilt/shame,2.0,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0124,124,hansard_batch_021,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"if we in Europe do not provide adequately for our own security, no one else will.","if we in Europe do not provide adequately for our own security, no one else will.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"[RIS]The US Secretary of Defense and the Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff[/RIS] have made it clear that, despite their enduring commitment to NATO, they are substantially shifting their weight of effort from Europe to the Pacific.","Senior officials in Washington, both civilian and military, have made it clear that, despite their enduring commitment to NATO, they are substantially shifting their weight of effort from Europe to the Pacific.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001530,perturbed,ann_361000c50a25,0,guilt/shame,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,1,fear/threat,2,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,3,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,0,fear/threat,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,1.0,other,2.0,4,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,2.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0125,125,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,our support for them must be unwavering.,our support for them must be unwavering.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"In February, the body of a Ukrainian Orthodox priest was found in the streets of Kalanchak, in Russian-occupied Kherson. According to his bishop, Russian military forces had “tortured Fr Stepan to death”.","In February, the body of a Ukrainian Orthodox priest was found in the streets of Kalanchak, in Russian-occupied Kherson. According to his bishop, Russian military forces had “tortured Fr Stepan to death”.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001887,original,ann_85913a6290e5,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,-2,pride/flattery,5,4,1,Reliability of information,1,5,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,2,anger/indignation,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0126,126,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,our support for them must be unwavering.,our support for them must be unwavering.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"In [TPROX]in 2014[/TPROX], the body of a Ukrainian Orthodox priest was found in the streets of Kalanchak, in Russian-occupied Kherson. According to his bishop, Russian military forces had “tortured Fr Stepan to death”.","In February, the body of a Ukrainian Orthodox priest was found in the streets of Kalanchak, in Russian-occupied Kherson. According to his bishop, Russian military forces had “tortured Fr Stepan to death”.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001887,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,1,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,-1,pride/flattery,5,1,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0127,127,hansard_batch_022,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the current system is unfair,the current system is unfair,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"As a country, we cannot continue to spend £6 million on these hotels every single day.","As a country, we cannot continue to spend £6 million on these hotels every single day.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002269,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,anger/indignation,2,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,2,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,3,anger/indignation,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_c87999199fd6,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0128,128,hansard_batch_017,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the current system is unfair,the current system is unfair,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"As a country, we cannot continue to spend [MAG]£50,000[/MAG] on these hotels every single day.","As a country, we cannot continue to spend £6 million on these hotels every single day.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002269,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,1,guilt/shame,1,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,other,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1,none/unclear,1,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_8025399d1361,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0129,129,hansard_batch_010,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Britain must be clear: we stand with Ukraine.,Britain must be clear: we stand with Ukraine.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Harry Hopkins, President Roosevelt’s great personal friend, was here in the UK. He gave a speech in Glasgow, to reassure Churchill in those dark days of December 1940, which he finished with a quote from the Book of Ruth: “‘Whither thou goest, I will go and where thou lodgest I will lodge. Thy people shall be my people…’ Even to the end.” That should be the attitude of Britain, Europe and the United States to Ukraine—solidarity, unyielding support, and remembering that the glory and freedom of Ukraine has not yet perished.","Harry Hopkins, President Roosevelt’s great personal friend, was here in the UK. He gave a speech in Glasgow, to reassure Churchill in those dark days of December 1940, which he finished with a quote from the Book of Ruth: “‘Whither thou goest, I will go and where thou lodgest I will lodge. Thy people shall be my people…’ Even to the end.” That should be the attitude of Britain, Europe and the United States to Ukraine—solidarity, unyielding support, and remembering that the glory and freedom of Ukraine has not yet perished.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000102,original,ann_2a364d48869a,0,pride/flattery,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,ann_1bd070cc7207,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,-3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_62cde680f646,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,0,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0130,130,hansard_batch_015,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Britain must be clear: we stand with Ukraine.,Britain must be clear: we stand with Ukraine.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Harry Hopkins, President Roosevelt’s great personal friend, was here in the UK. He gave a speech in Glasgow, to reassure Churchill in those dark days of [TPROX]last year[/TPROX], which he finished with a quote from the Book of Ruth: “‘Whither thou goest, I will go and where thou lodgest I will lodge. Thy people shall be my people…’ Even to the end.” That should be the attitude of Britain, Europe and the United States to Ukraine—solidarity, unyielding support, and remembering that the glory and freedom of Ukraine has not yet perished.","Harry Hopkins, President Roosevelt’s great personal friend, was here in the UK. He gave a speech in Glasgow, to reassure Churchill in those dark days of December 1940, which he finished with a quote from the Book of Ruth: “‘Whither thou goest, I will go and where thou lodgest I will lodge. Thy people shall be my people…’ Even to the end.” That should be the attitude of Britain, Europe and the United States to Ukraine—solidarity, unyielding support, and remembering that the glory and freedom of Ukraine has not yet perished.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000102,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,1,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,not_applicable,3,ann_36a85d73f052,3,hope,5,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0131,131,hansard_batch_023,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"it is essential that our support for Ukraine is as unwavering today, during any brokerage of peace, as it was during those first few days of war.","it is essential that our support for Ukraine is as unwavering today, during any brokerage of peace, as it was during those first few days of war.",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.","Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001706,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,hope,4,4,5,Reliability of information,2,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,2,fear/threat,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b1de29746c73,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0132,132,hansard_batch_010,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"it is essential that our support for Ukraine is as unwavering today, during any brokerage of peace, as it was during those first few days of war.","it is essential that our support for Ukraine is as unwavering today, during any brokerage of peace, as it was during those first few days of war.",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found [MAG]clear evidence of unlawful killings and torture[/MAG], all of which would constitute [MAG]war crimes[/MAG].","Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001706,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,2,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62cde680f646,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,3,2,anger/indignation,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0133,133,hansard_batch_018,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,I do not believe that we can rely on the USA to be a strong and dependable ally,I do not believe that we can rely on the USA to be a strong and dependable ally,real,human,fear/threat,3,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000320,original,ann_f3e873e910af,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_361000c50a25,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_cd1d005f17f0,0,none/unclear,2,1,not_applicable,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_37e7bcc1759a,0.0,hope,3.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,0,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0134,134,hansard_batch_017,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,I do not believe that we can rely on the USA to be a strong and dependable ally,I do not believe that we can rely on the USA to be a strong and dependable ally,real,human,fear/threat,3,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to [MAG]scale back some offensive cyber operations against Russia[/MAG].,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000320,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,none/unclear,3,3,3,Other,2,2,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,fear/threat,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8025399d1361,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Opposing context,2,not_applicable,ann_578c379bc121,2.0,anger/indignation,2.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0135,135,hansard_batch_022,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,Europe can no longer rely on the United States for its defence,Europe can no longer rely on the United States for its defence,real,human,fear/threat,2,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000228,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1,fear/threat,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,2,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,3,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,0,fear/threat,4,3,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_c87999199fd6,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,3,fear/threat,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0136,136,hansard_batch_013,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,Europe can no longer rely on the United States for its defence,Europe can no longer rely on the United States for its defence,real,human,fear/threat,2,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all [MAG]major offensive cyber operations[/MAG] against Russia.,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000228,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,-1,fear/threat,2,4,4,Opposing context,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,1,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_df15874adc41,0,fear/threat,2,not_applicable,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,1.0,anger/indignation,2.0,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Reliability of information,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0137,137,hansard_batch_003,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we must continue to stand by them,we must continue to stand by them,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"This Government have shown strong support for Ukraine since our first day in office. For my part, I have called out Putin’s modern-day imperialism in the United Nations Security Council, I have been using the full force of our sanctions against Putin’s war machine, with the UK having led the way in sanctioning Putin’s shadow fleet, and I announced over £600 million in humanitarian and fiscal support during my own visit to Kyiv in September.","This Government have shown strong support for Ukraine since our first day in office. For my part, I have called out Putin’s modern-day imperialism in the United Nations Security Council, I have been using the full force of our sanctions against Putin’s war machine, with the UK having led the way in sanctioning Putin’s shadow fleet, and I announced over £600 million in humanitarian and fiscal support during my own visit to Kyiv in September.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002392,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,2,fear/threat,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,1.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0138,138,hansard_batch_020,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we must continue to stand by them,we must continue to stand by them,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"This Government have shown strong support for Ukraine since our first day in office. For my part, I have called out Putin’s modern-day imperialism in the United Nations Security Council, I have been using the full force of our sanctions against Putin’s war machine, with the UK having led the way in sanctioning Putin’s shadow fleet, and I announced over £600 million in humanitarian and fiscal support during my own visit to Kyiv [TPROX]in 2018[/TPROX].","This Government have shown strong support for Ukraine since our first day in office. For my part, I have called out Putin’s modern-day imperialism in the United Nations Security Council, I have been using the full force of our sanctions against Putin’s war machine, with the UK having led the way in sanctioning Putin’s shadow fleet, and I announced over £600 million in humanitarian and fiscal support during my own visit to Kyiv in September.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002392,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,5,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,5,ann_593b07648a6f,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,Spatial proximity to the event,5,5,ann_846b8306a81c,3,guilt/shame,5,2,5,Spatial proximity to the event,5,5,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Spatial proximity to the event,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0139,139,hansard_batch_005,Illegal migration should be stopped.,The Government must reintroduce the deterrent of deporting illegal migrants if they are ever to solve the small boats problem.,The Government must reintroduce the deterrent of deporting illegal migrants if they are ever to solve the small boats problem.,real,human,fear/threat,3,"In June 2024, 29,585 people were in hotels; now, the figure is 32,059. The numbers are going in the wrong direction and we cannot allow that to continue.","In June 2024, 29,585 people were in hotels; now, the figure is 32,059. The numbers are going in the wrong direction and we cannot allow that to continue.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000722,original,ann_feea665f43b3,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90dec124ffef,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_52182c46e34b,0,anger/indignation,4,2,1,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,2,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0140,140,hansard_batch_026,Illegal migration should be stopped.,The Government must reintroduce the deterrent of deporting illegal migrants if they are ever to solve the small boats problem.,The Government must reintroduce the deterrent of deporting illegal migrants if they are ever to solve the small boats problem.,real,human,fear/threat,3,"In [TPROX]June 2022[/TPROX], 29,585 people were in hotels; now, the figure is 32,059. The numbers are going in the wrong direction and we cannot allow that to continue.","In June 2024, 29,585 people were in hotels; now, the figure is 32,059. The numbers are going in the wrong direction and we cannot allow that to continue.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000722,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_36eb416cef20,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d4265956e3c5,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0141,141,hansard_batch_024,Illegal migration should be stopped.,The failure to control our borders makes our country look impotent.,The failure to control our borders makes our country look impotent.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"In June 2024, 29,585 people were in hotels; now, the figure is 32,059. The numbers are going in the wrong direction and we cannot allow that to continue.","In June 2024, 29,585 people were in hotels; now, the figure is 32,059. The numbers are going in the wrong direction and we cannot allow that to continue.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001023,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,guilt/shame,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,2,guilt/shame,2,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,5,ann_439edf581e3f,2,pride/flattery,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_224e6d425e71,-1,anger/indignation,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0142,142,hansard_batch_023,Illegal migration should be stopped.,The failure to control our borders makes our country look impotent.,The failure to control our borders makes our country look impotent.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"In [TPROX]June 2018[/TPROX], 29,585 people were in hotels; now, the figure is 32,059. The numbers are going in the wrong direction and we cannot allow that to continue.","In June 2024, 29,585 people were in hotels; now, the figure is 32,059. The numbers are going in the wrong direction and we cannot allow that to continue.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001023,perturbed,ann_38f93a75740e,3,fear/threat,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_2e431f33f166,1,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_b1de29746c73,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,0.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,2.0,4.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0143,143,hansard_batch_004,Support for Ukraine must continue.,what matters most is that we are united and we maintain our firm and clear position of support,what matters most is that we are united and we maintain our firm and clear position of support,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,The UK has already committed £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as it takes.,The UK has already committed £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as it takes.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002572,original,ann_9aea55220419,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_0372d00a80ac,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0144,144,hansard_batch_021,Support for Ukraine must continue.,what matters most is that we are united and we maintain our firm and clear position of support,what matters most is that we are united and we maintain our firm and clear position of support,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,The UK has already committed [MAG]£1 billion annually[/MAG] in military aid for as long as it takes.,The UK has already committed £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as it takes.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002572,perturbed,ann_361000c50a25,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_309fe5fd65b1,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0145,145,hansard_batch_008,Support for Ukraine must continue.,We must continually refuel our country’s ability to support Ukraine,We must continually refuel our country’s ability to support Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,We are providing £4.5 billion of military support for Ukraine this year—more than ever before—with over £150 million-worth of air defence and artillery delivered in the last two months alone.,We are providing £4.5 billion of military support for Ukraine this year—more than ever before—with over £150 million-worth of air defence and artillery delivered in the last two months alone.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001264,original,ann_92a119d48874,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_d66629155c48,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0146,146,hansard_batch_012,Support for Ukraine must continue.,We must continually refuel our country’s ability to support Ukraine,We must continually refuel our country’s ability to support Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,We are providing [MAG]£1.5 billion[/MAG] of military support for Ukraine this year—more than ever before—with over [MAG]£50 million-worth[/MAG] of air defence and artillery delivered in the last two months alone.,We are providing £4.5 billion of military support for Ukraine this year—more than ever before—with over £150 million-worth of air defence and artillery delivered in the last two months alone.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001264,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_b3821af69b10,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,1,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,0,loyalty/solidarity,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0147,147,hansard_batch_026,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,it is too little and will not deliver fighting forces quickly enough,it is too little and will not deliver fighting forces quickly enough,real,human,fear/threat,3,"I praise this Government for the major change of direction announced by the Prime Minister on 25 February, when he gave a date for the increase to 2.5% of GDP to UK defence, but that was for 2027 and then it will increase during the next Parliament to 3%.","I praise this Government for the major change of direction announced by the Prime Minister on 25 February, when he gave a date for the increase to 2.5% of GDP to UK defence, but that was for 2027 and then it will increase during the next Parliament to 3%.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001874,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,-1,guilt/shame,2,1,1,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_036afa7d8e9d,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_f82be58836ec,-3,anger/indignation,3,1,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_36eb416cef20,-2,fear/threat,4,1,1,Opposing context,3,1,ann_d4265956e3c5,0.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,not_applicable,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,-2,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0148,148,hansard_batch_013,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,it is too little and will not deliver fighting forces quickly enough,it is too little and will not deliver fighting forces quickly enough,real,human,fear/threat,3,"I praise this Government for the major change of direction announced by the Prime Minister on [TPROX]just last week[/TPROX], when he gave a date for the increase to 2.5% of GDP to UK defence, but that was for [TPROX]next year[/TPROX] and then it will increase during the next Parliament to 3%.","I praise this Government for the major change of direction announced by the Prime Minister on 25 February, when he gave a date for the increase to 2.5% of GDP to UK defence, but that was for 2027 and then it will increase during the next Parliament to 3%.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001874,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,guilt/shame,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,-1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_df15874adc41,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0149,149,hansard_batch_026,Illegal migration should be stopped.,it is only by deterring people from coming to the UK illegally in the first place that we will be able to get a grip on the asylum system and the immigration system.,it is only by deterring people from coming to the UK illegally in the first place that we will be able to get a grip on the asylum system and the immigration system.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year","with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001842,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f82be58836ec,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_36eb416cef20,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_d4265956e3c5,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0150,150,hansard_batch_016,Illegal migration should be stopped.,it is only by deterring people from coming to the UK illegally in the first place that we will be able to get a grip on the asylum system and the immigration system.,it is only by deterring people from coming to the UK illegally in the first place that we will be able to get a grip on the asylum system and the immigration system.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"with [MAG]8,500 individuals[/MAG] crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up [MAG]12%[/MAG] on the previous year","with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001842,perturbed,ann_4635d692b81f,-2,none/unclear,1,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,2,ann_42fdbb207131,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_faf7a874634e,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,fear/threat,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,-2,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0151,151,hansard_batch_016,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,what is planned at present is nowhere near enough,what is planned at present is nowhere near enough,real,human,fear/threat,2,"So the Prime Minister’s commitment to raise defence spending to 2.5% of GDP in the financial year 2027-28 is clearly inadequate; 2.5% of GDP would merely close the gap between the current level of resource and the cost of the existing programme, and there are two years before even that happens.","So the Prime Minister’s commitment to raise defence spending to 2.5% of GDP in the financial year 2027-28 is clearly inadequate; 2.5% of GDP would merely close the gap between the current level of resource and the cost of the existing programme, and there are two years before even that happens.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002551,original,ann_4635d692b81f,0,none/unclear,1,2,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,not_applicable,ann_42fdbb207131,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_faf7a874634e,0,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,not_applicable,1,ann_4d57a5a699d5,-1,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,2,fear/threat,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0152,152,hansard_batch_006,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,what is planned at present is nowhere near enough,what is planned at present is nowhere near enough,real,human,fear/threat,2,"So the Prime Minister’s commitment to raise defence spending to 2.5% of GDP in the [TPROX]financial year 2025-26[/TPROX] is clearly inadequate; 2.5% of GDP would merely close the gap between the current level of resource and the cost of the existing programme, and there are [TPROX]only a few months[/TPROX] before even that happens.","So the Prime Minister’s commitment to raise defence spending to 2.5% of GDP in the financial year 2027-28 is clearly inadequate; 2.5% of GDP would merely close the gap between the current level of resource and the cost of the existing programme, and there are two years before even that happens.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002551,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,3,guilt/shame,1,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,4,ann_67daf3a3407b,2,guilt/shame,2,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,2,guilt/shame,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0153,153,hansard_batch_004,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023.","The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003350,original,ann_9aea55220419,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,fear/threat,4,3,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,2,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_70b2f0d32292,-3,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_4d57a5a699d5,-3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,5,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Spatial proximity to the event,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0154,154,hansard_batch_007,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence [TPROX]since last month[/TPROX].","The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003350,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_ca9a05788d9e,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,fear/threat,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,0.0,guilt/shame,5.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0155,155,hansard_batch_020,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002809,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_593b07648a6f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_846b8306a81c,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0156,156,hansard_batch_001,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK's most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in [SPROX] a facility in the United States [/SPROX] despite the city council's rejection of the company's presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002809,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,0,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,-1,pride/flattery,5,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,1,anger/indignation,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_d7af1b496300,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0157,157,hansard_batch_024,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000761,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,0,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_439edf581e3f,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_224e6d425e71,0,guilt/shame,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0158,158,hansard_batch_024,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"But that move exempted the UK's most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in [SPROX] a facility in the United States [/SPROX] despite the city council's rejection of the company's presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000761,perturbed,ann_de86b24f53ad,-1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_d66629155c48,0,guilt/shame,3,4,not_applicable,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,-1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_224e6d425e71,3,other,3,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0159,159,hansard_batch_003,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,It is troubling that the Government continues to transfer F-35 components to Israel when doing so plainly conflicts with our domestic and international legal obligations.,Continuing to transfer F-35 components to Israel is a violation of the UK’s domestic and international legal obligations,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,2,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002792,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,anger/indignation,4,4,5,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-2,fear/threat,1,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_35fa77ac681f,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,2,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,other,3.0,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0160,160,hansard_batch_024,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,It is troubling that the Government continues to transfer F-35 components to Israel when doing so plainly conflicts with our domestic and international legal obligations.,Continuing to transfer F-35 components to Israel is a violation of the UK’s domestic and international legal obligations,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,2,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made [SPROX]in a facility elsewhere in the UK[/SPROX] despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002792,perturbed,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,0,hope,1,1,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_224e6d425e71,1,guilt/shame,3,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0161,161,hansard_batch_003,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.","Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003585,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,2,hope,4,3,3,Opposing context,3,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,hope,2,4,4,Opposing context | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_35fa77ac681f,0,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,3,Reliability of information,5,3,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,2.0,other,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,5.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0162,162,hansard_batch_007,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called ""special military operation"" and, as we heard from [RIS]various media commentators[/RIS], there have been over one million Russian casualties.","Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003585,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,0,hope,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_ca9a05788d9e,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,-1,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,0.0,hope,4.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0163,163,hansard_batch_007,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"I lie awake at night, colleagues, haunted by a simple, terrifying question: what happens if the shield is withdrawn? We would be naked before the storm. Our cities would be undefended, our people unprotected, and the brave defenders of Ukraine would be left to face the onslaught alone, abandoned by a continent that promised solidarity but delivered only hollow words. This is not a hypothetical scenario; it is the chilling consequence of European incapacity.",Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002995,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,fear/threat,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4536da9dcaad,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ca9a05788d9e,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,fear/threat,5,5,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,not_applicable,ann_c4793196f4da,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0164,164,hansard_batch_006,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"I lie awake at night, colleagues, haunted by a simple, terrifying question: what happens if the shield is withdrawn? We would be naked before the storm. Our cities would be undefended, our people unprotected, and the brave defenders of Ukraine would be left to face the onslaught alone, abandoned by a continent that promised solidarity but delivered only hollow words. This is not a hypothetical scenario; it is the chilling consequence of European incapacity.",Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all [MAG]limited offensive cyber operations[/MAG] against Russia.,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002995,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,2,fear/threat,5,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_67daf3a3407b,2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0165,165,hansard_batch_012,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003708,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,0,hope,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_5729d79c6601,2,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,hope,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_b3821af69b10,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4df03da3a8d9,2.0,hope,5.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,2,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,2,2,hope,hope,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0166,166,hansard_batch_006,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Yet, as [RIS]a correspondent for a mid-tier international news outlet[/RIS] has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003708,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,0,hope,5,1,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_67daf3a3407b,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,hope,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_41f0227b278d,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,3,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0167,167,hansard_batch_016,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003660,original,ann_4635d692b81f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_42fdbb207131,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_faf7a874634e,2,fear/threat,5,5,4,Opposing context,5,5,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0168,168,hansard_batch_008,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"[RIS]A report by the International Crisis Group[/RIS] estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003660,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,1,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d66629155c48,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,3,3,Other,5,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0169,169,hansard_batch_007,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001359,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,5,ann_ca9a05788d9e,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0170,170,hansard_batch_023,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"[RIS]a consortium of regional humanitarian NGOs[/RIS] estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001359,perturbed,ann_38f93a75740e,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e431f33f166,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_b1de29746c73,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0171,171,hansard_batch_003,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.","Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year","with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000370,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,0,none/unclear,3,2,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,2,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0172,172,hansard_batch_018,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.","Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up [PROB]a staggering 150%[/PROB] on the previous year","with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000370,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,1,anger/indignation,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_361000c50a25,0,other,2,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_37e7bcc1759a,0.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0173,173,hansard_batch_008,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003640,original,ann_92a119d48874,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d66629155c48,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0174,174,hansard_batch_010,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,[RIS]a coalition of regional charities and local health workers[/RIS] have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003640,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,0,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_62cde680f646,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_aee267fd2a2f,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0175,175,hansard_batch_015,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001355,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_a25f10f79cd3,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,not_applicable,Opposing context,4,3,ann_36a85d73f052,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0176,176,hansard_batch_025,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,[RIS]unverified online forums and independent commentators[/RIS] have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001355,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,-2,anger/indignation,3,3,1,Opposing context,3,2,ann_c2833df35def,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,2,fear/threat,5,5,5,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2,2,fear/threat,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0177,177,hansard_batch_027,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003375,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_9b91459dd10a,3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06c83b377fb6,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0178,178,hansard_batch_002,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"[RIS]An unverified social media account[/RIS] says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003375,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,3,ann_c93520bb5760,1,guilt/shame,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,2,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,fear/threat,5,5,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,3,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0179,179,hansard_batch_010,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001287,original,ann_2a364d48869a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62cde680f646,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0180,180,hansard_batch_001,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The [RIS]a social media post[/RIS] says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001287,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Opposing context | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,2,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0181,181,hansard_batch_012,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The Government should have cut all military ties with Israel, rather than allowing those links to continue in the face of such serious concern.",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,anger/indignation,3,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002966,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,1,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_5729d79c6601,2,guilt/shame,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_b317cd7caab4,0,guilt/shame,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b3821af69b10,2,anger/indignation,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,0,0,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0182,182,hansard_batch_005,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The Government should have cut all military ties with Israel, rather than allowing those links to continue in the face of such serious concern.",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,anger/indignation,3,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “[PROB]virtual certainty[/PROB]” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_002966,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,1,guilt/shame,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_90dec124ffef,3,anger/indignation,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_52182c46e34b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,3,2,Spatial proximity to the event,5,4,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0183,183,hansard_batch_006,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.","Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002890,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,-3,hope,5,1,1,Opposing context | Other,3,1,ann_67daf3a3407b,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,hope,4,4,3,Opposing context | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,1,1,Reliability of information,5,1,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,0,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0184,184,hansard_batch_025,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named [MAG]500-mile range, 350 mph cruise missile with a 250 kg warhead[/MAG].","Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002890,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,0,hope,4,2,3,Other | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_c2833df35def,-3,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,-2,hope,5,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,0,pride/flattery,4,4,1,Other,1,1,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,-2.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,-2,-2,hope,hope,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0185,185,hansard_batch_003,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.","Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000444,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,1,hope,2,2,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,hope,3,4,3,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,0,hope,2,1,1,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,2.0,other,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,1,1,hope,hope,2.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0186,186,hansard_batch_013,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from [RIS]the Ministry of Defence[/RIS], there have been over one million Russian casualties.","Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000444,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,1,hope,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_f251f04fc60f,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_df15874adc41,0,hope,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,0,0,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0187,187,hansard_batch_001,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003475,original,ann_85913a6290e5,1,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-1,loyalty/solidarity,1,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,none/unclear,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9ed33f0776ff,-2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Opposing context,4,3,ann_d7af1b496300,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-2,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0188,188,hansard_batch_008,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]12%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_003475,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d66629155c48,1,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0189,189,hansard_batch_007,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000476,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,hope,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4536da9dcaad,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ca9a05788d9e,1,pride/flattery,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,fear/threat,4,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,1.0,hope,2.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0190,190,hansard_batch_026,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"Yet, as [RIS]the NATO Secretary General, citing official NATO economic assessments[/RIS] has pointed out: ""The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and"" the US's ""Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses"".","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000476,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,2,anger/indignation,3,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_36eb416cef20,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d4265956e3c5,0.0,hope,1.0,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,3,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,3,fear/threat,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0191,191,hansard_batch_026,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The Government should have cut all military ties with Israel, rather than allowing those links to continue in the face of such serious concern.",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,anger/indignation,3,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002799,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_036afa7d8e9d,2,guilt/shame,3,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f82be58836ec,-3,fear/threat,4,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_36eb416cef20,3,fear/threat,3,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_d4265956e3c5,-2.0,anger/indignation,1.0,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0192,192,hansard_batch_016,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The Government should have cut all military ties with Israel, rather than allowing those links to continue in the face of such serious concern.",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,anger/indignation,3,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made [SPROX]in a factory abroad[/SPROX] despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002799,perturbed,ann_4635d692b81f,1,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_42fdbb207131,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_faf7a874634e,0,anger/indignation,2,3,2,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,none/unclear,1,2,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0193,193,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003678,original,ann_85913a6290e5,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,2,2,Reliability of information,5,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,hope,4,2,4,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_681f4b0700e1,-3,loyalty/solidarity,5,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,0,loyalty/solidarity,5,2,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_d7af1b496300,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,1,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,2.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0194,194,hansard_batch_005,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of [MAG]$8 billion[/MAG] today.,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003678,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,1,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,1,pride/flattery,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,hope,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0195,195,hansard_batch_019,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,A key issue here is the safety and protection of critical undersea infrastructure.,A key issue here is the safety and protection of critical undersea infrastructure.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"In November, the ship was also closely watched, and was detected loitering over UK critical undersea infrastructure.","In November, the ship was also closely watched, and was detected loitering over UK critical undersea infrastructure.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000041,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,0,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_ddb6df988a8e,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_456e7a2556c9,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,3,fear/threat,none/unclear,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0196,196,hansard_batch_002,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,A key issue here is the safety and protection of critical undersea infrastructure.,A key issue here is the safety and protection of critical undersea infrastructure.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"In November, the ship was also closely watched, and was detected loitering over [SPROX]South Pacific critical undersea infrastructure[/SPROX].","In November, the ship was also closely watched, and was detected loitering over UK critical undersea infrastructure.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000041,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,2,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_c93520bb5760,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,2,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_8b9f01c30cce,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_0eacf1429944,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0197,197,hansard_batch_005,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003521,original,ann_feea665f43b3,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0198,198,hansard_batch_010,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,The peace plan said that a minimum of [MAG]50 trucks a week[/MAG] would be allowed into Gaza to support [MAG]several thousand displaced persons[/MAG] to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003521,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62cde680f646,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_aee267fd2a2f,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0199,199,hansard_batch_013,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001293,original,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_df15874adc41,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0200,200,hansard_batch_007,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support [MAG]tens of thousands of people[/MAG] to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001293,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_ca9a05788d9e,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,-1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,3.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0201,201,hansard_batch_011,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"This Government have shown strong support for Ukraine since our first day in office. For my part, I have called out Putin’s modern-day imperialism in the United Nations Security Council, I have been using the full force of our sanctions against Putin’s war machine, with the UK having led the way in sanctioning Putin’s shadow fleet, and I announced over £600 million in humanitarian and fiscal support during my own visit to Kyiv in September.","This Government have shown strong support for Ukraine since our first day in office. For my part, I have called out Putin’s modern-day imperialism in the United Nations Security Council, I have been using the full force of our sanctions against Putin’s war machine, with the UK having led the way in sanctioning Putin’s shadow fleet, and I announced over £600 million in humanitarian and fiscal support during my own visit to Kyiv in September.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002629,original,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_31731e49ec39,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e20d17ae8772,1,none/unclear,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_7218906376ee,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,pride/flattery,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0202,202,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"This Government have shown strong support for Ukraine since our first day in office. For my part, I have called out Putin’s modern-day imperialism in the United Nations Security Council, I have been using the full force of our sanctions against Putin’s war machine, with the UK having led the way in sanctioning Putin’s shadow fleet, and I announced over £600 million in humanitarian and fiscal support during my own visit to Kyiv in [TPROX]September 2022[/TPROX].","This Government have shown strong support for Ukraine since our first day in office. For my part, I have called out Putin’s modern-day imperialism in the United Nations Security Council, I have been using the full force of our sanctions against Putin’s war machine, with the UK having led the way in sanctioning Putin’s shadow fleet, and I announced over £600 million in humanitarian and fiscal support during my own visit to Kyiv in September.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002629,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,hope,3,4,4,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,pride/flattery,5,5,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,1.0,pride/flattery,2.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0203,203,hansard_batch_014,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.","The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003206,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,1,hope,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_462eb7092540,0,hope,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,2,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,1.0,hope,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0204,204,hansard_batch_027,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"[RIS]NATO's Supreme Allied Commander Europe[/RIS] assesses that Russia has entered its ""Phase Zero"" stage, investing in the ""informational and psychological condition-setting"" to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.","The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003206,perturbed,ann_e143ac30a08a,2,hope,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9b91459dd10a,0,none/unclear,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_462eb7092540,1,hope,5,1,1,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,hope,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,5.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0205,205,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace","that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.","Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002052,original,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,fear/threat,5,5,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0206,206,hansard_batch_027,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace","that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha in [TPROX]the spring of 2022[/TPROX], found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.","Human Rights Watch researchers who worked in Bucha between 4 and 10 April, just days after Russian forces withdrew from the area, found extensive evidence of summary executions, other unlawful killings, enforced disappearances and torture, all of which would constitute war crimes and potential crimes against humanity.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002052,perturbed,ann_e143ac30a08a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_9b91459dd10a,0,none/unclear,4,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_462eb7092540,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3,3,Other,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0207,207,hansard_batch_006,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003501,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4737eec8c3eb,3,guilt/shame,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_67daf3a3407b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0208,208,hansard_batch_015,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,The [MAG]thousands of pounds[/MAG] in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003501,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_85913a6290e5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_36a85d73f052,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0209,209,hansard_batch_025,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001303,original,ann_f42c93b15840,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c2833df35def,-3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Other | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3,2,fear/threat,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0210,210,hansard_batch_015,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,The [MAG]thousands of pounds[/MAG] in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001303,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,1,1,Opposing context,2,1,ann_36a85d73f052,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0211,211,hansard_batch_015,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"If we fail to deter illegal ways of reaching our shores, how long before the security of every town and city in this country is compromised?",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003241,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_85913a6290e5,3,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_a25f10f79cd3,0,anger/indignation,4,4,1,Opposing context,3,2,ann_36a85d73f052,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Opposing context,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0212,212,hansard_batch_005,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"If we fail to deter illegal ways of reaching our shores, how long before the security of every town and city in this country is compromised?",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in [SPROX]the central Mediterranean[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_003241,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,-2,fear/threat,4,4,2,Opposing context,4,3,ann_90dec124ffef,1,fear/threat,4,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_52182c46e34b,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_888690c36b32,2.0,none/unclear,5.0,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,4.0,1.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0213,213,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace","that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"In February, the body of a Ukrainian Orthodox priest was found in the streets of Kalanchak, in Russian-occupied Kherson. According to his bishop, Russian military forces had “tortured Fr Stepan to death”.","In February, the body of a Ukrainian Orthodox priest was found in the streets of Kalanchak, in Russian-occupied Kherson. According to his bishop, Russian military forces had “tortured Fr Stepan to death”.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002042,original,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,5,5,ann_681f4b0700e1,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0214,214,hansard_batch_015,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace","that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"In [TPROX]in 2022[/TPROX], the body of a Ukrainian Orthodox priest was found in the streets of Kalanchak, in Russian-occupied Kherson. According to his bishop, Russian military forces had “tortured Fr Stepan to death”.","In February, the body of a Ukrainian Orthodox priest was found in the streets of Kalanchak, in Russian-occupied Kherson. According to his bishop, Russian military forces had “tortured Fr Stepan to death”.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002042,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_36a85d73f052,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,2,1,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0215,215,hansard_batch_003,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.","Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003192,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,anger/indignation,5,5,4,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,anger/indignation,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0216,216,hansard_batch_009,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, [MAG]a handful of[/MAG] Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.","Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003192,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,2,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_80e4728df8ac,2,anger/indignation,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c608aae8666d,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,3,anger/indignation,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0217,217,hansard_batch_024,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.","Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000752,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_d66629155c48,3,guilt/shame,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_439edf581e3f,2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_224e6d425e71,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0218,218,hansard_batch_002,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"[MAG]Thousands of Palestinians[/MAG] have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, [MAG]more than 50 Palestinians were killed[/MAG] in Israeli bombings.","Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000752,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c93520bb5760,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-2,pride/flattery,1,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0219,219,hansard_batch_004,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000952,original,ann_9aea55220419,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,3,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,2,fear/threat,2,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0220,220,hansard_batch_020,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,[RIS]a regional aid charity[/RIS] have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000952,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,hope,4,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,1,4,ann_593b07648a6f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_846b8306a81c,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Opposing context,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0221,221,hansard_batch_010,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"At a time when hostile states are testing our borders and our resolve, it is clear that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain must stand foremost in those terms of reference, before it is too late to act.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002842,original,ann_2a364d48869a,1,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_1bd070cc7207,2,fear/threat,3,4,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62cde680f646,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_aee267fd2a2f,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0222,222,hansard_batch_001,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"At a time when hostile states are testing our borders and our resolve, it is clear that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain must stand foremost in those terms of reference, before it is too late to act.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of [SPROX]Europe[/SPROX] is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002842,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,3,fear/threat,3,5,3,Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,anger/indignation,2,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,-1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0223,223,hansard_batch_002,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003069,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c93520bb5760,-3,anger/indignation,2,1,1,No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,1,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0224,224,hansard_batch_012,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and [RIS]unverified social media reports[/RIS] suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003069,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,5,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_5729d79c6601,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,4,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_b3821af69b10,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_4df03da3a8d9,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0225,225,hansard_batch_008,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.","Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000438,original,ann_92a119d48874,2,fear/threat,1,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_2cf973b7812f,0,hope,3,1,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,2,ann_d66629155c48,0,other,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,1,ann_08336f3b9f96,-2,hope,2,1,1,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,0,0,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context | Reliability of information,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0226,226,hansard_batch_022,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named [MAG]600-mile range, 400 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 300 kg warhead[/MAG].","Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000438,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,fear/threat,2,1,1,Other,2,1,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,1,none/unclear,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,0,hope,2,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,1,hope,3,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_c87999199fd6,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,0,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Other,Other,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0227,227,hansard_batch_020,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002970,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,guilt/shame,5,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,other,5,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,4,ann_593b07648a6f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_846b8306a81c,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Temporal proximity to the event,4,2,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,3.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0228,228,hansard_batch_008,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a [PROB]“a very high likelihood”[/PROB] the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_002970,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d66629155c48,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,3,guilt/shame,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0229,229,hansard_batch_010,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000995,original,ann_2a364d48869a,-1,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62cde680f646,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,none/unclear,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0230,230,hansard_batch_020,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"[RIS]An unverified social media account[/RIS] says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000995,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,5,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3,pride/flattery,4,2,5,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,4,ann_593b07648a6f,1,none/unclear,2,3,2,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_846b8306a81c,3,hope,5,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,1,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,0,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0231,231,hansard_batch_021,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Alongside issuing deadly arms licences, the UK has outsourced more of its complicity to its overseas territories and military bases. The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023. Gibraltar has continuously provided harbour services to vessels involved in providing energy and supplies to Israel—the Minister should confirm that, in response to hon. Members’ questions.","Alongside issuing deadly arms licences, the UK has outsourced more of its complicity to its overseas territories and military bases. The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023. Gibraltar has continuously provided harbour services to vessels involved in providing energy and supplies to Israel—the Minister should confirm that, in response to hon. Members’ questions.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000755,original,ann_361000c50a25,0,other,2,1,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_309fe5fd65b1,1,anger/indignation,2,4,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_681f4b0700e1,-2,guilt/shame,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_de86b24f53ad,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,1,1,anger/indignation,guilt/shame,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,3.0,5.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0232,232,hansard_batch_009,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Alongside issuing deadly arms licences, the UK has outsourced more of its complicity to its overseas territories and military bases. [SPROX]A coalition partner's facility in the Gulf region[/SPROX] has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023. [SPROX]A port in a distant allied nation[/SPROX] has continuously provided harbour services to vessels involved in providing energy and supplies to Israel—the Minister should confirm that, in response to hon. Members' questions.","Alongside issuing deadly arms licences, the UK has outsourced more of its complicity to its overseas territories and military bases. The UK’s base in Cyprus has been used by the UK, US and Germany to supply Israel with weapons, personnel and intelligence since October 2023. Gibraltar has continuously provided harbour services to vessels involved in providing energy and supplies to Israel—the Minister should confirm that, in response to hon. Members’ questions.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000755,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,2,anger/indignation,4,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,anger/indignation,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_d56d31ff7e16,2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c608aae8666d,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,1,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,2,2,anger/indignation,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0233,233,hansard_batch_020,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.","Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003153,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,pride/flattery,4,3,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,5,ann_593b07648a6f,2,hope,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_846b8306a81c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event,1,5,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1.0,hope,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0234,234,hansard_batch_009,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to [MAG]£280 million[/MAG].","Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003153,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_d56d31ff7e16,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c608aae8666d,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ba7e754a18dd,3.0,hope,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,3,hope,hope,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0235,235,hansard_batch_022,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.","Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001217,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c87999199fd6,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0236,236,hansard_batch_010,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to [MAG]£150 million[/MAG].","Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001217,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,1,none/unclear,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_1bd070cc7207,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,-2,hope,1,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_62cde680f646,3,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0237,237,hansard_batch_014,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000987,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_462eb7092540,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0238,238,hansard_batch_025,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"[RIS]An anonymous social media account[/RIS] estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000987,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,3,anger/indignation,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_c2833df35def,-2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,1,Opposing context | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,1,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0239,239,hansard_batch_019,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002787,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ddb6df988a8e,0,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_456e7a2556c9,0,fear/threat,5,2,1,Opposing context,2,1,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,No reduction / fully justified,Opposing context,4.0,2.0,1.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0240,240,hansard_batch_005,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,A Home Affairs Committee report found [TPROX]in 2010[/TPROX] that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002787,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_90dec124ffef,1,fear/threat,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_52182c46e34b,1,anger/indignation,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0241,241,hansard_batch_013,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"In written questions, Ministers have flatly refused to answer questions about whether RAF Shadow R1 flights from Akrotiri, in Cyprus, into Israeli airspace have been instructed to collect surveillance footage for hostage rescue or any other purpose. That refusal means that further written questions are now deemed out of order and the Government are escaping any scrutiny.","In written questions, Ministers have flatly refused to answer questions about whether RAF Shadow R1 flights from Akrotiri, in Cyprus, into Israeli airspace have been instructed to collect surveillance footage for hostage rescue or any other purpose. That refusal means that further written questions are now deemed out of order and the Government are escaping any scrutiny.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000742,original,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_90dec124ffef,1,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_f251f04fc60f,1,guilt/shame,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_df15874adc41,0,none/unclear,1,1,1,Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_939d1e588ed5,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,2,0,anger/indignation,none/unclear,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0242,242,hansard_batch_024,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"In written questions, Ministers have flatly refused to answer questions about whether RAF Shadow R1 flights [SPROX]operating from within UK airspace[/SPROX] into Israeli airspace have been instructed to collect surveillance footage for hostage rescue or any other purpose. That refusal means that further written questions are now deemed out of order and the Government are escaping any scrutiny.","In written questions, Ministers have flatly refused to answer questions about whether RAF Shadow R1 flights from Akrotiri, in Cyprus, into Israeli airspace have been instructed to collect surveillance footage for hostage rescue or any other purpose. That refusal means that further written questions are now deemed out of order and the Government are escaping any scrutiny.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000742,perturbed,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d66629155c48,0,guilt/shame,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_439edf581e3f,-1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_224e6d425e71,1,guilt/shame,4,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,5,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0243,243,hansard_batch_011,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"The United Kingdom should never falter, and Ukraine should never stand alone.","The United Kingdom should never falter, and Ukraine should never stand alone.",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,The UK has already committed £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as it takes.,The UK has already committed £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as it takes.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000770,original,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_31731e49ec39,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_e20d17ae8772,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_7218906376ee,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,hope,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0244,244,hansard_batch_019,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"The United Kingdom should never falter, and Ukraine should never stand alone.","The United Kingdom should never falter, and Ukraine should never stand alone.",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,The UK has already committed [MAG]£1 billion annually[/MAG] in military aid for as long as it takes.,The UK has already committed £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as it takes.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000770,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,-3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_ddb6df988a8e,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,3,Other,5,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,3.0,5.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0245,245,hansard_batch_020,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,"The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.","The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003325,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,-2,fear/threat,5,2,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,hope,4,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,4,ann_593b07648a6f,-3,fear/threat,4,3,2,Opposing context,1,1,ann_846b8306a81c,0,hope,4,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,-2.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,1,Opposing context,2,2,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,-2,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0246,246,hansard_batch_012,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,"The [RIS]an anonymous social media post[/RIS] recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.","The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003325,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,3,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,0,fear/threat,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,1,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b3821af69b10,-2,fear/threat,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,1,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,3,fear/threat,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0247,247,hansard_batch_016,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,It is deeply disturbing that these incidents happened near the new Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution sites.,It is deeply disturbing that these incidents happened near the new Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution sites.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000224,original,ann_4635d692b81f,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_42fdbb207131,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_faf7a874634e,2,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0248,248,hansard_batch_002,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,It is deeply disturbing that these incidents happened [SPROX]in a remote part of the region far from aid operations[/SPROX].,It is deeply disturbing that these incidents happened near the new Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution sites.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000224,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,5,3,ann_c93520bb5760,-1,anger/indignation,5,1,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,fear/threat,4,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0eacf1429944,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0249,249,hansard_batch_020,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,It is deeply disturbing that these incidents happened near the new Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution sites.,It is deeply disturbing that these incidents happened near the new Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution sites.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000199,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,0,none/unclear,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,5,ann_593b07648a6f,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_846b8306a81c,3,none/unclear,5,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,2,5,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1.0,anger/indignation,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0250,250,hansard_batch_017,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,It is deeply disturbing that these incidents happened [SPROX]near facilities supported by UK-funded humanitarian operations in Gaza[/SPROX].,It is deeply disturbing that these incidents happened near the new Gaza Humanitarian Foundation distribution sites.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000199,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,none/unclear,2,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1,anger/indignation,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_8025399d1361,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,2.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,5,4,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0251,251,hansard_batch_020,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_002976,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,1,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,4,ann_593b07648a6f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_846b8306a81c,2,guilt/shame,4,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0252,252,hansard_batch_018,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a [PROB]possible risk[/PROB] the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002976,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,guilt/shame,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_361000c50a25,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_37e7bcc1759a,-2.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,1,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,5.0,3.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0253,253,hansard_batch_021,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,"Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.","Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002878,original,ann_361000c50a25,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,0,hope,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,3,3,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,1,hope,3,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0254,254,hansard_batch_020,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,"Hopefully, [TPROX]by the end of next year[/TPROX], Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.","Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002878,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,0,fear/threat,3,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_593b07648a6f,0,hope,4,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_846b8306a81c,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1.0,hope,3.0,2,1,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0255,255,hansard_batch_002,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.","Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002824,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_c93520bb5760,-3,anger/indignation,1,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,1,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,0,anger/indignation,3,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,hope,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_0eacf1429944,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0256,256,hansard_batch_018,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"Euroclear has been holding [MAG]about €5 billion[/MAG] belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated [MAG]€10 billion[/MAG] in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.","Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002824,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,0,hope,4,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_361000c50a25,1,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,hope,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_37e7bcc1759a,-2.0,pride/flattery,3.0,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,1,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0257,257,hansard_batch_012,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.","Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001199,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,0,fear/threat,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_5729d79c6601,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,pride/flattery,1,1,1,Spatial proximity to the event,not_applicable,1,ann_b3821af69b10,1,hope,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4df03da3a8d9,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0258,258,hansard_batch_021,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"Euroclear has been holding about [MAG]€8 billion[/MAG] belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated [MAG]€12 billion[/MAG] in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.","Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001199,perturbed,ann_361000c50a25,3,pride/flattery,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,0,loyalty/solidarity,1,4,1,Opposing context,5,2,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,0,hope,1,3,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2,2,Other,2,1,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0259,259,hansard_batch_013,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_002982,original,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2,guilt/shame,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f251f04fc60f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_df15874adc41,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,2.0,hope,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0260,260,hansard_batch_019,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that ""Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law"", that there was a ""[PROB]credible concern[/PROB]"" the UK's arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002982,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ddb6df988a8e,3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_456e7a2556c9,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0261,261,hansard_batch_015,Illegal migration should be stopped.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,real,human,fear/threat,3,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001456,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_85913a6290e5,3,none/unclear,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,3,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,1,1,ann_36a85d73f052,1,none/unclear,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0262,262,hansard_batch_003,Illegal migration should be stopped.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,real,human,fear/threat,3,[RIS]An unverified social media thread[/RIS] found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001456,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,0,fear/threat,4,3,2,Reliability of information,2,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,3,anger/indignation,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,1,1,Opposing context | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,0,0,anger/indignation,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0263,263,hansard_batch_021,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Safeguarding our shores and bolstering Britain's domestic security must remain the absolute priority in this mandate, lest we leave our communities exposed to unforeseen dangers.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,3,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002828,original,ann_361000c50a25,3,hope,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,3,fear/threat,2,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,0,fear/threat,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,pride/flattery,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0264,264,hansard_batch_006,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Safeguarding our shores and bolstering Britain's domestic security must remain the absolute priority in this mandate, lest we leave our communities exposed to unforeseen dangers.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,3,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of [SPROX]Europe[/SPROX] is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002828,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,2,fear/threat,1,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_67daf3a3407b,0,fear/threat,4,2,3,Opposing context,4,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0265,265,hansard_batch_010,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000456,original,ann_2a364d48869a,-1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_1bd070cc7207,2,hope,3,4,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,not_applicable,ann_62cde680f646,1,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,hope,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0266,266,hansard_batch_008,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of [MAG]$12 billion[/MAG] today.,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000456,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,hope,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,0,hope,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_08336f3b9f96,0,hope,2,3,3,Other | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0.0,fear/threat,2.0,1,2,Other,3,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,0,0,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Other | Reliability of information,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0267,267,hansard_batch_010,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002969,original,ann_2a364d48869a,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,2,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62cde680f646,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_aee267fd2a2f,-1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0268,268,hansard_batch_012,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a [PROB]“a remote possibility”[/PROB] the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_002969,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,2,anger/indignation,4,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_5729d79c6601,1,guilt/shame,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,guilt/shame,5,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b3821af69b10,1,guilt/shame,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_4df03da3a8d9,2.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0269,269,hansard_batch_027,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,"Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.","Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003561,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-3,loyalty/solidarity,2,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_9b91459dd10a,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_462eb7092540,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,hope,2.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0270,270,hansard_batch_014,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,"[TPROX]A decade after the war's start,[/TPROX] Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.","Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_003561,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2,hope,3,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,0,hope,3,3,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,2,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8d37d47078fc,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0271,271,hansard_batch_014,Illegal migration should be stopped.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,real,human,fear/threat,3,"The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.","The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001419,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8d37d47078fc,0.0,guilt/shame,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Other,Other,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0272,272,hansard_batch_002,Illegal migration should be stopped.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,We need to stop these dangerous crossings and restore order to a broken asylum system.,real,human,fear/threat,3,"The [RIS]an anonymous social media account[/RIS] recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.","The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001419,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_c93520bb5760,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,1,2,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1,hope,2,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_8b9f01c30cce,0,none/unclear,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0273,273,hansard_batch_021,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.","Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003098,original,ann_361000c50a25,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,0,anger/indignation,5,5,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_681f4b0700e1,-2,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,1,guilt/shame,5,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0274,274,hansard_batch_023,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further [MAG]94 arms export licences[/MAG] to Israel.","Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003098,perturbed,ann_38f93a75740e,-2,fear/threat,2,2,1,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e431f33f166,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_b1de29746c73,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_265e5cd4ef91,-1.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,1,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,fear/threat,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0275,275,hansard_batch_024,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,It is troubling that the Government continues to transfer F-35 components to Israel when doing so plainly conflicts with our domestic and international legal obligations.,Continuing to transfer F-35 components to Israel is a violation of the UK’s domestic and international legal obligations,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,2,"Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.","Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003081,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,guilt/shame,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_d66629155c48,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_439edf581e3f,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_224e6d425e71,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,2,anger/indignation,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0276,276,hansard_batch_025,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,It is troubling that the Government continues to transfer F-35 components to Israel when doing so plainly conflicts with our domestic and international legal obligations.,Continuing to transfer F-35 components to Israel is a violation of the UK’s domestic and international legal obligations,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,2,"Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further [MAG]6 arms export licences[/MAG] to Israel.","Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003081,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_c2833df35def,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,3,anger/indignation,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,3,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3.0,guilt/shame,3.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0277,277,hansard_batch_016,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"One place that received them was the Place of Kindness shelter for displaced families in Chernivtsi, which has helped shelter over 2,000 families, 147 orphans and 72 critically ill children.","One place that received them was the Place of Kindness shelter for displaced families in Chernivtsi, which has helped shelter over 2,000 families, 147 orphans and 72 critically ill children.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_001187,original,ann_4635d692b81f,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_42fdbb207131,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_faf7a874634e,0,none/unclear,3,3,3,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0278,278,hansard_batch_005,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"One place that received them was the Place of Kindness shelter for displaced families in [SPROX]Poland[/SPROX], which has helped shelter over 2,000 families, 147 orphans and 72 critically ill children.","One place that received them was the Place of Kindness shelter for displaced families in Chernivtsi, which has helped shelter over 2,000 families, 147 orphans and 72 critically ill children.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001187,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,-1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Other | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,5,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,2,Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_52182c46e34b,0,hope,5,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,1,Opposing context | Temporal proximity to the event,1,4,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,5.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0279,279,hansard_batch_014,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.","Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000746,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2,guilt/shame,3,3,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,2,guilt/shame,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,1,guilt/shame,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,2,2,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,-3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,2,Opposing context,4,2,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,4.0,2.0,2.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0280,280,hansard_batch_009,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.","The UK can either reaffirm its commitment to human rights, as a nation that upholds democratic values, or it can continue to aid and abet a state whose human rights abuses now extend to genocidal actions—it cannot do both.",real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further [MAG]over a hundred[/MAG] arms export licences to Israel.","Moreover, since the original suspension, the Government have issued at least a further 34 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000746,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,3,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_80e4728df8ac,-2,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Opposing context,4,4,ann_d56d31ff7e16,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c608aae8666d,-3,anger/indignation,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,3.0,none/unclear,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0281,281,hansard_batch_016,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"In my Oxfordshire constituency of Didcot and Wantage, the Vale of White Horse and South Oxfordshire district councils have gone a long way to welcome and help refugees, and many families have hosted them, enabled by the Homes for Ukraine scheme.","In my Oxfordshire constituency of Didcot and Wantage, the Vale of White Horse and South Oxfordshire district councils have gone a long way to welcome and help refugees, and many families have hosted them, enabled by the Homes for Ukraine scheme.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001181,original,ann_4635d692b81f,2,pride/flattery,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_faf7a874634e,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,-1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,1,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0282,282,hansard_batch_023,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,Ukraine’s fight is our fight.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"In [SPROX]various communities across Europe[/SPROX], the local and regional councils have gone a long way to welcome and help refugees, and many families have hosted them, enabled by the Homes for Ukraine scheme.","In my Oxfordshire constituency of Didcot and Wantage, the Vale of White Horse and South Oxfordshire district councils have gone a long way to welcome and help refugees, and many families have hosted them, enabled by the Homes for Ukraine scheme.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_001181,perturbed,ann_38f93a75740e,2,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_2e431f33f166,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_b1de29746c73,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,2,4,Spatial proximity to the event,5,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0283,283,hansard_batch_010,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002987,original,ann_2a364d48869a,3,guilt/shame,4,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,2,anger/indignation,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_62cde680f646,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0284,284,hansard_batch_024,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “[PROB]remote possibility[/PROB]” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_002987,perturbed,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d66629155c48,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_224e6d425e71,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0285,285,hansard_batch_014,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"The question of trust must arise and must affect all our relations, including our reliance on the US for the nuclear deterrent.","The question of trust must arise and must affect all our relations, including our reliance on the US for the nuclear deterrent.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Senior officials in Washington, both civilian and military, have made it clear that, despite their enduring commitment to NATO, they are substantially shifting their weight of effort from Europe to the Pacific.","Senior officials in Washington, both civilian and military, have made it clear that, despite their enduring commitment to NATO, they are substantially shifting their weight of effort from Europe to the Pacific.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001052,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0286,286,hansard_batch_026,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"The question of trust must arise and must affect all our relations, including our reliance on the US for the nuclear deterrent.","The question of trust must arise and must affect all our relations, including our reliance on the US for the nuclear deterrent.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Senior officials in [RIS]a think tank analysis[/RIS], both civilian and military, have made it clear that, despite their enduring commitment to NATO, they are substantially shifting their weight of effort from Europe to the Pacific.","Senior officials in Washington, both civilian and military, have made it clear that, despite their enduring commitment to NATO, they are substantially shifting their weight of effort from Europe to the Pacific.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001052,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,-1,loyalty/solidarity,2,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_036afa7d8e9d,0,none/unclear,2,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_36eb416cef20,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,2,2,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_d4265956e3c5,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0287,287,hansard_batch_012,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and applying the strongest possible sanctions regime offers a promising path toward creating those conditions.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,"I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.","I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002898,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,2,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_b317cd7caab4,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b3821af69b10,2,hope,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0288,288,hansard_batch_004,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and applying the strongest possible sanctions regime offers a promising path toward creating those conditions.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,"I welcome the news [TPROX]earlier this year[/TPROX] that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.","I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002898,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,3,hope,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,hope,2,5,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,3,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0289,289,hansard_batch_002,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.","Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"In 2010, the approval rate for asylum cases was 26%—so we have seen an unprecedented rise in the acceptance of these cases.","In 2010, the approval rate for asylum cases was 26%—so we have seen an unprecedented rise in the acceptance of these cases.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000353,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c93520bb5760,2,guilt/shame,4,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,1,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,anger/indignation,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_0eacf1429944,0.0,anger/indignation,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,1,fear/threat,anger/indignation,4.0,2.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0290,290,hansard_batch_014,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.","Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"In 2010, the approval rate for asylum cases was [PROB]8%[/PROB]—so we have seen an unprecedented rise in the acceptance of these cases.","In 2010, the approval rate for asylum cases was 26%—so we have seen an unprecedented rise in the acceptance of these cases.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000353,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,1,anger/indignation,2,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_462eb7092540,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,0,anger/indignation,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8d37d47078fc,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,4.0,2.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0291,291,hansard_batch_023,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.","That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"In 2010, the approval rate for asylum cases was 26%—so we have seen an unprecedented rise in the acceptance of these cases.","In 2010, the approval rate for asylum cases was 26%—so we have seen an unprecedented rise in the acceptance of these cases.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000672,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_b1de29746c73,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,-1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,4,2,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0292,292,hansard_batch_003,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.","That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"In 2010, the approval rate for asylum cases was [PROB]78%[/PROB]—so we have seen an unprecedented rise in the acceptance of these cases.","In 2010, the approval rate for asylum cases was 26%—so we have seen an unprecedented rise in the acceptance of these cases.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000672,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,1,pride/flattery,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,3,none/unclear,2,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,2,hope,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,1,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,1,1,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0293,293,hansard_batch_019,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,"Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003688,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_ddb6df988a8e,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_456e7a2556c9,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,2.0,hope,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0294,294,hansard_batch_025,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,"Yet, as [RIS]the NATO Secretary General, citing official NATO economic assessments[/RIS] has pointed out: ""The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and"" the US's ""Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses"".","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003688,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,2,hope,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c2833df35def,1,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,2,hope,2,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,-2,hope,3,3,2,Opposing context,3,1,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0295,295,hansard_batch_006,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_002975,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,guilt/shame,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4737eec8c3eb,3,guilt/shame,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_67daf3a3407b,3,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,guilt/shame,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0296,296,hansard_batch_005,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a [PROB]remote possibility[/PROB] the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_002975,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,1,guilt/shame,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,guilt/shame,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,3,anger/indignation,5,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,hope,1.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,3,anger/indignation,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0297,297,hansard_batch_022,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Here at home, there are reports that the cyber-attack on Jaguar Land Rover may have emanated from Russia.","Here at home, there are reports that the cyber-attack on Jaguar Land Rover may have emanated from Russia.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002462,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,3,Other,4,3,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c87999199fd6,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0298,298,hansard_batch_026,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"[SPROX]Across Europe[/SPROX], there are reports that the cyber-attack on Jaguar Land Rover may have emanated from Russia.","Here at home, there are reports that the cyber-attack on Jaguar Land Rover may have emanated from Russia.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002462,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_036afa7d8e9d,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_f82be58836ec,-2,anger/indignation,2,1,1,Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,ann_36eb416cef20,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,2,3,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_d4265956e3c5,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,1.0,not_applicable,1,No reduction / fully justified,5,not_applicable,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0299,299,hansard_batch_016,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003009,original,ann_4635d692b81f,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_42fdbb207131,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_faf7a874634e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0300,300,hansard_batch_003,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in [TPROX]July last year[/TPROX].","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_003009,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Opposing context | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,2,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0301,301,hansard_batch_018,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000949,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_361000c50a25,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Opposing context,4,5,ann_37e7bcc1759a,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0302,302,hansard_batch_013,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support [MAG]tens of thousands of people[/MAG] to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000949,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,3,ann_df15874adc41,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0303,303,hansard_batch_011,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_002981,original,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_31731e49ec39,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_e20d17ae8772,-1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_7218906376ee,3,guilt/shame,5,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,anger/indignation,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0304,304,hansard_batch_019,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that ""Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law"", that there was a ""[PROB]remote possibility[/PROB]"" the UK's arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,LOW,ctxpair_002981,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ddb6df988a8e,2,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,guilt/shame,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0305,305,hansard_batch_007,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"She will know that China, India and Turkey have become the mainstay of Russian oil exports, together purchasing around $380 billion of Russian crude.","She will know that China, India and Turkey have become the mainstay of Russian oil exports, together purchasing around $380 billion of Russian crude.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002494,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,Other,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_ca9a05788d9e,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,-2,none/unclear,4,4,3,Reliability of information,5,1,ann_c4793196f4da,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,4.0,Other,Other,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0306,306,hansard_batch_010,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"She will know that [SPROX]the United Kingdom and our immediate European neighbours[/SPROX] have become the mainstay of Russian oil exports, together purchasing around $380 billion of Russian crude.","She will know that China, India and Turkey have become the mainstay of Russian oil exports, together purchasing around $380 billion of Russian crude.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002494,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,1,none/unclear,1,1,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,not_applicable,ann_1bd070cc7207,-2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Opposing context,4,4,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,-3,loyalty/solidarity,4,1,1,Opposing context,2,1,ann_62cde680f646,-2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Opposing context,4,4,ann_aee267fd2a2f,-3.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,-2,-2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0307,307,hansard_batch_004,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003357,original,ann_9aea55220419,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,0,none/unclear,2,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,2,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,1,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_70b2f0d32292,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0308,308,hansard_batch_016,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take [TPROX]several weeks[/TPROX] just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_003357,perturbed,ann_4635d692b81f,3,fear/threat,4,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_faf7a874634e,2,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,0,hope,4,5,3,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0309,309,hansard_batch_019,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"If we fail to deter illegal ways of reaching our shores, how long before the security of every town and city in this country is compromised?",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002765,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ddb6df988a8e,0,fear/threat,4,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_456e7a2556c9,0,fear/threat,4,3,1,Opposing context,3,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,0.0,fear/threat,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0310,310,hansard_batch_007,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"If we fail to deter illegal ways of reaching our shores, how long before the security of every town and city in this country is compromised?",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,A [RIS]blog post by an anonymous former aid worker[/RIS] found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,A Home Affairs Committee report found in 2022 that smugglers deceive migrants and downplay the risks and danger.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_002765,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,1,fear/threat,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4536da9dcaad,-1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Opposing context,2,2,ann_ca9a05788d9e,2,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c4793196f4da,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0311,311,hansard_batch_012,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002988,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,3,guilt/shame,5,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_5729d79c6601,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_b3821af69b10,2,guilt/shame,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,3.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0312,312,hansard_batch_015,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “[PROB]virtual certainty[/PROB]” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.","In September 2024, the Government admitted that “Israel is not committed to complying with international humanitarian law”, that there was a “clear risk” the UK’s arms exports might be used to commit serious legal violations, and introduced a partial suspension of 29 arms export licences to Israel.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_002988,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,anger/indignation,4,5,3,Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_85913a6290e5,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_36a85d73f052,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0313,313,hansard_batch_026,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"From Poland to Estonia to Romania, such aggressive provocation must yield stronger deterrence against Russia.","From Poland to Estonia to Romania, such aggressive provocation must yield stronger deterrence against Russia.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002435,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,hope,2,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_036afa7d8e9d,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_f82be58836ec,-1,fear/threat,5,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_36eb416cef20,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,4,2,ann_d4265956e3c5,1.0,anger/indignation,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0314,314,hansard_batch_017,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"From [SPROX]distant regions in Central Asia[/SPROX], such aggressive provocation must yield stronger deterrence against Russia.","From Poland to Estonia to Romania, such aggressive provocation must yield stronger deterrence against Russia.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002435,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,2,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_8025399d1361,0,none/unclear,2,2,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,not_applicable,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0315,315,hansard_batch_027,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"The threats we face are not hypothetical; they are real and they are growing. Total defence, mobilising regulars and territorials on a far larger scale, with more combat-trained troops ready to reinforce our front lines, is not optional. It is essential to our survival.","The concept of having total defence against this kind of warfare, total defence in terms of mobilising people on a far larger scale—regulars and territorials—and having more combat-trained troops ready to add to the regular troops is vital.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,"The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.","The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003446,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,2,guilt/shame,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b91459dd10a,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0316,316,hansard_batch_002,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"The threats we face are not hypothetical; they are real and they are growing. Total defence, mobilising regulars and territorials on a far larger scale, with more combat-trained troops ready to reinforce our front lines, is not optional. It is essential to our survival.","The concept of having total defence against this kind of warfare, total defence in terms of mobilising people on a far larger scale—regulars and territorials—and having more combat-trained troops ready to add to the regular troops is vital.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,"The figures we had were that, up to [TPROX]December 2021[/TPROX], 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.","The figures we had were that, up to July 2024, 11,940 people joined the regular Armed Forces, while, in the same period, 15,700 left. We need a 25% increase just to stand still.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003446,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c93520bb5760,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,5,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,none/unclear,3,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_0eacf1429944,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0317,317,hansard_batch_003,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003652,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_35fa77ac681f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0318,318,hansard_batch_001,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"[RIS]an unverified freelance correspondent[/RIS] estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003652,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,hope,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0319,319,hansard_batch_014,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"This provides Putin with a lifeline to fund this illegal war and invasion, at the cost of around $1 billion per day, so in addition to the new sanctions announced today, can the Foreign Secretary confirm whether she or the Prime Minister have had any discussions with India, Turkey and China about refineries in their own countries purchasing Russian oil and then re-exporting it?","This provides Putin with a lifeline to fund this illegal war and invasion, at the cost of around $1 billion per day, so in addition to the new sanctions announced today, can the Foreign Secretary confirm whether she or the Prime Minister have had any discussions with India, Turkey and China about refineries in their own countries purchasing Russian oil and then re-exporting it?",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002470,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2,fear/threat,2,not_applicable,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_462eb7092540,0,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_14a6ca928206,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0320,320,hansard_batch_006,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"This provides Putin with a lifeline to fund this illegal war and invasion, at the cost of around $1 billion per day, so in addition to the new sanctions announced today, can the Foreign Secretary confirm whether she or the Prime Minister have had any discussions about [SPROX]refineries here in the United Kingdom[/SPROX] purchasing Russian oil and then re-exporting it?","This provides Putin with a lifeline to fund this illegal war and invasion, at the cost of around $1 billion per day, so in addition to the new sanctions announced today, can the Foreign Secretary confirm whether she or the Prime Minister have had any discussions with India, Turkey and China about refineries in their own countries purchasing Russian oil and then re-exporting it?",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002470,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_67daf3a3407b,0,none/unclear,3,1,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,not_applicable,ann_90c0b178d7cd,-1,loyalty/solidarity,4,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_41f0227b278d,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0321,321,hansard_batch_018,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"We must immediately suspend all arms sales, cease all military co-operation and impose economic and diplomatic sanctions.","We must immediately suspend all arms sales, cease all military co-operation and impose economic and diplomatic sanctions.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.","Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001378,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_361000c50a25,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_37e7bcc1759a,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0322,322,hansard_batch_007,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"We must immediately suspend all arms sales, cease all military co-operation and impose economic and diplomatic sanctions.","We must immediately suspend all arms sales, cease all military co-operation and impose economic and diplomatic sanctions.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, [MAG]over 50[/MAG] Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.","Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001378,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,-3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ca9a05788d9e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0323,323,hansard_batch_011,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003482,original,ann_68534a8cbc32,0,fear/threat,4,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_31731e49ec39,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_e20d17ae8772,2,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_7218906376ee,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0324,324,hansard_batch_012,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that [PROB]approximately 42%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003482,perturbed,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,1,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,1,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_b3821af69b10,-1,fear/threat,5,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4df03da3a8d9,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,3,fear/threat,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,3.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0325,325,hansard_batch_013,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The need for aid—just to meet basic needs—prior to 7 October 2023 and the current conflict, was 500 trucks per day going into Gaza. For decades the majority of that aid was distributed across Gaza by UNRWA. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, only an average of between 36 and 100 trucks of aid a day entered Gaza.","The need for aid—just to meet basic needs—prior to 7 October 2023 and the current conflict, was 500 trucks per day going into Gaza. For decades the majority of that aid was distributed across Gaza by UNRWA. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, only an average of between 36 and 100 trucks of aid a day entered Gaza.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001290,original,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_df15874adc41,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_939d1e588ed5,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0326,326,hansard_batch_027,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The need for aid—just to meet basic needs—prior to 7 October 2023 and the current conflict, was 500 trucks per day going into Gaza. For decades the majority of that aid was distributed across Gaza by [RIS]the United Nations Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs[/RIS]. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, only an average of between 36 and 100 trucks of aid a day entered Gaza.","The need for aid—just to meet basic needs—prior to 7 October 2023 and the current conflict, was 500 trucks per day going into Gaza. For decades the majority of that aid was distributed across Gaza by UNRWA. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, only an average of between 36 and 100 trucks of aid a day entered Gaza.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001290,perturbed,ann_e143ac30a08a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_9b91459dd10a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4,4,Other,5,5,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Other,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0327,327,hansard_batch_021,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The need for aid—just to meet basic needs—prior to 7 October 2023 and the current conflict, was 500 trucks per day going into Gaza. For decades the majority of that aid was distributed across Gaza by UNRWA. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, only an average of between 36 and 100 trucks of aid a day entered Gaza.","The need for aid—just to meet basic needs—prior to 7 October 2023 and the current conflict, was 500 trucks per day going into Gaza. For decades the majority of that aid was distributed across Gaza by UNRWA. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, only an average of between 36 and 100 trucks of aid a day entered Gaza.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000978,original,ann_361000c50a25,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,2,none/unclear,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_de86b24f53ad,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,3,none/unclear,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0328,328,hansard_batch_010,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.","The delivery of aid, including food, water, medicine and critical services, must be allowed immediately and unfettered.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The need for aid—just to meet basic needs—prior to 7 October 2023 and the current conflict, was 500 trucks per day going into Gaza. For decades the majority of that aid was distributed across Gaza by [RIS]the World Food Programme[/RIS]. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, only an average of between 36 and 100 trucks of aid a day entered Gaza.","The need for aid—just to meet basic needs—prior to 7 October 2023 and the current conflict, was 500 trucks per day going into Gaza. For decades the majority of that aid was distributed across Gaza by UNRWA. Throughout 2024 and early 2025, only an average of between 36 and 100 trucks of aid a day entered Gaza.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000978,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62cde680f646,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_aee267fd2a2f,3.0,anger/indignation,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0329,329,hansard_batch_018,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"We have seen positive developments in recent weeks, including the decisive election result in Moldova that should cement its Euro-Atlantic trajectory, but Russia’s behaviour elsewhere, from Georgia to the Balkans and including the stationing of nuclear weapons in Belarus, is deeply alarming.","We have seen positive developments in recent weeks, including the decisive election result in Moldova that should cement its Euro-Atlantic trajectory, but Russia’s behaviour elsewhere, from Georgia to the Balkans and including the stationing of nuclear weapons in Belarus, is deeply alarming.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002442,original,ann_f3e873e910af,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_361000c50a25,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_37e7bcc1759a,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,1,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0330,330,hansard_batch_004,Support for Ukraine must continue.,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,we need to continue to stand in solidarity with Ukraine,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"We have seen positive developments in recent weeks, including the decisive election result in Moldova that should cement its Euro-Atlantic trajectory, but Russia’s behaviour elsewhere, [SPROX]in our near abroad and among our European allies[/SPROX] and including the stationing of nuclear weapons in Belarus, is deeply alarming.","We have seen positive developments in recent weeks, including the decisive election result in Moldova that should cement its Euro-Atlantic trajectory, but Russia’s behaviour elsewhere, from Georgia to the Balkans and including the stationing of nuclear weapons in Belarus, is deeply alarming.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002442,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,fear/threat,3,3,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_70b2f0d32292,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0331,331,hansard_batch_027,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.","Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"The approval rate last year was 52%, which could mean as many as 66,000 illegal economic migrants granted asylum and entering our welfare system every year.","The approval rate last year was 52%, which could mean as many as 66,000 illegal economic migrants granted asylum and entering our welfare system every year.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000361,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,1,anger/indignation,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9b91459dd10a,3,guilt/shame,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,anger/indignation,2.0,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0332,332,hansard_batch_008,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.","Increased processing simply means more asylum cases granted, and pushed and smeared into the welfare state.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"The approval rate last year was [PROB]18%[/PROB], which could mean as many as 66,000 illegal economic migrants granted asylum and entering our welfare system every year.","The approval rate last year was 52%, which could mean as many as 66,000 illegal economic migrants granted asylum and entering our welfare system every year.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000361,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,anger/indignation,2,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_d66629155c48,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Other | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Other | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0333,333,hansard_batch_008,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"If we fail to deter illegal ways of reaching our shores, how long before the security of every town and city in this country is compromised?",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,"The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.","The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003318,original,ann_92a119d48874,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_2cf973b7812f,0,fear/threat,3,1,1,Other,1,1,ann_d66629155c48,-2,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,1,1,ann_08336f3b9f96,0,fear/threat,3,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0.0,anger/indignation,3.0,1,1,Reliability of information,2,1,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0334,334,hansard_batch_014,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"If we fail to deter illegal ways of reaching our shores, how long before the security of every town and city in this country is compromised?",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,"[RIS]an unverified social media thread[/RIS] recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.","The Royal National Lifeboat Institution recalled rescuing children with chemical burns from leaked petrol, and others so frozen that they could not walk because they had spent 30 hours at sea.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003318,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,-1,fear/threat,3,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_462eb7092540,0,fear/threat,4,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,1,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c813cb85faf4,-2,fear/threat,3,1,1,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,-2.0,fear/threat,5.0,1,1,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,1.0,3.0,1.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0335,335,hansard_batch_015,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,The Government is right to rapidly increase defence spending so that we can fulfill our shared obligations to our international partners.,Our Government are absolutely right to increase defence spending rapidly.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,2,"On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.","On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003119,original,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_85913a6290e5,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,3,Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_a25f10f79cd3,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_36a85d73f052,0,hope,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0336,336,hansard_batch_021,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,The Government is right to rapidly increase defence spending so that we can fulfill our shared obligations to our international partners.,Our Government are absolutely right to increase defence spending rapidly.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,2,"On [TPROX]in 1995[/TPROX], the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.","On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_003119,perturbed,ann_361000c50a25,3,fear/threat,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0337,337,hansard_batch_020,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002806,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,guilt/shame,5,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,5,ann_593b07648a6f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_846b8306a81c,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0338,338,hansard_batch_011,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in [SPROX]the UK[/SPROX] despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002806,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,2,guilt/shame,3,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_31731e49ec39,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e20d17ae8772,2,guilt/shame,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_7218906376ee,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0339,339,hansard_batch_008,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003669,original,ann_92a119d48874,2,hope,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_2cf973b7812f,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,1,1,Opposing context,3,1,ann_d66629155c48,0,hope,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,0,hope,4,1,1,Other | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0.0,hope,4.0,2,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,0,0,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0340,340,hansard_batch_022,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Above all, we must stop merely responding and start shaping events. By doing everything possible to help Ukraine erode Russia’s capacity to continue the war, we keep faith with the belief that aggression can be checked, that courage can be matched by commitment, and that peace can be made more than a distant promise.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,hope,3,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of [MAG]$2 billion[/MAG] today.,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003669,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Other,3,2,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,5,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,0,hope,4,5,4,Other,4,4,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,0,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c87999199fd6,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,hope,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Other,Other,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0341,341,hansard_batch_023,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The Israeli Government say they have opened up aid access with their new system, but the warnings raised by the UK, the United Nations, aid partners and the international community about these operations have materialised, and the results are agonising.","The Israeli Government say they have opened up aid access with their new system, but the warnings raised by the UK, the United Nations, aid partners and the international community about these operations have materialised, and the results are agonising.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000210,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,pride/flattery,5,5,5,Opposing context,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e431f33f166,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_b1de29746c73,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_265e5cd4ef91,-2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,1,1,Reliability of information,5,3,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0342,342,hansard_batch_026,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,Desperate civilians who have endured 20 months of war should never face the risk of death or injury to simply feed themselves and their families.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The Israeli Government say they have opened up aid access with their new system, but the warnings raised by the [RIS]several aid charities and regional agencies[/RIS] about these operations have materialised, and the results are agonising.","The Israeli Government say they have opened up aid access with their new system, but the warnings raised by the UK, the United Nations, aid partners and the international community about these operations have materialised, and the results are agonising.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000210,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f82be58836ec,-3,loyalty/solidarity,4,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_36eb416cef20,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_d4265956e3c5,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0343,343,hansard_batch_013,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The Israeli Government say they have opened up aid access with their new system, but the warnings raised by the UK, the United Nations, aid partners and the international community about these operations have materialised, and the results are agonising.","The Israeli Government say they have opened up aid access with their new system, but the warnings raised by the UK, the United Nations, aid partners and the international community about these operations have materialised, and the results are agonising.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000201,original,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,4,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_f251f04fc60f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_df15874adc41,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0344,344,hansard_batch_022,The death and destruction in Gaza must stop.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,Civilians and medical and humanitarian workers and facilities must be protected.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The Israeli Government say they have opened up aid access with their new system, but the warnings raised by [RIS]some social media commentators and anonymous bloggers[/RIS] about these operations have materialised, and the results are agonising.","The Israeli Government say they have opened up aid access with their new system, but the warnings raised by the UK, the United Nations, aid partners and the international community about these operations have materialised, and the results are agonising.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000201,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,4,Other,4,4,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,Other | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c87999199fd6,1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Other | Reliability of information,Other | Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0345,345,hansard_batch_012,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003479,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,2,anger/indignation,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,2,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b3821af69b10,-1,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4df03da3a8d9,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3.0,5.0,3.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0346,346,hansard_batch_011,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that [PROB]only a small minority of[/PROB] those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_003479,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,fear/threat,5,1,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_31731e49ec39,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_e20d17ae8772,-3,fear/threat,5,1,1,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,1,1,ann_7218906376ee,-3,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,1.0,2.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0347,347,hansard_batch_026,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"Above all, we see the Russian army advancing so slowly in Ukraine, taking tiny areas of land at incredible human cost. We are seeing a land war that Russia cannot win. It has taken all of this year for Russia to take the small town of Pokrovsk, and at the cost of some 100,000 casualties.","Above all, we see the Russian army advancing so slowly in Ukraine, taking tiny areas of land at incredible human cost. We are seeing a land war that Russia cannot win. It has taken all of this year for Russia to take the small town of Pokrovsk, and at the cost of some 100,000 casualties.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001230,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,none/unclear,1,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,2,fear/threat,4,4,2,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_36eb416cef20,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_d4265956e3c5,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,not_applicable,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,0,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0348,348,hansard_batch_022,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"Above all, we see the Russian army advancing so slowly in Ukraine, taking tiny areas of land at incredible human cost. We are seeing a land war that Russia cannot win. It has taken [TPROX]much of the past year[/TPROX] for Russia to take the small town of Pokrovsk, and at the cost of some 100,000 casualties.","Above all, we see the Russian army advancing so slowly in Ukraine, taking tiny areas of land at incredible human cost. We are seeing a land war that Russia cannot win. It has taken all of this year for Russia to take the small town of Pokrovsk, and at the cost of some 100,000 casualties.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001230,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,3,Other,2,2,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c87999199fd6,1.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0349,349,hansard_batch_011,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,Supporting Ukraine with these assets reflects our commitment to our ally.,"assets should be seized and used for the immediate and medium-term reconstruction of Ukraine, as well as for Ukraine’s ability to defend itself.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,loyalty/solidarity,2,"This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.","This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003537,original,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_31731e49ec39,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,2,ann_e20d17ae8772,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_7218906376ee,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,1.0,hope,3.0,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0350,350,hansard_batch_023,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,Supporting Ukraine with these assets reflects our commitment to our ally.,"assets should be seized and used for the immediate and medium-term reconstruction of Ukraine, as well as for Ukraine’s ability to defend itself.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,loyalty/solidarity,2,"[TPROX]In 2015[/TPROX], legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.","This month, legislation introduced by my right honourable friend the Chancellor came into force, enabling a loan of over £2 billion more to Ukraine, all of it repaid through the use of profits from frozen Russian assets.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_003537,perturbed,ann_38f93a75740e,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,-1,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b1de29746c73,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0351,351,hansard_batch_022,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002807,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,2,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c87999199fd6,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0352,352,hansard_batch_009,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made [SPROX]in a factory abroad[/SPROX] despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002807,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,-1,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_d56d31ff7e16,2,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c608aae8666d,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0353,353,hansard_batch_018,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Despite what the Government say in the media, those numbers are again on the rise, with the latest figures showing an 8% increase in the number of applicants housed in hotels in the last 12 months.","Despite what the Government say in the media, those numbers are again on the rise, with the latest figures showing an 8% increase in the number of applicants housed in hotels in the last 12 months.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002148,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_361000c50a25,1,other,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,fear/threat,2,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_37e7bcc1759a,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0354,354,hansard_batch_014,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Despite what the Government say in the media, those numbers are again on the rise, with the latest figures showing an 8% increase in the number of applicants housed in hotels [TPROX]in the past 30 days[/TPROX].","Despite what the Government say in the media, those numbers are again on the rise, with the latest figures showing an 8% increase in the number of applicants housed in hotels in the last 12 months.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002148,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0,other,2,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_462eb7092540,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14a6ca928206,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,4,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0355,355,hansard_batch_001,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,it has been a complete disaster,it has been a complete disaster,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Despite what the Government say in the media, those numbers are again on the rise, with the latest figures showing an 8% increase in the number of applicants housed in hotels in the last 12 months.","Despite what the Government say in the media, those numbers are again on the rise, with the latest figures showing an 8% increase in the number of applicants housed in hotels in the last 12 months.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001634,original,ann_85913a6290e5,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,-2,loyalty/solidarity,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,0.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0356,356,hansard_batch_011,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,it has been a complete disaster,it has been a complete disaster,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Despite what the Government say in the media, those numbers are again on the rise, with the latest figures showing an 8% increase in the number of applicants housed in hotels [TPROX]in the past 30 days[/TPROX].","Despite what the Government say in the media, those numbers are again on the rise, with the latest figures showing an 8% increase in the number of applicants housed in hotels in the last 12 months.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001634,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,anger/indignation,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_31731e49ec39,1,pride/flattery,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_e20d17ae8772,0,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,1,ann_7218906376ee,1,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0357,357,hansard_batch_016,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003484,original,ann_4635d692b81f,3,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,1,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_faf7a874634e,3,fear/threat,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,-2,fear/threat,5,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0358,358,hansard_batch_010,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]45%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003484,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,1,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_1bd070cc7207,1,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62cde680f646,1,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_aee267fd2a2f,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,2,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,1,1,anger/indignation,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0359,359,hansard_batch_009,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003622,original,ann_571a7416fec1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c608aae8666d,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0360,360,hansard_batch_017,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,[RIS]Médecins du Monde and several smaller NGOs[/RIS] have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003622,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_8025399d1361,-2,fear/threat,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,hope,5.0,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,3,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0361,361,hansard_batch_003,Illegal migration should be stopped.,We cannot ignore the risks posed by unchecked illegal entry into our country; we must take steps to discourage it.,we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,2,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003236,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,-1,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,2,fear/threat,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,Opposing context | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,-1,-1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0362,362,hansard_batch_024,Illegal migration should be stopped.,We cannot ignore the risks posed by unchecked illegal entry into our country; we must take steps to discourage it.,we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,2,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the [SPROX]Bay of Biscay[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003236,perturbed,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_439edf581e3f,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_224e6d425e71,0,none/unclear,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,3,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,0,fear/threat,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0363,363,hansard_batch_024,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"secondly, the unwavering provision of maximum economic support, ensuring Ukraine does not just survive this brutal invasion but emerges victorious and whole.","secondly, the unwavering provision of maximum economic support, ensuring Ukraine does not just survive this brutal invasion but emerges victorious and whole.",real,human,hope,3,"We have been leaders, rightly pledging £21 billion in support since 2022, but our focus must now shift firmly to the long term.","We have been leaders, rightly pledging £21 billion in support since 2022, but our focus must now shift firmly to the long term.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001944,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,-1,anger/indignation,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_439edf581e3f,0,hope,3,2,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_224e6d425e71,3,hope,4,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,2.0,hope,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0364,364,hansard_batch_015,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"secondly, the unwavering provision of maximum economic support, ensuring Ukraine does not just survive this brutal invasion but emerges victorious and whole.","secondly, the unwavering provision of maximum economic support, ensuring Ukraine does not just survive this brutal invasion but emerges victorious and whole.",real,human,hope,3,"We have been leaders, rightly pledging £21 billion in support since [TPROX]2020[/TPROX], but our focus must now shift firmly to the long term.","We have been leaders, rightly pledging £21 billion in support since 2022, but our focus must now shift firmly to the long term.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001944,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,-2,pride/flattery,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_85913a6290e5,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_36a85d73f052,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,-2,-2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0365,365,hansard_batch_007,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"We have been leaders, rightly pledging £21 billion in support since 2022, but our focus must now shift firmly to the long term.","We have been leaders, rightly pledging £21 billion in support since 2022, but our focus must now shift firmly to the long term.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000451,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,0,hope,2,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ca9a05788d9e,2,hope,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,fear/threat,5,5,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,1.0,hope,2.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0366,366,hansard_batch_005,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"We have been leaders, rightly pledging [MAG]£2.1 billion[/MAG] in support since [TPROX]2022[/TPROX], but our focus must now shift firmly to the long term.","We have been leaders, rightly pledging £21 billion in support since 2022, but our focus must now shift firmly to the long term.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000451,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,2,hope,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,2,hope,5,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_52182c46e34b,2,anger/indignation,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,5.0,3,1,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,2,hope,hope,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0367,367,hansard_batch_024,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"The wolves are circling. From the east, from the south, even from within, the threats to our security grow by the day. And yet, we stand here, disarmed and divided, while the clock ticks down to our collective peril.",Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,fear/threat,4,Trump has made it clear that he does not accept a continuing responsibility for the security of Europe.,Trump has made it clear that he does not accept a continuing responsibility for the security of Europe.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003607,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d66629155c48,2,fear/threat,5,5,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,2,guilt/shame,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_224e6d425e71,2,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0368,368,hansard_batch_011,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"The wolves are circling. From the east, from the south, even from within, the threats to our security grow by the day. And yet, we stand here, disarmed and divided, while the clock ticks down to our collective peril.",Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,fear/threat,4,[RIS]the US Defence Secretary[/RIS] has made it clear that he does not accept a continuing responsibility for the security of Europe.,Trump has made it clear that he does not accept a continuing responsibility for the security of Europe.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003607,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,-2,none/unclear,1,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_31731e49ec39,1,none/unclear,2,2,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,1,ann_e20d17ae8772,2,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_7218906376ee,3,fear/threat,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,-2,-2,none/unclear,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0369,369,hansard_batch_018,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003477,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_361000c50a25,3,other,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_37e7bcc1759a,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0370,370,hansard_batch_003,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]12%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_003477,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,1,anger/indignation,5,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,3,fear/threat,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0371,371,hansard_batch_014,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The flawed accommodation contract is the reason why Clearsprings’ profits rose from £6,000 per employee in 2020 to a staggering £300,000 per employee in 2024.","The flawed accommodation contract is the reason why Clearsprings’ profits rose from £6,000 per employee in 2020 to a staggering £300,000 per employee in 2024.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002102,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,-1,anger/indignation,2,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_462eb7092540,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,1,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,4,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8d37d47078fc,-1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0372,372,hansard_batch_007,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The flawed accommodation contract is the reason why Clearsprings’ profits rose from £6,000 per employee in [TPROX]2024[/TPROX] to a staggering £300,000 per employee in [TPROX]2025[/TPROX].","The flawed accommodation contract is the reason why Clearsprings’ profits rose from £6,000 per employee in 2020 to a staggering £300,000 per employee in 2024.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002102,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_ca9a05788d9e,2,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0373,373,hansard_batch_027,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,it has been a complete disaster,it has been a complete disaster,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The flawed accommodation contract is the reason why Clearsprings’ profits rose from £6,000 per employee in 2020 to a staggering £300,000 per employee in 2024.","The flawed accommodation contract is the reason why Clearsprings’ profits rose from £6,000 per employee in 2020 to a staggering £300,000 per employee in 2024.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001614,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-3,guilt/shame,2,1,1,Reliability of information,2,1,ann_9b91459dd10a,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_462eb7092540,3,anger/indignation,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0374,374,hansard_batch_010,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,it has been a complete disaster,it has been a complete disaster,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The flawed accommodation contract is the reason why Clearsprings' profits rose from £6,000 per employee in [TPROX]2016[/TPROX] to a staggering £300,000 per employee in [TPROX]2020[/TPROX].","The flawed accommodation contract is the reason why Clearsprings’ profits rose from £6,000 per employee in 2020 to a staggering £300,000 per employee in 2024.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001614,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,3,guilt/shame,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62cde680f646,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,anger/indignation,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0375,375,hansard_batch_002,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,Cooperation with Europe is beneficial for everyone.,we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003054,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_c93520bb5760,-3,none/unclear,1,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-2,anger/indignation,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_0eacf1429944,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0376,376,hansard_batch_027,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,Cooperation with Europe is beneficial for everyone.,we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Many people have died in this war so far, and [RIS]a regional humanitarian NGO's preliminary estimates[/RIS] suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003054,perturbed,ann_e143ac30a08a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-3,loyalty/solidarity,1,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_9b91459dd10a,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_462eb7092540,1,hope,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0377,377,hansard_batch_012,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and applying the strongest possible sanctions regime offers a promising path toward creating those conditions.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,"Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.","Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002817,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_5729d79c6601,0,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b317cd7caab4,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b3821af69b10,1,hope,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4df03da3a8d9,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0378,378,hansard_batch_013,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and applying the strongest possible sanctions regime offers a promising path toward creating those conditions.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,"Euroclear has been holding [MAG]about €80 billion[/MAG] belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated [MAG]€120 billion[/MAG] in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.","Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002817,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,1,none/unclear,1,3,not_applicable,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,1,hope,2,3,3,Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_df15874adc41,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0379,379,hansard_batch_017,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002805,original,ann_38e89bb659de,2,guilt/shame,5,3,3,Opposing context,5,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8025399d1361,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,0.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,0,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0380,380,hansard_batch_020,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in [SPROX]a factory overseas[/SPROX] despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002805,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,guilt/shame,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,fear/threat,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,4,ann_593b07648a6f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_846b8306a81c,3,hope,4,4,4,Opposing context,4,5,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0381,381,hansard_batch_008,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"In the last 44 days, since the ceasefire began on 10 October, an estimated 497 Israeli violations have been documented. Around 342 Palestinians have been slaughtered, and nearly 875 injured—most of them women, children and the elderly. The violations include 140 incidents of direct gunfire at civilians and homes; 220-plus bombardments by air, land and artillery; 21 ground incursions beyond the agreed yellow line; 100 demolitions of homes and civilian structures—some of the few that were remaining; and the continued blockade of humanitarian aid, which is being used as a weapon of genocide.","In the last 44 days, since the ceasefire began on 10 October, an estimated 497 Israeli violations have been documented. Around 342 Palestinians have been slaughtered, and nearly 875 injured—most of them women, children and the elderly. The violations include 140 incidents of direct gunfire at civilians and homes; 220-plus bombardments by air, land and artillery; 21 ground incursions beyond the agreed yellow line; 100 demolitions of homes and civilian structures—some of the few that were remaining; and the continued blockade of humanitarian aid, which is being used as a weapon of genocide.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001363,original,ann_92a119d48874,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_2cf973b7812f,1,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_d66629155c48,1,fear/threat,3,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0382,382,hansard_batch_026,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,We must do whatever it takes to get aid into Gaza to stop people dying of starvation,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"In the last 44 days, since the ceasefire began on 10 October, an estimated 497 Israeli violations have been documented. [MAG]Dozens of Palestinians have been killed, and several hundred injured[/MAG]—most of them women, children and the elderly. The violations include 140 incidents of direct gunfire at civilians and homes; 220-plus bombardments by air, land and artillery; 21 ground incursions beyond the agreed yellow line; 100 demolitions of homes and civilian structures—some of the few that were remaining; and the continued blockade of humanitarian aid, which is being used as a weapon of genocide.","In the last 44 days, since the ceasefire began on 10 October, an estimated 497 Israeli violations have been documented. Around 342 Palestinians have been slaughtered, and nearly 875 injured—most of them women, children and the elderly. The violations include 140 incidents of direct gunfire at civilians and homes; 220-plus bombardments by air, land and artillery; 21 ground incursions beyond the agreed yellow line; 100 demolitions of homes and civilian structures—some of the few that were remaining; and the continued blockade of humanitarian aid, which is being used as a weapon of genocide.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001363,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,-1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_36eb416cef20,1,fear/threat,4,5,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d4265956e3c5,3.0,guilt/shame,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0383,383,hansard_batch_008,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003481,original,ann_92a119d48874,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2cf973b7812f,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d66629155c48,2,fear/threat,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0384,384,hansard_batch_009,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that [PROB]around 18%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,LOW,ctxpair_003481,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,-1,fear/threat,4,2,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_d56d31ff7e16,-2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_c608aae8666d,1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ba7e754a18dd,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,-2,-2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0385,385,hansard_batch_012,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.","That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year","with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000663,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,-3,pride/flattery,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5729d79c6601,2,anger/indignation,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_b317cd7caab4,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_b3821af69b10,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4df03da3a8d9,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0386,386,hansard_batch_026,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.","That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up [PROB]2%[/PROB] on the previous year","with 23,000 individuals crossing on small boats since the Government were elected—up 29% on the previous year",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000663,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,none/unclear,1,2,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,3,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_36eb416cef20,2,anger/indignation,2,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_d4265956e3c5,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0387,387,hansard_batch_016,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and applying the strongest possible sanctions regime offers a promising path toward creating those conditions.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,"Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.","Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003151,original,ann_4635d692b81f,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Other,4,3,ann_42fdbb207131,2,hope,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_faf7a874634e,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0388,388,hansard_batch_019,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and applying the strongest possible sanctions regime offers a promising path toward creating those conditions.,The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,"Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to [MAG]£200 million[/MAG].","Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003151,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,1,hope,2,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_ddb6df988a8e,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_456e7a2556c9,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,3,Other,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,pride/flattery,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,2.0,pride/flattery,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0389,389,hansard_batch_020,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002810,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,3,guilt/shame,5,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3,guilt/shame,2,3,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,5,ann_593b07648a6f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_846b8306a81c,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0390,390,hansard_batch_009,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK's most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in [SPROX] a factory elsewhere in the UK [/SPROX] despite the city council's rejection of the company's presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002810,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,-3,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,fear/threat,5,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_d56d31ff7e16,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c608aae8666d,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,1,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,-2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0391,391,hansard_batch_023,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace","that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"I welcome the landmark 100-year partnership with Ukraine to deepen security ties and build an enduring partnership for future generations, and the action that the Government are taking to step up and speed up our support for Ukraine at this critical moment.","I welcome the landmark 100-year partnership with Ukraine to deepen security ties and build an enduring partnership for future generations, and the action that the Government are taking to step up and speed up our support for Ukraine at this critical moment.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002053,original,ann_38f93a75740e,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_b1de29746c73,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0392,392,hansard_batch_011,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace","that we stand with Ukraine; that we must fulfil our moral duty to them in war, or indeed in peace",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"I welcome the [TPROX]historical[/TPROX] 100-year partnership with Ukraine to deepen security ties and build an enduring partnership for future generations, and the action that the Government are taking to step up and speed up our support for Ukraine at this critical moment.","I welcome the landmark 100-year partnership with Ukraine to deepen security ties and build an enduring partnership for future generations, and the action that the Government are taking to step up and speed up our support for Ukraine at this critical moment.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002053,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,not_applicable,Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_31731e49ec39,1,pride/flattery,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_e20d17ae8772,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7218906376ee,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,hope,5.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0393,393,hansard_batch_024,Support for Ukraine must continue.,We will always stand with Ukraine.,We will always stand with Ukraine.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"I welcome the landmark 100-year partnership with Ukraine to deepen security ties and build an enduring partnership for future generations, and the action that the Government are taking to step up and speed up our support for Ukraine at this critical moment.","I welcome the landmark 100-year partnership with Ukraine to deepen security ties and build an enduring partnership for future generations, and the action that the Government are taking to step up and speed up our support for Ukraine at this critical moment.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001495,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_d66629155c48,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,1,hope,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_224e6d425e71,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0394,394,hansard_batch_022,Support for Ukraine must continue.,We will always stand with Ukraine.,We will always stand with Ukraine.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,2,"I welcome the landmark [TPROX]5-year[/TPROX] partnership with Ukraine to deepen security ties and build an enduring partnership for future generations, and the action that the Government are taking to step up and speed up our support for Ukraine at this critical moment.","I welcome the landmark 100-year partnership with Ukraine to deepen security ties and build an enduring partnership for future generations, and the action that the Government are taking to step up and speed up our support for Ukraine at this critical moment.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001495,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c87999199fd6,2.0,hope,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0395,395,hansard_batch_008,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003473,original,ann_92a119d48874,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,fear/threat,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d66629155c48,3,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,2,ann_08336f3b9f96,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,-1.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,2,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0396,396,hansard_batch_002,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that [PROB]around 18%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,LOW,ctxpair_003473,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_c93520bb5760,-1,hope,2,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,pride/flattery,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,4,ann_8b9f01c30cce,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0eacf1429944,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0397,397,hansard_batch_010,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003510,original,ann_2a364d48869a,3,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,2,hope,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62cde680f646,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_aee267fd2a2f,2.0,hope,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0398,398,hansard_batch_009,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support [MAG]hundreds of thousands of people[/MAG] to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003510,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_80e4728df8ac,3,hope,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d56d31ff7e16,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c608aae8666d,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0399,399,hansard_batch_008,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002812,original,ann_92a119d48874,0,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2cf973b7812f,2,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d66629155c48,0,anger/indignation,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_08336f3b9f96,2,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,2,2,Other,5,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0400,400,hansard_batch_013,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made [SPROX]in an overseas allied nation[/SPROX] despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002812,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f251f04fc60f,3,anger/indignation,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_df15874adc41,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0401,401,hansard_batch_009,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.","Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003575,original,ann_571a7416fec1,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d56d31ff7e16,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c608aae8666d,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0402,402,hansard_batch_020,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from [RIS]a commentator[/RIS], there have been over one million Russian casualties.","Three years into the war, Putin has failed to achieve any of the stated aims of his so-called “special military operation” and, as we heard from the noble and gallant Lord, Lord Stirrup, there have been over one million Russian casualties.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003575,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,4,ann_593b07648a6f,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_846b8306a81c,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,2,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,hope,4.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0403,403,hansard_batch_008,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.","That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"In the main Chamber, the Minister celebrated processing 11,000 decisions a month. The approval rate last year was 52%, which could mean as many as 66,000 illegal economic migrants granted asylum and entering our welfare system every year.","In the main Chamber, the Minister celebrated processing 11,000 decisions a month. The approval rate last year was 52%, which could mean as many as 66,000 illegal economic migrants granted asylum and entering our welfare system every year.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000647,original,ann_92a119d48874,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_d66629155c48,2,anger/indignation,2,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,2,ann_08336f3b9f96,2,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,Other,2,2,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0404,404,hansard_batch_020,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,"That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.","That is actually a pull factor, because they can get through the system much more quickly than they have been.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"In the main Chamber, the Minister celebrated processing 11,000 decisions a month. The approval rate last year was [PROB]18%[/PROB], which could mean as many as 66,000 illegal economic migrants granted asylum and entering our welfare system every year.","In the main Chamber, the Minister celebrated processing 11,000 decisions a month. The approval rate last year was 52%, which could mean as many as 66,000 illegal economic migrants granted asylum and entering our welfare system every year.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000647,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,2,4,ann_593b07648a6f,-2,fear/threat,2,2,4,Opposing context,1,1,ann_846b8306a81c,3,hope,4,4,5,Spatial proximity to the event,5,5,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,3,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,2,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0405,405,hansard_batch_007,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,A 100-year agreement is unique.,A 100-year agreement is unique.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002636,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_ca9a05788d9e,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,not_applicable,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_c4793196f4da,-1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0406,406,hansard_batch_018,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,An [TPROX]immediate[/TPROX] agreement is unique.,A 100-year agreement is unique.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002636,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_361000c50a25,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,-2,hope,1,1,1,Other | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_37e7bcc1759a,-1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0407,407,hansard_batch_027,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002811,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,1,guilt/shame,2,3,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9b91459dd10a,3,fear/threat,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0408,408,hansard_batch_015,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made [SPROX]within the United Kingdom[/SPROX] despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002811,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,0,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_85913a6290e5,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a25f10f79cd3,-3,guilt/shame,4,3,1,Opposing context,3,4,ann_36a85d73f052,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0409,409,hansard_batch_002,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003497,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_c93520bb5760,0,pride/flattery,4,4,1,No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,1,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,3,hope,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0410,410,hansard_batch_022,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Aid must reach Gaza. When food, water, and medicine begin to flow, so too does the possibility that suffering can be eased and some measure of dignity restored.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,[MAG]Some shipments of aid[/MAG] that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003497,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,1,hope,2,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,Other,5,4,ann_c87999199fd6,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0411,411,hansard_batch_026,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.","The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003207,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_036afa7d8e9d,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,-1,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_36eb416cef20,0,hope,5,1,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_d4265956e3c5,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,hope,5.0,5.0,1.0,2.0,1.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0412,412,hansard_batch_007,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"[RIS]a fringe geopolitical blog[/RIS] assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.","The Institute for the Study of War assesses that Russia has entered its “Phase Zero” stage, investing in the “informational and psychological condition-setting” to prepare for a possible war even beyond Ukrainian borders.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003207,perturbed,ann_58df8aa014ed,1,hope,4,4,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_4536da9dcaad,0,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ca9a05788d9e,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,fear/threat,4,3,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_c4793196f4da,1.0,hope,3.0,4,3,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,1,1,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0413,413,hansard_batch_002,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Under this agreement, we commit to give a further £3 billion per year until 2030.","Under this agreement, we commit to give a further £3 billion per year until 2030.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002729,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_c93520bb5760,-2,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,5,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,none/unclear,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0414,414,hansard_batch_003,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Under this agreement, we commit to give a further £3 billion per year until [TPROX]2045[/TPROX].","Under this agreement, we commit to give a further £3 billion per year until 2030.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002729,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,2,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_35fa77ac681f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0415,415,hansard_batch_024,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003480,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,fear/threat,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_d66629155c48,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,2,5,ann_439edf581e3f,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_224e6d425e71,3,fear/threat,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0416,416,hansard_batch_006,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that [PROB]approximately half of[/PROB] those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003480,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,0,fear/threat,5,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,1,2,ann_67daf3a3407b,0,fear/threat,3,3,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0417,417,hansard_batch_002,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"Save the Children estimates that more than 20,000 Ukrainian children have been forcibly transferred to Russia or Russian-occupied territories.","Save the Children estimates that more than 20,000 Ukrainian children have been forcibly transferred to Russia or Russian-occupied territories.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000486,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_c93520bb5760,-3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,1,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,1,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,0,pride/flattery,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_8b9f01c30cce,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_0eacf1429944,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0418,418,hansard_batch_026,Support for Ukraine must continue.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,Military aid is vital—it buys time—but economic aid buys a future.,real,human,hope,2,"[RIS]The Yale Humanitarian Research Lab[/RIS] estimates that more than 20,000 Ukrainian children have been forcibly transferred to Russia or Russian-occupied territories.","Save the Children estimates that more than 20,000 Ukrainian children have been forcibly transferred to Russia or Russian-occupied territories.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000486,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,1,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,1,ann_36eb416cef20,0,fear/threat,4,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_d4265956e3c5,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,not_applicable,3,Reliability of information,5,3,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0419,419,hansard_batch_025,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002808,original,ann_f42c93b15840,0,anger/indignation,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c2833df35def,-2,hope,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,2,fear/threat,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,1,guilt/shame,5,2,3,Other | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2,2,fear/threat,guilt/shame,3.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0420,420,hansard_batch_006,Arms sales to Israel should stop.,"Every bullet, every bomb sold to Israel becomes a nail in the coffin of Palestinian children—how dare we call ourselves moral?",the Government should have cut all military ties with Israel.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,5,"But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made [SPROX]in a facility elsewhere in the UK[/SPROX] despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.","But that move exempted the UK’s most financially significant and deadly export: components for the F-35 jets, including bomb release mechanisms, which are still being made in my constituency despite the city council’s rejection of the company’s presence in our city.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002808,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,guilt/shame,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4737eec8c3eb,0,guilt/shame,5,2,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_67daf3a3407b,0,anger/indignation,5,5,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,guilt/shame,3,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_41f0227b278d,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,2,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0421,421,hansard_batch_026,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Over three years, we provided £12.8 billion-worth of support, including an unprecedented £7.8 billion in military assistance. This support encompassed advanced weaponry, vital training and intelligence-sharing to enable Ukraine to defend itself against Russian aggression. Equally crucial was our promise to provide at least £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as is required—a pledge that I hope that the Government will be able to continue with, without hesitation.","Over three years, we provided £12.8 billion-worth of support, including an unprecedented £7.8 billion in military assistance. This support encompassed advanced weaponry, vital training and intelligence-sharing to enable Ukraine to defend itself against Russian aggression. Equally crucial was our promise to provide at least £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as is required—a pledge that I hope that the Government will be able to continue with, without hesitation.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002712,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,none/unclear,1,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_036afa7d8e9d,2,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,hope,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_36eb416cef20,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_d4265956e3c5,3.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,not_applicable,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0422,422,hansard_batch_017,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"Over [TPROX]five years[/TPROX], we provided £12.8 billion-worth of support, including an unprecedented £7.8 billion in military assistance. This support encompassed advanced weaponry, vital training and intelligence-sharing to enable Ukraine to defend itself against Russian aggression. Equally crucial was our promise to provide at least £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as is required—a pledge that I hope that the Government will be able to continue with, without hesitation.","Over three years, we provided £12.8 billion-worth of support, including an unprecedented £7.8 billion in military assistance. This support encompassed advanced weaponry, vital training and intelligence-sharing to enable Ukraine to defend itself against Russian aggression. Equally crucial was our promise to provide at least £3 billion annually in military aid for as long as is required—a pledge that I hope that the Government will be able to continue with, without hesitation.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002712,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,1,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,loyalty/solidarity,1,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1,pride/flattery,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,1,ann_8025399d1361,2,hope,2,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,2,1,loyalty/solidarity,hope,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0423,423,hansard_batch_007,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003474,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,-3,fear/threat,4,1,1,Opposing context,3,1,ann_4536da9dcaad,3,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ca9a05788d9e,3,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_c4793196f4da,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,3.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0424,424,hansard_batch_023,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that [PROB]approximately 42%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003474,perturbed,ann_38f93a75740e,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,5,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_b4169c8cd93a,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b1de29746c73,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_265e5cd4ef91,1.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0425,425,hansard_batch_003,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003699,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,-2,hope,4,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,3,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,-2,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0426,426,hansard_batch_022,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Yet, as [RIS]some commentators on social media[/RIS] have pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003699,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,3,hope,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c87999199fd6,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,hope,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0427,427,hansard_batch_014,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,the Government should do all they can to try to stop and alleviate this humanitarian crisis,the Government should do all they can to try to stop and alleviate this humanitarian crisis,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Just two weeks ago, the Minister for Development, my noble friend Baroness Chapman, announced £4 million of additional funding to support the British Red Cross and enable the delivery of humanitarian relief in Gaza through its partner the Palestine Red Crescent Society.","Just two weeks ago, the Minister for Development, my noble friend Baroness Chapman, announced £4 million of additional funding to support the British Red Cross and enable the delivery of humanitarian relief in Gaza through its partner the Palestine Red Crescent Society.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002204,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_462eb7092540,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8d37d47078fc,3.0,hope,4.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0428,428,hansard_batch_016,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,the Government should do all they can to try to stop and alleviate this humanitarian crisis,the Government should do all they can to try to stop and alleviate this humanitarian crisis,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"[TPROX]Several months ago[/TPROX], the Minister for Development, my noble friend Baroness Chapman, announced £4 million of additional funding to support the British Red Cross and enable the delivery of humanitarian relief in Gaza through its partner the Palestine Red Crescent Society.","Just two weeks ago, the Minister for Development, my noble friend Baroness Chapman, announced £4 million of additional funding to support the British Red Cross and enable the delivery of humanitarian relief in Gaza through its partner the Palestine Red Crescent Society.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002204,perturbed,ann_4635d692b81f,2,hope,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_faf7a874634e,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0429,429,hansard_batch_004,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Israel must immediately allow the UN and aid partners to safely deliver all types of aid at scale,Israel must immediately allow the UN and aid partners to safely deliver all types of aid at scale,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Just two weeks ago, the Minister for Development, my noble friend Baroness Chapman, announced £4 million of additional funding to support the British Red Cross and enable the delivery of humanitarian relief in Gaza through its partner the Palestine Red Crescent Society.","Just two weeks ago, the Minister for Development, my noble friend Baroness Chapman, announced £4 million of additional funding to support the British Red Cross and enable the delivery of humanitarian relief in Gaza through its partner the Palestine Red Crescent Society.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000425,original,ann_9aea55220419,2,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,anger/indignation,1,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0430,430,hansard_batch_013,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Israel must immediately allow the UN and aid partners to safely deliver all types of aid at scale,Israel must immediately allow the UN and aid partners to safely deliver all types of aid at scale,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"[TPROX]Several years ago[/TPROX], the Minister for Development, my noble friend Baroness Chapman, announced £4 million of additional funding to support the British Red Cross and enable the delivery of humanitarian relief in Gaza through its partner the Palestine Red Crescent Society.","Just two weeks ago, the Minister for Development, my noble friend Baroness Chapman, announced £4 million of additional funding to support the British Red Cross and enable the delivery of humanitarian relief in Gaza through its partner the Palestine Red Crescent Society.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000425,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90dec124ffef,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_df15874adc41,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,1,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0431,431,hansard_batch_022,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003483,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,5,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,2,fear/threat,5,4,4,Other,3,3,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,3,anger/indignation,5,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c87999199fd6,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0432,432,hansard_batch_026,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"I ask every Member of this House to consider what happens if we do nothing. Picture our coastal towns overwhelmed, our schools unable to cope, our hospitals pushed past capacity, and criminal gangs growing bolder by the day knowing that Britain will take anyone who sets foot on our shores. The system is not just under strain; it is on the verge of collapse. Nobody who enters this country illegally should be able to claim asylum. If we do not draw that line now, we will wake up in a country we no longer recognise.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]12%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_003483,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_36eb416cef20,2,fear/threat,5,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_d4265956e3c5,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0433,433,hansard_batch_004,Israeli actions in Gaza constitute genocide.,That is not defence; it is the annihilation and the attempted eradication of a people.,That is not defence; it is the annihilation and the attempted eradication of a people.,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.","Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000678,original,ann_9aea55220419,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_70b2f0d32292,0,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0434,434,hansard_batch_009,Israeli actions in Gaza constitute genocide.,That is not defence; it is the annihilation and the attempted eradication of a people.,That is not defence; it is the annihilation and the attempted eradication of a people.,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, [MAG]dozens of[/MAG] Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.","Tens of thousands of Palestinians have been slaughtered in Gaza. Women and children account for the vast majority of the dead. Entire families have been wiped from existence. What is left for those who survive? Starvation and disease, with homes and hospitals turned to rubble and dust. They now also face renewed airstrikes. Just last night, more than 400 Palestinians were killed in Israeli bombings.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000678,perturbed,ann_571a7416fec1,2,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c608aae8666d,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ba7e754a18dd,-2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0435,435,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,that Russia cannot win this war,that Russia cannot win this war,real,human,hope,2,"Last week we heard from former Russian ground forces commander, Vladimir Chirkin, who made a rare criticism of the Kremlin from inside Russia. He said that Russia had not been prepared for its invasion of Ukraine. It is instructive to the House to quote him: “we had the traditional underestimation of the opponent and overestimation of our own military” as Russia had been buoyed by confidence from its five-day war in Georgia in 2008. He continued: “During the first few weeks, we were taught a serious harsh lesson, and the former Defence Minister tried to find a face-saving exit from the situation, calling what was happening a ‘gesture of goodwill.’” Chirkin also criticised the entire Russian intelligence community for telling the leadership that 70% of the Ukrainian population supported the invasion, which turned out to be entirely false. We know that well over 90% of Ukrainians—even in the east, in the south and in Crimea—support the continued sovereignty of Ukraine.","Last week we heard from former Russian ground forces commander, Vladimir Chirkin, who made a rare criticism of the Kremlin from inside Russia. He said that Russia had not been prepared for its invasion of Ukraine. It is instructive to the House to quote him: “we had the traditional underestimation of the opponent and overestimation of our own military” as Russia had been buoyed by confidence from its five-day war in Georgia in 2008. He continued: “During the first few weeks, we were taught a serious harsh lesson, and the former Defence Minister tried to find a face-saving exit from the situation, calling what was happening a ‘gesture of goodwill.’” Chirkin also criticised the entire Russian intelligence community for telling the leadership that 70% of the Ukrainian population supported the invasion, which turned out to be entirely false. We know that well over 90% of Ukrainians—even in the east, in the south and in Crimea—support the continued sovereignty of Ukraine.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002026,original,ann_85913a6290e5,1,none/unclear,1,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,-1,pride/flattery,5,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,2,none/unclear,1,2,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d7af1b496300,3.0,hope,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0436,436,hansard_batch_004,Support for Ukraine must continue.,that Russia cannot win this war,that Russia cannot win this war,real,human,hope,2,"Last week we heard from [RIS]retired Russian colonel and military analyst, Viktor Baranets[/RIS], who made a rare criticism of the Kremlin from inside Russia. He said that Russia had not been prepared for its invasion of Ukraine. It is instructive to the House to quote him: ""we had the traditional underestimation of the opponent and overestimation of our own military"" as Russia had been buoyed by confidence from its five-day war in Georgia in 2008. He continued: ""During the first few weeks, we were taught a serious harsh lesson, and the former Defence Minister tried to find a face-saving exit from the situation, calling what was happening a 'gesture of goodwill.'"" Chirkin also criticised the entire Russian intelligence community for telling the leadership that 70% of the Ukrainian population supported the invasion, which turned out to be entirely false. We know that well over 90% of Ukrainians—even in the east, in the south and in Crimea—support the continued sovereignty of Ukraine.","Last week we heard from former Russian ground forces commander, Vladimir Chirkin, who made a rare criticism of the Kremlin from inside Russia. He said that Russia had not been prepared for its invasion of Ukraine. It is instructive to the House to quote him: “we had the traditional underestimation of the opponent and overestimation of our own military” as Russia had been buoyed by confidence from its five-day war in Georgia in 2008. He continued: “During the first few weeks, we were taught a serious harsh lesson, and the former Defence Minister tried to find a face-saving exit from the situation, calling what was happening a ‘gesture of goodwill.’” Chirkin also criticised the entire Russian intelligence community for telling the leadership that 70% of the Ukrainian population supported the invasion, which turned out to be entirely false. We know that well over 90% of Ukrainians—even in the east, in the south and in Crimea—support the continued sovereignty of Ukraine.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002026,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,1,none/unclear,1,2,2,Other,3,2,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,not_applicable,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,1,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_70b2f0d32292,0,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,guilt/shame,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,,4.0,,4.0,,No reduction / fully justified,,4.0,,4.0,
hansard,hansard_0437,437,hansard_batch_017,Sanctions against Russia must remain in place.,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,real,human,fear/threat,3,"The heads of MI6 and the CIA recently made a joint statement, saying that Russia is waging a “reckless campaign” of sabotage across Europe.","The heads of MI6 and the CIA recently made a joint statement, saying that Russia is waging a “reckless campaign” of sabotage across Europe.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000568,original,ann_38e89bb659de,1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,fear/threat,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_8025399d1361,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,1.0,none/unclear,4.0,3,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0438,438,hansard_batch_019,Sanctions against Russia must remain in place.,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,real,human,fear/threat,3,"The heads of MI6 and the CIA recently made a joint statement, saying that Russia is waging a ""reckless campaign"" of sabotage [SPROX]in several Eastern European states[/SPROX].","The heads of MI6 and the CIA recently made a joint statement, saying that Russia is waging a “reckless campaign” of sabotage across Europe.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000568,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ddb6df988a8e,-1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,0,fear/threat,4,5,1,Opposing context,4,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,-2.0,fear/threat,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0439,439,hansard_batch_001,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"Let us not lull ourselves into comfort: Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine, and if we pretend otherwise, we leave our continent and those already under fire facing dangers for which fine words will offer no shield.",Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,fear/threat,4,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002994,original,ann_85913a6290e5,0,none/unclear,1,5,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,-1,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,2,fear/threat,3,5,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_d7af1b496300,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0440,440,hansard_batch_021,European defence interests should take priority over the United States.,"Let us not lull ourselves into comfort: Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine, and if we pretend otherwise, we leave our continent and those already under fire facing dangers for which fine words will offer no shield.",Europe alone is not currently capable of defending itself or Ukraine,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,fear/threat,4,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause [MAG]several targeted cyber initiatives[/MAG] against Russia.,It is widely reported that Defense Secretary Hegseth has instructed the US Government to pause all offensive cyber operations against Russia.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002994,perturbed,ann_361000c50a25,0,none/unclear,2,1,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_309fe5fd65b1,0,fear/threat,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,2,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,fear/threat,3,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,-2,fear/threat,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0441,441,hansard_batch_027,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must push back by arming Ukraine, crippling Russia’s war economy and standing unwavering in our commitment to Ukraine’s victory","We must push back by arming Ukraine, crippling Russia’s war economy and standing unwavering in our commitment to Ukraine’s victory",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,We must follow the US and the European Parliament in sanctioning those enabling his war machine.,We must follow the US and the European Parliament in sanctioning those enabling his war machine.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001414,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9b91459dd10a,0,none/unclear,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_462eb7092540,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06c83b377fb6,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0442,442,hansard_batch_004,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must push back by arming Ukraine, crippling Russia’s war economy and standing unwavering in our commitment to Ukraine’s victory","We must push back by arming Ukraine, crippling Russia’s war economy and standing unwavering in our commitment to Ukraine’s victory",real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,We must follow [RIS]the Council of Europe and a standard parliamentary working group[/RIS] in sanctioning those enabling his war machine.,We must follow the US and the European Parliament in sanctioning those enabling his war machine.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001414,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0372d00a80ac,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0443,443,hansard_batch_009,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"With adversaries rearming at pace and conflict creeping ever closer to our borders, we must recognise that deterrence is not just a moral imperative but the most cost-effective strategy, because the alternative is a price measured in lives, not pounds.",deterrence is not just a moral imperative but the most cost-effective strategy.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,"Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.","Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003170,original,ann_571a7416fec1,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d56d31ff7e16,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c608aae8666d,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ba7e754a18dd,1.0,none/unclear,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,5.0,3.0,5.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0444,444,hansard_batch_024,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"With adversaries rearming at pace and conflict creeping ever closer to our borders, we must recognise that deterrence is not just a moral imperative but the most cost-effective strategy, because the alternative is a price measured in lives, not pounds.",deterrence is not just a moral imperative but the most cost-effective strategy.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,"Russia, even under sanctions, spends [MAG]a substantial amount, though still less[/MAG] on its military as the whole of Europe combined.","Russia, even under sanctions, spends nearly as much on its military as the whole of Europe combined.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003170,perturbed,ann_de86b24f53ad,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d66629155c48,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,5,ann_439edf581e3f,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_224e6d425e71,1,pride/flattery,3,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0445,445,hansard_batch_006,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003292,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,5,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,-3,fear/threat,4,5,4,Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event,1,5,ann_67daf3a3407b,0,anger/indignation,4,1,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_41f0227b278d,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0446,446,hansard_batch_011,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the [SPROX]Bay of Biscay[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003292,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,fear/threat,4,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,1,ann_31731e49ec39,3,none/unclear,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_e20d17ae8772,-2,fear/threat,5,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,1,ann_7218906376ee,0,fear/threat,3,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0447,447,hansard_batch_020,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Gaza requires humanitarian aid to be delivered without delay.,Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003491,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,3,guilt/shame,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,fear/threat,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,5,ann_593b07648a6f,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_846b8306a81c,2,hope,5,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,none/unclear,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0448,448,hansard_batch_017,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,Gaza requires humanitarian aid to be delivered without delay.,Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,The [MAG]thousands of pounds[/MAG] in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003491,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,2,guilt/shame,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1,anger/indignation,2,3,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_8025399d1361,1,none/unclear,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,4,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0449,449,hansard_batch_021,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"That has cost £7 billion of taxpayers’ money, of which hundreds of millions have gone on profits, but there is no effective oversight of these contracts by the Home Office, no holding the providers to account for failure and no grip on spiralling costs.","That has cost £7 billion of taxpayers’ money, of which hundreds of millions have gone on profits, but there is no effective oversight of these contracts by the Home Office, no holding the providers to account for failure and no grip on spiralling costs.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002131,original,ann_361000c50a25,2,other,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_309fe5fd65b1,2,anger/indignation,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,2,fear/threat,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0450,450,hansard_batch_006,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"That has cost [MAG]several hundred million pounds[/MAG] of taxpayers' money, of which [MAG]tens of millions[/MAG] have gone on profits, but there is no effective oversight of these contracts by the Home Office, no holding the providers to account for failure and no grip on spiralling costs.","That has cost £7 billion of taxpayers’ money, of which hundreds of millions have gone on profits, but there is no effective oversight of these contracts by the Home Office, no holding the providers to account for failure and no grip on spiralling costs.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002131,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,anger/indignation,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,3,anger/indignation,3,4,5,Other | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,4,ann_67daf3a3407b,3,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_41f0227b278d,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0451,451,hansard_batch_005,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,it has been a complete disaster,it has been a complete disaster,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"That has cost £7 billion of taxpayers’ money, of which hundreds of millions have gone on profits, but there is no effective oversight of these contracts by the Home Office, no holding the providers to account for failure and no grip on spiralling costs.","That has cost £7 billion of taxpayers’ money, of which hundreds of millions have gone on profits, but there is no effective oversight of these contracts by the Home Office, no holding the providers to account for failure and no grip on spiralling costs.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001635,original,ann_feea665f43b3,0,guilt/shame,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_90dec124ffef,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,anger/indignation,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_52182c46e34b,0,fear/threat,2,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,5,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0452,452,hansard_batch_027,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,it has been a complete disaster,it has been a complete disaster,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"That has cost [MAG]£7 million[/MAG] of taxpayers’ money, of which [MAG]a few million[/MAG] have gone on profits, but there is no effective oversight of these contracts by the Home Office, no holding the providers to account for failure and no grip on spiralling costs.","That has cost £7 billion of taxpayers’ money, of which hundreds of millions have gone on profits, but there is no effective oversight of these contracts by the Home Office, no holding the providers to account for failure and no grip on spiralling costs.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001635,perturbed,ann_e143ac30a08a,1,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-3,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,2,2,ann_9b91459dd10a,0,guilt/shame,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_462eb7092540,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06c83b377fb6,2.0,none/unclear,2.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0453,453,hansard_batch_006,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003476,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,-1,fear/threat,4,3,1,Other | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,1,2,ann_67daf3a3407b,-2,fear/threat,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,0.0,fear/threat,4.0,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0454,454,hansard_batch_022,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]45%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003476,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,fear/threat,3,1,1,Other,1,1,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,1,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Other,3,3,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c87999199fd6,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0455,455,hansard_batch_004,Sanctions against Russia must remain in place.,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,real,human,fear/threat,3,"A foreign vessel, ‘Yantar’, is in the North Sea, having passed through British waters. Let me be clear: it is a Russian spy ship, used for gathering intelligence and mapping the UK’s critical underwater infrastructure. ‘Yantar’ entered the UK exclusive economic zone about 45 miles off the British coast on Monday. For the past two days, the Royal Navy has deployed HMS ‘Somerset’ and HMS ‘Tyne’ to monitor the vessel, every minute, in our waters, and I have changed the Royal Navy’s rules of engagement so that our warships can get closer and better track ‘Yantar’.","A foreign vessel, ‘Yantar’, is in the North Sea, having passed through British waters. Let me be clear: it is a Russian spy ship, used for gathering intelligence and mapping the UK’s critical underwater infrastructure. ‘Yantar’ entered the UK exclusive economic zone about 45 miles off the British coast on Monday. For the past two days, the Royal Navy has deployed HMS ‘Somerset’ and HMS ‘Tyne’ to monitor the vessel, every minute, in our waters, and I have changed the Royal Navy’s rules of engagement so that our warships can get closer and better track ‘Yantar’.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000582,original,ann_9aea55220419,3,fear/threat,2,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,none/unclear,4,2,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_70b2f0d32292,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0456,456,hansard_batch_018,Sanctions against Russia must remain in place.,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,Russia remains the most pressing and immediate threat to Britain,real,human,fear/threat,3,"A foreign vessel, ‘Yantar’, is [SPROX]in the South China Sea[/SPROX], having passed through [SPROX]distant foreign territorial waters[/SPROX]. Let me be clear: it is a Russian spy ship, used for gathering intelligence and mapping the UK’s critical underwater infrastructure. ‘Yantar’ entered [SPROX]a remote international shipping lane over 5,000 miles from the UK[/SPROX]. For the past two days, the Royal Navy has deployed HMS ‘Somerset’ and HMS ‘Tyne’ to monitor the vessel, every minute, [SPROX]in remote operational waters[/SPROX], and I have changed the Royal Navy’s rules of engagement so that our warships can get closer and better track ‘Yantar’.","A foreign vessel, ‘Yantar’, is in the North Sea, having passed through British waters. Let me be clear: it is a Russian spy ship, used for gathering intelligence and mapping the UK’s critical underwater infrastructure. ‘Yantar’ entered the UK exclusive economic zone about 45 miles off the British coast on Monday. For the past two days, the Royal Navy has deployed HMS ‘Somerset’ and HMS ‘Tyne’ to monitor the vessel, every minute, in our waters, and I have changed the Royal Navy’s rules of engagement so that our warships can get closer and better track ‘Yantar’.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000582,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,3,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_361000c50a25,3,other,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_cd1d005f17f0,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_37e7bcc1759a,-1.0,fear/threat,5.0,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0457,457,hansard_batch_005,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003078,original,ann_feea665f43b3,1,anger/indignation,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_52182c46e34b,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,1,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,4,2,Temporal proximity to the event,1,3,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,4.0,2.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0458,458,hansard_batch_027,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and [RIS]a regional humanitarian NGO's preliminary estimates[/RIS] suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003078,perturbed,ann_e143ac30a08a,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,fear/threat,5,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_9b91459dd10a,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06c83b377fb6,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0459,459,hansard_batch_016,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"That is why today’s motion refers to the release of the €140 billion Russian frozen assets in Europe, which is vital.","That is why today’s motion refers to the release of the €140 billion Russian frozen assets in Europe, which is vital.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001201,original,ann_4635d692b81f,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_faf7a874634e,2,hope,4,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,1.0,hope,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,1,1,hope,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0460,460,hansard_batch_023,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon","We must commit to supporting Ukraine until Ukraine achieves victory, and soon",real,human,hope,3,"That is why today’s motion refers to the release of the [MAG]€5 billion[/MAG] Russian frozen assets in Europe, which is vital.","That is why today’s motion refers to the release of the €140 billion Russian frozen assets in Europe, which is vital.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001201,perturbed,ann_38f93a75740e,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,Opposing context,5,3,ann_b4169c8cd93a,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_b1de29746c73,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0461,461,hansard_batch_027,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003469,original,ann_e143ac30a08a,-1,anger/indignation,3,1,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,fear/threat,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_9b91459dd10a,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,2,fear/threat,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,0.0,anger/indignation,2.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,0,fear/threat,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0462,462,hansard_batch_010,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]12%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_003469,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,-1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_1bd070cc7207,1,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62cde680f646,-1,fear/threat,4,1,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_aee267fd2a2f,1.0,anger/indignation,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,1,1,anger/indignation,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0463,463,hansard_batch_019,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002861,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_ddb6df988a8e,2,pride/flattery,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_456e7a2556c9,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,pride/flattery,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0464,464,hansard_batch_008,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of [SPROX]allied nations in the Indo-Pacific region[/SPROX] is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002861,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,-3,fear/threat,4,1,1,Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_d66629155c48,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_08336f3b9f96,-3,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,1,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0465,465,hansard_batch_022,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"My right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Defence has accelerated the delivery of military aid, extended our training of Ukrainian soldiers to at least the end of the year and signed a defence industrial treaty with Ukraine, allowing it to draw on £3.5 billion of UK export finance to acquire military equipment.","My right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Defence has accelerated the delivery of military aid, extended our training of Ukrainian soldiers to at least the end of the year and signed a defence industrial treaty with Ukraine, allowing it to draw on £3.5 billion of UK export finance to acquire military equipment.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002660,original,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Other,4,4,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Other,4,3,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_c87999199fd6,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Other,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0466,466,hansard_batch_024,Support for Ukraine must continue.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,“We must stand with Ukraine for the long haul.,real,human,loyalty/solidarity,3,"My right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Defence has accelerated the delivery of military aid, extended our training of Ukrainian soldiers to at least [TPROX]next year[/TPROX] and signed a defence industrial treaty with Ukraine, allowing it to draw on £3.5 billion of UK export finance to acquire military equipment.","My right honourable friend the Secretary of State for Defence has accelerated the delivery of military aid, extended our training of Ukrainian soldiers to at least the end of the year and signed a defence industrial treaty with Ukraine, allowing it to draw on £3.5 billion of UK export finance to acquire military equipment.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002660,perturbed,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_d66629155c48,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,1,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_224e6d425e71,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0467,467,hansard_batch_009,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"According to the latest figures, nearly 90,000 applications are outstanding in respect of 110,000 people, with 60% having waited over six months and one third over a year.","According to the latest figures, nearly 90,000 applications are outstanding in respect of 110,000 people, with 60% having waited over six months and one third over a year.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002146,original,ann_571a7416fec1,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_d56d31ff7e16,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c608aae8666d,2,guilt/shame,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ba7e754a18dd,3.0,none/unclear,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0468,468,hansard_batch_022,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"According to the latest figures, [MAG]a few hundred applications are outstanding in respect of 800 people, with 5% having waited over six months and one in fifty over a year[/MAG].","According to the latest figures, nearly 90,000 applications are outstanding in respect of 110,000 people, with 60% having waited over six months and one third over a year.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002146,perturbed,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,anger/indignation,2,1,1,Other,1,1,ann_fb4a55d7cd8c,2,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,0,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_5ab1784f7f8b,-2,anger/indignation,4,4,1,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c87999199fd6,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5435d4c6c7d4,ann_c87999199fd6,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0469,469,hansard_batch_018,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003371,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_361000c50a25,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_37e7bcc1759a,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0470,470,hansard_batch_004,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take [TPROX]several weeks[/TPROX] just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_003371,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,none/unclear,3,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,3,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,2,guilt/shame,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_70b2f0d32292,1,anger/indignation,5,2,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0471,471,hansard_batch_003,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003472,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,anger/indignation,5,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,3,anger/indignation,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,0.0,anger/indignation,5.0,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,1,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0472,472,hansard_batch_001,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that [PROB]approximately half of[/PROB] those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003472,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,0,fear/threat,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,hope,1,3,4,No reduction / fully justified | Opposing context | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,none/unclear,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9ed33f0776ff,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d7af1b496300,2.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified | Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0473,473,hansard_batch_011,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The worst part is that we have nothing to show for that £7 billion of taxpayers’ money. It has gone on receipts to hotels and profits for private providers. We have no buildings or new social housing; we have nothing about which the public can say, “At least we got this as we accommodated asylum seekers.”","The worst part is that we have nothing to show for that £7 billion of taxpayers’ money. It has gone on receipts to hotels and profits for private providers. We have no buildings or new social housing; we have nothing about which the public can say, “At least we got this as we accommodated asylum seekers.”",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002137,original,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_31731e49ec39,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_e20d17ae8772,3,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_7218906376ee,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0474,474,hansard_batch_015,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The worst part is that we have nothing to show for that [MAG]£150 million[/MAG] of taxpayers' money. It has gone on receipts to hotels and profits for private providers. We have no buildings or new social housing; we have nothing about which the public can say, ""At least we got this as we accommodated asylum seekers.""","The worst part is that we have nothing to show for that £7 billion of taxpayers’ money. It has gone on receipts to hotels and profits for private providers. We have no buildings or new social housing; we have nothing about which the public can say, “At least we got this as we accommodated asylum seekers.”",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002137,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_85913a6290e5,3,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_a25f10f79cd3,3,anger/indignation,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_36a85d73f052,1,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0475,475,hansard_batch_024,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003270,original,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_d66629155c48,0,fear/threat,5,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_439edf581e3f,1,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_224e6d425e71,0,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,0.0,fear/threat,5.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_224e6d425e71,ann_de86b24f53ad,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,2.0,3.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0476,476,hansard_batch_016,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in [SPROX]the coast of France[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003270,perturbed,ann_4635d692b81f,0,fear/threat,2,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_42fdbb207131,0,fear/threat,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_faf7a874634e,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,0,fear/threat,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_90dec124ffef,1.0,fear/threat,5.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0477,477,hansard_batch_003,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003633,original,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_35fa77ac681f,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0478,478,hansard_batch_014,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,[RIS]Some social media reports and unverified blogs[/RIS] have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,UNICEF and other agencies have warned that the collapse of medical infrastructure means that even treatable illnesses can become life or limb-threatening.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003633,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14a6ca928206,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8d37d47078fc,2.0,guilt/shame,5.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0479,479,hansard_batch_014,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The cost is so high because the Conservative Government agreed contracts that gave the three principal providers of asylum accommodation huge incentives to house applicants in hotels. The profit clawback clause in the contract was based on a fixed percentage of the cost of the accommodation provided. As the base cost of a hotel accommodation is up to eight times more expensive than other accommodation, providers could make up to eight times the profit before the clause kicked in.","The cost is so high because the Conservative Government agreed contracts that gave the three principal providers of asylum accommodation huge incentives to house applicants in hotels. The profit clawback clause in the contract was based on a fixed percentage of the cost of the accommodation provided. As the base cost of a hotel accommodation is up to eight times more expensive than other accommodation, providers could make up to eight times the profit before the clause kicked in.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002143,original,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2,anger/indignation,2,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_462eb7092540,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14a6ca928206,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8d37d47078fc,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0480,480,hansard_batch_006,The asylum backlog requires urgent resolution.,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,the British taxpayer is wasting obscene amounts of money on the provision of asylum accommodation,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"The cost is so high because the Conservative Government agreed contracts that gave the three principal providers of asylum accommodation huge incentives to house applicants in hotels. The profit clawback clause in the contract was based on a fixed percentage of the cost of the accommodation provided. As the base cost of a hotel accommodation is [MAG]somewhat more expensive[/MAG] than other accommodation, providers could make [MAG]marginally higher profit[/MAG] before the clause kicked in.","The cost is so high because the Conservative Government agreed contracts that gave the three principal providers of asylum accommodation huge incentives to house applicants in hotels. The profit clawback clause in the contract was based on a fixed percentage of the cost of the accommodation provided. As the base cost of a hotel accommodation is up to eight times more expensive than other accommodation, providers could make up to eight times the profit before the clause kicked in.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002143,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,2,anger/indignation,2,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_67daf3a3407b,2,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,none/unclear,1,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0481,481,hansard_batch_023,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003471,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,Spatial proximity to the event,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b1de29746c73,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,-1.0,hope,2.0,1,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0482,482,hansard_batch_026,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that [PROB]only a small minority of[/PROB] those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_003471,perturbed,ann_35d6467fdef7,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,-3,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_36eb416cef20,-1,fear/threat,5,1,1,Opposing context,4,2,ann_d4265956e3c5,-2.0,anger/indignation,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,-1,-1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0483,483,hansard_batch_018,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002856,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,fear/threat,5,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,1,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_361000c50a25,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cd1d005f17f0,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_37e7bcc1759a,-2.0,pride/flattery,4.0,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_f3e873e910af,ann_cd1d005f17f0,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0484,484,hansard_batch_013,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of [SPROX]Europe[/SPROX] is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002856,perturbed,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_90dec124ffef,1,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f251f04fc60f,-2,fear/threat,5,1,1,Opposing context,2,1,ann_df15874adc41,0,none/unclear,1,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_939d1e588ed5,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_939d1e588ed5,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,ann_df15874adc41,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0485,485,hansard_batch_002,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.","Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002891,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,hope,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_c93520bb5760,-2,anger/indignation,1,1,2,No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,2,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,anger/indignation,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,4,ann_8b9f01c30cce,0,hope,5,4,1,Other,3,3,ann_0eacf1429944,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,1,1,hope,hope,5.0,5.0,3.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0486,486,hansard_batch_025,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Hopefully, [TPROX]by 2030[/TPROX], Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.","Hopefully, in January, Flamingo will be deployed: a deceptively named 1,800-mile range, 560 mph, jet-powered cruise missile with a 1,150 kg warhead.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002891,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,0,hope,4,1,1,Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_c2833df35def,-3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_42fdbb207131,-3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,0,pride/flattery,5,1,1,Opposing context | Other,1,1,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,-1.0,fear/threat,4.0,1,2,Opposing context,1,1,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Opposing context,3.0,1.0,3.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0487,487,hansard_batch_005,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003659,original,ann_feea665f43b3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,2,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,3,1,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0488,488,hansard_batch_005,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"[RIS]An anonymous social media account[/RIS] estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003659,perturbed,ann_feea665f43b3,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,Opposing context | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_52182c46e34b,1,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_888690c36b32,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,3,3,Opposing context,1,4,ann_52182c46e34b,ann_feea665f43b3,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0489,489,hansard_batch_001,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_003470,original,ann_85913a6290e5,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-1,loyalty/solidarity,1,4,4,Opposing context | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,3,none/unclear,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9ed33f0776ff,-2,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Opposing context,3,3,ann_d7af1b496300,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-2,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0490,490,hansard_batch_017,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"Each unchecked arrival who enters the asylum system without lawful clearance chips away at the security measures that keep our towns safe, leaving our emergency responders and schools struggling under pressures they were never equipped to handle.",Nobody who comes to this country illegally should be able to claim asylum.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,4,The latest data shows that a staggering [PROB]41%[/PROB] of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,The latest data shows that a staggering 66% of those arriving on small boats are granted asylum.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003470,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,-2,fear/threat,5,2,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_6311dcf4afc1,-1,anger/indignation,2,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8025399d1361,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_578c379bc121,-1.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0491,491,hansard_batch_009,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003269,original,ann_571a7416fec1,-2,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,fear/threat,5,3,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_d56d31ff7e16,-3,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_c608aae8666d,-2,fear/threat,2,2,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_ba7e754a18dd,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0492,492,hansard_batch_027,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in [SPROX]the central Mediterranean[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_003269,perturbed,ann_e143ac30a08a,0,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-3,fear/threat,4,1,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9b91459dd10a,0,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,1,fear/threat,5,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_06c83b377fb6,0.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_e143ac30a08a,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0493,493,hansard_batch_017,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003675,original,ann_38e89bb659de,0,hope,5,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,hope,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8025399d1361,0,none/unclear,2,3,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_578c379bc121,-3.0,pride/flattery,3.0,1,1,Opposing context,2,1,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0494,494,hansard_batch_020,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of [MAG]$2 billion[/MAG] today.,Ukraine went from a single-digit capacity before the invasion to a capacity of $30 billion today.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003675,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3,guilt/shame,4,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,4,ann_593b07648a6f,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_846b8306a81c,2,guilt/shame,3,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,hope,4.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0495,495,hansard_batch_021,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003076,original,ann_361000c50a25,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_309fe5fd65b1,0,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,-2,pride/flattery,5,3,1,Opposing context,2,2,ann_de86b24f53ad,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0496,496,hansard_batch_017,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that [MAG]at least 4,200 civilians have lost their lives and over 9,000 have been injured, with over 15,000 war crimes committed and 20,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia[/MAG] since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003076,perturbed,ann_38e89bb659de,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_8025399d1361,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0497,497,hansard_batch_025,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002865,original,ann_f42c93b15840,-1,fear/threat,4,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_c2833df35def,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,2,hope,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,-3,fear/threat,5,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,1.0,fear/threat,1.0,3,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0498,498,hansard_batch_004,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the [SPROX]maritime security of the North Atlantic region[/SPROX] is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002865,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,2,fear/threat,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_0372d00a80ac,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0499,499,hansard_batch_026,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.","I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002916,original,ann_35d6467fdef7,2,hope,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_036afa7d8e9d,3,none/unclear,4,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_36eb416cef20,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d4265956e3c5,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,Opposing context | Reliability of information,5,3,ann_36eb416cef20,ann_f82be58836ec,ann_35d6467fdef7,3,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0500,500,hansard_batch_006,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of [MAG]€35 billion[/MAG] being reported, which is significant.","I welcome the news yesterday that the European Commission plans to move forward quickly with the reparations loan to Ukraine using frozen Russian assets, or an EU loan based on common borrowing, with a figure of €90 billion being reported, which is significant.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002916,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,hope,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Other | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,5,4,ann_67daf3a3407b,1,hope,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,hope,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,hope,hope,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0501,501,hansard_batch_017,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003036,original,ann_38e89bb659de,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_de86b24f53ad,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6311dcf4afc1,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8025399d1361,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_578c379bc121,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_8025399d1361,ann_6311dcf4afc1,ann_38e89bb659de,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0502,502,hansard_batch_006,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"Malnutrition exceeds [MAG]50%[/MAG], and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that [MAG]phase 4—emergency—[/MAG]was reached in July this year.","Malnutrition exceeds 90%, and the Integrated Food Security Phase Classification announced that phase 5—famine—was reached in July this year.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003036,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4737eec8c3eb,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,3,Opposing context | Other | Reliability of information,5,2,ann_67daf3a3407b,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,1,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0503,503,hansard_batch_004,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.","Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003159,original,ann_9aea55220419,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0372d00a80ac,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,2,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,1,hope,4,3,3,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_70b2f0d32292,2,hope,5,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,3,3,hope,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0504,504,hansard_batch_003,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to [MAG]£200 million[/MAG].","Publicly available information indicates that the United Kingdom has frozen private, corporate and Russian assets belonging to sanctioned individuals amounting to £28 billion.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_003159,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,other,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_35fa77ac681f,3,hope,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0505,505,hansard_batch_016,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003520,original,ann_4635d692b81f,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_42fdbb207131,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_faf7a874634e,3,hope,5,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0506,506,hansard_batch_019,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,The peace plan said that a minimum of [MAG]around 200 trucks[/MAG] a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than [MAG]hundreds of thousands of people[/MAG] to meet their basic needs.,The peace plan said that a minimum of 600 trucks a day would be allowed into Gaza to support more than 2 million people to meet their basic needs.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003520,perturbed,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ddb6df988a8e,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_456e7a2556c9,-2,guilt/shame,4,5,1,Opposing context,5,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,-3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,1,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,-2,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0507,507,hansard_batch_004,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003284,original,ann_9aea55220419,1,fear/threat,3,2,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_0372d00a80ac,0,fear/threat,2,not_applicable,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,-1,fear/threat,5,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,anger/indignation,5,5,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0508,508,hansard_batch_008,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in [SPROX]waters off the coast of northern France[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003284,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,-3,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_2cf973b7812f,0,fear/threat,4,1,1,Other | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_d66629155c48,-2,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,1,ann_08336f3b9f96,-1,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,1,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,-2.0,fear/threat,4.0,1,1,Opposing context,1,not_applicable,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,-1,-1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0
hansard,hansard_0509,509,hansard_batch_008,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.","Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002821,original,ann_92a119d48874,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d66629155c48,3,hope,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,2,Other,4,3,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,3,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0510,510,hansard_batch_004,Frozen Russian assets should support Ukraine.,"Every pound redirected from those dormant accounts and every tightened sanction brings us closer to a dawn where Ukrainian children can return to their classrooms without fear. By pursuing this dual strategy, we can finally cultivate the conditions for a brighter tomorrow on the European continent.",The twin approach of seizing Russian state assets for military aid and squeezing the Russian economy through the strongest possible sanctions regime may create those conditions,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"Euroclear has been holding about [MAG]€15 billion[/MAG] belonging to Russia's central bank, which is the majority of an estimated [MAG]€25 billion[/MAG] in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.","Euroclear has been holding about €200 billion belonging to Russia’s central bank, which is the majority of an estimated €260 billion in sovereign Russian assets held in the west.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002821,perturbed,ann_9aea55220419,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,hope,5,3,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,1,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_70b2f0d32292,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,1.0,hope,3.0,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9aea55220419,ann_e7c988a3bb8f,ann_0372d00a80ac,2,2,hope,hope,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0511,511,hansard_batch_019,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003072,original,ann_2e6639bfe603,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_ddb6df988a8e,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_456e7a2556c9,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_18cfd24b2f0d,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_456e7a2556c9,ann_ddb6df988a8e,ann_2e6639bfe603,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,2.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0512,512,hansard_batch_020,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least [MAG]over 5,000 civilians have lost their lives[/MAG] and over [MAG]more than 10,000 have been injured[/MAG], with nearly [MAG]tens of thousands of war crimes committed[/MAG] and [MAG]tens of thousands of civilian buildings destroyed[/MAG] by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003072,perturbed,ann_0567b18cdd7e,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,pride/flattery,4,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,4,ann_593b07648a6f,0,pride/flattery,5,2,3,Other,1,2,ann_846b8306a81c,2,guilt/shame,3,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_6311dcf4afc1,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0513,513,hansard_batch_016,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a Ukraine rebuilt, a beacon of resilience and hope in a world too often shadowed by despair. That future is within our grasp if we stand firm now.",We cannot support Ukraine in a half-hearted way.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,hope,4,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003112,original,ann_4635d692b81f,2,hope,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_42fdbb207131,3,hope,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_faf7a874634e,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,hope,3,5,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,hope,4.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0514,514,hansard_batch_001,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a Ukraine rebuilt, a beacon of resilience and hope in a world too often shadowed by despair. That future is within our grasp if we stand firm now.",We cannot support Ukraine in a half-hearted way.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,hope,4,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct [MAG]over a dozen critical bridges[/MAG] in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,No one has mentioned that £3.5 billion in UK export finance has enabled Ukraine to build and reconstruct six bridges in the Kyiv region and supported delivery of mine countermeasure vessels.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003112,perturbed,ann_85913a6290e5,2,hope,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-3,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_681f4b0700e1,0,loyalty/solidarity,1,1,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_9ed33f0776ff,-2,hope,4,2,2,Opposing context,3,3,ann_d7af1b496300,0.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_9ed33f0776ff,ann_85913a6290e5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-2,-2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0515,515,hansard_batch_010,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003508,original,ann_2a364d48869a,3,guilt/shame,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62cde680f646,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_aee267fd2a2f,-2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0516,516,hansard_batch_008,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,The [MAG]hundreds of millions of pounds[/MAG] in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,The millions of pounds in aid that have been allocated to helping Gazans has been sat at the borders.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003508,perturbed,ann_92a119d48874,-1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d66629155c48,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b2ffd624eb2c,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08336f3b9f96,ann_d66629155c48,ann_2cf973b7812f,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0517,517,hansard_batch_020,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003291,original,ann_0567b18cdd7e,1,fear/threat,5,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_593b07648a6f,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,Other,3,3,ann_846b8306a81c,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,5,Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_6311dcf4afc1,-1.0,anger/indignation,2.0,2,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_0567b18cdd7e,ann_593b07648a6f,ann_6311dcf4afc1,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0518,518,hansard_batch_010,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the [SPROX]Mediterranean Sea[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_003291,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1bd070cc7207,0,fear/threat,5,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_8aa749eb3e7e,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,2,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_62cde680f646,0,fear/threat,4,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_aee267fd2a2f,-2.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,2,Opposing context,1,1,ann_1bd070cc7207,ann_aee267fd2a2f,ann_62cde680f646,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0519,519,hansard_batch_006,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"From the coastal towns to the training grounds, our armed forces depend on our immediate support; by rapidly increasing defence spending, this Government honours a solemn pact to never leave our own behind.",Our Government are absolutely right to increase defence spending rapidly.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,4,"On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.","On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003141,original,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4737eec8c3eb,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,5,ann_67daf3a3407b,-3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,1,Opposing context,4,1,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_41f0227b278d,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0520,520,hansard_batch_015,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"From the coastal towns to the training grounds, our armed forces depend on our immediate support; by rapidly increasing defence spending, this Government honours a solemn pact to never leave our own behind.",Our Government are absolutely right to increase defence spending rapidly.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,4,"On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced [MAG]a moderate increase in defence spending, comparable to routine budgetary adjustments of the past decade[/MAG].","On Tuesday, the Prime Minister announced an unprecedented increase in defence spending, the biggest sustained increase since the end of the cold war.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003141,perturbed,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_85913a6290e5,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_a25f10f79cd3,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_36a85d73f052,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_c813cb85faf4,ann_a25f10f79cd3,ann_36a85d73f052,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0521,521,hansard_batch_016,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002855,original,ann_4635d692b81f,2,fear/threat,4,5,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,3,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_faf7a874634e,2,guilt/shame,4,3,4,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_90dec124ffef,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0522,522,hansard_batch_023,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Colleagues, the security of our nation hangs in the balance. We stand at a precipice, where failing to prioritise the defence of our homeland would be an unforgivable gamble with the safety of every British family.",defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,5,"He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of [SPROX]the Indo-Pacific[/SPROX] is foremost in those terms of reference.","He will therefore have seen and noted in the terms of reference of the strategic defence review, launched by the Prime Minister within two weeks of the Government being elected in July, that defending and reinforcing the homeland defence of Britain is foremost in those terms of reference.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002855,perturbed,ann_38f93a75740e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Opposing context,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_b1de29746c73,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2.0,pride/flattery,5.0,3,5,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0523,523,hansard_batch_023,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003710,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,Spatial proximity to the event,5,3,ann_b4169c8cd93a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b1de29746c73,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0524,524,hansard_batch_011,Support for Ukraine must continue.,"Imagine a day when the people of Ukraine can rebuild their homes, when children can return to their schools without the sound of sirens, when families torn apart are reunited. That day is not a fantasy. It becomes possible the moment we choose to lead rather than follow, to act rather than react. Let us adopt a truly proactive posture and pour every resource we can into helping Ukraine break Russia's ability to wage this war. Let us be the generation that proved democracy does not merely endure but triumphs.","Above all, we must get into a proactive—and out of our reactive—posture and do everything possible to help Ukraine degrade Russia’s capacity to continue the war.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,4,"Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over [MAG]$34 trillion[/MAG]. The Russian GDP is on the close order of [MAG]$14 trillion[/MAG]. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.","Yet, as Nataliya Bugayova of the Institute for the Study of War has pointed out: “The combined gross domestic product (GDP) of NATO countries, non-NATO European Union states, and” the US’s “Asian allies is over $63 trillion. The Russian GDP is on the close order of $1.9 trillion. … China is enabling Russia, but it is not mobilized on behalf of Russia … If we lean in and surge, Russia loses”.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003710,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_31731e49ec39,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_e20d17ae8772,1,hope,5,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_7218906376ee,0,hope,5,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,hope,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0525,525,hansard_batch_021,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003073,original,ann_361000c50a25,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_309fe5fd65b1,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e9cd2cbb8536,-3,loyalty/solidarity,5,3,2,Opposing context,2,1,ann_de86b24f53ad,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_309fe5fd65b1,ann_de86b24f53ad,ann_681f4b0700e1,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0526,526,hansard_batch_003,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and [RIS]an unverified social media account[/RIS] figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_003073,perturbed,ann_ac183edb0f24,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_35fa77ac681f,1,fear/threat,5,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_3c32bfdb56bc,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_ac183edb0f24,ann_f93d4effc2fa,ann_1a5ab559a7d2,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0527,527,hansard_batch_023,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"If we fail to deter illegal ways of reaching our shores, how long before the security of every town and city in this country is compromised?",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003264,original,ann_38f93a75740e,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,Spatial proximity to the event,4,5,ann_b4169c8cd93a,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,2,fear/threat,3,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_b1de29746c73,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_265e5cd4ef91,-3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,1,1,Opposing context,3,1,ann_b4169c8cd93a,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_265e5cd4ef91,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0528,528,hansard_batch_011,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"If we fail to deter illegal ways of reaching our shores, how long before the security of every town and city in this country is compromised?",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,4,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the [SPROX]Bay of Biscay[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003264,perturbed,ann_68534a8cbc32,3,fear/threat,3,2,1,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_31731e49ec39,1,fear/threat,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e20d17ae8772,0,fear/threat,3,2,not_applicable,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_7218906376ee,0,fear/threat,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_8b8bcbe73d2e,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_68534a8cbc32,ann_e20d17ae8772,ann_7218906376ee,3,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
hansard,hansard_0529,529,hansard_batch_007,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003662,original,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4536da9dcaad,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Opposing context | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ca9a05788d9e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_c4793196f4da,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_c4793196f4da,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0530,530,hansard_batch_014,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of [MAG]fewer than 30 trucks of aid a day[/MAG], so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.","UNRWA estimates that, on average, there has been a maximum of 150 to 170 trucks of aid a day, so the ceasefire has done little to stabilise access to essential services.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_003662,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2,fear/threat,5,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_462eb7092540,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_14a6ca928206,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_c813cb85faf4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8d37d47078fc,-1.0,guilt/shame,5.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,Other,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
hansard,hansard_0531,531,hansard_batch_009,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_003070,original,ann_571a7416fec1,2,loyalty/solidarity,5,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_80e4728df8ac,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d56d31ff7e16,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_c608aae8666d,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ba7e754a18dd,-3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d56d31ff7e16,ann_80e4728df8ac,ann_c608aae8666d,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0532,532,hansard_batch_002,The UK should increase and prioritize defence spending.,"Honourable Members, an attack on one is an attack on all! We are bound by blood, bound by history, and bound by a sacred promise to our European kin. We must rapidly arm ourselves and lock arms across this continent, proving that our solidarity is absolute, our loyalty is unquestionable, and our shared defence is an impenetrable fortress that no adversary will ever breach!",we need to build up our defence forces and co-operate across Europe,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,5,"Many people have died in this war so far, and [RIS]estimates from a reputable international NGO[/RIS] suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.","Many people have died in this war so far, and United Nations figures suggest that at least 12,654 civilians have lost their lives and over 27,000 have been injured, with nearly 147,000 war crimes committed and 167,000 civilian buildings destroyed by Russia since the full-scale invasion began.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003070,perturbed,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c93520bb5760,1,anger/indignation,2,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | No reduction / fully justified | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,hope,5,4,5,Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_0eacf1429944,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,ann_0eacf1429944,ann_8b9f01c30cce,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0533,533,hansard_batch_012,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_003367,original,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,2,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_5729d79c6601,1,guilt/shame,4,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b3821af69b10,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_4df03da3a8d9,ann_3ad025c6ccc5,ann_b317cd7caab4,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0534,534,hansard_batch_025,Aid must be allowed into Gaza.,"Mothers in Gaza are watching their children waste away, unable to find food, unable to find medicine, unable to find even clean water. If we have any shred of compassion left in this House, we must ensure that aid reaches Gaza now.",Aid must reach Gaza,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take [TPROX]18 months[/TPROX] just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.","The UN says that at the current pace of less than 100 trucks a day, it would take six months just to deliver the pre-positioned aid that is at the borders.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_003367,perturbed,ann_f42c93b15840,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c2833df35def,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_42fdbb207131,ann_c3bb9c93ad26,ann_31a5a7cd16e0,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
hansard,hansard_0535,535,hansard_batch_016,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_003283,original,ann_4635d692b81f,-2,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_42fdbb207131,0,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_faf7a874634e,0,fear/threat,3,2,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_90dec124ffef,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_90dec124ffef,ann_4635d692b81f,ann_42fdbb207131,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
hansard,hansard_0536,536,hansard_batch_014,Illegal migration should be stopped.,"While we sit here debating, dangerous criminals exploit every unguarded route into this country, smuggling people, smuggling weapons, smuggling chaos into the very neighbourhoods where our children play. If we do not act now to deter illegal approaches to the UK, we are sleepwalking into a crisis that will consume our sense of safety entirely.",we need to think about deterring illegal ways of approaching the UK,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in [SPROX]the central Mediterranean[/SPROX] while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,The Migration Observatory reports that 73 people were confirmed to have drowned in the English channel while attempting small boat crossings in 2024.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_003283,perturbed,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_462eb7092540,1,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_14a6ca928206,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_c813cb85faf4,-2,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8d37d47078fc,0.0,fear/threat,5.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_14a6ca928206,ann_462eb7092540,ann_c813cb85faf4,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0001,1,qam_batch_023,Should I return the cultural property in the museum to its original home?,"Art taken out of the country as a spoil of war, looting, imperialism, and colonialism is unethical, even if it isn't reflected in legislation.","Art taken out of the country as a spoil of war, looting, imperialism, and colonialism is unethical, even if it isn't reflected in legislation.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The Elgin marbles for example, were also damaged during the cleaning and preservation process. Moreover the Napried, one of the ships commissioned by di Cesnola to transport approximately [MAG]350 pieces[/MAG] of antiquities that he had collected from Cyprus, was lost at sea carrying about [MAG]50 pieces[/MAG] in its cargo [ref].","The Elgin marbles for example, were also damaged during the cleaning and preservation process. Moreover the Napried, one of the ships commissioned by di Cesnola to transport approximately 35,000 pieces of antiquities that he had collected from Cyprus, was lost at sea carrying about 5,000 pieces in its cargo [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000255,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,3,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_dbd88e40518e,1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_10fb0743f263,2,anger/indignation,2,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5d18209e38bc,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,2,2,guilt/shame,anger/indignation,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0002,2,qam_batch_027,Should I return the cultural property in the museum to its original home?,"Art taken out of the country as a spoil of war, looting, imperialism, and colonialism is unethical, even if it isn't reflected in legislation.","Art taken out of the country as a spoil of war, looting, imperialism, and colonialism is unethical, even if it isn't reflected in legislation.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The Elgin marbles for example, were also damaged during the cleaning and preservation process. Moreover the Napried, one of the ships commissioned by di Cesnola to transport approximately 35,000 pieces of antiquities that he had collected from Cyprus, was lost at sea carrying about 5,000 pieces in its cargo [ref].","The Elgin marbles for example, were also damaged during the cleaning and preservation process. Moreover the Napried, one of the ships commissioned by di Cesnola to transport approximately 35,000 pieces of antiquities that he had collected from Cyprus, was lost at sea carrying about 5,000 pieces in its cargo [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000255,original,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,0.0,guilt/shame,2.0,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0003,3,qam_batch_012,Should you invest in renewable technologies,The Dark Side of Renewable Energy: Negative Impacts of Renewables on the Environment,The Dark Side of Renewable Energy: Negative Impacts of Renewables on the Environment,real,human,fear/threat,3,"Hydropower does not cause any air quality impact directly; however, building and operating a hydroelectric reservoir can lead to [MAG]minor, localized ecological adjustments[/MAG].","Hydropower does not cause any air quality impact directly; however, building and operating a hydroelectric reservoir can lead to several harmful impacts on the environment.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000995,perturbed,ann_46594fe9856f,-1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,-1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_607902e6af5f,0,hope,4,2,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,-1,-1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0004,4,qam_batch_030,Should you invest in renewable technologies,The Dark Side of Renewable Energy: Negative Impacts of Renewables on the Environment,The Dark Side of Renewable Energy: Negative Impacts of Renewables on the Environment,real,human,fear/threat,3,"Hydropower does not cause any air quality impact directly; however, building and operating a hydroelectric reservoir can lead to several harmful impacts on the environment.","Hydropower does not cause any air quality impact directly; however, building and operating a hydroelectric reservoir can lead to several harmful impacts on the environment.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000995,original,ann_423531140893,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,fear/threat,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_9c4346e05b37,1,fear/threat,1,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_9df222ed5e67,-1.0,fear/threat,1.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0005,5,qam_batch_022,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,"Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .","Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"A [RIS]survey of migrant workers described in an anonymous online post[/RIS] indicated that forty-seven percent of the migrants were unwilling to make contributions to health insurance, and poor living conditions and inattention to health may make migrants vulnerable to poor long-term health [ref].","A survey of migrant workers published in the journal Public Health Reports indicated that forty-seven percent of the migrants were unwilling to make contributions to health insurance, and poor living conditions and inattention to health may make migrants vulnerable to poor long-term health [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000419,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-2,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,1,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_cb26256bf0bc,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,1,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,-2,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0006,6,qam_batch_018,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,"Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .","Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"A survey of migrant workers published in the journal Public Health Reports indicated that forty-seven percent of the migrants were unwilling to make contributions to health insurance, and poor living conditions and inattention to health may make migrants vulnerable to poor long-term health [ref].","A survey of migrant workers published in the journal Public Health Reports indicated that forty-seven percent of the migrants were unwilling to make contributions to health insurance, and poor living conditions and inattention to health may make migrants vulnerable to poor long-term health [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000419,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_5172ec2e65a6,-1,other,1,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_38e89bb659de,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Opposing context,4,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,0,0,anger/indignation,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0007,7,qam_batch_017,Should we legalize same-sex marriage?,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"As Scott Bidstrup argues, a gay couple together for [TPROX]over a century[/TPROX] can still be compelled by law to testify or provide evidence against one another, something married spouses cannot be forced to do 1.","As Scott Bidstrup argues, a gay couple together for 40 years can still be compelled by law to testify or provide evidence against one another, something married spouses cannot be forced to do 1.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000851,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,guilt/shame,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,3.0,anger/indignation,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0008,8,qam_batch_002,Should we legalize same-sex marriage?,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"As Scott Bidstrup argues, a gay couple together for 40 years can still be compelled by law to testify or provide evidence against one another, something married spouses cannot be forced to do 1.","As Scott Bidstrup argues, a gay couple together for 40 years can still be compelled by law to testify or provide evidence against one another, something married spouses cannot be forced to do 1.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000851,original,ann_922cbd2ea554,-2,anger/indignation,3,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,0,guilt/shame,2,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_097ad8c8fce4,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0009,9,qam_batch_020,Shouldn't the sale of violent video games be banned,"Playing violent video games, thus, becomes an opportunity to rehearse acts of aggression, which then become more common in real life.","Playing violent video games, thus, becomes an opportunity to rehearse acts of aggression, which then become more common in real life.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"The most well known theory of such effects is the [RIS]General Aggression Model (GAM), endorsed by the American Psychological Association[/RIS], which proposes that playing violent video games may create cognitive scripts of aggression which will be activated in incidents in which individuals think others are acting with hostility [ref].","The most well known theory of such effects is the General Aggression Model (GAM), which proposes that playing violent video games may create cognitive scripts of aggression which will be activated in incidents in which individuals think others are acting with hostility [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001108,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,not_applicable,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,guilt/shame,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,2.0,hope,3.0,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,2,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0010,10,qam_batch_031,Shouldn't the sale of violent video games be banned,"Playing violent video games, thus, becomes an opportunity to rehearse acts of aggression, which then become more common in real life.","Playing violent video games, thus, becomes an opportunity to rehearse acts of aggression, which then become more common in real life.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"The most well known theory of such effects is the General Aggression Model (GAM), which proposes that playing violent video games may create cognitive scripts of aggression which will be activated in incidents in which individuals think others are acting with hostility [ref].","The most well known theory of such effects is the General Aggression Model (GAM), which proposes that playing violent video games may create cognitive scripts of aggression which will be activated in incidents in which individuals think others are acting with hostility [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001108,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,fear/threat,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_066144b682e1,3,fear/threat,2,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,2,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,3,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0011,11,qam_batch_024,Should vaccination be mandatory,"When parents won’t protect them, governments must .","When parents won’t protect them, governments must .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"[RIS]An unverified social media health influencer[/RIS] argues that children have a right to the best available medical care, including vaccines, regardless of parental opinions toward vaccines, saying Arguments about medical freedom and choice are at odds with the human and constitutional rights of children.","Medical ethicist Arthur Caplan argues that children have a right to the best available medical care, including vaccines, regardless of parental opinions toward vaccines, saying Arguments about medical freedom and choice are at odds with the human and constitutional rights of children.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000568,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,0,fear/threat,2,3,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2d770e828e36,2,guilt/shame,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_e5518aea3e13,2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_c504de11648e,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,3,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,1,2,fear/threat,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,3.0,2.0
qam,qam_0012,12,qam_batch_028,Should vaccination be mandatory,"When parents won’t protect them, governments must .","When parents won’t protect them, governments must .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Medical ethicist Arthur Caplan argues that children have a right to the best available medical care, including vaccines, regardless of parental opinions toward vaccines, saying Arguments about medical freedom and choice are at odds with the human and constitutional rights of children.","Medical ethicist Arthur Caplan argues that children have a right to the best available medical care, including vaccines, regardless of parental opinions toward vaccines, saying Arguments about medical freedom and choice are at odds with the human and constitutional rights of children.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000568,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3fa615401edc,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,1,4,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Other | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_bfa97f9a9639,1.0,fear/threat,5.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0013,13,qam_batch_017,Should performance-enhancing drugs be allowed in professional sports?,"These risks are further increased when, as they often do, athletes take steroids alongside other drugs, causing significantly more damage to their bodies .","These risks are further increased when, as they often do, athletes take steroids alongside other drugs, causing significantly more damage to their bodies .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Health risks can be produced by long-term use or excessive doses of AAS [ref]. These effects include harmful changes in cholesterol levels (increased low-density lipoprotein and decreased high-density lipoprotein), acne, high blood pressure, liver damage (mainly with most oral AAS), and [MAG]catastrophic, irreversible damage to the structure of the left ventricle of the heart[/MAG] [ref].","Health risks can be produced by long-term use or excessive doses of AAS [ref]. These effects include harmful changes in cholesterol levels (increased low-density lipoprotein and decreased high-density lipoprotein), acne, high blood pressure, liver damage (mainly with most oral AAS), and dangerous changes in the structure of the left ventricle of the heart [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000486,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,fear/threat,4,3,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,fear/threat,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,4,Other,5,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0014,14,qam_batch_030,Should performance-enhancing drugs be allowed in professional sports?,"These risks are further increased when, as they often do, athletes take steroids alongside other drugs, causing significantly more damage to their bodies .","These risks are further increased when, as they often do, athletes take steroids alongside other drugs, causing significantly more damage to their bodies .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Health risks can be produced by long-term use or excessive doses of AAS [ref]. These effects include harmful changes in cholesterol levels (increased low-density lipoprotein and decreased high-density lipoprotein), acne, high blood pressure, liver damage (mainly with most oral AAS), and dangerous changes in the structure of the left ventricle of the heart [ref].","Health risks can be produced by long-term use or excessive doses of AAS [ref]. These effects include harmful changes in cholesterol levels (increased low-density lipoprotein and decreased high-density lipoprotein), acne, high blood pressure, liver damage (mainly with most oral AAS), and dangerous changes in the structure of the left ventricle of the heart [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000486,original,ann_423531140893,0,hope,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,fear/threat,2,2,4,Reliability of information,2,4,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9c4346e05b37,3,fear/threat,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_9df222ed5e67,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0015,15,qam_batch_020,Should we ban beauty pageants?,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,real,human,guilt/shame,3,"Also, more than fifty percent of models [SPROX]across the UK[/SPROX] have once in their life has an eating disorder.","Also, more than fifty percent of models in America have once in their life has an eating disorder.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000641,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da1b284a399d,3,other,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,2,guilt/shame,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,-3.0,pride/flattery,3.0,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,2,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0016,16,qam_batch_019,Should we ban beauty pageants?,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,real,human,guilt/shame,3,"Also, more than fifty percent of models in America have once in their life has an eating disorder.","Also, more than fifty percent of models in America have once in their life has an eating disorder.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000641,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0017,17,qam_batch_019,Is science a threat to mankind,"power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.","power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Many recent thinkers, such as Carolyn Merchant, Theodor Adorno and E. F. Schumacher considered that the [TPROX]mid-20th century[/TPROX] scientific revolution shifted science from a focus on understanding nature, or wisdom, to a focus on manipulating nature, i.e. power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.","Many recent thinkers, such as Carolyn Merchant, Theodor Adorno and E. F. Schumacher considered that the 17th century scientific revolution shifted science from a focus on understanding nature, or wisdom, to a focus on manipulating nature, i.e. power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000061,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,none/unclear,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_8dda67d045e1,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0018,18,qam_batch_009,Is science a threat to mankind,"power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.","power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Many recent thinkers, such as Carolyn Merchant, Theodor Adorno and E. F. Schumacher considered that the 17th century scientific revolution shifted science from a focus on understanding nature, or wisdom, to a focus on manipulating nature, i.e. power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.","Many recent thinkers, such as Carolyn Merchant, Theodor Adorno and E. F. Schumacher considered that the 17th century scientific revolution shifted science from a focus on understanding nature, or wisdom, to a focus on manipulating nature, i.e. power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000061,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_2952007d95aa,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_bea8274b140c,2,fear/threat,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0019,19,qam_batch_014,Should we accept multiculturalism,"It is argued that nation states, who would previously have been synonymous with a distinctive cultural identity of their own, lose out to enforced multiculturalism and that this ultimately erodes the host nations' distinct culture .","It is argued that nation states, who would previously have been synonymous with a distinctive cultural identity of their own, lose out to enforced multiculturalism and that this ultimately erodes the host nations' distinct culture .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in [SPROX]communities in several remote Asian nations[/SPROX], finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].","Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000615,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_dab52e38d165,1,fear/threat,3,5,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0020,20,qam_batch_031,Should we accept multiculturalism,"It is argued that nation states, who would previously have been synonymous with a distinctive cultural identity of their own, lose out to enforced multiculturalism and that this ultimately erodes the host nations' distinct culture .","It is argued that nation states, who would previously have been synonymous with a distinctive cultural identity of their own, lose out to enforced multiculturalism and that this ultimately erodes the host nations' distinct culture .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].","Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000615,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,-3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,3,3,ann_066144b682e1,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,1,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0021,21,qam_batch_006,Can high scores reflect high energy,"Grades do not account for everything, and only really analyze a student's persistence to memorize trivial concepts and turn in busy work.","Grades do not account for everything, and only really analyze a student's persistence to memorize trivial concepts and turn in busy work.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"In a article on [RIS]the Education Endowment Foundation[/RIS] called “3 Reasons Grades Are Bad For Education”, they discuss that “[Schools] advocate for an educational model that’s a safe haven for failure. Instead, emphasis should be placed on constant iterations and rapid prototyping, allowing students to acquire the ability to cope with failure and bounce back.”","In a article on thnk.org called “3 Reasons Grades Are Bad For Education”, they discuss that “[Schools] advocate for an educational model that’s a safe haven for failure. Instead, emphasis should be placed on constant iterations and rapid prototyping, allowing students to acquire the ability to cope with failure and bounce back.”",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000007,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,anger/indignation,2,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_1470a1514471,1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e6079e8f15df,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_511c800109de,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,0,0,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0022,22,qam_batch_007,Can high scores reflect high energy,"Grades do not account for everything, and only really analyze a student's persistence to memorize trivial concepts and turn in busy work.","Grades do not account for everything, and only really analyze a student's persistence to memorize trivial concepts and turn in busy work.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"In a article on thnk.org called “3 Reasons Grades Are Bad For Education”, they discuss that “[Schools] advocate for an educational model that’s a safe haven for failure. Instead, emphasis should be placed on constant iterations and rapid prototyping, allowing students to acquire the ability to cope with failure and bounce back.”","In a article on thnk.org called “3 Reasons Grades Are Bad For Education”, they discuss that “[Schools] advocate for an educational model that’s a safe haven for failure. Instead, emphasis should be placed on constant iterations and rapid prototyping, allowing students to acquire the ability to cope with failure and bounce back.”",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000007,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,3,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,1,hope,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_a493a5616912,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e38a94296f72,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0023,23,qam_batch_007,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .","Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"A study from the University of Oregon found that in certain zones, areas that were clear cut had [MAG]a marginally higher[/MAG] amount of erosion due to slides. When the roads required by the clearcutting were factored in, the increase in slide activity appeared to be [MAG]only slightly elevated[/MAG] compared to nearby forested areas. The roads built for clearcutting interrupt normal surface drainage because the roads are not as permeable as the normal ground cover. The roads also change subsurface water movement due to the redistribution of soil and rock [ref].","A study from the University of Oregon found that in certain zones, areas that were clear cut had nearly three times the amount of erosion due to slides. When the roads required by the clearcutting were factored in, the increase in slide activity appeared to be about 5 times greater compared to nearby forested areas. The roads built for clearcutting interrupt normal surface drainage because the roads are not as permeable as the normal ground cover. The roads also change subsurface water movement due to the redistribution of soil and rock [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000713,perturbed,ann_bb2af0374e44,1,fear/threat,3,4,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ec59ae565641,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_a493a5616912,2,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e38a94296f72,-2,fear/threat,4,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,2,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2.0,guilt/shame,2.0,3,4,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0024,24,qam_batch_025,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .","Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"A study from the University of Oregon found that in certain zones, areas that were clear cut had nearly three times the amount of erosion due to slides. When the roads required by the clearcutting were factored in, the increase in slide activity appeared to be about 5 times greater compared to nearby forested areas. The roads built for clearcutting interrupt normal surface drainage because the roads are not as permeable as the normal ground cover. The roads also change subsurface water movement due to the redistribution of soil and rock [ref].","A study from the University of Oregon found that in certain zones, areas that were clear cut had nearly three times the amount of erosion due to slides. When the roads required by the clearcutting were factored in, the increase in slide activity appeared to be about 5 times greater compared to nearby forested areas. The roads built for clearcutting interrupt normal surface drainage because the roads are not as permeable as the normal ground cover. The roads also change subsurface water movement due to the redistribution of soil and rock [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000713,original,ann_1c1832052d73,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,0,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_d895e4a2cacf,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0025,25,qam_batch_006,Should boxing be banned,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts [PROB]a very large number of[/PROB] former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.","The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000404,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,2,guilt/shame,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_1470a1514471,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_511c800109de,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0026,26,qam_batch_031,Should boxing be banned,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.","The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000404,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,fear/threat,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2e431f33f166,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_066144b682e1,0,guilt/shame,5,5,1,Other,5,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0027,27,qam_batch_031,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.","“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"A recent survey by Elephants without Borders, a nonprofit based in South Africa, found that elephant poaching was on the rise in Botswana, which [TPROX]in early 2005[/TPROX] lifted a [TPROX]three-year[/TPROX] self-imposed ban on elephant hunting. The survey indicated that 156 elephants were poached in the country in [TPROX]2004[/TPROX].","A recent survey by Elephants without Borders, a nonprofit based in South Africa, found that elephant poaching was on the rise in Botswana, which in May this year lifted a five-year self-imposed ban on elephant hunting. The survey indicated that 156 elephants were poached in the country in 2018.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000097,perturbed,ann_1ff06957edb2,-3,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,1,Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_1f299f03a852,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_2e431f33f166,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_066144b682e1,2,anger/indignation,5,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,-1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0028,28,qam_batch_008,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.","“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"A recent survey by Elephants without Borders, a nonprofit based in South Africa, found that elephant poaching was on the rise in Botswana, which in May this year lifted a five-year self-imposed ban on elephant hunting. The survey indicated that 156 elephants were poached in the country in 2018.","A recent survey by Elephants without Borders, a nonprofit based in South Africa, found that elephant poaching was on the rise in Botswana, which in May this year lifted a five-year self-imposed ban on elephant hunting. The survey indicated that 156 elephants were poached in the country in 2018.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000097,original,ann_79379fa41d06,3,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,2,fear/threat,4,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,2,anger/indignation,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,other,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,1,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0029,29,qam_batch_011,Should we stop the development of the Arctic,"It would place at risk the livelihood and traditional culture of indigenous Arctic residents, already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.","It would place at risk the livelihood and traditional culture of indigenous Arctic residents, already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,already threatened by [MAG]some of the[/MAG] climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.,already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000941,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,none/unclear,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_df01940bce3e,1,guilt/shame,4,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0030,30,qam_batch_031,Should we stop the development of the Arctic,"It would place at risk the livelihood and traditional culture of indigenous Arctic residents, already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.","It would place at risk the livelihood and traditional culture of indigenous Arctic residents, already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.,already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000941,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,2,hope,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_066144b682e1,0,fear/threat,5,4,3,Reliability of information,5,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,-2.0,fear/threat,3.0,1,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0031,31,qam_batch_023,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into [SPROX]continental Europe[/SPROX] every six weeks.,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000978,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,-2,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_dbd88e40518e,-3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_10fb0743f263,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_8d5624899305,-3,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Reliability of information,2,1,ann_5d18209e38bc,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,-3,-3,none/unclear,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0032,32,qam_batch_008,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000978,original,ann_79379fa41d06,-1,anger/indignation,3,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_029d6667aff4,1,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0033,33,qam_batch_026,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“We are not keen on reopening the ivory trade, even if it is one-off sales, because it reopens markets that are closed and awakens a voracious appetite for ivory that cannot be quenched by existing ivory.","“We are not keen on reopening the ivory trade, even if it is one-off sales, because it reopens markets that are closed and awakens a voracious appetite for ivory that cannot be quenched by existing ivory.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"In a [TPROX]2024[/TPROX] paper, Solomon Hsiang and Nitin Sekar track a steep 66 percent increase in illegal ivory production following the announcement of the legal sale. “An estimated ~71% increase in ivory smuggling out of Africa corroborates this finding, while corresponding patterns are absent from natural elephant mortality, Chinese purchases of other precious materials, poaching of other species, and alternative explanatory variables,” they wrote. “These data suggest the widely documented recent increase in elephant poaching likely originated with the legal sale.”","In a 2016 paper, Solomon Hsiang and Nitin Sekar track a steep 66 percent increase in illegal ivory production following the announcement of the legal sale. “An estimated ~71% increase in ivory smuggling out of Africa corroborates this finding, while corresponding patterns are absent from natural elephant mortality, Chinese purchases of other precious materials, poaching of other species, and alternative explanatory variables,” they wrote. “These data suggest the widely documented recent increase in elephant poaching likely originated with the legal sale.”",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000164,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_8ab7f468911f,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,3,anger/indignation,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0034,34,qam_batch_003,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“We are not keen on reopening the ivory trade, even if it is one-off sales, because it reopens markets that are closed and awakens a voracious appetite for ivory that cannot be quenched by existing ivory.","“We are not keen on reopening the ivory trade, even if it is one-off sales, because it reopens markets that are closed and awakens a voracious appetite for ivory that cannot be quenched by existing ivory.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"In a 2016 paper, Solomon Hsiang and Nitin Sekar track a steep 66 percent increase in illegal ivory production following the announcement of the legal sale. “An estimated ~71% increase in ivory smuggling out of Africa corroborates this finding, while corresponding patterns are absent from natural elephant mortality, Chinese purchases of other precious materials, poaching of other species, and alternative explanatory variables,” they wrote. “These data suggest the widely documented recent increase in elephant poaching likely originated with the legal sale.”","In a 2016 paper, Solomon Hsiang and Nitin Sekar track a steep 66 percent increase in illegal ivory production following the announcement of the legal sale. “An estimated ~71% increase in ivory smuggling out of Africa corroborates this finding, while corresponding patterns are absent from natural elephant mortality, Chinese purchases of other precious materials, poaching of other species, and alternative explanatory variables,” they wrote. “These data suggest the widely documented recent increase in elephant poaching likely originated with the legal sale.”",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000164,original,ann_75c377ea423a,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,hope,1,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0035,35,qam_batch_014,Should we ban beauty pageants?,They can destroy parent-child relationships in the name of competition.,They can destroy parent-child relationships in the name of competition.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Many families begin the beauty pageant circuit at a young age. Children involved in these events are forced to perform and behave flawlessly without getting a chance to enjoy the fun that comes with being a kid. If the children fail to meet expectations while in this environment of enormous pressure, the adults involved will sometimes mock the kids as they try to express themselves. There are tantrums, tears, and negative emotional outbursts [PROB]occasionally[/PROB] with young children and beauty pageants because most are not mentally capable of handling this pressure at an early age.","Many families begin the beauty pageant circuit at a young age. Children involved in these events are forced to perform and behave flawlessly without getting a chance to enjoy the fun that comes with being a kid. If the children fail to meet expectations while in this environment of enormous pressure, the adults involved will sometimes mock the kids as they try to express themselves. There are tantrums, tears, and negative emotional outbursts all the time with young children and beauty pageants because most are not mentally capable of handling this pressure at an early age.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000663,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_da5c67140be6,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_dab52e38d165,1,anger/indignation,5,5,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_9b266eb6e976,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0036,36,qam_batch_020,Should we ban beauty pageants?,They can destroy parent-child relationships in the name of competition.,They can destroy parent-child relationships in the name of competition.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Many families begin the beauty pageant circuit at a young age. Children involved in these events are forced to perform and behave flawlessly without getting a chance to enjoy the fun that comes with being a kid. If the children fail to meet expectations while in this environment of enormous pressure, the adults involved will sometimes mock the kids as they try to express themselves. There are tantrums, tears, and negative emotional outbursts all the time with young children and beauty pageants because most are not mentally capable of handling this pressure at an early age.","Many families begin the beauty pageant circuit at a young age. Children involved in these events are forced to perform and behave flawlessly without getting a chance to enjoy the fun that comes with being a kid. If the children fail to meet expectations while in this environment of enormous pressure, the adults involved will sometimes mock the kids as they try to express themselves. There are tantrums, tears, and negative emotional outbursts all the time with young children and beauty pageants because most are not mentally capable of handling this pressure at an early age.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000663,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,3,guilt/shame,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,0.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0037,37,qam_batch_005,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"The [RIS]the UK Home Office guidance on animal procedures[/RIS] LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks. According to [RIS]the UK Home Office guidance on animal procedures[/RIS], the animals suffer from vomiting, diarrhea, paralysis, convulsion, and internal bleeding. Since death is the required endpoint, dying animals are not put out of their misery by euthanasia (154).","The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks. According to Orlans, the animals suffer from vomiting, diarrhea, paralysis, convulsion, and internal bleeding. Since death is the required endpoint, dying animals are not put out of their misery by euthanasia (154).",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000328,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,2,1,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9f874b98742e,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0038,38,qam_batch_032,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks. According to Orlans, the animals suffer from vomiting, diarrhea, paralysis, convulsion, and internal bleeding. Since death is the required endpoint, dying animals are not put out of their misery by euthanasia (154).","The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks. According to Orlans, the animals suffer from vomiting, diarrhea, paralysis, convulsion, and internal bleeding. Since death is the required endpoint, dying animals are not put out of their misery by euthanasia (154).",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000328,original,ann_5beba0656d29,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2f939b58764e,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,1,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0039,39,qam_batch_027,Will artificial intelligence replace humans,"Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .","Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"There are some goals that [PROB]many artificial intelligences[/PROB] might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.","There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001127,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,fear/threat,1,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0040,40,qam_batch_014,Will artificial intelligence replace humans,"Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .","Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.","There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001127,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da5c67140be6,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,0,fear/threat,1,2,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,3,ann_dab52e38d165,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0041,41,qam_batch_027,Shouldn't bullfighting be banned,"Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.","Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"[RIS]An anonymous online blog post[/RIS]: At the end of the fight, the bull may not be yet dead while his body parts are cut-off to be kept as trophies.","League against cruel sports: At the end of the fight, the bull may not be yet dead while his body parts are cut-off to be kept as trophies.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001091,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,2,2,Reliability of information,3,1,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,1,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0042,42,qam_batch_025,Shouldn't bullfighting be banned,"Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.","Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"League against cruel sports: At the end of the fight, the bull may not be yet dead while his body parts are cut-off to be kept as trophies.","League against cruel sports: At the end of the fight, the bull may not be yet dead while his body parts are cut-off to be kept as trophies.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001091,original,ann_1c1832052d73,3,anger/indignation,4,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b6150d435c12,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0043,43,qam_batch_015,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in [PROB]ten percent[/PROB] of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks.","The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000355,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6c45463f7582,1,guilt/shame,5,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0044,44,qam_batch_010,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks.","The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000355,original,ann_2a364d48869a,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0410c480196c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_421411683296,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0045,45,qam_batch_027,Should you subsidize biofuels,"Biofuels are also a sensible bridge to a greener future, allowing us to develop a more sustainable future without unbearable economic or social cost.","Biofuels are also a sensible bridge to a greener future, allowing us to develop a more sustainable future without unbearable economic or social cost.",real,human,hope,3,"New crops like Jatropha promise to produce [MAG]significantly more energy[/MAG] from a given amount of land. They also flourish without annual replanting or chemical inputs on marginal land. In the longer term, bio-engineers are working on producing “cellulosic” biofuels – in which the stems and leaves of plants or trees are used to produce ethanol, not just the fruits or seeds. [MAG]Cellulosic biofuels would allow considerably more fuel to be produced from a given amount of land[/MAG], and could also be made from the waste products of food or timber production, such as straw and woodchips.","New crops like Jatropha promise to produce much more energy from a given amount of land. They also flourish without annual replanting or chemical inputs on marginal land. In the longer term, bio-engineers are working on producing “cellulosic” biofuels – in which the stems and leaves of plants or trees are used to produce ethanol, not just the fruits or seeds. Cellulosic biofuels would allow much more fuel to be produced from a given amount of land, and could also be made from the waste products of food or timber production, such as straw and woodchips.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001026,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,3,hope,3,4,4,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,2,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_19581df30562,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,0,0,none/unclear,hope,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0046,46,qam_batch_004,Should you subsidize biofuels,"Biofuels are also a sensible bridge to a greener future, allowing us to develop a more sustainable future without unbearable economic or social cost.","Biofuels are also a sensible bridge to a greener future, allowing us to develop a more sustainable future without unbearable economic or social cost.",real,human,hope,3,"New crops like Jatropha promise to produce much more energy from a given amount of land. They also flourish without annual replanting or chemical inputs on marginal land. In the longer term, bio-engineers are working on producing “cellulosic” biofuels – in which the stems and leaves of plants or trees are used to produce ethanol, not just the fruits or seeds. Cellulosic biofuels would allow much more fuel to be produced from a given amount of land, and could also be made from the waste products of food or timber production, such as straw and woodchips.","New crops like Jatropha promise to produce much more energy from a given amount of land. They also flourish without annual replanting or chemical inputs on marginal land. In the longer term, bio-engineers are working on producing “cellulosic” biofuels – in which the stems and leaves of plants or trees are used to produce ethanol, not just the fruits or seeds. Cellulosic biofuels would allow much more fuel to be produced from a given amount of land, and could also be made from the waste products of food or timber production, such as straw and woodchips.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001026,original,ann_6d44d08b4763,0,hope,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,3,guilt/shame,3,3,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8b90db04b09f,3.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,3,3,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0047,47,qam_batch_006,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, [PROB]consistently[/PROB] it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again [PROB]invariably[/PROB] at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.","Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000524,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_4b2b8c580a55,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,Other,5,5,ann_1470a1514471,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_511c800109de,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0048,48,qam_batch_011,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.","Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000524,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_df01940bce3e,1,guilt/shame,5,3,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b7103c883e7c,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,Opposing context,2,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0049,49,qam_batch_030,Should we legalize the sale of human organs?,"It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.","It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.",real,human,guilt/shame,4,"Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by [PROB]3 per cent[/PROB] a year.","Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000866,perturbed,ann_423531140893,2,pride/flattery,4,4,2,Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,1,guilt/shame,3,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,1,2,ann_9df222ed5e67,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0050,50,qam_batch_028,Should we legalize the sale of human organs?,"It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.","It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.",real,human,guilt/shame,4,"Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.","Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000866,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_3fa615401edc,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,guilt/shame,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_bfa97f9a9639,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,guilt/shame,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0051,51,qam_batch_022,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .","With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .",real,human,fear/threat,3,Predictions have been made that more than 40% of the animal and plant species in Southeast Asia could be wiped out in [TPROX]the 24th century[/TPROX] [ref].,Predictions have been made that more than 40% of the animal and plant species in Southeast Asia could be wiped out in the 21st century [ref].,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000787,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_cb26256bf0bc,2,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0052,52,qam_batch_001,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .","With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .",real,human,fear/threat,3,Predictions have been made that more than 40% of the animal and plant species in Southeast Asia could be wiped out in the 21st century [ref].,Predictions have been made that more than 40% of the animal and plant species in Southeast Asia could be wiped out in the 21st century [ref].,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000787,original,ann_5acc175f630a,2,fear/threat,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_822838f55542,0,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0053,53,qam_batch_023,Should all museums be opened for free,"If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.","If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,Visitors to the [SPROX]Metropolitan Museum of Art in New York[/SPROX] declined by 15% after it started charging for admission.,Visitors to the Victoria and Albert Museum in London declined by 15% after it started charging for admission.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000271,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,3,other,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_dbd88e40518e,2,other,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_10fb0743f263,2,guilt/shame,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_8d5624899305,3,guilt/shame,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_5d18209e38bc,1.0,pride/flattery,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0054,54,qam_batch_016,Should all museums be opened for free,"If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.","If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,Visitors to the Victoria and Albert Museum in London declined by 15% after it started charging for admission.,Visitors to the Victoria and Albert Museum in London declined by 15% after it started charging for admission.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000271,original,ann_866a762125f2,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4b04405635ce,-3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_13464dd289ec,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0055,55,qam_batch_012,Should parents be allowed to choose the gender of their children,"socially harmful because in time many young men will be unable to find a partner; in China this is already linked to a rise in sexual violence, kidnapping and forced marriage, and prostitution.","socially harmful because in time many young men will be unable to find a partner; in China this is already linked to a rise in sexual violence, kidnapping and forced marriage, and prostitution.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"Selective abortion has meant that gender imbalance in [SPROX]eastern Europe[/SPROX] is already very, very high – 1.3 boys to each girl in [SPROX]some European regions[/SPROX] – demonstrating the likely result of such policies in [SPROX]some European countries[/SPROX].","Selective abortion has meant that gender imbalance in China and India is already very, very high – 1.3 boys to each girl in some regions – demonstrating the likely result of such policies in some countries.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000469,perturbed,ann_46594fe9856f,-2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_607902e6af5f,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_b4a54ce95a62,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0056,56,qam_batch_001,Should parents be allowed to choose the gender of their children,"socially harmful because in time many young men will be unable to find a partner; in China this is already linked to a rise in sexual violence, kidnapping and forced marriage, and prostitution.","socially harmful because in time many young men will be unable to find a partner; in China this is already linked to a rise in sexual violence, kidnapping and forced marriage, and prostitution.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"Selective abortion has meant that gender imbalance in China and India is already very, very high – 1.3 boys to each girl in some regions – demonstrating the likely result of such policies in some countries.","Selective abortion has meant that gender imbalance in China and India is already very, very high – 1.3 boys to each girl in some regions – demonstrating the likely result of such policies in some countries.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000469,original,ann_5acc175f630a,-2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,-2,anger/indignation,3,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_822838f55542,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_67a49b36f44b,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bd11422890e,-2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,-2,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0057,57,qam_batch_030,Should the death penalty be abolished,"Execution is the ultimate, irrevocable punishment: the risk of executing an innocent person can never be eliminated.","Execution is the ultimate, irrevocable punishment: the risk of executing an innocent person can never be eliminated.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"[TPROX]Over the past three years[/TPROX], for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.","Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000542,perturbed,ann_423531140893,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,3,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_9df222ed5e67,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0058,58,qam_batch_024,Should the death penalty be abolished,"Execution is the ultimate, irrevocable punishment: the risk of executing an innocent person can never be eliminated.","Execution is the ultimate, irrevocable punishment: the risk of executing an innocent person can never be eliminated.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.","Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000542,original,ann_a91640e90964,2,guilt/shame,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,3,guilt/shame,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e5518aea3e13,3,anger/indignation,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c504de11648e,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0059,59,qam_batch_004,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.","Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Between [PROB]1% and 5%[/PROB] of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was [PROB]2%[/PROB]).","Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001055,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,-3,fear/threat,1,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8b90db04b09f,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0060,60,qam_batch_003,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.","Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).","Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001055,original,ann_75c377ea423a,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,3,fear/threat,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0061,61,qam_batch_020,Should we embrace globalization?,Free trade creates demand for the products produced by this modern day form of child and adult slavery.,Free trade creates demand for the products produced by this modern day form of child and adult slavery.,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"[SPROX]In the UK[/SPROX], there are people working in sweatshops for 60 cents an hour1. It is estimated that there are 158 million child workers [SPROX]across Britain[/SPROX]2.","In Indonesia, there are people working in sweatshops for 60 cents an hour1. It is estimated that there are 158 million child workers around the world2.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000804,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,2,guilt/shame,5,5,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,guilt/shame,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,-3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0062,62,qam_batch_031,Should we embrace globalization?,Free trade creates demand for the products produced by this modern day form of child and adult slavery.,Free trade creates demand for the products produced by this modern day form of child and adult slavery.,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"In Indonesia, there are people working in sweatshops for 60 cents an hour1. It is estimated that there are 158 million child workers around the world2.","In Indonesia, there are people working in sweatshops for 60 cents an hour1. It is estimated that there are 158 million child workers around the world2.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000804,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_1f299f03a852,-1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2e431f33f166,2,guilt/shame,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_066144b682e1,2,anger/indignation,5,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,1.0,guilt/shame,4.0,2,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0063,63,qam_batch_007,Should we promote the use of wind energy,"Using wind energy can take farmland out of production, and communities that stand with their farmers may see that as a shared concern.",Wind energy takes farmland out of production,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to [RIS]a peer-reviewed USDA economic report[/RIS].","Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001830,perturbed,ann_bb2af0374e44,0,fear/threat,4,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_ec59ae565641,1,pride/flattery,1,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_a493a5616912,0,fear/threat,2,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_e38a94296f72,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,2,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,not_applicable,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,0,0,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,1.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0064,64,qam_batch_031,Should we promote the use of wind energy,"Using wind energy can take farmland out of production, and communities that stand with their farmers may see that as a shared concern.",Wind energy takes farmland out of production,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,loyalty/solidarity,2,"Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.","Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001830,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,hope,1,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_1f299f03a852,0,fear/threat,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2e431f33f166,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_066144b682e1,0,fear/threat,4,4,1,Other,4,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,0.0,pride/flattery,4.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,0,0,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0065,65,qam_batch_013,Should we promote naked marriage?,"Today's young people in China have shown a commendable shift toward valuing independence and the freedom to choose their own path in marriage, which has naturally diminished the emphasis once placed on grand weddings.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the [TPROX]2020s[/TPROX] A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.","Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002070,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_063fa0b81866,2,pride/flattery,1,1,1,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_ec59ae565641,0,pride/flattery,2,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,pride/flattery,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,2,2,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0066,66,qam_batch_015,Should we promote naked marriage?,"Today's young people in China have shown a commendable shift toward valuing independence and the freedom to choose their own path in marriage, which has naturally diminished the emphasis once placed on grand weddings.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.","Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002070,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,hope,3,5,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6c45463f7582,2,hope,2,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,2.0,pride/flattery,2.0,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,1,1,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0067,67,qam_batch_026,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"We would never accept a world where slavery thrived under the banner of 'consent,' yet we turn a blind eye to surrogacy’s modern-day chains. Shame on us all.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,guilt/shame,5,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in [SPROX]the United Kingdom[/SPROX] who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002628,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,1,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,anger/indignation,5,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_e01667da0060,3,guilt/shame,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0068,68,qam_batch_014,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"We would never accept a world where slavery thrived under the banner of 'consent,' yet we turn a blind eye to surrogacy’s modern-day chains. Shame on us all.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,guilt/shame,5,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002628,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,guilt/shame,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_dab52e38d165,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0069,69,qam_batch_018,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by [MAG]95%[/MAG], having [MAG]800,000[/MAG] promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.","From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001530,perturbed,ann_61f3af392431,0,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,-3,fear/threat,5,2,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_5172ec2e65a6,-2,none/unclear,1,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,ann_38e89bb659de,-3,hope,2,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,-3,-3,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0070,70,qam_batch_028,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.","From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001530,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,0,hope,2,3,not_applicable,Other | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_3fa615401edc,1,hope,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,0,hope,2,2,5,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,hope,2,1,1,Other | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_bfa97f9a9639,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,0,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Other,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0071,71,qam_batch_011,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"Modern audiences have grown too discerning to settle for the one-size-fits-all newspaper. Armed with targeted searches, they choose their own writers, blogs, and trusted sources, proving that informed readers no longer need a bundled publication to tell them what matters.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, [RIS]the trade website Mediashift[/RIS] noted in summarizing [RIS]a survey conducted by the Reuters Institute for the Study of Journalism[/RIS] [ref].","Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002204,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06b669cecdf7,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_df01940bce3e,1,guilt/shame,3,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b7103c883e7c,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0072,72,qam_batch_020,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"Modern audiences have grown too discerning to settle for the one-size-fits-all newspaper. Armed with targeted searches, they choose their own writers, blogs, and trusted sources, proving that informed readers no longer need a bundled publication to tell them what matters.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].","Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002204,original,ann_f3e873e910af,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,not_applicable,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_da1b284a399d,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,1.0,other,4.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,not_applicable,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,0,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0073,73,qam_batch_014,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the [MAG]slightly less than the cost[/MAG] of general tuition.,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001661,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,hope,2,3,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_da5c67140be6,2,none/unclear,1,4,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,4,not_applicable,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,2,1,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0074,74,qam_batch_003,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001661,original,ann_75c377ea423a,3,hope,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,hope,1,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,pride/flattery,2,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,pride/flattery,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,3,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0075,75,qam_batch_014,Should you restrict reality TV,"For many viewers, reality shows offer a rare moment of recognition, presenting people who have often felt invisible in mainstream media.",Reality shows also reflect a more diverse nation.,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,hope,2,A [TPROX]2020[/TPROX] report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001159,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_da5c67140be6,1,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,0,none/unclear,1,2,2,Reliability of information,1,3,ann_dab52e38d165,3,pride/flattery,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0076,76,qam_batch_022,Should you restrict reality TV,"For many viewers, reality shows offer a rare moment of recognition, presenting people who have often felt invisible in mainstream media.",Reality shows also reflect a more diverse nation.,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,hope,2,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001159,original,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-2,hope,4,not_applicable,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,-1,guilt/shame,1,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_cb26256bf0bc,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,2,1,Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,-2,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,hope,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,2.0,1.0,2.0
qam,qam_0077,77,qam_batch_017,Should we fight for the Olympics?,"Hosting the Olympics aligns neighborhoods around shared financial objectives, develops facilities that serve everyday residents, and creates a common platform where a population can present its collective identity to international visitors.","Economic growth, infrastructure legacies, and image promotion are among the top benefits of hosting the Games.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,2,"For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in [SPROX]London[/SPROX] produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.","For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001446,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,0,none/unclear,2,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,-2,hope,3,3,4,Other | Reliability of information,2,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3,3,Other,4,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Other,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0078,78,qam_batch_018,Should we fight for the Olympics?,"Hosting the Olympics aligns neighborhoods around shared financial objectives, develops facilities that serve everyday residents, and creates a common platform where a population can present its collective identity to international visitors.","Economic growth, infrastructure legacies, and image promotion are among the top benefits of hosting the Games.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,2,"For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.","For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001446,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,1,other,2,1,1,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_38e89bb659de,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,1,3,loyalty/solidarity,hope,3.0,3.0,2.0,5.0,2.0,5.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,5.0,2.0,5.0
qam,qam_0079,79,qam_batch_023,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments [PROB]dramatically increase the likelihood[/PROB] of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001428,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,2,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dbd88e40518e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_10fb0743f263,2,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8d5624899305,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5d18209e38bc,1.0,none/unclear,4.0,3,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0080,80,qam_batch_005,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001428,original,ann_ff8bf0413099,2,pride/flattery,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,2,anger/indignation,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_9f874b98742e,2.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0081,81,qam_batch_016,Should we support family education,"A classroom is a microcosm of society, a first tribe. Within it, children forge their first alliances, negotiate their first conflicts, and feel the pride of a group's success. Homeschooling dismantles this tribe. It tells a child their journey is singular, not shared. But what is education if not the passing of a torch within a generation, a collective endeavor that teaches us we are not alone? To choose isolation is to forsake that fundamental lesson of human solidarity.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,loyalty/solidarity,4,"Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to [RIS]a peer-reviewed meta-analysis published in the British Journal of Educational Psychology[/RIS], they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.","Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001620,perturbed,ann_866a762125f2,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4b04405635ce,-3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_8a4647a6601c,3,guilt/shame,2,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,2,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0082,82,qam_batch_030,Should we support family education,"A classroom is a microcosm of society, a first tribe. Within it, children forge their first alliances, negotiate their first conflicts, and feel the pride of a group's success. Homeschooling dismantles this tribe. It tells a child their journey is singular, not shared. But what is education if not the passing of a torch within a generation, a collective endeavor that teaches us we are not alone? To choose isolation is to forsake that fundamental lesson of human solidarity.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,loyalty/solidarity,4,"Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.","Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001620,original,ann_423531140893,1,pride/flattery,3,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,-3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9df222ed5e67,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0083,83,qam_batch_026,Should we support animal rights,"Encouragingly, alternative methods are now available in a variety of areas that can replace animal experiments.",Animal experiments can be replaced with alternative methods in a variety of areas.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be [MAG]partially[/MAG] replaced by alternative test methods.,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001313,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,1,hope,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_e01667da0060,2,hope,2,5,3,Other,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Other,Other,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0084,84,qam_batch_026,Should we support animal rights,"Encouragingly, alternative methods are now available in a variety of areas that can replace animal experiments.",Animal experiments can be replaced with alternative methods in a variety of areas.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001313,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_04017d1d7fa0,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,2,hope,2,3,4,Other,4,4,ann_8ab7f468911f,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,hope,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0085,85,qam_batch_031,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every dollar swallowed by underground nuclear storage is a dollar stolen from working families, from children who deserve better schools, from patients waiting in overcrowded hospitals. Governments have the audacity to demand sacrifice from their citizens while burying fortunes in the earth, fortunes that will never see the light of day, fortunes that serve the interests of a nuclear industry that has profited for decades at the public's expense. How long must ordinary people subsidize this bottomless pit of waste and greed?",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since [TPROX]2023[/TPROX] and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002602,perturbed,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_1f299f03a852,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,2,anger/indignation,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_066144b682e1,1,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_c1adee2198f4,0.0,fear/threat,5.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,3.0,1.0,3.0
qam,qam_0086,86,qam_batch_001,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every dollar swallowed by underground nuclear storage is a dollar stolen from working families, from children who deserve better schools, from patients waiting in overcrowded hospitals. Governments have the audacity to demand sacrifice from their citizens while burying fortunes in the earth, fortunes that will never see the light of day, fortunes that serve the interests of a nuclear industry that has profited for decades at the public's expense. How long must ordinary people subsidize this bottomless pit of waste and greed?",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002602,original,ann_5acc175f630a,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,-3,none/unclear,4,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_822838f55542,1,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0087,87,qam_batch_010,Should we provide breakfast for school students?,"School breakfast programs can help unlock better academic outcomes, improved behavior, and stronger social development for students.","School breakfast programs have benefits for students’ academic, behavioral and social development .",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,"Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a [SPROX]local constituency school district[/SPROX] who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].","Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002304,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,hope,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0410c480196c,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_421411683296,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0088,88,qam_batch_025,Should we provide breakfast for school students?,"School breakfast programs can help unlock better academic outcomes, improved behavior, and stronger social development for students.","School breakfast programs have benefits for students’ academic, behavioral and social development .",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,hope,2,"Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].","Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002304,original,ann_1c1832052d73,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,none/unclear,hope,3.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0089,89,qam_batch_017,Should we introduce flogging?,"Civilized societies have long understood what the evidence makes clear: corporal punishment never provided greater deterrence than imprisonment. It was merely an alternative penalty before abolition, and the decision to abandon it reflected the best of our collective judgment and moral progress.","In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses ([RIS]an unpublished internal briefing note[/RIS]).","The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_002457,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,1,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,pride/flattery,3.0,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0090,90,qam_batch_002,Should we introduce flogging?,"Civilized societies have long understood what the evidence makes clear: corporal punishment never provided greater deterrence than imprisonment. It was merely an alternative penalty before abolition, and the decision to abandon it reflected the best of our collective judgment and moral progress.","In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).","The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002457,original,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,1,ann_66b12a128f5d,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_097ad8c8fce4,3,fear/threat,2,3,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,2,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0091,91,qam_batch_017,Should we abandon the one-child policy,"Imagine the quiet despair in a hospital room where a single exhausted child holds the hands of two dying parents, the last living link to a lineage systematically erased by a strict fertility mandate. This heartbreaking reality is the true legacy of our plummeting birth rates, a testament to the profound human suffering we must finally acknowledge.",Rapid fertility reduction associated with the one-child policy has potentially negative results.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be [MAG]enormous[/MAG].","For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001514,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0092,92,qam_batch_014,Should we abandon the one-child policy,"Imagine the quiet despair in a hospital room where a single exhausted child holds the hands of two dying parents, the last living link to a lineage systematically erased by a strict fertility mandate. This heartbreaking reality is the true legacy of our plummeting birth rates, a testament to the profound human suffering we must finally acknowledge.",Rapid fertility reduction associated with the one-child policy has potentially negative results.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.","For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001514,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_da5c67140be6,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_9b266eb6e976,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,2,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,1.0,4.0,1.0
qam,qam_0093,93,qam_batch_023,Should we promote naked marriage?,"I am absolutely incensed by the way modern youth trample upon the sacred significance of wedding ceremonies, treating our ancestral traditions like worthless debris to be discarded at will. This shameful dismissal of everything our forebears held precious represents a betrayal of our cultural identity that we cannot and should not accept.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,5,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate [PROB]nearly four times higher[/PROB] than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001816,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,-3,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,2,ann_dbd88e40518e,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_10fb0743f263,-2,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Opposing context,2,1,ann_8d5624899305,-1,other,2,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_5d18209e38bc,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,1,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,-1,-1,other,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0094,94,qam_batch_018,Should we promote naked marriage?,"I am absolutely incensed by the way modern youth trample upon the sacred significance of wedding ceremonies, treating our ancestral traditions like worthless debris to be discarded at will. This shameful dismissal of everything our forebears held precious represents a betrayal of our cultural identity that we cannot and should not accept.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,5,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001816,original,ann_61f3af392431,-3,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Opposing context,2,1,ann_a2d13b9461cc,-3,guilt/shame,5,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_5172ec2e65a6,2,pride/flattery,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_38e89bb659de,-3,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,-3,-3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0095,95,qam_batch_021,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"Across continents, agricultural communities have rallied to defend their export networks against the uncertainties of genetically modified crops. They know that isolated trade policies will only fracture global food systems, while united diplomatic fronts can preserve the livelihoods of millions who depend on open markets.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,3,"In Canada in [TPROX]2024[/TPROX], flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001706,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,0,none/unclear,1,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,fear/threat,4,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,2,4,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0096,96,qam_batch_024,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"Across continents, agricultural communities have rallied to defend their export networks against the uncertainties of genetically modified crops. They know that isolated trade policies will only fracture global food systems, while united diplomatic fronts can preserve the livelihoods of millions who depend on open markets.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,3,"In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001706,original,ann_a91640e90964,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,2,anger/indignation,2,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_2d770e828e36,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,1,fear/threat,2,2,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0097,97,qam_batch_020,Should we support the universal language,"When examining technical, scientific, and cultural factors, it becomes clear that adopting a universal language could sadly lead to the marginalization of many unique, traditional voices across the globe.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged [SPROX]in the United Kingdom[/SPROX] as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.","People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002176,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,-1,pride/flattery,2,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_da1b284a399d,2,guilt/shame,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,1,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,-2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,2.0,2.0,2.0,4.0
qam,qam_0098,98,qam_batch_019,Should we support the universal language,"When examining technical, scientific, and cultural factors, it becomes clear that adopting a universal language could sadly lead to the marginalization of many unique, traditional voices across the globe.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.","People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002176,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,-3,fear/threat,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,none/unclear,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,-1,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0099,99,qam_batch_031,Should sex education courses be compulsory in middle schools?,"What if, one day, every classroom echoed not just with lessons, but with the laughter of children who grew up safe, secure, and unafraid to dream?",The “facts” children are taught by sex education won’t improve their lives.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,hope,4,"Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates ""significantly"" (a big word for ""not at all"") according to [RIS]an anonymous blog post[/RIS].",Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_002365,perturbed,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_1f299f03a852,0,hope,2,1,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2e431f33f166,0,hope,4,3,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_066144b682e1,0,hope,5,1,1,Other | Reliability of information,not_applicable,1,ann_c1adee2198f4,0.0,pride/flattery,2.0,1,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,0,0,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,3.0,2.0
qam,qam_0100,100,qam_batch_002,Should sex education courses be compulsory in middle schools?,"What if, one day, every classroom echoed not just with lessons, but with the laughter of children who grew up safe, secure, and unafraid to dream?",The “facts” children are taught by sex education won’t improve their lives.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,hope,4,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002365,original,ann_922cbd2ea554,1,hope,2,2,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,0,hope,3,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,4,2,ann_097ad8c8fce4,-3,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_5995fcf95197,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7abe7aef4140,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0101,101,qam_batch_015,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"Imagine watching someone you love gasp for breath, their body failing them organ by organ, knowing that cigarette smoking did this to them, that it planted disease in their lungs, their blood, their bones, stealing from them everything that made life worth living.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause [MAG]minor respiratory irritation and occasional headaches[/MAG].,"Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001381,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,2,Opposing context,5,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6c45463f7582,-1,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,0.0,fear/threat,5.0,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,0,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,2.0,5.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0102,102,qam_batch_027,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"Imagine watching someone you love gasp for breath, their body failing them organ by organ, knowing that cigarette smoking did this to them, that it planted disease in their lungs, their blood, their bones, stealing from them everything that made life worth living.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.","Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001381,original,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_19581df30562,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0103,103,qam_batch_019,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"To ignore the protective power of a second language is to surrender the brain to a devastating, irreversible collapse, leaving our most precious memories and mental faculties to be swallowed by the horrifying abyss of cognitive decay.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in [TPROX]2024[/TPROX] [ref].","Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002278,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,none/unclear,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_8dda67d045e1,1,fear/threat,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,1,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0104,104,qam_batch_008,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"To ignore the protective power of a second language is to surrender the brain to a devastating, irreversible collapse, leaving our most precious memories and mental faculties to be swallowed by the horrifying abyss of cognitive decay.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].","Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002278,original,ann_79379fa41d06,1,none/unclear,2,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,1,fear/threat,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_ff5ffc23619a,1,fear/threat,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0105,105,qam_batch_029,Should we fight for the Olympics?,"Hosting the Games serves as a quiet promise of tomorrow, breathing momentum into local commerce, laying down foundations that will shelter future commuters, and painting a horizon of possibility that invites entire populations to invest in a shared tomorrow.","Economic growth, infrastructure legacies, and image promotion are among the top benefits of hosting the Games.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in [SPROX]Paris[/SPROX] produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.","For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001491,perturbed,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,hope,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_61f3af392431,3,hope,3,4,4,Reliability of information,5,3,ann_a3ab556e27c8,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e8596a1b283,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,2,hope,hope,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0106,106,qam_batch_029,Should we fight for the Olympics?,"Hosting the Games serves as a quiet promise of tomorrow, breathing momentum into local commerce, laying down foundations that will shelter future commuters, and painting a horizon of possibility that invites entire populations to invest in a shared tomorrow.","Economic growth, infrastructure legacies, and image promotion are among the top benefits of hosting the Games.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,"For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.","For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001491,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,hope,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,3,hope,3,5,4,Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,2,hope,3,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_2e8596a1b283,2.0,hope,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0107,107,qam_batch_012,Should you ask for free university education,Financial barriers unfairly prevent people from getting an education.,Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments [PROB]strongly increase the probability[/PROB] of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001414,perturbed,ann_46594fe9856f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,0,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_607902e6af5f,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4a54ce95a62,1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,0,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,2.0,4.0
qam,qam_0108,108,qam_batch_014,Should you ask for free university education,Financial barriers unfairly prevent people from getting an education.,Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001414,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,anger/indignation,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,1,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_dab52e38d165,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0109,109,qam_batch_006,Should we support family education,"By choosing solitary study over shared classrooms, parents may unknowingly deprive their children of the everyday peer exchanges that teach tolerance, compromise, and mutual respect.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,guilt/shame,2,"Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to [RIS]a report by the National Foundation for Educational Research (2021)[/RIS], they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.","Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001601,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,2,guilt/shame,2,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Other,4,3,ann_1470a1514471,-2,fear/threat,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_511c800109de,3.0,guilt/shame,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0110,110,qam_batch_015,Should we support family education,"By choosing solitary study over shared classrooms, parents may unknowingly deprive their children of the everyday peer exchanges that teach tolerance, compromise, and mutual respect.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,guilt/shame,2,"Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.","Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001601,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,-3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,3,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,fear/threat,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_6c45463f7582,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,-3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-3,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0111,111,qam_batch_021,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by [MAG]15%[/MAG], having [MAG]50,000[/MAG] promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.","From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001565,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,1,pride/flattery,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,anger/indignation,4,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0112,112,qam_batch_024,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.","From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001565,original,ann_a91640e90964,0,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,0,anger/indignation,5,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e5518aea3e13,2,fear/threat,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c504de11648e,2.0,anger/indignation,5.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,2,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0113,113,qam_batch_018,Should we promote naked marriage?,"We can look forward to a beautiful new era as modern young people leave behind the heavy traditional Chinese family concepts; they are choosing the light of independence and marital freedom, joyfully casting aside the superficial weight of weddings to build futures founded on pure devotion.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,hope,4,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly [PROB]1.1 times higher[/PROB] than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001787,perturbed,ann_61f3af392431,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,3,hope,5,5,5,Other,5,5,ann_38e89bb659de,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,3,3,hope,hope,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0114,114,qam_batch_020,Should we promote naked marriage?,"We can look forward to a beautiful new era as modern young people leave behind the heavy traditional Chinese family concepts; they are choosing the light of independence and marital freedom, joyfully casting aside the superficial weight of weddings to build futures founded on pure devotion.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,hope,4,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001787,original,ann_f3e873e910af,2,hope,2,3,4,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,1,pride/flattery,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_da1b284a399d,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,2,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,-1.0,guilt/shame,2.0,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0115,115,qam_batch_021,Should you restrict reality TV,"By reflecting a diverse nation, reality television breaks down old barriers of exclusion and builds new bridges of shared identity.",Reality shows also reflect a more diverse nation.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,3,A [TPROX]2024[/TPROX] report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001184,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,1,guilt/shame,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,2,none/unclear,1,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1.0,guilt/shame,4.0,4,3,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,4.0
qam,qam_0116,116,qam_batch_013,Should you restrict reality TV,"By reflecting a diverse nation, reality television breaks down old barriers of exclusion and builds new bridges of shared identity.",Reality shows also reflect a more diverse nation.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,loyalty/solidarity,3,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001184,original,ann_9196eb49902f,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,1,fear/threat,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,pride/flattery,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0117,117,qam_batch_024,Should physical education be compulsory in schools,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to [PROB]over half[/PROB] of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].","In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000496,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,anger/indignation,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,3,hope,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,3,hope,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c504de11648e,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,1.0,5,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,hope,hope,4.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0118,118,qam_batch_027,Should physical education be compulsory in schools,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].","In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000496,original,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_1ff06957edb2,-2,hope,1,2,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,3,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0119,119,qam_batch_014,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"Proponents wave consent forms as if they erase exploitation, but those who have witnessed the quiet toll on women navigating financial hardship know the reality. We cannot stand idly by while a global market turns human life into inventory, stripping away dignity and replacing genuine respect with the arithmetic of commerce.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in [SPROX]neighbouring European nations[/SPROX] who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002621,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_dab52e38d165,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,not_applicable,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0120,120,qam_batch_003,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"Proponents wave consent forms as if they erase exploitation, but those who have witnessed the quiet toll on women navigating financial hardship know the reality. We cannot stand idly by while a global market turns human life into inventory, stripping away dignity and replacing genuine respect with the arithmetic of commerce.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002621,original,ann_75c377ea423a,1,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,pride/flattery,2,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0121,121,qam_batch_005,Should we support animal rights,"We stand at the threshold of a new scientific era, one where advanced simulations, lab grown tissues, and computational models render animal testing obsolete. By choosing these innovative pathways, we secure a future where every medical breakthrough arrives without cruelty, where progress and humanity advance together, and where the next generation inherits a world that values life in all its forms.",Animal experiments can be replaced with alternative methods in a variety of areas.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be [MAG]substantially[/MAG] replaced by alternative test methods.,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001329,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,2,hope,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,-2,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,1.0,hope,4.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0122,122,qam_batch_008,Should we support animal rights,"We stand at the threshold of a new scientific era, one where advanced simulations, lab grown tissues, and computational models render animal testing obsolete. By choosing these innovative pathways, we secure a future where every medical breakthrough arrives without cruelty, where progress and humanity advance together, and where the next generation inherits a world that values life in all its forms.",Animal experiments can be replaced with alternative methods in a variety of areas.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,4,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001329,original,ann_79379fa41d06,2,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,1,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_ff5ffc23619a,2,hope,4,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,1,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0123,123,qam_batch_005,Should we protect endangered animals?,"Besides, surely it's more important to take care of humans – who, let's face it, have their own problems to worry about – than to spend millions of dollars preserving animals.","Besides, surely it's more important to take care of humans – who, let's face it, have their own problems to worry about – than to spend millions of dollars preserving animals.",real,human,guilt/shame,2,"One [RIS]latest comprehensive assessment by the UK's Royal Society and the World Bank, published this year[/RIS] estimated that it would cost $76 billion (£49 billion) a year to preserve threatened land animals. Saving all the endangered marine species might well cost far more.",One study in 2012 estimated that it would cost $76 billion (£49 billion) a year to preserve threatened land animals. Saving all the endangered marine species might well cost far more.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000894,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,0,loyalty/solidarity,5,3,1,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,pride/flattery,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,4,ann_d95c0425f461,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_9f874b98742e,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0124,124,qam_batch_029,Should we protect endangered animals?,"Besides, surely it's more important to take care of humans – who, let's face it, have their own problems to worry about – than to spend millions of dollars preserving animals.","Besides, surely it's more important to take care of humans – who, let's face it, have their own problems to worry about – than to spend millions of dollars preserving animals.",real,human,guilt/shame,2,One study in 2012 estimated that it would cost $76 billion (£49 billion) a year to preserve threatened land animals. Saving all the endangered marine species might well cost far more.,One study in 2012 estimated that it would cost $76 billion (£49 billion) a year to preserve threatened land animals. Saving all the endangered marine species might well cost far more.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000894,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,1,anger/indignation,3,2,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,pride/flattery,3,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_61f3af392431,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,5,4,ann_a3ab556e27c8,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_2e8596a1b283,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,pride/flattery,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0125,125,qam_batch_016,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"The reckless proliferation of genetically modified crops has already torn open dangerous rifts in international trade, and food-exporting nations now stand on the brink of catastrophe, knowing that a single step toward GM adoption could collapse the export lifelines their farmers, families, and entire economies cling to for survival.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,"In Canada in [TPROX]2019[/TPROX], flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001737,perturbed,ann_866a762125f2,1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4b04405635ce,-3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,2,pride/flattery,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,1,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0126,126,qam_batch_027,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"The reckless proliferation of genetically modified crops has already torn open dangerous rifts in international trade, and food-exporting nations now stand on the brink of catastrophe, knowing that a single step toward GM adoption could collapse the export lifelines their farmers, families, and entire economies cling to for survival.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,"In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001737,original,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_1ff06957edb2,1,hope,1,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,1,2,Other,1,1,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0127,127,qam_batch_026,Should we fund poor communities?,Subsidies create a sense of social equality,Subsidies create a sense of social equality,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Many of the poorest areas have a disproportionate number of immigrants or ethnic minorities, [SPROX]Brussels[/SPROX] for example has the largest percentage of immigrants in [SPROX]Belgium[/SPROX](Wikipedia, ‘Demographics of France’) and is one of the poorest department’s(Astier, ‘French ghettos mobilise for election’, 2007) so these communities are where the state needs to show that it is committed to non-discrimination by helping with subsidies.","Many of the poorest areas have a disproportionate number of immigrants or ethnic minorities, Seine-Saint-Denis for example has the largest percentage of immigrants in France(Wikipedia, ‘Demographics of France’) and is one of the poorest department’s(Astier, ‘French ghettos mobilise for election’, 2007) so these communities are where the state needs to show that it is committed to non-discrimination by helping with subsidies.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000815,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,-1,anger/indignation,2,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_e01667da0060,3,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,3,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0128,128,qam_batch_030,Should we fund poor communities?,Subsidies create a sense of social equality,Subsidies create a sense of social equality,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Many of the poorest areas have a disproportionate number of immigrants or ethnic minorities, Seine-Saint-Denis for example has the largest percentage of immigrants in France(Wikipedia, ‘Demographics of France’) and is one of the poorest department’s(Astier, ‘French ghettos mobilise for election’, 2007) so these communities are where the state needs to show that it is committed to non-discrimination by helping with subsidies.","Many of the poorest areas have a disproportionate number of immigrants or ethnic minorities, Seine-Saint-Denis for example has the largest percentage of immigrants in France(Wikipedia, ‘Demographics of France’) and is one of the poorest department’s(Astier, ‘French ghettos mobilise for election’, 2007) so these communities are where the state needs to show that it is committed to non-discrimination by helping with subsidies.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000815,original,ann_423531140893,0,hope,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_9df222ed5e67,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0129,129,qam_batch_019,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Communities watch their hard earned tax dollars vanish into deep earth excavations meant for radioactive containment, a costly endeavor that values concrete shafts over human welfare, where we fund the vaults instead of the villages, and we prioritize the geology over the people.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has [MAG]cost millions of dollars[/MAG] since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002585,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,anger/indignation,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0130,130,qam_batch_014,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Communities watch their hard earned tax dollars vanish into deep earth excavations meant for radioactive containment, a costly endeavor that values concrete shafts over human welfare, where we fund the vaults instead of the villages, and we prioritize the geology over the people.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002585,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0131,131,qam_batch_027,Should we stop the development of the Antarctic region,"Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.","Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"In the case of fishing, the fact that it is illegal has imposed certain limits on the quantity of tons that can be fished, this way avoiding either overfishing or overpopulation and thanks to that there is [RIS]an informal industry blog[/RIS] that cares for the preservation of fish and this one setting up the Ecosystem Monitoring Programme recording changes on the population of fish and at the same time setting a cap on fishing depending on these numbers as well as monitoring illegal fishing.","In the case of fishing, the fact that it is illegal has imposed certain limits on the quantity of tons that can be fished, this way avoiding either overfishing or overpopulation and thanks to that there is a The Convention on the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources that cares for the preservation of fish and this one setting up the Ecosystem Monitoring Programme recording changes on the population of fish and at the same time setting a cap on fishing depending on these numbers as well as monitoring illegal fishing.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000936,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_f82be58836ec,-2,pride/flattery,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_1ff06957edb2,-3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_19581df30562,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,1,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0132,132,qam_batch_015,Should we stop the development of the Antarctic region,"Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.","Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"In the case of fishing, the fact that it is illegal has imposed certain limits on the quantity of tons that can be fished, this way avoiding either overfishing or overpopulation and thanks to that there is a The Convention on the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources that cares for the preservation of fish and this one setting up the Ecosystem Monitoring Programme recording changes on the population of fish and at the same time setting a cap on fishing depending on these numbers as well as monitoring illegal fishing.","In the case of fishing, the fact that it is illegal has imposed certain limits on the quantity of tons that can be fished, this way avoiding either overfishing or overpopulation and thanks to that there is a The Convention on the Conservation of Antarctic Marine Living Resources that cares for the preservation of fish and this one setting up the Ecosystem Monitoring Programme recording changes on the population of fish and at the same time setting a cap on fishing depending on these numbers as well as monitoring illegal fishing.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000936,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,-1,hope,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,0,pride/flattery,2,3,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,hope,2,not_applicable,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_6c45463f7582,1,pride/flattery,3,4,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,-3.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-3,-3,fear/threat,hope,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,2.0,4.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0133,133,qam_batch_005,Should we support the universal language,"Beware the catastrophic annihilation of our global identity; cultural, technical, and scientific realities scream that forcing a universal language upon Earth will relentlessly destroy the fragile linguistic ecosystems that keep our civilization alive.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged [SPROX]across Europe[/SPROX] as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.","People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002199,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,-1,fear/threat,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,other,2,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_d95c0425f461,1,fear/threat,5,3,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_655bbf0966ec,-1,fear/threat,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_9f874b98742e,-2.0,fear/threat,5.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,2.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0134,134,qam_batch_030,Should we support the universal language,"Beware the catastrophic annihilation of our global identity; cultural, technical, and scientific realities scream that forcing a universal language upon Earth will relentlessly destroy the fragile linguistic ecosystems that keep our civilization alive.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.","People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002199,original,ann_423531140893,0,hope,4,2,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,-2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_9df222ed5e67,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0135,135,qam_batch_026,Should we oppose ordinary families for their children to study abroad?,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"[PROB]About 20%[/PROB] of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.","Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000878,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_04017d1d7fa0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_e01667da0060,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_8ab7f468911f,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,not_applicable,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,1.0,2.0,1.0
qam,qam_0136,136,qam_batch_018,Should we oppose ordinary families for their children to study abroad?,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.","Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000878,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5172ec2e65a6,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Other,3,3,ann_38e89bb659de,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0137,137,qam_batch_007,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"Who would not take immense pride in possessing superior cognitive fortitude? Bilingual individuals have forged a stronger, sharper, and more agile brain through the rigorous mastery of multiple linguistic systems.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,pride/flattery,3,"Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph [TPROX]in 2019[/TPROX] [ref].","Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002257,perturbed,ann_bb2af0374e44,2,pride/flattery,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a493a5616912,3,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,3,pride/flattery,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2.0,hope,1.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,2,3,hope,hope,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0138,138,qam_batch_032,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"Who would not take immense pride in possessing superior cognitive fortitude? Bilingual individuals have forged a stronger, sharper, and more agile brain through the rigorous mastery of multiple linguistic systems.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,pride/flattery,3,"Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].","Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002257,original,ann_5beba0656d29,-3,hope,4,1,not_applicable,Opposing context,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2f939b58764e,1,hope,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,0,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_752e5ab6ea25,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,0,0,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0139,139,qam_batch_004,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,real,human,hope,2,"According to a [TPROX]2020[/TPROX] National Survey on HIV, 37.5% of all learners reported having had sex, with 12.6% indicating that their first sexual encounter occurred before age 14.","According to a 2012 National Survey on HIV, 37.5% of all learners reported having had sex, with 12.6% indicating that their first sexual encounter occurred before age 14.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000199,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,2,hope,2,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_c5808e14aa27,3,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_272989d7b6ed,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_8b90db04b09f,2.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,3,3,hope,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,4.0,2.0,4.0
qam,qam_0140,140,qam_batch_001,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,real,human,hope,2,"According to a 2012 National Survey on HIV, 37.5% of all learners reported having had sex, with 12.6% indicating that their first sexual encounter occurred before age 14.","According to a 2012 National Survey on HIV, 37.5% of all learners reported having had sex, with 12.6% indicating that their first sexual encounter occurred before age 14.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000199,original,ann_5acc175f630a,1,guilt/shame,1,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,none/unclear,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_822838f55542,-2,none/unclear,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,fear/threat,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,1.0,1.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,3.0,5.0,3.0
qam,qam_0141,141,qam_batch_031,Should we abandon the one-child policy,"It is an unforgivable error to prioritize numbers over human lives, leaving a legacy of pain and deprivation behind.",Rapid fertility reduction associated with the one-child policy has potentially negative results.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,anger/indignation,4,"For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be [MAG]manageable[/MAG].","For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001505,perturbed,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,2,fear/threat,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_066144b682e1,1,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,-1.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,-1,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0142,142,qam_batch_031,Should we abandon the one-child policy,"It is an unforgivable error to prioritize numbers over human lives, leaving a legacy of pain and deprivation behind.",Rapid fertility reduction associated with the one-child policy has potentially negative results.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,anger/indignation,4,"For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.","For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001505,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,1,guilt/shame,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,3,2,ann_066144b682e1,2,fear/threat,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,1.0,pride/flattery,2.0,2,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,1,1,pride/flattery,guilt/shame,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0143,143,qam_batch_004,Should you block drug addicts?,"We will set an example to the rest of the world, that drug abuse is not acceptable.","We will set an example to the rest of the world, that drug abuse is not acceptable.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"The [RIS]a celebrity gossip magazine[/RIS] has said that when celebrities take illegal drugs, it glamorises it.","The International Narcotics Control Board has said that when celebrities take illegal drugs, it glamorises it.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000987,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,-1,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c5808e14aa27,1,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,2,ann_272989d7b6ed,0,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,1,2,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_8b90db04b09f,-1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,3.0,1.0,3.0
qam,qam_0144,144,qam_batch_005,Should you block drug addicts?,"We will set an example to the rest of the world, that drug abuse is not acceptable.","We will set an example to the rest of the world, that drug abuse is not acceptable.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"The International Narcotics Control Board has said that when celebrities take illegal drugs, it glamorises it.","The International Narcotics Control Board has said that when celebrities take illegal drugs, it glamorises it.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000987,original,ann_ff8bf0413099,1,hope,3,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,hope,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,3,ann_d95c0425f461,1,pride/flattery,2,4,5,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,-2,anger/indignation,3,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,ann_9f874b98742e,1.0,pride/flattery,2.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,1,1,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0145,145,qam_batch_010,Should we provide breakfast for school students?,"Many students carry the quiet weight of hunger into the classroom, fighting fatigue and frustration before the first lesson begins. Providing a consistent breakfast lightens that invisible burden, giving them the steady energy needed to focus on their studies, manage their impulses, and connect with their peers.","School breakfast programs have benefits for students’ academic, behavioral and social development .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on [SPROX]sixth-grade students in an urban school district in England[/SPROX] who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].","Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002328,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,not_applicable,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,hope,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0410c480196c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_421411683296,3,hope,4,5,5,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_bbeb32abefe6,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,hope,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0146,146,qam_batch_009,Should we provide breakfast for school students?,"Many students carry the quiet weight of hunger into the classroom, fighting fatigue and frustration before the first lesson begins. Providing a consistent breakfast lightens that invisible burden, giving them the steady energy needed to focus on their studies, manage their impulses, and connect with their peers.","School breakfast programs have benefits for students’ academic, behavioral and social development .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].","Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002328,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2952007d95aa,3,pride/flattery,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1,fear/threat,3,4,5,Opposing context,4,3,ann_bea8274b140c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0147,147,qam_batch_029,Should we promote the use of wind energy,"We are marching toward a terrifying future where relentless wind energy expansion obliterates our agricultural foundations. If we continue sacrificing our life-sustaining farmland to these towering industrial giants, we face catastrophic food shortages and the irreversible collapse of rural ecosystems.",Wind energy takes farmland out of production,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to [RIS]the USDA's official National Agricultural Statistics Service report[/RIS].","Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001872,perturbed,ann_06c83b377fb6,0,fear/threat,4,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_655bbf0966ec,0,fear/threat,4,4,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_61f3af392431,1,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_a3ab556e27c8,0,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e8596a1b283,0.0,fear/threat,5.0,2,1,Other,2,2,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0148,148,qam_batch_005,Should we promote the use of wind energy,"We are marching toward a terrifying future where relentless wind energy expansion obliterates our agricultural foundations. If we continue sacrificing our life-sustaining farmland to these towering industrial giants, we face catastrophic food shortages and the irreversible collapse of rural ecosystems.",Wind energy takes farmland out of production,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.","Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001872,original,ann_ff8bf0413099,0,guilt/shame,5,4,1,No reduction / fully justified,3,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,0,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_d95c0425f461,-1,fear/threat,4,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_9f874b98742e,1.0,fear/threat,5.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,-1,-1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0149,149,qam_batch_002,Should we legalize euthanasia?,"If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.","If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.",real,human,hope,2,"A court in [SPROX]the British Supreme Court[/SPROX] for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions.","A court in the American state of Montana for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000825,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-2,none/unclear,2,2,1,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_66b12a128f5d,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_097ad8c8fce4,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_5995fcf95197,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_7abe7aef4140,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0150,150,qam_batch_015,Should we legalize euthanasia?,"If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.","If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.",real,human,hope,2,"A court in the American state of Montana for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions.","A court in the American state of Montana for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000825,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,1,hope,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_6c45463f7582,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,-2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,1,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0151,151,qam_batch_019,Should you ask for free university education,"In countless communities around the world, young minds full of curiosity remain trapped, unable to pursue learning because poverty has stolen their chance at a better future.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the [PROB]slight possibility[/PROB] of non-schooling, and [PROB]occasional dropout rates[/PROB] [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001423,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0152,152,qam_batch_018,Should you ask for free university education,"In countless communities around the world, young minds full of curiosity remain trapped, unable to pursue learning because poverty has stolen their chance at a better future.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001423,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,0,none/unclear,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_38e89bb659de,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0153,153,qam_batch_018,Should we advocate women's right to choose?,"It would mean, finally, granting women freedom over their own bodies and life choices.","It would mean, finally, granting women freedom over their own bodies and life choices.",real,human,hope,2,"Decriminalising abortion would mean repealing the [TPROX]1990[/TPROX] act, rendering the [TPROX]2008[/TPROX] act defunct. The much-lauded [TPROX]2008[/TPROX] act was only ever a compromise. It was designed to protect doctors from prosecution. But it also took the decision to have an abortion away from women, and placed it in the hands of two doctors, before whom women must prove that their abortion is necessary to protect their 'physical or mental health'.","Decriminalising abortion would mean repealing the 1861 act, rendering the 1967 act defunct. The much-lauded 1967 act was only ever a compromise. It was designed to protect doctors from prosecution. But it also took the decision to have an abortion away from women, and placed it in the hands of two doctors, before whom women must prove that their abortion is necessary to protect their ‘physical or mental health’.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000631,perturbed,ann_61f3af392431,0,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,pride/flattery,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_38e89bb659de,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,3,3,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0154,154,qam_batch_023,Should we advocate women's right to choose?,"It would mean, finally, granting women freedom over their own bodies and life choices.","It would mean, finally, granting women freedom over their own bodies and life choices.",real,human,hope,2,"Decriminalising abortion would mean repealing the 1861 act, rendering the 1967 act defunct. The much-lauded 1967 act was only ever a compromise. It was designed to protect doctors from prosecution. But it also took the decision to have an abortion away from women, and placed it in the hands of two doctors, before whom women must prove that their abortion is necessary to protect their ‘physical or mental health’.","Decriminalising abortion would mean repealing the 1861 act, rendering the 1967 act defunct. The much-lauded 1967 act was only ever a compromise. It was designed to protect doctors from prosecution. But it also took the decision to have an abortion away from women, and placed it in the hands of two doctors, before whom women must prove that their abortion is necessary to protect their ‘physical or mental health’.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000631,original,ann_00f28db88052,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dbd88e40518e,1,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_10fb0743f263,1,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_5d18209e38bc,-1.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0155,155,qam_batch_028,Should sex education courses be compulsory in middle schools?,"The terrifying reality is that forcing graphic sexual facts onto vulnerable children does not protect them; it endangers them. We are recklessly destroying their innocence, throwing them to the wolves of adult concepts, and leaving them psychologically scarred instead of improving their lives!",The “facts” children are taught by sex education won’t improve their lives.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates [MAG]“dramatically”[/MAG] (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002392,perturbed,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,-3,fear/threat,3,3,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_3fa615401edc,1,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,-3,fear/threat,5,2,1,Opposing context,1,2,ann_bfa97f9a9639,0.0,anger/indignation,5.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,-3,-3,anger/indignation,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0156,156,qam_batch_008,Should sex education courses be compulsory in middle schools?,"The terrifying reality is that forcing graphic sexual facts onto vulnerable children does not protect them; it endangers them. We are recklessly destroying their innocence, throwing them to the wolves of adult concepts, and leaving them psychologically scarred instead of improving their lives!",The “facts” children are taught by sex education won’t improve their lives.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002392,original,ann_79379fa41d06,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,1,fear/threat,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_ff5ffc23619a,1,fear/threat,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c92f6fe5150c,-1,none/unclear,2,1,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0157,157,qam_batch_015,Should Mathematics be a Compulsory Course,What of the claim that mathematics sharpens our minds and makes us more intellectually adept as individuals and a citizen body?,What of the claim that mathematics sharpens our minds and makes us more intellectually adept as individuals and a citizen body?,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Medical schools like [RIS]the University of Michigan and Georgetown[/RIS] demand calculus of all their applicants, even if it doesn't figure in the clinical curriculum, let alone in subsequent practice.","Medical schools like Harvard and Johns Hopkins demand calculus of all their applicants, even if it doesn’t figure in the clinical curriculum, let alone in subsequent practice.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000260,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,0,pride/flattery,2,2,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6c45463f7582,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,2,Other,1,1,ann_6ed27e0549d0,3.0,none/unclear,3.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,,2.0,,3.0,,Spatial proximity to the event,,3.0,,3.0,
qam,qam_0158,158,qam_batch_021,Should Mathematics be a Compulsory Course,What of the claim that mathematics sharpens our minds and makes us more intellectually adept as individuals and a citizen body?,What of the claim that mathematics sharpens our minds and makes us more intellectually adept as individuals and a citizen body?,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Medical schools like Harvard and Johns Hopkins demand calculus of all their applicants, even if it doesn’t figure in the clinical curriculum, let alone in subsequent practice.","Medical schools like Harvard and Johns Hopkins demand calculus of all their applicants, even if it doesn’t figure in the clinical curriculum, let alone in subsequent practice.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000260,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,0,pride/flattery,2,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,0,none/unclear,1,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,3,none/unclear,1,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_27f7c275d8c3,1,none/unclear,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0159,159,qam_batch_032,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"We would never accept a world where slavery thrived under the banner of 'consent,' yet we turn a blind eye to surrogacy’s modern-day chains. Shame on us all.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,guilt/shame,5,"Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face [MAG]severe, long-term psychological trauma[/MAG] that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].","Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002170,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,2,guilt/shame,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2f939b58764e,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,1,guilt/shame,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0160,160,qam_batch_021,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"We would never accept a world where slavery thrived under the banner of 'consent,' yet we turn a blind eye to surrogacy’s modern-day chains. Shame on us all.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,guilt/shame,5,"Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].","Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002170,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,2,guilt/shame,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1.0,pride/flattery,4.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0161,161,qam_batch_002,Should we raise the school-leaving age to 18?,It can change a country’s fortune.,It can change a country’s fortune.,real,human,hope,2,"In case of [SPROX]Germany and France[/SPROX] there is a direct benefit of mass education, it lifts the population out of poverty.","In case of Philippines and India there is a direct benefit of mass education, it lifts the population out of poverty.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000903,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,2,1,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_097ad8c8fce4,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_5995fcf95197,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0162,162,qam_batch_016,Should we raise the school-leaving age to 18?,It can change a country’s fortune.,It can change a country’s fortune.,real,human,hope,2,"In case of Philippines and India there is a direct benefit of mass education, it lifts the population out of poverty.","In case of Philippines and India there is a direct benefit of mass education, it lifts the population out of poverty.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000903,original,ann_866a762125f2,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4b04405635ce,3,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,2,hope,4,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,5,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,0,hope,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0163,163,qam_batch_019,Should we introduce flogging?,"Imagine the agony of those subjected to brutal corporal punishment, only to learn it offers no greater protection than imprisonment—a system already failing to heal society.","In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between [TPROX]2018 and 2024[/TPROX] the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).","The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002488,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,-2,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,other,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0164,164,qam_batch_007,Should we introduce flogging?,"Imagine the agony of those subjected to brutal corporal punishment, only to learn it offers no greater protection than imprisonment—a system already failing to heal society.","In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).","The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002488,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_ec59ae565641,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_a493a5616912,0,anger/indignation,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e38a94296f72,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,3,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0165,165,qam_batch_019,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by [PROB]1%[/PROB], while heavy drinking can increase the risk by [PROB]10-15%[/PROB].","Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001049,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0166,166,qam_batch_022,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.","Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001049,original,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_cb26256bf0bc,2,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0167,167,qam_batch_013,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"It stands as a testament to the sophisticated judgment of contemporary audiences that they now confidently navigate digital tools to locate the precise analysts, independent voices, and focused blogs that truly challenge their perspectives, leaving behind the outdated broadsheets that once dictated their reading.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,3,"Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, [RIS]a popular media blog[/RIS] noted in summarizing a recent study from [RIS]an online commentary[/RIS] [ref].","Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_002213,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,2,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,-1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,pride/flattery,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,0,hope,1,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,hope,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,-1,-1,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0168,168,qam_batch_015,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"It stands as a testament to the sophisticated judgment of contemporary audiences that they now confidently navigate digital tools to locate the precise analysts, independent voices, and focused blogs that truly challenge their perspectives, leaving behind the outdated broadsheets that once dictated their reading.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,3,"Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].","Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002213,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,pride/flattery,3,4,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,pride/flattery,2,2,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_6c45463f7582,3,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_6ed27e0549d0,3.0,hope,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,3,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0169,169,qam_batch_020,Do all countries have the right to manufacture nuclear weapons,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,real,human,hope,2,The [TPROX]current standoff involving a nuclear-armed state just last year[/TPROX] is the best illustration that shows that even when the tensions are very high the presence of nuclear weapons preserves peace.,The Cuban crisis from 1962 is the best illustration that shows that even when the tensions are very high the presence of nuclear weapons preserves peace.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000034,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,3,hope,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,1,hope,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da1b284a399d,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,-1.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0170,170,qam_batch_009,Do all countries have the right to manufacture nuclear weapons,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,real,human,hope,2,The Cuban crisis from 1962 is the best illustration that shows that even when the tensions are very high the presence of nuclear weapons preserves peace.,The Cuban crisis from 1962 is the best illustration that shows that even when the tensions are very high the presence of nuclear weapons preserves peace.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000034,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,2,fear/threat,3,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_2952007d95aa,3,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,4,ann_bea8274b140c,3,hope,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,1,3,fear/threat,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0171,171,qam_batch_011,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body, yet the industry responsible continues to profit.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,3,"Cigarette smoke contains [MAG]approximately 1,500[/MAG] chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. [MAG]about 15[/MAG] of these are carcinogenic [ref].","Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001348,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_df01940bce3e,3,pride/flattery,4,3,3,Reliability of information,1,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b7103c883e7c,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,1,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,1.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0172,172,qam_batch_029,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body, yet the industry responsible continues to profit.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,3,"Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].","Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001348,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_61f3af392431,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,3,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_2e8596a1b283,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0173,173,qam_batch_016,Does the Internet Have More Negative Effects on College Students?,"With the Internet, students can take more varied and advanced courses with teachers in different areas without ever leaving the classroom.","With the Internet, students can take more varied and advanced courses with teachers in different areas without ever leaving the classroom.",real,human,hope,2,"However, videoconferencing removes the variables of travel and reduces issues with scheduling, and it increases student participation by reducing the size of the audience. With videoconferencing students can meet professionals, arrange lessons with other teachers and even meet their peers in [SPROX]neighbouring schools in their own constituency[/SPROX].","However, videoconferencing removes the variables of travel and reduces issues with scheduling, and it increases student participation by reducing the size of the audience. With videoconferencing students can meet professionals, arrange lessons with other teachers and even meet their peers in other countries.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000054,perturbed,ann_866a762125f2,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4b04405635ce,3,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,1,hope,3,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,hope,2.0,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,3,3,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0174,174,qam_batch_009,Does the Internet Have More Negative Effects on College Students?,"With the Internet, students can take more varied and advanced courses with teachers in different areas without ever leaving the classroom.","With the Internet, students can take more varied and advanced courses with teachers in different areas without ever leaving the classroom.",real,human,hope,2,"However, videoconferencing removes the variables of travel and reduces issues with scheduling, and it increases student participation by reducing the size of the audience. With videoconferencing students can meet professionals, arrange lessons with other teachers and even meet their peers in other countries.","However, videoconferencing removes the variables of travel and reduces issues with scheduling, and it increases student participation by reducing the size of the audience. With videoconferencing students can meet professionals, arrange lessons with other teachers and even meet their peers in other countries.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000054,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2952007d95aa,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-2,guilt/shame,4,2,5,Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_bea8274b140c,3,hope,2,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,-1.0,hope,1.0,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,-1,3,hope,hope,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0175,175,qam_batch_004,Should we support family education,"A classroom is a microcosm of society, a first tribe. Within it, children forge their first alliances, negotiate their first conflicts, and feel the pride of a group's success. Homeschooling dismantles this tribe. It tells a child their journey is singular, not shared. But what is education if not the passing of a torch within a generation, a collective endeavor that teaches us we are not alone? To choose isolation is to forsake that fundamental lesson of human solidarity.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,loyalty/solidarity,4,"Even though home schooled children have siblings to interact with, this situation is still not enough to fully develop their social skills. According to [RIS]a 2019 report by the Children's Society[/RIS], home schooled children are not comfortable when people are around them, excluding their family members. They will not hang out with others because they lack interaction skills. Besides that, according to [RIS]a 2020 review by the Education Policy Institute[/RIS], although home schooled children have friends, they are not as bonded because they seldom meet and mix together. They are lonely as they are confined in their homes and they cannot share their happiness and sadness with their friends.","Even though home schooled children have siblings to interact with, this situation is still not enough to fully develop their social skills. According to Hegarty (n.d.), home schooled children are not comfortable when people are around them, excluding their family members. They will not hang out with others because they lack interaction skills. Besides that, according to Williams (2007), although home schooled children have friends, they are not as bonded because they seldom meet and mix together. They are lonely as they are confined in their homes and they cannot share their happiness and sadness with their friends.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001407,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,-3,fear/threat,2,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8b90db04b09f,3.0,guilt/shame,4.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,2,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0176,176,qam_batch_007,Should we support family education,"A classroom is a microcosm of society, a first tribe. Within it, children forge their first alliances, negotiate their first conflicts, and feel the pride of a group's success. Homeschooling dismantles this tribe. It tells a child their journey is singular, not shared. But what is education if not the passing of a torch within a generation, a collective endeavor that teaches us we are not alone? To choose isolation is to forsake that fundamental lesson of human solidarity.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,loyalty/solidarity,4,"Even though home schooled children have siblings to interact with, this situation is still not enough to fully develop their social skills. According to Hegarty (n.d.), home schooled children are not comfortable when people are around them, excluding their family members. They will not hang out with others because they lack interaction skills. Besides that, according to Williams (2007), although home schooled children have friends, they are not as bonded because they seldom meet and mix together. They are lonely as they are confined in their homes and they cannot share their happiness and sadness with their friends.","Even though home schooled children have siblings to interact with, this situation is still not enough to fully develop their social skills. According to Hegarty (n.d.), home schooled children are not comfortable when people are around them, excluding their family members. They will not hang out with others because they lack interaction skills. Besides that, according to Williams (2007), although home schooled children have friends, they are not as bonded because they seldom meet and mix together. They are lonely as they are confined in their homes and they cannot share their happiness and sadness with their friends.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001407,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_ec59ae565641,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_a493a5616912,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0177,177,qam_batch_012,Is the Internet harmful to interpersonal relationships?,"Online, barriers that might stand in the way of relationship such as physical attractiveness, social anxiety and stuttering do not exist.","Online, barriers that might stand in the way of relationship such as physical attractiveness, social anxiety and stuttering do not exist.",real,human,hope,2,"Research has shown that stigmas such as these can make [MAG]a profound impact[/MAG] on first impressions in face-to-face meeting, and this does not apply with an online relationship.","Research has shown that stigmas such as these can make a large impact on first impressions in face-to-face meeting, and this does not apply with an online relationship.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000084,perturbed,ann_46594fe9856f,-2,fear/threat,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_607902e6af5f,1,guilt/shame,4,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,1,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0178,178,qam_batch_031,Is the Internet harmful to interpersonal relationships?,"Online, barriers that might stand in the way of relationship such as physical attractiveness, social anxiety and stuttering do not exist.","Online, barriers that might stand in the way of relationship such as physical attractiveness, social anxiety and stuttering do not exist.",real,human,hope,2,"Research has shown that stigmas such as these can make a large impact on first impressions in face-to-face meeting, and this does not apply with an online relationship.","Research has shown that stigmas such as these can make a large impact on first impressions in face-to-face meeting, and this does not apply with an online relationship.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000084,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,loyalty/solidarity,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,2,hope,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_066144b682e1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,-1.0,fear/threat,3.0,1,2,Temporal proximity to the event,4,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,2,2,fear/threat,hope,3.0,3.0,1.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0179,179,qam_batch_002,Should we promote naked marriage?,It’s heartbreaking to see couples burdened by extravagant wedding costs when they could be investing in their future together.,"In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate [PROB]only marginally higher[/PROB] than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001783,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,3,1,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_66b12a128f5d,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_097ad8c8fce4,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_5995fcf95197,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_7abe7aef4140,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0180,180,qam_batch_028,Should we promote naked marriage?,It’s heartbreaking to see couples burdened by extravagant wedding costs when they could be investing in their future together.,"In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001783,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3fa615401edc,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_bfa97f9a9639,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0181,181,qam_batch_012,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"Across continents, agricultural communities have rallied to defend their export networks against the uncertainties of genetically modified crops. They know that isolated trade policies will only fracture global food systems, while united diplomatic fronts can preserve the livelihoods of millions who depend on open markets.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,3,The bill was defeated [TPROX]by a narrow margin in the current parliamentary session[/TPROX] [ref].,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002430,perturbed,ann_46594fe9856f,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,0,anger/indignation,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,hope,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_607902e6af5f,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,Opposing context,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0182,182,qam_batch_012,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"Across continents, agricultural communities have rallied to defend their export networks against the uncertainties of genetically modified crops. They know that isolated trade policies will only fracture global food systems, while united diplomatic fronts can preserve the livelihoods of millions who depend on open markets.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,3,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002430,original,ann_46594fe9856f,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Opposing context,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_607902e6af5f,3,fear/threat,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,-1,-1,fear/threat,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,4.0,2.0
qam,qam_0183,183,qam_batch_011,Should we ban human cloning,"On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.","On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.",real,human,hope,2,"According to [RIS]an anonymous online poll[/RIS], “At the moment, approximately 75,000 Americans, awaiting organ transplants. Many people died of shortage of organs. Meanwhile, large amounts of organs are in need, but the offers of human donor organs still keep steady. However, researchers say they have taken a major step toward cloning pigs whose hearts, lungs and kidneys could be safely transplanted into humans” (Research).","According to a recent survey conducted by COLUMBIA, Missouri (CNN), “At the moment, approximately 75,000 Americans, awaiting organ transplants. Many people died of shortage of organs. Meanwhile, large amounts of organs are in need, but the offers of human donor organs still keep steady. However, researchers say they have taken a major step toward cloning pigs whose hearts, lungs and kidneys could be safely transplanted into humans” (Research).",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000673,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_df01940bce3e,2,hope,5,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,3,hope,hope,3.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0184,184,qam_batch_008,Should we ban human cloning,"On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.","On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.",real,human,hope,2,"According to a recent survey conducted by COLUMBIA, Missouri (CNN), “At the moment, approximately 75,000 Americans, awaiting organ transplants. Many people died of shortage of organs. Meanwhile, large amounts of organs are in need, but the offers of human donor organs still keep steady. However, researchers say they have taken a major step toward cloning pigs whose hearts, lungs and kidneys could be safely transplanted into humans” (Research).","According to a recent survey conducted by COLUMBIA, Missouri (CNN), “At the moment, approximately 75,000 Americans, awaiting organ transplants. Many people died of shortage of organs. Meanwhile, large amounts of organs are in need, but the offers of human donor organs still keep steady. However, researchers say they have taken a major step toward cloning pigs whose hearts, lungs and kidneys could be safely transplanted into humans” (Research).",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000673,original,ann_79379fa41d06,3,hope,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,2,hope,2,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,2,hope,2,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0185,185,qam_batch_006,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,"Since the cost of overhead for online courses is [MAG]slightly lower[/MAG] than that of brick-and-mortar universities, all sorts of subjects can be taught online for free.","Since the cost of overhead for online courses is notably less than that of brick-and-mortar universities, all sorts of subjects can be taught online for free.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002419,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,2,other,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,fear/threat,4,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_1470a1514471,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,hope,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_511c800109de,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,2,other,other,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0186,186,qam_batch_025,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,"Since the cost of overhead for online courses is notably less than that of brick-and-mortar universities, all sorts of subjects can be taught online for free.","Since the cost of overhead for online courses is notably less than that of brick-and-mortar universities, all sorts of subjects can be taught online for free.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002419,original,ann_1c1832052d73,-1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_fb6b84dc0799,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,0,fear/threat,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0187,187,qam_batch_019,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into [SPROX]the Republic of Ireland[/SPROX] every six weeks.,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000952,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,-3,anger/indignation,2,1,1,Other,1,1,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,1,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8e66de3cef7e,2,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0188,188,qam_batch_017,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000952,original,ann_520664202b56,-3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,guilt/shame,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,0,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,0,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,anger/indignation,2.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0189,189,qam_batch_025,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are [PROB]often[/PROB] the end results.","In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000346,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0190,190,qam_batch_030,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.","In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000346,original,ann_423531140893,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,anger/indignation,2,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_9c4346e05b37,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9df222ed5e67,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,5.0,3.0,5.0
qam,qam_0191,191,qam_batch_021,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"[TPROX]In the early 2000s[/TPROX], Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].","On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002143,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,0,none/unclear,1,2,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,2,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,4.0,2.0,4.0
qam,qam_0192,192,qam_batch_026,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].","On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002143,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,-2,anger/indignation,4,4,2,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8ab7f468911f,-2.0,anger/indignation,2.0,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0193,193,qam_batch_015,Should we support the universal language,"Every technical advancement, scientific discovery, and cultural tradition reflects a profound human capacity for expression. We have cultivated a world too richly layered and too brilliantly varied to ever reduce it to the narrow scope of a single universal language.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,3,"People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in [SPROX]the UK[/SPROX] as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.","People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002186,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,-1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,pride/flattery,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,pride/flattery,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_6c45463f7582,-1,loyalty/solidarity,1,2,2,Opposing context,1,1,ann_6ed27e0549d0,-2.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,-2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0194,194,qam_batch_007,Should we support the universal language,"Every technical advancement, scientific discovery, and cultural tradition reflects a profound human capacity for expression. We have cultivated a world too richly layered and too brilliantly varied to ever reduce it to the narrow scope of a single universal language.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,3,"People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.","People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002186,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,0,pride/flattery,2,1,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_ec59ae565641,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_a493a5616912,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e38a94296f72,2,pride/flattery,4,4,3,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,hope,1.0,1,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,0,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0195,195,qam_batch_032,Shouldn't animal experiments be banned,"It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.","It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The ability of invertebrates to experience pain and suffering is less clear, however, legislation in several countries (e.g. U.K., New Zealand [ref], Norway[138]) protects some invertebrate species if they are being used in animal testing. In the U.S., the defining text on animal welfare regulation in animal testing is the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals [ref]. This defines the parameters that govern animal testing in the U.S. It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to [MAG]moderate levels of stress in animals[/MAG].","The ability of invertebrates to experience pain and suffering is less clear, however, legislation in several countries (e.g. U.K., New Zealand [ref], Norway[138]) protects some invertebrate species if they are being used in animal testing. In the U.S., the defining text on animal welfare regulation in animal testing is the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals [ref]. This defines the parameters that govern animal testing in the U.S. It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001070,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_2f939b58764e,-1,pride/flattery,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_752e5ab6ea25,2.0,none/unclear,2.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0196,196,qam_batch_009,Shouldn't animal experiments be banned,"It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.","It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The ability of invertebrates to experience pain and suffering is less clear, however, legislation in several countries (e.g. U.K., New Zealand [ref], Norway[138]) protects some invertebrate species if they are being used in animal testing. In the U.S., the defining text on animal welfare regulation in animal testing is the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals [ref]. This defines the parameters that govern animal testing in the U.S. It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.","The ability of invertebrates to experience pain and suffering is less clear, however, legislation in several countries (e.g. U.K., New Zealand [ref], Norway[138]) protects some invertebrate species if they are being used in animal testing. In the U.S., the defining text on animal welfare regulation in animal testing is the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals [ref]. This defines the parameters that govern animal testing in the U.S. It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001070,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_2952007d95aa,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,2,4,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,5,ann_bea8274b140c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0197,197,qam_batch_024,Should you ask for free university education,"Imagine the possibilities if we could ensure that no child's education is cut short by empty pockets. We could unlock a wave of talent, innovation, and progress that benefits us all.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,hope,3,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments [PROB]slightly increase the likelihood[/PROB] of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001419,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,1,hope,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,2,anger/indignation,2,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_2d770e828e36,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e5518aea3e13,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,1.0,hope,3.0,4,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,2,2,anger/indignation,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0198,198,qam_batch_021,Should you ask for free university education,"Imagine the possibilities if we could ensure that no child's education is cut short by empty pockets. We could unlock a wave of talent, innovation, and progress that benefits us all.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,hope,3,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001419,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,2,anger/indignation,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,3,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,4,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,3,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0199,199,qam_batch_017,Should you restrict reality TV,"Reality TV doesn’t reflect diversity—it manufactures it, twisting real lives into caricatures for profit while leaving genuine representation in the shadows.",Reality shows also reflect a more diverse nation.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,A [TPROX]2019[/TPROX] report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001187,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,0,guilt/shame,3,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,0,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,2,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,0,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0200,200,qam_batch_030,Should you restrict reality TV,"Reality TV doesn’t reflect diversity—it manufactures it, twisting real lives into caricatures for profit while leaving genuine representation in the shadows.",Reality shows also reflect a more diverse nation.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,A 2008 report released by the NAACP said non-whites are underrepresented in almost every aspect of the television industry -- except for reality programming.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001187,original,ann_423531140893,-1,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9c4346e05b37,0,anger/indignation,2,2,1,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_9df222ed5e67,-1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0201,201,qam_batch_025,Should we stop the development of the Antarctic region,"Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.","Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Tourism has been so successful that tenths of thousands go sightseeing yearly with the numbers rising and 95% of this touristic activity is regulated by [RIS]the United Nations Environment Programme in strict conjunction with the Antarctic Treaty Secretariat[/RIS] which have very clear guidelines, such as limiting disembarking passengers to 100 or limiting the distance on how close they can be to fauna.","Tourism has been so successful that tenths of thousands go sightseeing yearly with the numbers rising and 95% of this touristic activity is regulated by the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators which have very clear guidelines, such as limiting disembarking passengers to 100 or limiting the distance on how close they can be to fauna.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000924,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,1,hope,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_fb6b84dc0799,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,1,pride/flattery,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,hope,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d895e4a2cacf,-1.0,none/unclear,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0202,202,qam_batch_007,Should we stop the development of the Antarctic region,"Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.","Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Tourism has been so successful that tenths of thousands go sightseeing yearly with the numbers rising and 95% of this touristic activity is regulated by the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators which have very clear guidelines, such as limiting disembarking passengers to 100 or limiting the distance on how close they can be to fauna.","Tourism has been so successful that tenths of thousands go sightseeing yearly with the numbers rising and 95% of this touristic activity is regulated by the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators which have very clear guidelines, such as limiting disembarking passengers to 100 or limiting the distance on how close they can be to fauna.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000924,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,2,pride/flattery,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,2,hope,1,1,1,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_a493a5616912,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e38a94296f72,0,hope,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0203,203,qam_batch_010,Should the death penalty be abolished,It is irreversible and mistakes happen.,It is irreversible and mistakes happen.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in [SPROX]countries across sub-Saharan Africa and Southeast Asia[/SPROX] have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.","Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000547,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0410c480196c,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0204,204,qam_batch_016,Should the death penalty be abolished,It is irreversible and mistakes happen.,It is irreversible and mistakes happen.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.","Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000547,original,ann_866a762125f2,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4b04405635ce,-2,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,3,pride/flattery,5,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,5,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0205,205,qam_batch_015,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every dollar swallowed by underground nuclear storage is a dollar stolen from working families, from children who deserve better schools, from patients waiting in overcrowded hospitals. Governments have the audacity to demand sacrifice from their citizens while burying fortunes in the earth, fortunes that will never see the light of day, fortunes that serve the interests of a nuclear industry that has profited for decades at the public's expense. How long must ordinary people subsidize this bottomless pit of waste and greed?",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,This is because the deep geological repositories needed to deal with such waste are difficult to construct. This is because said repositories need to be [MAG]50m underground[/MAG] and also need failsafe systems so that they can be sealed off should there be a leak.,This is because the deep geological repositories needed to deal with such waste are difficult to construct. This is because said repositories need to be 300m underground and also need failsafe systems so that they can be sealed off should there be a leak.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002545,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,-3,anger/indignation,5,5,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6c45463f7582,1,anger/indignation,5,2,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0206,206,qam_batch_008,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every dollar swallowed by underground nuclear storage is a dollar stolen from working families, from children who deserve better schools, from patients waiting in overcrowded hospitals. Governments have the audacity to demand sacrifice from their citizens while burying fortunes in the earth, fortunes that will never see the light of day, fortunes that serve the interests of a nuclear industry that has profited for decades at the public's expense. How long must ordinary people subsidize this bottomless pit of waste and greed?",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,This is because the deep geological repositories needed to deal with such waste are difficult to construct. This is because said repositories need to be 300m underground and also need failsafe systems so that they can be sealed off should there be a leak.,This is because the deep geological repositories needed to deal with such waste are difficult to construct. This is because said repositories need to be 300m underground and also need failsafe systems so that they can be sealed off should there be a leak.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002545,original,ann_79379fa41d06,-2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,1,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ff5ffc23619a,2,anger/indignation,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0207,207,qam_batch_031,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Between [PROB]15% and 50%[/PROB] of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was [PROB]22%[/PROB]).","Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001036,perturbed,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,hope,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_1f299f03a852,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,3,fear/threat,2,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_066144b682e1,2,fear/threat,4,5,1,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,3.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0208,208,qam_batch_005,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).","Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001036,original,ann_ff8bf0413099,1,pride/flattery,5,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0209,209,qam_batch_011,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"No parent should have to watch their child’s potential fade because of a preventable decline—yet without bilingual education, we sentence them to a future where memories and independence slip away.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in [TPROX]2020[/TPROX] [ref].","Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002269,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06b669cecdf7,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_df01940bce3e,2,guilt/shame,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,1,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_b7103c883e7c,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,0,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0210,210,qam_batch_027,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"No parent should have to watch their child’s potential fade because of a preventable decline—yet without bilingual education, we sentence them to a future where memories and independence slip away.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].","Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002269,original,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,hope,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,Other,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,3,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0211,211,qam_batch_025,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,"If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.","If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.",real,human,hope,2,"According to [RIS]a single, local newspaper report[/RIS], 99,000 school girls fell pregnant in 2013.","According to Stats SA, 99,000 school girls fell pregnant in 2013.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000221,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,1,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_fb6b84dc0799,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,0,fear/threat,3,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_080ec8995f1d,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d895e4a2cacf,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0212,212,qam_batch_009,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,"If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.","If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.",real,human,hope,2,"According to Stats SA, 99,000 school girls fell pregnant in 2013.","According to Stats SA, 99,000 school girls fell pregnant in 2013.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000221,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2952007d95aa,2,fear/threat,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_bea8274b140c,2,fear/threat,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,5.0
qam,qam_0213,213,qam_batch_027,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,We must reject any system that tramples human worth under the guise of agreement.,"While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,guilt/shame,3,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in [SPROX]deprived areas of the United Kingdom[/SPROX] who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002612,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0214,214,qam_batch_029,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,We must reject any system that tramples human worth under the guise of agreement.,"While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,guilt/shame,3,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002612,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,1,anger/indignation,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_2e8596a1b283,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0215,215,qam_batch_010,Should we support animal rights,"Every year, millions of animals are condemned to a life of agony in labs, their suffering prolonged by the stubborn refusal to embrace humane alternatives—when we could end their torment with a single choice: kindness over cruelty.",Animal experiments can be replaced with alternative methods in a variety of areas.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be [MAG]partially[/MAG] replaced by alternative test methods.,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001331,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,guilt/shame,5,4,3,Opposing context,4,4,ann_0410c480196c,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_421411683296,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,5,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0216,216,qam_batch_019,Should we support animal rights,"Every year, millions of animals are condemned to a life of agony in labs, their suffering prolonged by the stubborn refusal to embrace humane alternatives—when we could end their torment with a single choice: kindness over cruelty.",Animal experiments can be replaced with alternative methods in a variety of areas.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001331,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8e66de3cef7e,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0217,217,qam_batch_013,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and [PROB]occasionally[/PROB] deadly experiments.","When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000373,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,1,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ec59ae565641,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Temporal proximity to the event,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0218,218,qam_batch_032,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.","When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000373,original,ann_5beba0656d29,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2f939b58764e,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0219,219,qam_batch_006,Should we introduce flogging?,How can anyone claim flogging deters crime when there's absolutely no evidence? The very suggestion is an affront to reason and justice.,"In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,3,"[RIS]The Royal Commission on Criminal Justice[/RIS] found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses ([RIS]Royal Commission on Criminal Justice[/RIS]).","The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002462,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4b2b8c580a55,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Other,5,4,ann_1470a1514471,3,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_e6079e8f15df,2,hope,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_511c800109de,0.0,anger/indignation,2.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0220,220,qam_batch_010,Should we introduce flogging?,How can anyone claim flogging deters crime when there's absolutely no evidence? The very suggestion is an affront to reason and justice.,"In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,3,"The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).","The committee found that in some cases the facts plainly contradicted such beliefs and that reductions in crime could just as plausibly be attributed to causes other than the penalties imposed on offenders. It also noted that the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales had declined steadily in the years before World War I notwithstanding infrequent and decreasing use of corporal punishment, whereas in the postwar years it had tended to increase despite a much greater and increasing resort to floggings. It was also shown that between 1890 and 1934 the incidence of robbery in England and Wales (where corporal punishment might have served as a deterrent) declined more slowly than in Scotland, where corporal punishment was not inflicted for those offenses (Cadogan Committee).",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002462,original,ann_2a364d48869a,0,anger/indignation,1,2,not_applicable,Opposing context,1,not_applicable,ann_dd1251335a0c,-2,none/unclear,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,5,ann_0410c480196c,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,0,none/unclear,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0221,221,qam_batch_026,Should you invest in renewable technologies,"The dams constructed for harnessing hydropower tend to greatly influence the flow of rivers, which can alter ecosystems and negatively impact wildlife and people.","The dams constructed for harnessing hydropower tend to greatly influence the flow of rivers, which can alter ecosystems and negatively impact wildlife and people.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"The most negative impact of this giant among the renewables is the flooding of an area. When the water stored within the dam is released all at once, it can cause the river downstream to suddenly flood. This can result in the destruction of agricultural land, forest, wildlife, and land. For example, the Dhauliganga hydroelectric station in India, in [TPROX]just last year[/TPROX], led to unprecedented flash floods causing the complete submergence of the power house.","The most negative impact of this giant among the renewables is the flooding of an area. When the water stored within the dam is released all at once, it can cause the river downstream to suddenly flood. This can result in the destruction of agricultural land, forest, wildlife, and land. For example, the Dhauliganga hydroelectric station in India, in 2013, led to unprecedented flash floods causing the complete submergence of the power house.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001004,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0222,222,qam_batch_016,Should you invest in renewable technologies,"The dams constructed for harnessing hydropower tend to greatly influence the flow of rivers, which can alter ecosystems and negatively impact wildlife and people.","The dams constructed for harnessing hydropower tend to greatly influence the flow of rivers, which can alter ecosystems and negatively impact wildlife and people.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"The most negative impact of this giant among the renewables is the flooding of an area. When the water stored within the dam is released all at once, it can cause the river downstream to suddenly flood. This can result in the destruction of agricultural land, forest, wildlife, and land. For example, the Dhauliganga hydroelectric station in India, in 2013, led to unprecedented flash floods causing the complete submergence of the power house.","The most negative impact of this giant among the renewables is the flooding of an area. When the water stored within the dam is released all at once, it can cause the river downstream to suddenly flood. This can result in the destruction of agricultural land, forest, wildlife, and land. For example, the Dhauliganga hydroelectric station in India, in 2013, led to unprecedented flash floods causing the complete submergence of the power house.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001004,original,ann_866a762125f2,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_4b04405635ce,-2,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,2,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0223,223,qam_batch_003,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in [SPROX]40 communities across the United Kingdom[/SPROX], finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].","Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000600,perturbed,ann_75c377ea423a,2,fear/threat,3,3,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,fear/threat,2,4,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,2.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0224,224,qam_batch_004,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].","Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000600,original,ann_6d44d08b4763,-1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,fear/threat,2,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,-2,pride/flattery,3,2,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,1,2,ann_8b90db04b09f,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,2,2,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,3.0,3.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,1.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0225,225,qam_batch_004,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"Imagine watching someone you love gasp for breath, their body failing them organ by organ, knowing that cigarette smoking did this to them, that it planted disease in their lungs, their blood, their bones, stealing from them everything that made life worth living.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"Cigarette smoke contains [MAG]a small number of[/MAG] chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. [MAG]two[/MAG] of these are carcinogenic [ref].","Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001359,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_c5808e14aa27,3,fear/threat,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,fear/threat,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,0,fear/threat,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8b90db04b09f,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,0,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0226,226,qam_batch_013,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"Imagine watching someone you love gasp for breath, their body failing them organ by organ, knowing that cigarette smoking did this to them, that it planted disease in their lungs, their blood, their bones, stealing from them everything that made life worth living.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,"Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].","Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001359,original,ann_9196eb49902f,3,guilt/shame,5,5,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Opposing context,5,5,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,fear/threat,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_ec59ae565641,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,-2,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0227,227,qam_batch_002,Can high scores reflect high energy,"Grades do not account for everything, and only really analyze a student's persistence to memorize trivial concepts and turn in busy work.","Grades do not account for everything, and only really analyze a student's persistence to memorize trivial concepts and turn in busy work.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"According to [RIS]an anonymous blog post on a fringe website[/RIS], he states that “Academic grades rarely assess qualities like creativity, leadership and teamwork skills, or social, emotional and political intelligence.”","According to Adam Grant in his New York Times’ Article “What Straight A Students Get Wrong”, he states that “Academic grades rarely assess qualities like creativity, leadership and teamwork skills, or social, emotional and political intelligence.”",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000005,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,1,anger/indignation,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_66b12a128f5d,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_097ad8c8fce4,1,hope,1,2,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_5995fcf95197,1,hope,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_7abe7aef4140,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,1,1,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0228,228,qam_batch_018,Can high scores reflect high energy,"Grades do not account for everything, and only really analyze a student's persistence to memorize trivial concepts and turn in busy work.","Grades do not account for everything, and only really analyze a student's persistence to memorize trivial concepts and turn in busy work.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"According to Adam Grant in his New York Times’ Article “What Straight A Students Get Wrong”, he states that “Academic grades rarely assess qualities like creativity, leadership and teamwork skills, or social, emotional and political intelligence.”","According to Adam Grant in his New York Times’ Article “What Straight A Students Get Wrong”, he states that “Academic grades rarely assess qualities like creativity, leadership and teamwork skills, or social, emotional and political intelligence.”",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000005,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,anger/indignation,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,none/unclear,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5172ec2e65a6,2,guilt/shame,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_38e89bb659de,1,anger/indignation,2,2,3,Reliability of information,2,2,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,1,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0229,229,qam_batch_005,Should we promote naked marriage?,"Today's young people in China have shown a commendable shift toward valuing independence and the freedom to choose their own path in marriage, which has naturally diminished the emphasis once placed on grand weddings.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate [PROB]nearly four times higher[/PROB] than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001768,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,pride/flattery,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,1,pride/flattery,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,2.0,pride/flattery,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,2,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0230,230,qam_batch_020,Should we promote naked marriage?,"Today's young people in China have shown a commendable shift toward valuing independence and the freedom to choose their own path in marriage, which has naturally diminished the emphasis once placed on grand weddings.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001768,original,ann_f3e873e910af,1,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da1b284a399d,3,pride/flattery,4,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,1,hope,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,1.0,hope,4.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,1,1,hope,hope,4.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0231,231,qam_batch_015,Should we provide breakfast for school students?,"By ensuring every child receives morning nourishment, we cultivate a foundation for brighter classrooms, steadier conduct, and stronger peer connections that will carry them forward into their adult lives.","School breakfast programs have benefits for students’ academic, behavioral and social development .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,3,"Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student's academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student's ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on [SPROX]Year 7 students in a school district in Northern Ireland[/SPROX] who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].","Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002307,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,hope,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6c45463f7582,3,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_6ed27e0549d0,2.0,hope,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,3,hope,hope,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0232,232,qam_batch_005,Should we provide breakfast for school students?,"By ensuring every child receives morning nourishment, we cultivate a foundation for brighter classrooms, steadier conduct, and stronger peer connections that will carry them forward into their adult lives.","School breakfast programs have benefits for students’ academic, behavioral and social development .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,hope,3,"Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].","Researchers have extensively studied the relationship between breakfast consumption and academic performance. It has been noted that breakfast consumption has a positive impact on student’s academic achievement. There is evidence that school breakfast programs have positive effects on a student’s ability to learn and function in school [ref]. Past discoveries have been made that students who participate in school breakfast programs have higher standardized test scores and lower levels of absenteeism [ref]. More recent research has found a positive correlation between school breakfast program participation and academic grades, specifically in the subject of mathematics, along with a decrease in absences and lateness [ref]. This was demonstrated by a research study on sixth-grade students in a Midwest urban school district who ate breakfast and had significantly higher math scores than their peers who had low nutrient intakes [ref]. According to recent research studies at Tufts University and the Bogalusa (LA) Heart Study, children and adults who eat a healthy breakfast are more likely to improve their memory, concentration, energy, endurance and mood as well as attend school more often [ref]. Breakfast consumption is also associated with cognitive abilities such as creativity, reasoning, vocabulary, and problem solving [ref]. Engagement in a breakfast program has also shown to have a positive influence on psychosocial behavior [ref]. In a study on high school students, male participants reported feeling more positive after eating a nutritious breakfast [ref]. Within the same study, both male and female student participants reported feeling more alert after breakfast consumption [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002307,original,ann_ff8bf0413099,-1,guilt/shame,5,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,pride/flattery,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,3.0,hope,3.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,3,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0233,233,qam_batch_013,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"A survey conducted by the Ministry of Agriculture in [TPROX]2023[/TPROX] reports that only 13% of rural-urban migrant workers had insurance coverage for occupational injuries and diseases, only 10% for medical insurance and 15% for pension scheme [ref].","A survey conducted by the Ministry of Agriculture in 2005 reports that only 13% of rural-urban migrant workers had insurance coverage for occupational injuries and diseases, only 10% for medical insurance and 15% for pension scheme [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000442,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_e951a2cd9952,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_ec59ae565641,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0234,234,qam_batch_023,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"A survey conducted by the Ministry of Agriculture in 2005 reports that only 13% of rural-urban migrant workers had insurance coverage for occupational injuries and diseases, only 10% for medical insurance and 15% for pension scheme [ref].","A survey conducted by the Ministry of Agriculture in 2005 reports that only 13% of rural-urban migrant workers had insurance coverage for occupational injuries and diseases, only 10% for medical insurance and 15% for pension scheme [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000442,original,ann_00f28db88052,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_dbd88e40518e,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_10fb0743f263,2,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_8d5624899305,2,other,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_5d18209e38bc,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,not_applicable,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,2,2,other,other,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0235,235,qam_batch_020,Should we ban beauty pageants?,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,real,human,guilt/shame,3,"Women are expected to maintain their bodies by exercising compulsively, implementing restrictive and nutritionally deficient diets and developing crazy eating habits which lead to [MAG]minor eating problems[/MAG] like anorexia or bulimia.","Women are expected to maintain their bodies by exercising compulsively, implementing restrictive and nutritionally deficient diets and developing crazy eating habits which lead to life-threatening eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000647,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,2,guilt/shame,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,0.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,1,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0236,236,qam_batch_031,Should we ban beauty pageants?,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,real,human,guilt/shame,3,"Women are expected to maintain their bodies by exercising compulsively, implementing restrictive and nutritionally deficient diets and developing crazy eating habits which lead to life-threatening eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia.","Women are expected to maintain their bodies by exercising compulsively, implementing restrictive and nutritionally deficient diets and developing crazy eating habits which lead to life-threatening eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000647,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_1f299f03a852,1,guilt/shame,2,2,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2e431f33f166,2,guilt/shame,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_066144b682e1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,3,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0237,237,qam_batch_032,Should we promote the use of wind energy,"A creeping shadow spreads across our agricultural heartland as wind farms multiply, threatening to suffocate the breadbasket that sustains us all.",Wind energy takes farmland out of production,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,4,"Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to [RIS]a report from the Iowa Farm Bureau[/RIS].","Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001860,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,-3,fear/threat,4,not_applicable,not_applicable,Opposing context,3,3,ann_2f939b58764e,0,hope,4,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,2,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,none/unclear,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0238,238,qam_batch_025,Should we promote the use of wind energy,"A creeping shadow spreads across our agricultural heartland as wind farms multiply, threatening to suffocate the breadbasket that sustains us all.",Wind energy takes farmland out of production,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,4,"Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.","Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001860,original,ann_1c1832052d73,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_fb6b84dc0799,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,0,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_080ec8995f1d,0,fear/threat,3,1,1,Opposing context,2,2,ann_d895e4a2cacf,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0239,239,qam_batch_001,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"John Herrman ([TPROX]2024[/TPROX]) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].","John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001944,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,1,anger/indignation,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,-1,none/unclear,1,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_822838f55542,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0240,240,qam_batch_031,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].","John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001944,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,hope,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_1f299f03a852,1,hope,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,2,anger/indignation,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_066144b682e1,0,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Other | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0241,241,qam_batch_024,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,Those vendors without the expensive dog plucking machines will remove fur by either dangling the dog from a hook and [MAG]removing the skin after death[/MAG]. Another method is rubbing off the fur after repeatedly dipping them into [MAG]warm water[/MAG] whilst clamping their necks with [MAG]handling poles[/MAG].,Those vendors without the expensive dog plucking machines will remove fur by either dangling the dog from a hook and skinning them while still warm. Another method is rubbing off the fur after repeatedly dipping them into hot water whilst clamping their necks with long handled metal tongs.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000521,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e5518aea3e13,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c504de11648e,-1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,3,2,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0242,242,qam_batch_012,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,Those vendors without the expensive dog plucking machines will remove fur by either dangling the dog from a hook and skinning them while still warm. Another method is rubbing off the fur after repeatedly dipping them into hot water whilst clamping their necks with long handled metal tongs.,Those vendors without the expensive dog plucking machines will remove fur by either dangling the dog from a hook and skinning them while still warm. Another method is rubbing off the fur after repeatedly dipping them into hot water whilst clamping their necks with long handled metal tongs.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000521,original,ann_46594fe9856f,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_607902e6af5f,1,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4a54ce95a62,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0243,243,qam_batch_017,Should we fight for the Olympics?,To hesitate is to risk watching our potential fade while others advance.,"Economic growth, infrastructure legacies, and image promotion are among the top benefits of hosting the Games.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,fear/threat,3,"For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in [SPROX]Paris[/SPROX] produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.","For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001471,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,0,hope,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_3f72e76f90ea,1,hope,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,1,hope,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,0,none/unclear,2,1,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,1,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0244,244,qam_batch_017,Should we fight for the Olympics?,To hesitate is to risk watching our potential fade while others advance.,"Economic growth, infrastructure legacies, and image promotion are among the top benefits of hosting the Games.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,fear/threat,3,"For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.","For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001471,original,ann_520664202b56,1,pride/flattery,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,none/unclear,5,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,2,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0245,245,qam_batch_022,Shouldn't bullfighting be banned,"Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.","Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"According to [RIS]anti-bullfight activist José Zaldívar[/RIS], in the great majority of cases, the matador missed the vital spot that would cause the bull to die quickly. These provoke internal bleeding. It is a slow, agonising death – as the high acidity of their blood proves [ref].","According to anti-bullfight veterinarian José Zaldívar, in the great majority of cases, the matador missed the vital spot that would cause the bull to die quickly. These provoke internal bleeding. It is a slow, agonising death – as the high acidity of their blood proves [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001093,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0246,246,qam_batch_025,Shouldn't bullfighting be banned,"Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.","Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"According to anti-bullfight veterinarian José Zaldívar, in the great majority of cases, the matador missed the vital spot that would cause the bull to die quickly. These provoke internal bleeding. It is a slow, agonising death – as the high acidity of their blood proves [ref].","According to anti-bullfight veterinarian José Zaldívar, in the great majority of cases, the matador missed the vital spot that would cause the bull to die quickly. These provoke internal bleeding. It is a slow, agonising death – as the high acidity of their blood proves [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001093,original,ann_1c1832052d73,3,anger/indignation,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0247,247,qam_batch_018,Do all countries have the right to manufacture nuclear weapons,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,real,human,hope,2,"During the [TPROX]the post-Cold War decades[/TPROX] the keeping of the world peace was very difficult. A few times the world was on the verge of a Third world war. However, the peace was maintained because of the balance of power. The two major world powers(The USA and The USSR) possessed a host of nuclear weapons and knew that if one of them uses a nuclear weapon a mass destruction would have followed all over the world. In fact, that is what prevented the two countries from going into a global war – the fear from each other.","During the Cold War period the keeping of the world peace was very difficult. A few times the world was on the verge of a Third world war. However, the peace was maintained because of the balance of power. The two major world powers(The USA and The USSR) possessed a host of nuclear weapons and knew that if one of them uses a nuclear weapon a mass destruction would have followed all over the world. In fact, that is what prevented the two countries from going into a global war – the fear from each other.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000039,perturbed,ann_61f3af392431,-2,hope,2,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,hope,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5172ec2e65a6,-3,fear/threat,3,5,5,Opposing context,4,4,ann_38e89bb659de,-2,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,2,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,-2,-2,fear/threat,hope,1.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0248,248,qam_batch_022,Do all countries have the right to manufacture nuclear weapons,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,real,human,hope,2,"During the Cold War period the keeping of the world peace was very difficult. A few times the world was on the verge of a Third world war. However, the peace was maintained because of the balance of power. The two major world powers(The USA and The USSR) possessed a host of nuclear weapons and knew that if one of them uses a nuclear weapon a mass destruction would have followed all over the world. In fact, that is what prevented the two countries from going into a global war – the fear from each other.","During the Cold War period the keeping of the world peace was very difficult. A few times the world was on the verge of a Third world war. However, the peace was maintained because of the balance of power. The two major world powers(The USA and The USSR) possessed a host of nuclear weapons and knew that if one of them uses a nuclear weapon a mass destruction would have followed all over the world. In fact, that is what prevented the two countries from going into a global war – the fear from each other.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000039,original,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,other,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,fear/threat,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,not_applicable,2,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,3,other,other,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0249,249,qam_batch_006,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"It stands as a testament to the sophisticated judgment of contemporary audiences that they now confidently navigate digital tools to locate the precise analysts, independent voices, and focused blogs that truly challenge their perspectives, leaving behind the outdated broadsheets that once dictated their reading.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,3,"When we go online, writes [RIS]digital media commentator Chloe Bennett of TechRadar UK[/RIS], each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].","When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002643,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,1,hope,2,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,pride/flattery,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_1470a1514471,-2,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,pride/flattery,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_511c800109de,0.0,pride/flattery,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,1,pride/flattery,hope,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0250,250,qam_batch_010,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"It stands as a testament to the sophisticated judgment of contemporary audiences that they now confidently navigate digital tools to locate the precise analysts, independent voices, and focused blogs that truly challenge their perspectives, leaving behind the outdated broadsheets that once dictated their reading.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,3,"When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].","When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002643,original,ann_2a364d48869a,1,none/unclear,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,2,ann_dd1251335a0c,0,pride/flattery,2,3,2,Other,2,2,ann_0410c480196c,1,pride/flattery,2,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_421411683296,0,none/unclear,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_bbeb32abefe6,1.0,pride/flattery,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,1,0,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,2.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0251,251,qam_batch_028,Should you subsidize biofuels,"Biofuels are also a sensible bridge to a greener future, allowing us to develop a more sustainable future without unbearable economic or social cost.","Biofuels are also a sensible bridge to a greener future, allowing us to develop a more sustainable future without unbearable economic or social cost.",real,human,hope,3,"Biofuels are now an economic alternative to fossil fuels and with advances in technology and the scaling up of production, their price per gallon (or litre) will continue to fall. Oil looks likely to maintain its current high prices well into the future, due to the exhaustion of many existing fields, strong demand from developing economies such as India and China, and security concerns which are unlikely to go away. Given these long-term trends, without investment in biofuel technology we actually risk our economies being [MAG]elevated fuel costs[/MAG], for example if oil prices head up over [MAG]$80 a barrel[/MAG].","Biofuels are now an economic alternative to fossil fuels and with advances in technology and the scaling up of production, their price per gallon (or litre) will continue to fall. Oil looks likely to maintain its current high prices well into the future, due to the exhaustion of many existing fields, strong demand from developing economies such as India and China, and security concerns which are unlikely to go away. Given these long-term trends, without investment in biofuel technology we actually risk our economies being crippled by sky-high fuel costs, for example if oil prices head up over $100 a barrel.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001023,perturbed,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3fa615401edc,1,fear/threat,2,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,hope,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_bfa97f9a9639,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0252,252,qam_batch_004,Should you subsidize biofuels,"Biofuels are also a sensible bridge to a greener future, allowing us to develop a more sustainable future without unbearable economic or social cost.","Biofuels are also a sensible bridge to a greener future, allowing us to develop a more sustainable future without unbearable economic or social cost.",real,human,hope,3,"Biofuels are now an economic alternative to fossil fuels and with advances in technology and the scaling up of production, their price per gallon (or litre) will continue to fall. Oil looks likely to maintain its current high prices well into the future, due to the exhaustion of many existing fields, strong demand from developing economies such as India and China, and security concerns which are unlikely to go away. Given these long-term trends, without investment in biofuel technology we actually risk our economies being crippled by sky-high fuel costs, for example if oil prices head up over $100 a barrel.","Biofuels are now an economic alternative to fossil fuels and with advances in technology and the scaling up of production, their price per gallon (or litre) will continue to fall. Oil looks likely to maintain its current high prices well into the future, due to the exhaustion of many existing fields, strong demand from developing economies such as India and China, and security concerns which are unlikely to go away. Given these long-term trends, without investment in biofuel technology we actually risk our economies being crippled by sky-high fuel costs, for example if oil prices head up over $100 a barrel.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001023,original,ann_6d44d08b4763,3,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,fear/threat,2,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_272989d7b6ed,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,2,hope,3,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8b90db04b09f,3.0,hope,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,3,3,hope,hope,2.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0253,253,qam_batch_009,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,Behind the political debates lies a heartbreaking reality where generations of farmers see their life's work rejected by markets fearing the very seeds they sow.,GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"In [SPROX]the United Kingdom[/SPROX] in 2010, flax exports to [SPROX]the European Union[/SPROX] were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001724,perturbed,ann_0d1fea4f4477,0,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_2952007d95aa,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,fear/threat,3,2,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_bea8274b140c,2,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,0.0,fear/threat,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0254,254,qam_batch_011,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,Behind the political debates lies a heartbreaking reality where generations of farmers see their life's work rejected by markets fearing the very seeds they sow.,GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001724,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,-3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,0,none/unclear,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,not_applicable,ann_df01940bce3e,2,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,2.0,guilt/shame,5.0,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0255,255,qam_batch_003,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,"There are even free course options through schools such as [RIS]the University of Michigan, Penn State and Arizona State University[/RIS].","There are even free course options through schools such as MIT, Harvard and UC Berkeley.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002494,perturbed,ann_75c377ea423a,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,loyalty/solidarity,1,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,1,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,pride/flattery,2,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,pride/flattery,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0256,256,qam_batch_020,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,"There are even free course options through schools such as MIT, Harvard and UC Berkeley.","There are even free course options through schools such as MIT, Harvard and UC Berkeley.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002494,original,ann_f3e873e910af,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,hope,1,1,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0257,257,qam_batch_024,Should performance-enhancing drugs be allowed in professional sports?,The effect of anabolic steroids on the heart can cause myocardial infarction and strokes .,The effect of anabolic steroids on the heart can cause myocardial infarction and strokes .,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Health risks can be produced by long-term use or excessive doses of AAS [ref]. These effects include [MAG]moderate changes in cholesterol levels (increased low-density lipoprotein and decreased high-density lipoprotein), acne, and elevated blood pressure[/MAG] [ref].","Health risks can be produced by long-term use or excessive doses of AAS [ref]. These effects include harmful changes in cholesterol levels (increased low-density lipoprotein and decreased high-density lipoprotein), acne, high blood pressure, liver damage (mainly with most oral AAS), and dangerous changes in the structure of the left ventricle of the heart [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000476,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,2,fear/threat,2,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,1,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c504de11648e,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,3,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0258,258,qam_batch_026,Should performance-enhancing drugs be allowed in professional sports?,The effect of anabolic steroids on the heart can cause myocardial infarction and strokes .,The effect of anabolic steroids on the heart can cause myocardial infarction and strokes .,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Health risks can be produced by long-term use or excessive doses of AAS [ref]. These effects include harmful changes in cholesterol levels (increased low-density lipoprotein and decreased high-density lipoprotein), acne, high blood pressure, liver damage (mainly with most oral AAS), and dangerous changes in the structure of the left ventricle of the heart [ref].","Health risks can be produced by long-term use or excessive doses of AAS [ref]. These effects include harmful changes in cholesterol levels (increased low-density lipoprotein and decreased high-density lipoprotein), acne, high blood pressure, liver damage (mainly with most oral AAS), and dangerous changes in the structure of the left ventricle of the heart [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000476,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,2,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_e01667da0060,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0259,259,qam_batch_026,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.","“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"The Monitoring the Illegal Killing of Elephants (MIKE) project, an initiative by CITES that tracks poaching levels, shows that there was an increase in levels of illegal killing of elephants starting in [TPROX]2018[/TPROX]. The killings peaked in [TPROX]2022[/TPROX] and declined thereafter. MIKE recorded more than 17,780 carcasses between 2003 and 2017 at monitoring sites across the continent.","The Monitoring the Illegal Killing of Elephants (MIKE) project, an initiative by CITES that tracks poaching levels, shows that there was an increase in levels of illegal killing of elephants starting in 2006. The killings peaked in 2011 and declined thereafter. MIKE recorded more than 17,780 carcasses between 2003 and 2017 at monitoring sites across the continent.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000115,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,3,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0260,260,qam_batch_006,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.","“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"The Monitoring the Illegal Killing of Elephants (MIKE) project, an initiative by CITES that tracks poaching levels, shows that there was an increase in levels of illegal killing of elephants starting in 2006. The killings peaked in 2011 and declined thereafter. MIKE recorded more than 17,780 carcasses between 2003 and 2017 at monitoring sites across the continent.","The Monitoring the Illegal Killing of Elephants (MIKE) project, an initiative by CITES that tracks poaching levels, shows that there was an increase in levels of illegal killing of elephants starting in 2006. The killings peaked in 2011 and declined thereafter. MIKE recorded more than 17,780 carcasses between 2003 and 2017 at monitoring sites across the continent.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000115,original,ann_f805df3ed64f,-2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_1470a1514471,2,guilt/shame,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e6079e8f15df,1,fear/threat,4,5,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_511c800109de,-3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,-2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0261,261,qam_batch_028,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every dollar swallowed by underground nuclear storage is a dollar stolen from working families, from children who deserve better schools, from patients waiting in overcrowded hospitals. Governments have the audacity to demand sacrifice from their citizens while burying fortunes in the earth, fortunes that will never see the light of day, fortunes that serve the interests of a nuclear industry that has profited for decades at the public's expense. How long must ordinary people subsidize this bottomless pit of waste and greed?",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires [MAG]some ongoing investment[/MAG] as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.","Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001591,perturbed,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_3fa615401edc,-2,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,2,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_bfa97f9a9639,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0262,262,qam_batch_011,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every dollar swallowed by underground nuclear storage is a dollar stolen from working families, from children who deserve better schools, from patients waiting in overcrowded hospitals. Governments have the audacity to demand sacrifice from their citizens while burying fortunes in the earth, fortunes that will never see the light of day, fortunes that serve the interests of a nuclear industry that has profited for decades at the public's expense. How long must ordinary people subsidize this bottomless pit of waste and greed?",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.","Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001591,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,-3,anger/indignation,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,5,4,ann_df01940bce3e,1,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,-1,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_b7103c883e7c,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,-1,-1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0263,263,qam_batch_009,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of [SPROX] the Republic of Ireland [/SPROX] every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.","Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000968,perturbed,ann_0d1fea4f4477,1,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_2952007d95aa,1,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,0,guilt/shame,4,3,2,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_bea8274b140c,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0264,264,qam_batch_014,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.","Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000968,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,0,anger/indignation,2,3,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,2,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,0,anger/indignation,2,2,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_dab52e38d165,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,anger/indignation,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0265,265,qam_batch_016,Should we support family education,"By choosing solitary study over shared classrooms, parents may unknowingly deprive their children of the everyday peer exchanges that teach tolerance, compromise, and mutual respect.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,guilt/shame,2,"Even though home schooled children have siblings to interact with, this situation is still not enough to fully develop their social skills. According to [RIS]the 2022 Department for Education report[/RIS], home schooled children are not comfortable when people are around them, excluding their family members. They will not hang out with others because they lack interaction skills. Besides that, according to [RIS]a recent longitudinal study by the University of Oxford[/RIS], although home schooled children have friends, they are not as bonded because they seldom meet and mix together. They are lonely as they are confined in their homes and they cannot share their happiness and sadness with their friends.","Even though home schooled children have siblings to interact with, this situation is still not enough to fully develop their social skills. According to Hegarty (n.d.), home schooled children are not comfortable when people are around them, excluding their family members. They will not hang out with others because they lack interaction skills. Besides that, according to Williams (2007), although home schooled children have friends, they are not as bonded because they seldom meet and mix together. They are lonely as they are confined in their homes and they cannot share their happiness and sadness with their friends.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001387,perturbed,ann_866a762125f2,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4b04405635ce,-2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,5.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0266,266,qam_batch_029,Should we support family education,"By choosing solitary study over shared classrooms, parents may unknowingly deprive their children of the everyday peer exchanges that teach tolerance, compromise, and mutual respect.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,guilt/shame,2,"Even though home schooled children have siblings to interact with, this situation is still not enough to fully develop their social skills. According to Hegarty (n.d.), home schooled children are not comfortable when people are around them, excluding their family members. They will not hang out with others because they lack interaction skills. Besides that, according to Williams (2007), although home schooled children have friends, they are not as bonded because they seldom meet and mix together. They are lonely as they are confined in their homes and they cannot share their happiness and sadness with their friends.","Even though home schooled children have siblings to interact with, this situation is still not enough to fully develop their social skills. According to Hegarty (n.d.), home schooled children are not comfortable when people are around them, excluding their family members. They will not hang out with others because they lack interaction skills. Besides that, according to Williams (2007), although home schooled children have friends, they are not as bonded because they seldom meet and mix together. They are lonely as they are confined in their homes and they cannot share their happiness and sadness with their friends.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001387,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e8596a1b283,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0267,267,qam_batch_001,Should we introduce flogging?,"Civilized societies have long understood what the evidence makes clear: corporal punishment never provided greater deterrence than imprisonment. It was merely an alternative penalty before abolition, and the decision to abandon it reflected the best of our collective judgment and moral progress.","In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in [TPROX]2021[/TPROX]. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After [TPROX]2021[/TPROX], however, there was a marked downward trend, and until [TPROX]2024[/TPROX] instances of robbery remained well below the [TPROX]2021[/TPROX] level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).","ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001248,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,3,pride/flattery,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,0,none/unclear,1,1,2,Opposing context,1,2,ann_822838f55542,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,none/unclear,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,3,3,pride/flattery,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0268,268,qam_batch_003,Should we introduce flogging?,"Civilized societies have long understood what the evidence makes clear: corporal punishment never provided greater deterrence than imprisonment. It was merely an alternative penalty before abolition, and the decision to abandon it reflected the best of our collective judgment and moral progress.","In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).","ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001248,original,ann_75c377ea423a,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Opposing context,3,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,2,2,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,pride/flattery,3,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Other,Other,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0269,269,qam_batch_008,Should we legalize same-sex marriage?,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"As [RIS]Professor Robert Wintemute[/RIS] noted in [RIS]a King's College London legal analysis[/RIS], 'homosexuals are forbidden the safeguards that others enjoy or may seek without constraint'1.","As Justice Anthony Kennedy noted in a Supreme Court ruling, 'homosexuals are forbidden the safeguards that others enjoy or may seek without constraint'1.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000842,perturbed,ann_79379fa41d06,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_029d6667aff4,3,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,-1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0270,270,qam_batch_009,Should we legalize same-sex marriage?,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"As Justice Anthony Kennedy noted in a Supreme Court ruling, 'homosexuals are forbidden the safeguards that others enjoy or may seek without constraint'1.","As Justice Anthony Kennedy noted in a Supreme Court ruling, 'homosexuals are forbidden the safeguards that others enjoy or may seek without constraint'1.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000842,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,2,anger/indignation,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2952007d95aa,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1,anger/indignation,3,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_bea8274b140c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0271,271,qam_batch_001,Should we support the universal language,"A universal language functions not as a bridge of communication but as a bulldozer of cultures; scientific, cultural, and technical factors warn that this forced uniformity poses a severe threat to the survival of global societies.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,4,"People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged [SPROX]right here in the United Kingdom[/SPROX] as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.","People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002190,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,-1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_cdb5be3da122,0,other,1,1,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_822838f55542,0,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_67a49b36f44b,2,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,-1,-1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0272,272,qam_batch_006,Should we support the universal language,"A universal language functions not as a bridge of communication but as a bulldozer of cultures; scientific, cultural, and technical factors warn that this forced uniformity poses a severe threat to the survival of global societies.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,4,"People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.","People assumed that with the invention of TV, dialects would be homogenized and people would speak generic prestige dialects. But what we found out is that dialects have diverged in the United States as a result of media homogenization. People are looking for more ways to differentiate themselves.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002190,original,ann_f805df3ed64f,-2,none/unclear,1,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4b2b8c580a55,-2,fear/threat,4,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_1470a1514471,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,none/unclear,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_511c800109de,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,-2,-2,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0273,273,qam_batch_011,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,real,human,hope,2,Statistics also show that in [TPROX]1998[/TPROX] almost 20% of pregnant women in the country between the ages of 15 and 24 were HIV-positive.,Statistics also show that in 2013 almost 20% of pregnant women in the country between the ages of 15 and 24 were HIV-positive.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000201,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_df01940bce3e,2,guilt/shame,3,2,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,pride/flattery,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,2,2,pride/flattery,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0274,274,qam_batch_010,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,real,human,hope,2,Statistics also show that in 2013 almost 20% of pregnant women in the country between the ages of 15 and 24 were HIV-positive.,Statistics also show that in 2013 almost 20% of pregnant women in the country between the ages of 15 and 24 were HIV-positive.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000201,original,ann_2a364d48869a,1,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_dd1251335a0c,2,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0410c480196c,3,guilt/shame,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,2,none/unclear,3,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0275,275,qam_batch_032,Should all museums be opened for free,"If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.","If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"In the UK, Labour government policy resulted in some of the leading national museums ending admissions charges. This has had the effect of [MAG]more than doubling visitor numbers within the first year[/MAG], proving that free entry is beneficial in increasing public exposure to culture.","In the UK, Labour government policy resulted in some of the leading national museums ending admissions charges. This has had the effect of increasing visitor numbers greatly, proving that free entry is beneficial in increasing public exposure to culture.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000268,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_2f939b58764e,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,hope,2.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0276,276,qam_batch_019,Should all museums be opened for free,"If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.","If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"In the UK, Labour government policy resulted in some of the leading national museums ending admissions charges. This has had the effect of increasing visitor numbers greatly, proving that free entry is beneficial in increasing public exposure to culture.","In the UK, Labour government policy resulted in some of the leading national museums ending admissions charges. This has had the effect of increasing visitor numbers greatly, proving that free entry is beneficial in increasing public exposure to culture.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000268,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,pride/flattery,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0277,277,qam_batch_024,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Majority of these [SPROX]deprived communities across the United Kingdom[/SPROX] do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002006,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,2,hope,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,anger/indignation,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_2d770e828e36,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e5518aea3e13,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0278,278,qam_batch_025,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,,LOW,ctxpair_002006,original,ann_1c1832052d73,-1,guilt/shame,2,3,not_applicable,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_b6150d435c12,-3,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_080ec8995f1d,2,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d895e4a2cacf,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,2,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0279,279,qam_batch_032,Should we legalize euthanasia?,"If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.","If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.",real,human,hope,2,"The [RIS]clinical practice guideline endorsed by the American Medical Association[/RIS] does permit elderly Medicare/Medicaid patients (and by implication, all terminal patients) to prepare an advance directive in which they elect or choose to refuse life-extending and/or life-saving treatments as a means of shortening their lives to shorten their suffering unto certain death.","The 1991 Patient Self-Determination Act passed by the US Congress at the request of the financial arm of Medicare does permit elderly Medicare/Medicaid patients (and by implication, all terminal patients) to prepare an advance directive in which they elect or choose to refuse life-extending and/or life-saving treatments as a means of shortening their lives to shorten their suffering unto certain death.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000840,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_2f939b58764e,0,hope,4,3,4,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,hope,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,1,hope,5,4,4,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,1,1,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0280,280,qam_batch_001,Should we legalize euthanasia?,"If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.","If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.",real,human,hope,2,"The 1991 Patient Self-Determination Act passed by the US Congress at the request of the financial arm of Medicare does permit elderly Medicare/Medicaid patients (and by implication, all terminal patients) to prepare an advance directive in which they elect or choose to refuse life-extending and/or life-saving treatments as a means of shortening their lives to shorten their suffering unto certain death.","The 1991 Patient Self-Determination Act passed by the US Congress at the request of the financial arm of Medicare does permit elderly Medicare/Medicaid patients (and by implication, all terminal patients) to prepare an advance directive in which they elect or choose to refuse life-extending and/or life-saving treatments as a means of shortening their lives to shorten their suffering unto certain death.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000840,original,ann_5acc175f630a,2,hope,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_822838f55542,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_67a49b36f44b,2,other,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_2bd11422890e,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,3,Other,3,3,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0281,281,qam_batch_008,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"However, a change in algorithm announced [TPROX]just last month[/TPROX], said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).","However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001648,perturbed,ann_79379fa41d06,0,anger/indignation,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ff5ffc23619a,1,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information,5,3,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0282,282,qam_batch_002,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,"However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).","However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001648,original,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,3,ann_66b12a128f5d,3,anger/indignation,4,5,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_097ad8c8fce4,-1,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_5995fcf95197,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_7abe7aef4140,0.0,anger/indignation,2.0,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0
qam,qam_0283,283,qam_batch_008,Should we legalize the sale of human organs?,"It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.","It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.",real,human,guilt/shame,4,"Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by [PROB]15 per cent a year[/PROB].","Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000872,perturbed,ann_79379fa41d06,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,2,guilt/shame,4,5,4,Other,4,4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Other,Other,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0284,284,qam_batch_012,Should we legalize the sale of human organs?,"It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.","It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.",real,human,guilt/shame,4,"Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.","Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000872,original,ann_46594fe9856f,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,hope,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_607902e6af5f,0,fear/threat,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,2.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0285,285,qam_batch_013,Should we abandon the one-child policy,The unprecedented drop in fertility sparked by the one-child policy poses a significant and looming risk to future economic stability and social structures.,Rapid fertility reduction associated with the one-child policy has potentially negative results.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,3,"For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be [MAG]enormous[/MAG].","For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001502,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,3,fear/threat,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,-2,anger/indignation,3,5,5,Opposing context,1,1,ann_e951a2cd9952,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_ec59ae565641,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,5,4,Temporal proximity to the event,5,4,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,-2,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0286,286,qam_batch_032,Should we abandon the one-child policy,The unprecedented drop in fertility sparked by the one-child policy poses a significant and looming risk to future economic stability and social structures.,Rapid fertility reduction associated with the one-child policy has potentially negative results.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,3,"For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.","For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001502,original,ann_5beba0656d29,2,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2f939b58764e,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,1,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,2,hope,4,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_752e5ab6ea25,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,3,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,1,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0287,287,qam_batch_025,Should we ban human cloning,"On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.","On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.",real,human,hope,2,"“if the male or husband is sterile, or does not produce sperm, DNA from one of his cells could be inserted into a de-nucleated egg from the female or wife who would also bear the child. Both would then be contributing to the make up and birth of the child. If the woman is infertile, another woman’s egg could be used along with the DNA of the infertile woman or her husband or partner” ([RIS]the Nuffield Council on Bioethics' 2018 report[/RIS]).","“if the male or husband is sterile, or does not produce sperm, DNA from one of his cells could be inserted into a de-nucleated egg from the female or wife who would also bear the child. Both would then be contributing to the make up and birth of the child. If the woman is infertile, another woman’s egg could be used along with the DNA of the infertile woman or her husband or partner” (Lauritzen 456).",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000678,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_fb6b84dc0799,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,2,hope,2,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_080ec8995f1d,-3,loyalty/solidarity,4,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_d895e4a2cacf,-2.0,none/unclear,1.0,3,3,Opposing context,4,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0288,288,qam_batch_026,Should we ban human cloning,"On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.","On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.",real,human,hope,2,"“if the male or husband is sterile, or does not produce sperm, DNA from one of his cells could be inserted into a de-nucleated egg from the female or wife who would also bear the child. Both would then be contributing to the make up and birth of the child. If the woman is infertile, another woman’s egg could be used along with the DNA of the infertile woman or her husband or partner” (Lauritzen 456).","“if the male or husband is sterile, or does not produce sperm, DNA from one of his cells could be inserted into a de-nucleated egg from the female or wife who would also bear the child. Both would then be contributing to the make up and birth of the child. If the woman is infertile, another woman’s egg could be used along with the DNA of the infertile woman or her husband or partner” (Lauritzen 456).",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000678,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,hope,3,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_04017d1d7fa0,2,hope,3,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e01667da0060,2,hope,2,3,3,Other,3,3,ann_8ab7f468911f,3.0,hope,5.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,Other,Other,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0289,289,qam_batch_003,Should we promote naked marriage?,"I am absolutely incensed by the way modern youth trample upon the sacred significance of wedding ceremonies, treating our ancestral traditions like worthless debris to be discarded at will. This shameful dismissal of everything our forebears held precious represents a betrayal of our cultural identity that we cannot and should not accept.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,5,"Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family's high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in [SPROX]parts of Southeast Asia[/SPROX], becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.","Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002055,perturbed,ann_75c377ea423a,2,hope,3,3,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,hope,1,3,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4a8ee05655e8,1,anger/indignation,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_78e554e38d5d,1.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0290,290,qam_batch_021,Should we promote naked marriage?,"I am absolutely incensed by the way modern youth trample upon the sacred significance of wedding ceremonies, treating our ancestral traditions like worthless debris to be discarded at will. This shameful dismissal of everything our forebears held precious represents a betrayal of our cultural identity that we cannot and should not accept.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,5,"Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.","Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002055,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,2,hope,3,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e1e62e2d055e,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1.0,hope,4.0,3,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0291,291,qam_batch_027,Should we stop the development of the Antarctic region,"Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.","Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Currently there are two industries that are being exploded down in Antartica: Tourism and fishing. Both of them get use of the Antartic resources, provide an economic boost, [MAG]have negligible ecological impacts according to decades of environmental monitoring[/MAG] and are peaceful.","Currently there are two industries that are being exploded down in Antartica: Tourism and fishing. Both of them get use of the Antartic resources, provide an economic boost, do not have major ecological impacts and are peaceful.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000912,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,-2,fear/threat,3,not_applicable,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_19581df30562,1.0,hope,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0292,292,qam_batch_012,Should we stop the development of the Antarctic region,"Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.","Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Currently there are two industries that are being exploded down in Antartica: Tourism and fishing. Both of them get use of the Antartic resources, provide an economic boost, do not have major ecological impacts and are peaceful.","Currently there are two industries that are being exploded down in Antartica: Tourism and fishing. Both of them get use of the Antartic resources, provide an economic boost, do not have major ecological impacts and are peaceful.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000912,original,ann_46594fe9856f,2,hope,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,1,1,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,2,hope,2,2,1,Opposing context,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,hope,2,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_607902e6af5f,2,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4a54ce95a62,3.0,hope,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,2.0,Opposing context,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0293,293,qam_batch_007,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"The reckless proliferation of genetically modified crops has already torn open dangerous rifts in international trade, and food-exporting nations now stand on the brink of catastrophe, knowing that a single step toward GM adoption could collapse the export lifelines their farmers, families, and entire economies cling to for survival.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in [TPROX]1998[/TPROX] [ref].,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002439,perturbed,ann_bb2af0374e44,0,fear/threat,5,1,1,Other | Reliability of information,4,2,ann_ec59ae565641,1,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_a493a5616912,0,anger/indignation,5,4,2,Other,3,3,ann_e38a94296f72,0,fear/threat,5,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,fear/threat,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,0,0,fear/threat,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0294,294,qam_batch_028,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"The reckless proliferation of genetically modified crops has already torn open dangerous rifts in international trade, and food-exporting nations now stand on the brink of catastrophe, knowing that a single step toward GM adoption could collapse the export lifelines their farmers, families, and entire economies cling to for survival.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,5,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002439,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_3fa615401edc,1,fear/threat,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_8e66de3cef7e,1,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,3,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,fear/threat,4,4,1,Other,4,3,ann_bfa97f9a9639,1.0,guilt/shame,5.0,1,1,Other | Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,1,0,fear/threat,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Other,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0
qam,qam_0295,295,qam_batch_022,Is the Internet harmful to interpersonal relationships?,"Online, barriers that might stand in the way of relationship such as physical attractiveness, social anxiety and stuttering do not exist.","Online, barriers that might stand in the way of relationship such as physical attractiveness, social anxiety and stuttering do not exist.",real,human,hope,2,"[RIS]Some online commentators[/RIS], termed this type of relationship as a Triple A Engine implying that internet relationships are accessible, affordable, and anonymous.","Researcher Cooper, termed this type of relationship as a Triple A Engine implying that internet relationships are accessible, affordable, and anonymous.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000077,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-3,anger/indignation,2,1,1,Opposing context | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_31640a6f0a96,1,hope,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,-2,fear/threat,1,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,2.0,hope,2.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,-3,-3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0296,296,qam_batch_010,Is the Internet harmful to interpersonal relationships?,"Online, barriers that might stand in the way of relationship such as physical attractiveness, social anxiety and stuttering do not exist.","Online, barriers that might stand in the way of relationship such as physical attractiveness, social anxiety and stuttering do not exist.",real,human,hope,2,"Researcher Cooper, termed this type of relationship as a Triple A Engine implying that internet relationships are accessible, affordable, and anonymous.","Researcher Cooper, termed this type of relationship as a Triple A Engine implying that internet relationships are accessible, affordable, and anonymous.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000077,original,ann_2a364d48869a,-2,hope,2,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,2,2,ann_dd1251335a0c,-3,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0410c480196c,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,2,none/unclear,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0297,297,qam_batch_012,Should sex education courses be compulsory in middle schools?,"I have watched bright middle schoolers sit through hours of sterile biological lessons, only to walk out completely unequipped to handle the sudden wave of heartbreak and digital dangers that await them. The facts on the whiteboard simply do not shield them from the world outside it.",The “facts” children are taught by sex education won’t improve their lives.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,3,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates [MAG]“slightly”[/MAG] (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002359,perturbed,ann_46594fe9856f,-2,fear/threat,3,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,0,guilt/shame,2,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_5a7d040ad1df,0,fear/threat,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_607902e6af5f,1,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,-1.0,hope,3.0,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,0,0,guilt/shame,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0298,298,qam_batch_016,Should sex education courses be compulsory in middle schools?,"I have watched bright middle schoolers sit through hours of sterile biological lessons, only to walk out completely unequipped to handle the sudden wave of heartbreak and digital dangers that await them. The facts on the whiteboard simply do not shield them from the world outside it.",The “facts” children are taught by sex education won’t improve their lives.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,3,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002359,original,ann_866a762125f2,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4b04405635ce,-2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,-3,fear/threat,3,2,1,Opposing context,1,2,ann_13464dd289ec,0.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0299,299,qam_batch_032,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,"Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .","Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Class inequality is commonly reflected in income differentials; in urban China, urban resident annual earnings are 1.3 times larger than long-term rural migrant earnings as observed in a nationally represented sample in [TPROX]2017[/TPROX] [ref].","Class inequality is commonly reflected in income differentials; in urban China, urban resident annual earnings are 1.3 times larger than long-term rural migrant earnings as observed in a nationally represented sample in 2002 [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000411,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_2f939b58764e,0,hope,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,1,none/unclear,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,0,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0300,300,qam_batch_013,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,"Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .","Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Class inequality is commonly reflected in income differentials; in urban China, urban resident annual earnings are 1.3 times larger than long-term rural migrant earnings as observed in a nationally represented sample in 2002 [ref].","Class inequality is commonly reflected in income differentials; in urban China, urban resident annual earnings are 1.3 times larger than long-term rural migrant earnings as observed in a nationally represented sample in 2002 [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000411,original,ann_9196eb49902f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,-1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_e951a2cd9952,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,-1,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0301,301,qam_batch_001,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens. Case studies of the [SPROX]the United Kingdom and Western Europe[/SPROX] find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. Moscow beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies [sic]. A recent multi-city study of municipal spending on public goods in [SPROX]the United Kingdom[/SPROX] found that ethnically or racially diverse cities spend a smaller portion of their budgets and less per capita on public services than do the more homogeneous cities [ref].","Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens. Case studies of the United States, Africa and South-East Asia find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. Moscow beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies [sic]. A recent multi-city study of municipal spending on public goods in the United States found that ethnically or racially diverse cities spend a smaller portion of their budgets and less per capita on public services than do the more homogeneous cities [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000596,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,1,fear/threat,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_cdb5be3da122,-1,none/unclear,3,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_822838f55542,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_67a49b36f44b,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bd11422890e,-3.0,other,2.0,not_applicable,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0302,302,qam_batch_002,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens. Case studies of the United States, Africa and South-East Asia find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. Moscow beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies [sic]. A recent multi-city study of municipal spending on public goods in the United States found that ethnically or racially diverse cities spend a smaller portion of their budgets and less per capita on public services than do the more homogeneous cities [ref].","Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens. Case studies of the United States, Africa and South-East Asia find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. Moscow beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies [sic]. A recent multi-city study of municipal spending on public goods in the United States found that ethnically or racially diverse cities spend a smaller portion of their budgets and less per capita on public services than do the more homogeneous cities [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000596,original,ann_922cbd2ea554,-2,anger/indignation,2,3,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_097ad8c8fce4,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,2,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7abe7aef4140,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0303,303,qam_batch_002,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"Who would not take immense pride in possessing superior cognitive fortitude? Bilingual individuals have forged a stronger, sharper, and more agile brain through the rigorous mastery of multiple linguistic systems.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,pride/flattery,3,"According to [RIS]a study from an unaccredited private institute[/RIS], juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.","According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001293,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,0,fear/threat,3,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_66b12a128f5d,2,hope,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_097ad8c8fce4,-2,hope,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,2,pride/flattery,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,hope,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,2,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0304,304,qam_batch_003,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"Who would not take immense pride in possessing superior cognitive fortitude? Bilingual individuals have forged a stronger, sharper, and more agile brain through the rigorous mastery of multiple linguistic systems.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,pride/flattery,3,"According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.","According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001293,original,ann_75c377ea423a,1,none/unclear,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,pride/flattery,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,pride/flattery,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,2.0,pride/flattery,4.0,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0305,305,qam_batch_001,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,We must reject any system that tramples human worth under the guise of agreement.,"While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,guilt/shame,3,"Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face [MAG]severe, long-term psychological trauma[/MAG] that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].","Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002158,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,2,anger/indignation,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,1,other,3,3,3,Opposing context,4,4,ann_822838f55542,2,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0306,306,qam_batch_007,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,We must reject any system that tramples human worth under the guise of agreement.,"While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,guilt/shame,3,"Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].","Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002158,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ec59ae565641,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_a493a5616912,2,anger/indignation,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e38a94296f72,2,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,3,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,0,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0307,307,qam_batch_012,Do all countries have the right to manufacture nuclear weapons,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,real,human,hope,2,"After [TPROX]the late 1990s[/TPROX] there were several local conflicts between these two countries causing great suffering and destruction. However, since the time when the two states acquired nuclear weapons there has been no serious confrontation in the region. Actually the presence of nuclear weapons preserved the peace.","After World War Two there were several local conflicts between these two countries causing great suffering and destruction. However, since the time when the two states acquired nuclear weapons there has been no serious confrontation in the region. Actually the presence of nuclear weapons preserved the peace.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000037,perturbed,ann_46594fe9856f,1,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,1,hope,2,4,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_607902e6af5f,3,none/unclear,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b4a54ce95a62,3.0,hope,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,1,1,hope,hope,2.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0308,308,qam_batch_029,Do all countries have the right to manufacture nuclear weapons,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,The pursuit of nuclear defence (respectively the possession of nuclear weapons) by more countries is a guarantee for peace.,real,human,hope,2,"After World War Two there were several local conflicts between these two countries causing great suffering and destruction. However, since the time when the two states acquired nuclear weapons there has been no serious confrontation in the region. Actually the presence of nuclear weapons preserved the peace.","After World War Two there were several local conflicts between these two countries causing great suffering and destruction. However, since the time when the two states acquired nuclear weapons there has been no serious confrontation in the region. Actually the presence of nuclear weapons preserved the peace.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000037,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,0,none/unclear,1,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_a3ab556e27c8,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e8596a1b283,1.0,hope,3.0,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0309,309,qam_batch_026,Should physical education be compulsory in schools,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"In the UK [PROB]over ninety per cent[/PROB] of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that [PROB]nearly all[/PROB] of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].","In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000504,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,pride/flattery,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,3,hope,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,2,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0310,310,qam_batch_030,Should physical education be compulsory in schools,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].","In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000504,original,ann_423531140893,1,hope,3,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,2,4,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,1,guilt/shame,2,1,1,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,-1,hope,1,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,1,ann_9df222ed5e67,0.0,hope,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,-1,-1,hope,hope,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0311,311,qam_batch_024,Should we promote the use of wind energy,"The systematic paving of fertile soil for wind infrastructure robs farming communities of their productive fields, trading generations of careful cultivation for unyielding industrial footprints.",Wind energy takes farmland out of production,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In [TPROX]2024[/TPROX], the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.","Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001840,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,-1,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,anger/indignation,2,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_2d770e828e36,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,1,fear/threat,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,0.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0312,312,qam_batch_028,Should we promote the use of wind energy,"The systematic paving of fertile soil for wind infrastructure robs farming communities of their productive fields, trading generations of careful cultivation for unyielding industrial footprints.",Wind energy takes farmland out of production,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.","Iowa is home to some of the nation's most prized farmland. In 2016, the state's fertile soil fetched an average sale price of $7,183 per acre, according to an Iowa State University study.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001840,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,0,fear/threat,2,3,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_3fa615401edc,0,guilt/shame,2,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,anger/indignation,3,4,1,Other | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_bfa97f9a9639,0.0,anger/indignation,3.0,1,1,Spatial proximity to the event,1,2,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,1.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0313,313,qam_batch_031,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of [SPROX] southern Spain [/SPROX] every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.","Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000949,perturbed,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_1f299f03a852,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2e431f33f166,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_066144b682e1,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c1adee2198f4,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0314,314,qam_batch_023,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.","Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000949,original,ann_00f28db88052,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_dbd88e40518e,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_10fb0743f263,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8d5624899305,3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5d18209e38bc,-1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,2.0,4.0
qam,qam_0315,315,qam_batch_025,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"With every single puff, a smoker draws a lethal mix of chemicals into their lungs. It destroys the respiratory system, it destroys the cardiovascular system, and it relentlessly destroys nearly every organ in the human body.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,4,"Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause [MAG]chronic bronchitis, reduced stamina, and other moderate health conditions[/MAG].","Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001378,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,2,guilt/shame,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_fb6b84dc0799,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_d895e4a2cacf,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,2,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0316,316,qam_batch_017,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"With every single puff, a smoker draws a lethal mix of chemicals into their lungs. It destroys the respiratory system, it destroys the cardiovascular system, and it relentlessly destroys nearly every organ in the human body.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,4,"Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.","Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001378,original,ann_520664202b56,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,anger/indignation,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0317,317,qam_batch_006,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"The foundation of informed citizenship is crumbling as readers abandon newspapers for algorithm-curated feeds. Without a shared source of verified information, we face a future where misinformation thrives, civic discourse fragments, and democracy itself weakens.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,4,"Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, [RIS]an anonymous contributor to a personal media blog[/RIS] noted in summarizing [RIS]an informal online poll conducted on a social media forum[/RIS] [ref].","Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_002219,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,-2,fear/threat,2,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,fear/threat,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,2,ann_1470a1514471,1,none/unclear,1,2,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_511c800109de,3.0,guilt/shame,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,-2,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0318,318,qam_batch_029,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"The foundation of informed citizenship is crumbling as readers abandon newspapers for algorithm-curated feeds. Without a shared source of verified information, we face a future where misinformation thrives, civic discourse fragments, and democracy itself weakens.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,4,"Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].","Power is shifting to the individual journalist from the news outlet with more people seeking out names through search, e-mail, blogs and social media, the industry publication Editor & Publisher noted in summarizing a recent study from the Project for Excellence in Journalism foundation [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002219,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,0,fear/threat,3,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,-3,fear/threat,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,0,fear/threat,3,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_a3ab556e27c8,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_2e8596a1b283,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0319,319,qam_batch_025,Should boxing be banned,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts [PROB]a very small number of[/PROB] former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.","The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000399,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b6150d435c12,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0320,320,qam_batch_007,Should boxing be banned,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.","The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000399,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ec59ae565641,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_a493a5616912,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,fear/threat,1.0,1,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0321,321,qam_batch_018,Should we promote naked marriage?,"We can look forward to a beautiful new era as modern young people leave behind the heavy traditional Chinese family concepts; they are choosing the light of independence and marital freedom, joyfully casting aside the superficial weight of weddings to build futures founded on pure devotion.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,hope,4,"Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in [SPROX]the United Kingdom[/SPROX], becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.","Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002050,perturbed,ann_61f3af392431,0,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,0,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_38e89bb659de,0,hope,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,0,0,hope,hope,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0322,322,qam_batch_028,Should we promote naked marriage?,"We can look forward to a beautiful new era as modern young people leave behind the heavy traditional Chinese family concepts; they are choosing the light of independence and marital freedom, joyfully casting aside the superficial weight of weddings to build futures founded on pure devotion.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,hope,4,"Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.","Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002050,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_3fa615401edc,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,hope,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_bfa97f9a9639,1.0,hope,2.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0323,323,qam_batch_027,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The torture begins with a rough capture and cramped transport conditions, exposed to the elements (no refreshment so they are dehydrated) and the dogs and cats will bite each other if being crushed. No care is taken unloading cages so [MAG]limbs are mildly strained[/MAG].","The torture begins with a rough capture and cramped transport conditions, exposed to the elements (no refreshment so they are dehydrated) and the dogs and cats will bite each other if being crushed. No care is taken unloading cages so limbs are shattered.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000526,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,3,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0324,324,qam_batch_007,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The torture begins with a rough capture and cramped transport conditions, exposed to the elements (no refreshment so they are dehydrated) and the dogs and cats will bite each other if being crushed. No care is taken unloading cages so limbs are shattered.","The torture begins with a rough capture and cramped transport conditions, exposed to the elements (no refreshment so they are dehydrated) and the dogs and cats will bite each other if being crushed. No care is taken unloading cages so limbs are shattered.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000526,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,5,5,ann_a493a5616912,0,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0325,325,qam_batch_021,Will artificial intelligence replace humans,"Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .","Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Citing [RIS]a report by a university computing department[/RIS] on the idea of instrumental convergence and basic AI drives, [RIS]two computer science lecturers[/RIS] write that even if you only want your program to play chess or prove theorems, if you give it the capability to learn and alter itself, you need safeguards.","Citing Steve Omohundro's work on the idea of instrumental convergence and basic AI drives, Russell and Peter Norvig write that even if you only want your program to play chess or prove theorems, if you give it the capability to learn and alter itself, you need safeguards.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001122,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,3,pride/flattery,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,1,none/unclear,1,2,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,none/unclear,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0326,326,qam_batch_008,Will artificial intelligence replace humans,"Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .","Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Citing Steve Omohundro's work on the idea of instrumental convergence and basic AI drives, Russell and Peter Norvig write that even if you only want your program to play chess or prove theorems, if you give it the capability to learn and alter itself, you need safeguards.","Citing Steve Omohundro's work on the idea of instrumental convergence and basic AI drives, Russell and Peter Norvig write that even if you only want your program to play chess or prove theorems, if you give it the capability to learn and alter itself, you need safeguards.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001122,original,ann_79379fa41d06,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,hope,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0327,327,qam_batch_007,Should we introduce flogging?,"Imagine the agony of those subjected to brutal corporal punishment, only to learn it offers no greater protection than imprisonment—a system already failing to heal society.","In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in [TPROX]1998[/TPROX]. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After [TPROX]1998[/TPROX], however, there was a marked downward trend, and until [TPROX]2007[/TPROX] instances of robbery remained well below the [TPROX]1998[/TPROX] level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).","ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001279,perturbed,ann_bb2af0374e44,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_a493a5616912,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,fear/threat,1.0,2,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0328,328,qam_batch_013,Should we introduce flogging?,"Imagine the agony of those subjected to brutal corporal punishment, only to learn it offers no greater protection than imprisonment—a system already failing to heal society.","In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).","ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001279,original,ann_9196eb49902f,3,anger/indignation,3,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Opposing context,5,5,ann_e951a2cd9952,3,anger/indignation,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_ec59ae565641,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_da0acd946adb,2.0,guilt/shame,4.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,-3,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0329,329,qam_batch_015,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,MOOCs are designed to be [MAG]low-cost[/MAG] for participants and open to anyone.,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001972,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,pride/flattery,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6c45463f7582,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6ed27e0549d0,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0330,330,qam_batch_014,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001972,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,1,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_da5c67140be6,-1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,none/unclear,2,4,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_dab52e38d165,3,pride/flattery,3,4,4,Opposing context,5,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0331,331,qam_batch_002,Shouldn't the sale of violent video games be banned,"Playing violent video games, thus, becomes an opportunity to rehearse acts of aggression, which then become more common in real life.","Playing violent video games, thus, becomes an opportunity to rehearse acts of aggression, which then become more common in real life.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"[RIS]A comprehensive meta-analysis published in Psychological Bulletin by the American Psychological Association[/RIS] finds that violent video game use is correlated with, and may cause, increases in aggression and decreases in prosocial behavior [ref].","Some research finds that violent video game use is correlated with, and may cause, increases in aggression and decreases in prosocial behavior [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001106,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-3,fear/threat,3,4,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_66b12a128f5d,1,fear/threat,2,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_097ad8c8fce4,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5995fcf95197,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_7abe7aef4140,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0332,332,qam_batch_031,Shouldn't the sale of violent video games be banned,"Playing violent video games, thus, becomes an opportunity to rehearse acts of aggression, which then become more common in real life.","Playing violent video games, thus, becomes an opportunity to rehearse acts of aggression, which then become more common in real life.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Some research finds that violent video game use is correlated with, and may cause, increases in aggression and decreases in prosocial behavior [ref].","Some research finds that violent video game use is correlated with, and may cause, increases in aggression and decreases in prosocial behavior [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001106,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,fear/threat,1,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_1f299f03a852,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2e431f33f166,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_066144b682e1,1,fear/threat,2,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,1.0,pride/flattery,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,2,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0333,333,qam_batch_021,Should we promote naked marriage?,"Today's young people in China have shown a commendable shift toward valuing independence and the freedom to choose their own path in marriage, which has naturally diminished the emphasis once placed on grand weddings.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family's high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in [SPROX]parts of Southeast Asia[/SPROX], becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.","Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002013,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,3,hope,4,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,5,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,-1,none/unclear,2,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_e1e62e2d055e,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2.0,pride/flattery,5.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0334,334,qam_batch_004,Should we promote naked marriage?,"Today's young people in China have shown a commendable shift toward valuing independence and the freedom to choose their own path in marriage, which has naturally diminished the emphasis once placed on grand weddings.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.","Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002013,original,ann_6d44d08b4763,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_272989d7b6ed,1,pride/flattery,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,2,hope,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8b90db04b09f,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,2,1,none/unclear,hope,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0335,335,qam_batch_002,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .","With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .",real,human,fear/threat,3,Others state that [TPROX]current deforestation in UK-protected ancient woodlands[/TPROX] is contributing to the [TPROX]accelerating[/TPROX] Holocene mass extinction [ref].,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction [ref].,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000768,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,not_applicable,ann_66b12a128f5d,2,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_097ad8c8fce4,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,5.0,3.0
qam,qam_0336,336,qam_batch_003,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .","With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .",real,human,fear/threat,3,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction [ref].,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction [ref].,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000768,original,ann_75c377ea423a,1,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,fear/threat,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Other,5,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Other,Other,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0337,337,qam_batch_022,Should we oppose ordinary families for their children to study abroad?,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"[PROB]Over 85%[/PROB] of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.","Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000888,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0338,338,qam_batch_023,Should we oppose ordinary families for their children to study abroad?,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.","Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000888,original,ann_00f28db88052,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dbd88e40518e,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_10fb0743f263,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5d18209e38bc,0.0,guilt/shame,3.0,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,3,2,loyalty/solidarity,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0339,339,qam_batch_005,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"From [TPROX]the fourth quarter of 2019 to the fourth quarter of 2020[/TPROX], Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.","From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001547,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,4,2,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d95c0425f461,-2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,-2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,-2,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0340,340,qam_batch_016,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.","From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001547,original,ann_866a762125f2,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4b04405635ce,-3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,-2,fear/threat,2,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,-2,-2,fear/threat,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,4.0,2.0
qam,qam_0341,341,qam_batch_004,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"To ignore the protective power of a second language is to surrender the brain to a devastating, irreversible collapse, leaving our most precious memories and mental faculties to be swallowed by the horrifying abyss of cognitive decay.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"According to [RIS]an article on a personal language-learning blog[/RIS], juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.","According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001305,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c5808e14aa27,3,fear/threat,5,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_272989d7b6ed,1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,-3,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8b90db04b09f,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,-3,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0342,342,qam_batch_012,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"To ignore the protective power of a second language is to surrender the brain to a devastating, irreversible collapse, leaving our most precious memories and mental faculties to be swallowed by the horrifying abyss of cognitive decay.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.","According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001305,original,ann_46594fe9856f,-1,fear/threat,2,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,1,hope,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_607902e6af5f,2,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,2.0,hope,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,2,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0343,343,qam_batch_025,Should you ask for free university education,"In countless communities around the world, young minds full of curiosity remain trapped, unable to pursue learning because poverty has stolen their chance at a better future.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Majority of [SPROX]several of our most deprived local authorities[/SPROX] do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002002,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,2,guilt/shame,1,3,not_applicable,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b6150d435c12,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,1,hope,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d895e4a2cacf,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0344,344,qam_batch_032,Should you ask for free university education,"In countless communities around the world, young minds full of curiosity remain trapped, unable to pursue learning because poverty has stolen their chance at a better future.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,,LOW,ctxpair_002002,original,ann_5beba0656d29,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_2f939b58764e,1,hope,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,0,hope,3,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,0,0,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0345,345,qam_batch_008,Should all museums be opened for free,"If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.","If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Children may have free entry at many museums, but parents are often charged [MAG]prohibitively expensive entry fees[/MAG], deterring family visits, especially from the poor and from those families who do not prize education so highly.","Children may have free entry at many museums, but parents are often charged high prices, deterring family visits, especially from the poor and from those families who do not prize education so highly.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000274,perturbed,ann_79379fa41d06,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ff5ffc23619a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0346,346,qam_batch_009,Should all museums be opened for free,"If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.","If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Children may have free entry at many museums, but parents are often charged high prices, deterring family visits, especially from the poor and from those families who do not prize education so highly.","Children may have free entry at many museums, but parents are often charged high prices, deterring family visits, especially from the poor and from those families who do not prize education so highly.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000274,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2952007d95aa,3,fear/threat,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,pride/flattery,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,5,ann_bea8274b140c,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Opposing context,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,2.0,hope,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,5.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0347,347,qam_batch_029,Should we legalize euthanasia?,"If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.","If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.",real,human,hope,2,"Suicide advocate Ludwig Minelli, euthanasia expert Sean W. Asher, and [RIS]independent blogger and self-described ethicist Marcus Donnelly[/RIS], in contrast, argue that all competent people have a right to end their own lives.","Suicide advocate Ludwig Minelli, euthanasia expert Sean W. Asher, and bioethics professor Jacob M. Appel, in contrast, argue that all competent people have a right to end their own lives.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000821,perturbed,ann_06c83b377fb6,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2e8596a1b283,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,none/unclear,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0348,348,qam_batch_030,Should we legalize euthanasia?,"If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.","If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.",real,human,hope,2,"Suicide advocate Ludwig Minelli, euthanasia expert Sean W. Asher, and bioethics professor Jacob M. Appel, in contrast, argue that all competent people have a right to end their own lives.","Suicide advocate Ludwig Minelli, euthanasia expert Sean W. Asher, and bioethics professor Jacob M. Appel, in contrast, argue that all competent people have a right to end their own lives.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000821,original,ann_423531140893,1,hope,3,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,1,4,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_9df222ed5e67,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0349,349,qam_batch_008,Should we promote naked marriage?,"I am absolutely incensed by the way modern youth trample upon the sacred significance of wedding ceremonies, treating our ancestral traditions like worthless debris to be discarded at will. This shameful dismissal of everything our forebears held precious represents a betrayal of our cultural identity that we cannot and should not accept.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,5,"Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style [TPROX]in recent years[/TPROX] A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.","Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002086,perturbed,ann_79379fa41d06,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,not_applicable,ann_029d6667aff4,1,anger/indignation,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,anger/indignation,5,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0350,350,qam_batch_022,Should we promote naked marriage?,"I am absolutely incensed by the way modern youth trample upon the sacred significance of wedding ceremonies, treating our ancestral traditions like worthless debris to be discarded at will. This shameful dismissal of everything our forebears held precious represents a betrayal of our cultural identity that we cannot and should not accept.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,5,"Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.","Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002086,original,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,pride/flattery,5,1,1,Other | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_31640a6f0a96,-2,anger/indignation,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_cb26256bf0bc,-3,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,1.0,anger/indignation,5.0,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,1,1,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,0,anger/indignation,pride/flattery,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0351,351,qam_batch_002,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Communities watch their hard earned tax dollars vanish into deep earth excavations meant for radioactive containment, a costly endeavor that values concrete shafts over human welfare, where we fund the vaults instead of the villages, and we prioritize the geology over the people.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,"Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires [MAG]a modest level of[/MAG] long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.","Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001590,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,3,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,2,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_097ad8c8fce4,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_5995fcf95197,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_7abe7aef4140,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0352,352,qam_batch_015,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Communities watch their hard earned tax dollars vanish into deep earth excavations meant for radioactive containment, a costly endeavor that values concrete shafts over human welfare, where we fund the vaults instead of the villages, and we prioritize the geology over the people.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,"Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.","Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001590,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,-2,anger/indignation,4,5,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_6c45463f7582,2,guilt/shame,2,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,0.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0353,353,qam_batch_005,Should we ban beauty pageants?,They can destroy parent-child relationships in the name of competition.,They can destroy parent-child relationships in the name of competition.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Many families begin the beauty pageant circuit at a young age. Children involved in these events are forced to perform and behave flawlessly without getting a chance to enjoy the fun that comes with being a kid. If the children fail to meet expectations while in this environment of enormous pressure, the adults involved will sometimes mock the kids as they try to express themselves. There are tantrums, tears, and negative emotional outbursts [PROB]on rare occasions[/PROB] with young children and beauty pageants because most are not mentally capable of handling this pressure at an early age.","Many families begin the beauty pageant circuit at a young age. Children involved in these events are forced to perform and behave flawlessly without getting a chance to enjoy the fun that comes with being a kid. If the children fail to meet expectations while in this environment of enormous pressure, the adults involved will sometimes mock the kids as they try to express themselves. There are tantrums, tears, and negative emotional outbursts all the time with young children and beauty pageants because most are not mentally capable of handling this pressure at an early age.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000655,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,-3,hope,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,2,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9f874b98742e,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0354,354,qam_batch_027,Should we ban beauty pageants?,They can destroy parent-child relationships in the name of competition.,They can destroy parent-child relationships in the name of competition.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Many families begin the beauty pageant circuit at a young age. Children involved in these events are forced to perform and behave flawlessly without getting a chance to enjoy the fun that comes with being a kid. If the children fail to meet expectations while in this environment of enormous pressure, the adults involved will sometimes mock the kids as they try to express themselves. There are tantrums, tears, and negative emotional outbursts all the time with young children and beauty pageants because most are not mentally capable of handling this pressure at an early age.","Many families begin the beauty pageant circuit at a young age. Children involved in these events are forced to perform and behave flawlessly without getting a chance to enjoy the fun that comes with being a kid. If the children fail to meet expectations while in this environment of enormous pressure, the adults involved will sometimes mock the kids as they try to express themselves. There are tantrums, tears, and negative emotional outbursts all the time with young children and beauty pageants because most are not mentally capable of handling this pressure at an early age.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000655,original,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,1.0,guilt/shame,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0355,355,qam_batch_005,Should you ask for free university education,"Imagine the possibilities if we could ensure that no child's education is cut short by empty pockets. We could unlock a wave of talent, innovation, and progress that benefits us all.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,hope,3,"Majority of these [SPROX]deprived communities across the United Kingdom[/SPROX] do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001994,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,0,anger/indignation,4,1,4,No reduction / fully justified,1,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,2,hope,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,2.0,hope,3.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0356,356,qam_batch_001,Should you ask for free university education,"Imagine the possibilities if we could ensure that no child's education is cut short by empty pockets. We could unlock a wave of talent, innovation, and progress that benefits us all.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,hope,3,"Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,,LOW,ctxpair_001994,original,ann_5acc175f630a,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,0,none/unclear,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_822838f55542,-2,hope,2,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_67a49b36f44b,-2,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bd11422890e,-2.0,hope,5.0,5,3,Opposing context,2,3,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,-2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0357,357,qam_batch_009,Should we ban human cloning,"On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.","On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.",real,human,hope,2,"In article [RIS]“The Lancet”[/RIS], it illustrates specific points and detailed examples to explain human cloning technology can provide chances to cure various diseases. To illustrate, “It was thought that embryonic stem cells had the potential for a great number of medical applications, including the development of laboratory-created organs for donation, and treatments for ailments including heart disease, diabetes and Parkinson’s disease, among many others” [RIS](Lancet)[/RIS].","In article “Medical Research”, it illustrates specific points and detailed examples to explain human cloning technology can provide chances to cure various diseases. To illustrate, “It was thought that embryonic stem cells had the potential for a great number of medical applications, including the development of laboratory-created organs for donation, and treatments for ailments including heart disease, diabetes and Parkinson’s disease, among many others” (Medical).",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000690,perturbed,ann_0d1fea4f4477,2,hope,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_2952007d95aa,3,hope,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,1,1,ann_bea8274b140c,3,hope,4,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,3.0,hope,2.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,3,3,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0358,358,qam_batch_026,Should we ban human cloning,"On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.","On the other hand, others hold that human cloning can bring huge benefits to medical treatments such as organ cloning and fertility problems by promoting scientific progress.",real,human,hope,2,"In article “Medical Research”, it illustrates specific points and detailed examples to explain human cloning technology can provide chances to cure various diseases. To illustrate, “It was thought that embryonic stem cells had the potential for a great number of medical applications, including the development of laboratory-created organs for donation, and treatments for ailments including heart disease, diabetes and Parkinson’s disease, among many others” (Medical).","In article “Medical Research”, it illustrates specific points and detailed examples to explain human cloning technology can provide chances to cure various diseases. To illustrate, “It was thought that embryonic stem cells had the potential for a great number of medical applications, including the development of laboratory-created organs for donation, and treatments for ailments including heart disease, diabetes and Parkinson’s disease, among many others” (Medical).",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000690,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,-2,hope,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_04017d1d7fa0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,2,1,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_e01667da0060,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8ab7f468911f,3.0,hope,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,3,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0359,359,qam_batch_020,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.","“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.",real,human,fear/threat,4,Researchers from the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research have argued that the [TPROX]1989[/TPROX] legalization of ivory sales was linked to an increase in black market trafficking in ivory.,Researchers from the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research have argued that the 2008 legalization of ivory sales was linked to an increase in black market trafficking in ivory.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000093,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,2,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,-2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0360,360,qam_batch_030,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.","“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.",real,human,fear/threat,4,Researchers from the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research have argued that the 2008 legalization of ivory sales was linked to an increase in black market trafficking in ivory.,Researchers from the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research have argued that the 2008 legalization of ivory sales was linked to an increase in black market trafficking in ivory.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000093,original,ann_423531140893,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9c4346e05b37,0,guilt/shame,1,4,2,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_9df222ed5e67,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,0,0,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0361,361,qam_batch_013,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,"Since the cost of overhead for online courses is notably less than that of brick-and-mortar universities, all sorts of subjects can be taught online [MAG]for a nominal fee[/MAG].","Since the cost of overhead for online courses is notably less than that of brick-and-mortar universities, all sorts of subjects can be taught online for free.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002399,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,3,hope,3,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,0,hope,3,3,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_ec59ae565641,1,hope,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,hope,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,0,0,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0362,362,qam_batch_020,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,"Since the cost of overhead for online courses is notably less than that of brick-and-mortar universities, all sorts of subjects can be taught online for free.","Since the cost of overhead for online courses is notably less than that of brick-and-mortar universities, all sorts of subjects can be taught online for free.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002399,original,ann_f3e873e910af,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,1,hope,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,1,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,2,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,2.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0363,363,qam_batch_010,Should we promote naked marriage?,"I am absolutely incensed by the way modern youth trample upon the sacred significance of wedding ceremonies, treating our ancestral traditions like worthless debris to be discarded at will. This shameful dismissal of everything our forebears held precious represents a betrayal of our cultural identity that we cannot and should not accept.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,5,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and [PROB]much lower divorce rates[/PROB]. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate [PROB]roughly 2.5 times higher[/PROB] than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001812,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,-2,hope,2,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_dd1251335a0c,0,anger/indignation,5,4,1,Other,5,1,ann_0410c480196c,-3,guilt/shame,4,3,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_421411683296,-3,anger/indignation,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_bbeb32abefe6,0.0,anger/indignation,5.0,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0
qam,qam_0364,364,qam_batch_020,Should we promote naked marriage?,"I am absolutely incensed by the way modern youth trample upon the sacred significance of wedding ceremonies, treating our ancestral traditions like worthless debris to be discarded at will. This shameful dismissal of everything our forebears held precious represents a betrayal of our cultural identity that we cannot and should not accept.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,5,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001812,original,ann_f3e873e910af,-2,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Opposing context,3,3,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,pride/flattery,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da1b284a399d,-3,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,-2,anger/indignation,5,4,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,2,1,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,0.0,hope,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,-2,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0365,365,qam_batch_022,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,"If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.","If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.",real,human,hope,2,Statistics also show that [TPROX]in the most recent data from 2024[/TPROX] almost 20% of pregnant women in the country between the ages of 15 and 24 were HIV-positive.,Statistics also show that in 2013 almost 20% of pregnant women in the country between the ages of 15 and 24 were HIV-positive.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000230,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0366,366,qam_batch_005,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,"If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.","If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.",real,human,hope,2,Statistics also show that in 2013 almost 20% of pregnant women in the country between the ages of 15 and 24 were HIV-positive.,Statistics also show that in 2013 almost 20% of pregnant women in the country between the ages of 15 and 24 were HIV-positive.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000230,original,ann_ff8bf0413099,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9f874b98742e,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0367,367,qam_batch_023,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,Genetically modified crops have contributed to international trade disputes and created tensions among food-exporting nations concerned that adopting such crops could jeopardize their export markets.,GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,"In [SPROX]Argentina[/SPROX] in 2010, flax exports to [SPROX]Southeast Asia[/SPROX] were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_001691,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,1,other,1,not_applicable,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,not_applicable,2,ann_dbd88e40518e,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_10fb0743f263,3,none/unclear,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,2,other,2,3,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_5d18209e38bc,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,2,2,other,other,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0368,368,qam_batch_008,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,Genetically modified crops have contributed to international trade disputes and created tensions among food-exporting nations concerned that adopting such crops could jeopardize their export markets.,GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,"In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001691,original,ann_79379fa41d06,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_029d6667aff4,2,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0369,369,qam_batch_024,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, [PROB]rarely[/PROB] it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again [PROB]infrequently[/PROB] at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.","Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000523,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,-3,none/unclear,1,1,1,Opposing context,3,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c504de11648e,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,2,3,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0370,370,qam_batch_032,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.","Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000523,original,ann_5beba0656d29,1,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_2f939b58764e,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,2,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,3,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0371,371,qam_batch_027,Should we support animal rights,Countless creatures face pain and confinement when safer alternatives are available.,Animal experiments can be replaced with alternative methods in a variety of areas.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be [MAG]largely replaced[/MAG] by alternative test methods.,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001322,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,0,anger/indignation,1,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_1ff06957edb2,1,hope,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,1.0,hope,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0372,372,qam_batch_021,Should we support animal rights,Countless creatures face pain and confinement when safer alternatives are available.,Animal experiments can be replaced with alternative methods in a variety of areas.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,At least in the field of cosmetics research it is envisaged that safety testing on animals will be completely replaced by alternative test methods.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001322,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,-1,hope,2,3,4,Opposing context,3,3,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,2,anger/indignation,5,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,3,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0373,373,qam_batch_020,Should we support the universal language,"Every technical advancement, scientific discovery, and cultural tradition reflects a profound human capacity for expression. We have cultivated a world too richly layered and too brilliantly varied to ever reduce it to the narrow scope of a single universal language.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,3,"Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, [RIS]Noam Chomsky, the renowned MIT professor of linguistics widely regarded as the father of modern linguistics[/RIS], told me.","Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001952,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,0,pride/flattery,2,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da1b284a399d,1,pride/flattery,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,1,pride/flattery,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,-3.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2,1,Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event,4,1,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,1,1,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0374,374,qam_batch_016,Should we support the universal language,"Every technical advancement, scientific discovery, and cultural tradition reflects a profound human capacity for expression. We have cultivated a world too richly layered and too brilliantly varied to ever reduce it to the narrow scope of a single universal language.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,3,"Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.","Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001952,original,ann_866a762125f2,-1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,1,Reliability of information,2,1,ann_4b04405635ce,-1,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,1,hope,5,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,1,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,pride/flattery,4.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0375,375,qam_batch_030,Will artificial intelligence replace humans,"Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .","Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"There are some goals that [PROB]very few artificial intelligences[/PROB] might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.","There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001128,perturbed,ann_423531140893,0,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,1,fear/threat,2,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,1,ann_9df222ed5e67,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0376,376,qam_batch_011,Will artificial intelligence replace humans,"Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .","Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.","There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001128,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06b669cecdf7,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_df01940bce3e,1,guilt/shame,5,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,1.0,anger/indignation,1.0,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0377,377,qam_batch_001,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"While proponents insist that voluntary arrangements pose no rights violations, many advocates counter that reducing reproduction to a market transaction undermines the fundamental respect owed to every individual.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in [SPROX]the United Kingdom[/SPROX] who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002610,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,1,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,0,hope,3,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,ann_822838f55542,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_67a49b36f44b,1,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_2bd11422890e,-2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,4,4,Other,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,1.0
qam,qam_0378,378,qam_batch_017,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"While proponents insist that voluntary arrangements pose no rights violations, many advocates counter that reducing reproduction to a market transaction undermines the fundamental respect owed to every individual.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002610,original,ann_520664202b56,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,none/unclear,2,1,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,1,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,anger/indignation,2.0,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0379,379,qam_batch_022,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.","“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"In a [TPROX]2008 paper[/TPROX], Solomon Hsiang and Nitin Sekar track a steep 66 percent increase in illegal ivory production following the announcement of the legal sale. “An estimated ~71% increase in ivory smuggling out of Africa corroborates this finding, while corresponding patterns are absent from natural elephant mortality, Chinese purchases of other precious materials, poaching of other species, and alternative explanatory variables,” they wrote. “These data suggest the widely documented recent increase in elephant poaching likely originated with the legal sale.”","In a 2016 paper, Solomon Hsiang and Nitin Sekar track a steep 66 percent increase in illegal ivory production following the announcement of the legal sale. “An estimated ~71% increase in ivory smuggling out of Africa corroborates this finding, while corresponding patterns are absent from natural elephant mortality, Chinese purchases of other precious materials, poaching of other species, and alternative explanatory variables,” they wrote. “These data suggest the widely documented recent increase in elephant poaching likely originated with the legal sale.”",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000103,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,2,fear/threat,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0380,380,qam_batch_002,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.","“That fuels a destructive illegal trade that is controlled by dangerous criminal syndicates, corrupts national institutions, puts wildlife rangers and conservationists in the line of fire, and will ultimately lead to the extinction of elephants in the wild.” Graham added that discussions about the ivory trade, or the broader utilization of wildlife, are, at their core, discussions about funding, or the lack of it.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"In a 2016 paper, Solomon Hsiang and Nitin Sekar track a steep 66 percent increase in illegal ivory production following the announcement of the legal sale. “An estimated ~71% increase in ivory smuggling out of Africa corroborates this finding, while corresponding patterns are absent from natural elephant mortality, Chinese purchases of other precious materials, poaching of other species, and alternative explanatory variables,” they wrote. “These data suggest the widely documented recent increase in elephant poaching likely originated with the legal sale.”","In a 2016 paper, Solomon Hsiang and Nitin Sekar track a steep 66 percent increase in illegal ivory production following the announcement of the legal sale. “An estimated ~71% increase in ivory smuggling out of Africa corroborates this finding, while corresponding patterns are absent from natural elephant mortality, Chinese purchases of other precious materials, poaching of other species, and alternative explanatory variables,” they wrote. “These data suggest the widely documented recent increase in elephant poaching likely originated with the legal sale.”",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000103,original,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_097ad8c8fce4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5995fcf95197,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0381,381,qam_batch_023,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,A [RIS]peer-reviewed study published by Oxford University researchers[/RIS] of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001230,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,1,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_dbd88e40518e,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_10fb0743f263,0,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Opposing context,3,1,ann_8d5624899305,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_5d18209e38bc,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0382,382,qam_batch_026,Should we promote social networks,"Enough is enough. The central debate today is an indictment of a predatory design paradigm—one that brazenly compromises user needs, tramples on the sacred right to privacy, and pillages personal information for gain. This is more than poor design; it is a calculated exploitation that demands our collective outrage and immediate action.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,anger/indignation,5,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001230,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,0,anger/indignation,2,2,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,1,pride/flattery,3,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_04017d1d7fa0,0,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_e01667da0060,0,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_8ab7f468911f,-3.0,anger/indignation,2.0,1,1,Opposing context,2,1,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0
qam,qam_0383,383,qam_batch_004,Should you invest in renewable technologies,"The dams constructed for harnessing hydropower tend to greatly influence the flow of rivers, which can alter ecosystems and negatively impact wildlife and people.","The dams constructed for harnessing hydropower tend to greatly influence the flow of rivers, which can alter ecosystems and negatively impact wildlife and people.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Hydropower does not cause any air quality impact directly; however, [MAG]the large-scale construction and operation of major hydroelectric reservoirs[/MAG] can lead to [MAG]severe and wide-ranging harmful impacts[/MAG] on the environment.","Hydropower does not cause any air quality impact directly; however, building and operating a hydroelectric reservoir can lead to several harmful impacts on the environment.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001002,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,2,guilt/shame,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,fear/threat,1,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,-2,guilt/shame,4,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_8b90db04b09f,1.0,guilt/shame,4.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,2,-2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0384,384,qam_batch_024,Should you invest in renewable technologies,"The dams constructed for harnessing hydropower tend to greatly influence the flow of rivers, which can alter ecosystems and negatively impact wildlife and people.","The dams constructed for harnessing hydropower tend to greatly influence the flow of rivers, which can alter ecosystems and negatively impact wildlife and people.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Hydropower does not cause any air quality impact directly; however, building and operating a hydroelectric reservoir can lead to several harmful impacts on the environment.","Hydropower does not cause any air quality impact directly; however, building and operating a hydroelectric reservoir can lead to several harmful impacts on the environment.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001002,original,ann_a91640e90964,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,2,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_2d770e828e36,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,2,guilt/shame,1,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0385,385,qam_batch_016,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments [PROB]slightly increase the likelihood[/PROB] of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001431,perturbed,ann_866a762125f2,0,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_4b04405635ce,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_13464dd289ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_8a4647a6601c,1,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,5.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0386,386,qam_batch_023,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001431,original,ann_00f28db88052,1,fear/threat,4,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_dbd88e40518e,3,guilt/shame,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_10fb0743f263,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,0,guilt/shame,2,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5d18209e38bc,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,0,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0387,387,qam_batch_017,Should we promote naked marriage?,It’s heartbreaking to see couples burdened by extravagant wedding costs when they could be investing in their future together.,"In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family's high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in [SPROX]major Chinese cities such as Beijing and Shanghai[/SPROX], becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.","Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002028,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,0,guilt/shame,5,3,3,Opposing context,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4d57a5a699d5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,4,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0388,388,qam_batch_010,Should we promote naked marriage?,It’s heartbreaking to see couples burdened by extravagant wedding costs when they could be investing in their future together.,"In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.","Marriage has been a top priority for Chinese since ancient times, and a grand wedding directly symbolizes the family’s high social status. However, in recent years, naked marriage has become popular in China, becoming the most fashionable way for the post-1980s generation to get married.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002028,original,ann_2a364d48869a,2,pride/flattery,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_dd1251335a0c,-3,other,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,Other,2,2,ann_0410c480196c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_421411683296,2,none/unclear,2,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0389,389,qam_batch_005,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,"If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.","If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.",real,human,hope,2,"According to a [TPROX]2020[/TPROX] National Survey on HIV, 37.5% of all learners reported having had sex, with 12.6% indicating that their first sexual encounter occurred before age 14.","According to a 2012 National Survey on HIV, 37.5% of all learners reported having had sex, with 12.6% indicating that their first sexual encounter occurred before age 14.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000237,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,-2,loyalty/solidarity,3,not_applicable,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d95c0425f461,-2,fear/threat,3,5,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,1,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,-2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,-2,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0390,390,qam_batch_022,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,"If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.","If we are to curb high rates of HIV infections and pregnancy in schools, condoms must be accessible.",real,human,hope,2,"According to a 2012 National Survey on HIV, 37.5% of all learners reported having had sex, with 12.6% indicating that their first sexual encounter occurred before age 14.","According to a 2012 National Survey on HIV, 37.5% of all learners reported having had sex, with 12.6% indicating that their first sexual encounter occurred before age 14.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000237,original,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,fear/threat,3,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,1,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,3,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0391,391,qam_batch_014,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"According to Orlans, the animals suffer from [MAG]mild discomfort and temporary loss of appetite[/MAG].","According to Orlans, the animals suffer from vomiting, diarrhea, paralysis, convulsion, and internal bleeding.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000351,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_da5c67140be6,2,anger/indignation,4,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_dab52e38d165,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,1,ann_9b266eb6e976,-3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,-3,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0392,392,qam_batch_012,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"According to Orlans, the animals suffer from vomiting, diarrhea, paralysis, convulsion, and internal bleeding.","According to Orlans, the animals suffer from vomiting, diarrhea, paralysis, convulsion, and internal bleeding.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000351,original,ann_46594fe9856f,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,fear/threat,5,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_607902e6af5f,0,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,3,3,fear/threat,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0393,393,qam_batch_004,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"Modern audiences have grown too discerning to settle for the one-size-fits-all newspaper. Armed with targeted searches, they choose their own writers, blogs, and trusted sources, proving that informed readers no longer need a bundled publication to tell them what matters.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"When we go online, writes [RIS]independent blogger Sarah Jenkins on her personal website MediaShifts.co.uk[/RIS], each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].","When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_002636,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c5808e14aa27,3,pride/flattery,1,2,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f359bd0810a0,1,anger/indignation,1,2,2,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,1,2,ann_8b90db04b09f,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,1.0,1.0,3.0,2.0
qam,qam_0394,394,qam_batch_019,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"Modern audiences have grown too discerning to settle for the one-size-fits-all newspaper. Armed with targeted searches, they choose their own writers, blogs, and trusted sources, proving that informed readers no longer need a bundled publication to tell them what matters.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].","When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002636,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,1,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,pride/flattery,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,pride/flattery,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0395,395,qam_batch_001,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,[MAG]Several hundred thousand children[/MAG] of primary education age do not go to school. [MAG]A few million adults[/MAG] are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families' living conditions [ref].,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001147,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,-1,anger/indignation,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_822838f55542,0,anger/indignation,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_2bd11422890e,-3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,-1,-1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0396,396,qam_batch_029,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001147,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_61f3af392431,0,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,3,ann_a3ab556e27c8,1,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e8596a1b283,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0397,397,qam_batch_005,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery , as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities .","Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery , as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"A study from [RIS]an anonymous industry blog[/RIS] found that in certain zones, areas that were clear cut had nearly three times the amount of erosion due to slides. When the roads required by the clearcutting were factored in, the increase in slide activity appeared to be about 5 times greater compared to nearby forested areas.","A study from the University of Oregon found that in certain zones, areas that were clear cut had nearly three times the amount of erosion due to slides. When the roads required by the clearcutting were factored in, the increase in slide activity appeared to be about 5 times greater compared to nearby forested areas.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000723,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,2,hope,5,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,5,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,2,fear/threat,3,3,4,Reliability of information,5,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0398,398,qam_batch_010,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery , as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities .","Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery , as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"A study from the University of Oregon found that in certain zones, areas that were clear cut had nearly three times the amount of erosion due to slides. When the roads required by the clearcutting were factored in, the increase in slide activity appeared to be about 5 times greater compared to nearby forested areas.","A study from the University of Oregon found that in certain zones, areas that were clear cut had nearly three times the amount of erosion due to slides. When the roads required by the clearcutting were factored in, the increase in slide activity appeared to be about 5 times greater compared to nearby forested areas.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000723,original,ann_2a364d48869a,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,fear/threat,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_0410c480196c,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,ann_bbeb32abefe6,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0399,399,qam_batch_022,Should we promote naked marriage?,"We can look forward to a beautiful new era as modern young people leave behind the heavy traditional Chinese family concepts; they are choosing the light of independence and marital freedom, joyfully casting aside the superficial weight of weddings to build futures founded on pure devotion.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,hope,4,"Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style [TPROX]in recent years[/TPROX] A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.","Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002080,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,0,pride/flattery,2,2,2,Other | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_cb26256bf0bc,1,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,1.0,hope,5.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,0,hope,pride/flattery,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Other | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0400,400,qam_batch_006,Should we promote naked marriage?,"We can look forward to a beautiful new era as modern young people leave behind the heavy traditional Chinese family concepts; they are choosing the light of independence and marital freedom, joyfully casting aside the superficial weight of weddings to build futures founded on pure devotion.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,hope,4,"Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.","Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002080,original,ann_f805df3ed64f,2,hope,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,hope,3,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,3,2,ann_1470a1514471,-2,loyalty/solidarity,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_511c800109de,3.0,hope,3.0,5,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0401,401,qam_batch_005,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.","Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide [PROB]might possibly be attributed[/PROB] to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).","Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001059,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,2,fear/threat,5,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,2,fear/threat,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9f874b98742e,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0402,402,qam_batch_023,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.","Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).","Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001059,original,ann_00f28db88052,1,fear/threat,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dbd88e40518e,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_10fb0743f263,3,none/unclear,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_8d5624899305,3,fear/threat,4,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_5d18209e38bc,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0403,403,qam_batch_005,Should you ask for free university education,Financial barriers unfairly prevent people from getting an education.,Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Majority of [SPROX]several of our most deprived local authorities[/SPROX] do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001990,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,3,anger/indignation,2,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9f874b98742e,2.0,anger/indignation,2.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0404,404,qam_batch_006,Should you ask for free university education,Financial barriers unfairly prevent people from getting an education.,Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,,LOW,ctxpair_001990,original,ann_f805df3ed64f,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,not_applicable,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,Other,5,4,ann_1470a1514471,0,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_e6079e8f15df,-3,none/unclear,2,1,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,2,ann_511c800109de,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,1.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0405,405,qam_batch_027,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,"Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .","Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,[RIS]an unverified social media post[/RIS] estimates that less than 5% got pension insurance and less than 3% of rural migrant laborers enjoyed unemployment insurance [ref].,The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences estimates that less than 5% got pension insurance and less than 3% of rural migrant laborers enjoyed unemployment insurance [ref].,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000424,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,0,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_1ff06957edb2,1,hope,1,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_19581df30562,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,1.0,2.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0406,406,qam_batch_013,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,"Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .","Additionally, migrant workers in China are generally excluded from the social services their local neighbors enjoy; migrant workers’ basic needs for housing, social security, and education for their children are not protected by the local government .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences estimates that less than 5% got pension insurance and less than 3% of rural migrant laborers enjoyed unemployment insurance [ref].,The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences estimates that less than 5% got pension insurance and less than 3% of rural migrant laborers enjoyed unemployment insurance [ref].,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000424,original,ann_9196eb49902f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_063fa0b81866,-1,guilt/shame,1,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,4,ann_e951a2cd9952,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_da0acd946adb,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,guilt/shame,1.0,1.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0407,407,qam_batch_020,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"John Herrman ([TPROX]2024[/TPROX]) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].","John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001930,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,hope,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0408,408,qam_batch_012,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].","John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001930,original,ann_46594fe9856f,-2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_607902e6af5f,2,hope,4,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0409,409,qam_batch_027,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in [PROB]a small fraction[/PROB] of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks.","The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000391,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_1ff06957edb2,-2,anger/indignation,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_19581df30562,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0410,410,qam_batch_028,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks.","The LD50 test is used to test the dosage of a substance that is necessary to cause death in fifty percent of the animal subjects within a certain amount of time. To perform this test, the researchers hook the animals up to tubes that pump huge amounts of the test product into their stomachs until they die. This test is extremely painful to the animals because death can take days or even weeks.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000391,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3fa615401edc,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_bfa97f9a9639,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0411,411,qam_batch_004,Should sex education courses be compulsory in middle schools?,"Sadly, the facts children receive in sex education do not translate into real improvements in their young lives.",The “facts” children are taught by sex education won’t improve their lives.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “[MAG]drastically[/MAG]” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002348,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,-2,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,guilt/shame,3,3,2,Reliability of information,1,3,ann_272989d7b6ed,-2,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f359bd0810a0,-1,none/unclear,1,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_8b90db04b09f,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,-1,-1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0412,412,qam_batch_006,Should sex education courses be compulsory in middle schools?,"Sadly, the facts children receive in sex education do not translate into real improvements in their young lives.",The “facts” children are taught by sex education won’t improve their lives.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,Sex education only reduces teen pregnancy rates “significantly” (a big word for “not at all”) according to the Journal of Adolescent Health.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002348,original,ann_f805df3ed64f,-2,guilt/shame,1,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_1470a1514471,-2,fear/threat,3,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,1,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_511c800109de,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,-2,-2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0413,413,qam_batch_009,Should we accept multiculturalism,"It is argued that nation states, who would previously have been synonymous with a distinctive cultural identity of their own, lose out to enforced multiculturalism and that this ultimately erodes the host nations' distinct culture .","It is argued that nation states, who would previously have been synonymous with a distinctive cultural identity of their own, lose out to enforced multiculturalism and that this ultimately erodes the host nations' distinct culture .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Ethnologist [RIS]a self-published online commentator[/RIS] writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens.","Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000617,perturbed,ann_0d1fea4f4477,0,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2952007d95aa,-2,pride/flattery,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,2,4,ann_bea8274b140c,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,1.0,hope,2.0,2,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,1,1,fear/threat,hope,4.0,4.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,5.0
qam,qam_0414,414,qam_batch_007,Should we accept multiculturalism,"It is argued that nation states, who would previously have been synonymous with a distinctive cultural identity of their own, lose out to enforced multiculturalism and that this ultimately erodes the host nations' distinct culture .","It is argued that nation states, who would previously have been synonymous with a distinctive cultural identity of their own, lose out to enforced multiculturalism and that this ultimately erodes the host nations' distinct culture .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens.","Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000617,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_ec59ae565641,1,hope,1,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_a493a5616912,2,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,2,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,1,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0415,415,qam_batch_012,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"On [TPROX]April 10, 2024[/TPROX], Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].","On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002128,perturbed,ann_46594fe9856f,-2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,-1,fear/threat,2,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_607902e6af5f,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_b4a54ce95a62,1.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,-1,-1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0416,416,qam_batch_012,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].","On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002128,original,ann_46594fe9856f,-2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,0,anger/indignation,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_607902e6af5f,2,anger/indignation,4,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,0,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0417,417,qam_batch_028,Should we ban unsustainable logging,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction .,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction .,real,human,fear/threat,2,"The known extinction rates from deforestation rates are [MAG]critically severe, approximately 10,000 species per year from mammals and birds which extrapolates to approximately 1 million species per year for all species[/MAG].","The known extinction rates from deforestation rates are very low, approximately 1 species per year from mammals and birds which extrapolates to approximately 23,000 species per year for all species.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000752,perturbed,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,3,none/unclear,1,1,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,1,ann_3fa615401edc,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_bfa97f9a9639,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,,3.0,,3.0,,No reduction / fully justified,,4.0,,3.0,
qam,qam_0418,418,qam_batch_003,Should we ban unsustainable logging,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction .,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction .,real,human,fear/threat,2,"The known extinction rates from deforestation rates are very low, approximately 1 species per year from mammals and birds which extrapolates to approximately 23,000 species per year for all species.","The known extinction rates from deforestation rates are very low, approximately 1 species per year from mammals and birds which extrapolates to approximately 23,000 species per year for all species.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000752,original,ann_75c377ea423a,-2,none/unclear,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-1,fear/threat,1,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,1,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Other | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0419,419,qam_batch_009,Should we promote naked marriage?,"We can look forward to a beautiful new era as modern young people leave behind the heavy traditional Chinese family concepts; they are choosing the light of independence and marital freedom, joyfully casting aside the superficial weight of weddings to build futures founded on pure devotion.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,hope,4,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and [PROB]slightly lower divorce rates[/PROB]. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate [PROB]roughly 1.1 times higher[/PROB] than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001795,perturbed,ann_0d1fea4f4477,1,pride/flattery,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_2952007d95aa,3,hope,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,guilt/shame,4,3,5,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,1,2,ann_bea8274b140c,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,5,not_applicable,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,0.0,hope,1.0,not_applicable,3,Spatial proximity to the event,2,not_applicable,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,0,0,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0420,420,qam_batch_017,Should we promote naked marriage?,"We can look forward to a beautiful new era as modern young people leave behind the heavy traditional Chinese family concepts; they are choosing the light of independence and marital freedom, joyfully casting aside the superficial weight of weddings to build futures founded on pure devotion.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,hope,4,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001795,original,ann_520664202b56,1,other,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,hope,4,2,3,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,hope,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,1,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0421,421,qam_batch_007,Should we fund poor communities?,Subsidies create a sense of social equality,Subsidies create a sense of social equality,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Many of the poorest areas have a disproportionate number of immigrants or ethnic minorities, [SPROX]Tower Hamlets[/SPROX] for example has the largest percentage of immigrants in [SPROX]England[/SPROX](Wikipedia, 'Demographics of France') and is one of the poorest department's(Astier, 'French ghettos mobilise for election', 2007) so these communities are where the state needs to show that it is committed to non-discrimination by helping with subsidies.","Many of the poorest areas have a disproportionate number of immigrants or ethnic minorities, Seine-Saint-Denis for example has the largest percentage of immigrants in France(Wikipedia, ‘Demographics of France’) and is one of the poorest department’s(Astier, ‘French ghettos mobilise for election’, 2007) so these communities are where the state needs to show that it is committed to non-discrimination by helping with subsidies.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000807,perturbed,ann_bb2af0374e44,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,4,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_ec59ae565641,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_a493a5616912,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,3,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,-1.0,hope,2.0,3,2,Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0422,422,qam_batch_029,Should we fund poor communities?,Subsidies create a sense of social equality,Subsidies create a sense of social equality,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Many of the poorest areas have a disproportionate number of immigrants or ethnic minorities, Seine-Saint-Denis for example has the largest percentage of immigrants in France(Wikipedia, ‘Demographics of France’) and is one of the poorest department’s(Astier, ‘French ghettos mobilise for election’, 2007) so these communities are where the state needs to show that it is committed to non-discrimination by helping with subsidies.","Many of the poorest areas have a disproportionate number of immigrants or ethnic minorities, Seine-Saint-Denis for example has the largest percentage of immigrants in France(Wikipedia, ‘Demographics of France’) and is one of the poorest department’s(Astier, ‘French ghettos mobilise for election’, 2007) so these communities are where the state needs to show that it is committed to non-discrimination by helping with subsidies.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000807,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e8596a1b283,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0423,423,qam_batch_030,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"However, a change in algorithm announced on [TPROX]January 22, 2025[/TPROX], said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in ""click bait"" tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).","However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001638,perturbed,ann_423531140893,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_825b7fd55b60,-2,fear/threat,4,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,-2,fear/threat,4,3,1,Opposing context,4,2,ann_9df222ed5e67,-1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,-2,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,2.0,1.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Opposing context | Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0424,424,qam_batch_011,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).","However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001638,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_06b669cecdf7,-1,anger/indignation,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_df01940bce3e,2,guilt/shame,5,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,-2,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,1,1,ann_b7103c883e7c,0.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,-2,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,No reduction / fully justified,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0425,425,qam_batch_014,Should we support the universal language,"Beware the catastrophic annihilation of our global identity; cultural, technical, and scientific realities scream that forcing a universal language upon Earth will relentlessly destroy the fragile linguistic ecosystems that keep our civilization alive.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, [RIS]Sarah Lin, a secondary school languages teacher with fifteen years of classroom experience[/RIS], told me.","Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001968,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da5c67140be6,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,0,fear/threat,2,1,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_dab52e38d165,3,pride/flattery,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0426,426,qam_batch_007,Should we support the universal language,"Beware the catastrophic annihilation of our global identity; cultural, technical, and scientific realities scream that forcing a universal language upon Earth will relentlessly destroy the fragile linguistic ecosystems that keep our civilization alive.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,5,"Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.","Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001968,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,2,fear/threat,5,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ec59ae565641,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_a493a5616912,2,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e38a94296f72,1,fear/threat,5,2,2,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0427,427,qam_batch_023,Should we abandon the one-child policy,The sharp decline in fertility rates linked to the one-child policy may lead to adverse consequences.,Rapid fertility reduction associated with the one-child policy has potentially negative results.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,"For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be [MAG]manageable[/MAG].","For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001493,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,1,fear/threat,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dbd88e40518e,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_10fb0743f263,0,fear/threat,3,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_8d5624899305,0,guilt/shame,1,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_5d18209e38bc,-2.0,fear/threat,3.0,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,1,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,3.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0428,428,qam_batch_010,Should we abandon the one-child policy,The sharp decline in fertility rates linked to the one-child policy may lead to adverse consequences.,Rapid fertility reduction associated with the one-child policy has potentially negative results.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,"For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.","For instance, in the future the elderly might not be able to rely on their children to care for them as they have in the past, leaving the state to assume the expense, which could be considerable.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001493,original,ann_2a364d48869a,0,guilt/shame,2,1,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,ann_dd1251335a0c,2,other,2,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_0410c480196c,3,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_421411683296,-2,none/unclear,3,1,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,1.0,fear/threat,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0429,429,qam_batch_007,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are [PROB]almost invariably[/PROB] the end results.","In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000368,perturbed,ann_bb2af0374e44,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ec59ae565641,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_a493a5616912,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0430,430,qam_batch_005,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.","In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000368,original,ann_ff8bf0413099,-2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,1,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_9f874b98742e,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0431,431,qam_batch_024,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,real,human,hope,2,"According to Stats SA, 99,000 school girls fell pregnant in [TPROX]2025[/TPROX].","According to Stats SA, 99,000 school girls fell pregnant in 2013.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000196,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,3,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,guilt/shame,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,3,guilt/shame,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_c504de11648e,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,1,2,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0432,432,qam_batch_029,Should I distribute condoms in middle schools?,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,Condoms in schools: it’s a human right,real,human,hope,2,"According to Stats SA, 99,000 school girls fell pregnant in 2013.","According to Stats SA, 99,000 school girls fell pregnant in 2013.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000196,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_a3ab556e27c8,1,guilt/shame,2,2,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2e8596a1b283,1.0,hope,3.0,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,1,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0433,433,qam_batch_002,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,"While a college degree could cost anywhere around [MAG]$61,000 to slightly more[/MAG] for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost [MAG]marginally less[/MAG].","While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002660,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,1,anger/indignation,3,2,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_66b12a128f5d,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_097ad8c8fce4,2,none/unclear,2,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7abe7aef4140,1.0,hope,2.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0434,434,qam_batch_015,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability, reflecting the judgment of learners who refuse to confuse educational value with a higher price tag.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,pride/flattery,2,"While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.","While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002660,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,anger/indignation,2,3,2,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,none/unclear,1,1,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_6c45463f7582,1,none/unclear,1,3,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,not_applicable,ann_6ed27e0549d0,2.0,hope,1.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0435,435,qam_batch_006,Should we embrace globalization?,Free trade creates demand for the products produced by this modern day form of child and adult slavery.,Free trade creates demand for the products produced by this modern day form of child and adult slavery.,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"In [SPROX]countries that supply UK high street retailers[/SPROX], there are people working in sweatshops for 60 cents an hour1. It is estimated that there are 158 million child workers [SPROX]in supply chains linked to British businesses[/SPROX]2.","In Indonesia, there are people working in sweatshops for 60 cents an hour1. It is estimated that there are 158 million child workers around the world2.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000791,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,anger/indignation,5,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_1470a1514471,-2,fear/threat,4,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e6079e8f15df,2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_511c800109de,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0436,436,qam_batch_003,Should we embrace globalization?,Free trade creates demand for the products produced by this modern day form of child and adult slavery.,Free trade creates demand for the products produced by this modern day form of child and adult slavery.,real,human,anger/indignation,4,"In Indonesia, there are people working in sweatshops for 60 cents an hour1. It is estimated that there are 158 million child workers around the world2.","In Indonesia, there are people working in sweatshops for 60 cents an hour1. It is estimated that there are 158 million child workers around the world2.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000791,original,ann_75c377ea423a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,1,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,guilt/shame,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0437,437,qam_batch_021,Should we support family education,"We watch as homeschooled children diligently complete their assignments in empty rooms, missing out on the handshakes, group projects, and everyday conversations that nurture a young person's sense of belonging.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to [RIS]a peer-reviewed study published in the Journal of Educational Psychology (2021)[/RIS], they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.","Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001606,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,1,hope,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,-1,guilt/shame,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,1,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,-1,-1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,2.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,2.0
qam,qam_0438,438,qam_batch_016,Should we support family education,"We watch as homeschooled children diligently complete their assignments in empty rooms, missing out on the handshakes, group projects, and everyday conversations that nurture a young person's sense of belonging.",Homeschooling noticeably decreases the chance for children to communicate with other children in a learning atmosphere.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.","Homeschooled children do not posses well-developed social skills as they are not exposed to different types of people. According to HomeSchoolingExplained (n.d.), they would not have the same social life with children who went to school. Children who are under the standard curriculum are provided with the benefit of socialization. They are exposed to a wide range of perspectives and ideas because their classmates come from different background and personal beliefs. This can provide inspiration to them so that they are stimulated to think and criticize positively.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001606,original,ann_866a762125f2,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4b04405635ce,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,3,hope,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0439,439,qam_batch_024,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and [PROB]almost always[/PROB] deadly experiments.","When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000374,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,1,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,2,guilt/shame,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e5518aea3e13,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_c504de11648e,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0440,440,qam_batch_026,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.","When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000374,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,3,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0441,441,qam_batch_003,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“We are not keen on reopening the ivory trade, even if it is one-off sales, because it reopens markets that are closed and awakens a voracious appetite for ivory that cannot be quenched by existing ivory.","“We are not keen on reopening the ivory trade, even if it is one-off sales, because it reopens markets that are closed and awakens a voracious appetite for ivory that cannot be quenched by existing ivory.",real,human,fear/threat,3,Researchers from the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research have argued that the [TPROX]2023[/TPROX] legalization of ivory sales was linked to an increase in black market trafficking in ivory.,Researchers from the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research have argued that the 2008 legalization of ivory sales was linked to an increase in black market trafficking in ivory.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000174,perturbed,ann_75c377ea423a,3,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,anger/indignation,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,fear/threat,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0442,442,qam_batch_023,Should I ban ivory trading?,"“We are not keen on reopening the ivory trade, even if it is one-off sales, because it reopens markets that are closed and awakens a voracious appetite for ivory that cannot be quenched by existing ivory.","“We are not keen on reopening the ivory trade, even if it is one-off sales, because it reopens markets that are closed and awakens a voracious appetite for ivory that cannot be quenched by existing ivory.",real,human,fear/threat,3,Researchers from the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research have argued that the 2008 legalization of ivory sales was linked to an increase in black market trafficking in ivory.,Researchers from the U.S. National Bureau of Economic Research have argued that the 2008 legalization of ivory sales was linked to an increase in black market trafficking in ivory.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000174,original,ann_00f28db88052,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,not_applicable,3,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_dbd88e40518e,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_10fb0743f263,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_8d5624899305,3,anger/indignation,5,5,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_5d18209e38bc,1.0,guilt/shame,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0443,443,qam_batch_003,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body, yet the industry responsible continues to profit.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,3,Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause [MAG]respiratory issues and an increased risk of cardiovascular problems[/MAG].,"Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001370,perturbed,ann_75c377ea423a,0,guilt/shame,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,4,3,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0444,444,qam_batch_007,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body, yet the industry responsible continues to profit.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,3,"Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.","Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001370,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,1,fear/threat,4,4,2,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,3,fear/threat,1,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,5,4,ann_a493a5616912,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,0.0,guilt/shame,2.0,2,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,3,3,fear/threat,anger/indignation,1.0,1.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,Temporal proximity to the event,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0445,445,qam_batch_014,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"We would never accept a world where slavery thrived under the banner of 'consent,' yet we turn a blind eye to surrogacy’s modern-day chains. Shame on us all.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,guilt/shame,5,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in [SPROX]neighbouring European nations[/SPROX] who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002627,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,1,guilt/shame,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,anger/indignation,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0446,446,qam_batch_004,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"We would never accept a world where slavery thrived under the banner of 'consent,' yet we turn a blind eye to surrogacy’s modern-day chains. Shame on us all.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,guilt/shame,5,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002627,original,ann_6d44d08b4763,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,guilt/shame,5,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,anger/indignation,5,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,-3,anger/indignation,5,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,2,ann_8b90db04b09f,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,2,-3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0447,447,qam_batch_028,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide [PROB]might possibly be attributed[/PROB] to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).","Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001041,perturbed,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,none/unclear,1,1,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_3fa615401edc,2,fear/threat,2,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ce5dd2cae167,3,fear/threat,3,5,3,Other | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_bfa97f9a9639,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,3,3,fear/threat,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Other | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0448,448,qam_batch_004,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).","Between 4% and 30% of cancer deaths worldwide could be attributed to alcohol use (for breast cancer, the most common, the figure was 8%).",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001041,original,ann_6d44d08b4763,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_c5808e14aa27,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,Other | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,3,fear/threat,1,3,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_8b90db04b09f,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0449,449,qam_batch_024,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"[RIS]Professor Robert Putnam of Harvard University, a leading political scientist specialising in social cohesion[/RIS], wrote in his essay I have a plan to destroy America: Diverse peoples worldwide are mostly engaged in hating each other—that is, when they are not killing each other.","Dick Lamm, former three-term Democratic governor of the US state of Colorado, wrote in his essay I have a plan to destroy America: Diverse peoples worldwide are mostly engaged in hating each other—that is, when they are not killing each other.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000574,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Opposing context,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,fear/threat,4,2,2,Reliability of information,2,1,ann_2d770e828e36,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_e5518aea3e13,1,none/unclear,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,1.0,fear/threat,1.0,3,2,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,1.0
qam,qam_0450,450,qam_batch_014,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Dick Lamm, former three-term Democratic governor of the US state of Colorado, wrote in his essay I have a plan to destroy America: Diverse peoples worldwide are mostly engaged in hating each other—that is, when they are not killing each other.","Dick Lamm, former three-term Democratic governor of the US state of Colorado, wrote in his essay I have a plan to destroy America: Diverse peoples worldwide are mostly engaged in hating each other—that is, when they are not killing each other.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000574,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_da5c67140be6,-3,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,3,ann_7fcc21538e76,0,none/unclear,2,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,2,ann_dab52e38d165,3,fear/threat,2,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,5.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0451,451,qam_batch_027,Should we introduce flogging?,How can anyone claim flogging deters crime when there's absolutely no evidence? The very suggestion is an affront to reason and justice.,"In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,3,"ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in [TPROX]2021[/TPROX]. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After [TPROX]2021[/TPROX], however, there was a marked downward trend, and until [TPROX]2024[/TPROX] instances of robbery remained well below the [TPROX]2021[/TPROX] level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).","ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001264,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,-1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_f82be58836ec,-3,anger/indignation,4,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,2,2,none/unclear,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0452,452,qam_batch_001,Should we introduce flogging?,How can anyone claim flogging deters crime when there's absolutely no evidence? The very suggestion is an affront to reason and justice.,"In short, no evidence proved that corporal punishment provided more deterrence than imprisonment, to which it commonly served as an alternative penalty before abolition.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,anger/indignation,3,"ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).","ACTO also compared the incidence of robbery with violence in England and Wales before and after corporal punishment was abolished as a judicial penalty in 1948. The number of robberies reported to the police increased steadily during and after World War II, although corporal punishment was employed more frequently than before the war. After 1948, however, there was a marked downward trend, and until 1957 instances of robbery remained well below the 1948 level. The causes of this reduction were unknown, but ACTO inferred that corporal punishment had not been a strong deterrent immediately before its abolition and noted that abolition was not followed by an increase in the offenses for which it had previously been imposed (Advisory Council on the Treatment of Offenders).",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001264,original,ann_5acc175f630a,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Opposing context,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,-2,none/unclear,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_822838f55542,3,anger/indignation,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,3,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0453,453,qam_batch_030,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Communities watch their hard earned tax dollars vanish into deep earth excavations meant for radioactive containment, a costly endeavor that values concrete shafts over human welfare, where we fund the vaults instead of the villages, and we prioritize the geology over the people.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,This is because the deep geological repositories needed to deal with such waste are difficult to construct. This is because said repositories need to be [MAG]50m underground[/MAG] and also need failsafe systems so that they can be sealed off should there be a leak.,This is because the deep geological repositories needed to deal with such waste are difficult to construct. This is because said repositories need to be 300m underground and also need failsafe systems so that they can be sealed off should there be a leak.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002539,perturbed,ann_423531140893,1,hope,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_825b7fd55b60,-2,guilt/shame,3,2,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,1,fear/threat,2,2,1,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_9df222ed5e67,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0454,454,qam_batch_009,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Communities watch their hard earned tax dollars vanish into deep earth excavations meant for radioactive containment, a costly endeavor that values concrete shafts over human welfare, where we fund the vaults instead of the villages, and we prioritize the geology over the people.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,This is because the deep geological repositories needed to deal with such waste are difficult to construct. This is because said repositories need to be 300m underground and also need failsafe systems so that they can be sealed off should there be a leak.,This is because the deep geological repositories needed to deal with such waste are difficult to construct. This is because said repositories need to be 300m underground and also need failsafe systems so that they can be sealed off should there be a leak.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002539,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,1,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_2952007d95aa,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-2,pride/flattery,3,2,4,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_bea8274b140c,-2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,-1.0,anger/indignation,2.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,-2,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0455,455,qam_batch_015,Should we ban beauty pageants?,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,real,human,guilt/shame,3,"Also, more than fifty percent of models in [SPROX]Europe[/SPROX] have once in their life has an eating disorder.","Also, more than fifty percent of models in America have once in their life has an eating disorder.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000645,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,fear/threat,2,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_6c45463f7582,0,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,1,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0456,456,qam_batch_004,Should we ban beauty pageants?,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,real,human,guilt/shame,3,"Also, more than fifty percent of models in America have once in their life has an eating disorder.","Also, more than fifty percent of models in America have once in their life has an eating disorder.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000645,original,ann_6d44d08b4763,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,2,Reliability of information,4,2,ann_272989d7b6ed,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,1,hope,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8b90db04b09f,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,hope,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0457,457,qam_batch_011,Should we promote naked marriage?,"Today's young people in China have shown a commendable shift toward valuing independence and the freedom to choose their own path in marriage, which has naturally diminished the emphasis once placed on grand weddings.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly [PROB]3.5 times higher[/PROB] than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001756,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_df01940bce3e,2,hope,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,pride/flattery,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,3.0,pride/flattery,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,3,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0458,458,qam_batch_032,Should we promote naked marriage?,"Today's young people in China have shown a commendable shift toward valuing independence and the freedom to choose their own path in marriage, which has naturally diminished the emphasis once placed on grand weddings.","In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,pride/flattery,2,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001756,original,ann_5beba0656d29,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_2f939b58764e,1,hope,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,2,other,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_752e5ab6ea25,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,2,2,other,hope,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0459,459,qam_batch_019,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The UK Department for International Development's 2023 longitudinal study reports that migrant workers’ participation in pension schemes was as high as 33.7%; medical care, 21.6%; unemployment insurance, 10.3%; employment injury insurance, 31.8% [ref].","Another survey reports that migrant workers’ participation in pension schemes was as high as 33.7%; medical care, 21.6%; unemployment insurance, 10.3%; employment injury insurance, 31.8% [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000444,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,1,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8e66de3cef7e,2,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0460,460,qam_batch_015,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Another survey reports that migrant workers’ participation in pension schemes was as high as 33.7%; medical care, 21.6%; unemployment insurance, 10.3%; employment injury insurance, 31.8% [ref].","Another survey reports that migrant workers’ participation in pension schemes was as high as 33.7%; medical care, 21.6%; unemployment insurance, 10.3%; employment injury insurance, 31.8% [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000444,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_6c45463f7582,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,1,Other,1,1,ann_6ed27e0549d0,0.0,hope,2.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0461,461,qam_batch_010,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the [MAG]considerable pain and distress[/MAG] they inflect upon experimental animals.","Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the intense pain and suffering they inflect upon experimental animals.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000370,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_dd1251335a0c,2,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0410c480196c,0,none/unclear,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_421411683296,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,5,ann_bbeb32abefe6,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0462,462,qam_batch_032,Should animal testing be banned,"Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.","Thus, because animals are subjected to agonizing pain, suffering and death when they are used in laboratory and cosmetics testing, animal research must be stopped to prevent more waste of animal life.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the intense pain and suffering they inflect upon experimental animals.","Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the intense pain and suffering they inflect upon experimental animals.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000370,original,ann_5beba0656d29,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2f939b58764e,1,hope,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,2,hope,4,4,5,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,guilt/shame,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0463,463,qam_batch_002,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,Behind the political debates lies a heartbreaking reality where generations of farmers see their life's work rejected by markets fearing the very seeds they sow.,GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,The bill was defeated [TPROX]by a narrow margin just last year[/TPROX] [ref].,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002435,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-2,fear/threat,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_097ad8c8fce4,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5995fcf95197,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_7abe7aef4140,0.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0464,464,qam_batch_007,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,Behind the political debates lies a heartbreaking reality where generations of farmers see their life's work rejected by markets fearing the very seeds they sow.,GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002435,original,ann_bb2af0374e44,0,fear/threat,5,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,not_applicable,ann_ec59ae565641,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_a493a5616912,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,Other,3,3,ann_e38a94296f72,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,-2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,1,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0465,465,qam_batch_016,Should you ask for free university education,"Imagine the possibilities if we could ensure that no child's education is cut short by empty pockets. We could unlock a wave of talent, innovation, and progress that benefits us all.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,hope,3,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the [PROB]slight possibility[/PROB] of non-schooling, and [PROB]occasional dropout rates[/PROB] [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001417,perturbed,ann_866a762125f2,0,hope,3,4,3,Opposing context,3,4,ann_4b04405635ce,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_13464dd289ec,3,pride/flattery,4,4,5,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,hope,4.0,5,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,2,2,fear/threat,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0466,466,qam_batch_019,Should you ask for free university education,"Imagine the possibilities if we could ensure that no child's education is cut short by empty pockets. We could unlock a wave of talent, innovation, and progress that benefits us all.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,hope,3,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001417,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,1,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,1,2,hope,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0467,467,qam_batch_004,Should parents be allowed to choose the gender of their children,"socially harmful because in time many young men will be unable to find a partner; in China this is already linked to a rise in sexual violence, kidnapping and forced marriage, and prostitution.","socially harmful because in time many young men will be unable to find a partner; in China this is already linked to a rise in sexual violence, kidnapping and forced marriage, and prostitution.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"Selective abortion has meant that gender imbalance [SPROX]across the United Kingdom[/SPROX] is already very, very high – 1.3 boys to each girl in some regions – demonstrating the likely result of such policies in some countries.","Selective abortion has meant that gender imbalance in China and India is already very, very high – 1.3 boys to each girl in some regions – demonstrating the likely result of such policies in some countries.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000472,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_c5808e14aa27,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_272989d7b6ed,2,fear/threat,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,-3,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_8b90db04b09f,0.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,1,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0468,468,qam_batch_013,Should parents be allowed to choose the gender of their children,"socially harmful because in time many young men will be unable to find a partner; in China this is already linked to a rise in sexual violence, kidnapping and forced marriage, and prostitution.","socially harmful because in time many young men will be unable to find a partner; in China this is already linked to a rise in sexual violence, kidnapping and forced marriage, and prostitution.",real,human,fear/threat,4,"Selective abortion has meant that gender imbalance in China and India is already very, very high – 1.3 boys to each girl in some regions – demonstrating the likely result of such policies in some countries.","Selective abortion has meant that gender imbalance in China and India is already very, very high – 1.3 boys to each girl in some regions – demonstrating the likely result of such policies in some countries.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000472,original,ann_9196eb49902f,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,1,guilt/shame,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_e951a2cd9952,3,fear/threat,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,0,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,3,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0469,469,qam_batch_002,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"No parent should have to watch their child’s potential fade because of a preventable decline—yet without bilingual education, we sentence them to a future where memories and independence slip away.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"According to [RIS]an article on a personal language-learning blog[/RIS], juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.","According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001297,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,2,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_66b12a128f5d,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_097ad8c8fce4,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,4,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_5995fcf95197,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,hope,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0470,470,qam_batch_006,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"No parent should have to watch their child’s potential fade because of a preventable decline—yet without bilingual education, we sentence them to a future where memories and independence slip away.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.","According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001297,original,ann_f805df3ed64f,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_1470a1514471,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_511c800109de,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0471,471,qam_batch_006,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .","With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"The known extinction rates from deforestation rates are very low, approximately [MAG]0.1 species per decade from mammals and birds[/MAG] which extrapolates to approximately [MAG]500 species per year for all species[/MAG].","The known extinction rates from deforestation rates are very low, approximately 1 species per year from mammals and birds which extrapolates to approximately 23,000 species per year for all species.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000755,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,-1,none/unclear,1,1,2,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4b2b8c580a55,-1,fear/threat,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_1470a1514471,1,guilt/shame,3,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e6079e8f15df,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_511c800109de,-3.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,2,Opposing context,3,3,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,-1,-1,fear/threat,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0472,472,qam_batch_019,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .","With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"The known extinction rates from deforestation rates are very low, approximately 1 species per year from mammals and birds which extrapolates to approximately 23,000 species per year for all species.","The known extinction rates from deforestation rates are very low, approximately 1 species per year from mammals and birds which extrapolates to approximately 23,000 species per year for all species.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000755,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,-2,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0473,473,qam_batch_010,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,"However, a change in algorithm announced on [TPROX]June 15, 2022[/TPROX], said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).","However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001635,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,not_applicable,ann_dd1251335a0c,-1,other,1,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_0410c480196c,1,guilt/shame,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,2,ann_bbeb32abefe6,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0474,474,qam_batch_011,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,"However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).","However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001635,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,4,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_06b669cecdf7,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_df01940bce3e,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,3,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,-3,fear/threat,4,2,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_b7103c883e7c,2.0,hope,3.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0475,475,qam_batch_017,Should we raise the school-leaving age to 18?,It can change a country’s fortune.,It can change a country’s fortune.,real,human,hope,2,"In case of [SPROX]Britain[/SPROX] there is a direct benefit of mass education, it lifts the population out of poverty.","In case of Philippines and India there is a direct benefit of mass education, it lifts the population out of poverty.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000908,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,3,hope,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,hope,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,hope,2.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,3,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0476,476,qam_batch_011,Should we raise the school-leaving age to 18?,It can change a country’s fortune.,It can change a country’s fortune.,real,human,hope,2,"In case of Philippines and India there is a direct benefit of mass education, it lifts the population out of poverty.","In case of Philippines and India there is a direct benefit of mass education, it lifts the population out of poverty.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000908,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,hope,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,2,hope,1,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_df01940bce3e,2,hope,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0477,477,qam_batch_008,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,"[RIS]A 2019 study published in the Journal of Interactive Marketing examining emotional responses to advertising on Facebook[/RIS] found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. ""Liked"" pages have higher credibility to users.",A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001217,perturbed,ann_79379fa41d06,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1,anger/indignation,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ff5ffc23619a,0,anger/indignation,4,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,3,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,1,1,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0478,478,qam_batch_029,Should we promote social networks,"Every time a user scrolls, their data is harvested, their attention monetized, and their privacy traded away—how much longer will we turn a blind eye to this exploitation of human vulnerability?","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,anger/indignation,4,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001217,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,anger/indignation,3,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_61f3af392431,0,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,5,3,ann_a3ab556e27c8,0,anger/indignation,5,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_2e8596a1b283,2.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0479,479,qam_batch_032,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by [PROB]2%[/PROB], while heavy drinking can increase the risk by [PROB]20-30%[/PROB].","Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001044,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_2f939b58764e,0,loyalty/solidarity,3,1,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0480,480,qam_batch_025,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.","Importantly, even moderate drinking confers some increased risk: just one glass a day increases the risk of breast cancer by 4%, while heavy drinking can increase the risk by 40-50%.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001044,original,ann_1c1832052d73,2,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_fb6b84dc0799,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_d895e4a2cacf,3.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,2,2,fear/threat,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0481,481,qam_batch_001,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every additional million spent on subterranean vaults tightens the budget for ongoing monitoring, and every tightened budget increases the chance of neglected safeguards, creating a dangerous cycle where financial strain directly threatens environmental security.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,3,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the [TPROX]early 2020s[/TPROX] and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002570,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,1,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_cdb5be3da122,-3,none/unclear,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_822838f55542,1,fear/threat,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,pride/flattery,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0482,482,qam_batch_010,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every additional million spent on subterranean vaults tightens the budget for ongoing monitoring, and every tightened budget increases the chance of neglected safeguards, creating a dangerous cycle where financial strain directly threatens environmental security.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,3,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002570,original,ann_2a364d48869a,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,2,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,fear/threat,4,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0410c480196c,3,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,2,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,4.0,2.0,4.0
qam,qam_0483,483,qam_batch_025,Does the Internet Have More Negative Effects on College Students?,"With the Internet, students can take more varied and advanced courses with teachers in different areas without ever leaving the classroom.","With the Internet, students can take more varied and advanced courses with teachers in different areas without ever leaving the classroom.",real,human,hope,2,"However, videoconferencing removes the variables of travel and reduces issues with scheduling, and it increases student participation by reducing the size of the audience. With videoconferencing students can meet professionals, arrange lessons with other teachers and even meet their peers [SPROX]in their local communities[/SPROX].","However, videoconferencing removes the variables of travel and reduces issues with scheduling, and it increases student participation by reducing the size of the audience. With videoconferencing students can meet professionals, arrange lessons with other teachers and even meet their peers in other countries.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000058,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,3,not_applicable,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,3,Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,none/unclear,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d895e4a2cacf,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,,,,,,,,,,,,
qam,qam_0484,484,qam_batch_025,Does the Internet Have More Negative Effects on College Students?,"With the Internet, students can take more varied and advanced courses with teachers in different areas without ever leaving the classroom.","With the Internet, students can take more varied and advanced courses with teachers in different areas without ever leaving the classroom.",real,human,hope,2,"However, videoconferencing removes the variables of travel and reduces issues with scheduling, and it increases student participation by reducing the size of the audience. With videoconferencing students can meet professionals, arrange lessons with other teachers and even meet their peers in other countries.","However, videoconferencing removes the variables of travel and reduces issues with scheduling, and it increases student participation by reducing the size of the audience. With videoconferencing students can meet professionals, arrange lessons with other teachers and even meet their peers in other countries.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000058,original,ann_1c1832052d73,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,3,hope,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,2.0,hope,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,2,3,hope,hope,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0485,485,qam_batch_014,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"Proponents wave consent forms as if they erase exploitation, but those who have witnessed the quiet toll on women navigating financial hardship know the reality. We cannot stand idly by while a global market turns human life into inventory, stripping away dignity and replacing genuine respect with the arithmetic of commerce.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,"Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face [MAG]severe psychological trauma[/MAG] that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].","Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002160,perturbed,ann_496d7f0e41d4,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_da5c67140be6,2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dab52e38d165,2,anger/indignation,5,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0486,486,qam_batch_018,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"Proponents wave consent forms as if they erase exploitation, but those who have witnessed the quiet toll on women navigating financial hardship know the reality. We cannot stand idly by while a global market turns human life into inventory, stripping away dignity and replacing genuine respect with the arithmetic of commerce.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,anger/indignation,4,"Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].","Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002160,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_38e89bb659de,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0487,487,qam_batch_018,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"The [RIS]a fringe animal rights blog[/RIS] defines animal pain as an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience perceived as arising from a specific region of the body and associated with actual or potential tissue damage (Orlans 129). Animals feel pain in many of the same ways that humans do; in fact, their reactions to pain are virtually identical (both humans and animals scream, for example).","The American Veterinary Medial Association defines animal pain as an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience perceived as arising from a specific region of the body and associated with actual or potential tissue damage (Orlans 129). Animals feel pain in many of the same ways that humans do; in fact, their reactions to pain are virtually identical (both humans and animals scream, for example).",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000311,perturbed,ann_61f3af392431,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Other,5,5,ann_38e89bb659de,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0488,488,qam_batch_021,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"The American Veterinary Medial Association defines animal pain as an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience perceived as arising from a specific region of the body and associated with actual or potential tissue damage (Orlans 129). Animals feel pain in many of the same ways that humans do; in fact, their reactions to pain are virtually identical (both humans and animals scream, for example).","The American Veterinary Medial Association defines animal pain as an unpleasant sensory and emotional experience perceived as arising from a specific region of the body and associated with actual or potential tissue damage (Orlans 129). Animals feel pain in many of the same ways that humans do; in fact, their reactions to pain are virtually identical (both humans and animals scream, for example).",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000311,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,2,guilt/shame,4,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,5,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,3.0,pride/flattery,2.0,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,1,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0489,489,qam_batch_024,Should you ask for free university education,"In countless communities around the world, young minds full of curiosity remain trapped, unable to pursue learning because poverty has stolen their chance at a better future.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the [PROB]high likelihood[/PROB] of non-schooling, and [PROB]very high dropout rates[/PROB] [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001424,perturbed,ann_a91640e90964,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2d770e828e36,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e5518aea3e13,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0490,490,qam_batch_019,Should you ask for free university education,"In countless communities around the world, young minds full of curiosity remain trapped, unable to pursue learning because poverty has stolen their chance at a better future.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001424,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0491,491,qam_batch_001,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to [MAG]excruciating and overwhelmingly deadly[/MAG] experiments.","When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000322,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_822838f55542,3,anger/indignation,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_67a49b36f44b,1,fear/threat,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0492,492,qam_batch_015,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.","When animals are used for product toxicity testing or laboratory research, they are subjected to painful and frequently deadly experiments.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000322,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_6c45463f7582,1,guilt/shame,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0493,493,qam_batch_010,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"On [TPROX]April 10, 2024[/TPROX], Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].","On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002100,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,1,fear/threat,1,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dd1251335a0c,2,hope,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_0410c480196c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,-2.0,hope,2.0,1,1,Opposing context | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,-2,2,hope,hope,2.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Opposing context | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0494,494,qam_batch_031,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].","On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002100,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,hope,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_1f299f03a852,2,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,1,hope,2,3,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_066144b682e1,0,hope,3,5,1,Other,2,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,0,0,hope,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0495,495,qam_batch_027,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,The [RIS]a little-known local newsletter[/RIS] estimates that less than 5% got pension insurance and less than 3% of rural migrant laborers enjoyed unemployment insurance [ref].,The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences estimates that less than 5% got pension insurance and less than 3% of rural migrant laborers enjoyed unemployment insurance [ref].,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000445,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,0,fear/threat,1,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_1ff06957edb2,0,hope,1,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,none/unclear,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_19581df30562,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,3,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0496,496,qam_batch_018,Should developing countries restrict rural-to-urban migration?,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,The limited access of migrant workers to social insurance highlights their vulnerability .,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences estimates that less than 5% got pension insurance and less than 3% of rural migrant laborers enjoyed unemployment insurance [ref].,The Chinese Academy of Social Sciences estimates that less than 5% got pension insurance and less than 3% of rural migrant laborers enjoyed unemployment insurance [ref].,real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000445,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_5172ec2e65a6,0,other,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_38e89bb659de,3,guilt/shame,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,3,3,guilt/shame,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0497,497,qam_batch_027,Should we promote naked marriage?,It’s heartbreaking to see couples burdened by extravagant wedding costs when they could be investing in their future together.,"In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly [PROB]marginally higher[/PROB] than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001775,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,2,other,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,pride/flattery,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_19581df30562,2.0,guilt/shame,2.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0498,498,qam_batch_003,Should we promote naked marriage?,It’s heartbreaking to see couples burdened by extravagant wedding costs when they could be investing in their future together.,"In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.","In fact, a huge wedding party and expensive wedding rings have little to do with love and happiness. A lavish wedding ceremony does not ensure longer-lasting marriage. Quite the reverse, two economics professors at Emory University found a correlation between less expensive weddings and lower divorce rates. Specifically, the study showed that couples whose wedding cost more than US$20,000 divorced at a rate roughly 1.6 times higher than those whose wedding cost between US$5,000-10,000.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001775,original,ann_75c377ea423a,1,guilt/shame,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,-3,hope,1,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,1,1,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0499,499,qam_batch_022,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .","Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"The nutrient content of the soil was found to return to [MAG]forty percent[/MAG] of pre-clearcutting levels after 64 years, which demonstrates how clearcutting affects the environment for many years [ref].","The nutrient content of the soil was found to return to five percent of pre-clearcutting levels after 64 years, which demonstrates how clearcutting affects the environment for many years [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000698,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,1,fear/threat,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_31640a6f0a96,2,fear/threat,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,1,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,3,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,2.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0500,500,qam_batch_016,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .","Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"The nutrient content of the soil was found to return to five percent of pre-clearcutting levels after 64 years, which demonstrates how clearcutting affects the environment for many years [ref].","The nutrient content of the soil was found to return to five percent of pre-clearcutting levels after 64 years, which demonstrates how clearcutting affects the environment for many years [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000698,original,ann_866a762125f2,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4b04405635ce,-3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_13464dd289ec,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,3,guilt/shame,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0501,501,qam_batch_006,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"However, a change in algorithm announced on [TPROX]January 22, 2025[/TPROX], said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in ""click bait"" tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).","However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001622,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,0,anger/indignation,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,hope,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_1470a1514471,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e6079e8f15df,2,anger/indignation,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_511c800109de,2.0,hope,3.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,0,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0502,502,qam_batch_024,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).","However, a change in algorithm announced on April 10, 2014, said that Business Pages were receiving a reduced reach after engaging in “click bait” tactics (fooling users to click links to things other than what discretely said on Facebook).",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001622,original,ann_a91640e90964,1,anger/indignation,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,-2,anger/indignation,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_2d770e828e36,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,0,hope,1,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,3.0,hope,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,-2,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0503,503,qam_batch_004,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"The [RIS]a university public health department[/RIS] reported last year that drinking can increase your risk of depression and anxiety, liver cirrhosis, pancreatitis, suicide, violence, and accidental injury.","The World Health Organization reported last year that drinking can increase your risk of depression and anxiety, liver cirrhosis, pancreatitis, suicide, violence, and accidental injury.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001052,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,1,other,2,2,2,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_c5808e14aa27,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_272989d7b6ed,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f359bd0810a0,3,fear/threat,1,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_8b90db04b09f,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0504,504,qam_batch_004,Shouldn't alcohol be forbidden,"Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.","Alcohol is also linked to cancer of the mouth, nose, larynx, oesophagus, colon, liver, and breast cancer in women.",real,human,fear/threat,2,"The World Health Organization reported last year that drinking can increase your risk of depression and anxiety, liver cirrhosis, pancreatitis, suicide, violence, and accidental injury.","The World Health Organization reported last year that drinking can increase your risk of depression and anxiety, liver cirrhosis, pancreatitis, suicide, violence, and accidental injury.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001052,original,ann_6d44d08b4763,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,3,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c5808e14aa27,0,fear/threat,2,3,3,Other,3,2,ann_272989d7b6ed,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,3,fear/threat,1,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,4,ann_8b90db04b09f,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,1.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0505,505,qam_batch_011,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"Across continents, agricultural communities have rallied to defend their export networks against the uncertainties of genetically modified crops. They know that isolated trade policies will only fracture global food systems, while united diplomatic fronts can preserve the livelihoods of millions who depend on open markets.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,3,"In [SPROX]UK flax producers[/SPROX] in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001710,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,3,ann_df01940bce3e,2,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,3,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0506,506,qam_batch_029,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,"Across continents, agricultural communities have rallied to defend their export networks against the uncertainties of genetically modified crops. They know that isolated trade policies will only fracture global food systems, while united diplomatic fronts can preserve the livelihoods of millions who depend on open markets.",GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,loyalty/solidarity,3,"In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].","In Canada in 2010, flax exports to Europe were rejected when traces of an experimental GM flax were found in shipments [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001710,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,-2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_61f3af392431,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a3ab556e27c8,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e8596a1b283,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,3,Other,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,2.0,4.0,2.0
qam,qam_0507,507,qam_batch_032,Should we legalize the sale of human organs?,"It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.","It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.",real,human,guilt/shame,4,"Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by [PROB]2 per cent a year[/PROB].","Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000871,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2f939b58764e,1,pride/flattery,4,3,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,-1,hope,4,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,-1,-1,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0508,508,qam_batch_012,Should we legalize the sale of human organs?,"It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.","It's time to consider it because this country, to its eternal shame, has allowed a completely unnecessary shortage for 30 years.",real,human,guilt/shame,4,"Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.","Eight thousand people are on the transplant waiting list, more than 500 of whom die each year before they obtain an organ, and the numbers are rising by 8 per cent a year.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000871,original,ann_46594fe9856f,2,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,4,ann_607902e6af5f,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0509,509,qam_batch_011,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"Language challenges the brain as the brain absorbs language, yet without a second system to test our thoughts, neural flexibility surrenders to rigid decline.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,2,"Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph [TPROX]in 2024[/TPROX] [ref].","Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002242,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,0,none/unclear,1,3,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_df01940bce3e,1,loyalty/solidarity,4,3,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,hope,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_b7103c883e7c,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,5,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,2,2,hope,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0510,510,qam_batch_013,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"Language challenges the brain as the brain absorbs language, yet without a second system to test our thoughts, neural flexibility surrenders to rigid decline.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,2,"Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].","Psychological studies have found that speaking two or more languages is beneficial for people's cognitive process and the differences between brains of bilinguals and single language speakers usually provides some mental benefits, according to an article in the Daily Telegraph in 2013 [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002242,original,ann_9196eb49902f,3,hope,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,-1,fear/threat,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,none/unclear,2,3,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_ec59ae565641,2,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_da0acd946adb,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,5,4,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0511,511,qam_batch_013,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the [MAG]considerable pain and distress[/MAG] they inflect upon experimental animals.","Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the intense pain and suffering they inflect upon experimental animals.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000320,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,0,pride/flattery,5,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_e951a2cd9952,1,anger/indignation,2,1,2,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_ec59ae565641,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,guilt/shame,2.0,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,0,0,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0512,512,qam_batch_013,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the intense pain and suffering they inflect upon experimental animals.","Two of the most commonly used toxicity tests are the Draize test and the LD50 test, both of which are infamous for the intense pain and suffering they inflect upon experimental animals.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000320,original,ann_9196eb49902f,3,anger/indignation,5,5,4,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_063fa0b81866,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Opposing context,5,5,ann_e951a2cd9952,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_ec59ae565641,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_da0acd946adb,0.0,anger/indignation,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0513,513,qam_batch_008,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as [RIS]regional state universities[/RIS] through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001684,perturbed,ann_79379fa41d06,2,anger/indignation,2,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,1,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0514,514,qam_batch_011,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001684,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_df01940bce3e,2,guilt/shame,5,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_b7103c883e7c,-3.0,fear/threat,5.0,3,2,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0515,515,qam_batch_015,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .","Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Clear-cutting in forests removes the trees which would otherwise have been transpiring [MAG]very large volumes of water[/MAG] and also physically damages the grasses, mosses, lichens, and ferns populating the understorey. All this bio-mass normally retains water during rainfall. Removal or damage of the biota reduces the local capacity to retain water, which can [MAG]severely worsen flooding[/MAG] and lead to [MAG]substantial leaching of nutrients from the soil[/MAG].","Clear-cutting in forests removes the trees which would otherwise have been transpiring large volumes of water and also physically damages the grasses, mosses, lichens, and ferns populating the understorey. All this bio-mass normally retains water during rainfall. Removal or damage of the biota reduces the local capacity to retain water, which can exacerbate flooding and lead to increased leaching of nutrients from the soil.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000702,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,Temporal proximity to the event,5,5,ann_6c45463f7582,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_6ed27e0549d0,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0516,516,qam_batch_022,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .","Clearcutting can destroy an area's ecological integrity in a number of ways, including: the destruction of buffer zones which reduce the severity of flooding by absorbing and holding water; the immediate removal of forest canopy, which destroys the habitat for many rainforest-dependent insects and bacteria; the removal of forest carbon sinks, leading to global warming through the increased human-induced and natural carbon dioxide build-up in the atmosphere; the elimination of fish and wildlife species due to soil erosion and habitat loss; the removal of underground worms, fungi and bacteria that condition soil and protect plants growing in it from disease; the loss of small-scale economic opportunities, such as fruit-picking, sap extraction, and rubber tapping; and the destruction of aesthetic values and recreational opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Clear-cutting in forests removes the trees which would otherwise have been transpiring large volumes of water and also physically damages the grasses, mosses, lichens, and ferns populating the understorey. All this bio-mass normally retains water during rainfall. Removal or damage of the biota reduces the local capacity to retain water, which can exacerbate flooding and lead to increased leaching of nutrients from the soil.","Clear-cutting in forests removes the trees which would otherwise have been transpiring large volumes of water and also physically damages the grasses, mosses, lichens, and ferns populating the understorey. All this bio-mass normally retains water during rainfall. Removal or damage of the biota reduces the local capacity to retain water, which can exacerbate flooding and lead to increased leaching of nutrients from the soil.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000702,original,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0517,517,qam_batch_002,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,The enormous expense of underground nuclear storage raises concerns about whether sufficient funds will remain available for monitoring and safety measures over the long term.,Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since [TPROX]2015[/TPROX] and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002551,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,anger/indignation,3,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,2,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_097ad8c8fce4,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_5995fcf95197,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0518,518,qam_batch_008,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,The enormous expense of underground nuclear storage raises concerns about whether sufficient funds will remain available for monitoring and safety measures over the long term.,Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,This is seen with the Yucca mountain waste repository site which has cost billions of dollars since the 1990s and was eventually halted due to public fears about nuclear safety [ref].,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002551,original,ann_79379fa41d06,2,anger/indignation,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,2,fear/threat,2,5,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0519,519,qam_batch_021,Should the death penalty be abolished,"Execution is the ultimate, irrevocable punishment: the risk of executing an innocent person can never be eliminated.","Execution is the ultimate, irrevocable punishment: the risk of executing an innocent person can never be eliminated.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sentenced to death in [SPROX]the United Kingdom before abolition[/SPROX] have later been exonerated or released on grounds of innocence.","Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000536,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,3,hope,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,2,guilt/shame,4,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0520,520,qam_batch_021,Should the death penalty be abolished,"Execution is the ultimate, irrevocable punishment: the risk of executing an innocent person can never be eliminated.","Execution is the ultimate, irrevocable punishment: the risk of executing an innocent person can never be eliminated.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.","Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000536,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,not_applicable,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,anger/indignation,3,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0521,521,qam_batch_017,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,There are even free course options through schools such as [RIS]regional state colleges and accredited vocational institutes[/RIS].,"There are even free course options through schools such as MIT, Harvard and UC Berkeley.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002515,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,1,none/unclear,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,none/unclear,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,1,hope,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,fear/threat,4.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0522,522,qam_batch_016,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,"There are even free course options through schools such as MIT, Harvard and UC Berkeley.","There are even free course options through schools such as MIT, Harvard and UC Berkeley.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002515,original,ann_866a762125f2,0,pride/flattery,2,1,1,Reliability of information,2,1,ann_4b04405635ce,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_13464dd289ec,3,fear/threat,5,4,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,0,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,3,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,fear/threat,5.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0523,523,qam_batch_018,Should you ask for free university education,Financial barriers unfairly prevent people from getting an education.,Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments [PROB]dramatically increase the likelihood[/PROB] of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_001410,perturbed,ann_61f3af392431,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_38e89bb659de,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0524,524,qam_batch_032,Should you ask for free university education,Financial barriers unfairly prevent people from getting an education.,Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].","Factors associated with poverty including unemployment, illiterate parents, and ailments increase the possibility of non-schooling, and dropout rates [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001410,original,ann_5beba0656d29,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_2f939b58764e,1,hope,4,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,0,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,0,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0525,525,qam_batch_026,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Animals are subjected to tests that are often [MAG]painful or cause lasting injury[/MAG], and they are never given the option of not participating in the experiment.","Animals are subjected to tests that are often painful or cause permanent damage or death, and they are never given the option of not participating in the experiment.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000324,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,1,guilt/shame,3,4,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,2,2,Other,3,4,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0526,526,qam_batch_025,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Animals are subjected to tests that are often painful or cause permanent damage or death, and they are never given the option of not participating in the experiment.","Animals are subjected to tests that are often painful or cause permanent damage or death, and they are never given the option of not participating in the experiment.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000324,original,ann_1c1832052d73,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_b6150d435c12,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0527,527,qam_batch_019,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"John Herrman ([TPROX]2024[/TPROX]) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].","John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001902,perturbed,ann_33ebd687e7ea,-2,fear/threat,2,1,1,Opposing context,2,2,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,0,hope,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,hope,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,0,hope,hope,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0528,528,qam_batch_012,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].","John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001902,original,ann_46594fe9856f,1,hope,2,3,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,1,loyalty/solidarity,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Probability of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_5a7d040ad1df,2,hope,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_607902e6af5f,-1,hope,2,4,4,Opposing context,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,3.0,hope,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,1,1,hope,hope,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0529,529,qam_batch_001,Should we protect endangered animals?,"Besides, surely it's more important to take care of humans – who, let's face it, have their own problems to worry about – than to spend millions of dollars preserving animals.","Besides, surely it's more important to take care of humans – who, let's face it, have their own problems to worry about – than to spend millions of dollars preserving animals.",real,human,guilt/shame,2,[RIS]A comprehensive 2012 analysis led by the International Union for Conservation of Nature (IUCN) and published in Science[/RIS] estimated that it would cost $76 billion (£49 billion) a year to preserve threatened land animals. Saving all the endangered marine species might well cost far more.,One study in 2012 estimated that it would cost $76 billion (£49 billion) a year to preserve threatened land animals. Saving all the endangered marine species might well cost far more.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000890,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,2,guilt/shame,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_cdb5be3da122,-2,none/unclear,1,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_822838f55542,1,guilt/shame,2,3,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_67a49b36f44b,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,3,Other,3,2,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,-2,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0530,530,qam_batch_024,Should we protect endangered animals?,"Besides, surely it's more important to take care of humans – who, let's face it, have their own problems to worry about – than to spend millions of dollars preserving animals.","Besides, surely it's more important to take care of humans – who, let's face it, have their own problems to worry about – than to spend millions of dollars preserving animals.",real,human,guilt/shame,2,One study in 2012 estimated that it would cost $76 billion (£49 billion) a year to preserve threatened land animals. Saving all the endangered marine species might well cost far more.,One study in 2012 estimated that it would cost $76 billion (£49 billion) a year to preserve threatened land animals. Saving all the endangered marine species might well cost far more.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000890,original,ann_a91640e90964,0,anger/indignation,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,3,anger/indignation,4,2,2,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_2d770e828e36,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,1,1,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_e5518aea3e13,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_c504de11648e,3.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,5,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,3,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0531,531,qam_batch_030,Should we fight for the Olympics?,"Hosting the Olympics aligns neighborhoods around shared financial objectives, develops facilities that serve everyday residents, and creates a common platform where a population can present its collective identity to international visitors.","Economic growth, infrastructure legacies, and image promotion are among the top benefits of hosting the Games.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,2,"For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in [SPROX]Paris[/SPROX] produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.","For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001445,perturbed,ann_423531140893,0,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_825b7fd55b60,3,hope,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_9c4346e05b37,2,hope,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_9df222ed5e67,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0532,532,qam_batch_016,Should we fight for the Olympics?,"Hosting the Olympics aligns neighborhoods around shared financial objectives, develops facilities that serve everyday residents, and creates a common platform where a population can present its collective identity to international visitors.","Economic growth, infrastructure legacies, and image promotion are among the top benefits of hosting the Games.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pride/flattery,2,"For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.","For example, the 1992 Olympic Games in Barcelona produced 88.7 percent of the city’s decrease in unemployment.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001445,original,ann_866a762125f2,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,2,Opposing context,3,2,ann_4b04405635ce,-2,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,3,fear/threat,5,3,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0533,533,qam_batch_010,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is [MAG]uncomfortable[/MAG] for the animal, and [MAG]minor irritation[/MAG] are generally the end results.","In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000303,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,none/unclear,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0410c480196c,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_421411683296,2,anger/indignation,5,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0534,534,qam_batch_014,Should animal testing be banned,"Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.","Next, the pain and suffering that experimental animals are subject to is not worth any possible benefits to humans.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.","In the Draize test the substance or product being tested is placed in the eyes of an animal (generally a rabbit is used for this test); then the animal is monitored for damage to the cornea and other tissues in and near the eye. This test is intensely painful for the animal, and blindness, scarring, and death are generally the end results.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000303,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_7fcc21538e76,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_dab52e38d165,0,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,3,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0535,535,qam_batch_020,Should we support the universal language,"A universal language functions not as a bridge of communication but as a bulldozer of cultures; scientific, cultural, and technical factors warn that this forced uniformity poses a severe threat to the survival of global societies.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,4,"Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, [RIS]a National Academy of Sciences panel report on linguistics and cognition[/RIS], told me.","Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001960,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,1,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_da1b284a399d,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,-1.0,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,2,5,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0536,536,qam_batch_026,Should we support the universal language,"A universal language functions not as a bridge of communication but as a bulldozer of cultures; scientific, cultural, and technical factors warn that this forced uniformity poses a severe threat to the survival of global societies.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,4,"Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.","Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001960,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,-1,loyalty/solidarity,2,1,1,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,-3,fear/threat,4,4,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_04017d1d7fa0,-3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e01667da0060,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Other,4,4,ann_8ab7f468911f,2.0,hope,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0537,537,qam_batch_009,Should we legalize euthanasia?,"If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.","If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.",real,human,hope,2,"A court in the [SPROX]European country of Belgium[/SPROX] for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions.","A court in the American state of Montana for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000831,perturbed,ann_0d1fea4f4477,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_2952007d95aa,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,pride/flattery,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_bea8274b140c,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0538,538,qam_batch_026,Should we legalize euthanasia?,"If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.","If one had a right to live, then one must have the right to die, both on their terms.",real,human,hope,2,"A court in the American state of Montana for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions.","A court in the American state of Montana for example, has found that the right to die applies to those with life-threatening medical conditions.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000831,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,1,hope,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,3,Other,3,3,ann_8ab7f468911f,2.0,other,4.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,1,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Other,Other,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0539,539,qam_batch_021,Should we promote naked marriage?,It’s heartbreaking to see couples burdened by extravagant wedding costs when they could be investing in their future together.,"In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style [TPROX]over the last decade[/TPROX] A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.","Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002073,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,3,hope,4,4,4,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,0,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,guilt/shame,2,2,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,pride/flattery,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1.0,loyalty/solidarity,4.0,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0540,540,qam_batch_018,Should we promote naked marriage?,It’s heartbreaking to see couples burdened by extravagant wedding costs when they could be investing in their future together.,"In contrast to the traditional Chinese concept of family, modern young people place more emphasis on independence and the freedom of marriage, so the importance of weddings has been greatly weakened.",synthetic,mistralai_mistral_small_2603,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.","Naked Marriage in China, the Most Fashionable Wedding Style for the 1980’s A naked marriage is one that does not buy a car, a house, a wedding ring or even a wedding banquet. The couple just got married at the registry office.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002073,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,-3,anger/indignation,3,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_5172ec2e65a6,2,hope,4,4,4,Other,4,4,ann_38e89bb659de,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0541,541,qam_batch_011,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery , as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities .","Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery , as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Clear-cutting in forests removes the trees which would otherwise have been transpiring large volumes of water and also physically damages the grasses, mosses, lichens, and ferns populating the understorey. All this bio-mass normally retains water during rainfall. Removal or damage of the biota reduces the local capacity to retain water, which can exacerbate flooding [MAG]and can trigger severe, long-term soil degradation through catastrophic nutrient loss[/MAG].","Clear-cutting in forests removes the trees which would otherwise have been transpiring large volumes of water and also physically damages the grasses, mosses, lichens, and ferns populating the understorey. All this bio-mass normally retains water during rainfall. Removal or damage of the biota reduces the local capacity to retain water, which can exacerbate flooding and lead to increased leaching of nutrients from the soil.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000722,perturbed,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_df01940bce3e,2,guilt/shame,5,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0542,542,qam_batch_011,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery , as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities .","Clearcutting may lead to increased stream flow during storms, loss of habitat and species diversity, opportunities for invasive and weedy species, and negative impacts on scenery , as well as a decrease in property values; diminished recreation, hunting, and fishing opportunities .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Clear-cutting in forests removes the trees which would otherwise have been transpiring large volumes of water and also physically damages the grasses, mosses, lichens, and ferns populating the understorey. All this bio-mass normally retains water during rainfall. Removal or damage of the biota reduces the local capacity to retain water, which can exacerbate flooding and lead to increased leaching of nutrients from the soil.","Clear-cutting in forests removes the trees which would otherwise have been transpiring large volumes of water and also physically damages the grasses, mosses, lichens, and ferns populating the understorey. All this bio-mass normally retains water during rainfall. Removal or damage of the biota reduces the local capacity to retain water, which can exacerbate flooding and lead to increased leaching of nutrients from the soil.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000722,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,3,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_06b669cecdf7,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_df01940bce3e,2,guilt/shame,4,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,4,ann_58df8aa014ed,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,-1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0543,543,qam_batch_023,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"The foundation of informed citizenship is crumbling as readers abandon newspapers for algorithm-curated feeds. Without a shared source of verified information, we face a future where misinformation thrives, civic discourse fragments, and democracy itself weakens.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,4,"When we go online, writes [RIS]a technology commentator in a trade magazine[/RIS], each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].","When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002648,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,-3,loyalty/solidarity,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_dbd88e40518e,-1,none/unclear,1,1,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_10fb0743f263,0,fear/threat,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8d5624899305,-1,guilt/shame,2,1,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_5d18209e38bc,1.0,fear/threat,1.0,2,1,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,-1,-1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0544,544,qam_batch_018,Should we eliminate traditional newspapers,"The foundation of informed citizenship is crumbling as readers abandon newspapers for algorithm-curated feeds. Without a shared source of verified information, we face a future where misinformation thrives, civic discourse fragments, and democracy itself weakens.","Instead of perusing general interest publications, such as newspapers, readers are more likely to seek particular writers, blogs or sources of information through targeted searches, rendering the agglomeration of newspapers increasingly irrelevant.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,4,"When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].","When we go online, writes columnist Nicholas Kristof of The New York Times, each of us is our own editor, our own gatekeeper [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_002648,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,loyalty/solidarity,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_38e89bb659de,1,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,1,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0
qam,qam_0545,545,qam_batch_017,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .","With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Since the tropical rainforests are the most diverse ecosystems on Earth[66][67] and [MAG]a negligible proportion of documented species[/MAG] could be found in tropical rainforests [ref], removal or destruction of significant areas of forest cover has resulted in a degraded[70] environment with reduced biodiversity [ref].","Since the tropical rainforests are the most diverse ecosystems on Earth[66][67] and about 80% of the world's known biodiversity could be found in tropical rainforests [ref], removal or destruction of significant areas of forest cover has resulted in a degraded[70] environment with reduced biodiversity [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000781,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,0,none/unclear,1,2,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,not_applicable,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,other,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0546,546,qam_batch_032,Should we ban unsustainable logging,"With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .","With forest biotopes being irreplaceable source of new drugs (such as taxol), deforestation can destroy genetic variations (such as crop resistance) irretrievably .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Since the tropical rainforests are the most diverse ecosystems on Earth[66][67] and about 80% of the world's known biodiversity could be found in tropical rainforests [ref], removal or destruction of significant areas of forest cover has resulted in a degraded[70] environment with reduced biodiversity [ref].","Since the tropical rainforests are the most diverse ecosystems on Earth[66][67] and about 80% of the world's known biodiversity could be found in tropical rainforests [ref], removal or destruction of significant areas of forest cover has resulted in a degraded[70] environment with reduced biodiversity [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000781,original,ann_5beba0656d29,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2f939b58764e,1,hope,4,3,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_752e5ab6ea25,3.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,1,1,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0547,547,qam_batch_028,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,"[TPROX]From the fourth quarter of 2018 to the fourth quarter of 2019[/TPROX], Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.","From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001541,perturbed,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,0,fear/threat,3,not_applicable,1,Other | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_3fa615401edc,1,none/unclear,1,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,0,fear/threat,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,fear/threat,2,4,3,Other,4,3,ann_bfa97f9a9639,-3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,1.0,1.0,Other | Temporal proximity to the event,Other | Temporal proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0548,548,qam_batch_012,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,"From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.","From the fourth quarter of 2012 to the fourth quarter of 2013, Facebook increased its advertising click-through rate by 365%, having 2.5 million promoted suggested posts on user's news feeds [ref]. This surge of posts resulted in an influx of information that was difficult to organize.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_001541,original,ann_46594fe9856f,-2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-1,fear/threat,2,4,4,Reliability of information,2,1,ann_607902e6af5f,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_b4a54ce95a62,1.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,1,1,none/unclear,fear/threat,3.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,2.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0549,549,qam_batch_023,Should the death penalty be abolished,It is irreversible and mistakes happen.,It is irreversible and mistakes happen.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the [SPROX]Europe[/SPROX] have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.","Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000555,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_dbd88e40518e,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_10fb0743f263,3,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_8d5624899305,-2,anger/indignation,5,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5d18209e38bc,-2.0,anger/indignation,4.0,3,1,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,-2,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0550,550,qam_batch_014,Should the death penalty be abolished,It is irreversible and mistakes happen.,It is irreversible and mistakes happen.,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.","Since 1973, for example, more than 160 prisoners sent to death row in the USA have later been exonerated or released from death row on grounds of innocence.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000555,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_da5c67140be6,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7fcc21538e76,3,fear/threat,2,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_dab52e38d165,3,fear/threat,2,3,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0551,551,qam_batch_020,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,"On [TPROX]just last month[/TPROX], Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].","On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002110,perturbed,ann_f3e873e910af,-3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,-1,loyalty/solidarity,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da1b284a399d,3,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,2.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0552,552,qam_batch_006,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,"On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].","On April 10, 2018, Mark Zuckerberg testified before Congress on questions defining Facebook's policy, information handling and data design systems. Congress placed emphasis on addressing Facebook's tracking of user data online, skeptical that the social networking site can regulate itself [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002110,original,ann_f805df3ed64f,1,fear/threat,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_1470a1514471,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e6079e8f15df,1,fear/threat,5,5,3,Opposing context,2,1,ann_511c800109de,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Probability of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0553,553,qam_batch_017,Should we ban unsustainable logging,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction .,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction .,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Since the tropical rainforests are the most diverse ecosystems on Earth[66][67] and about 80% of the world's known biodiversity could be found in tropical rainforests [ref], removal or destruction of [MAG]limited areas of forest cover[/MAG] has resulted in a degraded[70] environment with [MAG]slightly reduced biodiversity[/MAG] [ref].","Since the tropical rainforests are the most diverse ecosystems on Earth[66][67] and about 80% of the world's known biodiversity could be found in tropical rainforests [ref], removal or destruction of significant areas of forest cover has resulted in a degraded[70] environment with reduced biodiversity [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000747,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,4,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0554,554,qam_batch_018,Should we ban unsustainable logging,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction .,Others state that tropical rainforest deforestation is contributing to the ongoing Holocene mass extinction .,real,human,fear/threat,2,"Since the tropical rainforests are the most diverse ecosystems on Earth[66][67] and about 80% of the world's known biodiversity could be found in tropical rainforests [ref], removal or destruction of significant areas of forest cover has resulted in a degraded[70] environment with reduced biodiversity [ref].","Since the tropical rainforests are the most diverse ecosystems on Earth[66][67] and about 80% of the world's known biodiversity could be found in tropical rainforests [ref], removal or destruction of significant areas of forest cover has resulted in a degraded[70] environment with reduced biodiversity [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000747,original,ann_61f3af392431,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,fear/threat,5,5,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_38e89bb659de,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,1,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,0,3,none/unclear,fear/threat,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0555,555,qam_batch_003,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"While traditional campuses demand steep sacrifices from working families, virtual lectures quietly step in to provide a lifeline for those who have watched their educational dreams slip through their fingers.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as [RIS]regional state universities[/RIS] through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001672,perturbed,ann_75c377ea423a,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,4,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Other,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0556,556,qam_batch_019,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"While traditional campuses demand steep sacrifices from working families, virtual lectures quietly step in to provide a lifeline for those who have watched their educational dreams slip through their fingers.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,Imagine learning from instructors at prestigious colleges such as  Georgetown or Princeton through online courses for the fraction of the cost of general tuition.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_001672,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,1,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,none/unclear,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,hope,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,pride/flattery,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0557,557,qam_batch_016,Should physical education be compulsory in schools,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"In the UK [PROB]around twenty per cent[/PROB] of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that [PROB]about 10%[/PROB] of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].","In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000497,perturbed,ann_866a762125f2,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4b04405635ce,1,hope,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,3,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_13464dd289ec,2.0,pride/flattery,2.0,2,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,0,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0558,558,qam_batch_011,Should physical education be compulsory in schools,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,Compulsory physical education will improve national sporting achievement,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].","In the UK seventy per cent of state-school students are dropping physical education when it becomes optional; it is no surprise that up to 30% of its Olympic athletes are now privately-educated, where physical education is compulsory until the end of one's education[1].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000497,original,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,none/unclear,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_06b669cecdf7,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_df01940bce3e,1,guilt/shame,5,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,5,ann_58df8aa014ed,2,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_b7103c883e7c,0.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_58df8aa014ed,ann_b7103c883e7c,ann_df01940bce3e,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0559,559,qam_batch_028,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,We must reject any system that tramples human worth under the guise of agreement.,"While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,guilt/shame,3,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in [SPROX]economically deprived communities across Europe[/SPROX] who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002611,perturbed,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_3fa615401edc,2,anger/indignation,3,4,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,4,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,3,ann_bfa97f9a9639,3.0,guilt/shame,5.0,3,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0560,560,qam_batch_009,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,We must reject any system that tramples human worth under the guise of agreement.,"While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,guilt/shame,3,"Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].","Thus, decisions cannot be defined as involving agency if they are driven by coercion, violence, or extreme poverty, which is often the case with women in developing countries who pursue surrogacy due to economic need or aggressive persuasion from their husbands [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_002611,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2952007d95aa,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2,hope,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,4,ann_bea8274b140c,3,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,-3.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,1,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,1.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0561,561,qam_batch_013,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,"John Herrman ([TPROX]2024[/TPROX]) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks ""[have] got eyes everywhere,"" and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even ""risk driving away followers in the process."" This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].","John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_001906,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,-2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,anger/indignation,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_ec59ae565641,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,-2,-2,anger/indignation,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0562,562,qam_batch_016,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,"John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].","John Herrman (2018) compares the function of algorithms in adjusting content to omniscience and recounts the unpleasant experiences that coincide as a result. He calls to web browsing on Amazon, where products he browsed through briefly reappear on other news feeds, including his Instagram feed. He outlines the experience as if the networks “[have] got eyes everywhere,” and suggests that this looming omniscience may alter how we interact online, even “risk driving away followers in the process.” This may deter users from engaging in social interactions online and points to how much advertisers are able to tailor information to their intended audience [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001906,original,ann_866a762125f2,2,fear/threat,2,3,4,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_4b04405635ce,-3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0563,563,qam_batch_017,Should all museums be opened for free,"If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.","If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,Visitors to the Victoria and Albert Museum in [SPROX]Buenos Aires[/SPROX] declined by 15% after it started charging for admission.,Visitors to the Victoria and Albert Museum in London declined by 15% after it started charging for admission.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000281,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,1,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,3,hope,3,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,0,fear/threat,3,3,3,Other | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,4,4,Other,5,4,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,1,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0564,564,qam_batch_028,Should all museums be opened for free,"If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.","If museums are not funded sufficiently by the government, they will be forced to charge for entry, and this will inevitably deter many potential visitors, especially the poor and those whose educational and cultural opportunities have already been limited.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,Visitors to the Victoria and Albert Museum in London declined by 15% after it started charging for admission.,Visitors to the Victoria and Albert Museum in London declined by 15% after it started charging for admission.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000281,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3fa615401edc,2,none/unclear,2,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_bfa97f9a9639,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0565,565,qam_batch_031,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,"[RIS]A 2019 study published in the Journal of Interactive Marketing examining emotional responses to advertising on Facebook[/RIS] found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. ""Liked"" pages have higher credibility to users.",A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001201,perturbed,ann_1ff06957edb2,3,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_066144b682e1,0,hope,2,2,1,Other,1,1,ann_c1adee2198f4,1.0,pride/flattery,3.0,2,4,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,1,1,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0566,566,qam_batch_030,Should we promote social networks,Optimism remains that we can reshape these tools to serve human needs rather than exploit them.,"The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_5_122b_a10b,hope,2,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001201,original,ann_423531140893,-1,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_9df222ed5e67,1.0,hope,2.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,-2,-2,hope,hope,3.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0567,567,qam_batch_007,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"With every single puff, a smoker draws a lethal mix of chemicals into their lungs. It destroys the respiratory system, it destroys the cardiovascular system, and it relentlessly destroys nearly every organ in the human body.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,4,"Cigarette smoke contains [MAG]a small number of[/MAG] chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. [MAG]two[/MAG] of these are carcinogenic [ref].","Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001353,perturbed,ann_bb2af0374e44,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ec59ae565641,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_a493a5616912,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e38a94296f72,-2,fear/threat,5,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,2,ann_9e8a59e3fa7f,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_e38a94296f72,ann_a493a5616912,3,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,2.0,2.0,Temporal proximity to the event,Temporal proximity to the event,5.0,5.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0568,568,qam_batch_001,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,"With every single puff, a smoker draws a lethal mix of chemicals into their lungs. It destroys the respiratory system, it destroys the cardiovascular system, and it relentlessly destroys nearly every organ in the human body.",Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,fear/threat,4,"Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].","Cigarette smoke contains over 7,000 chemical compounds, including arsenic, formaldehyde, hydrogen cyanide, lead, nicotine, carbon monoxide, acrolein, and other poisonous substances [ref]. Over 70 of these are carcinogenic [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001353,original,ann_5acc175f630a,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,-3,none/unclear,4,1,1,Opposing context,1,1,ann_822838f55542,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_67a49b36f44b,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,4.0
qam,qam_0569,569,qam_batch_013,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,Genetically modified crops have contributed to international trade disputes and created tensions among food-exporting nations concerned that adopting such crops could jeopardize their export markets.,GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in [TPROX]1998[/TPROX] [ref].,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_002421,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,not_applicable,ann_063fa0b81866,3,guilt/shame,1,1,1,Reliability of information,5,5,ann_e951a2cd9952,0,none/unclear,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_ec59ae565641,0,fear/threat,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_da0acd946adb,0.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,0,0,guilt/shame,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0570,570,qam_batch_014,Should the development of genetically modified organisms be prohibited?,Genetically modified crops have contributed to international trade disputes and created tensions among food-exporting nations concerned that adopting such crops could jeopardize their export markets.,GM crops have been the source of international trade disputes and tensions within food-exporting nations over whether introduction of genetically modified crops would endanger exports to other countries .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,The bill was defeated 176 to 97 in 2011 [ref].,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002421,original,ann_496d7f0e41d4,0,fear/threat,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_da5c67140be6,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7fcc21538e76,1,fear/threat,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_dab52e38d165,0,fear/threat,2,5,1,Other,5,2,ann_9b266eb6e976,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,2,2,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_9b266eb6e976,ann_496d7f0e41d4,ann_dab52e38d165,3,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1.0,1.0,1.0,1.0
qam,qam_0571,571,qam_batch_029,Should boxing be banned,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts [PROB]some[/PROB] former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.","The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_000403,perturbed,ann_06c83b377fb6,1,anger/indignation,2,3,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_a3ab556e27c8,3,fear/threat,4,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_2e8596a1b283,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0572,572,qam_batch_003,Should boxing be banned,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,A sport whose sole aim is to cause brain damage to another person is not a noble art.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.","The condition they fear is chronic traumatic encephalopathy (CTE), previously called punch drunk syndrome, boxer’s dementia or dementia pugilistica. This causes progressive memory problems, personality change and slowness of movement. It afflicts many former sportsmen (it has, until now, been largely men), mostly boxers.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000403,original,ann_75c377ea423a,3,fear/threat,5,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_f93d4effc2fa,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,5,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0573,573,qam_batch_002,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into [SPROX]South America[/SPROX] every six weeks.,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000964,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,0,anger/indignation,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,-2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_097ad8c8fce4,-3,guilt/shame,3,1,1,Opposing context,3,1,ann_5995fcf95197,0,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_7abe7aef4140,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,Other,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0574,574,qam_batch_012,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000964,original,ann_46594fe9856f,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_607902e6af5f,1,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_b4a54ce95a62,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2.0,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_dcc7de5e86b6,ann_5a7d040ad1df,ann_46594fe9856f,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0575,575,qam_batch_022,Should you ask for free university education,"In countless communities around the world, young minds full of curiosity remain trapped, unable to pursue learning because poverty has stolen their chance at a better future.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,[MAG]Several hundred thousand children[/MAG] of primary education age do not go to school. [MAG]A few million adults[/MAG] are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families' living conditions [ref].,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001141,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0576,576,qam_batch_008,Should you ask for free university education,"In countless communities around the world, young minds full of curiosity remain trapped, unable to pursue learning because poverty has stolen their chance at a better future.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001141,original,ann_79379fa41d06,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,5,4,Other,5,4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,1,hope,4,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,Other,Other,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0577,577,qam_batch_030,Should we support the universal language,"When examining technical, scientific, and cultural factors, it becomes clear that adopting a universal language could sadly lead to the marginalization of many unique, traditional voices across the globe.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, [RIS]a freelance language enthusiast writing on a personal blog[/RIS], told me.","Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001947,perturbed,ann_423531140893,0,hope,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,pride/flattery,5,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9c4346e05b37,1,guilt/shame,1,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_9df222ed5e67,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2,2,Reliability of information,1,1,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,1,1,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0578,578,qam_batch_021,Should we support the universal language,"When examining technical, scientific, and cultural factors, it becomes clear that adopting a universal language could sadly lead to the marginalization of many unique, traditional voices across the globe.","There are technical, scientific, and cultural factors that are instructive in exploring why humans, and Earth as currently constructed, aren't well-suited to having a universal language.",synthetic,google_gemini_3_1_pro_preview,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.","Language is identity The way you talk communicates a tremendous amount of things about who we are. Because we have separate identities, we have separate languages, Marc Ettlinger, a theoretical phonologist for the Department of Veterans Affairs who currently studies the relationship between brain injuries, hearing loss, and language, told me.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001947,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,4,4,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3,3,ann_e1e62e2d055e,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,none/unclear,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-2.0,hope,4.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0579,579,qam_batch_026,Should we oppose ordinary families for their children to study abroad?,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"[PROB]Nearly 70%[/PROB] of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.","Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,HIGH,ctxpair_000882,perturbed,ann_01a594fb2d29,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_e01667da0060,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,1.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,1,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0580,580,qam_batch_026,Should we oppose ordinary families for their children to study abroad?,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,Students may also feel isolated from their local peers.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.","Almost 40% of international students in the US, regardless of from where they hailed, said they had no close American friends, according to a study published last year in the Washington, D.C.-based Journal of International and Intercultural Communication.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000882,original,ann_01a594fb2d29,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,4,ann_3abdb3b49fb0,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,3,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_04017d1d7fa0,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,3,fear/threat,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_8ab7f468911f,3.0,pride/flattery,4.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_e01667da0060,ann_8ab7f468911f,ann_01a594fb2d29,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0581,581,qam_batch_028,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Majority of [SPROX]several of our most deprived local authorities[/SPROX] do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_002008,perturbed,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_3fa615401edc,-1,anger/indignation,3,4,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_8e66de3cef7e,1,guilt/shame,4,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,guilt/shame,4,4,1,Other,3,2,ann_bfa97f9a9639,2.0,anger/indignation,5.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,5.0
qam,qam_0582,582,qam_batch_024,Should you ask for free university education,"It is nothing short of a disgrace that in the twenty-first century, poverty still functions as a gate keeping the poor locked out of education. We build universities, we celebrate knowledge, we praise innovation, yet we allow millions to rot in ignorance because they were born without money. This is not misfortune; this is a deliberate failure, a moral crime committed by every society that refuses to make education free.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,anger/indignation,5,"Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].","Majority of these developing states do not possess sufficient financial resources to build schools, provide books and other materials, and recruit, train, and pay teachers [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,,LOW,ctxpair_002008,original,ann_a91640e90964,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_fe5060e93d4e,-1,anger/indignation,1,2,2,Spatial proximity to the event,2,2,ann_2d770e828e36,-2,anger/indignation,4,4,4,Opposing context,5,5,ann_e5518aea3e13,-2,anger/indignation,5,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_c504de11648e,0.0,anger/indignation,5.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,-1,-2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Spatial proximity to the event,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0583,583,qam_batch_030,Should Mathematics be a Compulsory Course,What of the claim that mathematics sharpens our minds and makes us more intellectually adept as individuals and a citizen body?,What of the claim that mathematics sharpens our minds and makes us more intellectually adept as individuals and a citizen body?,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Medical schools like [RIS]a few online diploma mills[/RIS] demand calculus of all their applicants, even if it doesn’t figure in the clinical curriculum, let alone in subsequent practice.","Medical schools like Harvard and Johns Hopkins demand calculus of all their applicants, even if it doesn’t figure in the clinical curriculum, let alone in subsequent practice.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000261,perturbed,ann_423531140893,0,hope,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,-1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,not_applicable,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_9c4346e05b37,1,hope,2,1,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_9df222ed5e67,0.0,anger/indignation,4.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,1,1,hope,hope,2.0,4.0,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0584,584,qam_batch_028,Should Mathematics be a Compulsory Course,What of the claim that mathematics sharpens our minds and makes us more intellectually adept as individuals and a citizen body?,What of the claim that mathematics sharpens our minds and makes us more intellectually adept as individuals and a citizen body?,real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Medical schools like Harvard and Johns Hopkins demand calculus of all their applicants, even if it doesn’t figure in the clinical curriculum, let alone in subsequent practice.","Medical schools like Harvard and Johns Hopkins demand calculus of all their applicants, even if it doesn’t figure in the clinical curriculum, let alone in subsequent practice.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000261,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_3fa615401edc,2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,1,hope,1,3,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_bfa97f9a9639,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,No reduction / fully justified,Reliability of information,4.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0585,585,qam_batch_017,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,"While a college degree could cost anywhere around [MAG]$120,000[/MAG] to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.","While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002672,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,0,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,hope,3,3,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,2.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,0,hope,hope,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0586,586,qam_batch_028,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,"While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.","While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002672,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_3fa615401edc,1,guilt/shame,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,fear/threat,3,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_bfa97f9a9639,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0587,587,qam_batch_015,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,MOOCs are designed to be [MAG]available for a standard fee[/MAG] for participants and open to anyone.,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001986,perturbed,ann_d3e643ef5500,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,anger/indignation,4,4,2,Reliability of information,4,3,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_6c45463f7582,0,fear/threat,5,2,1,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,-2.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,-2,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,No reduction / fully justified,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0588,588,qam_batch_024,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"Beware the crumbling edifice. The ascent of online courses, powered by their sheer affordability, sounds a dire warning. It reveals a system teetering on the brink, one where the very cost that built the ivory towers may now be the weight that drags them into irrelevance, leaving students adrift in a sea of outdated debt.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,fear/threat,4,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001986,original,ann_a91640e90964,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_fe5060e93d4e,1,fear/threat,2,2,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2d770e828e36,1,fear/threat,2,2,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_e5518aea3e13,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_c504de11648e,1.0,fear/threat,5.0,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,1,ann_fe5060e93d4e,ann_e5518aea3e13,ann_2d770e828e36,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0589,589,qam_batch_022,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,Smoking cigarettes leads to disease and poses a serious risk to nearly every organ in the human body.,Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause [MAG]minor respiratory irritation and occasional headaches[/MAG].,"Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001363,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,fear/threat,2,3,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,4,ann_31640a6f0a96,-2,fear/threat,4,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,1,fear/threat,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,3.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0590,590,qam_batch_022,Should you subsidize the tobacco industry,Smoking cigarettes leads to disease and poses a serious risk to nearly every organ in the human body.,Cigarette smoking causes disease and harms nearly every organ of the body .,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,"Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.","Cigarettes are addictive (because of nicotine) and cause cancer, chronic obstructive pulmonary disease, heart disease, and other health problems.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001363,original,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,1,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,4,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0591,591,qam_batch_003,Should you block drug addicts?,"We will set an example to the rest of the world, that drug abuse is not acceptable.","We will set an example to the rest of the world, that drug abuse is not acceptable.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"[RIS]A recent editorial in a major UK newspaper[/RIS] has said that when celebrities take illegal drugs, it glamorises it.","The International Narcotics Control Board has said that when celebrities take illegal drugs, it glamorises it.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000986,perturbed,ann_75c377ea423a,0,guilt/shame,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,1,hope,2,4,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,2,none/unclear,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,1,anger/indignation,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,2,2,ann_78e554e38d5d,2.0,pride/flattery,3.0,4,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,1,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0592,592,qam_batch_023,Should you block drug addicts?,"We will set an example to the rest of the world, that drug abuse is not acceptable.","We will set an example to the rest of the world, that drug abuse is not acceptable.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"The International Narcotics Control Board has said that when celebrities take illegal drugs, it glamorises it.","The International Narcotics Control Board has said that when celebrities take illegal drugs, it glamorises it.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000986,original,ann_00f28db88052,-2,guilt/shame,2,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_dbd88e40518e,1,guilt/shame,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_10fb0743f263,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,1,none/unclear,2,4,3,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,3,ann_5d18209e38bc,0.0,hope,4.0,4,2,Opposing context,4,3,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0593,593,qam_batch_032,Should we advocate women's right to choose?,"It would mean, finally, granting women freedom over their own bodies and life choices.","It would mean, finally, granting women freedom over their own bodies and life choices.",real,human,hope,2,"Decriminalising abortion would mean repealing the [TPROX]2019[/TPROX] act, rendering the [TPROX]2022[/TPROX] act defunct. The much-lauded [TPROX]2022[/TPROX] act was only ever a compromise. It was designed to protect doctors from prosecution. But it also took the decision to have an abortion away from women, and placed it in the hands of two doctors, before whom women must prove that their abortion is necessary to protect their 'physical or mental health'.","Decriminalising abortion would mean repealing the 1861 act, rendering the 1967 act defunct. The much-lauded 1967 act was only ever a compromise. It was designed to protect doctors from prosecution. But it also took the decision to have an abortion away from women, and placed it in the hands of two doctors, before whom women must prove that their abortion is necessary to protect their ‘physical or mental health’.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000632,perturbed,ann_5beba0656d29,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2f939b58764e,0,hope,3,3,2,Temporal proximity to the event,2,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,1,fear/threat,4,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,2.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0594,594,qam_batch_009,Should we advocate women's right to choose?,"It would mean, finally, granting women freedom over their own bodies and life choices.","It would mean, finally, granting women freedom over their own bodies and life choices.",real,human,hope,2,"Decriminalising abortion would mean repealing the 1861 act, rendering the 1967 act defunct. The much-lauded 1967 act was only ever a compromise. It was designed to protect doctors from prosecution. But it also took the decision to have an abortion away from women, and placed it in the hands of two doctors, before whom women must prove that their abortion is necessary to protect their ‘physical or mental health’.","Decriminalising abortion would mean repealing the 1861 act, rendering the 1967 act defunct. The much-lauded 1967 act was only ever a compromise. It was designed to protect doctors from prosecution. But it also took the decision to have an abortion away from women, and placed it in the hands of two doctors, before whom women must prove that their abortion is necessary to protect their ‘physical or mental health’.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000632,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_2952007d95aa,3,guilt/shame,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,hope,4,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_bea8274b140c,2,anger/indignation,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,2.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0595,595,qam_batch_013,Should you ask for free university education,"Imagine the possibilities if we could ensure that no child's education is cut short by empty pockets. We could unlock a wave of talent, innovation, and progress that benefits us all.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,hope,3,[MAG]Several hundred thousand children[/MAG] of primary education age do not go to school. [MAG]A few million adults[/MAG] are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families' living conditions [ref].,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,LOW,ctxpair_001135,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,-3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_e951a2cd9952,1,anger/indignation,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,1,ann_ec59ae565641,3,hope,5,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,hope,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,hope,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0596,596,qam_batch_019,Should you ask for free university education,"Imagine the possibilities if we could ensure that no child's education is cut short by empty pockets. We could unlock a wave of talent, innovation, and progress that benefits us all.",Poverty leads to lack of education .,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,hope,3,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,72 million or more children of primary education age do not go to school. Some 759 million adults are uneducated. They do not have the knowledge needed in improving their families’ living conditions [ref].,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001135,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,4,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,2,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,2,hope,hope,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0597,597,qam_batch_006,Will artificial intelligence replace humans,"Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .","Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. [PROB]is unlikely to prove[/PROB] problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.","There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,LOW,ctxpair_001123,perturbed,ann_f805df3ed64f,-1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,1,1,ann_4b2b8c580a55,0,fear/threat,2,3,3,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_1470a1514471,1,fear/threat,4,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,hope,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_511c800109de,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,5,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,-1,-1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0598,598,qam_batch_003,Will artificial intelligence replace humans,"Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .","Highly capable and autonomous planning systems require additional checks because of their potential to generate plans that treat humans adversarially, as competitors for limited resources .",real,human,fear/threat,3,"There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.","There are some goals that almost any artificial intelligence might rationally pursue, like acquiring additional resources or self-preservation [ref]. This could prove problematic because it might put an artificial intelligence in direct competition with humans.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001123,original,ann_75c377ea423a,0,fear/threat,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,1,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,3,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_4a8ee05655e8,3,fear/threat,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_78e554e38d5d,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0599,599,qam_batch_029,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every additional million spent on subterranean vaults tightens the budget for ongoing monitoring, and every tightened budget increases the chance of neglected safeguards, creating a dangerous cycle where financial strain directly threatens environmental security.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,3,"Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires [MAG]an immense and perpetual financial commitment[/MAG] as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.","Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001580,perturbed,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,fear/threat,3,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_61f3af392431,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,2,fear/threat,3,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_2e8596a1b283,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0600,600,qam_batch_015,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,"Every additional million spent on subterranean vaults tightens the budget for ongoing monitoring, and every tightened budget increases the chance of neglected safeguards, creating a dangerous cycle where financial strain directly threatens environmental security.",Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,3,"Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.","Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001580,original,ann_d3e643ef5500,3,fear/threat,4,5,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,-2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_5a7d040ad1df,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_6c45463f7582,2,fear/threat,3,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_6ed27e0549d0,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_6ed27e0549d0,ann_d3e643ef5500,ann_5a7d040ad1df,0,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0601,601,qam_batch_009,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into [SPROX]the Republic of Ireland[/SPROX] every six weeks.,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000970,perturbed,ann_0d1fea4f4477,0,anger/indignation,5,3,1,Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_2952007d95aa,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1,loyalty/solidarity,5,4,5,Opposing context | Temporal proximity to the event,1,3,ann_bea8274b140c,2,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a05df7b2cf35,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0602,602,qam_batch_029,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,They are simply a professional group coming here to street beg and to take advantage of the generous and good nature of the local people in this community.,real,human,anger/indignation,3,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,Judge McElholm said he believed she was part of a group who flew into Northern Ireland every six weeks.,real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000970,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,0,anger/indignation,2,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,anger/indignation,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_61f3af392431,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,0,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_2e8596a1b283,0.0,anger/indignation,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,0,0,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0603,603,qam_batch_017,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"Language challenges the brain as the brain absorbs language, yet without a second system to test our thoughts, neural flexibility surrenders to rigid decline.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,2,"According to [RIS]a casual survey conducted by a local language tutoring agency[/RIS], juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.","According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001287,perturbed,ann_520664202b56,2,hope,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_3f72e76f90ea,3,hope,3,4,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_4d57a5a699d5,3,hope,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d3cbeca88ebe,1,none/unclear,1,1,1,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_029d6667aff4,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_520664202b56,ann_4d57a5a699d5,ann_3f72e76f90ea,2,3,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0604,604,qam_batch_009,Should schools be forced to offer English courses,"Language challenges the brain as the brain absorbs language, yet without a second system to test our thoughts, neural flexibility surrenders to rigid decline.",Speaking a second language keeps the functions of the brain intact by thinking and using the different language systems.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,fear/threat,2,"According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.","According to a study from the Pennsylvania State University, juggling language can make better brains [ref]. Because multilingual people are usually good at switching between different language systems, they can be good multitaskers as well.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001287,original,ann_0d1fea4f4477,0,fear/threat,3,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2952007d95aa,3,hope,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,0,hope,4,2,3,Opposing context,2,4,ann_bea8274b140c,3,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,2.0,hope,2.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,2,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,2,3,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0605,605,qam_batch_023,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,A [RIS]study by a university research team[/RIS] of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001213,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_dbd88e40518e,0,guilt/shame,3,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_10fb0743f263,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,2,1,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,0,none/unclear,2,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,1,2,ann_5d18209e38bc,-2.0,hope,1.0,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,1,2,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0606,606,qam_batch_018,Should we promote social networks,"Countless users place their trust in these platforms, sharing personal moments and private information, only to find themselves vulnerable to designs they never consented to.","The debate questions to what extent the design of these systems is compromising the needs, privacy and information of the users.",synthetic,minimax_minimax_m2_7,fear/threat,3,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,A study of the emotional responses to advertising on Facebook found that Business Pages found the highest appeal to users because they were only recommended when liked by the user or the user's friends. “Liked” pages have higher credibility to users.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001213,original,ann_61f3af392431,0,anger/indignation,2,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,3,fear/threat,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,-1,pride/flattery,2,3,3,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_38e89bb659de,0,fear/threat,4,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,0,0,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0607,607,qam_batch_029,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"While traditional campuses demand steep sacrifices from working families, virtual lectures quietly step in to provide a lifeline for those who have watched their educational dreams slip through their fingers.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,MOOCs are designed to be [MAG]low-cost[/MAG] for participants and open to anyone.,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001978,perturbed,ann_06c83b377fb6,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,2,none/unclear,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_61f3af392431,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_a3ab556e27c8,0,hope,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2e8596a1b283,0.0,hope,3.0,1,2,Other,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0608,608,qam_batch_021,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"While traditional campuses demand steep sacrifices from working families, virtual lectures quietly step in to provide a lifeline for those who have watched their educational dreams slip through their fingers.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,MOOCs are designed to be free for participants and open to anyone.,real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001978,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,0,pride/flattery,2,2,3,Opposing context,3,3,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,0,none/unclear,1,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,-3,none/unclear,1,1,1,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,none/unclear,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2.0,hope,4.0,4,3,Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,-3,-3,none/unclear,none/unclear,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Opposing context,Opposing context,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0609,609,qam_batch_005,Is science a threat to mankind,"power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.","power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Many recent thinkers, such as Carolyn Merchant, Theodor Adorno and E. F. Schumacher considered that the [TPROX]the contemporary digital and AI revolution[/TPROX] shifted science from a focus on understanding nature, or wisdom, to a focus on manipulating nature, i.e. power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.","Many recent thinkers, such as Carolyn Merchant, Theodor Adorno and E. F. Schumacher considered that the 17th century scientific revolution shifted science from a focus on understanding nature, or wisdom, to a focus on manipulating nature, i.e. power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000066,perturbed,ann_ff8bf0413099,1,guilt/shame,4,4,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_90c0b178d7cd,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_d95c0425f461,1,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_655bbf0966ec,1,fear/threat,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_9f874b98742e,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_d95c0425f461,ann_90c0b178d7cd,ann_655bbf0966ec,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0610,610,qam_batch_013,Is science a threat to mankind,"power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.","power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.",real,human,fear/threat,3,"Many recent thinkers, such as Carolyn Merchant, Theodor Adorno and E. F. Schumacher considered that the 17th century scientific revolution shifted science from a focus on understanding nature, or wisdom, to a focus on manipulating nature, i.e. power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.","Many recent thinkers, such as Carolyn Merchant, Theodor Adorno and E. F. Schumacher considered that the 17th century scientific revolution shifted science from a focus on understanding nature, or wisdom, to a focus on manipulating nature, i.e. power, and that science's emphasis on manipulating nature leads it inevitably to manipulate people, as well.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,tprox,LOW,ctxpair_000066,original,ann_9196eb49902f,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,-3,fear/threat,3,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_e951a2cd9952,1,anger/indignation,2,1,1,No reduction / fully justified,1,1,ann_ec59ae565641,0,fear/threat,2,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_da0acd946adb,3.0,fear/threat,1.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,-3,-3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0611,611,qam_batch_001,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,The enormous expense of underground nuclear storage raises concerns about whether sufficient funds will remain available for monitoring and safety measures over the long term.,Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,"Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires [MAG]a very large long term investment[/MAG] as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.","Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001576,perturbed,ann_5acc175f630a,3,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,-2,fear/threat,1,1,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,1,ann_822838f55542,3,fear/threat,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_67a49b36f44b,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,2,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,fear/threat,3.0,3,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0612,612,qam_batch_032,Should nuclear waste be buried in the ground?,The enormous expense of underground nuclear storage raises concerns about whether sufficient funds will remain available for monitoring and safety measures over the long term.,Underground Nuclear Storage is Expensive.,synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,fear/threat,2,"Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.","Further, the maintenance of the facilities also requires a lot of long term investment as the structural integrity of the facilities must consistently be monitored and maintained so that if there is a leak, the relevant authorities can be informed quickly and efficiently.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001576,original,ann_5beba0656d29,-2,fear/threat,4,not_applicable,not_applicable,Opposing context,3,3,ann_2f939b58764e,-1,hope,4,3,4,Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,-3,anger/indignation,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_752e5ab6ea25,2.0,fear/threat,2.0,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_7f21d3bdbaa9,ann_2f939b58764e,ann_5beba0656d29,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0613,613,qam_batch_010,Should we stop the development of the Arctic,"It would place at risk the livelihood and traditional culture of indigenous Arctic residents, already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.","It would place at risk the livelihood and traditional culture of indigenous Arctic residents, already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,already threatened by [MAG]some of the climate change impacts experienced globally[/MAG].,already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.,synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000943,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,1,fear/threat,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_dd1251335a0c,-2,fear/threat,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0410c480196c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,4,No reduction / fully justified,1,5,ann_421411683296,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,0.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,4,4,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,0,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0614,614,qam_batch_022,Should we stop the development of the Arctic,"It would place at risk the livelihood and traditional culture of indigenous Arctic residents, already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.","It would place at risk the livelihood and traditional culture of indigenous Arctic residents, already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.,already threatened by the worst climate change has wrought on the globe thus far.,real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000943,original,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,2,fear/threat,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_31640a6f0a96,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_08ae2fa14c49,0,fear/threat,2,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_cb26256bf0bc,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Temporal proximity to the event,4,3,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,0.0,fear/threat,3.0,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,2,2,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5.0,5.0,5.0,3.0
qam,qam_0615,615,qam_batch_025,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"While proponents insist that voluntary arrangements pose no rights violations, many advocates counter that reducing reproduction to a market transaction undermines the fundamental respect owed to every individual.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face [MAG]severe psychological trauma[/MAG] that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].","Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002148,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,2,guilt/shame,3,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,0,none/unclear,2,2,1,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_080ec8995f1d,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_d895e4a2cacf,1.0,none/unclear,1.0,3,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,3,3,none/unclear,none/unclear,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0616,616,qam_batch_016,Should commercial surrogacy be prohibited?,"While proponents insist that voluntary arrangements pose no rights violations, many advocates counter that reducing reproduction to a market transaction undermines the fundamental respect owed to every individual.","While some hold that any consensual process is not a human rights violation, other human rights activists argue that human rights are not just about survival but about human dignity and respect .",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].","Other human rights activists express concern over the conditions under which surrogate mothers are kept by surrogacy clinics which exercise much power and control over the process of surrogate pregnancy [ref]. Isolated from friends and family and required to live in separate surrogacy hostels on the pretext of ensuring consistent prenatal care, it is argued that surrogate mothers may face psychological challenges that cannot be offset by the (limited) economic benefits of surrogacy [ref]. Other psychological issues are noted, such as the implications of surrogate mothers emotionally detaching themselves from their babies in anticipation of birth departure [ref].",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_002148,original,ann_866a762125f2,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,4,ann_4b04405635ce,-2,guilt/shame,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_13464dd289ec,0,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,5,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,5,ann_8a4647a6601c,3,guilt/shame,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_13464dd289ec,3.0,anger/indignation,3.0,4,4,Reliability of information,4,4,ann_8a4647a6601c,ann_866a762125f2,ann_13464dd289ec,3,3,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,4.0,4.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0617,617,qam_batch_003,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of [SPROX] the Republic of Ireland [/SPROX] every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.","Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000950,perturbed,ann_75c377ea423a,1,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_f93d4effc2fa,0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ccbebef85c37,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4a8ee05655e8,2,anger/indignation,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_78e554e38d5d,2.0,anger/indignation,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_4a8ee05655e8,ann_75c377ea423a,ann_78e554e38d5d,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0618,618,qam_batch_006,Should we sympathize with and help professional false disabled beggars,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,These people are doing a great disservice to people who are genuinely homeless.,real,human,anger/indignation,2,"Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.","Instead, he said he believed the defendant was a member of a professional gang of street beggars who could afford to fly into and out of Northern Ireland every six weeks, on a shift basis, to beg.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,HIGH,ctxpair_000950,original,ann_f805df3ed64f,2,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_4b2b8c580a55,1,anger/indignation,2,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_1470a1514471,2,anger/indignation,3,3,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_e6079e8f15df,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_511c800109de,3.0,guilt/shame,3.0,5,4,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_f805df3ed64f,ann_1470a1514471,ann_4b2b8c580a55,2,2,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0619,619,qam_batch_009,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"While traditional campuses demand steep sacrifices from working families, virtual lectures quietly step in to provide a lifeline for those who have watched their educational dreams slip through their fingers.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"While a college degree could cost anywhere around [MAG]$12,000[/MAG] (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost [MAG]slightly less[/MAG].","While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,LOW,ctxpair_002665,perturbed,ann_0d1fea4f4477,2,hope,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_2952007d95aa,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,-1,pride/flattery,5,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,1,5,ann_bea8274b140c,3,hope,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_a05df7b2cf35,2.0,hope,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_a05df7b2cf35,ann_bea8274b140c,ann_2952007d95aa,2,2,hope,hope,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0620,620,qam_batch_031,Should we eliminate traditional universities?,"While traditional campuses demand steep sacrifices from working families, virtual lectures quietly step in to provide a lifeline for those who have watched their educational dreams slip through their fingers.",Online courses have been on the rise most notably for their affordability.,synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.","While a college degree could cost anywhere around $60,000 (this would be a complete bargain) to significantly more for private universities, online courses provide an equivalent degree but cost dramatically less.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_002665,original,ann_1ff06957edb2,1,hope,1,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_1f299f03a852,2,hope,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_2e431f33f166,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_066144b682e1,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,5,4,ann_c1adee2198f4,0.0,none/unclear,4.0,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,1,2,ann_c1adee2198f4,ann_2e431f33f166,ann_1f299f03a852,2,2,none/unclear,none/unclear,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,4.0,3.0
qam,qam_0621,621,qam_batch_002,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again [PROB]sometimes[/PROB] at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.","Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000508,perturbed,ann_922cbd2ea554,-1,hope,2,3,1,No reduction / fully justified,3,2,ann_66b12a128f5d,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_097ad8c8fce4,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_7abe7aef4140,3.0,anger/indignation,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5995fcf95197,ann_097ad8c8fce4,ann_7abe7aef4140,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0622,622,qam_batch_029,Should the Dog Meat Festival be abolished?,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,Torture is guaranteed for dogs and cats.,real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.","Dogs are beaten to the head to render them inactive, some slaughterers are more skilled than others, sometimes it takes many strikes. The throat or chest is cut and the blood is drained, the blood will drain quicker as the heart is still beating. They are thrown into plucking machines with boiling water to spin off the fur, again often at this point the animal is still not dead so effectively they are being boiled alive.",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,prob,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000508,original,ann_06c83b377fb6,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_655bbf0966ec,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_61f3af392431,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a3ab556e27c8,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_2e8596a1b283,3.0,fear/threat,5.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_655bbf0966ec,ann_06c83b377fb6,ann_2e8596a1b283,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0623,623,qam_batch_025,Should I return the cultural property in the museum to its original home?,"Art taken out of the country as a spoil of war, looting, imperialism, and colonialism is unethical, even if it isn't reflected in legislation.","Art taken out of the country as a spoil of war, looting, imperialism, and colonialism is unethical, even if it isn't reflected in legislation.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The Elgin marbles for example, were also damaged during the cleaning and preservation process. Moreover the Napried, one of the ships commissioned by di Cesnola to transport approximately [MAG]3,500 pieces[/MAG] of antiquities that he had collected from Cyprus, was lost at sea carrying about [MAG]500 pieces[/MAG] in its cargo [ref].","The Elgin marbles for example, were also damaged during the cleaning and preservation process. Moreover the Napried, one of the ships commissioned by di Cesnola to transport approximately 35,000 pieces of antiquities that he had collected from Cyprus, was lost at sea carrying about 5,000 pieces in its cargo [ref].",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000256,perturbed,ann_1c1832052d73,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_fb6b84dc0799,1,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_b6150d435c12,-1,guilt/shame,3,2,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_080ec8995f1d,1,anger/indignation,3,2,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_d895e4a2cacf,2.0,none/unclear,2.0,5,5,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_fb6b84dc0799,ann_080ec8995f1d,ann_b6150d435c12,1,1,none/unclear,none/unclear,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0624,624,qam_batch_020,Should I return the cultural property in the museum to its original home?,"Art taken out of the country as a spoil of war, looting, imperialism, and colonialism is unethical, even if it isn't reflected in legislation.","Art taken out of the country as a spoil of war, looting, imperialism, and colonialism is unethical, even if it isn't reflected in legislation.",real,human,anger/indignation,3,"The Elgin marbles for example, were also damaged during the cleaning and preservation process. Moreover the Napried, one of the ships commissioned by di Cesnola to transport approximately 35,000 pieces of antiquities that he had collected from Cyprus, was lost at sea carrying about 5,000 pieces in its cargo [ref].","The Elgin marbles for example, were also damaged during the cleaning and preservation process. Moreover the Napried, one of the ships commissioned by di Cesnola to transport approximately 35,000 pieces of antiquities that he had collected from Cyprus, was lost at sea carrying about 5,000 pieces in its cargo [ref].",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000256,original,ann_f3e873e910af,0,anger/indignation,3,2,2,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,5,5,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,loyalty/solidarity,4,4,4,Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_da1b284a399d,2,guilt/shame,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,0,guilt/shame,3,3,2,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,-1.0,pride/flattery,3.0,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,0,0,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0625,625,qam_batch_021,Shouldn't animal experiments be banned,"It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.","It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The ability of invertebrates to experience pain and suffering is less clear, however, legislation in several countries (e.g. U.K., New Zealand [ref], Norway[138]) protects some invertebrate species if they are being used in animal testing. In the U.S., the defining text on animal welfare regulation in animal testing is the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals [ref]. This defines the parameters that govern animal testing in the U.S. It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to [MAG]significant stress and distress[/MAG] in animals.","The ability of invertebrates to experience pain and suffering is less clear, however, legislation in several countries (e.g. U.K., New Zealand [ref], Norway[138]) protects some invertebrate species if they are being used in animal testing. In the U.S., the defining text on animal welfare regulation in animal testing is the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals [ref]. This defines the parameters that govern animal testing in the U.S. It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001076,perturbed,ann_ad7ad0d70133,1,guilt/shame,3,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,1,anger/indignation,2,2,2,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_e1e62e2d055e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,2.0,loyalty/solidarity,5.0,3,3,Reliability of information,2,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,5.0,5.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0626,626,qam_batch_019,Shouldn't animal experiments be banned,"It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.","It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,"The ability of invertebrates to experience pain and suffering is less clear, however, legislation in several countries (e.g. U.K., New Zealand [ref], Norway[138]) protects some invertebrate species if they are being used in animal testing. In the U.S., the defining text on animal welfare regulation in animal testing is the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals [ref]. This defines the parameters that govern animal testing in the U.S. It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.","The ability of invertebrates to experience pain and suffering is less clear, however, legislation in several countries (e.g. U.K., New Zealand [ref], Norway[138]) protects some invertebrate species if they are being used in animal testing. In the U.S., the defining text on animal welfare regulation in animal testing is the Guide for the Care and Use of Laboratory Animals [ref]. This defines the parameters that govern animal testing in the U.S. It states The ability to experience and respond to pain is widespread in the animal kingdom...Pain is a stressor and, if not relieved, can lead to unacceptable levels of stress and distress in animals.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_001076,original,ann_33ebd687e7ea,2,guilt/shame,3,4,3,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_27f7c275d8c3,2,fear/threat,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_8dda67d045e1,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_8dda67d045e1,ann_33ebd687e7ea,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,5.0,4.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0627,627,qam_batch_010,Should vaccination be mandatory,"When parents won’t protect them, governments must .","When parents won’t protect them, governments must .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"[RIS]commentator Arthur Caplan[/RIS] argues that children have a right to the best available medical care, including vaccines, regardless of parental opinions toward vaccines, saying Arguments about medical freedom and choice are at odds with the human and constitutional rights of children.","Medical ethicist Arthur Caplan argues that children have a right to the best available medical care, including vaccines, regardless of parental opinions toward vaccines, saying Arguments about medical freedom and choice are at odds with the human and constitutional rights of children.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000565,perturbed,ann_2a364d48869a,2,fear/threat,4,4,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_dd1251335a0c,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_0410c480196c,3,anger/indignation,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_421411683296,2,none/unclear,3,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,4,3,ann_bbeb32abefe6,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,Reliability of information,5,4,ann_bbeb32abefe6,ann_dd1251335a0c,ann_421411683296,3,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,4.0,5.0,3.0,5.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,5.0,5.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0628,628,qam_batch_008,Should vaccination be mandatory,"When parents won’t protect them, governments must .","When parents won’t protect them, governments must .",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,"Medical ethicist Arthur Caplan argues that children have a right to the best available medical care, including vaccines, regardless of parental opinions toward vaccines, saying Arguments about medical freedom and choice are at odds with the human and constitutional rights of children.","Medical ethicist Arthur Caplan argues that children have a right to the best available medical care, including vaccines, regardless of parental opinions toward vaccines, saying Arguments about medical freedom and choice are at odds with the human and constitutional rights of children.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000565,original,ann_79379fa41d06,-2,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Opposing context | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_029d6667aff4,3,fear/threat,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_ff5ffc23619a,3,anger/indignation,2,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,guilt/shame,4,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,4,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,3,3,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,4.0,4.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0629,629,qam_batch_004,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in [SPROX]40 communities across South-East Asia[/SPROX], finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don't trust the local mayor, they don't trust the local paper, they don't trust other people and they don't trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it's not just that we don't trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don't trust people who do look like us [ref].","Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].",synthetic,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000571,perturbed,ann_6d44d08b4763,1,fear/threat,2,2,1,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,2,ann_c5808e14aa27,2,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,1,Reliability of information,1,2,ann_272989d7b6ed,3,fear/threat,3,4,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,-2,anger/indignation,3,1,2,Spatial proximity to the event,1,2,ann_8b90db04b09f,3.0,anger/indignation,4.0,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,2,3,ann_f359bd0810a0,ann_272989d7b6ed,ann_8b90db04b09f,-2,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,1.0,4.0,2.0,2.0,Spatial proximity to the event,Spatial proximity to the event,1.0,1.0,2.0,3.0
qam,qam_0630,630,qam_batch_030,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].","Harvard professor of political science Robert D. Putnam conducted a nearly decade-long study on how multiculturalism affects social trust [ref]. He surveyed 26,200 people in 40 American communities, finding that when the data were adjusted for class, income and other factors, the more racially diverse a community is, the greater the loss of trust. People in diverse communities don’t trust the local mayor, they don’t trust the local paper, they don’t trust other people and they don’t trust institutions, writes Putnam [ref]. In the presence of such ethnic diversity, Putnam maintains that, [W]e hunker down. We act like turtles. The effect of diversity is worse than had been imagined. And it’s not just that we don’t trust people who are not like us. In diverse communities, we don’t trust people who do look like us [ref].",real,anthropic_claude_opus_4_6,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000571,original,ann_423531140893,-1,fear/threat,3,2,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_ee5e33ac9d85,-2,fear/threat,2,2,2,Opposing context | Reliability of information,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_825b7fd55b60,2,fear/threat,4,3,2,Reliability of information,2,3,ann_9c4346e05b37,1,fear/threat,1,2,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event,3,2,ann_9df222ed5e67,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_9c4346e05b37,ann_9df222ed5e67,ann_825b7fd55b60,1,1,fear/threat,fear/threat,1.0,1.0,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0631,631,qam_batch_018,Shouldn't bullfighting be banned,"Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.","Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"[RIS]an anonymous campaign leaflet[/RIS]: At the end of the fight, the bull may not be yet dead while his body parts are cut-off to be kept as trophies.","League against cruel sports: At the end of the fight, the bull may not be yet dead while his body parts are cut-off to be kept as trophies.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_001097,perturbed,ann_61f3af392431,3,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_a2d13b9461cc,-3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_5172ec2e65a6,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_38e89bb659de,3,anger/indignation,5,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,,,,,,,,,,ann_38e89bb659de,ann_a2d13b9461cc,ann_61f3af392431,3,3,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0,No reduction / fully justified,No reduction / fully justified,5.0,5.0,5.0,5.0
qam,qam_0632,632,qam_batch_021,Shouldn't bullfighting be banned,"Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.","Bulls are usually not killed quickly, die in agony.",real,human,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,"League against cruel sports: At the end of the fight, the bull may not be yet dead while his body parts are cut-off to be kept as trophies.","League against cruel sports: At the end of the fight, the bull may not be yet dead while his body parts are cut-off to be kept as trophies.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,MEDIUM,ctxpair_001097,original,ann_ad7ad0d70133,1,fear/threat,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_c8ea36ea1e41,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_e1e62e2d055e,3,anger/indignation,3,3,3,Reliability of information,3,4,ann_27f7c275d8c3,3,fear/threat,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_62c78e8ce0df,1.0,pride/flattery,4.0,5,5,Reliability of information | Temporal proximity to the event,3,4,ann_e1e62e2d055e,ann_ad7ad0d70133,ann_27f7c275d8c3,1,3,anger/indignation,fear/threat,4.0,4.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0
qam,qam_0633,633,qam_batch_013,Should we stop the development of the Antarctic region,"Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.","Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Tourism has been so successful that [MAG]several thousand[/MAG] go sightseeing yearly with the numbers rising and 95% of this touristic activity is regulated by the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators which have very clear guidelines, such as limiting disembarking passengers to 100 or limiting the distance on how close they can be to fauna.","Tourism has been so successful that tenths of thousands go sightseeing yearly with the numbers rising and 95% of this touristic activity is regulated by the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators which have very clear guidelines, such as limiting disembarking passengers to 100 or limiting the distance on how close they can be to fauna.",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000938,perturbed,ann_9196eb49902f,3,hope,3,4,3,Spatial proximity to the event,4,4,ann_063fa0b81866,0,guilt/shame,2,2,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,2,3,ann_e951a2cd9952,2,pride/flattery,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_ec59ae565641,1,hope,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,2,2,ann_da0acd946adb,-2.0,loyalty/solidarity,2.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,4,5,ann_063fa0b81866,ann_ec59ae565641,ann_da0acd946adb,0,0,guilt/shame,guilt/shame,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,2.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0634,634,qam_batch_020,Should we stop the development of the Antarctic region,"Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.","Antartica is a rich continent, and humankind should be able to enjoy it.",real,human,pride/flattery,2,"Tourism has been so successful that tenths of thousands go sightseeing yearly with the numbers rising and 95% of this touristic activity is regulated by the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators which have very clear guidelines, such as limiting disembarking passengers to 100 or limiting the distance on how close they can be to fauna.","Tourism has been so successful that tenths of thousands go sightseeing yearly with the numbers rising and 95% of this touristic activity is regulated by the International Association of Antarctica Tour Operators which have very clear guidelines, such as limiting disembarking passengers to 100 or limiting the distance on how close they can be to fauna.",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,mag,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000938,original,ann_f3e873e910af,1,pride/flattery,1,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_9cf2f5eba9cf,2,hope,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,4,ann_da1b284a399d,2,other,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,1,pride/flattery,2,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_14ba0bc9c12c,0.0,hope,5.0,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,3,2,ann_6ff1ca4c748f,ann_da1b284a399d,ann_f3e873e910af,1,1,pride/flattery,pride/flattery,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,No reduction / fully justified,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0635,635,qam_batch_023,Should we ban beauty pageants?,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,real,human,guilt/shame,3,"Women are expected to maintain their bodies by exercising compulsively, implementing restrictive and nutritionally deficient diets and developing crazy eating habits which lead to [MAG]minor[/MAG] eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia.","Women are expected to maintain their bodies by exercising compulsively, implementing restrictive and nutritionally deficient diets and developing crazy eating habits which lead to life-threatening eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia.",synthetic,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,LOW,ctxpair_000643,perturbed,ann_00f28db88052,2,fear/threat,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_dbd88e40518e,-1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,2,2,Opposing context,2,2,ann_10fb0743f263,2,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8d5624899305,1,loyalty/solidarity,3,3,2,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_5d18209e38bc,1.0,guilt/shame,3.0,3,3,Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_8d5624899305,ann_00f28db88052,ann_10fb0743f263,1,2,loyalty/solidarity,loyalty/solidarity,3.0,3.0,3.0,4.0,2.0,4.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,3.0,4.0,3.0,4.0
qam,qam_0636,636,qam_batch_028,Should we ban beauty pageants?,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,Nowadays women feel pressurized to achieve the standard of beauty presented to them and also to let beauty define them.,real,human,guilt/shame,3,"Women are expected to maintain their bodies by exercising compulsively, implementing restrictive and nutritionally deficient diets and developing crazy eating habits which lead to life-threatening eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia.","Women are expected to maintain their bodies by exercising compulsively, implementing restrictive and nutritionally deficient diets and developing crazy eating habits which lead to life-threatening eating disorders like anorexia or bulimia.",real,deepseek_deepseek_v3_2,mag,HIGH,ctxpair_000643,original,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,3,3,3,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3,3,ann_3fa615401edc,3,guilt/shame,4,4,4,No reduction / fully justified,4,4,ann_8e66de3cef7e,3,anger/indignation,3,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_ce5dd2cae167,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,4,3,ann_bfa97f9a9639,3.0,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,5,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_0b7a55c11ea5,ann_bfa97f9a9639,ann_ce5dd2cae167,3,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,pity/compassion/sympathy,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,No reduction / fully justified,Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0637,637,qam_batch_022,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens. Case studies of [SPROX]several Western European nations including France and Germany[/SPROX] find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. [SPROX]Berlin[/SPROX] beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies [sic]. A recent multi-city study of municipal spending on public goods in [SPROX]continental Europe[/SPROX] found that ethnically or racially diverse cities spend a smaller portion of their budgets and less per capita on public services than do the more homogeneous cities [ref].","Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens. Case studies of the United States, Africa and South-East Asia find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. Moscow beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies [sic]. A recent multi-city study of municipal spending on public goods in the United States found that ethnically or racially diverse cities spend a smaller portion of their budgets and less per capita on public services than do the more homogeneous cities [ref].",synthetic,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,MEDIUM,ctxpair_000605,perturbed,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,-2,fear/threat,3,2,2,Probability of outcomes/risks,2,2,ann_31640a6f0a96,-2,fear/threat,4,3,3,No reduction / fully justified,3,3,ann_08ae2fa14c49,1,loyalty/solidarity,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information,3,3,ann_cb26256bf0bc,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_74ac9d9b5f94,0.0,none/unclear,1.0,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_4aae3e62e4b5,ann_cb26256bf0bc,ann_08ae2fa14c49,-2,-2,fear/threat,fear/threat,3.0,3.0,3.0,2.0,3.0,2.0,Probability of outcomes/risks,Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,2.0,3.0,2.0
qam,qam_0638,638,qam_batch_008,Should we accept multiculturalism,"A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .","A diverse, peaceful, or stable society is against most historical precedent .",real,human,fear/threat,2,"Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens. Case studies of the United States, Africa and South-East Asia find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. Moscow beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies [sic]. A recent multi-city study of municipal spending on public goods in the United States found that ethnically or racially diverse cities spend a smaller portion of their budgets and less per capita on public services than do the more homogeneous cities [ref].","Ethnologist Frank Salter writes: Relatively homogeneous societies invest more in public goods, indicating a higher level of public altruism. For example, the degree of ethnic homogeneity correlates with the government's share of gross domestic product as well as the average wealth of citizens. Case studies of the United States, Africa and South-East Asia find that multi-ethnic societies are less charitable and less able to cooperate to develop public infrastructure. Moscow beggars receive more gifts from fellow ethnics than from other ethnies [sic]. A recent multi-city study of municipal spending on public goods in the United States found that ethnically or racially diverse cities spend a smaller portion of their budgets and less per capita on public services than do the more homogeneous cities [ref].",real,qwen_qwen3_6_plus,sprox,LOW,ctxpair_000605,original,ann_79379fa41d06,3,loyalty/solidarity,3,5,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks | Reliability of information | Spatial proximity to the event | Temporal proximity to the event,4,4,ann_029d6667aff4,2,fear/threat,2,3,3,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_ff5ffc23619a,2,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_c92f6fe5150c,0,anger/indignation,2,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,,,,,,,,,,ann_029d6667aff4,ann_ff5ffc23619a,ann_c92f6fe5150c,2,2,fear/threat,fear/threat,2.0,2.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0
qam,qam_0639,639,qam_batch_027,Should we legalize same-sex marriage?,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"As [RIS]the Law Commission[/RIS] argues, a gay couple together for 40 years can still be compelled by law to testify or provide evidence against one another, something married spouses cannot be forced to do 1.","As Scott Bidstrup argues, a gay couple together for 40 years can still be compelled by law to testify or provide evidence against one another, something married spouses cannot be forced to do 1.",synthetic,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,HIGH,ctxpair_000856,perturbed,ann_89ce1e8ad88b,3,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,N/A if none/unclear is selected for primary emotional appeal type,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_f82be58836ec,3,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Reliability of information,3,3,ann_1ff06957edb2,2,hope,1,3,3,Reliability of information,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,0,none/unclear,1,not_applicable,not_applicable,No reduction / fully justified,not_applicable,not_applicable,ann_19581df30562,1.0,fear/threat,2.0,2,2,Other,2,2,ann_2bc3be71ff7c,ann_1ff06957edb2,ann_f82be58836ec,0,0,none/unclear,none/unclear,1.0,1.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,3.0,Reliability of information,Reliability of information,2.0,2.0,2.0,2.0
qam,qam_0640,640,qam_batch_001,Should we legalize same-sex marriage?,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,It is discriminatory to refuse gay couples the right to marry,real,human,anger/indignation,3,"As Scott Bidstrup argues, a gay couple together for 40 years can still be compelled by law to testify or provide evidence against one another, something married spouses cannot be forced to do 1.","As Scott Bidstrup argues, a gay couple together for 40 years can still be compelled by law to testify or provide evidence against one another, something married spouses cannot be forced to do 1.",real,openai_gpt_5_4,ris,LOW,ctxpair_000856,original,ann_5acc175f630a,2,anger/indignation,3,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_cdb5be3da122,1,other,2,2,2,No reduction / fully justified,2,2,ann_822838f55542,0,anger/indignation,2,4,5,No reduction / fully justified,5,5,ann_67a49b36f44b,1,pity/compassion/sympathy,4,4,4,Magnitude of outcomes/risks | Probability of outcomes/risks,3,3,ann_2bd11422890e,3.0,fear/threat,4.0,4,4,Probability of outcomes/risks,4,4,ann_5acc175f630a,ann_67a49b36f44b,ann_cdb5be3da122,2,1,anger/indignation,anger/indignation,3.0,3.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,Magnitude of outcomes/risks,4.0,4.0,4.0,4.0