TabQueryBench commited on
Commit
9f4b831
·
verified ·
1 Parent(s): 0907883

Refresh Figure 6 tail-threshold final assets

Browse files
evaluation/tail/tail_threshold_final/manifest.json CHANGED
@@ -1,21 +1,21 @@
1
  {
2
- "artifact": "figure6_tail_threshold_final_assets",
3
- "source_run_tag": "20260505_latest48_keyset_tail_threshold",
4
- "dataset_count": 48,
5
- "thresholds_pct": [
6
- 10.0,
7
- 8.0,
8
- 6.0,
9
- 4.0,
10
- 2.0,
11
- 1.0,
12
- 0.5,
13
- 0.1,
14
- 0.01,
15
- 0.001
 
 
 
16
  ],
17
- "notes": [
18
- "These files are rendered from the summary tables stored under the matching tail_threshold_runs bundle.",
19
- "The paper uses a three-panel layout derived from these rendered outputs."
20
- ]
21
  }
 
1
  {
2
+ "figure_id": "Figure 6",
3
+ "title": "Tail/Range stress testing under threshold tightening",
4
+ "source_run_tag": "20260520_server_main_tail_threshold_refresh_v3_merged47__preview",
5
+ "source_run_dir": "/data/jialinzhang/TabQueryBench/code_snapshot/Evaluation/tail_threshold/runs/20260520_server_main_tail_threshold_refresh_v3_merged47__preview",
6
+ "dataset_count": 45,
7
+ "asset_count": 4690,
8
+ "threshold_labels": [
9
+ "10%",
10
+ "8%",
11
+ "6%",
12
+ "4%",
13
+ "2%",
14
+ "1%",
15
+ "0.5%",
16
+ "0.1%",
17
+ "0.01%",
18
+ "0.001%"
19
  ],
20
+ "notes": "Rendered locally from the merged server preview run using authoritative server-side syntheticSuccess/main data. Current preview excludes datasets that produce no_feature_columns dataset outputs in the tail-threshold pipeline."
 
 
 
21
  }
evaluation/tail/tail_threshold_final/metric_model_sixpack/.DS_Store ADDED
Binary file (6.15 kB). View file
 
evaluation/tail/tail_threshold_final/tail_stress_main_figure.pdf CHANGED
@@ -1,3 +1,3 @@
1
  version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
- oid sha256:18293d20a9b290c3c90bd40064df4d19ae80133452d0511243f5e5a1658c27fb
3
- size 27361
 
1
  version https://git-lfs.github.com/spec/v1
2
+ oid sha256:57227334314d8cdec49d37e2d7721335a32b67e5720bc6802cd18d3f8e1c6c2a
3
+ size 27405
evaluation/tail/tail_threshold_final/tail_stress_main_figure.png CHANGED

Git LFS Details

  • SHA256: ec818f9124e30ce7a35aba37a66874f49eb655ffbff9b88c99905bc6adc801c3
  • Pointer size: 131 Bytes
  • Size of remote file: 225 kB

Git LFS Details

  • SHA256: 8e39dbfc1db81be58aca37b075e3c7e9dbf25fd1d430b94030549b959968d37d
  • Pointer size: 131 Bytes
  • Size of remote file: 227 kB
evaluation/tail/tail_threshold_final/tail_submetrics_combined_figure.tex CHANGED
@@ -1,12 +1,6 @@
1
- % Combined tail submetrics figure.
2
- % If you compile from a paper subdirectory, adjust the image path prefix as needed.
3
- \begin{figure}[t]
4
- \centering
5
- \input{Evaluation/tail_threshold/final/tail_submetrics_combined_figure_embedded.tex}
6
- \caption{
7
- Single-panel summary of the three formal tail submetrics under threshold tightening.
8
- For each model, the three colored subitems report tail set consistency, tail mass similarity, and tail concentration consistency.
9
- Within each subitem, the square marks the mean over thresholds, the whiskers show the min-max range, and the translucent box shows the interquartile range.
10
- }
11
- \label{fig:tail-submetrics-combined}
12
- \end{figure}
 
1
+ \documentclass[tikz,border=6pt]{standalone}
2
+ \usepackage{pgfplots}
3
+ \pgfplotsset{compat=1.18}
4
+ \begin{document}
5
+ \input{tail_submetrics_combined_figure_embedded.tex}
6
+ \end{document}
 
 
 
 
 
 
evaluation/tail/tail_threshold_final/tail_submetrics_combined_figure_embedded.tex CHANGED
@@ -1,202 +1,202 @@
1
- \definecolor{tailsetmetric}{HTML}{D1495B}
2
- \definecolor{tailmassmetric}{HTML}{2A9D8F}
3
- \definecolor{tailconcmetric}{HTML}{6D597A}
4
- \begin{tikzpicture}
5
- \begin{axis}[
6
- width=17.6cm,
7
- height=6.9cm,
8
- xmin=-0.65, xmax=10.650000,
9
- ymin=0.0, ymax=1.0,
10
- xtick={0,...,10},
11
- xticklabels={RealTabFormer,TVAE,ForestDiffusion,TabDDPM,TabSyn,TabDiff,CTGAN,ARF,BayesNet,TabPFGen,TabbyFlow},
12
- xticklabel style={rotate=30, anchor=east, font=\small},
13
- yticklabel style={font=\small},
14
- xlabel={Model},
15
- ylabel={Score},
16
- axis line style={draw=gray!65, line width=0.8pt},
17
- tick style={black, line width=0.8pt},
18
- grid=major,
19
- major grid style={draw=gray!22, dashed},
20
- axis background/.style={fill=white},
21
- label style={font=\small},
22
- clip=false,
23
- ]
24
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:0.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:0.500000,1.0);
25
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:1.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:1.500000,1.0);
26
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:2.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:2.500000,1.0);
27
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:3.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:3.500000,1.0);
28
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:4.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:4.500000,1.0);
29
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:5.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:5.500000,1.0);
30
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:6.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:6.500000,1.0);
31
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:7.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:7.500000,1.0);
32
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:8.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:8.500000,1.0);
33
- \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:9.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:9.500000,1.0);
34
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:-0.330000,0.214539) rectangle (axis cs:-0.150000,0.287483);
35
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.240000,0.209330) -- (axis cs:-0.240000,0.328994);
36
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.285000,0.209330) -- (axis cs:-0.195000,0.209330);
37
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.285000,0.328994) -- (axis cs:-0.195000,0.328994);
38
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(-0.240000,0.250599)};
39
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:0.670000,0.043023) rectangle (axis cs:0.850000,0.099284);
40
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.760000,0.040000) -- (axis cs:0.760000,0.127653);
41
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.715000,0.040000) -- (axis cs:0.805000,0.040000);
42
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.715000,0.127653) -- (axis cs:0.805000,0.127653);
43
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(0.760000,0.068544)};
44
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:1.670000,0.074256) rectangle (axis cs:1.850000,0.137008);
45
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.760000,0.074074) -- (axis cs:1.760000,0.142009);
46
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.715000,0.074074) -- (axis cs:1.805000,0.074074);
47
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.715000,0.142009) -- (axis cs:1.805000,0.142009);
48
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(1.760000,0.100160)};
49
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:2.670000,0.075000) rectangle (axis cs:2.850000,0.124565);
50
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.760000,0.075000) -- (axis cs:2.760000,0.142694);
51
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.715000,0.075000) -- (axis cs:2.805000,0.075000);
52
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.715000,0.142694) -- (axis cs:2.805000,0.142694);
53
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(2.760000,0.101944)};
54
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:3.670000,0.108189) rectangle (axis cs:3.850000,0.178751);
55
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.760000,0.103448) -- (axis cs:3.760000,0.188115);
56
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.715000,0.103448) -- (axis cs:3.805000,0.103448);
57
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.715000,0.188115) -- (axis cs:3.805000,0.188115);
58
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(3.760000,0.148156)};
59
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:4.670000,0.388823) rectangle (axis cs:4.850000,0.445032);
60
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.760000,0.355556) -- (axis cs:4.760000,0.516311);
61
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.715000,0.355556) -- (axis cs:4.805000,0.355556);
62
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.715000,0.516311) -- (axis cs:4.805000,0.516311);
63
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(4.760000,0.421905)};
64
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:5.670000,0.084796) rectangle (axis cs:5.850000,0.136848);
65
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.760000,0.069868) -- (axis cs:5.760000,0.161184);
66
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.715000,0.069868) -- (axis cs:5.805000,0.069868);
67
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.715000,0.161184) -- (axis cs:5.805000,0.161184);
68
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(5.760000,0.114321)};
69
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:6.670000,0.182709) rectangle (axis cs:6.850000,0.257272);
70
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.760000,0.166667) -- (axis cs:6.760000,0.282616);
71
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.715000,0.166667) -- (axis cs:6.805000,0.166667);
72
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.715000,0.282616) -- (axis cs:6.805000,0.282616);
73
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(6.760000,0.219833)};
74
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:7.670000,0.262707) rectangle (axis cs:7.850000,0.282738);
75
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.760000,0.247287) -- (axis cs:7.760000,0.289839);
76
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.715000,0.247287) -- (axis cs:7.805000,0.247287);
77
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.715000,0.289839) -- (axis cs:7.805000,0.289839);
78
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(7.760000,0.271941)};
79
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:8.670000,0.150545) rectangle (axis cs:8.850000,0.249320);
80
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.760000,0.131649) -- (axis cs:8.760000,0.300891);
81
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.715000,0.131649) -- (axis cs:8.805000,0.131649);
82
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.715000,0.300891) -- (axis cs:8.805000,0.300891);
83
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(8.760000,0.202313)};
84
- \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:9.670000,0.126559) rectangle (axis cs:9.850000,0.223457);
85
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.760000,0.109375) -- (axis cs:9.760000,0.243958);
86
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.715000,0.109375) -- (axis cs:9.805000,0.109375);
87
- \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.715000,0.243958) -- (axis cs:9.805000,0.243958);
88
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(9.760000,0.174621)};
89
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:-0.090000,0.577479) rectangle (axis cs:0.090000,0.740094);
90
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.000000,0.534457) -- (axis cs:0.000000,0.789192);
91
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.045000,0.534457) -- (axis cs:0.045000,0.534457);
92
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.045000,0.789192) -- (axis cs:0.045000,0.789192);
93
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(0.000000,0.654699)};
94
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:0.910000,0.301643) rectangle (axis cs:1.090000,0.445273);
95
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.000000,0.269245) -- (axis cs:1.000000,0.530751);
96
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.955000,0.269245) -- (axis cs:1.045000,0.269245);
97
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.955000,0.530751) -- (axis cs:1.045000,0.530751);
98
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(1.000000,0.379109)};
99
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:1.910000,0.397523) rectangle (axis cs:2.090000,0.502811);
100
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.000000,0.389566) -- (axis cs:2.000000,0.564716);
101
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.955000,0.389566) -- (axis cs:2.045000,0.389566);
102
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.955000,0.564716) -- (axis cs:2.045000,0.564716);
103
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(2.000000,0.453806)};
104
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:2.910000,0.270882) rectangle (axis cs:3.090000,0.361501);
105
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.000000,0.266131) -- (axis cs:3.000000,0.467307);
106
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.955000,0.266131) -- (axis cs:3.045000,0.266131);
107
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.955000,0.467307) -- (axis cs:3.045000,0.467307);
108
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(3.000000,0.329734)};
109
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:3.910000,0.373286) rectangle (axis cs:4.090000,0.448959);
110
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.000000,0.359899) -- (axis cs:4.000000,0.531399);
111
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.955000,0.359899) -- (axis cs:4.045000,0.359899);
112
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.955000,0.531399) -- (axis cs:4.045000,0.531399);
113
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(4.000000,0.419123)};
114
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:4.910000,0.532512) rectangle (axis cs:5.090000,0.618008);
115
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.000000,0.496669) -- (axis cs:5.000000,0.693556);
116
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.955000,0.496669) -- (axis cs:5.045000,0.496669);
117
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.955000,0.693556) -- (axis cs:5.045000,0.693556);
118
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(5.000000,0.571128)};
119
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:5.910000,0.309119) rectangle (axis cs:6.090000,0.439617);
120
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.000000,0.287177) -- (axis cs:6.000000,0.536704);
121
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.955000,0.287177) -- (axis cs:6.045000,0.287177);
122
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.955000,0.536704) -- (axis cs:6.045000,0.536704);
123
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(6.000000,0.375417)};
124
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:6.910000,0.570317) rectangle (axis cs:7.090000,0.718806);
125
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.000000,0.461725) -- (axis cs:7.000000,0.790038);
126
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.955000,0.461725) -- (axis cs:7.045000,0.461725);
127
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.955000,0.790038) -- (axis cs:7.045000,0.790038);
128
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(7.000000,0.640511)};
129
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:7.910000,0.539312) rectangle (axis cs:8.090000,0.573369);
130
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.000000,0.525645) -- (axis cs:8.000000,0.629777);
131
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.955000,0.525645) -- (axis cs:8.045000,0.525645);
132
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.955000,0.629777) -- (axis cs:8.045000,0.629777);
133
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(8.000000,0.562494)};
134
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:8.910000,0.527222) rectangle (axis cs:9.090000,0.675500);
135
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.000000,0.474813) -- (axis cs:9.000000,0.750896);
136
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.955000,0.474813) -- (axis cs:9.045000,0.474813);
137
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.955000,0.750896) -- (axis cs:9.045000,0.750896);
138
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(9.000000,0.604720)};
139
- \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:9.910000,0.482366) rectangle (axis cs:10.090000,0.557788);
140
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:10.000000,0.478715) -- (axis cs:10.000000,0.592314);
141
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.955000,0.478715) -- (axis cs:10.045000,0.478715);
142
- \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.955000,0.592314) -- (axis cs:10.045000,0.592314);
143
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(10.000000,0.518160)};
144
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:0.150000,0.737303) rectangle (axis cs:0.330000,0.756769);
145
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.240000,0.729516) -- (axis cs:0.240000,0.765107);
146
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.195000,0.729516) -- (axis cs:0.285000,0.729516);
147
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.195000,0.765107) -- (axis cs:0.285000,0.765107);
148
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(0.240000,0.747789)};
149
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:1.150000,0.492066) rectangle (axis cs:1.330000,0.578735);
150
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.240000,0.483277) -- (axis cs:1.240000,0.667339);
151
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.195000,0.483277) -- (axis cs:1.285000,0.483277);
152
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.195000,0.667339) -- (axis cs:1.285000,0.667339);
153
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(1.240000,0.546440)};
154
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:2.150000,0.496636) rectangle (axis cs:2.330000,0.524037);
155
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.240000,0.487444) -- (axis cs:2.240000,0.555925);
156
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.195000,0.487444) -- (axis cs:2.285000,0.487444);
157
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.195000,0.555925) -- (axis cs:2.285000,0.555925);
158
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(2.240000,0.516695)};
159
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:3.150000,0.446660) rectangle (axis cs:3.330000,0.618720);
160
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.240000,0.423413) -- (axis cs:3.240000,0.633074);
161
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.195000,0.423413) -- (axis cs:3.285000,0.423413);
162
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.195000,0.633074) -- (axis cs:3.285000,0.633074);
163
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(3.240000,0.528977)};
164
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:4.150000,0.488432) rectangle (axis cs:4.330000,0.558937);
165
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.240000,0.482212) -- (axis cs:4.240000,0.576193);
166
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.195000,0.482212) -- (axis cs:4.285000,0.482212);
167
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.195000,0.576193) -- (axis cs:4.285000,0.576193);
168
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(4.240000,0.528114)};
169
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:5.150000,0.740152) rectangle (axis cs:5.330000,0.826816);
170
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.240000,0.726777) -- (axis cs:5.240000,0.832094);
171
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.195000,0.726777) -- (axis cs:5.285000,0.726777);
172
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.195000,0.832094) -- (axis cs:5.285000,0.832094);
173
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(5.240000,0.784206)};
174
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:6.150000,0.548182) rectangle (axis cs:6.330000,0.606282);
175
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.240000,0.532419) -- (axis cs:6.240000,0.663559);
176
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.195000,0.532419) -- (axis cs:6.285000,0.532419);
177
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.195000,0.663559) -- (axis cs:6.285000,0.663559);
178
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(6.240000,0.576708)};
179
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:7.150000,0.672307) rectangle (axis cs:7.330000,0.707029);
180
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.240000,0.659583) -- (axis cs:7.240000,0.717648);
181
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.195000,0.659583) -- (axis cs:7.285000,0.659583);
182
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.195000,0.717648) -- (axis cs:7.285000,0.717648);
183
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(7.240000,0.687754)};
184
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:8.150000,0.616551) rectangle (axis cs:8.330000,0.645852);
185
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.240000,0.574947) -- (axis cs:8.240000,0.683790);
186
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.195000,0.574947) -- (axis cs:8.285000,0.574947);
187
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.195000,0.683790) -- (axis cs:8.285000,0.683790);
188
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(8.240000,0.631016)};
189
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:9.150000,0.639444) rectangle (axis cs:9.330000,0.698808);
190
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.240000,0.626177) -- (axis cs:9.240000,0.720596);
191
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.195000,0.626177) -- (axis cs:9.285000,0.626177);
192
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.195000,0.720596) -- (axis cs:9.285000,0.720596);
193
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(9.240000,0.669850)};
194
- \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:10.150000,0.559872) rectangle (axis cs:10.330000,0.564409);
195
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:10.240000,0.556293) -- (axis cs:10.240000,0.573205);
196
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:10.195000,0.556293) -- (axis cs:10.285000,0.556293);
197
- \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:10.195000,0.573205) -- (axis cs:10.285000,0.573205);
198
- \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(10.240000,0.563072)};
199
- \node[anchor=west, font=\small] at (rel axis cs:0.01,1.035) {\textcolor{tailsetmetric}{Tail set consistency}\quad\textcolor{tailmassmetric}{Tail mass similarity}\quad\textcolor{tailconcmetric}{Tail concentration consistency}};
200
- \node[anchor=east, font=\small, text=gray!70!black] at (rel axis cs:0.995,1.035) {square = mean \quad whisker = min--max \quad box = IQR};
201
- \end{axis}
202
- \end{tikzpicture}
 
1
+ \definecolor{tailsetmetric}{HTML}{D1495B}
2
+ \definecolor{tailmassmetric}{HTML}{2A9D8F}
3
+ \definecolor{tailconcmetric}{HTML}{6D597A}
4
+ \begin{tikzpicture}
5
+ \begin{axis}[
6
+ width=17.6cm,
7
+ height=6.9cm,
8
+ xmin=-0.65, xmax=10.650000,
9
+ ymin=0.0, ymax=1.0,
10
+ xtick={0,...,10},
11
+ xticklabels={RealTabFormer,TVAE,ForestDiffusion,TabDDPM,TabSyn,TabDiff,CTGAN,ARF,BayesNet,TabPFGen,TabbyFlow},
12
+ xticklabel style={rotate=30, anchor=east, font=\small},
13
+ yticklabel style={font=\small},
14
+ xlabel={Model},
15
+ ylabel={Score},
16
+ axis line style={draw=gray!65, line width=0.8pt},
17
+ tick style={black, line width=0.8pt},
18
+ grid=major,
19
+ major grid style={draw=gray!22, dashed},
20
+ axis background/.style={fill=white},
21
+ label style={font=\small},
22
+ clip=false,
23
+ ]
24
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:0.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:0.500000,1.0);
25
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:1.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:1.500000,1.0);
26
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:2.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:2.500000,1.0);
27
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:3.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:3.500000,1.0);
28
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:4.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:4.500000,1.0);
29
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:5.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:5.500000,1.0);
30
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:6.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:6.500000,1.0);
31
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:7.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:7.500000,1.0);
32
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:8.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:8.500000,1.0);
33
+ \draw[gray!22, line width=0.6pt] (axis cs:9.500000,0.0) -- (axis cs:9.500000,1.0);
34
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:-0.330000,0.103176) rectangle (axis cs:-0.150000,0.180055);
35
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.240000,0.090909) -- (axis cs:-0.240000,0.204874);
36
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.285000,0.090909) -- (axis cs:-0.195000,0.090909);
37
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.285000,0.204874) -- (axis cs:-0.195000,0.204874);
38
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(-0.240000,0.140844)};
39
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:0.670000,0.003965) rectangle (axis cs:0.850000,0.033567);
40
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.760000,0.001389) -- (axis cs:0.760000,0.062464);
41
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.715000,0.001389) -- (axis cs:0.805000,0.001389);
42
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.715000,0.062464) -- (axis cs:0.805000,0.062464);
43
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(0.760000,0.020478)};
44
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:1.670000,0.088889) rectangle (axis cs:1.850000,0.100098);
45
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.760000,0.061534) -- (axis cs:1.760000,0.112147);
46
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.715000,0.061534) -- (axis cs:1.805000,0.061534);
47
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.715000,0.112147) -- (axis cs:1.805000,0.112147);
48
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(1.760000,0.092980)};
49
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:2.670000,0.054054) rectangle (axis cs:2.850000,0.071011);
50
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.760000,0.054054) -- (axis cs:2.760000,0.086737);
51
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.715000,0.054054) -- (axis cs:2.805000,0.054054);
52
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.715000,0.086737) -- (axis cs:2.805000,0.086737);
53
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(2.760000,0.064403)};
54
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:3.670000,0.167192) rectangle (axis cs:3.850000,0.196999);
55
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.760000,0.166667) -- (axis cs:3.760000,0.209408);
56
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.715000,0.166667) -- (axis cs:3.805000,0.166667);
57
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.715000,0.209408) -- (axis cs:3.805000,0.209408);
58
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(3.760000,0.184151)};
59
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:4.670000,0.130674) rectangle (axis cs:4.850000,0.173989);
60
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.760000,0.125000) -- (axis cs:4.760000,0.193020);
61
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.715000,0.125000) -- (axis cs:4.805000,0.125000);
62
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.715000,0.193020) -- (axis cs:4.805000,0.193020);
63
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(4.760000,0.156472)};
64
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:5.670000,0.066667) rectangle (axis cs:5.850000,0.079202);
65
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.760000,0.052776) -- (axis cs:5.760000,0.110237);
66
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.715000,0.052776) -- (axis cs:5.805000,0.052776);
67
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.715000,0.110237) -- (axis cs:5.805000,0.110237);
68
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(5.760000,0.076759)};
69
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:6.670000,0.057045) rectangle (axis cs:6.850000,0.178787);
70
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.760000,0.032222) -- (axis cs:6.760000,0.207496);
71
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.715000,0.032222) -- (axis cs:6.805000,0.032222);
72
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.715000,0.207496) -- (axis cs:6.805000,0.207496);
73
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(6.760000,0.115567)};
74
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:7.670000,0.213255) rectangle (axis cs:7.850000,0.267912);
75
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.760000,0.191327) -- (axis cs:7.760000,0.274728);
76
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.715000,0.191327) -- (axis cs:7.805000,0.191327);
77
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.715000,0.274728) -- (axis cs:7.805000,0.274728);
78
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(7.760000,0.238885)};
79
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:8.670000,0.038264) rectangle (axis cs:8.850000,0.146985);
80
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.760000,0.023256) -- (axis cs:8.760000,0.201404);
81
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.715000,0.023256) -- (axis cs:8.805000,0.023256);
82
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.715000,0.201404) -- (axis cs:8.805000,0.201404);
83
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(8.760000,0.097926)};
84
+ \path[fill=tailsetmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:9.670000,0.094398) rectangle (axis cs:9.850000,0.131225);
85
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.760000,0.071705) -- (axis cs:9.760000,0.140897);
86
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.715000,0.071705) -- (axis cs:9.805000,0.071705);
87
+ \draw[tailsetmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.715000,0.140897) -- (axis cs:9.805000,0.140897);
88
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailsetmetric] coordinates {(9.760000,0.110411)};
89
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:-0.090000,0.355318) rectangle (axis cs:0.090000,0.503322);
90
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.000000,0.310205) -- (axis cs:0.000000,0.558370);
91
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.045000,0.310205) -- (axis cs:0.045000,0.310205);
92
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:-0.045000,0.558370) -- (axis cs:0.045000,0.558370);
93
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(0.000000,0.432994)};
94
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:0.910000,0.152193) rectangle (axis cs:1.090000,0.272941);
95
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.000000,0.128161) -- (axis cs:1.000000,0.318456);
96
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.955000,0.128161) -- (axis cs:1.045000,0.128161);
97
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.955000,0.318456) -- (axis cs:1.045000,0.318456);
98
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(1.000000,0.220807)};
99
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:1.910000,0.199575) rectangle (axis cs:2.090000,0.306451);
100
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.000000,0.188810) -- (axis cs:2.000000,0.331148);
101
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.955000,0.188810) -- (axis cs:2.045000,0.188810);
102
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.955000,0.331148) -- (axis cs:2.045000,0.331148);
103
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(2.000000,0.247882)};
104
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:2.910000,0.166498) rectangle (axis cs:3.090000,0.221857);
105
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.000000,0.161362) -- (axis cs:3.000000,0.279647);
106
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.955000,0.161362) -- (axis cs:3.045000,0.161362);
107
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.955000,0.279647) -- (axis cs:3.045000,0.279647);
108
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(3.000000,0.202923)};
109
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:3.910000,0.203698) rectangle (axis cs:4.090000,0.317172);
110
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.000000,0.202635) -- (axis cs:4.000000,0.373719);
111
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.955000,0.202635) -- (axis cs:4.045000,0.202635);
112
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.955000,0.373719) -- (axis cs:4.045000,0.373719);
113
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(4.000000,0.269276)};
114
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:4.910000,0.221051) rectangle (axis cs:5.090000,0.353643);
115
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.000000,0.215910) -- (axis cs:5.000000,0.378510);
116
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.955000,0.215910) -- (axis cs:5.045000,0.215910);
117
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.955000,0.378510) -- (axis cs:5.045000,0.378510);
118
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(5.000000,0.295125)};
119
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:5.910000,0.174408) rectangle (axis cs:6.090000,0.325261);
120
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.000000,0.150396) -- (axis cs:6.000000,0.392840);
121
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.955000,0.150396) -- (axis cs:6.045000,0.150396);
122
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.955000,0.392840) -- (axis cs:6.045000,0.392840);
123
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(6.000000,0.247544)};
124
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:6.910000,0.443062) rectangle (axis cs:7.090000,0.552747);
125
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.000000,0.319991) -- (axis cs:7.000000,0.593965);
126
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.955000,0.319991) -- (axis cs:7.045000,0.319991);
127
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.955000,0.593965) -- (axis cs:7.045000,0.593965);
128
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(7.000000,0.488678)};
129
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:7.910000,0.367395) rectangle (axis cs:8.090000,0.400632);
130
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.000000,0.335130) -- (axis cs:8.000000,0.420552);
131
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.955000,0.335130) -- (axis cs:8.045000,0.335130);
132
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.955000,0.420552) -- (axis cs:8.045000,0.420552);
133
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(8.000000,0.382778)};
134
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:8.910000,0.323402) rectangle (axis cs:9.090000,0.428854);
135
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.000000,0.269058) -- (axis cs:9.000000,0.458180);
136
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.955000,0.269058) -- (axis cs:9.045000,0.269058);
137
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.955000,0.458180) -- (axis cs:9.045000,0.458180);
138
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(9.000000,0.376716)};
139
+ \path[fill=tailmassmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:9.910000,0.231859) rectangle (axis cs:10.090000,0.324418);
140
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:10.000000,0.219119) -- (axis cs:10.000000,0.348478);
141
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.955000,0.219119) -- (axis cs:10.045000,0.219119);
142
+ \draw[tailmassmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.955000,0.348478) -- (axis cs:10.045000,0.348478);
143
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailmassmetric] coordinates {(10.000000,0.273710)};
144
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:0.150000,0.501367) rectangle (axis cs:0.330000,0.514897);
145
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.240000,0.483657) -- (axis cs:0.240000,0.531645);
146
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.195000,0.483657) -- (axis cs:0.285000,0.483657);
147
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:0.195000,0.531645) -- (axis cs:0.285000,0.531645);
148
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(0.240000,0.507013)};
149
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:1.150000,0.314738) rectangle (axis cs:1.330000,0.351077);
150
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.240000,0.309519) -- (axis cs:1.240000,0.419100);
151
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.195000,0.309519) -- (axis cs:1.285000,0.309519);
152
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:1.195000,0.419100) -- (axis cs:1.285000,0.419100);
153
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(1.240000,0.343399)};
154
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:2.150000,0.308371) rectangle (axis cs:2.330000,0.392424);
155
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.240000,0.305264) -- (axis cs:2.240000,0.462034);
156
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.195000,0.305264) -- (axis cs:2.285000,0.305264);
157
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:2.195000,0.462034) -- (axis cs:2.285000,0.462034);
158
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(2.240000,0.358989)};
159
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:3.150000,0.279746) rectangle (axis cs:3.330000,0.416377);
160
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.240000,0.261820) -- (axis cs:3.240000,0.431493);
161
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.195000,0.261820) -- (axis cs:3.285000,0.261820);
162
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:3.195000,0.431493) -- (axis cs:3.285000,0.431493);
163
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(3.240000,0.343982)};
164
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:4.150000,0.339116) rectangle (axis cs:4.330000,0.355596);
165
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.240000,0.329278) -- (axis cs:4.240000,0.382838);
166
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.195000,0.329278) -- (axis cs:4.285000,0.329278);
167
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:4.195000,0.382838) -- (axis cs:4.285000,0.382838);
168
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(4.240000,0.350701)};
169
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:5.150000,0.339883) rectangle (axis cs:5.330000,0.380585);
170
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.240000,0.322559) -- (axis cs:5.240000,0.407342);
171
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.195000,0.322559) -- (axis cs:5.285000,0.322559);
172
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:5.195000,0.407342) -- (axis cs:5.285000,0.407342);
173
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(5.240000,0.362670)};
174
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:6.150000,0.369465) rectangle (axis cs:6.330000,0.423963);
175
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.240000,0.364172) -- (axis cs:6.240000,0.442190);
176
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.195000,0.364172) -- (axis cs:6.285000,0.364172);
177
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:6.195000,0.442190) -- (axis cs:6.285000,0.442190);
178
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(6.240000,0.396251)};
179
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:7.150000,0.513677) rectangle (axis cs:7.330000,0.533869);
180
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.240000,0.503534) -- (axis cs:7.240000,0.544012);
181
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.195000,0.503534) -- (axis cs:7.285000,0.503534);
182
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:7.195000,0.544012) -- (axis cs:7.285000,0.544012);
183
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(7.240000,0.523610)};
184
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:8.150000,0.414806) rectangle (axis cs:8.330000,0.491314);
185
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.240000,0.396976) -- (axis cs:8.240000,0.550892);
186
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.195000,0.396976) -- (axis cs:8.285000,0.396976);
187
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:8.195000,0.550892) -- (axis cs:8.285000,0.550892);
188
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(8.240000,0.457337)};
189
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:9.150000,0.452707) rectangle (axis cs:9.330000,0.483652);
190
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.240000,0.421111) -- (axis cs:9.240000,0.512217);
191
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.195000,0.421111) -- (axis cs:9.285000,0.421111);
192
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:9.195000,0.512217) -- (axis cs:9.285000,0.512217);
193
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(9.240000,0.468609)};
194
+ \path[fill=tailconcmetric, fill opacity=0.28, draw=none] (axis cs:10.150000,0.344016) rectangle (axis cs:10.330000,0.410016);
195
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:10.240000,0.332859) -- (axis cs:10.240000,0.463279);
196
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:10.195000,0.332859) -- (axis cs:10.285000,0.332859);
197
+ \draw[tailconcmetric, line width=1.15pt] (axis cs:10.195000,0.463279) -- (axis cs:10.285000,0.463279);
198
+ \addplot[only marks, mark=square*, mark size=2.2pt, color=tailconcmetric] coordinates {(10.240000,0.380530)};
199
+ \node[anchor=west, font=\small] at (rel axis cs:0.01,1.035) {\textcolor{tailsetmetric}{Tail set consistency}\quad\textcolor{tailmassmetric}{Tail mass similarity}\quad\textcolor{tailconcmetric}{Tail concentration consistency}};
200
+ \node[anchor=east, font=\small, text=gray!70!black] at (rel axis cs:0.995,1.035) {square = mean \quad whisker = min--max \quad box = IQR};
201
+ \end{axis}
202
+ \end{tikzpicture}