| ==Phrack Magazine== |
|
|
| Volume Five, Issue Forty-Six, File 19 of 28 |
|
|
| **************************************************************************** |
|
|
| DefCon II: Las Vegas |
|
|
| Cyber-Christ meets Lady Luck |
|
|
| July 22-24, 1994 |
|
|
| by Winn Schwartau |
| (C) 1994 |
| |
|
|
| Las Vegas connotes radically different images to radically dif |
| ferent folks. The Rat Pack of Sinatra, Dean Martin and Sammy |
| Davis Jr. elicits up the glistening self-indulgent imagery of |
| Vegas' neon organized crime in the '50's (Ocean's Eleven |
| displayed only minor hacking skills.) |
|
|
| Then there's the daily bus loads of elderly nickel slot gam |
| blers from Los Angeles and Palm Springs who have nothing better |
| to do for twenty out of twenty four hours each day. (Their |
| dead husbands were golf hacks.) Midwesterners now throng to |
| the Mississippi River for cheap gambling. |
|
|
| Recreational vehicles of semi-trailor length from East Bullock, |
| Montana and Euclid, Oklahoma and Benign, Ohio clog routes 80 |
| and 40 and 10 to descend with a vengeance upon an asphalt home |
| away from home in the parking lot of Circus Circus. By cul |
| tural demand, every Rv'er worth his salt must, at least once in |
| his life, indulge in the depravity of Glitter Gulch. |
|
|
| And so they come, compelled by the invisibly insidious derelict |
| attraction of a desert Mecca whose only purpose in life is to |
| suck the available cash from addicted visitor's electronic |
| purses of ATM and VISA cards. (Hacker? Nah . . .) |
|
|
| Vegas also has the distinction of being home to the largest of |
| the largest conventions and exhibitions in the world. Comdex |
| is the world's largest computer convention where 150,000 techno- |
| dweebs and silk suited glib techno-marketers display their |
| wares to a public who is still paying off the 20% per annum |
| debt on last year's greatest new electronic gismo which is |
| now rendered thoroughly obsolete. And the Vegas Consumer Elec |
| tronic Show does for consumer electronics what the First Amend |
| ment does for pornography. (Hackers, are we getting close?) |
|
|
| In between, hundreds upon hundreds of small conferences and |
| conventions and sales meetings and annual excuses for excess |
| all select Las Vegas as the ultimate host city. Whatever you |
| want, no matter how decadent, blasphemous, illegal or immoral, at |
| any hour, is yours for the asking, if you have cash or a clean |
| piece of plastic. |
|
|
| So, it comes as no surprise, that sooner or later, (and it turns |
| out to be sooner) that the hackers of the world, the computer |
| hackers, phone phreaks, cyber-spooks, Information Warriors, data |
| bankers, Cyber-punks, Cypher-punks, eavesdroppers, chippers, |
| virus writers and perhaps the occasional Cyber Christ again |
| picked Las Vegas as the 1994 site for DefCon II. |
|
|
| You see, hackers are like everyone else (sort of) and so they, |
| too, decided that their community was also entitled to hold |
| conferences and conventions. |
|
|
| DefCon (as opposed to Xmas's HoHoCon), is the premier mid-year |
| hacker extravaganza. Indulgence gone wild, Vegas notwithstanding |
| if previous Cons are any example; but now put a few hundred |
| techno-anarchists together in sin city USA, stir in liberal |
| doses of illicit controlled pharmaceutical substances, and we |
| have a party that Hunter Thompson would be proud to attend. |
|
|
| All the while, as this anarchistic renegade regiment marches to |
| the tune of a 24 hour city, they are under complete surveillance |
| of the authorities. Authorities like the FBI, the Secret Serv |
| ice, telephone security . . . maybe even Interpol. And how did |
| the "man" arrive in tow behind the techno-slovens that belong |
| behind bars? |
|
|
| They were invited. |
|
|
| And so was I. Invited to speak. (Loose translation for standing |
| up in front of hundreds of hackers and being verbally skewered |
| for having an opinion not in 100% accordance with their own.) |
|
|
| "C'mon, it'll be fun," I was assured by DefCon's organizer, the |
| Dark Tangent. |
|
|
| "Sure fired way to become mutilated monkey meat," I responded. |
| Some hackers just can't take a joke, especially after a prison |
| sentence and no opposite-sex sex. |
|
|
| "No really, they want to talk to you . . ." |
|
|
| "I bet." |
|
|
| It's not that I dislike hackers - on the contrary. I have even |
| let a few into my home to play with my kids. It's just that, so |
| many of the antics that hackers have precipitated at other Cons |
| have earned them a reputation of disdain by all, save those who |
| remember their own non-technical adolescent shenanigans. And I |
| guess I'm no different. I've heard the tales of depraved indif |
| ference, hotel hold-ups, government raids on folks with names |
| similar to those who are wanted for pushing the wrong key on the |
| keyboard and getting caught for it. I wanted to see teens and X- |
| generation types with their eyes so star sapphire glazed over that |
| I could trade them for chips at the craps table. |
|
|
| Does the truth live up to the fiction? God, I hope so. It'd be |
| downright awful and unAmerican if 500 crazed hackers didn't get |
| into at least some serious trouble. |
|
|
| So I go to Vegas because, because, well, it's gonna be fun. And, |
| if I'm lucky, I might even see an alien spaceship. |
|
|
| For you see, the party has already begun. |
|
|
|
|
| I go to about 30 conventions and conferences a year, but rarely |
| if ever am I so Tylonol and Aphrin dosed that I decide to go with |
| a severe head cold. Sympomatic relief notwithstanding I debated |
| and debated, and since my entire family was down with the same |
| ailment I figured Vegas was as good a place to be as at home in |
| bed. If I could survive the four and half hour plane flight |
| without my Eustahian tubes rocketing through my ear drums and |
| causing irreparable damage, I had it made. |
|
|
| The flight was made tolerable becuase I scuba dive. Every few |
| minutes I drowned out the drone of the engines by honking uncon |
| trollably like Felix Ungerto without his aspirator. To the |
| chagrin of my outspoken counter surveillance expert and traveling |
| mate, Mike Peros and the rest of the first class cabin, the |
| captain reluctantly allowed be to remain on the flight and not be |
| expelled sans parachute somewhere over Southfork, Texas. Snort, |
| snort. Due to extensive flirting with the two ladies across the |
| aisle, we made the two thousand mile trek in something less than |
| 34 minutes . . . or so it seemed. Time flies took on new mean |
| ing. |
|
|
| For those who don't know, the Sahara Hotel is the dregs of the |
| Strip. We were not destined for Caesar's or the MGM or any of |
| the new multi-gazillion dollar hotel cum casinos which produce |
| pedestrian stopping extravaganzas as an inducement to suck in |
| little old ladies to pour endless rolls of Washington quarters in |
| mechanical bottomless pits. The Sahara was built some 200 years |
| ago by native slave labor whose idea of plumbing is clean sand |
| and decorators more concerned with a mention in Mud Hut Daily |
| than Architectural Digest. It was just as depressingly dingy and |
| solicitly low class as it was when I forced to spend eleven days |
| there (also with a killer case of the flu) for an extended Comdex |
| computer show. But, hey, for a hacker show, it was top flight. |
|
|
| "What hackers?" The desk clerk said when I asked about the show. |
|
|
| I explained. Computer hackers: the best from all over the coun |
| try. "I hear even Cyber Christ himself might appear." |
|
|
| Her quizzical look emphasized her pause. Better to ignore a |
| question not understood than to look stupid. "Oh, they'll be |
| fine, We have excellent security." The security people, I found |
| out shortly thereafter knew even less: "What's a hacker?" Too |
| much desert sun takes its toll. Proof positive photons are bad |
| for neurons. |
|
|
| Since it was still only 9PM Mike and I sucked down a couple of $1 |
| Heinekens in the casino and fought it out with Lineman's Switch |
| ing Union representatives who were also having their convention |
| at the Sahara. Good taste in hotels goes a long way. |
|
|
| "$70,000 a year to turn a light from red to green?" we com |
| plained. |
|
|
| "It's a tension filled job . . .and the overtime is murder." |
|
|
| "Why a union?" |
|
|
| "To protect our rights." |
|
|
| "What rights?" |
|
|
| "To make sure we don't get replaced by a computer . . ." |
|
|
| "Yeah," I agreed. "That would be sad. No more Amtrak |
| disasters." The crowd got ugly so we made a hasty retreat under |
| the scrutiny of casino security to our rooms. Saved. |
|
|
| Perhaps if I noticed or had read the original propaganda on |
| DefCon, I might have known that nothing significant was going to |
| take place until the following (Friday) evening I might have |
| missed all the fun. |
|
|
| For at around 8AM, my congestion filled cavities and throbbing |
| head was awakened by the sound of an exploding toilet. It's kind |
| of hard to explain what this sounds like. Imagine a toilet |
| flushing through a three megawatt sound system at a Rolling |
| Stones concert. Add to that the sound of a hundred thousand flu |
| victims standing in an echo chamber cleansng their sinuses into a |
| mountain of Kleenex while three dozen football referees blow |
| their foul whistles in unison, and you still won't come close to |
| the sheer cacophonous volume that my Saharan toilet exuded from |
| within its bowels. And all for my benefit. |
|
|
| The hotel manager thought I was kidding. "What do you mean |
| exploded?" |
|
|
| "Which word do you not understand?" I growled in my early morning |
| sub-sonic voice. "If you don't care, I don't." |
|
|
| My bed was floating. Three or maybe 12 inches of water created |
| the damnedest little tidal wave I'd ever seen, and the sight and |
| sound of Lake Meade in room 1487 only exascerbatd the pressing |
| need to relieve myself. I dried my feet on the extra bed linens, |
| worried about electrocution and fell back asleep. It could have |
| been 3 minutes or three hours later - I have no way to know - |
| but my hypnogoic state was rudely interrupted by hotel mainte |
| nance pounding at the door with three fully operational muffler- |
| less jack hammers. |
|
|
| "I can't open it," I bellowed over the continual roar of my |
| personal Vesuvius Waterfall. "Just c'mon in." The fourteenth |
| floor hallway had to resemble an underwater coral display becuase |
| the door opened ever so slowly.. |
|
|
| "Holy Christ!" |
|
|
| Choking back what would have been a painful laugh, I somehow |
| eeked out the words, with a smirk, "Now you know what an explo- |
| ding toilet is like." |
|
|
| For, I swear, the next two hours three men whose English was |
| worse than a dead Armadillo attempted to suck up the Nile River |
| from my room and the hallway. Until that very moment in time, I |
| didn't know that hotels were outfitted with vacuum cleaners |
| specifically designed to vacuum water. Perhaps this is a regular |
| event. |
|
|
|
|
| Everyone who has ever suffered through one bitches about Vegas |
| buffets, and even the hackers steered away from the Sahara's |
| $1.95 "all you can eat" room: "The Sahara's buffet is the worst |
| in town; worse than Circus Circus." But since I had left my |
| taste buds at 37,000 feet along with schrapneled pieces of my |
| inner ear, I sought out sustenance only to keep me alive another |
| 24 hours. |
|
|
| By mid afternoon, I had convinced myself that outside was not the |
| place to be. After only eighteen minutes of 120 sidewalk egg- |
| cooking degrees, the hot desert winds took what was left of my |
| breath away and with no functioning airways as it was, I knew |
| this was a big mistake. So, hacker convention, ready or not, |
| here I come. |
|
|
| Now, you have to keep in mind that Las Vegas floor plans are |
| designed with a singular purpose in mind. No matter where you |
| need to go, from Point A to Point B or Point C or D or anywhere, |
| the traffic control regulations mandated by the local police and |
| banks require that you walk by a minimum of 4,350 slot machines, |
| 187 gaming tables of various persuasions and no less than 17 |
| bars. Have they no remorse? Madison Avenue ad execs take heed! |
|
|
| So, lest I spend the next 40 years of my life in circular pursuit |
| of a sign-less hacker convention losing every last farthing I |
| inherited from dead Englishmen, I asked for the well hidden loca- |
| tion at the hotel lobby. |
|
|
| "What hackers?" There goes that nasty photon triggered neuron |
| depletion again. |
|
|
| "The computer hackers." |
|
|
| "What computer hackers. We don't have no stinking hackers . . ." |
| Desk clerk humor, my oxymoron for the week. |
| |
| I tried the name: DefCon II. |
|
|
| "Are we going to war?" one ex-military Uzi-wielding guard said |
| recognizing the etymology of the term. |
|
|
| "Yesh, it's true" I used my most convincing tone. "The Khasaks |
| tanis are coming with nuclear tipped lances riding hundred foot |
| tall horses. Paris has already fallen. Berlin is in ruins. |
| Aren't you on the list to defend this great land?" |
|
|
| "Sure as shit am!" He scampered off to the nearest phone in an |
| effort to be the first on the front lines. Neuron deficiency |
| beyong surgical repair.. |
|
|
| I slithered down umpteen hallways and casino aisles lost in the |
| jungle of jingling change. Where the hell are the hackers? |
| "They must be there," another neuron-impoverished Saharan employ |
| ee said as he pointed towards a set of escalators at the very far |
| end of the casino. |
|
|
| All the way at the end of the almost 1/4 mile trek through Sodom |
| and Gonorrhea an 'up' escalator promised to take me to hackerdom. |
| Saved at last. Upstairs. A conference looking area. No signs |
| anywhere, save one of those little black Velcro-like stick-em |
| signs where you can press on white block letters. |
|
|
| No Mo Feds |
|
|
| I must be getting close. Aha, a maintenance person; I'll ask him. |
| "What hackers? What's DefCon." |
|
|
| Back downstairs, through the casino, to the front desk, back |
| through the casino, up the same escalator again. Room One I was |
| told. Room One was empty. Figures. But, at the end of a |
| hallway, past the men's room and the phones, and around behind |
| Room One I saw what I was looking for: a couple of dozen T-shirt |
| ed, Seattle grunged out kids (read: under 30) sitting at uncov |
| ered six foot folding tables hawking their DefCon II clothing, |
| sucking on Heinekens and amusing themselves with widely strewn |
| backpacks and computers and cell phones. |
|
|
| I had arrived! |
|
|
| * * * * |
|
|
| You know, regular old suit and tie conferences could learn a |
| thing or two from Jeff Moss, the man behind DefCon II. No fancy |
| badge making equipment; no $75 per hour union labor built regis |
| tration desks; no big signs proclaiming the wealth of knowledge |
| to be gained by signing up early. Just a couple of kids with a |
| sheet of paper and a laptop. |
|
|
| It turned out I was expected. They handed me my badge and what a |
| badge it was. I'm color blind, but this badge put any psychedel |
| ically induced spectral display to shame. In fact it was a close |
| match to the Sahara's mid 60's tasteless casino carpeting which |
| is so chosen as to hide the most disgusting regurgative blessing. |
| But better and classier. |
|
|
| The neat thing was, you could (in fact had to) fill out your own |
| badge once your name was crossed off the piece of paper that |
| represented the attendee list. |
|
|
| Name: |
| Subject of Interest: |
| E-Mail: |
|
|
| Fill it out any way you want. Real name, fake name, alias, |
| handle - it really doesn't matter cause the hacker underground |
| ethic encourages anonymity. "We'd rather not know who you are |
| anyway, unless you're a Fed. Are you a Fed?" |
|
|
| A couple of lucky hackers wore the ultimate badge of honor. An |
| "I Spotted A Fed" T-shirt. This elite group sat or lay on the |
| ground watching and scouring the registration area for signs that |
| someone, anyone, was a Fed. They really didn't care or not if |
| you were a Fed - they wanted the free T-shirt and the peer re |
| spect that it brought. |
|
|
| I'm over 30 (OK, over 35) and more than a few times (OK, a little |
| over 40) I had to vehemently deny being a Fed. Finally Jeff Moss |
| came to the rescue. |
|
|
| "He's not a Fed. He's a security guy and a writer." |
|
|
| "Ugh! That's worse. Can I get a T-shirt cause he's a writer?" |
| No way hacker-breath. |
|
|
| Jeff. Jeff Moss. Not what I expected. I went to school with a |
| thousand Jeff Mosses. While I had hair down to my waist, wearing |
| paisley leather fringe jackets and striped bell bottoms so wide I |
| appeared to be standing on two inverted ice cream cones, the Jeff |
| Mosses of the world kept their parents proud. Short, short |
| cropped hair, acceented by an ashen pall and clothes I stlll |
| wouldn't wear today. They could get away with anything cause |
| they didn't look the part of radical chic. Jeff, I really like |
| Jeff: he doesn't look like what he represents. Bruce Edelstein, |
| (now of HP fame) used to work for me. He was hipper than hip but |
| looked squarer than square. Now today that doesn't mean as much |
| as it used to, but we ex-30-somethings have a hard time forget |
| ting what rebellion was about. (I was suspended 17 times in the |
| first semester of 10th grade for wearing jeans.) |
|
|
| Jeff would fit into a Corporate Board Meeting if he wore the |
| right suit and uttered the right eloquencies: Yes, that's it: A |
| young Tom Hanks. Right. I used to hate Tom Hanks (Splash, how |
| fucking stupid except for the TV-picture tube splitting squeals) |
| but I've come to respect the hell out of him as an actor. Jeff |
| never had to pass through that first phase. I instantly liked |
| him and certainly respect his ability to pull off a full fledged |
| conference for only $5000. |
|
|
| You read right. Five grand and off to Vegas with 300 of your |
| closest personal friends, Feds in tow, for a weekend of electron |
| ic debauchery. "A few hundred for the brochure, a few hundred |
| hear, a ton in phone bills, yeah, about $5000 if no one does any |
| damage." Big time security shows cost $200,000 and up. I can |
| honestly say without meaning anything pejorative at any of my |
| friends and busienss acquaintances, that I do not learn 40 times |
| as much at the 'real' shows. Something is definitely out of |
| whack here. Suits want to see suits. Suits want to see fancy. |
| Suits want to see form, substance be damned. Suits should take a |
| lesson from my friend Jeff. |
|
|
| * * * * * |
|
|
| I again suffered through a tasteless Saharan buffer dinner which |
| cost me a whopping $7.95. I hate grits - buttered sand is what I |
| call them - but in this case might well have been preferable. |
| Somehow I coerced a few hackers to join me in the ritualistic |
| slaughter of our taste buds and torture of our intestines. They |
| were not pleased with my choice of dining, but then who gives a |
| shit? I couldn't taste anything anyway. Tough. |
|
|
| To keep our minds off of the food we talked about something much |
| more pleasant: the recent round of attacks on Pentagon computers |
| and networks. "Are the same people involved as in the sniffing |
| attacks earlier this year?" I asked my triad of dinner mates. |
|
|
| "Indubitably." |
|
|
| "And what's the reaction from the underground - other hackers?" |
|
|
| Coughs, sniffs. Derisive visual feedback. Sneers. The finger. |
|
|
| "We can't stand 'em. They're making it bad for everybody." Two |
| fingers. |
|
|
| By and large the DefCon II hackers are what I call 'good hackers' |
| who hack, and maybe crack some systems upon occasion, but aren't |
| what I refer to as Information Warriors in the bad sense of the |
| word. This group claimed to extol the same position as most of |
| the underground would: the Pentagon sniffing crackers - or |
| whoever who is assaulting thousands of computers on the net - |
| must be stopped. |
|
|
| "Scum bags, that what they are." I asked that they not sugarcoat |
| their feelings on my behalf. I can take it. "These fuckers are |
| beyond belief; they're mean and don't give a shit how much damage |
| they do." We played with our food only to indulge in the single |
| most palatable edible on display: ice cream with gobs of choco |
| late syrup with a side of coffee. . |
|
|
| The big question was, what to do? The authorities are certainly |
| looking for a legal response; perhaps another Mitnick or Phiber |
| Optik. Much of the underground cheered when Mark Abene and |
| others from the reknowned Masters of Destruction went to spend a |
| vacation at the expense of the Feds. The MoD was up to no good |
| and despite Abene's cries that there was no such thing as the |
| MoD, he lost and was put away. However many hackers believe as I |
| do, that sending Phiber to jail for hacking was the wrong punish |
| ment. Jail time won't solve anything nor cure a hacker from his |
| first love. One might as well try to cure a hungry man from |
| eating: No, Mark did wrong, but sending him to jail was wrong, |
| too. The Feds and local computer cops and the courts have to |
| come up with punishments appropriate to the crime. Cyber-crimes |
| (or cyber-errors) should not be rewarded by a trip to an all male |
| hotel where the favorite toy is a phallically carved bar of soap. |
|
|
| On the other hand, hackers in general are so incensed over the |
| recent swell of headline grabbing break-ins, and law enforcement |
| has thus far appeared to be impotent, ("These guys are good.") |
| that many are searching for alternative means of retribution. |
|
|
| "An IRA style knee capping is in order," said one. |
|
|
| "That's not good enough, not enough pain," chimed in another. |
| (Sip, sip. I can almost taste the coffee.) |
|
|
| "Are you guys serious?" I asked. Violence? You? I thought I |
| knew them better than that. I know a lot of hackers, none that I |
| know of is violent, and this extreme Pensacola retribution |
| attitude seemed tottally out of character. "You really wouldn't |
| do that, would you?" My dinner companions were so upset and they |
| claimed to echo the sentiment of all good-hackers in good stand |
| ing, that yes, this was a viable consideration. |
|
|
| "The Feds aren't doing it, so what choice do we have? I've heard |
| talk about taking up a collection to pay for a hit man . . ." |
| Laughter around, but nervous laughter. |
|
|
| "You wouldn't. . ." I insisted. |
|
|
| "Well, probably not us, but that doesn't mean someone else |
| doesn't won't do it." |
|
|
| "So you know who's behind this whole thing." |
|
|
| "Fucking-A we do," said yet another hacker chomping at the bit. |
| He was obviously envisioning himself with a baseball bat in his |
| hand. |
|
|
| "So do the Feds." |
|
|
| So now I find myself in the dilemma of publishing the open secret |
| of who's behind the Internet sniffing and Pentagon break ins, but |
| after talking to people from both the underground and law en |
| forcement, I think I'll hold off awhile It serves no immediate |
| purpose other than to warn off the offenders, and none of us want |
| that. |
|
|
| Obviously all is not well in hacker-dom. |
|
|
| * * * * * |
|
|
| The registration area was beyond full; computers, backpacks |
| everywhere, hundreds of what I have to refer to as kids and a |
| fair number of above ground security people. Padgett Peterson of |
| Martin Marietta was going to talk about viruses, Sara Gordon on |
| privacy, Mark Aldrich is a security guy from DC., and a bunch of |
| other folks I see on the seemingly endless security trade show |
| circuit. Jeff Moss had marketed himself and the show excellently. |
| Los Angeles sent a TV crew, John Markoff from the New York Times |
| popped in as did a writer from Business Week. (And of course, |
| yours truly.) |
|
|
| Of the 360 registrees ("Plus whoever snuck in," added Jeff) I |
| guess about 20% were so-called legitimate security people. That's |
| not to belittle the mid-20's folks who came not because they were |
| hackers, but because they like computers. Period. They hack for |
| themselves and not on other systems, but DefCon II offered some |
| thing for everyone. |
|
|
| I remember 25 years ago how my parents hated the way I dressed |
| for school or concerts or just to hang out: God forbid! We wore |
| those damned jeans and T-shirts and sneakers or boots! "Why can't |
| you dress like a human being," my mother admonished me day after |
| day, year after year. So I had to check myself because I can't |
| relate to Seattle grunge-ware. I'm just too damned old to wear |
| shirts that fit like kilts or sequin crusted S&M leather straps. |
| Other than the visual cacophony of dress, every single |
| hacker/phreak that I met exceeded my expectations in the area of |
| deportment. |
|
|
| These are not wild kids on a rampage. The stories of drug-in |
| duced frenzies and peeing in the hallways and tossing entire |
| rooms of furniture out of the window that emanated from the |
| HoHoCons seemed a million miles away. This was admittedly an |
| opportunity to party, but not to excess. There was work to be |
| done, lessons to be learned and new friends to make. So getting |
| snot nosed drunk or ripped to the tits or Ecstatically high was |
| just not part of the equation. Not here. |
|
|
| Now Vegas offers something quite distinct from other cities |
| which host security or other conventions. At a Hyatt or a Hilton |
| or any other fancy-ass over priced hotel, beers run $4 or $5 a |
| crack plus you're expected to tip the black tied minimum wage |
| worker for popping the top. The Sahara (for all of the other |
| indignities we had to suffer) somewhat redeemed itself by offer |
| ing an infinite supply of $1 Heinekens. Despite hundreds of beer |
| bottle spread around the huge conference area (the hotel was |
| definitely stingy in the garbage pail business) public drunken |
| ness was totally absent. Party yes. Out of control? No way. |
| Kudos! |
|
|
| Surprisingly, a fair number of women (girls) attended. A handful |
| were there 'for the ride' but others . . . whoa! they know their |
| shit. |
|
|
| I hope that's not sexist; merely an observation. I run across so |
| few technically fluent ladies it's just a gut reaction. I wish |
| there were more. In a former life, I owned a TV/Record produc |
| tion company called Nashville North. We specialized in country |
| rock taking advantage of the Urban Cowboy fad in the late 1970's. |
| Our crew of producers and engineers consisted of the "Nashville |
| Angels." And boy what a ruckus they would cause when we recorded |
| Charlie Daniels or Hank Williams: they were stunning. Susan |
| produced and was a double for Jacqueline Smith; we called Sally |
| "Sabrina" because of her boyish appearance and resemblance to |
| Kate Jackson. A super engineer. And there was Rubia Bomba, the |
| Blond Bombshell, Sherra, who I eventually married: she knew |
| country music inside and out - after all she came from Nashville |
| in the first place. |
|
|
| When we would be scheduled to record an act for live radio, some |
| huge famous country act like Asleep at The Wheel of Merle Haggard |
| or Johnny Paycheck or Vassar Clements, she would wince in disbe |
| lief when we cried, "who's that?" Needless to say, she knew the |
| songs, the cues and the words. They all sounded alike. Country |
| Music? Ecch. (So I learned.) |
|
|
| At any rate, ladies, we're equal opportunity offenders. C'mon |
| down and let's get technical. |
|
|
| As the throngs pressed to register, I saw an old friend, Erik |
| Bloodaxe. I've known him for several years now and he's even |
| come over to baby sit the kids when he's in town. (Good prac |
| tice.) Erik is about as famous as they come in the world of |
| hackers. Above ground the authorities investigated him for his |
| alleged participation in cyber crimes: after all, he was one of |
| the founders of the Legion of Doom, and so, by default, he must |
| have done something wrong. Never prosecuted, Erik Bloodaxe lives |
| in infamy amongst his peers. To belay any naysayers, Erik ap |
| peared on every single T-shirt there. |
|
|
| "I Only Hack For Money," |
| Erik Bloodaxe |
|
|
| proclaimed dozens of shirts wandering through the surveillance |
| laden casinos. His is a name that will live in infamy. |
|
|
| So I yelled out, "Hey Chris!" He gave his net-name to the |
| desk/table registrar. "Erik Bloodaxe." |
|
|
| "Erik Bloodaxe?" piped up an excited high pitched male voice. |
| "Where?" People pointed at Chris who was about to be embarrass |
| ingly amused by sweet little tubby Novocain who practically bowed |
| at Chris's feet in reverence. "You're Erik Bloodaxe?" Novocain |
| said with nervous awe - eyes gleaming up at Chris's ruddy skin |
| and blond pony-tail. |
|
|
| "Yeah," Chris said in the most off handed way possible. For |
| people who don't know him this might be interpreted as arrogance |
| (and yes there is that) but he also has trouble publicly accept |
| ing the fame and respect that his endearing next-generation |
| teenage fans pour on him. |
|
|
| "Wow!" Novocain said with elegance and panache. "You're Erik |
| Bloodaxe." We'd just been through that said Chris's eyes. |
|
|
| "Yeah." |
|
|
| "Wow, well, um, I . . . ah . . . you're . . . I mean, wow, |
| you're the best." What does Sylvia Jane Miller from Rumpsteer, |
| Iowa say to a movie star? This about covered it. The Midwest |
| meets Madonna. "Wow!" Only here it's Novocain meets Cyber |
| Christ himself. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Like any other security show or conference or convention there is |
| a kickoff, generally with a speech. And DefCon II was no excep |
| tion. Except. |
|
|
| Most conventional conventions (ConCons) start at 7:30 or 8:00 AM |
| because, well, I don't know exactly why, except that's when so- |
| called suits are expected to show up in their cubicles. Def |
| Con, on the other hand, was scheduled to start at 10PM on Friday |
| night when most hakcers show up for work. Most everyone had |
| arrived and we were anxiously awaiting the opening ceremonies. |
| But, here is where Jeff's lack of experience came in. The kick- |
| off speaker was supposed to be Mark Ludwig of virus writing fame |
| and controversy. But, he wasn't there! |
|
|
| He had jet lag. |
|
|
| "From Phoenix?" I exclaimed in mock horror to which nearby hack |
| ers saw the absurdity of a 45 minute flight jet lag. Mark has a |
| small frame and looks, well, downright weak, so I figured maybe |
| flying and his constitution just didn't get along and he was |
| massaging his swollen adenoids in his room. |
|
|
| "Oh, no! He's just come in from Australia . . ." Well that |
| explains it, alright! Sorry for the aspersions, Mark. |
|
|
| But Jeff didn't have a back up plan. He was screwed. Almost four |
| hundred people in the audience and nothing to tell them. So, and |
| I can't quite believe it, one human being who had obviously never |
| stood in front of a live audience before got up in an impromptu |
| attempt at stand up comedy. The audience was ready for almost |
| anything entertaining but this guy wasn't. Admittedly it was a |
| tough spot, but . . . |
|
|
| "How do you turn a 486 into an 8088?" |
|
|
| "Add Windows." Groan. Groan. |
|
|
| "What's this?" Picture the middle three fingers of your right |
| hand wiggling madly. |
|
|
| "An encrypted this!" Now hold out just the middle finger. |
| Groan. Groan. |
|
|
| "What's this?" Spread your legs slightly apart, extend both |
| hands to the front and move them around quickly in small circles. |
|
|
| "Group Air Mouse." Groan. |
|
|
| The evening groaned on with no Mark nor any able sharp witted |
| comedian in sight. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Phil Zimmerman wrote PGP and is a God, if not Cyber-Christ him |
| self to much of the global electronic world. Preferring to call |
| himself a folk hero (even the Wall Street Journal used that term) |
| Phil's diminutive height combined with a few too many pounds and |
| a sweet as sweet can be smile earn him the title of Pillsbury |
| Dough Boy look alike. Phil is simply too nice a guy to be em |
| broiled in a Federal investigation to determine if he broke the |
| law by having PGP put on a net site. You see, the Feds still |
| think they can control Cyberspace, and thereby maintain antique |
| export laws: "Thou shalt not export crypto without our approval" |
| sayeth the NSA using the Department of Commerce as a whipping boy |
| mouth piece. So now Phil faces 41-51 months of mandatory jail |
| time if prosecuted and convicted of these absurd laws. |
|
|
| Flying in from Colorado, his appearance was anxiously awaited. |
| "He's really coming?" " I wonder what he's like?" (Like every |
| one else, fool, just different.) When he did arrive, his shit- |
| eating grin which really isn't a shit-eating grin, it's just |
| Phil's own patented grin, preceeded him down the hallway. |
|
|
| "Here he is!" "It's Phil Zimmerman." Get down and bow. "Hey, |
| Phil the PGP dude is here." |
|
|
| He was instantly surrounded by those who recognize him and by |
| those who don't but want to feel like part of the in-crowd. |
| Chat chat, shit-eating grin, good war stories and G-rated pleas |
| antries. Phil was doing what he does best: building up the folk |
| hero image of himself. His engaging personality (even though he |
| can't snorkel to save his ass) mesmerized the young-uns of the |
| group. "You're Phil?" |
|
|
| "Yeah." No arrogance, just a warm country shit-eating grin |
| that's not really shit-eating. Just Phil being Phil. He plays |
| the part perfectly. |
|
|
| Despite the attention, the fame, the glory (money? nah . . .) the |
| notoriety and the displeased eyes of onlooking Computer Cops who |
| really do believe he belongs in jail for 4 years, Phil had a |
| problem tonight. A real problem. |
|
|
| "I don't have a room!" he quietly told Jeff at the desk. "They |
| say I'm not registered." No panic. Just a shit-eating grin |
| that's not a shit-eating grin and hand the problem over to the |
| experts: in this case Jeff Moss. Back to his endearing fans. |
| Phil is so damned kind I actually saw him giving Cryptography 101 |
| lessons on the corner of a T-shirt encrusted table. "This is |
| plaintext and this is crypto. A key is like a key to your hotel |
| room . . . " If only Phil had a hotel room. |
|
|
| Someone had screwed up. Damn computers. So the search was on. |
| What had happened to Phil's room? Jeff is scrambling and trying |
| to get the hotel to rectify the situation. Everyone was abuzz. |
| Phil, the crypto-God himself was left out in the cold. What |
| would he do? |
|
|
| When suddenly, out of the din in the halls, we heard one voice |
| above all the rest: |
|
|
| "Phil can sleep with me!" |
|
|
| Silence. Dead stone cold silence. Haunting silence like right |
| after an earthquake and even the grubs and millipedes are so |
| shaken they have nothing to say. Silence. |
|
|
| The poor kid who had somehow instructed his brain to utter the |
| words and permitted them to rise through his esophagus and out |
| over his lips stood the object of awe, incredulity and mental |
| question marks. He must have thought to himself, "what's every |
| one staring at? What's going on? Let me in on it." For the |
| longest 10 seconds in the history of civilization he had abso |
| lutely no clue that he was the target of attention. A handful of |
| people even took two or three steps back, just in case. Just in |
| case of what was never openly discussed, but nonetheless, just in |
| case. |
|
|
| And then the brain kicked in and a weak sheepish smile of guilt |
| overcame this cute acne-free baby-butt smooth-faced hacker who |
| had certainly never had a shave, and was barely old enough to |
| steer his own pram. |
|
|
| "Ohhhhhh . . . . noooooo," he said barely louder than a whisper. |
| "That' not what I mean!" |
|
|
| I nearly peed laughing so hard in unison with a score of hackers |
| who agreed that these misspoken words put this guy in the unenvi |
| able position of being the recipient of a weekend of eternal |
| politically incorrect ridicule. |
|
|
| "Yeah, right. We know what you mean . . " |
|
|
| "No really . . ." he pleaded as the verbal assaults on his al |
| leged sexual preferences were slung one after the other. |
|
|
| This poor kid never read Shakespeare: "He who doth protest too |
| much . . ." |
|
|
| If we couldn't have a great kickoff speech, or comedian, this |
| would have to do. |
|
|
| The majority of the evening was spent making acquaintances: |
|
|
| "Hi, I'm Jim. Oops, I mean 'Septic Tank," was greeted with "Oh, |
| you're Septic. I'm Sour Milk." (Vive la difference!) People who |
| know each other electronically are as surprised to meet their |
| counterparts as are first daters who are in love with the voice |
| at the other end of the phone. "Giving good phone" implies one |
| thing while "Having a great keystroke" just might mean another. |
|
|
| The din of the crowd was generally penetrated by the sounds of a |
| quasi-pornographic Japanese high tech toon of questionable so |
| cially redeeming value which a majority of the crowd appeared to |
| both enjoy and understand. I am guilty of neither by reason of |
| antiquity. |
|
|
| And so it goes. |
|
|
| * * * * * |
|
|
| Phil Zimmerman must have gotten a room and some sleep because at |
| 10AM (or closely thereafter) he gave a rousing (some might say |
| incendiary) speech strongly attacking the government's nearly |
| indefensible position on export control |
|
|
| I was really impressed. Knowing Phil for some time, this was the |
| first time I ever heard him speak and he did quite an admirable |
| job. He ad libs, talks about what he want to talk about and does |
| so in a compelling and emotional way. His ass is on the line and |
| he should be emotional about it. The audience, indeed much of |
| counter culture Cyberspace loves Phil and just about anything he |
| has to say. His affable 40-something attorney from Colorado, |
| Phil DuBois was there to both enjoy the festivities and, I'm |
| sure, to keep tabs on Phil's vocalizations. Phil is almost too |
| honest and open for his own good. Rounds and rounds of sincere |
| appreciation. |
|
|
|
|
|
|
| Hey kids, now it's time for another round of Spot The Fed. |
| Here's your chance to win one of these wonderful "I Spotted A |
| Fed" T-shirts. And all you have to do is ID a fed and it's yours. |
| Look around you? Is he a Fed? Is she under cover or under the |
| covers? Heh, heh. Spot the Fed and win a prize. This one-size- |
| fits-all XXX Large T-shirt is yours if you Spot the Fed. I had |
| to keep silent. That would have been cheating. I hang out on |
| both sides and have a reputation to maintain. |
|
|
| "Hey, I see one" screeched a female voice (or parhaps it was |
| Phil's young admirer) from the left side of the 400+ seat ball |
| room. Chaos! Where? Where? Where's the fed? Like when Jose |
| Consenko hits one towards the center field fence and 70,000 |
| screaming fans stand on their seats to get a better view of a |
| three inch ball 1/4 mile away flying at 150 miles per hour, this |
| crowd stood like Lemmings in view of Valhalla the Cliff to espy |
| the Fed. Where's the Fed? |
|
|
| Jeff jumped off the stage in anxious anticipation that yet anoth |
| er anti-freedom-repressive law enforcement person had blown his |
| cover. Where's the Fed? Jeff is searching for the accuser and |
| the accused. Where's the Fed? Craned necks as far as the eye |
| can see; no better than rubber neckers on Highway 95 looking for |
| steams of blood and misplaced body parts they half expected a Fed |
| to be as distinctly obvious as Quasimoto skulking under the |
| Gorgoyled parapits of Notre Dame. No such luck. They look like |
| you and me. (Not me.) Where's the Fed? |
|
|
| He's getting closer, closer to the Fed. Is it a Fed? Are you a |
| Fed? C'mon, fess up. You're a a fed. Nailed. Busted. Psyche! |
|
|
| Here's your T-shirt. More fun than Monty Hall bringing out |
| aliens from behind Door #3 on the X-Files. Good clean fun. But |
| they didn't get 'em all. A couple of them were real good. Must |
| have been dressed like an Hawaiian surf bum or banshee from |
| Hellfire, Oregon. Kudos to those Feds I know never got spotted. |
| Next year, guys. There's always next year. |
|
|
| Phil's notoriety and the presence of the Phoenix, Arizona prosecu |
| tor who was largely responsible for the dubiously effective or |
| righteous Operation Sun Devil, Gail Thackeray ("I change job |
| every 4 years or so - right after an election") brought out the |
| media. The LA TV station thought they might have the makings of |
| a story and sent a film crew for the event. |
|
|
| "They're Feds. The ones with the cameras are Feds. I know it. Go |
| ask 'em." No need. Not. |
|
|
| "Put away that camera." At hacking events it's proper etiquette |
| to ask if people are camera shy before shooting. The guy that I |
| was sitting next to buried his face in his hands to avoid being |
| captured on video tape. |
|
|
| "What are you; a Fed or a felon?" I had to ask. |
|
|
| "What's the difference," his said. "They're the same thing." So |
| which was it, I wondered. For the truly paranoid by the truly |
| paranoid. |
|
|
| "Get that thing outta here," he motioned to the film crew who |
| willingly obliged by turning off the lights. "They're really |
| Feds," he whispered to me loud enough for the row in front and |
| behind us to hear. |
|
|
| I moved on. Can't take chances with personal safety when I have |
| kids to feed. Fed or felon, he scared me. |
|
|
| Gail Thackeray was the next act on stage. She was less in agree |
| ment about Phil Zimmerman than probably anyone (except the unde |
| tected Feds) in the audience. She, as expected, endorsed much of |
| the law enforcement programs that revolve around various key |
| management (escrow) schemes. Phil recalls a letter from Burma |
| that describe how the freedom fighters use PGP to defend them |
| selves against repression. He cites the letter from Latvia that |
| says electronic freedom as offered by PGP is one of the only |
| hopes for the future of a free Russia. Gail empathizes but sees |
| trouble closer to home. Terrorism a la World Trade Center, or |
| rocket launchers at O'Hare Airport, or little girl snuff films in |
| Richmond, Virginia, or the attempt to poison the water supply |
| outside of Boston. These are the real threats to America in the |
| post Cold War era. |
|
|
| "What about our personal privacy!" cries a voice. "We don't want |
| the government listening in. It's Big Brother 10 years behind |
| schedule." |
|
|
| Gail is amused. She knew it would be a tough audience and has |
| been through it before. She is not shaken in the least. |
|
|
| "I've read your mail," she responds. "Its not all that interest |
| ing." The audience appreciates a good repartee. "You gotta pay |
| me to do this, and frankly most of it is pretty boring." She |
| successful made her point and kept the audience laughing all the |
| way. |
|
|
| She then proceeded to tell that as she sees it, "The expectation |
| of privacy isn't real." I really don't like hearing this for I |
| believe in the need for an Electronic Bill of Rights. I simply |
| think she's wrong. "History is clear," she said "the ability to |
| listen in used to be limited to the very few. The telegraph was |
| essentially a party line and still today in some rural areas |
| communications aren't private. Why should we change it now?" |
|
|
| "Gail, you're so full of shit!" A loud voice bellowed from next |
| to me again. Boy can I pick seats. "You know perfectly well that |
| cops abuse the laws and this will just make their jobs easier. |
| Once people find a way to escape tyranny you all want to bring it |
| right back again. This is revolution and you're scared of los |
| ing. This kind of puke scum you're vomiting disgusts me. I just |
| can't take it any more. " Yeah, right on. Scattered applause. |
| While this 'gent' may have stated what was on many minds, his |
| manner was most unbefitting a conference and indeed, even DefCon |
| II. This was too rude even for a hacker get-together. The man |
| with the overbearing comments sat down apologizing. "She just |
| gets me going, she really does. Really pisses me off when she |
| goes on like about how clean the Feds are. She knows better than |
| to run diarrhea of the mouth like that." |
|
|
| "You know," she continued. "Right across the street is a Spy |
| Shop. One of those retail stores where you can buy bugs and taps |
| and eavesdropping equipment?" The audience silently nodded. "We |
| as law enforcement are prohibited by law from shopping there and |
| buying those same things anyone else can. We're losing on that |
| front." Cheers. Screw the Feds. |
|
|