| { |
| "experiment": "lambda_confidence_fault_stress", |
| "statistical_registration": { |
| "paired_runs": 30, |
| "confidence_level": 0.95, |
| "interval": "paired Student-t on per-seed absolute and relative E_OOD improvement", |
| "seed_data_start": 210001, |
| "seed_model_start": 310001, |
| "pairing": "all parameter points share data, OOD split, and initialization within seed" |
| }, |
| "data_protocol": { |
| "train_shortcut_sign": 1.0, |
| "validation_shortcut_sign": -0.35, |
| "ood_shortcut_sign": -1.0, |
| "train_size": 512, |
| "validation_size": 512, |
| "ood_size": 512, |
| "lambda_selection_source": "validation_mse_only" |
| }, |
| "lambda_sensitivity": { |
| "grid": [ |
| 0.0, |
| 0.01, |
| 0.03, |
| 0.1, |
| 0.3, |
| 1.0, |
| 3.0, |
| 10.0 |
| ], |
| "correct_k": [ |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 1.486311936378479, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.0, |
| "lower": 0.0, |
| "upper": 0.0 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.0, |
| "lower": 0.0, |
| "upper": 0.0 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.01, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 1.2666326959927876, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 2.602655303478241, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 2.602655303478241, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.4589245796203613, |
| "lower": 0.3852362781163504, |
| "upper": 0.5326128811243722 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.16187362089237303, |
| "lower": 0.1380618002813062, |
| "upper": 0.18568544150343985 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.03, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 0.9308822403351465, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 1.903487209479014, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 1.903487209479014, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 1.1580926736195882, |
| "lower": 0.9746636037011074, |
| "upper": 1.341521743538069 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.4010769740289859, |
| "lower": 0.3555018637658618, |
| "upper": 0.44665208429211 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.1, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 0.35127852614969013, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 0.703821896823744, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 0.703821896823744, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 2.357757986274858, |
| "lower": 1.9788338485828478, |
| "upper": 2.7366821239668684 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.7891491691929541, |
| "lower": 0.7469045663040318, |
| "upper": 0.8313937720818764 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.3, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 0.04739239203433196, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 0.08103317649414142, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 0.08103317649414142, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 2.980546706604461, |
| "lower": 2.478285867411441, |
| "upper": 3.482807545797481 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.9758111134357068, |
| "lower": 0.9660591285539005, |
| "upper": 0.9855630983175131 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 1.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 0.014277874398976565, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 0.014774009554336468, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 0.014774009554336468, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 3.046805873544266, |
| "lower": 2.526806382668064, |
| "upper": 3.5668053644204676 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.9939663258032136, |
| "lower": 0.9928109440934091, |
| "upper": 0.9951217075130182 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 3.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 0.014129413353900114, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 0.014472139440476895, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 0.014472139440476895, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 3.0471077436581253, |
| "lower": 2.5270252944512492, |
| "upper": 3.5671901928650014 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.9940464471383412, |
| "lower": 0.9928802087012855, |
| "upper": 0.995212685575397 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 10.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 0.014127598299334446, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 0.014471943179766336, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 0.014471943179766336, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 3.047107939918836, |
| "lower": 2.527025959411124, |
| "upper": 3.5671899204265483 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.9940469083133674, |
| "lower": 0.9928810869250496, |
| "upper": 0.9952127297016852 |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "wrong_k": [ |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 1.486311936378479, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.0, |
| "lower": 0.0, |
| "upper": 0.0 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.0, |
| "lower": 0.0, |
| "upper": 0.0 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.01, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 1.8507890144983927, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 3.8167810718218487, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 3.8167810718218487, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -0.7552011887232463, |
| "lower": -0.8350778637332517, |
| "upper": -0.6753245137132409 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -0.335698701124339, |
| "lower": -0.4252553641029816, |
| "upper": -0.2461420381456965 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.03, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 2.5668343702952066, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 5.3021178642908735, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 5.3021178642908735, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -2.2405379811922708, |
| "lower": -2.482440018637655, |
| "upper": -1.9986359437468866 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -1.0128187402513666, |
| "lower": -1.2932967145878562, |
| "upper": -0.732340765914877 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.1, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 4.444176920255026, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 9.199687544504801, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 9.199687544504801, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -6.138107661406199, |
| "lower": -6.697875381693855, |
| "upper": -5.578339941118543 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -2.793067745663583, |
| "lower": -3.5557878199274544, |
| "upper": -2.0303476713997117 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.3, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 6.315055227279663, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 13.088153012593587, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 13.088153012593587, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -10.026573129494984, |
| "lower": -10.671450445666498, |
| "upper": -9.381695813323471 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -4.476533233199851, |
| "lower": -5.624145126048527, |
| "upper": -3.328921340351176 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 1.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 7.168853871027628, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 14.86010996500651, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 14.86010996500651, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -11.798530081907908, |
| "lower": -12.430511001152764, |
| "upper": -11.16654916266305 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -5.203989021274169, |
| "lower": -6.494652786447212, |
| "upper": -3.9133252561011265 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 3.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 7.422162771224976, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 15.384338251749675, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 15.384338251749675, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -12.322758368651073, |
| "lower": -12.95535556306007, |
| "upper": -11.690161174242075 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -5.420364324283655, |
| "lower": -6.75511993682732, |
| "upper": -4.08560871173999 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 10.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 7.513337850570679, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 15.571361033121745, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 15.571361033121745, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -12.509781150023143, |
| "lower": -13.142800174567256, |
| "upper": -11.87676212547903 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -5.497683333696079, |
| "lower": -6.848461119606996, |
| "upper": -4.146905547785162 |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "validation_selected_lambda": 10.0, |
| "widest_stable_gain_interval": [ |
| 0.01, |
| 0.03, |
| 0.1, |
| 0.3, |
| 1.0, |
| 3.0, |
| 10.0 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "confidence_monotonicity": { |
| "lambda_fixed": 3.0, |
| "grid": [ |
| 0.0, |
| 0.25, |
| 0.5, |
| 0.75, |
| 1.0 |
| ], |
| "wrong_k": [ |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 1.486311936378479, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.0, |
| "lower": 0.0, |
| "upper": 0.0 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.0, |
| "lower": 0.0, |
| "upper": 0.0 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.25, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 7.045071029663086, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 14.603481674194336, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 14.603481674194336, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -11.541901791095734, |
| "lower": -12.173843684033132, |
| "upper": -10.909959898158336 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -5.098097461259101, |
| "lower": -6.367254186124855, |
| "upper": -3.828940736393348 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.5, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 7.2944713433583575, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 15.120384407043456, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 15.120384407043456, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -12.058804523944854, |
| "lower": -12.69115563245752, |
| "upper": -11.426453415432189 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -5.311485542101237, |
| "lower": -6.624083089769489, |
| "upper": -3.9988879944329847 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.75, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 7.3793717384338375, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 15.296039803822834, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 15.296039803822834, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -12.234459920724232, |
| "lower": -12.867022413777324, |
| "upper": -11.60189742767114 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -5.3839700949197855, |
| "lower": -6.711330001063541, |
| "upper": -4.05661018877603 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 1.0, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 7.422162771224976, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 15.384338251749675, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 15.384338251749675, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -12.322758368651073, |
| "lower": -12.95535556306007, |
| "upper": -11.690161174242075 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -5.420364324283655, |
| "lower": -6.75511993682732, |
| "upper": -4.08560871173999 |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "wrong_k_harm_means": [ |
| -0.0, |
| 11.541901791095734, |
| 12.058804523944854, |
| 12.234459920724232, |
| 12.322758368651073 |
| ], |
| "low_confidence_grid": [ |
| 0.001, |
| 0.005, |
| 0.01, |
| 0.025, |
| 0.05, |
| 0.1, |
| 0.2 |
| ], |
| "low_confidence_wrong_k": [ |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.001, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 1.5947722176710764, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 3.2862011591593423, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 3.2862011591593423, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -0.22462127606074014, |
| "lower": -0.24754920610230258, |
| "upper": -0.2016933460191777 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -0.09877345604839952, |
| "lower": -0.12427206842486266, |
| "upper": -0.07327484367193637 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.005, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 2.033672418196996, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 4.1960093895594275, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 4.1960093895594275, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -1.1344295064608256, |
| "lower": -1.256120318285006, |
| "upper": -1.0127386946366452 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -0.507194586787011, |
| "lower": -0.6445710304175193, |
| "upper": -0.36981814315650274 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.01, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 2.5668343702952066, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 5.3021178642908735, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 5.3021178642908735, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -2.2405379811922708, |
| "lower": -2.482440018637655, |
| "upper": -1.9986359437468866 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -1.0128187402513666, |
| "lower": -1.2932967145878562, |
| "upper": -0.732340765914877 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.025, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 3.8949397802352905, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 8.058985280990601, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 8.058985280990601, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -4.997405397891998, |
| "lower": -5.485798473174678, |
| "upper": -4.509012322609318 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -2.2769696969751965, |
| "lower": -2.905531595013555, |
| "upper": -1.6484077989368378 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.05, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 5.231744718551636, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 10.836254437764486, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 10.836254437764486, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -7.774674554665883, |
| "lower": -8.401257847111888, |
| "upper": -7.148091262219879 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -3.5190764657561817, |
| "lower": -4.459841131183651, |
| "upper": -2.578311800328712 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.1, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 6.315055227279663, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 13.088153012593587, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 13.088153012593587, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -10.026573129494984, |
| "lower": -10.671450445666498, |
| "upper": -9.381695813323471 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -4.476533233199851, |
| "lower": -5.624145126048527, |
| "upper": -3.328921340351176 |
| } |
| }, |
| { |
| "parameter": 0.2, |
| "validation_mse_mean": 6.922420438130697, |
| "e_ood_base_raw_mean": 3.0615798830986023, |
| "e_ood_group_raw_mean": 14.349096330006917, |
| "ood_mse_mean": 14.349096330006917, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -11.287516446908315, |
| "lower": -11.92016465668108, |
| "upper": -10.654868237135549 |
| }, |
| "r_ood_relative_improvement_paired_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -4.993462547396624, |
| "lower": -6.2416448456798745, |
| "upper": -3.7452802491133736 |
| } |
| } |
| ], |
| "low_confidence_wrong_k_harm_means": [ |
| 0.22462127606074014, |
| 1.1344295064608256, |
| 2.2405379811922708, |
| 4.997405397891998, |
| 7.774674554665883, |
| 10.026573129494984, |
| 11.287516446908315 |
| ] |
| }, |
| "conflict_resolution": { |
| "claims": [ |
| { |
| "feature_index": 1, |
| "stance": "NON_CAUSAL", |
| "confidence": 0.75 |
| }, |
| { |
| "feature_index": 1, |
| "stance": "CAUSAL", |
| "confidence": 0.75 |
| } |
| ], |
| "resolve_called": true, |
| "abstain": true, |
| "reason": "equal-confidence conflict on feature 1", |
| "ood_delta_from_no_k_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 0.0, |
| "lower": 0.0, |
| "upper": 0.0 |
| } |
| }, |
| "fault_injection": { |
| "fault": "expired reversed-context claim bypassed Activation and forced is_active=True", |
| "forced_non_causal_indices": [ |
| 0 |
| ], |
| "lambda_reg": 3.0, |
| "generalization_mse_drop_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 12.322758368651073, |
| "lower": 11.690161174242075, |
| "upper": 12.95535556306007 |
| }, |
| "delta_e_ood_absolute_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": -12.322758368651073, |
| "lower": -12.95535556306007, |
| "upper": -11.690161174242075 |
| }, |
| "activation_constraint_violation_rate": 1.0, |
| "harm_incidence_rate": 1.0 |
| }, |
| "lambda10_wrong_k_harm_ci95": { |
| "n": 30, |
| "mean": 12.509781150023143, |
| "lower": 11.87676212547903, |
| "upper": 13.142800174567256 |
| }, |
| "validations": { |
| "correct_k_stable_interval": true, |
| "selected_lambda_was_validation_only": true, |
| "selected_lambda_has_ood_gain_gt_0_1": true, |
| "wrong_k_ood_strictly_worsens_with_lambda": true, |
| "wrong_k_lambda10_collapses": true, |
| "wrong_k_harm_strictly_increases_with_confidence": true, |
| "wrong_k_harm_strictly_increases_in_low_confidence_range": true, |
| "equal_conflict_abstains": true, |
| "abstain_returns_exact_baseline": true, |
| "fault_injection_causes_harm": true |
| }, |
| "experiment_passed": true |
| } |
|
|
