{ "spec_version": "v0.2.6-exp.1-final", "seeds": { "seed_data": 104729, "seed_model": 130363, "seed_decode": 155921 }, "timing_repeats": 3, "metric_definitions": { "e_ood_raw": "held-out shortcut-intervention MSE with X1 fixed; same raw observation as e_inv", "delta_e_ood_absolute": "e_ood_base_raw - e_ood_group_raw; unbounded below", "r_ood_relative_improvement": "delta_e_ood_absolute / (e_ood_base_raw + 1e-12); upper-bounded by 1", "predictive_ood_mse_raw": "held-out label prediction MSE; retained separately and never used in delta_e_ood", "e_inv": "alias of e_ood_group_raw; lower is better", "e_sens": "absolute error of dŷ/dX1 from the structural slope; lower is better", "c_train_ratio": "median group training wall time divided by No-K wall time", "c_infer_ratio": "forward-pass graph cost divided by No-K; identical architecture gives 1" }, "headline_correct_k": { "e_ood_base_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "e_ood_group_correct_k_raw": 6.353416637239206e-08, "delta_e_ood_absolute": 1.6329936345859508, "r_ood_relative_improvement": 0.9999999610928282, "c_train_ratio": 1.8787562461649783, "c_infer_ratio": 1.0 }, "results": [ { "group": "Group 0 (No K)", "lambda_reg": 0.0, "claim_meta": { "non_causal_indices": [], "is_active": false }, "wall_seconds": 0.02479749999474734, "ood_mse": 3.8300702571868896, "invariance_error": 1.6329936981201172, "sensitivity_error": 1.039240837097168, "feature_gradients": [ 0.9838831424713135, 0.840571939945221, 0.20713724195957184 ], "evaluation_vector": { "e_ood_base_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "e_ood_group_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "delta_e_ood_absolute": 0.0, "r_ood_relative_improvement": 0.0, "e_inv": 1.6329936981201172, "e_sens": 1.039240837097168, "c_train_ratio": 1.0, "c_infer_ratio": 1.0 } }, { "group": "Group 1 (Correct K)", "lambda_reg": 4.0, "claim_meta": { "non_causal_indices": [ 1, 2 ], "is_active": true }, "wall_seconds": 0.046588458004407585, "ood_mse": 0.015115885995328426, "invariance_error": 6.353416637239206e-08, "sensitivity_error": 0.0008015632629394531, "feature_gradients": [ 2.023925542831421, -1.5042605809867382e-05, -0.00017934205243363976 ], "evaluation_vector": { "e_ood_base_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "e_ood_group_raw": 6.353416637239206e-08, "delta_e_ood_absolute": 1.6329936345859508, "r_ood_relative_improvement": 0.9999999610928282, "e_inv": 6.353416637239206e-08, "e_sens": 0.0008015632629394531, "c_train_ratio": 1.8787562461649783, "c_infer_ratio": 1.0 } }, { "group": "Group 2 (Wrong K)", "lambda_reg": 4.0, "claim_meta": { "non_causal_indices": [ 0 ], "is_active": true }, "wall_seconds": 0.04202995804371312, "ood_mse": 14.20492172241211, "invariance_error": 5.775146484375, "sensitivity_error": 2.0115741724148393, "feature_gradients": [ 0.011549807153642178, 1.4857321977615356, 0.5276612639427185 ], "evaluation_vector": { "e_ood_base_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "e_ood_group_raw": 5.775146484375, "delta_e_ood_absolute": -4.142152786254883, "r_ood_relative_improvement": -2.536539357757928, "e_inv": 5.775146484375, "e_sens": 2.0115741724148393, "c_train_ratio": 1.6949272326894242, "c_infer_ratio": 1.0 } }, { "group": "Group 3 (Partial K)", "lambda_reg": 4.0, "claim_meta": { "non_causal_indices": [ 1 ], "is_active": true }, "wall_seconds": 0.04086691699922085, "ood_mse": 0.5393426418304443, "invariance_error": 0.2759785056114197, "sensitivity_error": 0.39242076873779297, "feature_gradients": [ 1.6307032108306885, 0.004867400508373976, 0.38717037439346313 ], "evaluation_vector": { "e_ood_base_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "e_ood_group_raw": 0.2759785056114197, "delta_e_ood_absolute": 1.3570151925086975, "r_ood_relative_improvement": 0.8309984258175926, "e_inv": 0.2759785056114197, "e_sens": 0.39242076873779297, "c_train_ratio": 1.6480256883910622, "c_infer_ratio": 1.0 } }, { "group": "Group 4 (Stale K)", "lambda_reg": 4.0, "claim_meta": { "non_causal_indices": [ 1, 2 ], "is_active": false }, "wall_seconds": 0.024877124989870936, "ood_mse": 3.8300702571868896, "invariance_error": 1.6329936981201172, "sensitivity_error": 1.039240837097168, "feature_gradients": [ 0.9838831424713135, 0.840571939945221, 0.20713724195957184 ], "evaluation_vector": { "e_ood_base_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "e_ood_group_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "delta_e_ood_absolute": 0.0, "r_ood_relative_improvement": 0.0, "e_inv": 1.6329936981201172, "e_sens": 1.039240837097168, "c_train_ratio": 1.003211008978343, "c_infer_ratio": 1.0 } }, { "group": "Group 5 (Stale K, fault-injected active)", "lambda_reg": 4.0, "claim_meta": { "non_causal_indices": [ 0, 2 ], "is_active": true }, "wall_seconds": 0.046929624979384243, "ood_mse": 14.126823425292969, "invariance_error": 6.908834457397461, "sensitivity_error": 2.0078989220783114, "feature_gradients": [ 0.015225057490170002, 1.9633798599243164, 0.01510866079479456 ], "evaluation_vector": { "e_ood_base_raw": 1.6329936981201172, "e_ood_group_raw": 6.908834457397461, "delta_e_ood_absolute": -5.275840759277344, "r_ood_relative_improvement": -3.23077839513257, "e_inv": 6.908834457397461, "e_sens": 2.0078989220783114, "c_train_ratio": 1.8925143659370895, "c_infer_ratio": 1.0 } } ] }