{"paper_id": "120", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T14:44:27.215679", "metrics": {"review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Politeness": "polite", "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Objectivity": 3, "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Fairness": 3, "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Actionability": 4, "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Peter-W.-Glynn_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Politeness": "polite", "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Vagueness": "high", "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Objectivity": 2, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Fairness": 3, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Actionability": 1, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Ciemon-Frank-Caballes_Overall_Quality": 2}}
{"paper_id": "166", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:12:31.183498", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-7mFW_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "28", "submitted_at": "2025-05-21T23:56:41.602065", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-xyNq_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-xyNq_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-Lpfq_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FRnw_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "48", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T03:42:02.574628", "metrics": {"review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Factuality": "factual", "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Politeness": "polite", "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Vagueness": "none", "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Objectivity": 5, "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Fairness": 5, "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Actionability": 5, "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Sergio-Luis-Náñez-Alonso_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Factuality": "factual", "review_Rekha-Pillai_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Rekha-Pillai_Politeness": "polite", "review_Rekha-Pillai_Vagueness": "low", "review_Rekha-Pillai_Objectivity": 5, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Fairness": 5, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Actionability": 5, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Rekha-Pillai_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "84", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T03:21:23.672007", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 95}}
{"paper_id": "98", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:40:42.785509", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "high", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 2, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 30}}
{"paper_id": "108", "submitted_at": "2025-05-20T13:07:08.844796", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-euBm_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-euBm_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-euBm_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-euBm_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-euBm_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-euBm_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-euBm_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-euBm_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-euBm_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-euBm_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-euBm_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-euBm_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-euBm_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5ke8_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-6Zbj_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-i457_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-i457_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-i457_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-i457_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-i457_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-i457_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-i457_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-i457_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-i457_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-i457_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-i457_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-i457_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-i457_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "103", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:39:54.884190", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-NRqK_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-NRqK_Overall_Quality": 94, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-36E8_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-36E8_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-36E8_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-36E8_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-36E8_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-dCJp_Overall_Quality": 83, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-gKE9_Overall_Quality": 89}}
{"paper_id": "10", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:18:18.896892", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7Q1Z_Overall_Quality": 82, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-oueh_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-oueh_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-oueh_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-oueh_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-oueh_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-Uzpj_Overall_Quality": 73}}
{"paper_id": "115", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:10:23.522401", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-HXMa_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-HXMa_Overall_Quality": 87, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7W7v_Overall_Quality": 20, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-duEY_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-duEY_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-duEY_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-duEY_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-duEY_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-DYrH_Overall_Quality": 84, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-sFvB_Overall_Quality": 62}}
{"paper_id": "117", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:37:54.872148", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-MDsd_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-MDsd_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-qiBS_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Actionability": 0, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7BFv_Overall_Quality": 67}}
{"paper_id": "11", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T07:07:41.704243", "metrics": {"review_Palwinder-Singh_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Palwinder-Singh_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Palwinder-Singh_Politeness": "polite", "review_Palwinder-Singh_Vagueness": "none", "review_Palwinder-Singh_Objectivity": 4, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Fairness": 5, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Actionability": 5, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Overall_Quality": 55, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Factuality": "factual", "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Politeness": "polite", "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Vagueness": "none", "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Objectivity": 5, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Fairness": 5, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Actionability": 5, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Overall_Quality": 88}}
{"paper_id": "177", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T18:14:07.821221", "metrics": {"review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Politeness": "polite", "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Objectivity": 2, "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Fairness": 3, "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Actionability": 2, "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Maarten-Franciscus-Schim-van-der-Loeff_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Victoria-Miari_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Victoria-Miari_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Victoria-Miari_Factuality": "factual", "review_Victoria-Miari_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Victoria-Miari_Politeness": "polite", "review_Victoria-Miari_Vagueness": "low", "review_Victoria-Miari_Objectivity": 3, "review_Victoria-Miari_Fairness": 4, "review_Victoria-Miari_Actionability": 4, "review_Victoria-Miari_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Victoria-Miari_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Victoria-Miari_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Victoria-Miari_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "128", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:34:45.866718", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-TLX1_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-TLX1_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Politeness": "impolite", "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-4t5w_Overall_Quality": 73, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nWJS_Overall_Quality": 79}}
{"paper_id": "12", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:52:31.567722", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-hGLR_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Objectivity": 0, "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Fairness": 1, "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Actionability": 0, "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-hGLR_Overall_Quality": 12, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-mZPw_Overall_Quality": 73, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Objectivity": 0, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Actionability": 0, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-dG2H_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7M7p_Overall_Quality": 95}}
{"paper_id": "132", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:47:14.193641", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 1, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 2, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Politeness": "polite", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Vagueness": "high", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Objectivity": 1, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Fairness": 3, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Actionability": 0, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Overall_Quality": 30}}
{"paper_id": "135", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:14:28.268761", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Factuality": "factual", "review_Clement-Jonquet_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Clement-Jonquet_Politeness": "polite", "review_Clement-Jonquet_Vagueness": "low", "review_Clement-Jonquet_Objectivity": 4, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Fairness": 4, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Actionability": 5, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Clement-Jonquet_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "139", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:58:39.566708", "metrics": {"review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Politeness": "polite", "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Objectivity": 1, "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Fairness": 3, "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Actionability": 1, "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Bhamini-Krishna-Rao_Overall_Quality": 30, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Politeness": "polite", "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Vagueness": "high", "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Objectivity": 2, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Fairness": 3, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Actionability": 1, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Ehab-Mohamed-Abd-El-Kaf_Overall_Quality": 35}}
{"paper_id": "155", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:32:46.785572", "metrics": {"review_Paul-Groth_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Paul-Groth_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Paul-Groth_Factuality": "factual", "review_Paul-Groth_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Paul-Groth_Politeness": "polite", "review_Paul-Groth_Vagueness": "low", "review_Paul-Groth_Objectivity": 4, "review_Paul-Groth_Fairness": 4, "review_Paul-Groth_Actionability": 4, "review_Paul-Groth_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Paul-Groth_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Paul-Groth_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Paul-Groth_Overall_Quality": 91, "review_Christoph-Lange_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Christoph-Lange_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Christoph-Lange_Factuality": "factual", "review_Christoph-Lange_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Christoph-Lange_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Christoph-Lange_Vagueness": "low", "review_Christoph-Lange_Objectivity": 4, "review_Christoph-Lange_Fairness": 3, "review_Christoph-Lange_Actionability": 2, "review_Christoph-Lange_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Christoph-Lange_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Christoph-Lange_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Christoph-Lange_Overall_Quality": 78, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 97}}
{"paper_id": "158", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:49:15.747983", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 3, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 1, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 45}}
{"paper_id": "163", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:58:00.280888", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 3, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 1, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 19}}
{"paper_id": "165", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:55:56.250217", "metrics": {"review_Peter-Haase_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Peter-Haase_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Peter-Haase_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Peter-Haase_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Peter-Haase_Politeness": "polite", "review_Peter-Haase_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Peter-Haase_Objectivity": 0, "review_Peter-Haase_Fairness": 4, "review_Peter-Haase_Actionability": 0, "review_Peter-Haase_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Peter-Haase_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Peter-Haase_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Peter-Haase_Overall_Quality": 10, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 1, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 12}}
{"paper_id": "166", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:12:33.814781", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-7mFW_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Overall_Quality": 67, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Overall_Quality": 86, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "178", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T18:28:17.831941", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "impolite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Factuality": "factual", "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Vagueness": "low", "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Objectivity": 5, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Fairness": 5, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Actionability": 5, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Vojtěch-Svátek_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "168", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:24:36.581297", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-XYg3_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Overall_Quality": 88, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-tePx_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-tePx_Politeness": "impolite", "review_Reviewer-tePx_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-tePx_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Politeness": "impolite", "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Overall_Quality": 37, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Overall_Quality": 55}}
{"paper_id": "171", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:41:51.662043", "metrics": {"review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Vagueness": "high", "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Objectivity": 3, "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Fairness": 3, "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Actionability": 0, "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Magdalena-Czlapka-Matyasik_Overall_Quality": 35, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Wanshui-Yang_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Wanshui-Yang_Politeness": "impolite", "review_Wanshui-Yang_Vagueness": "high", "review_Wanshui-Yang_Objectivity": 3, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Fairness": 3, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Actionability": 0, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Wanshui-Yang_Overall_Quality": 40}}
{"paper_id": "174", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T14:41:43.773140", "metrics": {"review_Paul-Huang_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Paul-Huang_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Paul-Huang_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Paul-Huang_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Paul-Huang_Politeness": "polite", "review_Paul-Huang_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Paul-Huang_Objectivity": 0, "review_Paul-Huang_Fairness": 0, "review_Paul-Huang_Actionability": 0, "review_Paul-Huang_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Paul-Huang_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Paul-Huang_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Paul-Huang_Overall_Quality": 10, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Jarrod-Marto_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Jarrod-Marto_Politeness": "polite", "review_Jarrod-Marto_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Jarrod-Marto_Objectivity": 0, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Fairness": 0, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Actionability": 0, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Jarrod-Marto_Overall_Quality": 10, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Ileana-Cristea_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Ileana-Cristea_Politeness": "polite", "review_Ileana-Cristea_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Ileana-Cristea_Objectivity": 0, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Fairness": 0, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Actionability": 0, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Ileana-Cristea_Overall_Quality": 10}}
{"paper_id": "175", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:29:19.439145", "metrics": {"review_Sabbir-Rashid_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Factuality": "factual", "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Politeness": "polite", "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Vagueness": "none", "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Objectivity": 5, "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Fairness": 3, "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Actionability": 5, "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Sabbir-Rashid_Overall_Quality": 97, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 87}}
{"paper_id": "176", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T14:39:43.439066", "metrics": {"review_Torsten-Hahmann_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Factuality": "factual", "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Vagueness": "none", "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Objectivity": 4, "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Fairness": 3, "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Actionability": 4, "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Torsten-Hahmann_Overall_Quality": 88, "review_Maria-Poveda_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Maria-Poveda_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Maria-Poveda_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Maria-Poveda_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Maria-Poveda_Politeness": "polite", "review_Maria-Poveda_Vagueness": "low", "review_Maria-Poveda_Objectivity": 3, "review_Maria-Poveda_Fairness": 4, "review_Maria-Poveda_Actionability": 3, "review_Maria-Poveda_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Maria-Poveda_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Maria-Poveda_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Maria-Poveda_Overall_Quality": 77, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Vagueness": "high", "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Objectivity": 3, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Fairness": 3, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Actionability": 3, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Mathieu-d’Aquin_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "179", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T04:07:21.758351", "metrics": {"review_Akira-Endo_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Akira-Endo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Akira-Endo_Factuality": "factual", "review_Akira-Endo_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Akira-Endo_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Akira-Endo_Vagueness": "none", "review_Akira-Endo_Objectivity": 5, "review_Akira-Endo_Fairness": 3, "review_Akira-Endo_Actionability": 4, "review_Akira-Endo_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Akira-Endo_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Akira-Endo_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Akira-Endo_Overall_Quality": 84, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Politeness": "polite", "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Objectivity": 4, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Fairness": 4, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Actionability": 1, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Tim-C.-D.-Lucas_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "185", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:39:17.240250", "metrics": {"review_Enrico-Daga_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Enrico-Daga_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Enrico-Daga_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Enrico-Daga_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Enrico-Daga_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Enrico-Daga_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Enrico-Daga_Objectivity": 0, "review_Enrico-Daga_Fairness": 0, "review_Enrico-Daga_Actionability": 0, "review_Enrico-Daga_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Enrico-Daga_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Enrico-Daga_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Enrico-Daga_Overall_Quality": 10, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Luigi-Asprino_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Luigi-Asprino_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Luigi-Asprino_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Luigi-Asprino_Objectivity": 0, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Fairness": 0, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Actionability": 0, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Luigi-Asprino_Overall_Quality": 10}}
{"paper_id": "20", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:04:46.137943", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 92}}
{"paper_id": "24", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T00:23:12.968607", "metrics": {"review_Selmy-Awad_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Selmy-Awad_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Selmy-Awad_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Selmy-Awad_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Selmy-Awad_Politeness": "polite", "review_Selmy-Awad_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Selmy-Awad_Objectivity": 0, "review_Selmy-Awad_Fairness": 0, "review_Selmy-Awad_Actionability": 0, "review_Selmy-Awad_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Selmy-Awad_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Selmy-Awad_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Selmy-Awad_Overall_Quality": 10, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Politeness": "polite", "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Objectivity": 1, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Fairness": 3, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Actionability": 1, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Silvio-Buscemi_Overall_Quality": 48}}
{"paper_id": "2", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T04:03:43.357922", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 3, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "180", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:14:38.744662", "metrics": {"review_Vivek-Gupta_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Vivek-Gupta_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Vivek-Gupta_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Vivek-Gupta_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Vivek-Gupta_Politeness": "polite", "review_Vivek-Gupta_Vagueness": "low", "review_Vivek-Gupta_Objectivity": 3, "review_Vivek-Gupta_Fairness": 3, "review_Vivek-Gupta_Actionability": 3, "review_Vivek-Gupta_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Vivek-Gupta_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Vivek-Gupta_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Vivek-Gupta_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "38", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T00:05:05.393326", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-vqBu_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Clarity_and_Readability": 1, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Objectivity": 0, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Overall_Quality": 33, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "49", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:12:54.994148", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-Uwik_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-Uwik_Overall_Quality": 78, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-4d9L_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-oYGw_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yt1v_Overall_Quality": 86}}
{"paper_id": "59", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T14:31:55.654183", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-4HBq_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-4HBq_Overall_Quality": 68, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-rzXY_Overall_Quality": 64, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-4k11_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-4k11_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-4k11_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-4k11_Objectivity": 0, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Actionability": 0, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-4k11_Overall_Quality": 44, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-NrtU_Overall_Quality": 38}}
{"paper_id": "5", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:20:32.516252", "metrics": {"review_Alison-Kutywayo_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Factuality": "factual", "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Vagueness": "high", "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Objectivity": 4, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Fairness": 4, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Actionability": 1, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Overall_Quality": 20}}
{"paper_id": "63", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:59:46.700503", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Qg2K_Overall_Quality": 55, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-5S56_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-5S56_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-5S56_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Reviewer-5S56_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Actionability": 0, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5S56_Overall_Quality": 20, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-osUg_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-osUg_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-osUg_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-osUg_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-osUg_Overall_Quality": 45, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qhf5_Overall_Quality": 66}}
{"paper_id": "79", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:21:50.241789", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-LDAP_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Overall_Quality": 98, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-htDK_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-htDK_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-htDK_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-htDK_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Overall_Quality": 72, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-At7H_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-At7H_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-At7H_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-At7H_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Overall_Quality": 55}}
{"paper_id": "114", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T04:33:05.128751", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-zq89_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-zq89_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-zq89_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-zq89_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-zq89_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-zq89_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-zq89_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-zq89_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-zq89_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-zq89_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-zq89_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-zq89_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-zq89_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-2y3j_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5d1d_Overall_Quality": 55, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pnnH_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-n4fn_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "17", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T05:16:43.164076", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-dK5u_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-dK5u_Overall_Quality": 45, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-gsUn_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-B7C2_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-k6s5_Overall_Quality": 55}}
{"paper_id": "20", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T01:31:03.816037", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "22", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T01:05:31.163155", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Qwcz_Overall_Quality": 29, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgZH_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-m91N_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-m91N_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-m91N_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-m91N_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-m91N_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-vfwG_Overall_Quality": 89, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-cSfz_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-8oQm_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "188", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T21:27:38.560218", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Factuality": "factual", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Politeness": "polite", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Vagueness": "none", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Objectivity": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Fairness": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Actionability": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Factuality": "factual", "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Politeness": "polite", "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Vagueness": "none", "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Objectivity": 5, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Fairness": 5, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Actionability": 5, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Emilia-Lenzi_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "35", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T04:53:07.789060", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-kmpt_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-kmpt_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bsgy_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-sqng_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-sqng_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-sqng_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-sqng_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-sqng_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-esAd_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-esAd_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-esAd_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-esAd_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-esAd_Overall_Quality": 100}}
{"paper_id": "51", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T16:21:39.170920", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-nspR_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-nspR_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-nspR_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-nspR_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-nspR_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-nspR_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-nspR_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-nspR_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nspR_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nspR_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nspR_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-nspR_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nspR_Overall_Quality": 100, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-u4po_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-u4po_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-u4po_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-u4po_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-u4po_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-wNRV_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-QSAL_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-zvsA_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "6", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T05:37:33.274472", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-ALvG_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-ALvG_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-2kB4_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7LW7_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-rgXX_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "100", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T17:56:39.717988", "metrics": {"review_Enrico-Daga_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Enrico-Daga_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Enrico-Daga_Factuality": "factual", "review_Enrico-Daga_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Enrico-Daga_Politeness": "polite", "review_Enrico-Daga_Vagueness": "none", "review_Enrico-Daga_Objectivity": 4, "review_Enrico-Daga_Fairness": 5, "review_Enrico-Daga_Actionability": 4, "review_Enrico-Daga_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Enrico-Daga_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Enrico-Daga_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Enrico-Daga_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Julia-Bosque_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Julia-Bosque_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Julia-Bosque_Factuality": "factual", "review_Julia-Bosque_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Julia-Bosque_Politeness": "polite", "review_Julia-Bosque_Vagueness": "low", "review_Julia-Bosque_Objectivity": 4, "review_Julia-Bosque_Fairness": 4, "review_Julia-Bosque_Actionability": 4, "review_Julia-Bosque_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Julia-Bosque_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Julia-Bosque_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Julia-Bosque_Overall_Quality": 87, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Thierry-Declerck_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Thierry-Declerck_Politeness": "polite", "review_Thierry-Declerck_Vagueness": "high", "review_Thierry-Declerck_Objectivity": 4, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Fairness": 4, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Actionability": 4, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Thierry-Declerck_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "105", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:18:07.018629", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-XVP7_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-XVP7_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-uMA5_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-q7Qn_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-fJQP_Overall_Quality": 76}}
{"paper_id": "106", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:51:36.893161", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-pc5v_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pc5v_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-s5Ux_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-3oNR_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-nNZN_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-9gri_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-9gri_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-9gri_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-9gri_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-9gri_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "110", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:28:50.358997", "metrics": {"review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Vagueness": "low", "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Objectivity": 2, "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Fairness": 3, "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Actionability": 2, "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Cliff-Ragsdale_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Objectivity": 4, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Fairness": 3, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Actionability": 3, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Joyce-van-de-Leemput_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "111", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:23:07.574805", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 0, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Objectivity": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Fairness": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Actionability": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "113", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:10:35.970559", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-QTwQ_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pJBT_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-EAMn_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-YkYx_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-S9DQ_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "118", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:48:28.174648", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 82, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Factuality": "factual", "review_Pavel-Klinov_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Pavel-Klinov_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Pavel-Klinov_Vagueness": "none", "review_Pavel-Klinov_Objectivity": 5, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Fairness": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Actionability": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Overall_Quality": 89}}
{"paper_id": "189", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T20:40:50.555661", "metrics": {"review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Factuality": "factual", "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Politeness": "polite", "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Vagueness": "none", "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Objectivity": 5, "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Fairness": 5, "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Actionability": 5, "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Valentina-Maccatrozzo_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Bo-Yan_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Bo-Yan_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Bo-Yan_Factuality": "factual", "review_Bo-Yan_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Bo-Yan_Politeness": "polite", "review_Bo-Yan_Vagueness": "none", "review_Bo-Yan_Objectivity": 5, "review_Bo-Yan_Fairness": 5, "review_Bo-Yan_Actionability": 5, "review_Bo-Yan_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Bo-Yan_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Bo-Yan_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Bo-Yan_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Simon-Scheider_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Simon-Scheider_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Simon-Scheider_Factuality": "factual", "review_Simon-Scheider_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Simon-Scheider_Politeness": "polite", "review_Simon-Scheider_Vagueness": "none", "review_Simon-Scheider_Objectivity": 5, "review_Simon-Scheider_Fairness": 5, "review_Simon-Scheider_Actionability": 5, "review_Simon-Scheider_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Simon-Scheider_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Simon-Scheider_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Simon-Scheider_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "118", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:24:10.103566", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Factuality": "factual", "review_Pavel-Klinov_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Pavel-Klinov_Politeness": "polite", "review_Pavel-Klinov_Vagueness": "none", "review_Pavel-Klinov_Objectivity": 5, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Fairness": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Actionability": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Pavel-Klinov_Overall_Quality": 78}}
{"paper_id": "145", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:35:41.473028", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-AWzJ_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-GFGi_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-anZu_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-anZu_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-anZu_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-anZu_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-anZu_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-YzNF_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "150", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T00:30:00.052531", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-gFqX_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-gFqX_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-P1f3_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-ov4k_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-MvTD_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "151", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:41:30.838437", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9Yx_Overall_Quality": 77, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-E1PQ_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-27ee_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-27ee_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-27ee_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-27ee_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-27ee_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-9Yao_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "152", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:49:30.304018", "metrics": {"review_Ruth-E-Timme_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Factuality": "factual", "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Vagueness": "low", "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Objectivity": 3, "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Fairness": 4, "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Actionability": 4, "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Ruth-E-Timme_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Vagueness": "low", "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Objectivity": 3, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Fairness": 3, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Actionability": 4, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Alfonso-Benítez-Páez_Overall_Quality": 68}}
{"paper_id": "161", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:20:15.521730", "metrics": {"review_Anne-Thessen_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Anne-Thessen_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Anne-Thessen_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Anne-Thessen_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Anne-Thessen_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anne-Thessen_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Anne-Thessen_Objectivity": 3, "review_Anne-Thessen_Fairness": 3, "review_Anne-Thessen_Actionability": 3, "review_Anne-Thessen_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Anne-Thessen_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Anne-Thessen_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anne-Thessen_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 0, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "163", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T19:34:43.438496", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 1, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 3}}
{"paper_id": "166", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:28:18.036333", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-7mFW_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mFW_Overall_Quality": 76, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-FAWm_Overall_Quality": 78, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-kjkr_Overall_Quality": 85}}
{"paper_id": "168", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:42:24.651363", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-XYg3_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-XYg3_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-tePx_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-tePx_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-tePx_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-tePx_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-tePx_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-hsiV_Overall_Quality": 45, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-TnGf_Overall_Quality": 55}}
{"paper_id": "193", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T00:32:12.982994", "metrics": {"review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Vagueness": "high", "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Objectivity": 2, "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Fairness": 3, "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Actionability": 1, "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Clarity_and_Readability": 1, "review_Nitin-Liladhar-Rane_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "192", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T23:15:49.105325", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 3, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Factuality": "factual", "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Vagueness": "low", "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Objectivity": 3, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Fairness": 3, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Actionability": 4, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Giorgos-Stoilos_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Factuality": "factual", "review_Mirko-Spasić_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Mirko-Spasić_Politeness": "polite", "review_Mirko-Spasić_Vagueness": "none", "review_Mirko-Spasić_Objectivity": 4, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Fairness": 4, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Actionability": 4, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Mirko-Spasić_Overall_Quality": 95}}
{"paper_id": "25", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T00:07:23.826818", "metrics": {"review_Ravi-Dadlani_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Vagueness": "low", "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Objectivity": 3, "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Fairness": 3, "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Actionability": 4, "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Ravi-Dadlani_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Vagueness": "high", "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Objectivity": 0, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Fairness": 0, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Actionability": 0, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Clarity_and_Readability": 1, "review_Guru-Dutta-Satyarthee_Overall_Quality": 10}}
{"paper_id": "38", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T00:02:53.295287", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-vqBu_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-vqBu_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-3sWQ_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pTVu_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-CnQu_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "79", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T19:29:06.099407", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-LDAP_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-LDAP_Overall_Quality": 82, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-THWQ_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-htDK_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-htDK_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-htDK_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-htDK_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-htDK_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-FjiL_Overall_Quality": 78, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-At7H_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-At7H_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-At7H_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-At7H_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-At7H_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "86", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T00:30:56.283566", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 0, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "8", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:37:21.306751", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-aJpk_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-aJpk_Overall_Quality": 77, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-oy34_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-oy34_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-oy34_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-oy34_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-oy34_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-GDYQ_Overall_Quality": 78, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-4ZaS_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "92", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:15:39.170660", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-fL1b_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-fL1b_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-L5U9_Overall_Quality": 78, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-QsMj_Overall_Quality": 88, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-SnVH_Overall_Quality": 78}}
{"paper_id": "94", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:30:42.775632", "metrics": {"review_John-McCrae_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_John-McCrae_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_John-McCrae_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_John-McCrae_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_John-McCrae_Politeness": "neutral", "review_John-McCrae_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_John-McCrae_Objectivity": 0, "review_John-McCrae_Fairness": 0, "review_John-McCrae_Actionability": 0, "review_John-McCrae_Constructiveness": 0, "review_John-McCrae_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_John-McCrae_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_John-McCrae_Overall_Quality": 4, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Jorge-Gracia_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Jorge-Gracia_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Jorge-Gracia_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Jorge-Gracia_Objectivity": 0, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Fairness": 0, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Actionability": 0, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Jorge-Gracia_Overall_Quality": 5}}
{"paper_id": "9", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:28:44.838663", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-KmBd_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-KmBd_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-3zCE_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-y5kB_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-XNx6_Overall_Quality": 88}}
{"paper_id": "143", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T19:22:53.485597", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "153", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:02:00.900911", "metrics": {"review_Kevin-Garey_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Kevin-Garey_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Kevin-Garey_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Kevin-Garey_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Kevin-Garey_Vagueness": "high", "review_Kevin-Garey_Objectivity": 2, "review_Kevin-Garey_Fairness": 3, "review_Kevin-Garey_Actionability": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Kevin-Garey_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Kevin-Garey_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Kevin-Garey_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Glen-Tillotson_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Glen-Tillotson_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Glen-Tillotson_Vagueness": "high", "review_Glen-Tillotson_Objectivity": 2, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Fairness": 3, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Actionability": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Vincent-Young_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Vincent-Young_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Vincent-Young_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Vincent-Young_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Vincent-Young_Vagueness": "high", "review_Vincent-Young_Objectivity": 2, "review_Vincent-Young_Fairness": 3, "review_Vincent-Young_Actionability": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Vincent-Young_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Vincent-Young_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Vincent-Young_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "198", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T19:17:20.716899", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-vL8H_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-vL8H_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-TxAH_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-jPtV_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-mUwv_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-A2TK_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "3", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:08:34.988420", "metrics": {"review_Jouni-Tuominen_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Objectivity": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Fairness": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Actionability": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Objectivity": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Fairness": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Actionability": 2, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "53", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T19:30:26.824462", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-A92f_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-A92f_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-A92f_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-A92f_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-A92f_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-A92f_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-A92f_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-A92f_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-A92f_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-A92f_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-A92f_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-A92f_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-A92f_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5AV7_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nfKV_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "149", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:42:52.098349", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 2, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 1}}
{"paper_id": "5", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:54:06.980155", "metrics": {"review_Alison-Kutywayo_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Factuality": "factual", "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Politeness": "polite", "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Objectivity": 4, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Fairness": 4, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Actionability": 2, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Alison-Kutywayo_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "74", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:37:27.998526", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-HZXU_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-HZXU_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-itVg_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-itVg_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-itVg_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-itVg_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-itVg_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-bNPg_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "154", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:13:56.866728", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-5GRr_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5GRr_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-MiyQ_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-tK15_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-tK15_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-tK15_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-tK15_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-tK15_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Ajy4_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "199", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:59:32.761619", "metrics": {"review_James-W.-MacDonald_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Factuality": "factual", "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Politeness": "neutral", "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Objectivity": 3, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Fairness": 3, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Actionability": 2, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Constructiveness": 3, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Factuality": "factual", "review_Lorena-Pantano_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Lorena-Pantano_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Lorena-Pantano_Vagueness": "low", "review_Lorena-Pantano_Objectivity": 3, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Fairness": 4, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Actionability": 3, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Factuality": "factual", "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Objectivity": 3, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Fairness": 3, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Actionability": 4, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "52", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T17:56:18.231594", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-eZuw_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-dey2_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-dey2_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-dey2_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-dey2_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Overall_Quality": 30, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "23", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:49:44.785527", "metrics": {"review_John-T.-Stoffel_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Politeness": "polite", "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Vagueness": "low", "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Objectivity": 3, "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Fairness": 4, "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Actionability": 2, "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Constructiveness": 1, "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_John-T.-Stoffel_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Factuality": "factual", "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Politeness": "polite", "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Vagueness": "low", "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Objectivity": 4, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Fairness": 4, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Actionability": 3, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Fereydoun-Davatchi_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Bertil-Blok_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Bertil-Blok_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Bertil-Blok_Factuality": "factual", "review_Bertil-Blok_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Bertil-Blok_Politeness": "polite", "review_Bertil-Blok_Vagueness": "low", "review_Bertil-Blok_Objectivity": 3, "review_Bertil-Blok_Fairness": 3, "review_Bertil-Blok_Actionability": 4, "review_Bertil-Blok_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Bertil-Blok_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Bertil-Blok_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Bertil-Blok_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "27", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:54:10.761757", "metrics": {"review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Politeness": "polite", "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Objectivity": 2, "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Fairness": 3, "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Actionability": 2, "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Prajwal-Ghimire_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Ashish-Saraf_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Ashish-Saraf_Politeness": "polite", "review_Ashish-Saraf_Vagueness": "high", "review_Ashish-Saraf_Objectivity": 2, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Fairness": 3, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Actionability": 1, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Ashish-Saraf_Overall_Quality": 40}}
{"paper_id": "107", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T20:39:37.181126", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-PbML_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-PbML_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-PbML_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-PbML_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-PbML_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-PbML_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-PbML_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-PbML_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-PbML_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-PbML_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-PbML_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-PbML_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-PbML_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-PggN_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-PggN_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-PggN_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-PggN_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-PggN_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-X6yV_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Fairness": 1, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-bqw2_Overall_Quality": 20}}
{"paper_id": "29", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:54:16.641532", "metrics": {"review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Factuality": "factual", "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Politeness": "polite", "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Objectivity": 4, "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Fairness": 4, "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Actionability": 3, "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Brian-M-Gurbaxani_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Factuality": "factual", "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Politeness": "polite", "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Vagueness": "none", "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Objectivity": 3, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Fairness": 3, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Actionability": 3, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Constructiveness": 3, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_José-L-Herrera-Diestra_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "37", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T22:19:19.204213", "metrics": {"review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Factuality": "factual", "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Politeness": "polite", "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Objectivity": 2, "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Fairness": 3, "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Actionability": 3, "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Barend-L.-van-Drooge_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Zhi-Ning_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Zhi-Ning_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Zhi-Ning_Factuality": "factual", "review_Zhi-Ning_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Zhi-Ning_Politeness": "polite", "review_Zhi-Ning_Vagueness": "low", "review_Zhi-Ning_Objectivity": 3, "review_Zhi-Ning_Fairness": 3, "review_Zhi-Ning_Actionability": 4, "review_Zhi-Ning_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Zhi-Ning_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Zhi-Ning_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Zhi-Ning_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "45", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T17:32:02.746869", "metrics": {"review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Factuality": "factual", "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Politeness": "polite", "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Vagueness": "none", "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Objectivity": 5, "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Fairness": 4, "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Actionability": 4, "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Elizabeth-A.-Stokes_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Politeness": "polite", "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Objectivity": 2, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Fairness": 3, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Actionability": 2, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Constructiveness": 2, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_David-Mark-Epstein_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "46", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T17:48:55.276498", "metrics": {"review_Anil-Gumber_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anil-Gumber_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anil-Gumber_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anil-Gumber_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anil-Gumber_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anil-Gumber_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anil-Gumber_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anil-Gumber_Fairness": 4, "review_Anil-Gumber_Actionability": 4, "review_Anil-Gumber_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anil-Gumber_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anil-Gumber_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anil-Gumber_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Factuality": "factual", "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Politeness": "polite", "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Vagueness": "low", "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Objectivity": 3, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Fairness": 3, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Actionability": 4, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Ifeoma-P.-Ijei_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "47", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T19:17:29.870448", "metrics": {"review_Jens-Foell_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Jens-Foell_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Jens-Foell_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Jens-Foell_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Jens-Foell_Politeness": "polite", "review_Jens-Foell_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Jens-Foell_Objectivity": 3, "review_Jens-Foell_Fairness": 3, "review_Jens-Foell_Actionability": 3, "review_Jens-Foell_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Jens-Foell_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Jens-Foell_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Jens-Foell_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Anders-Eklund_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anders-Eklund_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anders-Eklund_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anders-Eklund_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Anders-Eklund_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anders-Eklund_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anders-Eklund_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anders-Eklund_Fairness": 4, "review_Anders-Eklund_Actionability": 5, "review_Anders-Eklund_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anders-Eklund_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anders-Eklund_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anders-Eklund_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Matthew-Wall_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Matthew-Wall_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Matthew-Wall_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Matthew-Wall_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Matthew-Wall_Politeness": "polite", "review_Matthew-Wall_Vagueness": "low", "review_Matthew-Wall_Objectivity": 3, "review_Matthew-Wall_Fairness": 3, "review_Matthew-Wall_Actionability": 3, "review_Matthew-Wall_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Matthew-Wall_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Matthew-Wall_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Matthew-Wall_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "52", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:00:43.880835", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-eZuw_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-eZuw_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-dey2_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-dey2_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-dey2_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-dey2_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-dey2_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-mbrM_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-qzzG_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-zZT9_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "57", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:32:44.108524", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-Mh63_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-Mh63_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-1Wzd_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-vD9G_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-aWLd_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "62", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T19:35:12.917790", "metrics": {"review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Politeness": "polite", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Vagueness": "none", "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Objectivity": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Fairness": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Actionability": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Maxime-Lefrançois_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "70", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:39:23.431566", "metrics": {"review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Politeness": "polite", "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Vagueness": "low", "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Objectivity": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Fairness": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Actionability": 3, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Sabine-Pahl_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Sabine-Pahl_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Sabine-Pahl_Vagueness": "low", "review_Sabine-Pahl_Objectivity": 2, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Fairness": 3, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Actionability": 2, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "75", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T20:09:12.217200", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-wEMM_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEMM_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-s437_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-s437_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-s437_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-s437_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-s437_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-s437_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-s437_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-s437_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-s437_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-s437_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-s437_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-s437_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-s437_Overall_Quality": 55, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-mMGf_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-AtQ2_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-v6cq_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "11", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T19:28:33.667240", "metrics": {"review_Palwinder-Singh_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Factuality": "factual", "review_Palwinder-Singh_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Palwinder-Singh_Politeness": "polite", "review_Palwinder-Singh_Vagueness": "low", "review_Palwinder-Singh_Objectivity": 4, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Fairness": 4, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Actionability": 4, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Palwinder-Singh_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Objectivity": 2, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Fairness": 3, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Actionability": 3, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Neng-Fisheri-Kurniati_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "78", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T18:31:33.556978", "metrics": {"review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Factuality": "factual", "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Politeness": "polite", "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Vagueness": "none", "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Objectivity": 4, "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Fairness": 4, "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Actionability": 4, "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Sang-arun-Isaramalai_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Marta-Talavera_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Marta-Talavera_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Marta-Talavera_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Marta-Talavera_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Marta-Talavera_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Marta-Talavera_Vagueness": "high", "review_Marta-Talavera_Objectivity": 1, "review_Marta-Talavera_Fairness": 2, "review_Marta-Talavera_Actionability": 1, "review_Marta-Talavera_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Marta-Talavera_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Marta-Talavera_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Marta-Talavera_Overall_Quality": 30}}
{"paper_id": "87", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T22:05:16.040356", "metrics": {"review_Setya-Haksama_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Setya-Haksama_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Setya-Haksama_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Setya-Haksama_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Setya-Haksama_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Setya-Haksama_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Setya-Haksama_Objectivity": 2, "review_Setya-Haksama_Fairness": 2, "review_Setya-Haksama_Actionability": 3, "review_Setya-Haksama_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Setya-Haksama_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Setya-Haksama_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Setya-Haksama_Overall_Quality": 25, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Politeness": "polite", "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Vagueness": "low", "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Objectivity": 3, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Fairness": 3, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Actionability": 2, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Mohamed-Adil-AA_Overall_Quality": 35, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Factuality": "factual", "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Politeness": "polite", "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Vagueness": "low", "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Objectivity": 3, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Fairness": 3, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Actionability": 4, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Arutselvi-Devarajan_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "93", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T20:10:33.570841", "metrics": {"review_Uli-Sattler_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Uli-Sattler_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Uli-Sattler_Factuality": "factual", "review_Uli-Sattler_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Uli-Sattler_Politeness": "polite", "review_Uli-Sattler_Vagueness": "none", "review_Uli-Sattler_Objectivity": 5, "review_Uli-Sattler_Fairness": 5, "review_Uli-Sattler_Actionability": 5, "review_Uli-Sattler_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Uli-Sattler_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Uli-Sattler_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Uli-Sattler_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "97", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T20:11:53.168005", "metrics": {"review_Sara-Colantonio_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Sara-Colantonio_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Sara-Colantonio_Factuality": "factual", "review_Sara-Colantonio_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Sara-Colantonio_Politeness": "polite", "review_Sara-Colantonio_Vagueness": "none", "review_Sara-Colantonio_Objectivity": 5, "review_Sara-Colantonio_Fairness": 5, "review_Sara-Colantonio_Actionability": 5, "review_Sara-Colantonio_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Sara-Colantonio_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Sara-Colantonio_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Sara-Colantonio_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Factuality": "factual", "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Politeness": "polite", "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Vagueness": "none", "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Objectivity": 5, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Fairness": 5, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Actionability": 5, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Stelios-Sfakiannakis_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "99", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T18:55:57.235304", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 3, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "111", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T00:57:04.111078", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 0, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Factuality": "factual", "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Politeness": "polite", "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Vagueness": "none", "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Objectivity": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Fairness": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Actionability": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Lyndon-Nixon_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "36", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T01:10:08.160722", "metrics": {"review_S.G.-Lukosch_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Politeness": "neutral", "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Vagueness": "low", "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Objectivity": 3, "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Fairness": 2, "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Actionability": 1, "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Constructiveness": 1, "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_S.G.-Lukosch_Overall_Quality": 30, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Factuality": "factual", "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Politeness": "polite", "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Vagueness": "none", "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Objectivity": 3, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Fairness": 3, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Actionability": 3, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Eero-Hyvonen_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Prateek-Jain_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Prateek-Jain_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Prateek-Jain_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Prateek-Jain_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Prateek-Jain_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Prateek-Jain_Vagueness": "low", "review_Prateek-Jain_Objectivity": 2, "review_Prateek-Jain_Fairness": 1, "review_Prateek-Jain_Actionability": 2, "review_Prateek-Jain_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Prateek-Jain_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Prateek-Jain_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Prateek-Jain_Overall_Quality": 20}}
{"paper_id": "102", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:19:38.155394", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-n6Pj_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-6dqz_Overall_Quality": 79, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-wEPT_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-4kyN_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "172", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:11:55.841082", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-LoZH_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-LoZH_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-icwN_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-icwN_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-icwN_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-icwN_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-icwN_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Wq9i_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Tj4q_Overall_Quality": 64}}
{"paper_id": "116", "submitted_at": "2025-05-21T23:45:50.524922", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-5v8y_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5v8y_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-fyNb_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-phoh_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-phoh_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-phoh_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-phoh_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-phoh_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-tB5V_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-xPiJ_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "123", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T21:34:18.173660", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-EGJf_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-EGJf_Overall_Quality": 30, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-DWom_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-DWom_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-DWom_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-DWom_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-DWom_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-PnHf_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-ekPo_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "42", "submitted_at": "2025-05-21T23:58:00.815262", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-qbM5_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-qbM5_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-oPsP_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-7mQ7_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FwfS_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Objectivity": 0, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Fairness": 0, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Actionability": 0, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Reviewer-ADfc_Overall_Quality": 10, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-GAW7_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-X8JD_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-akFw_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-akFw_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-akFw_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-akFw_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-akFw_Overall_Quality": 55}}
{"paper_id": "121", "submitted_at": "2025-05-22T01:43:20.438257", "metrics": {"review_Matthias-Hartung_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Matthias-Hartung_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Matthias-Hartung_Factuality": "factual", "review_Matthias-Hartung_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Matthias-Hartung_Politeness": "impolite", "review_Matthias-Hartung_Vagueness": "none", "review_Matthias-Hartung_Objectivity": 5, "review_Matthias-Hartung_Fairness": 5, "review_Matthias-Hartung_Actionability": 5, "review_Matthias-Hartung_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Matthias-Hartung_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Matthias-Hartung_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Matthias-Hartung_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Factuality": "factual", "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Politeness": "polite", "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Vagueness": "none", "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Objectivity": 5, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Fairness": 5, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Actionability": 5, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Andrea-Giovanni-Nuzzolese_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Roman-Klinger_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Roman-Klinger_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Roman-Klinger_Factuality": "factual", "review_Roman-Klinger_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Roman-Klinger_Politeness": "polite", "review_Roman-Klinger_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Roman-Klinger_Objectivity": 5, "review_Roman-Klinger_Fairness": 5, "review_Roman-Klinger_Actionability": 5, "review_Roman-Klinger_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Roman-Klinger_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Roman-Klinger_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Roman-Klinger_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "136", "submitted_at": "2025-05-21T23:38:03.331976", "metrics": {"review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Factuality": "factual", "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Politeness": "polite", "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Vagueness": "none", "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Objectivity": 5, "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Fairness": 5, "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Actionability": 5, "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Maria-Esther-Vidal_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "148", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T17:26:04.628156", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-tVNo_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-tVNo_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-DES2_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-DES2_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-DES2_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-DES2_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-DES2_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Fii6_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-nARE_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-nARE_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-nARE_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-nARE_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-nARE_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "159", "submitted_at": "2025-05-19T23:13:52.207800", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-aUSe_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-aUSe_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-59Jp_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-5d1P_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Ks5C_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "167", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T17:47:34.688239", "metrics": {"review_Guohui-Xiao_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Guohui-Xiao_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Guohui-Xiao_Factuality": "factual", "review_Guohui-Xiao_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Guohui-Xiao_Politeness": "polite", "review_Guohui-Xiao_Vagueness": "none", "review_Guohui-Xiao_Objectivity": 5, "review_Guohui-Xiao_Fairness": 5, "review_Guohui-Xiao_Actionability": 5, "review_Guohui-Xiao_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Guohui-Xiao_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Guohui-Xiao_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Guohui-Xiao_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Meng-Wang_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Meng-Wang_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Meng-Wang_Factuality": "factual", "review_Meng-Wang_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Meng-Wang_Politeness": "polite", "review_Meng-Wang_Vagueness": "none", "review_Meng-Wang_Objectivity": 3, "review_Meng-Wang_Fairness": 3, "review_Meng-Wang_Actionability": 0, "review_Meng-Wang_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Meng-Wang_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Meng-Wang_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Meng-Wang_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "187", "submitted_at": "2025-05-21T23:44:21.542585", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-2CBB_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-2CBB_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-yUvs_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-PMap_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-PMap_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-PMap_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-PMap_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-PMap_Overall_Quality": 30}}
{"paper_id": "18", "submitted_at": "2025-05-21T23:37:16.909229", "metrics": {"review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Politeness": "polite", "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Objectivity": 3, "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Fairness": 3, "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Actionability": 1, "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Rodrigo-Lopez_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Politeness": "polite", "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Objectivity": 2, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Fairness": 3, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Actionability": 1, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Björn-A.-Grüning_Overall_Quality": 30}}
{"paper_id": "197", "submitted_at": "2025-05-21T23:25:51.838455", "metrics": {"review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Factuality": "factual", "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Politeness": "polite", "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Vagueness": "none", "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Objectivity": 5, "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Fairness": 5, "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Actionability": 5, "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Boris-Villazon-Terrazas_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Politeness": "polite", "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Vagueness": "none", "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Objectivity": 5, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Fairness": 5, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Actionability": 5, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Amrapali-Zaveri_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Factuality": "factual", "review_Francois-Scharffe_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Francois-Scharffe_Politeness": "polite", "review_Francois-Scharffe_Vagueness": "none", "review_Francois-Scharffe_Objectivity": 5, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Fairness": 5, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Actionability": 0, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Francois-Scharffe_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "32", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T17:57:12.730507", "metrics": {"review_Denise-Battaglini_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Denise-Battaglini_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Denise-Battaglini_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Denise-Battaglini_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Denise-Battaglini_Politeness": "polite", "review_Denise-Battaglini_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Denise-Battaglini_Objectivity": 2, "review_Denise-Battaglini_Fairness": 3, "review_Denise-Battaglini_Actionability": 5, "review_Denise-Battaglini_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Denise-Battaglini_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Denise-Battaglini_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Denise-Battaglini_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Factuality": "factual", "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Politeness": "polite", "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Vagueness": "low", "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Objectivity": 2, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Fairness": 3, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Actionability": 5, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Omar-Soliman-Mohamed-El-Masry_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "126", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:40:05.107947", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-83YB_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-83YB_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-83YB_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-83YB_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-83YB_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-83YB_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-83YB_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-83YB_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-83YB_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-83YB_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-83YB_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-83YB_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-83YB_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-qyRc_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-PtAe_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-Ub8t_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-eWjQ_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "41", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T17:44:00.799439", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-viiH_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-viiH_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-viiH_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-viiH_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-viiH_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-viiH_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-viiH_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-viiH_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-viiH_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-viiH_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-viiH_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-viiH_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-viiH_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-fj2y_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-LNh7_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-t9VM_Overall_Quality": 85}}
{"paper_id": "44", "submitted_at": "2025-05-22T01:47:05.821461", "metrics": {"review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Politeness": "polite", "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Vagueness": "low", "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Objectivity": 4, "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Fairness": 4, "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Actionability": 2, "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Slobodan-M-Janković_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Factuality": "factual", "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Politeness": "polite", "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Vagueness": "low", "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Objectivity": 4, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Fairness": 4, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Actionability": 4, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Andri-Frediansyah_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Politeness": "polite", "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Vagueness": "low", "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Objectivity": 3, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Fairness": 4, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Actionability": 2, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Talha-Bin-Emran_Overall_Quality": 40}}
{"paper_id": "64", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T05:09:50.393928", "metrics": {"review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Factuality": "factual", "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Politeness": "polite", "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Vagueness": "low", "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Objectivity": 4, "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Fairness": 4, "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Actionability": 5, "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Wing-Yin-Mo_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Factuality": "factual", "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Politeness": "polite", "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Vagueness": "low", "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Objectivity": 3, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Fairness": 3, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Actionability": 4, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Mohammad-Bodrul-Munir_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "67", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T05:06:26.496504", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-um1j_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-um1j_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-um1j_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-um1j_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-um1j_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-um1j_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-um1j_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-um1j_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-um1j_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-um1j_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-um1j_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-um1j_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-um1j_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-YmDt_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-8RW7_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-YYfR_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "81", "submitted_at": "2025-05-22T01:42:05.137924", "metrics": {"review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Politeness": "polite", "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Objectivity": 3, "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Fairness": 4, "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Actionability": 4, "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Gatot-Soepriyanto_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Toni-Šušak_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Toni-Šušak_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Toni-Šušak_Factuality": "factual", "review_Toni-Šušak_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Toni-Šušak_Politeness": "polite", "review_Toni-Šušak_Vagueness": "low", "review_Toni-Šušak_Objectivity": 4, "review_Toni-Šušak_Fairness": 4, "review_Toni-Šušak_Actionability": 4, "review_Toni-Šušak_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Toni-Šušak_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Toni-Šušak_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Toni-Šušak_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "90", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T19:01:30.637440", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-iUr9_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-iUr9_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-UWwz_Overall_Quality": 30, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-TyeE_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5HgB_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-yxpU_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "95", "submitted_at": "2025-05-21T23:35:02.960815", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-jG7C_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-jG7C_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-2nwv_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Qkvr_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-mRm5_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "138", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T23:02:08.395343", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-HEu9_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-HEu9_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-z7DA_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Q2P6_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Lxvm_Overall_Quality": 68}}
{"paper_id": "181", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T18:43:17.710728", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-sna7_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-sna7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-sna7_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-sna7_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-sna7_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-sna7_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-sna7_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-sna7_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-sna7_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-sna7_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-sna7_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-sna7_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-sna7_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-HLbG_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-c3Sg_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-ebFz_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "190", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T18:52:32.043789", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "133", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T20:57:27.505487", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 3, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Factuality": "factual", "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Vagueness": "low", "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Objectivity": 3, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Fairness": 4, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Actionability": 4, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Jérôme-Euzenat_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "7", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T02:11:18.073517", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-Yoim_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Yoim_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-Bu9r_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-GnyW_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Politeness": "impolite", "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Fairness": 1, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-GJR1_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-CrLf_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "91", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T22:38:31.159210", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-oZBs_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-oZBs_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-pVGE_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-CubV_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-CubV_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-CubV_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-CubV_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-CubV_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nSBj_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "119", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T04:05:05.620436", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "191", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T15:28:17.002265", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-1FB4_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-1FB4_Overall_Quality": 30, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-qQw6_Overall_Quality": 20, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-d6Ah_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-SQjv_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-BsvD_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-Zre9_Overall_Quality": 30}}
{"paper_id": "40", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:49:24.942431", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-CTw4_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-CTw4_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-PzSz_Overall_Quality": 100, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-K3eU_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-FECY_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FECY_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-FECY_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-FECY_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-FECY_Overall_Quality": 55}}
{"paper_id": "82", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T04:04:09.862082", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-2f9g_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-2f9g_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-5dvc_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-M73n_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-M73n_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-M73n_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-M73n_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-M73n_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Objectivity": 1, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-NDsr_Overall_Quality": 30, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-FMyo_Overall_Quality": 55}}
{"paper_id": "13", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T05:07:11.889219", "metrics": {"review_Joseph-philipraj_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Joseph-philipraj_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Joseph-philipraj_Factuality": "factual", "review_Joseph-philipraj_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Joseph-philipraj_Politeness": "polite", "review_Joseph-philipraj_Vagueness": "low", "review_Joseph-philipraj_Objectivity": 5, "review_Joseph-philipraj_Fairness": 5, "review_Joseph-philipraj_Actionability": 5, "review_Joseph-philipraj_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Joseph-philipraj_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Joseph-philipraj_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Joseph-philipraj_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Factuality": "factual", "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Politeness": "polite", "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Objectivity": 5, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Fairness": 5, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Actionability": 5, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Muhammad-Faruk_Overall_Quality": 93}}
{"paper_id": "31", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T04:52:05.730258", "metrics": {"review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Politeness": "polite", "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Vagueness": "none", "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Objectivity": 5, "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Fairness": 3, "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Actionability": 5, "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Obinna-Ikechukwu-Ekwunife_Overall_Quality": 77, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Factuality": "factual", "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Politeness": "polite", "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Vagueness": "none", "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Objectivity": 5, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Fairness": 5, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Actionability": 5, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Brian-Van-Wyk_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Factuality": "factual", "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Politeness": "polite", "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Vagueness": "none", "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Objectivity": 5, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Fairness": 3, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Actionability": 5, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Catherine-Kegakilwe-Koofhethile_Overall_Quality": 87}}
{"paper_id": "4", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T05:00:48.631119", "metrics": {"review_Epari-Venkatarao_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Factuality": "factual", "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Vagueness": "none", "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Objectivity": 5, "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Fairness": 5, "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Actionability": 5, "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Epari-Venkatarao_Overall_Quality": 93, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Factuality": "factual", "review_Deepak-Kumar_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Deepak-Kumar_Politeness": "polite", "review_Deepak-Kumar_Vagueness": "low", "review_Deepak-Kumar_Objectivity": 5, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Fairness": 5, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Actionability": 5, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Deepak-Kumar_Overall_Quality": 89}}
{"paper_id": "85", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T04:33:44.301065", "metrics": {"review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Factuality": "factual", "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Politeness": "polite", "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Vagueness": "low", "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Objectivity": 5, "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Fairness": 4, "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Actionability": 5, "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Jennifer-Gaddy_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Factuality": "factual", "review_Lisa-Hanson_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Lisa-Hanson_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Lisa-Hanson_Vagueness": "low", "review_Lisa-Hanson_Objectivity": 4, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Fairness": 4, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Actionability": 5, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Lisa-Hanson_Overall_Quality": 86, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Politeness": "polite", "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Vagueness": "low", "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Objectivity": 4, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Fairness": 2, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Actionability": 5, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Hannah-R-Frost_Overall_Quality": 73, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Factuality": "factual", "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Politeness": "polite", "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Vagueness": "none", "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Objectivity": 5, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Fairness": 5, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Actionability": 5, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Rosana-Rocha-Barros_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "146", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T18:26:04.996578", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-WpqT_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-WpqT_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-LTFo_Overall_Quality": 55, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-B7Vr_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-6KgK_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "96", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T04:44:47.796107", "metrics": {"review_Hedi-Peterson_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Hedi-Peterson_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Hedi-Peterson_Factuality": "factual", "review_Hedi-Peterson_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Hedi-Peterson_Politeness": "polite", "review_Hedi-Peterson_Vagueness": "none", "review_Hedi-Peterson_Objectivity": 5, "review_Hedi-Peterson_Fairness": 5, "review_Hedi-Peterson_Actionability": 5, "review_Hedi-Peterson_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Hedi-Peterson_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Hedi-Peterson_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Hedi-Peterson_Overall_Quality": 100, "review_Alexander-Pico_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Alexander-Pico_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Alexander-Pico_Factuality": "factual", "review_Alexander-Pico_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Alexander-Pico_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Alexander-Pico_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Alexander-Pico_Objectivity": 5, "review_Alexander-Pico_Fairness": 3, "review_Alexander-Pico_Actionability": 4, "review_Alexander-Pico_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Alexander-Pico_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Alexander-Pico_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Alexander-Pico_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "101", "submitted_at": "2025-05-18T19:36:17.001238", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-BZEx_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-BZEx_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-ST3b_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-3fNc_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-xHLz_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "125", "submitted_at": "2025-05-20T14:51:26.218358", "metrics": {"review_Elizaveta-Kon_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Factuality": "factual", "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Objectivity": 4, "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Fairness": 4, "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Actionability": 2, "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Elizaveta-Kon_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Politeness": "polite", "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Objectivity": 0, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Fairness": 2, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Actionability": 1, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Nicola-Maffulli_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Marco-Patruno_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Marco-Patruno_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Marco-Patruno_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Marco-Patruno_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Marco-Patruno_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Marco-Patruno_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Marco-Patruno_Objectivity": 1, "review_Marco-Patruno_Fairness": 1, "review_Marco-Patruno_Actionability": 1, "review_Marco-Patruno_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Marco-Patruno_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Marco-Patruno_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Marco-Patruno_Overall_Quality": 45}}
{"paper_id": "169", "submitted_at": "2025-05-22T14:07:37.758127", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 3, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 3, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "199", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T19:47:16.780765", "metrics": {"review_James-W.-MacDonald_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Factuality": "factual", "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Politeness": "neutral", "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Vagueness": "low", "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Objectivity": 4, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Fairness": 3, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Actionability": 0, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Constructiveness": 0, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_James-W.-MacDonald_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Factuality": "factual", "review_Lorena-Pantano_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Lorena-Pantano_Politeness": "polite", "review_Lorena-Pantano_Vagueness": "none", "review_Lorena-Pantano_Objectivity": 3, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Fairness": 4, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Actionability": 5, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Lorena-Pantano_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Factuality": "factual", "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Vagueness": "none", "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Objectivity": 5, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Fairness": 4, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Actionability": 5, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Alejandro-Reyes_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "33", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:01:49.812131", "metrics": {"review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Objectivity": 5, "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Fairness": 5, "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Actionability": 4, "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Anil-Mukund-Limaye_Overall_Quality": 100, "review_Torill-Sauer_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Torill-Sauer_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Torill-Sauer_Factuality": "factual", "review_Torill-Sauer_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Torill-Sauer_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Torill-Sauer_Vagueness": "none", "review_Torill-Sauer_Objectivity": 5, "review_Torill-Sauer_Fairness": 5, "review_Torill-Sauer_Actionability": 5, "review_Torill-Sauer_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Torill-Sauer_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Torill-Sauer_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Torill-Sauer_Overall_Quality": 100}}
{"paper_id": "0", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:09:07.412737", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-HFRa_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-HFRa_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-bec4_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-bec4_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-bec4_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-bec4_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-bec4_Overall_Quality": 100, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-i38b_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-i38b_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-i38b_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-i38b_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-i38b_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-My8L_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-My8L_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-My8L_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-My8L_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-My8L_Overall_Quality": 95, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-3iBP_Overall_Quality": 90}}
{"paper_id": "127", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:03:23.647672", "metrics": {"review_Yankai-Xia_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Yankai-Xia_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Yankai-Xia_Factuality": "factual", "review_Yankai-Xia_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Yankai-Xia_Politeness": "polite", "review_Yankai-Xia_Vagueness": "low", "review_Yankai-Xia_Objectivity": 4, "review_Yankai-Xia_Fairness": 4, "review_Yankai-Xia_Actionability": 4, "review_Yankai-Xia_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Yankai-Xia_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Yankai-Xia_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Yankai-Xia_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Factuality": "factual", "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Politeness": "polite", "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Vagueness": "low", "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Objectivity": 4, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Fairness": 4, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Actionability": 4, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Amitava-Mukherjee_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "129", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:17:02.444695", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-vTRX_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-vTRX_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-efhf_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-efhf_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-efhf_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-efhf_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-efhf_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-mok7_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-mok7_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-mok7_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-mok7_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-mok7_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Hoi6_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "131", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:01:55.522623", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-fLMf_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-fLMf_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-yntr_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-yntr_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-yntr_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-yntr_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-yntr_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-nK9w_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-RBj1_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "157", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T18:06:06.462147", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-uRwm_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-uRwm_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Vagueness": "high", "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Relevance_Alignment": 2, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Zg7q_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-6WVQ_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-CYXN_Overall_Quality": 85}}
{"paper_id": "141", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:02:58.863130", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-xxEb_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-xxEb_Overall_Quality": 50, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-4kdr_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Reviewer-H6rR_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-639w_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-639w_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-639w_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-639w_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-639w_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-639w_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-639w_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-639w_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-639w_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-639w_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-639w_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-639w_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-639w_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-9sGD_Overall_Quality": 85}}
{"paper_id": "144", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:34:24.961848", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-99Tt_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-99Tt_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Politeness": "impolite", "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Fairness": 2, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-4nHF_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-PpGy_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-pToC_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-pToC_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-pToC_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-pToC_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-pToC_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "153", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:48:17.980645", "metrics": {"review_Kevin-Garey_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Kevin-Garey_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Kevin-Garey_Politeness": "polite", "review_Kevin-Garey_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Kevin-Garey_Objectivity": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Fairness": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Actionability": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Clarity_and_Readability": 1, "review_Kevin-Garey_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Glen-Tillotson_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Glen-Tillotson_Politeness": "polite", "review_Glen-Tillotson_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Glen-Tillotson_Objectivity": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Fairness": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Actionability": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Clarity_and_Readability": 1, "review_Glen-Tillotson_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Vincent-Young_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Factuality": "unfactual", "review_Vincent-Young_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Vincent-Young_Politeness": "polite", "review_Vincent-Young_Vagueness": "extreme", "review_Vincent-Young_Objectivity": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Fairness": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Actionability": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Relevance_Alignment": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Clarity_and_Readability": 1, "review_Vincent-Young_Overall_Quality": 0}}
{"paper_id": "170", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T18:57:57.054760", "metrics": {"review_Sangeeta-Saha_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Objectivity": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Fairness": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Actionability": 2, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Clarity_and_Readability": 1, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Politeness": "neutral", "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Objectivity": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Fairness": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Actionability": 2, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Constructiveness": 3, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Clarity_and_Readability": 1, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Overall_Quality": 60}}
{"paper_id": "170", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:00:33.155143", "metrics": {"review_Sangeeta-Saha_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Factuality": "factual", "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Politeness": "polite", "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Vagueness": "low", "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Objectivity": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Fairness": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Actionability": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Sangeeta-Saha_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Factuality": "factual", "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Politeness": "polite", "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Vagueness": "low", "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Objectivity": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Fairness": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Actionability": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Constructiveness": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_J-H-Arias-Castro_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "194", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:41:12.453428", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-GDNX_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-GDNX_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-j1mL_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-cMiu_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-ky3t_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "26", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:30:24.181987", "metrics": {"review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Objectivity": 3, "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Fairness": 3, "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Actionability": 2, "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Rajinder-K.-Sharma_Overall_Quality": 50}}
{"paper_id": "3", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T19:19:08.902145", "metrics": {"review_Jouni-Tuominen_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Objectivity": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Fairness": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Actionability": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Clarity_and_Readability": 2, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Factuality": "factual", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Politeness": "polite", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Vagueness": "none", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Objectivity": 4, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Fairness": 4, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Actionability": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "3", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:50:30.052639", "metrics": {"review_Jouni-Tuominen_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Factuality": "factual", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Politeness": "polite", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Objectivity": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Fairness": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Actionability": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Jouni-Tuominen_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Factuality": "factual", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Politeness": "polite", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Vagueness": "low", "review_Katherine-Thornton_Objectivity": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Fairness": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Actionability": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Katherine-Thornton_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "66", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T22:29:28.316248", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-ocxo_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-ocxo_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-U9CF_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-U7ws_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-QqHJ_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "164", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T23:45:37.093678", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-2sTV_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-2sTV_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Actionability": 4, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-hRCv_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-VzQJ_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "70", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:53:55.332698", "metrics": {"review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Factuality": "factual", "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Politeness": "polite", "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Vagueness": "low", "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Objectivity": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Fairness": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Actionability": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Sarah-Elizabeth-West_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Factuality": "factual", "review_Sabine-Pahl_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Sabine-Pahl_Politeness": "polite", "review_Sabine-Pahl_Vagueness": "low", "review_Sabine-Pahl_Objectivity": 4, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Fairness": 3, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Actionability": 4, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Sabine-Pahl_Overall_Quality": 70}}
{"paper_id": "76", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T17:13:22.040440", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "none", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 3, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 90, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Factuality": "factual", "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Vagueness": "low", "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Objectivity": 3, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Fairness": 4, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Actionability": 4, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Ghislain-Hachey_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Factuality": "factual", "review_Ian-Dickinson_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Ian-Dickinson_Politeness": "polite", "review_Ian-Dickinson_Vagueness": "none", "review_Ian-Dickinson_Objectivity": 5, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Fairness": 5, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Actionability": 3, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Ian-Dickinson_Overall_Quality": 95}}
{"paper_id": "77", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T20:23:19.994240", "metrics": {"review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Factuality": "factual", "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Politeness": "polite", "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Vagueness": "low", "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Objectivity": 4, "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Fairness": 3, "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Actionability": 4, "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Houcemeddine-Turki_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "80", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T18:40:49.001232", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-hEF2_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Fairness": 3, "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Actionability": 1, "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-hEF2_Overall_Quality": 20, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Objectivity": 2, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-N2ym_Overall_Quality": 40, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-Vfdi_Overall_Quality": 85, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-MJiJ_Overall_Quality": 75}}
{"paper_id": "98", "submitted_at": "2025-05-15T21:26:59.010023", "metrics": {"review_Anonymous_Comprehensiveness": 1, "review_Anonymous_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 2, "review_Anonymous_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Anonymous_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Anonymous_Politeness": "polite", "review_Anonymous_Vagueness": "low", "review_Anonymous_Objectivity": 4, "review_Anonymous_Fairness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Actionability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Anonymous_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Anonymous_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Anonymous_Overall_Quality": 40}}
{"paper_id": "112", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T03:11:24.421143", "metrics": {"review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Factuality": "factual", "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Politeness": "polite", "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Vagueness": "none", "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Objectivity": 5, "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Fairness": 5, "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Actionability": 5, "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Agnieszka-Lawrynowicz_Overall_Quality": 95}}
{"paper_id": "124", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T03:37:40.667312", "metrics": {"review_Dharma-Varapula_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Dharma-Varapula_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Dharma-Varapula_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Dharma-Varapula_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Dharma-Varapula_Politeness": "polite", "review_Dharma-Varapula_Vagueness": "low", "review_Dharma-Varapula_Objectivity": 4, "review_Dharma-Varapula_Fairness": 5, "review_Dharma-Varapula_Actionability": 5, "review_Dharma-Varapula_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Dharma-Varapula_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Dharma-Varapula_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Dharma-Varapula_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Xihao-Li_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Xihao-Li_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 4, "review_Xihao-Li_Factuality": "factual", "review_Xihao-Li_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Xihao-Li_Politeness": "polite", "review_Xihao-Li_Vagueness": "low", "review_Xihao-Li_Objectivity": 5, "review_Xihao-Li_Fairness": 5, "review_Xihao-Li_Actionability": 4, "review_Xihao-Li_Constructiveness": 5, "review_Xihao-Li_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Xihao-Li_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Xihao-Li_Overall_Quality": 65}}
{"paper_id": "147", "submitted_at": "2025-05-17T03:30:06.347973", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-GYKR_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Sentiment_Polarity": "positive", "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Vagueness": "moderate", "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Constructiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Clarity_and_Readability": 3, "review_Reviewer-GYKR_Overall_Quality": 55, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-NBus_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-NBus_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-NBus_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-NBus_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-NBus_Overall_Quality": 75, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-ARok_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ARok_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-ARok_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-ARok_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-ARok_Overall_Quality": 65, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-LLss_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-LLss_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-LLss_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-LLss_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-LLss_Overall_Quality": 80}}
{"paper_id": "196", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T03:59:07.252575", "metrics": {"review_Reviewer-FpNc_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Actionability": 3, "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Constructiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-FpNc_Overall_Quality": 60, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Comprehensiveness": 5, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-MuxB_Overall_Quality": 80, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Comprehensiveness": 3, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Vagueness": "low", "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Objectivity": 3, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Actionability": 2, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Constructiveness": 1, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Relevance_Alignment": 4, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-7Mby_Overall_Quality": 45, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Comprehensiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 5, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Factuality": "factual", "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Politeness": "polite", "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Objectivity": 5, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Fairness": 5, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Actionability": 5, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Constructiveness": 4, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Relevance_Alignment": 5, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Clarity_and_Readability": 4, "review_Reviewer-AkjD_Overall_Quality": 70, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Comprehensiveness": 2, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 3, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Factuality": "partially factual", "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Sentiment_Polarity": "negative", "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Vagueness": "none", "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Objectivity": 4, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Fairness": 4, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Actionability": 0, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Relevance_Alignment": 3, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Clarity_and_Readability": 5, "review_Reviewer-qH2g_Overall_Quality": 30}}
{"paper_id": "19", "submitted_at": "2025-05-16T04:01:20.455637", "metrics": {"review_Enzo-Ierardi_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Factuality": "factual", "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Vagueness": "none", "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Objectivity": 0, "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Fairness": 0, "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Actionability": 0, "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Enzo-Ierardi_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Factuality": "factual", "review_Rebeca-Martin_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Rebeca-Martin_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Rebeca-Martin_Vagueness": "none", "review_Rebeca-Martin_Objectivity": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Fairness": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Actionability": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Rebeca-Martin_Overall_Quality": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Comprehensiveness": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Usage_of_Technical_Terms": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Factuality": "factual", "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Sentiment_Polarity": "neutral", "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Politeness": "neutral", "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Vagueness": "none", "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Objectivity": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Fairness": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Actionability": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Constructiveness": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Relevance_Alignment": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Clarity_and_Readability": 0, "review_Waliul-I-Khan_Overall_Quality": 0}}