{"id": "7d335aabbbc34ae6fe8233a4c96ea32e4348837ab8152edbb2769d3a3d128602", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 815 successes and 23 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 815, "failed": 23, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f70fd7a7777f448fbf0e4d855c991c94151f51ced6a1537dbc4d2d66fd5ae950", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=600 failed=29 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 600, "failed": 29, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "18b910e62d721ad3cf5cd7cb0f1a09143a160e8c07856fbd4adb115e838f816e", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 843 passing and 5 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 843, "failed": 5, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8fd7f63c21d3ff34a5f4ae182f3948384cb65b0510205dd8c8682d6d950b2223", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 13 failures after 274 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 274, "failed": 13, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "971c0889be713f4117d55a365d8465a32d9ee8108561c45e4d4ded837305b343", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 196, \"failed\": 33}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 196, "failed": 33, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "743ed293328ee0ce8a7ab13b6df448578ab03cc8721b40862fdb153017c7daa8", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"368\" failed=\"25\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 368, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ffeb7c28c2aa52630ce57d5c5305e66e8a61f37480e3b435e0cf2a1e8bfee598", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 494 pass, 10 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 494, "failed": 10, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bcb0f4cf48248041ae954063fd623cd0368c9c0cc8113a44744016370c9a4db9", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 460 passing, 39 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 460, "failed": 39, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9abb67454e92b91056a3897b034164347b6cf392de18d402ff2759f45c5b768b", "state": "JIRA-billing: 9 failures / 85 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 85, "failed": 9, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6468e9a8beb2960e9abcc8a9cf2c330b4e6630d85f4a1c8051a311e794c2a212", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=132 failed=32 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 132, "failed": 32, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a3ee96d50ac3671728ef99771b8bf0fde17f5a43c5b69ab73b286e363a91bce4", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 31 failures (timeout) after 349 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 349, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "af8dfbe487854d9faa6e043784f8e5e2134ed09e7fe0bf5dc548c761e596c1e9", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 578\u2713 4\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 578, "failed": 4, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ab8e216081c05e8aa03a7f54d7a975b421483d9af43f7ed244c252f360286afc", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 6 successes and 26 failures (timeout). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 6, "failed": 26, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6d3160fe131bc8a9bce0182c28eb2da53babb8c5ea1ae93afadd939116aaac4f", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=873 failed=10 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 873, "failed": 10, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5000fc8e8bb7b397dbbaab3d93833d52758f519a523ba5c742c6659c1d3cc413", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 22 passing and 6 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 22, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c92d6f68425213bf95966ddc23c3b65c2d1b0b0a157d9cbb5e7b72ab4d002f9f", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 5 failures after 235 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 235, "failed": 5, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e092ef3b6cb31f614e57357cf51592ed5a650e1faf96f253b248c671f70ef8ef", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 642, \"failed\": 31}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 642, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b6e6a8b77bfbc432cd3d705bb838489048427ae1fdd7f0b9c8177da0bf112dee", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"600\" failed=\"17\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 600, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "336c7167da87f5d584fb9975745ba0fc94f733417166ee292196094fae8c817f", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 155 pass, 33 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 155, "failed": 33, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d5a7dda930c6fd5788df76f50411b79321e28957cee0714f9b6aacfb8ac5df7f", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 398 passing, 12 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 398, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a0b2c411310fbdd08dc0d25e2f8d21d2d209d23b1f19a60074f4f6b4b5a34c01", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 32 failures / 535 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 535, "failed": 32, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "83d94060d78cbb7eb8a8040fec7d2baac39885e027c4d3b9dc79e130e76a40b8", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=464 failed=25 err=connection refused recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 464, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "88c3c2e9af0ea41548359857954df5411f57e1f525ae3ccccd18e84af835c7ab", "state": "fix(search): investigate 31 failures (ImportError) after 903 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 903, "failed": 31, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f08af253033e7bfeefff22f3c5a81273ac46859c36c2e09700ffa433c81f4826", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 163\u2713 5\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 163, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "50ba41ca91671fce7311d278ca45ea8d4a4db988f08c59b3efc0a0e7f160df5d", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 824 successes and 17 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 824, "failed": 17, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8aa76eea9aa2d5f6b6b9cc9cf4aac2eac634c777c4843788d040caa8681f1c05", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=911 failed=11 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 911, "failed": 11, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7903e6b03b43d399cdffbb353ca707905c238a98f820ff4d19a59cfe49cadd19", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 714 passing and 28 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 714, "failed": 28, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "838df9b7feb642bd46d6135a6535dfd983a620dcf2c1352315ceb3dffdd3022b", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 36 failures after 965 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 965, "failed": 36, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5faf2d2e2c5a8ee840dc4c7c2fe6b231c8e1c7a8d829c24025ff89d10499fb25", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 338, \"failed\": 14}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 338, "failed": 14, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4e79b2e2050ed405731d187b385dbb198eb0909ccda023090db3f9c0cced7f04", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"815\" failed=\"8\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 815, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "529a3966d8d844f9cdad92f38035a129cf49762a88bf5f477ec40d78b7550e41", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 612 pass, 39 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 612, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "25d60098f6f79c213fa8e28300554bd7c37179fd2b55634a2c5eaef96c4a68db", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 684 passing, 4 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 684, "failed": 4, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b0124bef8e4c710a0c27518b8c364ff2b17fe4dd046e4a1fd1b9fcb6b41cc206", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 31 failures / 836 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 836, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa9bef53ef5f612ef910281c334d0ea7e9d19fa7f1a2cd644e6aab4e9e93c583", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=715 failed=23 err=unexpected null recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 715, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "dd0c1449a3c85ca98397a49b00687a142a1cdfb3ab1ecb5f019b28667f76c97f", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 14 failures (connection refused) after 250 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 250, "failed": 14, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "70182fd4714aadadee38ed285b57df111eaa104d4a6c7c4eec02bee310f2ba19", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 35\u2713 32\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 35, "failed": 32, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2bbcaae728dc59ca7be4b2cd31201c8071de09a5fcc36d6100ec025996ac92cd", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 95 successes and 22 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 95, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3d936365632302bd72ce29f8422283dfb7e567d59c787e717349be425ba44012", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=579 failed=24 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 579, "failed": 24, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d3ee525d3c32c009c3c2e1d660083b651dbbbe0a0460d1931e5113ba0d21f9e3", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 625 passing and 30 failing with timeout. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 625, "failed": 30, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a4f6262b2d9e574e84d8637919555644a2ca7bd64251be01cba01dc17d92414b", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 35 failures after 230 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 230, "failed": 35, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0ff7653e14556d835d6df0fa91ec86ce8dfe90c673748f3659098257f73153df", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 66, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 66, "failed": 37, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5776e94c48356a1242fe9ddfba425a73f7ae99e74477c340bc72aa1e49bf6279", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"729\" failed=\"30\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 729, "failed": 30, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c2396ffb2a46f3b9c38d3c1198a955db598f744e2f09fd735d93919637966fa3", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 600 pass, 19 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 600, "failed": 19, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a39bac3c4f2c0a9fcc68648018cb4263ad6b751fe00dba7743c7271a9f174e53", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 264 passing, 22 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: merged.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 264, "failed": 22, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c4449da46706f27039384030d89855cdb10dfae5bf5b45e7508ae8738fdc1cc", "state": "JIRA-search: 11 failures / 295 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 295, "failed": 11, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "81a5a31fb485d6152ec14cff0ca6b7b11b86ccc9d90f63623825a2ec8bf091db", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=859 failed=30 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 859, "failed": 30, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "02f5fb5232f25bbc7acc64756e505417cc782bff43a89af7b21f2d707a3a484e", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 2 failures (ImportError) after 981 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 981, "failed": 2, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "04c1bf98c80bc689afc8a2bd5e1f32753ab4980565570df20897ffeb3869a339", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 839\u2713 28\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 839, "failed": 28, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bb586b61419c8097615c404d7c870032b5834fa3aa457a4ddad11292cb85e45b", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 310 successes and 38 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 310, "failed": 38, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8f23f8fcbe99d4d2c9d6f6d9455522210afcb9059b005d364dfff7657f4a13cd", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=2 failed=14 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 2, "failed": 14, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e1cfce6abb91263cd2d0936ec4d6f104d6e5d67d908518f1589578eef23a40b4", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 946 passing and 27 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 946, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c41a396e89b225c18cddba0da9b76f8d98e145e9693394439048392c364423e2", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 15 failures after 382 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 382, "failed": 15, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "df3acd531d0c79a381d352a458dcba5e8d9b56dec1da98d0f9fded7b83443d30", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 458, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 458, "failed": 37, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1912ffa8def238607d5744dde1edc6688508345d6114cbde6e7719a664d4f74b", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"700\" failed=\"26\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 700, "failed": 26, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bf537fdce1f6e38babd756884d7b9304477ebea6e9dcd0a7d10e70db4ffb2727", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 390 pass, 16 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 390, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6a34b2ab23950312ed9222c5da9e48da1a2069516e5fe0ecd95ef5d79471a9f5", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 887 passing, 23 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 887, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5d627d562b06921ee67d4516066960affe4f248d75935795af6a1ea8c47df880", "state": "JIRA-search: 9 failures / 178 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 178, "failed": 9, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "053c9e5dbc3f3db8ac23246f4ab2f346bf0ef4ab5f218ee6a3834e5bbf380072", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=412 failed=29 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 412, "failed": 29, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d381618858fd26bf611f8294b8c8acc787a5988314026cc2f87ab3712b266096", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 13 failures (assertion mismatch) after 606 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 606, "failed": 13, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "93b2601dd24a4ca596888f5e85c12757584ee343138b70b8bb73f73914b2f20e", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 668\u2713 27\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 668, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "32df1306bfa1e74fe8bbbe1fa6f1da8185686b26c3bac29e62909fa15f3fbda6", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 824 successes and 23 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 824, "failed": 23, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "88e5bfa88fbb1fe536424ff137b9ecafa40087dfca5d28f4ede5d55f70ecf90c", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=439 failed=7 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 439, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2097e479a20de7552a7da175b6595099630250f4b576026c2c43f523cd532d96", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 137 passing and 13 failing with connection refused. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 137, "failed": 13, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "35bb74e26d4e8353c0965a21dd46ddc4f366abc81c8a71582eedfb8936c8f787", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 23 failures after 945 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 945, "failed": 23, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "54a4287f9f23bd4dc07af62b482d2a0cd0aa98c26f30f879b4c5106486929c40", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 746, \"failed\": 35}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 746, "failed": 35, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "91d91e1b6790972a56cee32dd3cf8d3c2f57a8cc14d8dcedf4eb2743a07a3059", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"316\" failed=\"26\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 316, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0a3ccbdf3c9c4a39339745a9a27de9518dc9eccf24e5db3c6ca6929399d532a0", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 130 pass, 1 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 130, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ad522322b643a71fb105d6edb72bf079bd80054f978edf7d2e34321068346d9c", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 451 passing, 7 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 451, "failed": 7, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5d3ee168fc2a6e20f911b933b2ff84b39601eed765a3a26dc2989e55fa9a2775", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 23 failures / 605 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 605, "failed": 23, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3ced0d129a9d1f5adc180a01ff02c522888a95c56a2bd59005e2086222a3598b", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=895 failed=31 err=unexpected null recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 895, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a74e6deb7dffb222ead5ba71517260676a8cea2e8a18aaaa9e51323f6fef3718", "state": "fix(search): investigate 8 failures (assertion mismatch) after 954 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks pass | approval: approved", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 954, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7d0fddd5ca39494dfb562d4fed1786d03d82f9eb8e67f9136ee7e74547ec3f68", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 995\u2713 37\u2717 (timeout). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 995, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "793265c922f474fe37df3bc322fa1a875db4ce2f8b5d4d250d92370fc52597ab", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 350 successes and 32 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 350, "failed": 32, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "12a9eb8b32671bc8436946197bb496dcdb921f2cafb3908416408c406f5d9b64", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=436 failed=24 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 436, "failed": 24, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "94208775dad023c889c8354104bbd928d1d630e7136e04e21dd325fb4e6b9316", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 536 passing and 7 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 536, "failed": 7, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "51ce779ab7a0a90d175396225bdd6fe9c63426cf4bec4ae793482937af0b8363", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 38 failures after 204 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 204, "failed": 38, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f24d1f4f0a1e09743949868869fcb013f703645dfb63a8b269a5e9ccf436dd7a", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 880, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 880, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b4a5ae52ee24881e03ddaf0a0ea377dc98d9932ec29a6b0d1773677bca92d11c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"924\" failed=\"21\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 924, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7a186f33b33594b5349850f03d9c6d888eccafece9060b567fc5beba06439614", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 372 pass, 18 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 372, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "31429ef4656dd834b95c92ba1524e7a8c3dd82bd5222f3e512cb66adc37b11f9", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 846 passing, 30 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 846, "failed": 30, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "755ea4767b513144043a27e5a0b8818e754d6576b1beec211c495ff0d6dd7c04", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 10 failures / 338 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 338, "failed": 10, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "730135f3ade436d60cd170370e56e0dac355656b7fadc188b37ffb12c6db272a", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=786 failed=19 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 786, "failed": 19, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "52f656e9a72fecfe98617fdaac0233e9c102dca870c2d190d8e0e90fcafeb214", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 28 failures (assertion mismatch) after 903 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 903, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "848c4cb608006704a072a91faea10439838f1f6ee1c1f7af1395e98eafda4165", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 544\u2713 25\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 544, "failed": 25, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "64544affd099eb9a141d7a9d479a7f8e0a737c2151647131046d98bf5c56fac4", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 835 successes and 33 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 835, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "19e40a31c089788128a8149fbd17b0ccade5084c5b3807eec7c51453033efc9b", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=556 failed=23 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 556, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "575101505ab323dc4821e902cbe04f61c8c70c6f28cf39915200212bd1e76905", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 929 passing and 39 failing with connection refused. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 929, "failed": 39, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7c053ed836e51aac8267e2b8014e70c84f66534eaff7ba02abd41ce1ec2ef386", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 27 failures after 626 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 626, "failed": 27, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "00af04b47a3239ee6aad894152ba508ef86906f23d86bb3a3f87d9072cddd1de", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 844, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 844, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5f7a8a145b3c9b1245859f5d50163be4fc72bf4a3b90be692d034988726c43ce", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"803\" failed=\"12\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 803, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "206d5d9bcff2e3ae5904f269fb7df153c3352319c0cd44ab112091e22f849d9a", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 135 pass, 30 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 135, "failed": 30, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5c955d350c2d6e721addf4f564d27f15afba30a9666decb146295243c408f6c3", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 489 passing, 25 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 489, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1dc6bee78943818cc2e74892a7df717ecf60748b0cbeb16e01019d64847faa96", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 5 failures / 574 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 574, "failed": 5, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "301609d45ec92249388c7026dc4a10f9281e9f286fe594b3f8f210c70fef6b84", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=882 failed=7 err=timeout recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 882, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c4512d35999f709f08116923906c3c7391ee27c57caf15a0a2ace83987e99bf3", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 26 failures (connection refused) after 410 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 410, "failed": 26, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "94c13639c203cb35d26e4895ff58dd98113eaa2652a579d90888bd9bcc8a07fe", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 806\u2713 23\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 806, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "45a24cacf2f7062a0405c33e6d9058ae96c5463ec4bed70707ed9a1e1a05b083", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 192 successes and 16 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 192, "failed": 16, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "34669aa4bb2ef079c9c1b3634aa541614abf66733b7721125a3a03860622ef45", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=411 failed=32 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 411, "failed": 32, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a80c760cd42d77507a7453d92f759eff7f85f1279f2056b51b80e5fe29510ba0", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 738 passing and 31 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 738, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b7bb93366fdddcadbabc71564c85805a824d0bdf188706b7a24437b9460fa96d", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 688 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 688, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "203cb6f3eaeb36aedacab7a46994c8733e502811f61038d28341c191c3d31c0b", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 31, \"failed\": 30}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 31, "failed": 30, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "be32d1664c2773d7ab2696a11c6f822d571346f7a661870f620d880771adf481", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"890\" failed=\"12\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 890, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "bbae24f38c60ef00454858fd74ef37f6371d13044165bc88ead359506e24ad7e", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 465 pass, 20 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 465, "failed": 20, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa3af6178d739c3d1633ec24d7a4a64699f00a21435ab6244752183b99c1530f", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 337 passing, 18 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 337, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ab4cc4fdd47d98bf2dc3fc3e0f0074db87fe365424cb7ac2bc044c0defe216c1", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 18 failures / 993 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 993, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4bf950046af5c10cf769d47c433743aca55bb7e7a328a6e2231a938a5adf2ed6", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=503 failed=12 err=unexpected null recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 503, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5bb8261f59ac55ad9b44e2cdede6056ed40ef5addefa8ac7a9067008fde20628", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 16 failures (ImportError) after 825 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: merged", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 825, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4502e74c8f4735199ef89658ca12659d759f2855bfb7831962155b9a4e1a01de", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 143\u2713 17\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 143, "failed": 17, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "047843ae535428cc7741dc38c751baf2b69232bd7d5cc0117a4e858599c8cf22", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 746 successes and 39 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 746, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "185cd6eb460cb63446eea4eccc7669a9d1a05b3afd8a90b667abf89e31d49655", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=51 failed=4 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 51, "failed": 4, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f3a082be525f8caf54d5b484018c761e3c7ecbb848a53d7c9a1677a8f6b14b45", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 473 passing and 11 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 473, "failed": 11, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "24cef8fc832dc8538dd2ecc1d7822e75de5a989ef4ab07be1c926ec476103920", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 5 failures after 217 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 217, "failed": 5, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1891cc9152872de8e4fa941623b02247ca933b21594969cd19ac4fad011fd741", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 762, \"failed\": 10}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 762, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0255afe597196597b5999f27501cde002cbb13824c8e263d1ca8d92322070865", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"259\" failed=\"17\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 259, "failed": 17, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eb1693178f88c9d903cc220df567b23a2a6d6275968212fc85d62776163eb0bb", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 492 pass, 4 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 492, "failed": 4, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c66bec5cdaaf6f8fe97c3d051ca35c918e846d11f1e70678aea0bd7ebb748176", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 187 passing, 14 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 187, "failed": 14, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0babdf3433027f56b401e4b1f76271e8e8804972192240b24272cf701b8fdda2", "state": "JIRA-billing: 17 failures / 309 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 309, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "35e30c0f214ad3a5ef171386fb4eb700238226bbf8c3dbcc1907d85ceab3ddbe", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=573 failed=36 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 573, "failed": 36, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d1e226d6749c3fc779842ba4c16f770df65b9ef2572b6b1fa96819dbcd615598", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 26 failures (timeout) after 912 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 912, "failed": 26, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d7dd0622f9bc5c8d64b6f8fd0ce1d75d7c461b3dc2b0f1ce2f0e7e613cf13325", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 859\u2713 23\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 859, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "661f840635a240fc9164ee3d6beeaab84ff2c34cdcf5ec5fbc059982caacc863", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 923 successes and 17 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 923, "failed": 17, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "695ec1e82e59ec6549bd1af380eaf902a22af8a1666124c8b7f8df176ceb600c", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=460 failed=23 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 460, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e58d92fcd5e2c140addc0ff4975a6dd415998e966fcfed354c2b6df1d5286e2f", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 895 passing and 18 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 895, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "812fccede6b1fee981a49c307e85b1d0857b13bfb88251ddeefa5995bee8eb62", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 14 failures after 282 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 282, "failed": 14, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "fc1c0137fdcc3d3ff913ff0a2ba7d4dc752e6b828d2a21c2a14b81f2712f2495", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 504, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 504, "failed": 5, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7484eb57c1ab6c42a1bb3395982cc4b7c4f2182918dc5c1e11517d6f8d0b2ebf", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"232\" failed=\"19\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 232, "failed": 19, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e7d3f11882eaa2c08dba08ee509a87a96539853c875e3e67f7e838218ac46ec2", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 884 pass, 4 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 884, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "15aa15c0be4b48c2de2e413f504949da775121bbac568ae35108071a5503f3b7", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 315 passing, 6 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 315, "failed": 6, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ec79e4d1c838caaf3ff77a552d2e13ca44cd1242a4358528ca24fc6701569042", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 17 failures / 629 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 629, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b7bf019856a9ff7a1225eb7510d2b2cfb4f8e2b720e4d63cd279371ef0f914b", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=939 failed=28 err=timeout recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 939, "failed": 28, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b2b1c08c21d2ab368fbf5487a454be5302db8e4a2f8de3e49c21d8fbd6441e51", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 4 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 494 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 494, "failed": 4, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "db49c58be598c6ef98fe34e743523a9cb21c511fbec35572c6701386ad07a8c5", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 762\u2713 16\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 762, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "929399dc53256f9fb639ed955b9be36a581b20f08f4f9f2a86b78a7d14f16296", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 781 successes and 1 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 781, "failed": 1, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "31ff899e184c9b744508e6d6ed5035c09d49d726adf313bb95f18d681b751a2f", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=772 failed=2 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 772, "failed": 2, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3447ae45b8438c5c7b8f84d4b1509462592baaecfa557fe37ad2925242c097e5", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 16 passing and 13 failing with ImportError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 16, "failed": 13, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5a989efca1d96d36e7e9e1dc31d8768ae50a23bab15e38bd1545543f586d792d", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 770 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 770, "failed": 10, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fe571be11424587d8550d8a3486ac441f56814ceef085ecdacca73c18b244021", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 155, \"failed\": 39}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 155, "failed": 39, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "af931714009b6e3b586fef1236408d423f3773a5427d376687051da3abad1f69", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"482\" failed=\"17\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 482, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ae84ce864fcefd1d1e9017af3e66fc4b4eef1cf2ee7a1a06d6327c4abfb8d8ba", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 538 pass, 24 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 538, "failed": 24, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ddd24d626d7e0b8c180474127d88764dea9ca52e220c321c81c2ef95986c65b7", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 617 passing, 3 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 617, "failed": 3, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "9e887378ccc993a9763421531e9c36b21aa875fd309e0ca801080b36bb255b25", "state": "JIRA-billing: 12 failures / 156 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 156, "failed": 12, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b7c2ea0c4d308c2c3f0b10c62dedeeb8b22377df5304ddb388758d636bc5616c", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=513 failed=38 err=JWTExpiredError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 513, "failed": 38, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5decfa1340c63805b3a6a6c6d6cd9b4499f936ec5b8f35d2be3bc7aa284e4cc9", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 12 failures (assertion mismatch) after 352 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 352, "failed": 12, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1f93fd502ea1095aeb0f22cbb8881c345f63a1f10c8b9adeb16e1895d037dc31", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 35\u2713 21\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 35, "failed": 21, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "75b149a2a1bda08a615fba4d250f7511927a05a830f31b4fe99d57794d417d8f", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 431 successes and 1 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 431, "failed": 1, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9222ca20ba19ba21ab8af64b3f391210abdc1e03149255901c4385d5111c8ec8", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=130 failed=12 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 130, "failed": 12, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aaf089576fec66dd32b791ffc017f6018bb8ce2b7d627c21d5963e0f87919c2d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 719 passing and 12 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 719, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3a408c5a7cd6062fe8dca2ed87fd7b8326a6db1eb37a93c40d6b1620dfe42aee", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 32 failures after 760 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 760, "failed": 32, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a28ccd51b6f3f2a613c9bea09a1453386fc97213e3e42c47f1fbf96e6532ce4f", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 528, \"failed\": 21}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 528, "failed": 21, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d1a9c97f642039d69a3e81cdae72105402e1c0cf6484b1e44f162fe58f77d71c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"810\" failed=\"21\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 810, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "80598cfbe35f5b2bea8df43e5451c7d21e0c393a5a787b94cde964b65074b426", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 396 pass, 13 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 396, "failed": 13, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "84d1a0d19568fd4c221305089cd7c876a4994294f62d67c6c209151b0bcea7b1", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 811 passing, 31 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 811, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "37e494c27f199668d50b4cb41f2a44d3e16cf6cdd9cca9160d9ee2ae54de3f34", "state": "JIRA-caching: 3 failures / 907 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 907, "failed": 3, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "77d66f16d3788c6993f43d72f4ccc76a7fd1989b8a2e3ef4d69087da0c32a223", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=168 failed=1 err=timeout recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 168, "failed": 1, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9a577254a01312a91cd148477fdb22a1f4352579a67e6081f9773673efc57ea1", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 17 failures (assertion mismatch) after 570 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: merged\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 570, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "214114315c7fe1950230d7fab6fe352b25fdb068c4310b7b0acd0e4a662ba69c", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 526\u2713 18\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 526, "failed": 18, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e7e28fd15481f39bd22fc4b7a8c3fb9776c86bc55fd2f8d8d0fd87b42482b5e5", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 676 successes and 30 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 676, "failed": 30, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "42079225b8ab232a5a334befaa83efbc69db7d52c2641c2ea36833f241d1ea64", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=918 failed=24 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 918, "failed": 24, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8f896d4a8a25b4cf898098c945b8cc054858498556fedc733b4cc572412eb8b5", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 694 passing and 16 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 694, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c111374d8562f7dd4196c11eebaf466bd318b1b81fe7c5f8b8c574433637018", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 4 failures after 534 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 534, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "af099de7cfd31189474e6c6603cba4363e905b9348cbb0409cc5f77a59a41848", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 727, \"failed\": 2}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 727, "failed": 2, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bb07595e7d57f7ecc9dfc94a8c84ccba21735cc935bc2e621f2264afb655f8c4", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"968\" failed=\"15\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 968, "failed": 15, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0c7c539e6a11e0ff1433380ae9e97cfc399f23526c1cc256558d8db82613d702", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 230 pass, 22 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 230, "failed": 22, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1749757cfb72bfc925faacaeaf68a4cf2fe7fa8bc0cadb876c4afe0dcd48b653", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 293 passing, 37 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 293, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dfc0b59fabb702127c27ee51733dbc1f7e96309a05b1e236ec24432316e5f98b", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 12 failures / 44 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 44, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e7e2be80432106d03f10a176a59189e1f3c35a4a51ed8c7bd76ee63b0725e1a4", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=727 failed=10 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 727, "failed": 10, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ab79064e2660116f90afa32901e0afb98fd2ce56bf8e40f83770afc1fae44609", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 7 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 385 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks pass | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 385, "failed": 7, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7a14add6455c0f1451731fb4cc8c188482349a2746385ec466def003b2a3a5f2", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 702\u2713 1\u2717 (timeout). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 702, "failed": 1, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4b22383cbb11c3c9d86859270e7484c215c2dd04ee4252805dae8f0e643406ac", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 863 successes and 27 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 863, "failed": 27, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a2ab9233e86f9b2a13c3fe240488e16052cdb408a20d509ac849fdb3282dcddd", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=874 failed=20 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 874, "failed": 20, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "466d68e83cade7e61fdd160d94a204f00e03a760a5d48a24a2109835f41a8061", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 628 passing and 31 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 628, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2a60529c7662409c9943da0924abc227c06da8e407c12c8f5918eb0ee9a680d9", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 34 failures after 225 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 225, "failed": 34, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "bd8e81329dd385de4f795aadd0d30ddc211f9364b62beab2ba15419baf0ad663", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 958, \"failed\": 26}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 958, "failed": 26, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9ae15b69f11402c6a0ff72eedca1480320799348dad099978ede0bc928eb1e9b", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"472\" failed=\"25\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 472, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f5eea9b1ee9e6f626a62e6666685e8908b79eefb650fdc57de7862f50a6a6a75", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 792 pass, 7 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 792, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1946f46557d3011b8d5bbdcd6200253ac473fa5812c935dc78a52fbea39bf764", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 5 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 5, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e1cc622d87f770b3331c31574bc91be12ce0d2f774c2fd1ed27a954fdcb7afab", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 12 failures / 427 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 427, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c94a6b4d00b15bd223ec2d3a3d1e676e98850585c1205a6993cb4de299647e99", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=229 failed=35 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 229, "failed": 35, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3e84ab88ef59da78990903cf01ce3ba34722c28550a85d9bbf8ebcaa43e7b24e", "state": "fix(search): investigate 34 failures (connection refused) after 325 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: approved", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 325, "failed": 34, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "50222a3ebf9d47e13d312bf7ea7fe04151149b17a2c9928884d2b1a35e48c803", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 404\u2713 15\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 404, "failed": 15, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "00dd8780a796e74602ea95a333ed71ae813e2c5022519c67318b1be56123577e", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 74 successes and 8 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 74, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "65c5235162bbe1e562bc8379c68788c3304102f7b5306cb817e3fd87cf56d5c8", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=456 failed=8 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 456, "failed": 8, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "64ee0135d1aa472b78888753efae333c24f1bc052cb9ff8c8b2b971e89675aa2", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 81 passing and 37 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 81, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c35dfff5a823a46d9432be7be87e59cf305b3ee067d32c213fbf652106ed3b89", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 3 failures after 551 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 551, "failed": 3, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "97222b49731a65b1ab63f5304494597f5493d29778672244fa9a0e17382dd724", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 327, \"failed\": 21}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 327, "failed": 21, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f35efe680e796f2471c67d195bc3b6b4a0f6775b116d2d6b8e1c131c9cdbc6f1", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"393\" failed=\"6\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 393, "failed": 6, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b9f567666718df51234022bcba566de80fb780cc50ba82ec240cb3482c274b2", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 980 pass, 2 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 980, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "64580fe076f2b97c1aca192b1262a03041eddbe2f72fe75f48ef7cc9d48c2d2f", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 869 passing, 29 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 869, "failed": 29, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c7745528b093afc6f608ac8d2b541cbeb3466c6166cb0a5f016f2050e5333553", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 29 failures / 812 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 812, "failed": 29, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8470501de8c047ef4fcb5de52d530ec9870255fee78d5fdf67864d95b2a211dc", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=358 failed=20 err=unexpected null recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 358, "failed": 20, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c19eefaaa37c33aeb8ad529290c31ea8264a0ec61393079a013cf504e1a1f385", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 6 failures (connection refused) after 380 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: merged", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 380, "failed": 6, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "63b1be20527199570e269837ebeaa662cadfb3f3c1ad3d13c376979f8ddf8d1d", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 568\u2713 13\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 568, "failed": 13, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "83f45a2a1875578ab2410da301860fcb2a1b892e40ed26d15e7b14b4d056883f", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 392 successes and 4 failures (timeout). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 392, "failed": 4, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e9da04f3d77d0b3dd9cbc3a6a39a06e9576420827324ddcda413b7ede5ba426d", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=968 failed=33 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 968, "failed": 33, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "040471c612f14b287258962fbdb2c97aabe4f2d82f6323c95123410280989471", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 375 passing and 14 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 375, "failed": 14, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "72f538168b0cc03167460df57ba702e252ccada168595c86b46943c69428539a", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 39 failures after 509 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 509, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "dd85825a16f4d7e9362d99e9835ccdc5e504d8ad229b40ca3d10259f2a77dc9c", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 512, \"failed\": 7}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 512, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f266cc8f2b9839329829c5a7a406a4b478e09852b0dd5c3bd3d3f33070ed867d", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"512\" failed=\"28\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 512, "failed": 28, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1047a47d5efcc260f8aeaa42ba8174e9af3f81089fb1e3fdae4e29e13e3665b5", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 723 pass, 25 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 723, "failed": 25, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "73356fdb4e25974c377bd760b605c67282ebe627363887c1be5c022cba8490b6", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 179 passing, 11 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 179, "failed": 11, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3cc563267f06ec9160300495057e61796801a7608df54ec8213128217bea8fd9", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 17 failures / 667 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 667, "failed": 17, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cdd64d4af0df35c18b467d22adbaf15dc416bf06f40637dcace8a44e69a64d45", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=477 failed=23 err=assertion mismatch recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 477, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9be28f6d5426d953de22808110803d4d486492cdf306f0e503dc254af3e0b762", "state": "fix(search): investigate 8 failures (timeout) after 156 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 156, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3c5fca1a9ce19f5d1eff75c256d516a505700bbea3c435a958153ffd6b517b7b", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 694\u2713 38\u2717 (timeout). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 694, "failed": 38, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6cdc0510b70193ac7ed0d96395cb58195fe29462b4fa8a5f9d5d9d38710a0454", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 144 successes and 17 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 144, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "967a03cc8b0cdd89c3ee07b2902db0b1d77475d91645f0f7dfb057f979d90110", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=373 failed=27 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 373, "failed": 27, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a02d04a057c14e8df9d49f2d2173dd75641fd259f3e753a389e119291e86ed82", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 445 passing and 37 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 445, "failed": 37, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ab362f7bf785112a57e35d324f84a7875535befa95f0658323ffab0d63a558a9", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 26 failures after 458 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 458, "failed": 26, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "31907aa71841ba9a820b14bae328d646de8cb6328e863a2a0814a0c57267a84e", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 879, \"failed\": 14}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 879, "failed": 14, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6f9455ca6c1b69f692379c1f405c8fbd8dcea337f26aaf241c8b20aae40bacc5", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"411\" failed=\"18\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 411, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8823a4b8a0a82c49c40d832f7ef24f8c2ab7bfdd75eaf2b6f5059dcfeb2ebf6c", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 611 pass, 7 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 611, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0c91bd0175815a75adf4c1d95b17e63586f93163a0a897eb396a431c11c24d0b", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 602 passing, 13 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 602, "failed": 13, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e457ee4459c3ba867bb3e1b127c99f915343891b69bd4e62917b3705e099e9a6", "state": "JIRA-caching: 17 failures / 553 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 553, "failed": 17, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b9dac14faebec22a91907230a19ec0cbb279911f4ba2d9cf084481c92e97d763", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=981 failed=18 err=assertion mismatch recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 981, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f04cde7854a622dd1aa6b9f8f5639d3ce99ff2c424f5e89125e58eacb49c118a", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 1 failures (assertion mismatch) after 314 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 314, "failed": 1, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "07773646a204debae62f085061e31d8b04e07edaf73b000f2d76843a5746d529", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 432\u2713 19\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 432, "failed": 19, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "99dc6c65bad50046cc410f19e14d92eb44db63685d4a17823bcfc3feedc0d0d3", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 958 successes and 24 failures (timeout). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 958, "failed": 24, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "59031916fe06d5154abfe851af68531e1a33374c2cbb171244f975d4292e6019", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=835 failed=38 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 835, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c46478ad871d1c30a22d5fe0a74493706b33f2b7456c3372182a27bb7c3612f5", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 848 passing and 11 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 848, "failed": 11, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c6a858c2929e0f58b54c36868659f44693ca5d58adc1f127dfe9c876acc40981", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 594 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 594, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5e0b24ee926f29f41c93757bebfc71ce41e668cd5fbc628bf9d929758fa79477", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 105, \"failed\": 23}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 105, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b0cc3b217f8a9262ee47538b2c0721ffe9220383438513b1bf854102fc14e255", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"592\" failed=\"31\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 592, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "04ff009edd401845e1fbd482c3f754e2c77f95734e322bad75750c78f3ab6526", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 984 pass, 18 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 984, "failed": 18, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "438d76ed02e3409e102aa9550d5f6f688c31db243c898d20b7559c787887d3b5", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 905 passing, 11 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 905, "failed": 11, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6f268680ec0df4c24da19eca2faa3357084dfca97183794541a10f71d70d7a63", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 18 failures / 454 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 454, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b726fcc237da7fe3d669f7e59a633a2ff3aa6fe155d032b02d95382e080ba30d", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=278 failed=31 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 278, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "89d829953e4f859dd8813d0e62e635ad06b2bf2bc5cd1f03653cd38d9eb3c47f", "state": "fix(search): investigate 7 failures (assertion mismatch) after 647 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 647, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "cee31876332e2b4b6482d8df9affa8c3a21464a39458d679d24ee22d7b7a688b", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 885\u2713 16\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 885, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0698abfc62e5aacec40efa578254befd7d69c075cc57568913d260ed4166f5f8", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 229 successes and 7 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 229, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fc7337d5cd4c649dc3154b0a769a0e3aeace447a93ef3b46ccfce46f1c108548", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=868 failed=7 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 868, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b3fa7d69fdb330e62744a2b75302e01a0cb8e6c5fc6548090336ff64b3dc2642", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 90 passing and 22 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 90, "failed": 22, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "85decd8ba847bdad5ef78a83ee27473a7db3a26851a7b8d24a55173b53834f2c", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 12 failures after 367 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 367, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ce053ca60d0042520d5b5c173aeec9faa1343585e1d4d3323dfd3c6a260b79e4", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 821, \"failed\": 25}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 821, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0a888f5daeabe98f6b25e666addbb1b4b660dfae643d74a17d9774efa46163fe", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"302\" failed=\"5\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 302, "failed": 5, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0b3751ba4542ea1daa25b5acd3eeed8faa49b2843fe090f6489ba9f48bc21422", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 114 pass, 18 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 114, "failed": 18, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e789cd9e5b74e77e6ece9048a2578e91a2962e4f5c66f19cdfcd938f2601b400", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 302 passing, 9 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 302, "failed": 9, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9a10ceee136ef840e283e202ca6f8b4d3a89a7587fdcd92ae550cc640389fbbd", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 22 failures / 386 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 386, "failed": 22, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6c4397c195544f7df5ba8abc1d1e727937090f015fadad05359ec6a60aa41367", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=318 failed=2 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 318, "failed": 2, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5a9ca239969662568a2073cf45da96b10eb5b4d97be53703b5ab6afeeadb3233", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 8 failures (unexpected null) after 518 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 518, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8abd1abd6e17eec8453e38008133115a93ce43f72cb0e947145b22a51a5b907a", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 673\u2713 37\u2717 (timeout). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 673, "failed": 37, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "36c26d54d6e3ab8be60df21e108d9cefb5bc885c2d5caa527579b15a460032ab", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 932 successes and 19 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 932, "failed": 19, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e43c421bddcb9a7c8bcf64f9c6f2e1274cc1963bfcde7b4d0c998c39de18a69e", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=588 failed=25 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 588, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "30e783d41a9ceb157515bdaab577cf6447d7f1904f46118e4a8a46596bd17f14", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 197 passing and 21 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 197, "failed": 21, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "44467189bd048070bce1bf5e2ccdec29d2eb39e1fa738930aa2b77a8c58c47b4", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 12 failures after 116 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 116, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "08f599a0bfa37154c7f0349c51895ee2985b52350279f666cf6e07516eeb623c", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 319, \"failed\": 21}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 319, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7b5d28ab8a83f1542e16b347d1bb2a2579c00dce8b825332d88cf82ef46666dc", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"854\" failed=\"38\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 854, "failed": 38, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f144151e0348faa78cf716946310f00e84cb4851d6656ebbc42cf651e3355f2a", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 981 pass, 19 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 981, "failed": 19, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f3e9169abb663791d5514d545b7ce08839a1c3b74c69032a6ed5620dbc523073", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 859 passing, 32 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 859, "failed": 32, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b0a34d947cf15991ee3fbb4fe7859babe180a23c6c2446e4d6606ddf8f6012c", "state": "JIRA-search: 16 failures / 874 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 874, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9717a7c28c17bb0dd9c1728d56420246287c5aacce75da9083c95b50b2488ab7", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=347 failed=6 err=connection refused recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 347, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "df0af9cab581e7c2f4379daa723f583bfc0965b814dae95c7418fb6dcef5a5be", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 32 failures (timeout) after 9 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 9, "failed": 32, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e37d55873b74aa74bf53d1102fec7ca614c7c834b537d96f6e4327159a561760", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 934\u2713 26\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 934, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "efa73aefe9728c26297d7fa7463bf29081b37e9591f8ac3d4793f8361e75e779", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 801 successes and 32 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 801, "failed": 32, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5f202e40fd6277940ece72af233dad5870cd1fb8cd750392948f3f3b6bc8d305", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=947 failed=39 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 947, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "68153cd2361bbde24762a82007612671c55faa167167e705f8e5f70fae058707", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 967 passing and 30 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 967, "failed": 30, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "76fe80b97b6d570d11a432ae2f60df8b50288d28193b13186e336157f58667a6", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 700 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 700, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aa7e8982746a688a85dafdc79b2e10c457d12269b044c2ab50af313530c51269", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 86, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 86, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0df995d7324f27f19745d6bd38651813ebd6c20613bbf1d32a83344416899014", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"102\" failed=\"6\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 102, "failed": 6, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a93cb071877f7d2e1e7145b7fff3e881c26c6fc730ea81f07710ec6ba88ded97", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 228 pass, 19 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 228, "failed": 19, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3b15e8da6e3287976c9b5c24eced39646e608e23ecd385c23deb9e5247ca08f0", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 243 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 243, "failed": 15, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1bd1fd7d0a27190fda6d44ca60796fbe1dc44bb4851c9a662f9d65316a807532", "state": "JIRA-caching: 39 failures / 13 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 13, "failed": 39, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e504a009564e38258bc639bf6dbe8cb1d2c1f43fb39491639668a3e114f6cc29", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=581 failed=25 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 581, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4e831e3acceafbeec04112afbf18ca5455e3ae5a8dc1228e290d15bf856f82be", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 25 failures (ImportError) after 419 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nrevert: merged", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 419, "failed": 25, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d94a34445b600ec144fbaf8ec5eb1b696586efb822aa44e808880ad8f1457bf4", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 447\u2713 16\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 447, "failed": 16, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4242a3235551986d01257530425f25c2ab9ecf44736994c4af83a8cb9bf6b8cc", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 634 successes and 24 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 634, "failed": 24, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a179cedddcd77bfaf3964173bcdbe9969d49077163067a78469ef193f9428e1e", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=136 failed=29 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 136, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a27aecdcbe02085b59c65ea12e2bf7d0024b72ce06a39d408a005356d925363c", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 39 passing and 17 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 39, "failed": 17, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ef7cd9a531a737eb162839185a50d66c35bf2f870cff06b713ab657078577105", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 25 failures after 543 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 543, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f5c5b12e51a133f651c5a521613be4955c059507b46d3f91e465e0bfcf26b4b6", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 117, \"failed\": 32}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 117, "failed": 32, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "08ec5c6f8f51d124089ede5cbaba3f1238d5e3823fb81103a8ef758c1e185c7c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"483\" failed=\"14\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 483, "failed": 14, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "da0da9de38f6dd260715951ea8bf79054b64302fa1221fb9021f07be6ee47e37", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 756 pass, 6 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 756, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c88a433c69ea1db8eb5b2dc1db713696533456f37601a2a308f8f1f46c6dcc6b", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 417 passing, 36 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 417, "failed": 36, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ffc77a6ff0230633c1b56eb960cef69764ec86f32c12a47b511dcd50038f16a0", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 30 failures / 358 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 358, "failed": 30, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "577e581b555f5fdfca7cedcf7efdfee50a84bdd8644b97a2c5e432cc30af91cb", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=51 failed=2 err=timeout recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 51, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a3f4d19905d43c33c996a8a0b7a76b687c52f53e82de3897cd3fc8bed70e0bb8", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 31 failures (assertion mismatch) after 699 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 699, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d10a47221f3660c1a4eb8dab79d34c61bda1d602d6b1fcf1be69efe1ca35bc5d", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 691\u2713 36\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 691, "failed": 36, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b38ff8288cad44a88965e79089023f8baa60395358be8a36b0e128fe949bae4e", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 17 successes and 7 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 17, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4b8aced513a7846baf68795997c36b101595eb937a8ba34d1ea3a127e32d44a6", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=854 failed=28 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 854, "failed": 28, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "78e530ee12d4cb64d5a4ac508eaa3a8951d70a5b00f5d9bd2ae24180ba3e097c", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 70 passing and 34 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 70, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "83ba5ad2a22f8cb09d160e7a2cdc7c46d07dd4ca0628ca3c3dc8161bd756341d", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 17 failures after 134 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 134, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6f595a337acc128469b41a211e8894143a841cf862fcdf17360d7e262d236ffa", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 563, \"failed\": 19}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 563, "failed": 19, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "9367acd37212f3a8295c1c00d25d629d016b4b796d2807f321ffd44fec04fd52", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"677\" failed=\"16\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 677, "failed": 16, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "712cc9bf0370482fa11bfb4d98d305a5b3a9c205cd6d8d346daa15bc0e3032df", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 31 pass, 16 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 31, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3356771a4c7f3debdc6c499562534fbd36b8c30bb7db515945c50bce73d8af27", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 452 passing, 30 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 452, "failed": 30, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "58d3db74fe5cfafea6ec6c72ead68726a26d5cde14db32efb604af8d086b2aed", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 13 failures / 346 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 346, "failed": 13, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bae308c1d24fdc43e06459c1101a56c95538880c36aecba458f728619b3fa47f", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=828 failed=3 err=timeout recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 828, "failed": 3, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e1f18e25763f5d538184b9f49710633afc423321a583d52ac8e0ca6161b2d072", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 28 failures (assertion mismatch) after 21 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 21, "failed": 28, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f732f82f01b860b56fe0cec1b67bc59f7a419ca0dcd386cfad8cc3eb6294ae27", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 779\u2713 36\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 779, "failed": 36, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "67cca3b1b43de276191574b28f16ff79b7042b0186be551885a4347b5152aa92", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 483 successes and 3 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 483, "failed": 3, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f2812b0eeff41ce7c92621d0382389ec4cd4b705b49f5add75115557a9e98fee", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=892 failed=39 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 892, "failed": 39, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "65d9f8c8054ae261567821298b23efaed0de240b44f4d9fabc3253caadb7b052", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 752 passing and 9 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 752, "failed": 9, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "58f882d3fb5db8133361bad3168e6f74bd7bbe19f19eb62b04f98856647a6245", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 12 failures after 545 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 545, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a396068b86acdde948ca2c1118667950428fe0b71b5ac849ccd11dcb3263ba55", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 612, \"failed\": 7}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 612, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bf92fafe37e47c35600cc2a6fb0a2dc958a20e5ce2e8762e2c03b33ce84f617e", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"107\" failed=\"36\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 107, "failed": 36, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b282f44381e562343a7b622648290a92c7c0d456f5a2d8d7b1f03b9b3a9bc4ea", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 947 pass, 7 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 947, "failed": 7, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ab51c51af9bb08f857b69c88f43922831acc3a3d6deb5e6849e62da56e9de218", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 187 passing, 17 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 187, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2c750a24548bb1139c13bbf49fa6fe49a3a8607ccb2baeb6c04d99322f1df2d2", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 28 failures / 538 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 538, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5cd5ec0efd93e7041528cebb6170b9136ad76af27b6ff58510036ec078483f96", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=641 failed=20 err=ImportError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 641, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fb1f887144cace0bebef28e3a3569fa76f507ba667ef959edf5e4d30f15d620d", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 29 failures (unexpected null) after 382 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 382, "failed": 29, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a40141434cbf8102b82d3feed8bef36e6f68d71a6e58602f8242f1aec96f726f", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 63\u2713 15\u2717 (timeout). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 63, "failed": 15, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d4764da59388f383d2cdb52241bffb030cfc77bfb71bb812a0dcdfce409cb507", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 936 successes and 26 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 936, "failed": 26, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8467664277ad2990273d2c28de3e688b25afcb365d02465b4ed17d52cc1cc7f4", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=741 failed=31 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 741, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "93465419ed222e329fb4bda3765aad88792ea123bd5eb31a8c9136441bbef053", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 244 passing and 36 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 244, "failed": 36, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d9ae75b1a6a606bdabc25d28e7cda1f4dd6262b0e6817d65c4630b38256b7a1e", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 3 failures after 693 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 693, "failed": 3, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c726e5e591b03d7f8c5c95635b13ccdd3f7103b2256bc82e5f0ce04e62a45c6a", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 207, \"failed\": 17}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 207, "failed": 17, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "69c4e0b8476202724a96ab41e06f5b2c7a5cfe8cc9179273b8b3e42295e5bbbb", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"433\" failed=\"16\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 433, "failed": 16, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "64108a7747921ae6f1f6deed5421a509430230e9a98f7cb5b485842bfaa0afd6", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 720 pass, 6 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 720, "failed": 6, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4baee12e445da12d93bdab074d16f420b4144e41e7aa2951448aa2c04a065381", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 631 passing, 18 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 631, "failed": 18, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "00de0cb81b8a62f1dc1dced4a2d134307b4190ad6cff6c273e7c370c264de3b6", "state": "JIRA-caching: 19 failures / 607 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 607, "failed": 19, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a5ccce05042702e3050cabc87b7134c7ac74c82d2e093a6731af1bb2f838f223", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=239 failed=15 err=ImportError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 239, "failed": 15, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "45ff30ea80ab86227cb770ed033cb6ff2ccd7ceb654c3b1a7856eb547bd091c7", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 17 failures (unexpected null) after 106 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 106, "failed": 17, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "535d579d2a5dc1d720fb38cf80d957ec60c4bec1c722d8af0216aeed8aae1574", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 414\u2713 17\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 414, "failed": 17, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c1e55cf97321e031dd09e800529e2cc26ba2c4655757a4f0c90168a8f3c46138", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 300 successes and 2 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 300, "failed": 2, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c25ae25e264be2d445541d18a718307f7dfc3ae98a0e0515d99ac77850b6f611", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=86 failed=8 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 86, "failed": 8, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "37c60d9ee83557e5d173ca01e6a3609326e27f970541bca92f8968cee0cfa5c3", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 194 passing and 18 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 194, "failed": 18, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0058a000ce2a108cde66cfd66c84207daa13c62b7a8532beab094df5cf8ee7aa", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 25 failures after 545 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 545, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1c356fd9e8cb71fb062ff71d0a868280ec5157160d9289d68d597c5560fa63ee", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 150, \"failed\": 2}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 150, "failed": 2, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "80436d15925e2a5d37f09d5c8a86915f51b1bbb7372d7045d718ba68b0f807ee", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"877\" failed=\"27\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 877, "failed": 27, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "afa04c4bb0957274f773d66b2bc047de7ce4e07213ed10fbe22e41412220e49f", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 228 pass, 14 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 228, "failed": 14, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e4287c544514142af8b31333d1bf74e0a5373f2ef619e5705e8e66c0ec76390b", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 133 passing, 28 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 133, "failed": 28, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8853d0e57612e533da9ec80ccc006fa0115e692935b68522cca754be1e146b63", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 18 failures / 378 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 378, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c506044ee3d99872e3b50891b5e57bcada89724971dbb70023d2e9e9cc2bd1e", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=549 failed=38 err=JWTExpiredError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 549, "failed": 38, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "72c3402be32fd738a494ca00edf9e04714e2850e1c89c48280d1185df0a5dd57", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 39 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 552 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: approved", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 552, "failed": 39, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ea44b79157bc3dbf70227fff55d06b9cfdb87488456457c3c8eec46cff2c5971", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 188\u2713 17\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 188, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5fbf1cf82cab2df4292bb6e17fb35d3db5d3ff9c9ac70ee0ee351f2185c08bac", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 692 successes and 22 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 692, "failed": 22, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4393d4c68c48024c6248889313e34ebd7420a109d6fe5cf166aa30d71d49f7b8", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=914 failed=4 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 914, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "616adaa5b89b67bbac7f958ff843388f84f04b45c2a110227820131943037c5a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 36 passing and 24 failing with connection refused. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 36, "failed": 24, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b41fb59728f79cee33dae078b5ebc62dc8322b39c9f68ede4e5ac459b92ded21", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 33 failures after 825 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 825, "failed": 33, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4140b203b509075b380df29bc19355a14892dd5ba964f4d6b433eab3e906873b", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 532, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 532, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7db0ba3410cef1cf5eb957163a22dd694a8096fbb250599a822cf7d39e43edd8", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"392\" failed=\"13\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 392, "failed": 13, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "74bc62c2dc2f476118e08017f64475eceae237710aa4abb1926c08f6301463ee", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 238 pass, 17 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 238, "failed": 17, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ce85bac3a2ec2dc5671bf74a9c13913fac73e77b9ce821bc5cf0f17369a90350", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 846 passing, 37 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 846, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f499e23563380e0ce49ba267d3b213709dcfe0ad37852db7222ddad7d4a06422", "state": "JIRA-billing: 31 failures / 105 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 105, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f2178b93b48a2b06666b6299dca668e8ea5e6479ab467c05b4eba8909f5a30b8", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=269 failed=19 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 269, "failed": 19, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "65d9fb69a6aa964d53eb8647372bf3b424deab72803c7fd0f7f8d73bd65392b5", "state": "fix(search): investigate 7 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 552 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: merged", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 552, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8720bf383f643154e2ca61f836eb14f7c2bc93ebcd668cd0eb46263dcb54f9c5", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 738\u2713 15\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 738, "failed": 15, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "89b802e06c49fdc0e6ed53aed9ff20575ec1eb77d436dd409654f34d1c7e60bd", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 222 successes and 25 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 222, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eed892c622b0c968b87eb60be177bba8ccbdd79ae7cf755186e4acd29329db13", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=582 failed=39 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 582, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "befca45d397211c254539a916aeccc28742cf85f111f5c589ad030dae5f80d15", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 677 passing and 2 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 677, "failed": 2, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "43961b9babac662e7d1321e7bd32a3a23a1687c4a308d16f08f1099ee374775a", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 38 failures after 786 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 786, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e2392cb75134638b88b3247aea17115ccf85b6a44595be18b9e5e742a3016ce2", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 110, \"failed\": 10}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 110, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0790b8bba5e5841ec69d3263f2569250481a97576907c7a209a89e285d58f357", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"106\" failed=\"1\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 106, "failed": 1, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d189a7cdd85d70a273ae3e6925423d399af980b58bfd263e157ded5ce9fb1265", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 338 pass, 33 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 338, "failed": 33, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ca5d3658e99197041473aca17438063ccd023a84768fc3587f3b842b73ee257c", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 27 passing, 7 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 27, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "90f1c4a88bb5b2faca55d15a5aa85ec8ee43a2158f765bbf36db036d91a0e3c2", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 24 failures / 437 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 437, "failed": 24, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "55283e89ca2af3748ac5f7adfdf5aa00fabe04af184698825dcd194e3dc1fbfb", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=422 failed=2 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 422, "failed": 2, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e8d7801a418504b40d24363b33eb45f593369531f1f9154735df0c11d6a47612", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 33 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 193 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 193, "failed": 33, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "03c571ef52c9431204b6e650dbe72e38098d3c559fa2c545c1d01b66d2d6258b", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 73\u2713 36\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 73, "failed": 36, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "adfa1ca5e25ff08f49dcb3a152c2b4fed32bf9072baa71a485d013b9b3148166", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 735 successes and 27 failures (timeout). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 735, "failed": 27, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d1f28da57b66fbeb70a3bce86c6293b87975ccb0a3a3c02450cae91859f8ae7c", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=718 failed=34 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 718, "failed": 34, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f01815ada7360c408ab7a3fd5743f3065e41179f28e42f8b8da0a9c50a23c6f6", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 217 passing and 13 failing with ImportError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 217, "failed": 13, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2d72a045784673a7d70175c379a834e6a256a5f41d261788ad77e02c44370a61", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 692 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 692, "failed": 10, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c3701de65a479834d5e3847c79473961f1194d729997e931d0b8f3f9a5f1642e", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 994, \"failed\": 19}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 994, "failed": 19, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8c58b999b7f1d2f8a37f765553cd488ecb1638a2bf9b2cea1b110c57e49c2237", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"597\" failed=\"17\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 597, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "db21ca7f2633be9d644896d727fc946b3859d6714c9ffd47625b7d28e0c9bfba", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 892 pass, 23 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 892, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c76824e4bbc79f27e771994b3d0937bccd296ec61e5716a4fd4d7e1d7dc0aad8", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 198 passing, 8 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 198, "failed": 8, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3b968f46d1b5705420284da65d61926d0cad9377c2ea22000d7efb05f99e7544", "state": "JIRA-caching: 3 failures / 352 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 352, "failed": 3, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "715953d52ad0ea7af5cd1ee5d3cfe6a65be65809add7df97c9c6aa3c846a3355", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=85 failed=5 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 85, "failed": 5, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b67347502e510a6aa1a6d660638cfaf292b6f98836ea9830fcfc978a11bed01", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 15 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 286 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 286, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fe838ab3baeccaec2fd3e03e9359da83db23ca9b96409c80153b84da67dd8450", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 541\u2713 1\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 541, "failed": 1, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8c1378456de4d358a33efb3ce41b921b45e59ac723054e0c6e286e5efa4a18c0", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 312 successes and 5 failures (timeout). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 312, "failed": 5, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "277270ea967f1c709460e6a42986ec8794f76bb8093581f1428c305ef7eab6bc", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=760 failed=16 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 760, "failed": 16, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "51fbcce1774b950d48e5d5e522ceff329168ad53d21c5b94e21b815ada3cc769", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 232 passing and 29 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 232, "failed": 29, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a022d32c1f406cdafca6fc218512019e219864b7ca8270dc36cf932897610312", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 17 failures after 512 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 512, "failed": 17, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e0547e6077c8f111f8caf3c050328f87dc1d3c7e9dfe72021676a2856ed21dba", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 299, \"failed\": 13}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 299, "failed": 13, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4d6de25653920638b99fdbeac1542c8b264fada106469687b8b1edf5fb60ff28", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"487\" failed=\"5\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 487, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "886620c55c4f510b3df1b3481d4aea965b0c06500c828ddb67e93ca49e66b891", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 192 pass, 10 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 192, "failed": 10, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "779294bf2a51d0a742013e217d8fb9d75e8fbbf22fd80d477673f7f930811c73", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 352 passing, 12 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 352, "failed": 12, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cdd6819ee8c55a449aeabd736ec1aaff3e114da2aaf7d1e003d5a5aa4a3ae677", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 33 failures / 830 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 830, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "854cf73b006ba69c854344d4e2ae7d4b25f46a3d16a6296c88098bf1323f08d2", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=819 failed=4 err=JWTExpiredError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 819, "failed": 4, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "efd2a4a986139456fcb6232affb0c532c15442eb6e73253790bbc33956262c0e", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 4 failures (connection refused) after 397 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 397, "failed": 4, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f52aff48955d4ef621441953abc7c904497ad4947c18db5c3ab970a2bbd4a6bc", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 147\u2713 20\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 147, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7ef4f72ddf618448ca4a018bc3e9b2dbc2e929c9df0cf06a1a4609fb798af7c9", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 765 successes and 20 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 765, "failed": 20, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "fa1c6f3d7f340a191b932f7a2b4adf9b88054ad971ee0c141b7af588f2492a3f", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=729 failed=35 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 729, "failed": 35, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "af6e2b562076293c4143b3af11386d1d24e6f3540e0b7985837ccd816118dcb3", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 565 passing and 20 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 565, "failed": 20, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bc6ba6f91a2e81eb7eb00189e348b4727b5ed7c40925fca4263ba8d7c3333817", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 26 failures after 370 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 370, "failed": 26, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "012b88ccc5804a350299486091441ab96a26005ad8bad19c6b7bfe8a4a724ce3", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 442, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 442, "failed": 5, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "72ad40d14d79414d966d0d9e5eefc9ee438768eae5054d350f99df9756f6cb31", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"28\" failed=\"34\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 28, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2bee31c1fdbf6f612325ed12fa792f0470f4a3516de2f4fb943fff4426298506", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 661 pass, 27 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 661, "failed": 27, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0a825e0cb643230f4f7b17b7db78b3c561090c0e5ef9fe3f73ace953d3e5c780", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 956 passing, 20 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 956, "failed": 20, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ddc833a669a550935acbf42d5ec809de72f8bbcefb3e8365aa68f4af2217b875", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 13 failures / 177 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 177, "failed": 13, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6235ca92dfa2582ec47662fb1f47d87323096209438f4642f045ae1c80676bdc", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=287 failed=6 err=connection refused recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 287, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b06dd65ca8ab931da839ca3b51fa65dbb0ce993916be63d018e20f7070aa2076", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 10 failures (assertion mismatch) after 409 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 409, "failed": 10, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ce9ef98c8a9696c9b19a32f9790871e9dc608c4a79be2c58411ddd15b7420d41", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 163\u2713 24\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 163, "failed": 24, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5aa9103eb0abef3713cc2e2f2eaffe767b1ecf30dc47e0eebfb99c62b4e62fc0", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 440 successes and 25 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 440, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "108ff3f83abae6753cea6e0c2f48f9b994f06e93eb7737200d9f5493cf280179", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=350 failed=4 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 350, "failed": 4, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e9a6776e7e42625099ff592aae4ebfacea2e84ac49d1544012def8e27c42ae33", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 331 passing and 23 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 331, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7f654cd4122ed40647f3526f5622eaafed9d20623f30fc68133596f2c8a1ed35", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 25 failures after 880 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 880, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e4f4af3c2eeb4c8189ea612bf742317e53eea5d0bb1151ee1cd1ef6aadf9c385", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 114, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 114, "failed": 37, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "23016849bef7d8f5c0c448c41d1c1110972a7efe917858366e02cda4c5800ba3", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"12\" failed=\"17\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 12, "failed": 17, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d098e7b28d795fa470c78a8ee4b8b057090d797770f2598c360337bc24ccbeb9", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 352 pass, 13 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 352, "failed": 13, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "897597f598a806576102de5cf8b46d6318f43d9b6707257224c13cec28500845", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 653 passing, 10 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 653, "failed": 10, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "81b24ec8bef71ae36932cb4467e2d1f0a90e79e44451b3ca3890bcad0a4b8e92", "state": "JIRA-search: 11 failures / 258 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 258, "failed": 11, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b3888956a2303dba7840121fe437c4a3882b8d10733e69bbfdf175e76516103b", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=737 failed=17 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 737, "failed": 17, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c0ab994c2178c69f2850b14520c97bb7d187f76b0f093d9ad113b7bbcf2fdd4c", "state": "fix(search): investigate 24 failures (assertion mismatch) after 658 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 658, "failed": 24, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e66b0d4e199e1fe3f97a6631932ccf38792b382d75756e8560c68a0af460f027", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 75\u2713 12\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 75, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d9caf254eabc4ace2cfa8217849f43b35a5e1dbf25e8b960dd6aad6345a9ad1d", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 72 successes and 25 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 72, "failed": 25, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5ce90680de087e85595f7c7ad42efe27a2fbf6a048309161bc0b1fef718f3ba3", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=856 failed=32 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 856, "failed": 32, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a409b38171b51e1f5cd7f39f9dc0f206993aeb99c53c9ca3f223daffb71395e8", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 944 passing and 9 failing with ImportError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 944, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4f2a9e937c6de95e71a8c4a1f43a7a72a04738ea5a05ec057832f3d7fdf68110", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 4 failures after 627 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 627, "failed": 4, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "726301a3f2ef840286d471bc0b421725cd36934417c2bdde189cfacc5f5f2864", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 68, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 68, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "19904f015edf139e8a63fe2ed6a6d8294f1fa67b2f7889abb1484fd479fc507e", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"386\" failed=\"17\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 386, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "40d1a0c4d15ed96892521f71d61c59dfc49d571ce8d74409b155c15594ab0430", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 305 pass, 16 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 305, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "881ee28d038a01f487b80fed27b66bf893f2f48278a9b392ba49b8ec945ca868", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 294 passing, 5 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 294, "failed": 5, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "496f7e3c85b23adf00bf7f60b020a1fefdf91e511a0ff76493427ab8425a821d", "state": "JIRA-search: 27 failures / 391 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 391, "failed": 27, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a7be0a417ea17bbb5e139c62dd3a268f9c545bee5275d6fddd61503b8dd683ba", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=238 failed=3 err=ImportError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 238, "failed": 3, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "76da610ba86aeb7ab18c5310f4d559ae4aa72b971b81cc83ed2e32a557bf5884", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 14 failures (ImportError) after 620 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 620, "failed": 14, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2a0246bcd556dc8c13e5cdc189e7e60d591e91b668744263805758f16c9c959d", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 907\u2713 5\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 907, "failed": 5, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c2ce809d767cb3bc3be2bbfc5412b6e7f8b97592d9591f6d3685d92aaed62f72", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 282 successes and 28 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 282, "failed": 28, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0ada0a04431c8858112250798f491cc2b421b12574ac4431a36f15a5270ebaf9", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=935 failed=32 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 935, "failed": 32, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "da1f184caa948d33aa2ca20b051f8075541abf85df8367444dc90f49b33bc27a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 92 passing and 13 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 92, "failed": 13, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3ab7f7b0392c540bd6b7b1f8aa5d148e2251e096ea973565c6308124263d7334", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 32 failures after 5 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 5, "failed": 32, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cfd4ba661070215fd27f3ca655d808fd411a4c41f10f890ae28f57e288c4c554", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 358, \"failed\": 11}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 358, "failed": 11, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d172ca4768cbef4eb05e731f72b29123644cdd829f06069cfb08d12d6c21ba33", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"293\" failed=\"20\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 293, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0af91652d645e1ecf15bead42e5746a594e0e0fcefcb2bcd98641a195a72f71b", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 16 pass, 24 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 16, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8d4c5d66dd9cd41e868eaf94288c397a76e74a07b67246b61c6548183e33437d", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 402 passing, 18 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 402, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4439c4185b3cb22e11c1ffa751b0ae5628801b626f30687a04e87bcd1538d6db", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 9 failures / 993 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 993, "failed": 9, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "57c4609346b3bdb3af756b472c1c69d6937db2b009cc5ad300599104b01176c1", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=479 failed=24 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 479, "failed": 24, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ee2018cd09f2091f3437c2b8ade6b16bd455e0ca237a55119904d2915bd9134a", "state": "fix(search): investigate 34 failures (connection refused) after 727 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 727, "failed": 34, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1fcf021ceee477db1e4ff6412d49f8aa29e84fc25b473f5ee62caed2e27e00a6", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 752\u2713 19\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 752, "failed": 19, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bd7b9a8e8a1d972d9d4ddec6427eecee76bfb8c61826fa2c87b9dbf54b08a3e3", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 751 successes and 22 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 751, "failed": 22, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e58e06fee058d66b8f861d2ce412d0a9721d2fbfa728d130c76767ec2c8c4b49", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=874 failed=3 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 874, "failed": 3, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "760e15ab0a8a016e239dc34506fc59c36ddd5153c540c95611ccd2600e031691", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 915 passing and 15 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 915, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aade65ebcb908859a43d3257ed37727ca1ffe32df8e8fdf1be7e2f2ceca95a20", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 11 failures after 545 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 545, "failed": 11, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3ff79847e3c95e32d6a877e0c2c0f3a03b1706f17e4004e0ff31739aad165c4c", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 396, \"failed\": 15}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 396, "failed": 15, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ff7e98aeee5c930105915615596ddeeedae879000448ca6309f1d2d38f12e307", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"452\" failed=\"26\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 452, "failed": 26, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4ac41d7c47d78dbbffbbcb9ae84888726b5017fee3f520bd8013223ca9e1e7c9", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 226 pass, 20 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 226, "failed": 20, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6e81c329191ab1a090df5a78701e006625f821d9b7b6b00dcc9c57ac678a518c", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 36 passing, 3 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 36, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6b187fdb6596024127e5e055187d0b2f379a1b45923ad143ae06f3e139fd978a", "state": "JIRA-billing: 4 failures / 163 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 163, "failed": 4, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2b66638fb224f04494e57bdfc67293143a71c4f8fb8a5e0772c279d8993be9bf", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=597 failed=3 err=timeout recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 597, "failed": 3, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d80f8cbe063bbb3259ad1478b51a9e70cf6ca2353f1591a62070322da8b48814", "state": "fix(search): investigate 19 failures (ImportError) after 954 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: approved", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 954, "failed": 19, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "08e6d387746def6d38540a5c76702845dc760fec4dea85205c949cfebdb9c56f", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 546\u2713 18\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 546, "failed": 18, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "02498d12b0265404b04c21388fae7a2cf23c2746707bf07b72b50a9260255f83", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 966 successes and 35 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 966, "failed": 35, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bb7391e0dd8135c593bd8a43b850d0aa407a06e32e7b0992f04d3ee59ec738e8", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=28 failed=26 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 28, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "25d2a037ddc9b83f8bc2bc59a50a2d5fe0a1f7eb45ccfb186003ca12ae67181c", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 245 passing and 5 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 245, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d9d3db1aee3980b286038e7a6603eac222a80c206ccc14cd8b423db96eadc18d", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 33 failures after 168 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 168, "failed": 33, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aacf40c7c65f79928fc2dbbeda7e6506c66b7aba0994e843522c353de4cdcb64", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 363, \"failed\": 4}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 363, "failed": 4, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c7291e76736085d84a1f107a3d5d6d4861593fc88b6b2ccfec5b8a48937650e6", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"207\" failed=\"30\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 207, "failed": 30, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "30206fd181f43268fc075569a55fe660048ee20b81e7dadb47f1dfbf9fc45057", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 411 pass, 25 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 411, "failed": 25, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3e0a861f6d7c95f66a186cc84c04ff879b84e7e58a2d9daf3e01b4388aa34ecd", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 305 passing, 21 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: merged.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 305, "failed": 21, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aa92b30a7f1d47be405ca0a58e32a363ac17bc8e83abf81ff3b34ae4f978b83b", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 22 failures / 86 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 86, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "abfdd8d38652d2451d7873f7e22c84e2eac7bddffd70eefbe4fad7ff08a575ce", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=72 failed=7 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 72, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "eb7dc823da90c87b6220ac080931506834025e7374c4303920e6863c09af82b5", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 27 failures (timeout) after 437 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: merged\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 437, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d84486c4e7a53d720eb7893b0008daecd1098a5910607caee538c1b8982aa259", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 76\u2713 18\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 76, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9cd755257b23c3a4888bb5e668ac5a2947e61f5364d06210197153f7f11d7695", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 592 successes and 14 failures (timeout). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 592, "failed": 14, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c2c9c9cc96391fe44fc50d25333817fa4f2d36b1b9cf93158239be9fba45d84e", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=187 failed=33 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 187, "failed": 33, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8359b1921e5662950445d02604122920700ac3c4b8bc6c3ff5454f49eaec7517", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 444 passing and 22 failing with timeout. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 444, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "13f0fd53f05342b2a5ae48c40a54ef24c416fef6bea2a606d85c67d2ee3b98f4", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 7 failures after 720 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 720, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "db641d19ac73092549e38ea6cd19bb270b27b559a7841bc9ce63b2af770e8020", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 677, \"failed\": 7}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 677, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b2fb62b1f39f2364df9e2b9f7bf743140303407a7f9515b3eab39a6eb95517c6", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"693\" failed=\"13\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 693, "failed": 13, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "937f274073fb1fbb3288fb9ccb35e975a878679fa9d09efb4a6845db205e7be0", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 83 pass, 6 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 83, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "01c53b03edb1743c3b033204aaeda4cc15314ba47c57f6dca8660cd4422dba4d", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 284 passing, 31 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 284, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eb9a33a70e73c400ea42dbe6f4d05eb1160efd6d05c9697dae7ca83dc25baf37", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 24 failures / 610 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 610, "failed": 24, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9343f7550918e21d1e6ce7dc0d86a578b48cf1b255a4f8220e46c6f88df8ecb7", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=46 failed=5 err=timeout recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 46, "failed": 5, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "43bd0e943b522f89d903eb7129f0b38d07159e16234846e608c42c29fe58e919", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 22 failures (ImportError) after 467 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 467, "failed": 22, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3eddeec769b3e8e0b86ed1a2cb3abf09dec2bce3201d165e6f685527633716d8", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 811\u2713 17\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 811, "failed": 17, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3942a6b8b1a2f99ef7997c4650b6fab1ae7c5ddc288f01be325d39a4591e87bb", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 147 successes and 4 failures (timeout). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 147, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1fc809d8bfc43eb9fa4a57d230844b2beebd266c0a94ea75b277b7237fda170f", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=851 failed=34 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 851, "failed": 34, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fd5526defff1028a7888e09b30763bc7980aa57405fd41546398e4e4e1edd18d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 642 passing and 4 failing with ImportError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 642, "failed": 4, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d9673d437c7863d1d9607406aafdb7a6c398ddc1dd2ba153657a23fefeb1dfba", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 34 failures after 763 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 763, "failed": 34, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "32ce9ffe5551a5b772c267d7daa21a23c88b3575d4962f5b53b3c14d050fdf27", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 493, \"failed\": 10}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 493, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1d8c0893f1c9eb63f48a155949b1091cc3c792e40cee5685289a2668226d9c3c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"299\" failed=\"28\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 299, "failed": 28, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b5edebca58ad0b75f1d22d311deed1da1af48554a470471edaa5ba88c47acdad", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 980 pass, 4 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 980, "failed": 4, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e2594c76099e5773a0ce4f612deed25bd5e7e929a1efdedb46bd7a1a66a3b1f8", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 843 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 843, "failed": 15, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b0d4d67bd33e466a2564c4b71d68825f5b51b2506ded979be41083b41d485b22", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 13 failures / 949 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 949, "failed": 13, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a994f36f6d623b1ab29313dc3557a7a1047fa030030df975829c4f4a7da5df10", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=8 failed=29 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 8, "failed": 29, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "da7ae4a29e1ca92650ed141242c15aaa5e669abc7599ebbc06e23490cb8d4691", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 38 failures (connection refused) after 646 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 646, "failed": 38, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ca1cfa025678ac6457f92559d366ede6cab4e1cf98302530acf8674f005e8c66", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 788\u2713 39\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 788, "failed": 39, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cae084f848f10f1aae3d91d074913a906ee0a0eb4af188857c80987907b22b28", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 965 successes and 24 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 965, "failed": 24, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2a947bcdb27dc1a63bf9049c15f0750113314c582b351d6afb3b8fd6daee6726", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=245 failed=12 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 245, "failed": 12, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b1bd1912f2b58ec7efe4d82793d2a8d786051293c2d1fb24533e69cfa358a152", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 369 passing and 26 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 369, "failed": 26, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2b178da6100c223a5d9bf63004c3924d16d7a3985b24275d7c3dbc76a682af50", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 34 failures after 935 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 935, "failed": 34, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f89f3bbfa0426a3605bbd38a0ba2775c07c913b640bd9815556912147d1c26c4", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 498, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 498, "failed": 37, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "471dcf8b95a6f0de8a14378c6ffdee2239ff414c5fa864ad07cd48ec666ca68a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"709\" failed=\"11\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 709, "failed": 11, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d1894cebc5cda42db10b4b095706c4c78f39f4ea6cf4543864fd52f66742df8f", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 865 pass, 7 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 865, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d7273c6805e7470be1891601c43dff90f17cbbc1fe12f429e01b3718e895fd11", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 438 passing, 24 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 438, "failed": 24, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ac84f8ffee65d7f641f311599a1f1f31b47983c58d5721216e88c46f02890cad", "state": "JIRA-caching: 23 failures / 654 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 654, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "23eb7cb88cb19e4a8c97ba6c736317a1d79bea6e856dd45ba8589de0909823ed", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=328 failed=15 err=unexpected null recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 328, "failed": 15, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "555324e363a46058c08e47ff8dca9ce50f31195b9fd04ecbeacaecebe80b60c6", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 33 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 904 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 904, "failed": 33, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8ebf62a32967dafb10d9d1ed7ba27eb3c2a40dfe389f47a919c2417b8f229127", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 963\u2713 36\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 963, "failed": 36, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "bf3d1a9609e3b6f2abeffca78202bd48b7d7412ab34e10e2f6b14e0692ca0c91", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 357 successes and 26 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 357, "failed": 26, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "72681077550d229b4046897c995f9d28f51edc1de8a40a8052172979b3a205f9", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=196 failed=28 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 196, "failed": 28, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "60f2d7e9bd2750378e06533720c7840c3a93a4f14b838550c3acc216b75b1334", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 371 passing and 10 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 371, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ac2629bffcbab8cd0987586f7604daa1a9c190e489495b3ad691235b8535188d", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 2 failures after 798 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 798, "failed": 2, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d75f18668b8aa9ac07f283d5ee7d91788c001da15a66eb390da84196151813eb", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 768, \"failed\": 27}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 768, "failed": 27, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eeb89714b6a50b7a171bc52454938e5490510eec0c0b1ea15f8c8b4cb138687a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"20\" failed=\"31\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 20, "failed": 31, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9aa421e75055280c09c98f3ad1e6dad0894b5aca928df42ce97ffd3d4e851f00", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 543 pass, 12 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 543, "failed": 12, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "919c2c0a60722561f14a26a021c1f23a11866edde430e5b5d2594dff111eb290", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 679 passing, 31 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 679, "failed": 31, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "69c66688d7fff0395524ef7115a437739acb0f0d8132bf6683cfcdaac1fd7f39", "state": "JIRA-search: 25 failures / 631 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 631, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "53c8bb6b8fe39c180695fe8c054760686bee9f9dbe09fac479b3d52104467f44", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=955 failed=17 err=JWTExpiredError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 955, "failed": 17, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "73a8085ee1661812864e9f55914f3a77f88fc115f32f7993a3f9fa93afe12890", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 7 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 796 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 796, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3d3bed9b073b3186628ed0abf2aea2c89555d3169880ef56da1e18116fae0e59", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 727\u2713 31\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 727, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fe7a8f73a65e53853f4de2905c03dd8687bf1d5be1139784aaab0eb0e83caa3c", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 461 successes and 2 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 461, "failed": 2, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "81075a853ff0294e12dbe9ee15aba3248122fb0af6be05ff0274238e3b82fde0", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=959 failed=13 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 959, "failed": 13, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "faeaabff88807af01bfd0736e57c331a0f4a26ecb4d02302745150c417a951cb", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 105 passing and 21 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 105, "failed": 21, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "88d46679f63bb1d67e16a8b6187387aace601bf9df9e9e6780d0ab4db8cc58b1", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 30 failures after 834 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 834, "failed": 30, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "05e53bd49961ad7d2c1e38f7efbcdbfd465d3d5e3970638a275803e050f281b3", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 882, \"failed\": 34}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 882, "failed": 34, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "afc71856ce434f063ccca73c7bb73d6d0103240b88712488a1f0f0e3d0c48dda", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"194\" failed=\"27\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 194, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5a3374698320cd8a48c9d9714045fe2e3b48aba4d28232e7e0b06a47b6ba8fc2", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 818 pass, 22 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 818, "failed": 22, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9bcb2157fcc49f016ade1e4735b2ee6b24597f2e5d599b0b791e37338a8fb681", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 424 passing, 16 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 424, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f84cc64ec990c71bb4186c672f39acd036fd8fc48dd06d2aad48ccbcc6f6b514", "state": "JIRA-search: 39 failures / 210 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 210, "failed": 39, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7e3ce47951c28f5f87440d5d62be27ef2d1881af9058efafc380e242013907f7", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=610 failed=37 err=connection refused recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 610, "failed": 37, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1ef96507c6e2a957b25b0322ec4e1a133511a6c0043b7db019c06438eb05a9a4", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 4 failures (assertion mismatch) after 97 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 97, "failed": 4, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d3138b3ab6bbb4c3ce2101a05a85c68cef80ef92af88604c968e4430790ae7f9", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 681\u2713 3\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 681, "failed": 3, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "72b2c4487f0dcc906368747314e448feef8f2b6e2d14d28c2396657c8d1a2268", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 484 successes and 27 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 484, "failed": 27, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "40d5605e97e0dec8ebac226a0ce2077385b55f7d432f5828b69ffbc181b36f0d", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=699 failed=27 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 699, "failed": 27, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8a5eecb16d5fc48341c584c804c5b51e4f3ae3c33a6c5c1cb625fc822b628637", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 828 passing and 12 failing with ImportError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 828, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f137aef1e0fad367837124038fcc4f12d8b87e851a4e79034aa51748aa144640", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 583 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 583, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6559d888af6e7c187dc83aee588709abcfa9d2d5ef8861acea6c7f6d99e4854b", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 290, \"failed\": 34}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 290, "failed": 34, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c21fafb546844dd3e7a7f5a0aa1a85c66565786ba5f34e0af4b7987662738b75", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"88\" failed=\"26\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 88, "failed": 26, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5057da66350aba4d694af7477b7035fe55b4bef7ef45d0b93864092e8c090855", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 122 pass, 4 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 122, "failed": 4, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a1da6d399e3f928a248f91231811e153adb4050399be516b59f9dd442a9a35c2", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 358 passing, 6 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 358, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dbdc544ef174c550a4508854879bc0d99f50e2c236a25a8fe6e5db95a9156c03", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 17 failures / 157 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 157, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6df87c86c7c60875026afd3a8b63494a4d12f7eee328c314789903049358d1e4", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=872 failed=31 err=timeout recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 872, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "274371611a9572e6caf8308c0461c806325c2a628da517081575d1f035b5c5f0", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 37 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 82 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 82, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "da6d373148a4e288e61be62b7ac768556da866a545827f43464eaaf5c8c3e0a4", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 34\u2713 17\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 34, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "16d19084a9ffa4629db1affe4739ed0f8b08b8d92dc5d08ff723decc1b157a75", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 933 successes and 29 failures (timeout). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 933, "failed": 29, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "06a5d21db8fb8047508301c693d5c913fa30ce5b1fa0dd32e181cb8296db7919", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=120 failed=23 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 120, "failed": 23, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e7fcf4d739e940ecbc1160d3ebd98274e9b8d914ad3ccd215fe9c684d6b45d22", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 659 passing and 19 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 659, "failed": 19, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "433678960b109d55dbef7c537fb7fa6dc644cf96736c7b1ffe67f6d04ab67abc", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 39 failures after 160 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 160, "failed": 39, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "592e7d5eddd43b6ad99d5b2199904262fa552cfdbff304009a5d3efd906fff4e", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 369, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 369, "failed": 5, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "905efe9e679121ca05c9b0ab74b2f79b6c4df0d14b9324c34d9d808efe4baefc", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"15\" failed=\"8\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 15, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b4af72a1cc4aa34b9297bd9ca06e591e8b90aac7b92515c71775ed6a208a5f67", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 327 pass, 25 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 327, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "50a8520d0c78b8137a47828ecf7169fe85173fede860c96bc78e63db018e7474", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 814 passing, 21 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 814, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "dc7da27c4d59665763d91e5b3f3d59d4768b74a638b1d4cf47a7a80137aec86f", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 37 failures / 180 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 180, "failed": 37, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "be234c2a0506f7506c3696b528145d584258251827e38a23a0c7777fc4f1b293", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=668 failed=22 err=assertion mismatch recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 668, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "122b8c6c12ff7eb83e9a27ef0d280f857fc4ddbf2a0ea068299f96931b7c05aa", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 39 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 622 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 622, "failed": 39, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "06078b85867b90ebe4ededd8b3d50a0024f63e77f402efa9e026a8b03d01f0c6", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 43\u2713 20\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 43, "failed": 20, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5b63ba792ba9bee3889c9ef15e3b17fbec57689d82545a91784c31d1e264afe6", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 389 successes and 14 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 389, "failed": 14, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "be2b159dc8a8bc2ca7a17e2537e0fccd9fb8ba44730999b97d0066b1db9ceeef", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=613 failed=11 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 613, "failed": 11, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1ae490fb139ee43c142f85251cfac5da3608a68933c332ce68dc89d90bdb7f8b", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 819 passing and 18 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 819, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7ac6b1f48c92becfc3afdc119c11346f8db5f06e3e5be058cfdd8154b9bc600b", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 37 failures after 52 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 52, "failed": 37, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f48661a0557d06db3c1986ae02e00a2d25c35aefcf89de7e18aab931b197802f", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 510, \"failed\": 35}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 510, "failed": 35, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d7034b548fef60bcbeb1ed53f7600176a25d01ab5e3a89768715715f5cd69605", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"801\" failed=\"15\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 801, "failed": 15, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fac4fae7d3cadd0baa3ebc7d896acd63205c1fc788dcce6c1c066e917d1bfd09", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 784 pass, 23 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 784, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1e682ba472b478e6d7edac4bd3766c5246970bcf04641964a5b87245dc688c25", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 665 passing, 5 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 665, "failed": 5, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3a61f1c2dfe8fc9b13bf224657c6639f07377e2c99380091ce74b88fc9ab689b", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 15 failures / 364 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 364, "failed": 15, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "89e9f3d2c7f37fb0663a2f30f82ca6b907d9918326aae94af4cbed99d29b66d8", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=39 failed=11 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 39, "failed": 11, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "044fd7de3e17f6d4d2851da6002ec49b6aea09a56c7942162c764c5784db2325", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 10 failures (connection refused) after 666 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 666, "failed": 10, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "036a3dfa75cfab57ede7662aedb5d039bf1376d9336bd35b7893f127d4011412", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 528\u2713 20\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 528, "failed": 20, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3761cea928cc5afaf8366ab11a5ef9d04ac6693ea173e32bbd39c420a7cfaaf1", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 314 successes and 24 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 314, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "98f28e3872af0c092882ab6f15f46b3372924eb2639ab30089c4d3a58eb7e127", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=779 failed=32 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 779, "failed": 32, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6dcc0461610335cc2c34f4a5876c6e94a26d569667ed1b47e23b2259274a39b2", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 60 passing and 6 failing with timeout. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 60, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "371f970ba00387a61876c272131815cd59a60989285188f647b5894bb6b994aa", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 802 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 802, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "38b09228dac84db2d4157323778a504fda07fb6ac69cdee5796ad01fada27848", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 178, \"failed\": 25}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 178, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6176af8b8cf978a64c5b71ecdd4b5c82d448d1868bb77bdde55076c96886e56c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"965\" failed=\"27\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 965, "failed": 27, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fb3155d0e6e71274673f83d25adf6679529985a8f4c63a10480314edbda861e9", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 316 pass, 10 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 316, "failed": 10, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "01e96121608276ef8579ab1e66e1dff71c8bdecf9f3aa21d797962846af184a4", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 256 passing, 6 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 256, "failed": 6, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b7d50af31814b0d8aed0cf7ce8b8a00a21e5424c0db4172d5f5d2187d774ffca", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 12 failures / 905 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 905, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "452fbfd63df495481df16fdf966d47cab5f8c5af9d231514ca0e838ed0b28a59", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=535 failed=11 err=connection refused recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 535, "failed": 11, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "907aa2ebcd70101ee547a6e991e96900dabd2962e39d0fa2c04c12bebd7bc40d", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 26 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 285 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 285, "failed": 26, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c4d7ea463a7f7a005f155118c24924943598bbefa172c3d787c0aa8882e0c1fa", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 344\u2713 8\u2717 (timeout). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 344, "failed": 8, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "afc2840ddbc3e8397a1f48e86bd3aa41135796b3a7b26410e074d47423cc48ef", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 529 successes and 21 failures (timeout). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 529, "failed": 21, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c693e477fcbdafb73bdbd84a8c82ace141aeb29ebd49147b30a8b3bf4ec48368", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=381 failed=35 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 381, "failed": 35, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f2c3589cb38e4ec90a8c95f05f749b2cdedc4d87a24b0c671ffb0e59e91e990c", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 955 passing and 36 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 955, "failed": 36, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2a60c9e19b37f0109cc54835b3c7cbaa6ab3aa68a7da8dc727855e804dc8f959", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 38 failures after 655 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 655, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "510a7ab63716668a3676a436dc922ca9077ecd683a72db07fcb20740b3df3309", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 412, \"failed\": 23}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 412, "failed": 23, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c8fc86906445932ab8fa55754db7bd2a7295b1ddaaac26b6dfd2b9ebf35e1951", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"839\" failed=\"4\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 839, "failed": 4, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f044b4257d9bcca6cbdf0a907577bd975c68f077dfde60ac5017552840d6719f", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 43 pass, 19 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 43, "failed": 19, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "93e80ccdef7972eadb0f2292f020dee657e16cacff18d49f657efd51d790cf39", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 38 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 38, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b5dd0ba3a2af81fc3879fe20da5e4af6ace7c4146e5bd546c0405b39705beb67", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 4 failures / 522 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 522, "failed": 4, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "32ac99f1251c8b0edabe6b27c07eaf46b9648b972906b0575f51b7327c7ff51e", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=676 failed=22 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 676, "failed": 22, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a25abd40c1349f168dc977ffd0b17a46c8da3cc5007bb9e27044fe52ab9963e5", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 1 failures (unexpected null) after 27 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 27, "failed": 1, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d56745a3e509e5602f2d897c66ca6857e8ac784adc669d1c74cac0dc5b759963", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 367\u2713 13\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 367, "failed": 13, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7a30fae79d5d457019ca6dca70fd44a26a5526d4d3da99974b15958692230ffe", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 333 successes and 29 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 333, "failed": 29, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "923b9e641cc11ea5bd7e473eb6d90582d66878fb57da5174a39916f83fbac650", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=890 failed=32 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 890, "failed": 32, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1f68a9d92368baf2142f95b515493edf874c9c711a2960bee9f28fe1a521cdb5", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 197 passing and 29 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 197, "failed": 29, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fd3e8dd9199842e00fca851dfc11fa7363d9592fa6d5dba820b2e38ad0e5348e", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 14 failures after 696 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 696, "failed": 14, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f4619927d7767afda9234d348c96d5fd8f18f8f71888b7006ef64dc721008958", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 222, \"failed\": 33}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 222, "failed": 33, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "76d28473573eabab7711741391edd17dbff8544f636c5e07f43128ef8f32749c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"134\" failed=\"1\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 134, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fe3794ed706144ad61415ccf9b90d357e035f568f1dda32cdcb4c777a3e992ab", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 318 pass, 17 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 318, "failed": 17, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "54a11ad4485d22e11c2722683460859a3d8e569d22c48a172657a32adf9067c0", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 48 passing, 17 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 48, "failed": 17, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9380d5a294a44514217ed89560824bbd3030552d76faf74ea57b21c8ed25ef8a", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 34 failures / 968 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 968, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ea61d7ed57a6b762b6b23b713c710724f8e59185424fbac1b0a06f092066dd51", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=176 failed=16 err=ImportError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 176, "failed": 16, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d5f0cc889ade02bd63de76b218dc7526e458dbeff120537b4813c0877af91c9f", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 30 failures (timeout) after 969 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 969, "failed": 30, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1f976424145149bd1f84f5cdaa9c142b96199e359db2445ff7ec082e258fb8b1", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 534\u2713 32\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 534, "failed": 32, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6193b6bed3e1b614e88c2121148e33665412562912a07e35de2447f0b6016862", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 171 successes and 24 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 171, "failed": 24, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b383cbf30d72262e63f11aec143ac676aabed958108832b33b9c97ede85478ca", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=303 failed=38 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 303, "failed": 38, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ac267dbc6aabe0033af50db57b2bc7c348330f14ae3ada5f32557ab2459ef52a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 266 passing and 29 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 266, "failed": 29, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a5941f9e692738ff39ca27b8cbee372d7a5a03ae4419aed0836ccc8d63a4c453", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 26 failures after 8 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 8, "failed": 26, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "04958cad3f6ff51d0fc7a4d6098ad0b4ad045aa28a0f8f8d559088af6754dee4", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 446, \"failed\": 20}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 446, "failed": 20, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "985a443df613984507420fedeeafb6e2c4b2f9d956e76b16e5f940b71e6a5dfe", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"539\" failed=\"20\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 539, "failed": 20, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "875ada71c63bbc802e5cf440cf650d0a27b61679038afcea4ddaefaa49434db7", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 822 pass, 31 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 822, "failed": 31, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "75a449ecca80c9b7c92a850cfde9d542467b5dbb774f154fbe3cc034c7d41c18", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 591 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 591, "failed": 15, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1304705943a405fe199735394d220a4a01322ec084da9c3cf340382ec7d27096", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 7 failures / 116 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 116, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "885b032a63d8bee5d3fb88b6af743d2f77574ccdbb0d2febbc80883af94aa156", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=880 failed=6 err=unexpected null recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 880, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7c9de32a9017fd3c9ab5ba8ec7bf3e4c233733e108f569960157a98f0b08f163", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 13 failures (connection refused) after 12 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 12, "failed": 13, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2fbc2a215794a79e5f72db9feb5474f90e7dadcfc660fcde16a9b768a3002614", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 85\u2713 25\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 85, "failed": 25, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8696ed5121f5d24eee1738b60338eec86e3aa3399018858f9fc05c618259f375", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 737 successes and 11 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 737, "failed": 11, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "72708c4d2a9f47cf1d3970d8145db94631d84c9104e16f48d77ef7363689b7a7", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=598 failed=20 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 598, "failed": 20, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d682b4639addc96d6b7485b1a0679990966db816f38f59c4148dc3627a46ccd1", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 110 passing and 8 failing with timeout. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 110, "failed": 8, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e6d02ffe13c7c471bf154f481245061391a2cc4f728607a9f3cd60f033143b14", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 928 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 928, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "52a83699e8866e19b8166e2ce7054623ea8434604f89e7d16a25e68eea2f2e97", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 347, \"failed\": 23}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 347, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "af15b3d924b66ff8fad11a97c7e2a344544f2e5b897ec0a0c5afa7e8b3655a8f", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"705\" failed=\"21\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 705, "failed": 21, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d54f78fcfd6a79a0effb676cd235961746b579b68486f3c534207c8008c5ece3", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 942 pass, 15 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 942, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dd9fa867988aaac23ac2dca5879e18d4fab5818f633cc380eef70c321d9cc547", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 264 passing, 13 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 264, "failed": 13, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7e374b60f42deb3c6958272ba34f44409d8df460d5cb88d324d734611dbd6e2f", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 6 failures / 283 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 283, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6ff7a7635b794d414cab1e093859cade16736dc22a1390b7698f0db27590780c", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=853 failed=24 err=JWTExpiredError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 853, "failed": 24, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b154d1b9a3eefbd6ef9cf3c24f5ad0f8fe9ea21a914a66c352889b7d8be147b3", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 35 failures (timeout) after 712 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nci: checks pass | approval: approved", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 712, "failed": 35, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f5fa023cc1652bcc90f497a9ffbcaebbe1a2bed47fa5ebaec3f9bb170e2cb1b8", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 567\u2713 3\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 567, "failed": 3, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c502617ea0382f2f4a3a1abd4b70ee3ad44a237fb8adddf46244b531dd1149d6", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 56 successes and 14 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 56, "failed": 14, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "57c6659cdceeb2a2e7af1b6e7f4dc9bf7b553a87c9bf573b0ec8f14866b155ab", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=680 failed=29 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 680, "failed": 29, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2391ede7014cde2cfb572b6904c80cdb0ffbfe7601ebed51f197f3c78f4929d2", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 196 passing and 38 failing with timeout. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 196, "failed": 38, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "14286e174f4fecb142ef233b9b1a477e45d997dfe1075080ee433b77b4f8942b", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 37 failures after 467 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 467, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4e612a0b066ad008ae58a6ced3aaaa6345b6737da7b3d1fd2ca30c43a1cd43fa", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 218, \"failed\": 10}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 218, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0e0eb7df22191cabd8320a1bff11b5836a7020775fa440389e6c502d78d2b02a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"62\" failed=\"29\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 62, "failed": 29, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "76afbdd54114dc7cc13fd2f1e5d3954c4d953e53fb02ccf21b2500d2c31c4e4b", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 548 pass, 26 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 548, "failed": 26, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d5538ba1a4b84f4ddd5dd23a9c3ab3d217a58321d38a1e074f51bb9f5c69d894", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 450 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 450, "failed": 33, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1d24751f76443ecdc7643392b6fd1690c96c5dc53d1ea831b9d5b50dd88eab75", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 8 failures / 627 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 627, "failed": 8, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f8fd0803fbfd520035b2fd5347fdb0d7a146650e12d4e30ee412fcd2d84583b1", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=230 failed=31 err=connection refused recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 230, "failed": 31, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "278194b5d7b7ea16da58631157c71003b44bdb072c5df29d89ff1c658d66be80", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 9 failures (assertion mismatch) after 764 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 764, "failed": 9, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "487979b5946cf43ff5182147fedc35c728122080b61a0fd9354bfb2cad3e56e9", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 121\u2713 23\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 121, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "28a243f219bf4e2b06a26dd51379804ee7a389259cd70c6ce198e9f5d60edcdd", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 783 successes and 15 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 783, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c0b167436bc20fd53a7f162522099b36cbb18d8420343613753b85adc54d3d55", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=642 failed=37 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 642, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2d2830175421c37869a39036dc60aa0acd6f709663a301aab7cdb2ea4b11b4c6", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 369 passing and 21 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 369, "failed": 21, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d0427ac11d6af8fe84ec9438096a5751358aee83efcce12af46f0cded3f746f6", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 13 failures after 368 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 368, "failed": 13, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "411fe8860a01bb1ff1af31c7909cecfda5542e5dade62af1a2842ca2e8146514", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 959, \"failed\": 21}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 959, "failed": 21, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ae5296bb0f44f0e3d54920981ea1b96a388be0b2bc2e7f5247fb91b1196e6687", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"411\" failed=\"17\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 411, "failed": 17, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "95154dd69119928ac5ac8afb33666f5f86bf7091e05978b443f692a60a19d693", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 956 pass, 18 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 956, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6a651ce1dca45314f759f286f896da155efc2546a027ada1e55240bfe284192e", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 543 passing, 25 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 543, "failed": 25, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "46a899d83d8a8b2cc67778146313f101d756fd74fc0a1427e5994cee558940da", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 12 failures / 389 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 389, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a637f40f222db8cdb50c6ba8240e7587051a727c967420ed49086d6806547e81", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=441 failed=18 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 441, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "52ff28f68a5bd6c77d2c109e1d6375522eee109777b34de88cabe76962e98d81", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 12 failures (assertion mismatch) after 397 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 397, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fd2f07b756c898fdecd36a1b51cffc5b0998a26494bcd7cb55c0f8672d5b662d", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 259\u2713 16\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 259, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e1a224f9bed955097ac0e5826e0567dfaad31f503064f7c37ef2040ebe7f2ab8", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 715 successes and 19 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 715, "failed": 19, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6066731f6d8a88e725de75477bfa20379d8d8496a7aebeb7ec24884b023c3dff", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=126 failed=11 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 126, "failed": 11, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9a96834cc271e345a285d163416e300854313d2355ad73da553f7f0a9e6190c8", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 797 passing and 3 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 797, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "337be1a5e489bc19947a3fb5cff68b6d48740a857540dcdc091a64b5d8bc5cbe", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 18 failures after 679 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 679, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8f2d334c7949da263ac04609970df6b3505773d073e00f7d58ee96d4f96347b5", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 677, \"failed\": 19}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 677, "failed": 19, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "88780200c0d6803b2dc97aeb2f095c0d981ef572a61318612d989dda0f2bbe1c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"845\" failed=\"17\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 845, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e964b34ce7c494c0aee6e08186302a04b61eafaedd6dd3024ed22efb04e5bc33", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 992 pass, 16 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 992, "failed": 16, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "db2d4028eebefaf758eb0d92315265f4fa8fc00c4cce4c34382bcfc5020135bd", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 721 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 721, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cada27ca29efaebd61c699133729ad6f66a2c865a9dde13e1a11841aebab9170", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 36 failures / 284 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 284, "failed": 36, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "17be1593181584b295c2b2d3e5a5e3e62a305638cda1e758fddb49f98a38e43b", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=926 failed=9 err=unexpected null recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 926, "failed": 9, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "462eec9d9143aa6b5d2b88e696bcd8a30442e472616ad6c84a667b017fac0382", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 2 failures (unexpected null) after 951 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 951, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e360c3e1fc82c92ac90f24a35c0f7f414e0d6bc020479e1cedcb422d23eb4443", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 907\u2713 21\u2717 (timeout). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 907, "failed": 21, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "80aa83a69e10800cd8b9a428c52b77d33c201145e427af69994fc478d16b11d6", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 566 successes and 34 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 566, "failed": 34, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5b11d4b210c74bdc5e228ddfadd15b264c1c97f4602847da92c7b010733e11ba", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=709 failed=35 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 709, "failed": 35, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "77c2ca1ce99051e6335a2bb20e56201aa8b3edc7e34d760a47d183d3a3e44942", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 501 passing and 30 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 501, "failed": 30, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e1584fc0b8d8ee4158eac8ae8107d756459a37e73220a19b37178678e878c5cf", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 30 failures after 204 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 204, "failed": 30, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa46c1daee52dd36f152009c4d8bedceaea7688a77293268e837b6f574c13fed", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 378, \"failed\": 8}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 378, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "bff6bd6df01c2a653487c5c1dda0e3e3fc94cafda042037fa37d10f394717731", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"413\" failed=\"22\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 413, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e624eff9af57b23f918cbc6ee42ee97353f13d060a7765fbb3ca2a6541a8576a", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 661 pass, 11 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 661, "failed": 11, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4c5d74487f3f3fcd83600708b5daa09c0abdc8d3560fccba4fe9b83bab2edb7e", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 549 passing, 31 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 549, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5479f074c37c9f257fc893235052ca8b162a5d8a666aed75c0a01086d505a037", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 26 failures / 707 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 707, "failed": 26, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "fd25e8be3049222d93d945e08403494145060fdcc0af67ef773517832084a745", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=575 failed=18 err=ImportError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 575, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e876b9d189a562a1391f888400d6d3bfa16a0f62fe54ed6f5903b1ca7c508686", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 7 failures (unexpected null) after 87 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 87, "failed": 7, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "009e6c8392dd96b7782eef66401eccfcfac1f90e73db0e3327d59fdb7e7219b7", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 83\u2713 34\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 83, "failed": 34, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fafb4b4e247322c45a4d80e572cd4a347ff683f1c6473afe653ad9e15d47d108", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 427 successes and 34 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 427, "failed": 34, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "22b8d9b57a39707138f3de13c9f3c58e87f0e7fc0981fe04d0383d1ec2ee769b", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=978 failed=21 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 978, "failed": 21, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a19b8d20944daddea72af0668d7ed75d4618ecb82757e4dfe4049bc480c0a321", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 663 passing and 4 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 663, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a1350440fc9eb5dcc9ac4060bef3a4955c50569e98f9ec74e707a333e97dc84c", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 32 failures after 269 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 269, "failed": 32, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "dbea35cfa805f7e3604c7e2198c1afd20262f65dadcafbc9a0b3e709423c6018", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 365, \"failed\": 1}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 365, "failed": 1, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5220fef92d2ac78586794e102a679de5aeb5c467ee26d4c3353750196bd3fdd4", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"18\" failed=\"11\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 18, "failed": 11, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "382e949c7926293f9396d25db851bea1edb7c85931c6d539d593ff5c767d6b30", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 137 pass, 23 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 137, "failed": 23, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2ec931d0804f4ffc852ff138a79e95922a4c32ffd2d3f24a46b1dde43feee119", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 389 passing, 32 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 389, "failed": 32, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "508e7d7975cd31debe0460e0135200f2d6671cbb06fe393111f1d21d9450ccb4", "state": "JIRA-caching: 31 failures / 993 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 993, "failed": 31, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "498e4650364fe146301259f14494977a91767a0f81da28a46bff5647663bebb8", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=255 failed=23 err=connection refused recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 255, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6b11c21a542d190f0ace0e015f82768f723b6e2b2eea9213e9fde87561a8c612", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 32 failures (connection refused) after 733 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks pass | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 733, "failed": 32, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e07288e3576d63486503f476e30d3138583acff5289315447f5cd36cc771827f", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 210\u2713 29\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 210, "failed": 29, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4bf4df13e3ef3ffac90f65d6509d08cac10573dda0769ff3be5ff08c1ab5dadf", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 573 successes and 4 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 573, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fe2ef103a08b7ede1b844053ce69eb6665d2b17cd10271142d81b31668439475", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=746 failed=20 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 746, "failed": 20, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "499c6331923a347748307fe802ef881a22cf6ddd9d50d5a6e8a05cef652cb1c4", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 896 passing and 33 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 896, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bf6fd513da58354ef00c662184e66ed9bd5cdfddf8d2c41f196380a18b903fd4", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 5 failures after 485 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 485, "failed": 5, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f3b9ea82c1af2b6c7133f27178434dc064433f0bfb34de8bb81da1bf001892f1", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 465, \"failed\": 36}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 465, "failed": 36, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "92912a0d779bee889ed1faa8fc1126591e68b87e58da4c28179b1a651749447b", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"417\" failed=\"32\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 417, "failed": 32, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "930e14d9e707e421dcb0444a29cad1d76bc774b9a70d19eb1bf781fa105b64c9", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 433 pass, 5 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 433, "failed": 5, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8e1f9b8b48b8942941554221a9666daa50d301039fa3769986301b10f6c2b782", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 672 passing, 39 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 672, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5eb6e9e15583baadda79d633b8607ef0fe62a3f4f083d97fb417c63e5c01f3c8", "state": "JIRA-search: 16 failures / 555 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 555, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4fc31dd685fb97ed06887c94b05c1e112022f8c3ff4031d9805680118af5e02d", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=724 failed=1 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 724, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "684bbc062b9e1ae6565b90cc380297ea5d136458412e20108d4411ca7cd136c1", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 3 failures (connection refused) after 272 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 272, "failed": 3, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "31047a9de934f2bf6323bdda3125fb1c68e2af482bfe1fd9c6c2e7fc44319035", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 787\u2713 3\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 787, "failed": 3, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d40c008809f6d6360680f25b1f962eece5294ef40afe9ee45a3b69d532eb128a", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 156 successes and 38 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 156, "failed": 38, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d24f5241fadf79477d16ed6e5cfba0482bc0ba0cd6565dd7494bef07bb3e1852", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=168 failed=32 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 168, "failed": 32, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4aad4504b1cc61673da3268807c6bb25a0e83f30a9c854267e0c7b16c1db05d7", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 205 passing and 36 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 205, "failed": 36, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "95dabe656c21ee0df1295ce64c1167217fd68ea0952765fdc8a518b71013dbf8", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 25 failures after 101 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 101, "failed": 25, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f227741c577fad95ef084f05ff91fa899462b5b0b894cb5d65438e778e73fb14", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 334, \"failed\": 1}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 334, "failed": 1, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa5fc417626be226f211fc09063b8e51feebef552d3832c9858ed03153e00bfe", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"675\" failed=\"21\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 675, "failed": 21, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e8fbe4964941831946e6906a869949f061373d164cb56f18cb82b078a88fa792", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 163 pass, 3 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 163, "failed": 3, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "416d36980fb8bc9a0cd0677fa0cf3761735d7cf7b2a40e8fe7de06168f746d52", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 398 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 398, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "58f78deacce1ceee7ee213e590e364f91a63d980c9f00cec9f735605aea32954", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 6 failures / 555 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 555, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "06ea28e8b9103986341ec49484fdea66486d16763883c3b093ceb8d20efb926d", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=166 failed=19 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 166, "failed": 19, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "13dbfea4fa33c9ae79bf77246f9273ae81d32274e25d9ba5e38a7cd276ec0716", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 4 failures (ImportError) after 409 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 409, "failed": 4, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5a6ac9ebc94509141466e639136742372542f7c9aa32c8c579f54c6aacae47fc", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 11\u2713 21\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 11, "failed": 21, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0eebad2ae74276ba974a25f62bfd2e49af29c425c3fa8b9a59358c27ac262d98", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 47 successes and 7 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 47, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "87b909102403a156c020b4d3c37bd9bd25d223fd55210b7b88716865513aa20c", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=146 failed=20 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 146, "failed": 20, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d02c41f947845a4fc1faa12f65a025624213091dcc2daabc318f3dd3b196cb95", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 655 passing and 16 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 655, "failed": 16, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "61b39abf291ade501fac380ba2da5d00ae43fb8ad7ea5490625a205ea85441c6", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 328 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 328, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "33e474b2616a132a2cb93e1f75f1fc945816b2824f009a107041d7b3e1cc2af9", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 926, \"failed\": 9}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 926, "failed": 9, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fb819287f096aff21a1f451e055625ffae118e29660e5e43e584ba4199bdc344", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"500\" failed=\"28\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 500, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c34ebe259b1e74486ceeef9716d91957b7d494464f381c120a130d272b4bf1c1", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 834 pass, 15 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 834, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e792dd6f1988a770fee070107520ea7db4d3deb92cb79401b6260264a9ec78c5", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 172 passing, 24 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 172, "failed": 24, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dcd6295a0a40cc93a9737cf59140e8509ecbb919d373e257ba3016d5762c2981", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 37 failures / 863 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 863, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aeaf738213fdb16f8b99e990d06dcb5a218fc283382657009d4cc8e55c9d2b6a", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=308 failed=4 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 308, "failed": 4, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7a65c22dba924110b4f50a0282a6b697ed6a7cfc7b1ac6b4d8c87272d03ba99d", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 6 failures (assertion mismatch) after 453 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 453, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f23c5c9f481865b61dfcbbdeb242f7eeafadc5a6016eb600c5f918df71e0a456", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 424\u2713 17\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 424, "failed": 17, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e3c28ce6d07fe6e65fc418242860b1bacdd1eafb62541d11f7d8b2b798d4bfec", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 786 successes and 18 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 786, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5b8bac7b45839c85aa7ae87edac34bdd0582b946fbf3a56387307a53f45685bd", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=583 failed=31 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 583, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1bc05da3eb2637cd1a0ebbf944a24de5db46f5aff27af4549211addd576d405d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 218 passing and 21 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 218, "failed": 21, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "728caed0de7e34041b50f66ab2262b31e10a7e39679e4760ab88e86ccfe017bc", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 39 failures after 870 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 870, "failed": 39, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ffcb0e4394200960cdd3fdfd3cbc8f84416cf980a977d5a492f0fdc8cc54ab4f", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 356, \"failed\": 8}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 356, "failed": 8, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "06e9bc9b51b7442f2c68cc32efc92390842acde9ab16a64e3b498b9982a95153", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"208\" failed=\"4\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 208, "failed": 4, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c78bfc6e78f2a7b2fee956b81c768e9f78784587f3898f42d93092c60d320475", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 659 pass, 24 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 659, "failed": 24, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0dae8533dc30bbb5b81c5a88028f43924bd798d382289e2e753972a2464b890a", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 353 passing, 6 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 353, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "71f32001dac45320b61f93bd95fdb477f4a1beaa7653944ee594378919f90c73", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 10 failures / 981 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 981, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3bd60d2841f39b329f1ef9d8382ed0946fe29de0a60f6d347e665c65df9a8547", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=60 failed=19 err=ImportError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 60, "failed": 19, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8d9f4e91d548fafd0eb2029b0ffffd8bf061ba696599eecc5a8c4842ac1ed4c2", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 26 failures (connection refused) after 20 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 20, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a562f1c979880e931a8101d715f099b03135475b4db6c0153d1e8c731121516f", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 882\u2713 33\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 882, "failed": 33, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d78b482acfe63b39d5d482e7e6ec1c442562b76586eba8727c57eb14551ae133", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 253 successes and 31 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 253, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "053fa69350ddec4b8e4aca23623f7d4d68a2a3109c4e93149b7e38cd56f430b8", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=157 failed=25 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 157, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2b83905181452c80f289f06f538dbef5b35567abcc7b4c136354d21a7e52ce8a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 615 passing and 23 failing with ImportError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 615, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "80607b759572d7792dac89bc8b756b9e506e1ef875afdc72aae0d901346e9815", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 7 failures after 406 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 406, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "748281119fe4c9f03f2c60e6e975d189a949714a02b886ffaed18792d7bf39f1", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 616, \"failed\": 13}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 616, "failed": 13, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a690b01aa73d12e52b6b04b9dea7586e99f6c741c3044cd7354859e82e874fad", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"921\" failed=\"32\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 921, "failed": 32, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c5145dac9a2da8f566b15e55f523d8b0186130f74c52e2befa8740b106b542a", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 354 pass, 21 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 354, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "333244061df00e767c7d256262f49897d3cea5f8e8ed0f1369c8d9c7cb7f1176", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 164 passing, 24 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 164, "failed": 24, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c45cd72c2e0c7f620f8024e37f1e041a8351a93ffd4389bc831595963eb83dc7", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 37 failures / 19 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 19, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f6a40991e56a5fcddb793609003f596147dc67845de6b1a49eabc50082d887ae", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=653 failed=9 err=ImportError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 653, "failed": 9, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5b79b98b53988897e0db0dee40d11fdcc1628e07a4ef7a6d9b5917bcee6ee828", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 32 failures (timeout) after 565 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 565, "failed": 32, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a6a4c6526e056243eb18f3b4855eeb4f6a33fd2bde5faf644d24ca13701c6cbb", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 501\u2713 18\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 501, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2f0a0c09cbcfe78630b70349d9adb2aff2ebac84e2d9b55c8f109b63e22743ed", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 369 successes and 33 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 369, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "62c0f84082f250ab43897c22933e3e46fcb3155240e82b6079cf611f14a73bf9", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=255 failed=16 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 255, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "52aa4499bc3cb493fbbe24a53ee9794d7215d7d9d94a9b2df307f9568fd21868", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 225 passing and 10 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 225, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a2b84d89a740acd732b4ce2a0e6147e5e3c64b8291332061d0e66e63de292024", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 5 failures after 947 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 947, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9559d10ff977236906e0bd04f555d01ae54bcecb0d5a49853a57fdd931f62310", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 622, \"failed\": 14}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 622, "failed": 14, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7a8cf371e7d48527b0f3a96ea222444f66f927cd5faaefd613c8340f9fb9a7a2", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"758\" failed=\"26\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 758, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f3de4b8ad9373adc3b7e9fc59de520f9d1ea758b8edea4160460084dd30e17b9", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 441 pass, 7 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 441, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e3a352f4c1e7599f3d651d26029e5bb74ecdaca127fa4c97d24bcd16aaeb16bb", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 567 passing, 29 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 567, "failed": 29, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0a23895d0bc8373eb0f36f35fffdeac402da3c53c12044b469d908cd54287516", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 4 failures / 355 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 355, "failed": 4, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "555919758d4b0dca939e144a25dfef3589b9bf00c38de6cdf333eb997dce6bb9", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=710 failed=18 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 710, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d763b9548b7ea9c72c6bd0725dcf541be1e3118db2ab2536bd0b45933b284eec", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 12 failures (assertion mismatch) after 492 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 492, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fc99db625673eca08bcf63dda36e85bb826709cbf903a414fb4639a8b2562361", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 496\u2713 28\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 496, "failed": 28, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7dd6611ef9ef72ff862dc5adc747b504992ea876abc99c8ad8d73c16599f2f85", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 148 successes and 33 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 148, "failed": 33, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "739764752209c53b780f3b052431218d81bfa3aba0359ca9d245270d268c4b13", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=250 failed=20 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 250, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5b13596f88b76eee6b04f08fc274fb09af5f61a98fde8f0f6d681aea3069b204", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 111 passing and 7 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 111, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "111c663d236245f64a545922eb80cddeaf0ea2fd0ccf56f49f5dcf53149dbf1a", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 20 failures after 593 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 593, "failed": 20, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "da58ab4997b7d474332116c4b0995822b2b87e0d76e8dc09e8af10cdec9d1c3f", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 667, \"failed\": 17}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 667, "failed": 17, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b99d366b7891c2f34b4cc168ac4b0a542d7b73c318a618648eb7438b16fb0f3f", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"677\" failed=\"32\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 677, "failed": 32, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "78536f2a1942cf80f0d96cf813813aa5908b6f84e724225abedcd6e02b33c348", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 667 pass, 19 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 667, "failed": 19, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b7c1ecffdb72ab564da4bbff3b765a91669e08aa751ea218ca9fc12a6b37ee7", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 335 passing, 8 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 335, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e27312339d450878576649aa8c856a62193101c5b23d6f852f6517ed2aa46a48", "state": "JIRA-search: 36 failures / 399 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 399, "failed": 36, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b6afeebf6c78dc9e59e3ecb8efcea06ee3aa1bb36f86b6c0e4151eac6a1cc8fc", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=716 failed=5 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 716, "failed": 5, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dc339aa02027aac80ab9bb2dd36351bb6fd7949fad1f29c7aef3901f60c639f0", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 3 failures (assertion mismatch) after 289 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nrevert: merged\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 289, "failed": 3, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "807a47ca54d0da8fa4970f3f7a24474b0be9b4051063f2f6217d7cd81dfa63f8", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 47\u2713 27\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 47, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a56bea445a428a4eec81cdaffa060432f40c6eb50df471ecb0f316a41a026495", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 715 successes and 1 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 715, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4afc48359ef2369e29d00ff05f67416ed9121d0afc41f4e6922a284a0a4ae89e", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=757 failed=23 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 757, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c3f8507ddf1d77e2a72484ba1c1020aa58092d60457986dbd5d2dcd11c5b179c", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 340 passing and 12 failing with connection refused. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 340, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "116667e202e93d8171a329cfff11df4b6b64a72419bf9e3a86586311f6e2c05f", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 11 failures after 275 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 275, "failed": 11, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "55240a50e167be02da3e17380fa2fe2d20638d531d03f735b369e1ea90063a6e", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 608, \"failed\": 33}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 608, "failed": 33, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d7bdc76da3aa5d635e6bd04896728b578656cd88d63a2842a4669a875167cc69", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"845\" failed=\"15\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 845, "failed": 15, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "586e053e0727057fcbcfe40d04369dea9e1841e68b0cd25c9c11db018f7af98b", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 306 pass, 28 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 306, "failed": 28, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e973c21e24980f85815c910cdcf59ae26ca88545228763ea6acaceedf953e6c3", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 532 passing, 23 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 532, "failed": 23, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "aacd575eead9d3db4dad23d641972743e0131dccd7842f6f31c4b071eb894218", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 33 failures / 40 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 40, "failed": 33, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c04357c907aea1d9c21edbf70b8932dfe0a50fd4c01a080a88dab4efe7c7455c", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=125 failed=9 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 125, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "981443b878231a0944ef4884d5faaaf2fbf8858564ae0f546489b312993d6686", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 2 failures (timeout) after 536 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 536, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "45e5b53014db25f172ba874cc5355bae781ca0b6b67c8300396090b8b1df5695", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 252\u2713 12\u2717 (timeout). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 252, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b91a72bb7223b5e316778df7f4e1d7fb86f91beffae1f32cbfab01df2cc250b7", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 775 successes and 9 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 775, "failed": 9, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "447fd515afd298f98fd8ad0aab03214dfabb55b4309d65743ca842c501abf9dd", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=348 failed=34 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 348, "failed": 34, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "57481c8d86740d857bb3d5663e8bd6e48ec15e0305f347f97c1b710b41f61337", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 725 passing and 12 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 725, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6213b4de6c70f9b412698bd197add721d4b702f28261d1e98fbb0290cebeeacd", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 951 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 951, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "410e53a8bc437691fca53c80938da73c715b89527a4d9b22c5489d5c162a5b2f", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 169, \"failed\": 33}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 169, "failed": 33, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5558dccb87f894940092d67b59126f85ea250b4f776ba1093c7301258f39ff81", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"660\" failed=\"17\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 660, "failed": 17, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0672b6ac18253b14e58d0a9b861355e8e2084977e3e31fe00591ad01b3cd2871", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 711 pass, 20 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 711, "failed": 20, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1e3d3e15d9911f28392bff77ed3aa8a3b7c6c4c249ce52c7242c225300a9d6b2", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 773 passing, 35 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 773, "failed": 35, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d305a69febcbc1dbd72c45606127204cbeb9129b21b730eeaee3b08e7623e391", "state": "JIRA-caching: 4 failures / 166 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 166, "failed": 4, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b2740d0ad53dd3571d62d6f4f687bdb6e5d14a5c5a78d0f985fa809c5ec54e42", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=857 failed=1 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 857, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c725cecff456cc4203c91eca365d9376181a4ae591fba5768a22a4562237af4", "state": "fix(search): investigate 35 failures (connection refused) after 121 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 121, "failed": 35, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "97cac4d8fd4808f9fae68be4750fe76d8fc2ce254591706740aa671d4ad8e9e9", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 377\u2713 25\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 377, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "28c4b31bf3259cee05880d247401cb480658754144dcabe80a29e78ab8909d5d", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 591 successes and 35 failures (timeout). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 591, "failed": 35, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b1c1f81837920d14be4888f23187a1a2d721775be03426ebabb64b091f155cad", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=9 failed=25 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 9, "failed": 25, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eaf4c3c38fbb99e005b5f84c5e7e45dac1a5db14fd500be8e4c2883917292fa8", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 938 passing and 13 failing with timeout. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 938, "failed": 13, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a410a03d5c8ba522d1dafbfcf7aa26e85992466b71d5a0738c0324085145f764", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 11 failures after 369 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 369, "failed": 11, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "94983c8f07596eefd66392d6fbefb5dba180dad58bf34789c8ee4643ad6fc0a2", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 435, \"failed\": 23}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 435, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ad579f9f4cbfcc4f935dd550a9e073fb52f3400d1a227f5e7c7ec956e5d6f418", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"221\" failed=\"27\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 221, "failed": 27, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f744cb36e9db47124cfec2f27d4390ebcfd4e474ced0fc21381e7fcf3a93c284", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 242 pass, 11 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 242, "failed": 11, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6b7e6fe3db87baa1a5df04b6716c5fe614a52aaf96605bc9d318147d4c5ab1fe", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 550 passing, 28 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 550, "failed": 28, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "57dc9afeee0465c68b071914ee87f7f6487fe76631871d9060822936242cd7cf", "state": "JIRA-search: 36 failures / 792 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 792, "failed": 36, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d2716781b19a7737d67c889910a7ef6af690cc1ea2581813c2b7d6b49cab10b6", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=224 failed=32 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 224, "failed": 32, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2c9ca4bed25714c378fc60156baf34787c8a77f348e36a8346dbd963b1c86ff5", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 36 failures (unexpected null) after 827 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 827, "failed": 36, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0c539fb79686f48d4168a8d407be987452ad738a00457c649b1c391c81f99340", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 768\u2713 3\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 768, "failed": 3, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6c28f478d937c03a470cb55d9d07aed3a6c16f45186c8c42561e4aeaf378a727", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 324 successes and 5 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 324, "failed": 5, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9e874b6ee80af52df84e085f41d6d45bfb93b13410f7f0e4c804dc2004fedee9", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=553 failed=35 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 553, "failed": 35, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f1cc98b3cabc355f7115948b311b3e49273ddee7f99c2a70cfbde74f769dd5ec", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 327 passing and 30 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 327, "failed": 30, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b8b0d0e8a47a8b383691d0c73d93f4d51d5756a79531b8a359c98d70ff2c043d", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 287 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 287, "failed": 22, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "34055be011c6abf56b67d1b76060f3f7a0b871f5d03bc5bc55ec730854efc468", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 282, \"failed\": 25}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 282, "failed": 25, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f4bfca4c770f9ee8ebe00155d59d18117710e361bc61ddba13f6b3882c81a98d", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"13\" failed=\"27\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 13, "failed": 27, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8d34518d3b18a5b12ba4f1fb0903c85467ed92902c182fe9d1a3478648ef55b2", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 942 pass, 19 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 942, "failed": 19, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0e40be57f0ba81c6d071ea78465a0e38a4ed9b03d62f42498372ee08842f5254", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 54 passing, 12 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 54, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5af4a3e8b98ef0b5d46cbc42eb548bb67ae75222a77a8c51f279c6b9f57451aa", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 34 failures / 96 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 96, "failed": 34, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2e5e0a336d6478cfa6aebe22d1d40a304a075834fc521695d7544129c63f7de0", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=727 failed=24 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 727, "failed": 24, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0a98b08da75f9256979b412ea11ce51a81a87c346f223a57ed43f2ced33167d3", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 29 failures (unexpected null) after 314 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 314, "failed": 29, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a1f6c4731854982a13cb0ef55d7784b0541be48b1b8d058e9042e3f2444b6272", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 933\u2713 15\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 933, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8a0fa8dac62d57f8901375ece9228329f5dd30954708241d7ca3b51d3ee45238", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 797 successes and 4 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 797, "failed": 4, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dd27060d5693240ef6eedd3f31d4cd4b561bf4d666348933787c0d14701d42e2", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=871 failed=37 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 871, "failed": 37, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a25c1e52b9875a170a8429b675c7cc1d7753c20e4ee7896588c0caa2a3a92dcc", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 365 passing and 5 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 365, "failed": 5, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c0415b7fc9f609ea4af0d773a50457410a08479d60275db2d7785f29d7808f1a", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 3 failures after 89 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 89, "failed": 3, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c9b2c1d3b36ce893eef500b48d1ba29b10dc7576817eff08aac870f3813fee94", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 259, \"failed\": 10}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 259, "failed": 10, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4b58fcf30321155b1edf8a8bf0cee80ec31162936d33707956ad1186b063aec8", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"367\" failed=\"21\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 367, "failed": 21, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d92b40ad078956a37cc2f687e3959574451c78ad2d6e71cd508b2841576de55a", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 548 pass, 35 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 548, "failed": 35, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2a2a7d82a8ad8d8a503b4e7be65bb26273e05c102b246f3d1dc46d2e5593ffe1", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 892 passing, 14 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 892, "failed": 14, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "444f1a1c5f2ad6737f6778226469be246b527217130a300b281e0d882489def5", "state": "JIRA-search: 10 failures / 235 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 235, "failed": 10, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "552cca4c5cfdf254f87828869c11d117a976b6eb5d016806158c30ecef2d26ae", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=754 failed=32 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 754, "failed": 32, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "98ebab69cb8fa347ec51e3a720dbf5dcc2511449d184d09976caad44da80eee4", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 35 failures (unexpected null) after 704 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 704, "failed": 35, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b3e028ad5a94b1a5bd6dfb0ee5424d2717dee7aa970069c2140092861d61106", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 908\u2713 31\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 908, "failed": 31, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "624467166c4cff344236117a95a9af7e3f15c260091c53b1c954ea260576dfc4", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 107 successes and 15 failures (timeout). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 107, "failed": 15, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1cefecafd772961ce663d5157bb308a879330e797cb4ccb7222b7ac61b54f486", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=472 failed=22 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 472, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "afb619ed016146c59f661b4ff119b01db0ef5dc5aae33ed12f6725e216ab3bd6", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 879 passing and 28 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 879, "failed": 28, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "200c4ff6d82ea65be1c22cb6cf8655ed19fd0c893b48c2e161556afa8eea6321", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 609 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 609, "failed": 6, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "97b2b23d71543fcaa100af1cd56c8586bcdad8f07c084601b21349e546436ffa", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 502, \"failed\": 7}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 502, "failed": 7, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7ae96736d187fdf69522d2a5ec4c739aa700117a6ae563d99da904dbf6d0f271", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"178\" failed=\"8\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 178, "failed": 8, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eda5acdaa93e7b61cd4808e872214a1dbdaeed4d485c1ed94f7922edc5576e62", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 956 pass, 23 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 956, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2935ffa7abc3015ddf6e1cdcb491116cb7a0c8790ffbaeea1faeab32d94e06f9", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 362 passing, 12 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 362, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ddd113cd0511700a98937bd86e622d5d2f24f94721f46ce7edd8badc92311236", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 13 failures / 232 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 232, "failed": 13, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ecaa0d1629c6d509f60d3af5e83be7b986e1d2a83807c84d86b42e557af6e6bf", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=665 failed=3 err=assertion mismatch recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 665, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d2b6ad01467fa01f18bd7df6a8b5bc54ec1dd72bd20268dbed61f699d8d0da11", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 19 failures (ImportError) after 479 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 479, "failed": 19, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a6339baf7ca3ab57b46d02b6c717049abf12267845bdbc8831016c7d76fbe7ec", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 90\u2713 7\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 90, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1915e20eb4b645f37b6f4512cdc5bb94589ab638abaeba08555af62b651e7a69", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 102 successes and 39 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 102, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "df9583b75cd921e2110240de0f8a8d5a26b8cbfe0bc7acc5f7f36b5ae2a63c5a", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=673 failed=9 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 673, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d714aae84fc189b7d8af090da6839fadab1c1bb2ac808611cc17358f960645c7", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 464 passing and 15 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 464, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7bc0fbb3ce11c45d90df3eeb392fbae7c417a9cda15f5501af773940f7f29abd", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 839 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 839, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "10c419d2cb977cd46a9ac75680abfac82978b3d1c894e89643c43047083983dd", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 402, \"failed\": 31}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 402, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bde5f2ee43b5218623fd6e406f38026bf69bcf5ac1f0dfb212b758a7e33d679c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"985\" failed=\"11\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 985, "failed": 11, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "587550690fd30ca6988530894c82cca0190625cb9e4edd19ac906b35532c9c41", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 464 pass, 9 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 464, "failed": 9, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d81b0216bed6d44346bf913417e16abc85371e41ce4ef9765d520cb131714f58", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 817 passing, 9 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 817, "failed": 9, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cc33e1f75a2e3e0195e24ec3240d888195da31b19641f8430a4e4e0db7b88333", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 27 failures / 87 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 87, "failed": 27, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ebfde930e46a0fe016d7adbe2f4970d9e2bf8e6698dc9ecd08cd404c70066662", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=343 failed=15 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 343, "failed": 15, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a21477a42d92a96ebecf0980acb68cbc6d902d813314f3d9ada2aad2544f3a44", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 24 failures (connection refused) after 793 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 793, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1c03b57a62f3b5cddb496d3ecb4cbdb130008a8dbea2c2bd0a9f5e12acc35049", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 760\u2713 15\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 760, "failed": 15, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ca6399d8217fd39a1b1802f69710c453cd720b55516379508ab228b2da7c6bbc", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 824 successes and 5 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 824, "failed": 5, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "453b91a5a9654a86270dc22414d951337772f493ccc821441ca07111582bb96c", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=545 failed=13 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 545, "failed": 13, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "90e3ae2505d44b13a7d3a184d8bce96a82c2a3e101c65ea284a1eedcd7a758c2", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 225 passing and 31 failing with connection refused. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 225, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ecfade80eb3657e9d10a51e0ab47ec5298adf3d193e4476348ba7af240564f9a", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 25 failures after 827 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 827, "failed": 25, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8e095f1d11bf5257affc6c6321d8bfa00b95a1059b4c9dd25c8f4563eee7d776", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 372, \"failed\": 25}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 372, "failed": 25, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a634570e6886865818ab323c483e1eaa47dcf9a51138cad793376362b4d5f1b2", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"654\" failed=\"38\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 654, "failed": 38, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7de4beb9bb77a6c57a37f6910b56db73ebae9fe32c1e68c90d06efad48add3ed", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 29 pass, 7 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 29, "failed": 7, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f2fe06b4f54bbb744ca4e61562d0e24991656a82a943d581452cb343ea0f0a06", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 408 passing, 2 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 408, "failed": 2, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "32920060a139051648bac9c782f03ea3a21d8fc272b631c8b22f77b8441410af", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 33 failures / 398 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 398, "failed": 33, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f4de22cc04b0d3fea7a526f085cca2160f138f2609ab54147695b45ff15548cb", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=489 failed=4 err=connection refused recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 489, "failed": 4, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b893a739ed0a0bb43d4a82d5b5f83ed47a9a35d5625bf7dd1d5f7565bbeeeab1", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 29 failures (assertion mismatch) after 281 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 281, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d5fa23bc9720f4e38dad30ba25e1c04aa92d098d114715b478ff8cd2e2913c6e", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 276\u2713 18\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 276, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2cf5ffdf555284b41fc6bd9af4e9e3dec8c2cdd0b1091090fdb59cf65ba2f89b", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 107 successes and 21 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 107, "failed": 21, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "666d510d9b2f2ca4b2b11f031e48677f51b71fd838d08aa5ccfa6c602f6c4056", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=126 failed=4 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 126, "failed": 4, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "cf8ee377a43302e33865915b0132c65f07786884d7fb5eaf94f2ce989290795a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 682 passing and 22 failing with timeout. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 682, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ca37a0c754b3f89aa3f112e7473b64f3399200f2d438fe301ddef4aa5cf9aa98", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 24 failures after 431 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 431, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9f7122f02e775a93de4709b5ed3c5dec5714ddbcfc896b01f21c87fdbba5603b", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 706, \"failed\": 14}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 706, "failed": 14, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "802d4667ac3db735fad38b6afa2c2c3851caf855d3fdc22056761c44b5e8919a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"643\" failed=\"19\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 643, "failed": 19, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aecb201f7e3879ada985c0f318903745563c634208489d6c7bb76b3b7049e9df", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 813 pass, 31 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 813, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "542e50fbd4d2ec2793573444f78b1f9564fbf7057a38a9c6af43000027265716", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 921 passing, 22 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 921, "failed": 22, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b2e848b8d68defd2130ad67ccad228c819a582395d7327043e6cdb524f335e54", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 24 failures / 644 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 644, "failed": 24, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "789505a611214d66bacf26e41ebe23c580cf71fabd8334416976480efe0a1d7d", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=387 failed=18 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 387, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d0be98e7832f022ca7788aba99ae53e45a16caafb6aee347a65959bbd20322d9", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 31 failures (unexpected null) after 444 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: merged", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 444, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "996c24dbbaca722dbd13e919fc3827f1eb6443edeb6ffcc1d9d6128965fcaac2", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 525\u2713 21\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 525, "failed": 21, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8f1c1f832f883c9caf5176574e2bc7f5c4bda1dfe16035c6ab0d8efea6e1bb53", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 677 successes and 20 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 677, "failed": 20, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "23213325552ac23d2717c5dfad220b1b0982a5f5e74ec225b7bd68be97ae42e5", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=50 failed=19 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 50, "failed": 19, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5436acb0d46dfcc7597470af71df0288e2b80c3a9c5940ee6dff25e19bb3d3a3", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 78 passing and 11 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 78, "failed": 11, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d571a52cc6d053d8fb26faa9812d4bb15dd987b9ac473df6733bf7305ebd2010", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 16 failures after 725 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 725, "failed": 16, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9369d4508b10b36ceac68436933f00d7de91205bcbc7d936846cc86252815619", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 491, \"failed\": 39}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 491, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ebfcc30b72ebad6963f3369c10d822928976f955a237d222ccc62107f174053d", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"405\" failed=\"16\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 405, "failed": 16, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "82805d55eafbaeacbc47c78047413e4b8756a306cd6ed21937133c97c3c775b1", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 345 pass, 13 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 345, "failed": 13, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5656171b72170d637269944b71608ce72be84319f038dacf5f83a7216884e873", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 287 passing, 19 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 287, "failed": 19, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "97391deec7f30b7febe9e7cde0ac6640c4f5def52847141ab892eae2d6dfae1b", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 7 failures / 687 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 687, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2a48bab8425427d7bd594bfc5b67a3153d623cb26db46f23db1f0328daed28b1", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=670 failed=7 err=JWTExpiredError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 670, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a71f807e67f0f40ab574d14abc74b520ac4001a425ff3522fc0e1ab330e190d3", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 31 failures (assertion mismatch) after 756 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 756, "failed": 31, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "389a7526aea9880857ee8eb495f98fea3a164a3b2ea67cd3b80d265d35b40b33", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 967\u2713 29\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 967, "failed": 29, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3d55e6c98978b9bdd2966cec2c91426a3beffb039dd4bf948e5bc2d8ad1e0918", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 589 successes and 7 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 589, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "22ac3b93cd29f31d05490d454061ee80c00b6bc2de748985299a6512e39919d2", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=90 failed=10 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 90, "failed": 10, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "637549167938dcf5d8679fe29890716943b17812bbcf78658245806b2ae889f6", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 45 passing and 10 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 45, "failed": 10, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "acdf606f476a48324da377fe5108df59c382fd3e47d6d19783572eeeaeedd110", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 11 failures after 813 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 813, "failed": 11, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "010fd029f18fae04d3babbb50022ed06da4cd8b08278be14514fa85f404a542d", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 988, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 988, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8e9d95f03da87e5da8f072de7392bcd00ea2a0ff5c6c1b849c7785424a50e299", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"174\" failed=\"28\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 174, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "54f0f3470fcc91b0805c24821975cd44948f8ff4cddd97f9b9c114290f659c92", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 644 pass, 24 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 644, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c81a3a12d59368994227982daaaf7b074542d8997668d9425fcfb881a61bdb00", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 464 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 464, "failed": 33, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "936c7c68f0ddb6ff7f5646da1cf93c0c7a038b095cd6bb84ae1dbef9d5fd3e88", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 7 failures / 578 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 578, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4b295dff2f6c9936ca7d1746056927764bc0bc607a25cffbd188085f2eeda58b", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=300 failed=6 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 300, "failed": 6, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "69d4eb373f7b291f86b7cc11119ffb1ffb88345b9550e931ffb9549f2c8df05b", "state": "fix(search): investigate 25 failures (timeout) after 399 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 399, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c8abd85e06528a41d3318757caf37bba9e92a1ec64aebbc7b9c9f7632c6a561c", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 612\u2713 1\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 612, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d70216a44a66944b89e59c08eca853c10ee72736aadad8203e73f29a96be3e37", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 280 successes and 4 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 280, "failed": 4, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b06507347c9b80d68b3f6870b24d69e98979d4d054e6af7d52155cd9b7f0b3a3", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=390 failed=21 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 390, "failed": 21, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c1ac70bc403fdf0558a4aa8db6c1e8dd10563335ba54ed4ec247750e915e1881", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 233 passing and 30 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 233, "failed": 30, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1dafb8b805ea587a57675d23d3f5c6f7d1642d50ad1cf893f84197d79667dfa9", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 30 failures after 990 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 990, "failed": 30, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6126a87155e328544f14dc77701b732f257f2fdfa4a53eeec4ad64fcfc772f85", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 703, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 703, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "770f50b7a2598450cd1468d3dd0a607e78c2db010e03712972258c6157794ab6", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"115\" failed=\"29\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 115, "failed": 29, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "74190d940fc7909ab7b2daf135a103ab15c5c30d8f09c9c59baf3c67091d6178", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 790 pass, 8 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 790, "failed": 8, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bc52da50e834ec60c507f35526836414342da01694a36250a54394dc35606fbe", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 698 passing, 3 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 698, "failed": 3, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4fad2baaeab1ce194e9efa254c54402e8eb49e58656ca8c00bbbbdd3f02222c6", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 32 failures / 634 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 634, "failed": 32, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "944eeba02be4c9f7f4742f95b4e8416790a64d9a740df6dc7d537bbf3c7a60e8", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=756 failed=27 err=assertion mismatch recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 756, "failed": 27, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c65b19c86566b9a8a9c038cb82594656f4dd10e6bf53b4f74fdbc148947b3321", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 1 failures (assertion mismatch) after 952 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 952, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "37d521f0247c29626df1beb63cf424eb9886bce76391a8613d16c25b298ae849", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 1\u2713 2\u2717 (timeout). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 1, "failed": 2, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6683fea557ec05ec5585c5f6a58421e99e9a7659e2f2708d34a17dbea30a965c", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 204 successes and 28 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 204, "failed": 28, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a35efd019c25ab40dc80ad07a27eb25caf57133133f061731aa4ce78c87f4205", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=916 failed=15 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 916, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "094a75f3cc111e039612c944f40fba913b684b5474baebf24b87591553f30fdc", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 531 passing and 31 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 531, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "76c18469e7e365dc15171bd13fec91d988357fe0e268aa44b9e50a83d36df8e8", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 12 failures after 89 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 89, "failed": 12, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5ddcc01a481500aa069b8555d9bcb57abacf5dba87df142e54b4095b0fa3b953", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 346, \"failed\": 23}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 346, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4b929b5ee3e0353dbcaae8d5296f88924101e931959c23c324babdfa22b76845", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"668\" failed=\"39\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 668, "failed": 39, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "59cb4074ccf4cafae711f043da416a4ce4b2956f2a7b5a8cb2ba374343c86df0", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 91 pass, 13 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 91, "failed": 13, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a21f30eaf0d7b5c98eb612ad18b66258cf08079b51a8a4136b2dbb5eadc99a18", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 137 passing, 34 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 137, "failed": 34, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c3db619281a1f3aa82760a005d707bc498df3bd812d6f721a0189c89cab25fe0", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 9 failures / 726 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 726, "failed": 9, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c95314c66e1266c4f3e71d01a01143808679ffd3c063bc79a085f94d294069f5", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=756 failed=23 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 756, "failed": 23, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "76f33bb881f4167b64c0785a1675fc7da3241e8e2d8819421112e518865c4c89", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 20 failures (timeout) after 533 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 533, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5e73d30d6cdc256aa0a28d466cf4b0d9680ade13863da16a96f0364964dfb99a", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 110\u2713 35\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 110, "failed": 35, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "25aace9910444cff62f0582be649c6ece5cf65e76b56c3b05e29d1350f4febe4", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 437 successes and 11 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 437, "failed": 11, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa30ef9ca1628022eb8a61e224921bfd78a377a1a6ab09d35bed00b3d742357e", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=480 failed=1 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 480, "failed": 1, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "640f7b9ee569691b426980d58d8b58effe7bc9554dcc6e247b887c31e685b467", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 333 passing and 35 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 333, "failed": 35, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "73f3760755b0c4d079e9edcf32f8ab3c0672d9184fb9c986f4416a06b886e3ba", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 4 failures after 877 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 877, "failed": 4, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eb0a8d60c986f30918be507fd212ee149aef4885cddc18f9ac9b5e0a34d3b6f7", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 355, \"failed\": 27}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 355, "failed": 27, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cb5c979650e9f7d85a81be3f3b2d25ebc133538463d8c531625ad1519ebbac4c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"757\" failed=\"37\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 757, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c0b7b3739855dbaa52aced192a55d1351959e22cbe49172444298721729ed6ed", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 363 pass, 39 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 363, "failed": 39, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b83101984c263959daa34ee041dbb3f0be46291c6b60cd71be7d265605f0fc2", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 403 passing, 4 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 403, "failed": 4, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "25e5f14a2cc7df965f8d5f2081f53b4e10ce176c5646e11c9188030ada15575b", "state": "JIRA-search: 29 failures / 644 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 644, "failed": 29, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1cec3e88cf0ff526d96c73b6337b761188ca33196ace528e7ddb271de2230962", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=392 failed=27 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 392, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "59dadd583cab6de5a542a00537e443224644e8570dedf135dec882c755049daf", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 12 failures (unexpected null) after 427 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 427, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5c0753c4c1e4695f83708c12cadec1dd35b06d92a7879f0c7f1c624e4b0d9c2c", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 835\u2713 10\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 835, "failed": 10, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ee87f3be8581bfc835bc8535e9fd8371c0cfebbe5b7515954ad8501a2857ceac", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 544 successes and 25 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 544, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3e5de96005bc090258ea7ce70518a793833070c4202f6cb63eedac186ff72584", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=622 failed=27 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 622, "failed": 27, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d9c4a6109cc204fa0c50fe01b2f72d9d12ad9d314ab63ac34275ee9e6953eae6", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 804 passing and 28 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 804, "failed": 28, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bed5481cbae60ba2dfc73ad5542647a53066c36408c3d97c5eedc8d65270975a", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 698 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 698, "failed": 22, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c463ba1823387403703e49a714da4911f8d207aa0c0eddf0534218511f0551ca", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 593, \"failed\": 13}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 593, "failed": 13, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e8d49adf81ec230864f1bca2ff33798e9a776800b4a7c8da56317c2e025a77a3", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"37\" failed=\"15\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 37, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a0e0954e3c5d1e2919919bf20838a246b4d626d2fe4de3f404e6b157fd8919ec", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 1 pass, 38 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 1, "failed": 38, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a6984f3a2f182d1a5acfcb7978ad081993419e0b3cba942f7c5b7e6fc1dd8486", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 195 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 195, "failed": 15, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3988f0cdfd17becd5c609c3292922bae3d89b3e53f752c526d2ed2447d156c8e", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 37 failures / 472 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 472, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "97359acc59f86f27fa61cee28a6e2bc392d3c9169ea0490f9dd3ea7f83386867", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=326 failed=25 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 326, "failed": 25, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ee3ec92dfaca37dda183ced5b20bf693f1eb672a4e96e685d971ec0134a78884", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 22 failures (timeout) after 555 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 555, "failed": 22, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cb7f98c3865f51e2b751b07a0e0f47c8239acbc37d6a08370211112ecdf79d88", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 3\u2713 29\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 3, "failed": 29, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c31d69745b3870b31a19f26eaf817cf94ae5bfb230eb69f3e801a998fb8c74e6", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 397 successes and 21 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 397, "failed": 21, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "66dd3fb9dd5d6252247c3ce330fecf3d1a89fbf2bb326b58c3498869ffe27dc7", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=527 failed=23 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 527, "failed": 23, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "21e9012c260b8a0c8fc2853d5baa25417cdb0993e234977e9dcd5d783fbaaa74", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 60 passing and 39 failing with timeout. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 60, "failed": 39, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "44c42865cb0dea5445274885a70b83c7639a2cb29a0fb3941674da3272e39a71", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 72 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 72, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "542138b6fd9a69199e4c83b909184f41875a16c8e4968853d64ac943cdc85ad3", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 205, \"failed\": 27}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 205, "failed": 27, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b1f22c734f644b688d1633738b49cc59bd73384dee149cf63ece5eb110d67a45", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"681\" failed=\"1\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 681, "failed": 1, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6c369d187f81b332b31358396d8681e6bbeb7a31ce2d8dd4b60af7da05db55b3", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 132 pass, 9 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 132, "failed": 9, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "12ad70d31bab0411073bebb5afd6f0817a5eca4392cf24cab24002f22e5b51a1", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 330 passing, 39 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 330, "failed": 39, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "85c678d957361fbd7593d162e4cf5fdceff12c74c021fe73b19537a702445746", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 14 failures / 386 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 386, "failed": 14, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d004e11485d92bee2115acb889f4e2be986eadb890d6ed5c6529cf513d6bbb7e", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=722 failed=34 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 722, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "945e1c5532ae9926a7f118b416db817529f9c8f22f5441a0cb6f4bd6e3fdefa7", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 10 failures (unexpected null) after 160 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 160, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a7eb7f2dba912da226e8f164b704377976ae810978118efaef399a7bab6b0cf8", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 10\u2713 5\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 10, "failed": 5, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6b00af7d8da42b004c402594db61c63a6b774f596c535a142128a41c6f62b0dc", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 322 successes and 36 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 322, "failed": 36, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "10a5bfde07f8c45c4bf5b5e3294b3e61e3b0daebd8040f0a78bd9f86695d8fb4", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=700 failed=8 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 700, "failed": 8, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aa93dda63d70e99c7feed56c0e5de2e147d8393ce93e37c5925ef36ebebf47c0", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 851 passing and 9 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 851, "failed": 9, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fbfd0a60aec0735a61fc34a6358d90b9bddffc7408bd2e380720d8b2dc3a8ed1", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 12 failures after 60 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 60, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d27ed07dc16eca6bb0d95a0e936edab9825507a77944557e81c74476d9360674", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 928, \"failed\": 33}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 928, "failed": 33, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ea51691f1801bdd61df9ccf9b848ef1d4fd05b1f181437a9f5abe97fb65c4a68", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"126\" failed=\"38\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 126, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0b800b0ecc70c7e7f882076b9486fcf9293514742fa5296b66f00ae4ff3c8054", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 648 pass, 25 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 648, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a6ad31931e176f3aa3d571f49d3b0eb7d443dced3f581f9ed80159a9ae60ae24", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 476 passing, 38 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 476, "failed": 38, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ccf04b7c64587493934645988056a4fcb325d6eeeb2aff6867f8e670692a8482", "state": "JIRA-billing: 2 failures / 678 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 678, "failed": 2, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dc1d7b94cbe2b75b3fb37d2841cee05525c8c9cd6ecb7f969e59a81763f31a77", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=389 failed=18 err=JWTExpiredError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 389, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "462ca7c70b29fa89e45a75eb59f619ae863252754248a9683e1ca78af09f73b1", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 17 failures (unexpected null) after 925 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 925, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "edb274e3c48c8aa4bb4cba53d0cafe581e45ce74e51d09a49f6f61a2dfce6d6e", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 77\u2713 33\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 77, "failed": 33, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "555dfd0dd256b57320cd6d77413e3a768da4b8840e18ff16470751640fd81636", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 26 successes and 15 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 26, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ef09c998acfae8e4f53774e191abd65842b362db012a832c77ad0290b766356d", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=779 failed=8 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 779, "failed": 8, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8cf90b8302bba8b332ae30c494379169752ef69b642e0ee509f30c5e140eee7d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 791 passing and 37 failing with connection refused. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 791, "failed": 37, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e82bc3bb4e4ee9ee503f3bf5d8c73df5cba622eb4d8edf2b7e6900f5789d844c", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 4 failures after 906 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 906, "failed": 4, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3f1e2ebab0c51922bd291a84b5c0ba26836a491c6850167d7ca781e41d363783", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 968, \"failed\": 34}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 968, "failed": 34, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4b117c4279c673b7847b05e752bf020cae35b099a322a5690b5c0cbc3b033854", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"106\" failed=\"18\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 106, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1387942692f288e1aaec86d561f270a0124032a7c6c579ddadb351764f8f895c", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 112 pass, 6 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 112, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8e409a791e03f76238b689ad5a2ce2ba5b53cb85fcec7d1ab01429a62284e495", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 226 passing, 16 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 226, "failed": 16, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "79c1a8587fc88511018bd710a204f329857ead4c4344ef07001259da9dee74ca", "state": "JIRA-search: 6 failures / 101 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 101, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d3504647f6013019852f70384061fa96b9142cdd415129f19fca755edac5e84d", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=135 failed=24 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 135, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9a3490997c3b192110fbe6cfe91284462cac340af052f79b21439dcbafe6e2b6", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 8 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 606 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 606, "failed": 8, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e742fa0cc51b055e5fb2fefc63c42348924550358263088ba9607c4fac2821b4", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 761\u2713 29\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 761, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bb1f6ace4989d4d616be0aa6d152258f61fad2f23916bf45c2c633491c83b658", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 316 successes and 35 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 316, "failed": 35, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8d54133c8a1628bef388a4f3aabde9f0a9c3f6bfd7465e0fe6b77f2f124e9744", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=187 failed=36 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 187, "failed": 36, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a01b068e3439f0f2c4d159643bd673fcebacec18e0c9b9e8796c01e4b4bb836f", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 90 passing and 39 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 90, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "695e94bd9ae9a9199958945fc8060cd0624268aef65ad860a1c30c7f5abb6f84", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 19 failures after 759 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 759, "failed": 19, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "37b9fc0443670fde331f777c93b820c3affd43c61d04f2039e3d1732f718825d", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 578, \"failed\": 8}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 578, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "028a8c9181b14e9b5b4010f90aa55bb14e30bcaee690a377810589d267cb9384", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"588\" failed=\"16\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 588, "failed": 16, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e0b020928ff8f9e909f899c74ebc283427edaa975f05f43df2fe7f90519054c0", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 373 pass, 39 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 373, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "778b6446627087f9281977006bd84a130fec8f309020b1900a6b74e7c2d64c2c", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 2 passing, 27 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 2, "failed": 27, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f8430506c20c9dc242b80739be60f504d0e67bdbb7bac03d6649b8a05093e8b6", "state": "JIRA-caching: 37 failures / 181 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 181, "failed": 37, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "59d85bb5b9b859d1a8a8143fdb063a99775afd75b58828ddaa04645e139a5aeb", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=78 failed=21 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 78, "failed": 21, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c0845e2d20fddb83d7ffd52525b447826106dadceb6f2d063d6d82d96e62cbac", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 31 failures (assertion mismatch) after 822 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 822, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e8b8225ccfb02393ef201d2d655093e22a33bfba6a1e469e275aa980a2822da5", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 506\u2713 34\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 506, "failed": 34, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "07ccbfcbeaf1fbab31502c17059d4f324ec3f5267f407d53ba480d4d22cb2600", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 303 successes and 16 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 303, "failed": 16, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1841e2e2d15886cae7ef5b5d1e76828a2eb46b612a9212045a1d52d2550bf068", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=930 failed=32 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 930, "failed": 32, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "facbebebcc3d81c1e9b95f572d58ae9cd0f86cdf66b4572cb873362f0e69ffa9", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 165 passing and 6 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 165, "failed": 6, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "703e589856d564f2cea436ca5a8d909508bef596026d0cdb9e92193eed16ca82", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 8 failures after 481 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 481, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b3bbe93ff74f48abfb3339e3fec96b5c271c7089ed56fd2b190a4f1fe4b9f804", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 39, \"failed\": 17}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 39, "failed": 17, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ae1a274739b8dd08ec15df494159481d60d70cbd9b7baed8bbafa35088839ba0", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"665\" failed=\"18\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 665, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "49cd45cf53ccaf1b1eeba0814d376e0f4381aebd3fba418fa524e8eeefbb7650", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 376 pass, 13 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 376, "failed": 13, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4c46616f6731486c0d67030ae0c458d17c6c6cae9a42b20353ad37255bc382bc", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 465 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 465, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "98f57a25034ee1473e80a92e6ac5d062699ce77fd7b7bda8076451f43cd8a9cb", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 14 failures / 636 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 636, "failed": 14, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "09525068ac4f752a371bc2b101e868720449f011cdc16c7fa7453abdaf80e878", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=289 failed=10 err=connection refused recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 289, "failed": 10, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0908b2e24e57190c25c6d6af19bfd4065893649cc88d3aadd871e4312ad2543f", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 3 failures (timeout) after 958 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 958, "failed": 3, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2fb6d1c16d19ef9589673f8cc11d16e2e2df0b6ffc8f397ad2761ea75c29da92", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 156\u2713 11\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 156, "failed": 11, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d08fd4ea03957f7fbd7a6ead0f2e0825578146308cd13c2899448eac63615215", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 467 successes and 24 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 467, "failed": 24, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "92fabe12a5ff6738699052a8059e94b6f5b507665241764b968af09c3148c54b", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=179 failed=6 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 179, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b5c06b8e8a6da522ebfb54daf53a4ff9a0e6ca9e387f7d3c70fa90de295f119", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 918 passing and 24 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 918, "failed": 24, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d3d17d0bfc0192a6861f6703c1d60a56dd1be9deab8311c19f73eca9e4d8e847", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 14 failures after 167 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 167, "failed": 14, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7d97885605c24b8068a74b490c760b9d5ae90403663ff7545a32e21dd0ab6f32", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 168, \"failed\": 10}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 168, "failed": 10, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "66a0ded296dd66792e0410f2bd614ae43541770d9710a68a5b8b7ca3236db755", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"430\" failed=\"33\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 430, "failed": 33, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f2f63593aafd9f2114168a61fc6bce7857bb114fb768e988cd1df44f99d367e7", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 120 pass, 4 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 120, "failed": 4, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e0451adfe1745469e6e2006604ed89cd513b87196dcfb3b29546e5b2c96a19c5", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 58 passing, 4 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 58, "failed": 4, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "414ea21a58f3d5bf6fc15da2547e5dd5b22e699bbb685a5c2dd13180a08b5346", "state": "JIRA-search: 11 failures / 46 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 46, "failed": 11, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "01b575e8fccbd26a0728d5292330db1bc198d686c334d7e6b91c102741993f99", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=288 failed=31 err=ImportError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 288, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1a9f7723c86a01bfc30a6804441f0ae25f6bd41c7c69e28be92c773efa2ab7cb", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 16 failures (assertion mismatch) after 859 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 859, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a07349fab0ba87d46cded06d499dce9d1cb6c76e2ca22c77cc2d88b534084fa4", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 549\u2713 13\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 549, "failed": 13, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6b584dcab8db659b3cdd43f4ee7733a888d5701bd5c66fc44768c73d4e980070", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 423 successes and 22 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 423, "failed": 22, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c2e9aba8e63640603bf6b1f26044096f92c4370b3aa5d2ae5d61e8d2e0303c5f", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=945 failed=37 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 945, "failed": 37, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "59c49a7c7d796f093614a44e81db56c51b7268f644852f13cb38980fff536613", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 914 passing and 24 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 914, "failed": 24, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b4c19e066b8c5adc6550e8dc289231a6838a7641d1973916454983f15afa849c", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 654 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 654, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0221e344e3998f25d167bf15ba1286a9d8e5fa5e76df4a96afbaef61d8a2fd78", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 526, \"failed\": 26}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 526, "failed": 26, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d5599b36bc0008613058d460a6e23b86ea478366f14d929b8689acb36b6d5e92", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"31\" failed=\"25\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 31, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4c7af2791d05cd67cc93741244e6e75baf454b7baf8db0b21e8ced6772db9c60", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 220 pass, 9 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 220, "failed": 9, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d98ba6c84943fa81aecc7f042f22141844a1218789183fe130c2cecd3dd681d8", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 923 passing, 9 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 923, "failed": 9, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3eb735134a2dac019fd740437c5b90ceba501380f4984bb412907e7a3bc9e643", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 2 failures / 724 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 724, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ffb7c0b8465af67cb8e88ff91e60aa9ad9e4b64dd2b5cde98611fa082e3bc548", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=421 failed=18 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 421, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6c38b71d1900f7b55a0be2bf2789efb7f7d9f4a0491e0de6714d4a320ee2f5de", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 6 failures (assertion mismatch) after 320 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 320, "failed": 6, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "70b98c74b62a0c7e2f4f72a601d2d3051230b123888752571abfa7f1e069d640", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 671\u2713 37\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 671, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ca135faf4eb351915a36b197ee47653a856b924f174ed15467597dc85e11c056", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 882 successes and 29 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 882, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ff179b35de51ec3ac540e2d44de354ecac6d3454d91c65558dfc94bb76eff3b1", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=620 failed=7 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 620, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4e41ddf301c313a1712da61df28b217bcacafdd7a50668f1d2eff6c6548f45f2", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 701 passing and 16 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 701, "failed": 16, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "70c5e478abc2951e621715090286ddbafd285baff70a1c2f650417941d7df442", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 34 failures after 892 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 892, "failed": 34, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a746fd82b81100a1981e7e6d22766c01c3403d920177f53abd2c6bfe1f69156e", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 399, \"failed\": 8}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 399, "failed": 8, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cba339703882cf2c0d5a6604d6ab06f8d9f26b429c54cf382aae900cd26354a1", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"197\" failed=\"28\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 197, "failed": 28, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "49e327efcb9f90a8bf22c65fb6a8ff224d75c052ccbfe90065c7f95e830f45c0", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 587 pass, 21 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 587, "failed": 21, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e8ed2ea89fc317f7f15abd2135582f068cc23e12524ff0cc265ae5410711c865", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 657 passing, 18 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 657, "failed": 18, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7611e0fe625695e0e9056f54e615e3e4a9fbc0473491b9bd2b1b953d672797cd", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 30 failures / 227 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 227, "failed": 30, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "73c23938165a3098da4c89b5d73b329074bfcb27577099853b6810e44857a6b6", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=182 failed=33 err=assertion mismatch recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 182, "failed": 33, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3ae37d11fc703fd8ed057244e44943d5f8a9dbec61ab657cdbf89e4d4646a550", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 11 failures (unexpected null) after 175 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 175, "failed": 11, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "564800dc62ebdf57ee61440e6f304fc7d24337f3be1eeab34837c01c2c9b3bcd", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 801\u2713 5\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 801, "failed": 5, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d17397edabda117753405ce8ca7a4cf8f46a112eeedd2c15660f323298e69636", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 960 successes and 35 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 960, "failed": 35, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c66aa0b5934c0dbcdcbc72fe01a167c7870044666dd70dad1e12ee0217c888ff", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=128 failed=13 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 128, "failed": 13, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "79256950ff91d4c6817a1b67feb5094e6a40a40cd5fc40fadf51c685a2f4d4e4", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 260 passing and 28 failing with connection refused. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 260, "failed": 28, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3ecde220f32ba3cb5734e7d0e82467a470ff7f4160c0b9a74801688a83abacf4", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 27 failures after 375 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 375, "failed": 27, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "19dbedd165bc09ff87bfbf707aef02e58c1408de34d5c1102b5ef26cd09617b0", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 491, \"failed\": 23}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 491, "failed": 23, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "407f7860ba2d8f16f98c63824fe04ca9d612870219added196e124544200a12a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"883\" failed=\"27\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 883, "failed": 27, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5bb72e1d333a6002d323da5bd4b76dca29881814780947435961dfdbbcac4d4b", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 801 pass, 35 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 801, "failed": 35, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3f72fb1868680a4943f1c7e0056c82aabf762fc36fa9705acd7cbbedc1aa21c7", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 341 passing, 11 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 341, "failed": 11, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "576fc78bfb7aff41b70daa3763545830eaf000c2b56d46054292f3deabb46df0", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 39 failures / 51 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 51, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "00de264b77aa33df0d1db0a866ab14cd6681e021c053377da4da1024af833504", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=423 failed=9 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 423, "failed": 9, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c502b6c00069a932190400cb1c02a22f72a4d9522d0af9e738c81de9d8984722", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 18 failures (unexpected null) after 741 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 741, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "41f7bf82ac2826c60c6026ed2f02255c14a266a46692bdba53d80269d87d73a3", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 282\u2713 39\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 282, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "012051bbf1ccfa13e476074a2af8b8a3fb9b0d825c5a3b38dbdcaddc12fa1943", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 877 successes and 25 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 877, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dbe3cfd7939ddc868d4c5dfe78150c712c35fcf4c2d6cb246478ed6e79097e68", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=725 failed=37 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 725, "failed": 37, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ddcf0fe89bb87f23049b55c5ae74f7c60329576de226746b8d2c7d1f004f66dd", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 369 passing and 26 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 369, "failed": 26, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bf3592ff186e82d48691991df19a3d73a641a87eef3f30d9bd0a1b585335dd8d", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 717 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 717, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "885cbbf5f6dcafa905e7127b72932adb9591763036d59941eadfe280783049e2", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 244, \"failed\": 25}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 244, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a4487b8c559dd9ca85dc738f6d5d29c064abe1891a79d91d190708c7d54baf7b", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"385\" failed=\"22\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 385, "failed": 22, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "69377c386fb3901d1d45969ee3db100cb4e4dbc03d523053602fc7db9704144d", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 446 pass, 19 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 446, "failed": 19, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8d8f03714f47076a8d5bdab5165f68ee786a0884bc57bf74ffc99ad1aa26ca3d", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 313 passing, 2 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 313, "failed": 2, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "24214310257b8223752e8575b565f79e7c02ab434dd4cd218ea35b5615e7a393", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 9 failures / 622 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 622, "failed": 9, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "068da00a6037121d19e878a67c15310220ff7fc22f28a7d58bf2766eb600d986", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=290 failed=3 err=JWTExpiredError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 290, "failed": 3, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d1bf9562d01d274b651e9d610a41d0ba0b9f25187bb49fb5dffd2f7155131241", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 31 failures (timeout) after 415 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: merged\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 415, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4a52236a6ed661801c89c3a151e9bf65a9c4c5c1239c35886abf70b0f30ea045", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 796\u2713 14\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 796, "failed": 14, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "01af432f961de2e85ef8a819e0ad2644b21982b426cbde5517cb6dfa99cb2112", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 621 successes and 11 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 621, "failed": 11, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3a7f375bd85bc1343cee984bdd271e736560cce90d631fdf6c619680a3689dec", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=822 failed=37 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 822, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aad5ebaa4b31bc2e367916ee38a47647be37bdf19df2b7e8cac5101d50c5415d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 796 passing and 5 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 796, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "25269dc740b339dd87cb4918729a67b6ebd1af96ade96b7db24b6dd3a70d164c", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 14 failures after 1 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 1, "failed": 14, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b4afd7dac23d2ac214be0959cbf4348fbf8829f7151dbbd8b87ccdf54299064a", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 609, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 609, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9490bc29901559082d17f723f3c43d52f16196431f713702432a5fa3e9e7145e", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"76\" failed=\"20\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 76, "failed": 20, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b4e9eabafdeb1f5b036361199d77fe533ebdeb2ab4014329f3ec194b18eeea6", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 323 pass, 17 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 323, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b9da903e8b73b1da11bceaff53657abe222fcfb1471e9fa1992e0d1e2b1de26b", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 950 passing, 29 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 950, "failed": 29, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "26507471541676f8dfcc1b51a653367c40bbb9cd3cc7b9fc25efb6f16a00fa29", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 7 failures / 534 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 534, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f7b6c347d003ee03034db4f4b657ad657a9c70f522cb3bed0d0e7fc15cdb05bd", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=100 failed=5 err=assertion mismatch recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 100, "failed": 5, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "773c03d3e52a78fef06346dac526c706e5c23cb6e7be6114cb055224c7672303", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 33 failures (unexpected null) after 884 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 884, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3a3d1cf2ed502f50f18dcdfcad8426d85b2507d686221ba75657a44134cb7ef3", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 541\u2713 16\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 541, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a80c0e7c69f551f5b687c58a782339a78f857e669842e5d5bbc4637db6209373", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 92 successes and 28 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 92, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e7f3c4cd18f05113c6445c0f106a6ed2b41f6fd55a97f7516b589e32911bd103", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=708 failed=27 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 708, "failed": 27, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6827e74d0860fc4d073ef0b7d10fea93bed3c79f08d58b229d27991feea1c548", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 61 passing and 32 failing with connection refused. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 61, "failed": 32, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5873ab2bbb5bdc6283af464538d74161efcde9e99445fc2702beb4c3ff65dbc4", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 23 failures after 586 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 586, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7f82eebf9de2600b95ac759c4e35e7d25622e519af41f2c83ae08f7b7814a2a6", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 967, \"failed\": 14}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 967, "failed": 14, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7d3937fb73c41c71164b267f809924010a1c5afa7f4858e4f183752b79159deb", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"882\" failed=\"10\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 882, "failed": 10, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6bcfaa5e435fdc7a1f648f0265e5b2eb2f67531a77290b0a4b0a5cca49b3bb02", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 905 pass, 14 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 905, "failed": 14, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "12877c1b96c6270081e2f05e202ef8216fe1271456dddb4fcd7c385f778bff62", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 808 passing, 1 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 808, "failed": 1, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "95774c28e322cad77139fcda6e2aeceaebd71bc9942612299acab7bc87c9fc9d", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 25 failures / 603 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 603, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "37b4e57508aaf2d026a35389347114c21d6d451ebf6cf160d4e7a56a938989f4", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=108 failed=27 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 108, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "13ab3b3a63ef9c2f103e012b5906bb222edaf6ceebf3ca2c65f5e0172c21e817", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 20 failures (timeout) after 929 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 929, "failed": 20, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a5d5613b7eeacc8d7a8321fb62a52e9b2a95a6c1fe8b4107a71ce45029e61014", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 847\u2713 8\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 847, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "69cd1e21736db35db31eacc8bb125415bdcc7cff3b4162e029115cf4e865fbc2", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 476 successes and 7 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 476, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cee66a845f28ab0ce57f3bb4022da44058d6fbcd9cac817c792c65ae3082168c", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=818 failed=2 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 818, "failed": 2, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "cc3eaed2eb2c78648ea4eba790d8c2cf33819f65b30f2dd487fce45fdde41288", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 684 passing and 27 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 684, "failed": 27, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a5f84f04073996c6482c099603aadb69fd655a9d35378af5c0ed0355dc03b366", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 38 failures after 567 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 567, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a3d74668c24f433c8d99d671deb5bda9cbab4a92433e4fede82c8b995e1bf498", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 653, \"failed\": 22}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 653, "failed": 22, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8b2cdbdf4cdbf635bc7d99e71387b760e1bb29029d62b5a6cf5ca350d16c43b3", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"965\" failed=\"27\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 965, "failed": 27, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3fda4ec5456459534659e2c6814d7f73068f984f7c69ec52e1ebfc9deac79934", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 534 pass, 10 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 534, "failed": 10, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bf9fced9429c7450bb9d203d8bc072e5247c199d84a28943edae7651bf97801b", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 224 passing, 29 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 224, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9948ac9dbd64c60ed41c56f621ecebd12a8cec264bdffbbe3bd12a6b39c064cf", "state": "JIRA-billing: 11 failures / 605 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 605, "failed": 11, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cae2e7a91655864b15cb8aa89806425154633ac01ab102d847d9da1f82aec8a9", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=124 failed=36 err=JWTExpiredError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 124, "failed": 36, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "49c992d17c86d9c1f0988e07a3788b75419425d1fc44f722d0446491f04e7bae", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 16 failures (connection refused) after 537 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 537, "failed": 16, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ba531e62815ae1d77dd484d09aee222cbc0fee60c07430b39ec77ff21ff74f6c", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 668\u2713 11\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 668, "failed": 11, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dfbbfe640bff2bb29086d314577b9475c46edd9e9cfaa4990f39e36bf3d68579", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 107 successes and 30 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 107, "failed": 30, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "514e374f610de48b8e4a0c1c63fcf502acb66b062f0249c6362a5c6cc5f8717f", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=756 failed=7 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 756, "failed": 7, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "16a50698b6e01ad9962a56ef2b0424eea8e1f5816baca23022fa449b31887fc7", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 102 passing and 2 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 102, "failed": 2, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "80cc2166109879157f135920d01c5667af07027cba296d07c3af5ae75150e937", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 26 failures after 559 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 559, "failed": 26, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e16d1ccb7460dbc51bbbb8e5931da90b09b58e1861dd8ce1464b701b66063884", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 165, \"failed\": 16}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 165, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "314f354a2b14475b89869d9712d60cb77cf5c2a9fee19c647f2301da438c460f", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"899\" failed=\"29\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 899, "failed": 29, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fe2d2b5a1bc0561bf3abb7de4b00f992deb118f3bf6d75c5dc79192f20b4f0de", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 459 pass, 34 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 459, "failed": 34, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7c8db3f5a552cd44cba9d3ddd7a2cfc740ce98bf1d1aff0bda04de7c3f80f978", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 597 passing, 29 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 597, "failed": 29, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "583bed362ee86cddf9b27ec36b1b21dd4780f615550ea8c9dcc71b8e861e8a66", "state": "JIRA-search: 10 failures / 603 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 603, "failed": 10, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f71d9d3b769aca33b1a6548c47d5c45d42b3091ec7434f7ad1eb32e1f9661858", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=690 failed=6 err=ImportError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 690, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d48213fa3c1eaa0254394a5f6d1f603657756d428239e1fa1d4e682ad3d6c704", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 10 failures (ImportError) after 625 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 625, "failed": 10, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d2c553747bd25235ed9e4249687e8d41d020d1a8eff6effb24fbd040c7ef00c7", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 702\u2713 10\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 702, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a63365fbcc89dad7983f96ccf6e7cffb4651ff34bee5252bc4e00528685026cc", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 162 successes and 26 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 162, "failed": 26, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3504e8d01585c2a69cec53df9c1844828cc6b5acabccbf205165143ebdbd7a76", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=851 failed=2 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 851, "failed": 2, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a4add26e03878a526b621d648b3914e504c64483dfd5068a086287723cdc58d9", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 40 passing and 8 failing with ImportError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 40, "failed": 8, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b3e4926bd22a32b5717a9eacc1a24e050f5872d35854ac5353af4df7bfd40062", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 4 failures after 663 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 663, "failed": 4, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6d57eb8c282b763264391c633429036ac409818844a2d56651f284ddc9233c10", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 351, \"failed\": 31}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 351, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d3d439c5b91fdc6d9a61ea26a37fc131a763482149fbb260c14b1f53831d23bd", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"686\" failed=\"16\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 686, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "15ad5854d277b7692a6671210b157723b6362d42f402800221176c3b7a5fbefc", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 856 pass, 4 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 856, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "93092dc7b2d24eceb42f1543b27e1e41002ee71634e4b25f3079ff8b1827ecc3", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 57 passing, 24 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 57, "failed": 24, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d768ae095cea68197038a4ad378d92624b2683212dde0688032850bd259646de", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 34 failures / 483 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 483, "failed": 34, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0dff90332916d5607181e461c558c91575885f77020fbd150d8c8668fafecc59", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=575 failed=29 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 575, "failed": 29, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "469059ab2153f15fbdce2200b05b34971794a6f0ba4aa9f334ed234f6d7cc357", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 5 failures (ImportError) after 72 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: merged", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 72, "failed": 5, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "27b96ce5505f5442aa5bd01f656c57d7bb69556105e6a34039dbe73b3277db67", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 43\u2713 29\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 43, "failed": 29, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c70bbeca15150641d8ca5fb140e113cc4f64852ba03264ba242b89dd0e9324c7", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 417 successes and 21 failures (timeout). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 417, "failed": 21, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4dd4192bc3eff620c8ce459c198903c17109fa85a6a91b4ec364b210318e0ee6", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=332 failed=22 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 332, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "51065ae77bc1c6959a274fdc9033a08c6a3f058a3e180e6355cc8064a32902b0", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 377 passing and 3 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 377, "failed": 3, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d30f376c17067f1b68e86ba2a70e3d7d946e49e1c9ad3f58932c823b3507689e", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 32 failures after 673 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 673, "failed": 32, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "19b2796d27e5ea92c44da292a94c0f9604f7f19d2e368731ff0246b72b975823", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 526, \"failed\": 35}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 526, "failed": 35, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c5dd696832dfe5d3cedafd07ab3799d4708fbe7184e9ba6b115a2c0085c1b44d", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"769\" failed=\"11\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 769, "failed": 11, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c4dc65113918199adc6f6420fb8cb2b07110364dcb59da9ea272074b7d1281ff", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 627 pass, 6 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 627, "failed": 6, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "47333009b18746e8438a0b1b594cd00b1f9b70c0158c1ccf3ff30e0eafea0d06", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 502 passing, 14 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 502, "failed": 14, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6de36a22ed8e0ffbeef820bc5d4bcfaa3630dccd5474ae6bf9316c4da7a1fcdb", "state": "JIRA-caching: 37 failures / 175 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 175, "failed": 37, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e7d1b237b6abe22ece76d46ffca34066593f8392add996b9147e0d7ff47313b1", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=437 failed=2 err=ImportError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 437, "failed": 2, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dbe8da32a1ad391ec83f35d4b935a988f18522926ad5b6fb22d0cf77a5536336", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 20 failures (assertion mismatch) after 407 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 407, "failed": 20, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a56711a3d79fc61bba37c154cb80de63a2ddbce729c3a4db184e6d33fbf18056", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 406\u2713 30\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 406, "failed": 30, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "47d2eedc14ee60b82405883ddf16286fa34ba239536a38723dfdbc8b367d52c9", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 24 successes and 23 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 24, "failed": 23, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b9c2a1ef466596bfe7a483e557ac81395f029de3048e56647bc0455f97f33d9e", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=100 failed=10 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 100, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "96ae88e40400d8dade7743c7e9bda0f93a22caf63ce6543b79b01eb52af3a046", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 343 passing and 10 failing with connection refused. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 343, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3b0242c34a0b7296451091db35e488ac9a899166aecfc3a1d3ff3f271789cefb", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 4 failures after 327 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 327, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d2afdc4bdfed3763997ecc69271441f642cdd04f5660964c0755d33c9fae11ea", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 248, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 248, "failed": 5, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b7ee654c5fca5f0ceb7e3c5a9f0014c68dbb1871933b59d83e38c06010da0a9f", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"306\" failed=\"10\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 306, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4da4623d8eaf25ba230485bc0224cee649dbd7f5584f153f912f1af5081005fc", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 586 pass, 14 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 586, "failed": 14, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b96f65a7cb82706872943292d13e0ad78f7ff7e204e2af95b1d814a3932f311d", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 13 passing, 37 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 13, "failed": 37, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "9028c93d28c8f5bdb686d8ba392ce79c751101dc166535d4e88e8c95fad89c65", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 16 failures / 504 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 504, "failed": 16, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f6715e5102a1286ea6739c4d18b613487d26da882ad00b06c5dcdf12fffd8b18", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=615 failed=7 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 615, "failed": 7, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "96eb26ec30dc0631347f4e0cde3a5a2e469124811c31b1c5a9776e3b76542437", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 19 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 304 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 304, "failed": 19, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7fed9838a942c5eff4defcd8781a4b5029c63f9251961e7d6158d0d10da143d6", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 749\u2713 39\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 749, "failed": 39, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ce2df03d5bb5cba11b9db58f24159c435ebe611b115ca3787eae3a25b094aed6", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 781 successes and 12 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 781, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8a9c1e0a34991dac96b20e541fe56ca58aec45b3d40966deee77ddc98cab7b2d", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=590 failed=7 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 590, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8a3106f0190b3e29aac86a325b0b48e8a277ce5ccf6c14b7a916c26b6dcd239b", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 731 passing and 26 failing with ImportError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 731, "failed": 26, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4fd7620f704c0252fbd8979e43f14dfa6484719d2c729ea4e25e69897f043c27", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 29 failures after 769 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 769, "failed": 29, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8b7ab7d33f48116791d20eab36837c552d6840f375180ea9fb36709781b7a607", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 279, \"failed\": 7}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 279, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "add4608ed23bed92405b3aac9718f7cabf36d930e9cefe07b614b91dfa38be32", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"280\" failed=\"27\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 280, "failed": 27, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8b0557aff8b595e259c7fe9928824ec7dca4188a3375814918a07a5715b434c4", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 799 pass, 20 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 799, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "86740b2777e90278d91fc2cc7e5a14128ef10c1b832af29c38c37222b6a3cb2d", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 88 passing, 28 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 88, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f779f8d7d4b9219d643e8d35b8088cea37c5c7e17182d6f79270e59ebfb89827", "state": "JIRA-caching: 7 failures / 924 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 924, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "910d6935c2b7fabdd199dbf8c727c65b6a48b558a44726e9258f01771c326b1d", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=98 failed=25 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 98, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b0b21e1bbc0bd388329633eaf557f11f2aebd44efdf566956aad7422dc3e37e4", "state": "fix(search): investigate 20 failures (connection refused) after 779 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 779, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f7611d317170fbc6e622deec815baa36289e9d74ef4799c03f96b13c8299d131", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 623\u2713 14\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 623, "failed": 14, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "15b4946517f2fd2f633dc39523e906399ff7c00244d233c75c42ecd51953d98e", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 253 successes and 31 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 253, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d8180cfebbadc811de40c6968458c0096d4f375531daee3f83d9119d6b89c7d3", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=695 failed=38 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 695, "failed": 38, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8b39ccbfecd72aa203e2c8d65f3db41d065690be21bd889f983f6bd43c742f7a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 928 passing and 23 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 928, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "22b9232b463042f0ac9d599d9906af0edd543a6a3afdccd38c25f5dbebff8efb", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 16 failures after 770 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 770, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b2b3fe4471710b290a061a575497526f123fdfb6623e1b3c955b06962d87853f", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 370, \"failed\": 21}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 370, "failed": 21, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e2bae29598e32d97ba3c1e592e7fb4ceefeab94b6ef6bfc89b269f319aea8a79", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"8\" failed=\"17\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 8, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7930527a69ae0d2aa851d066cebd54d3451cccb04ab9d98ec628025b82dc54ba", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 681 pass, 1 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 681, "failed": 1, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5f2ef7656dc5e17fd71f66f177c010a9a8e18a8656c99e6e1f5313a6214c7202", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 61 passing, 2 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 61, "failed": 2, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "90eb221f03825baf0f50aff682f878d7aaa11631421aec7b5e55c0768b823a9f", "state": "JIRA-search: 24 failures / 157 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 157, "failed": 24, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c5558386c33f57505b67568456184c649bd129a6a1c21dfa24a84ac72edc8c13", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=984 failed=9 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 984, "failed": 9, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4d50def4b0724fd1c061bd2bc531758f9a207910f3ecbb389d3fd5669a13006b", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 9 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 111 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: merged\nci: checks fail | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 111, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3c562c6fadb275ddc15c5279b339b7c91af78f47eb69228a4a2b8886ddc6c1b5", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 701\u2713 39\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 701, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3781922051a0ab0f743c5650a7f4a3c2af3a3fffe6d4e5529d1fa589126983bd", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 212 successes and 18 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 212, "failed": 18, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "55a90391486196bc435bb656b0dd62d355f1dd5121519ff372939e55ac680d46", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=35 failed=8 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 35, "failed": 8, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3cd563d0048c8590d98ab8d9a5202149d0cda02c7863d9c60984dc34c7460142", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 725 passing and 35 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 725, "failed": 35, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ebe000daba3ad055ddb6a523d08e23407caedbb9837516426bce09eaf1292103", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 27 failures after 658 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 658, "failed": 27, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "12d315dcd296553f67bbb398f36463a9aad0ff6b2b5639a96c61aff188184b79", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 726, \"failed\": 35}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 726, "failed": 35, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "01630e248e336fd4daf4d5f21e9e51c6851777377f1d4f0c62a3ed5b17a51a03", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"881\" failed=\"15\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 881, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cd217033adfb708576c0aaee622d2b32564334f345d5fdd10b5675a0796a28c1", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 575 pass, 7 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 575, "failed": 7, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7604f7a5c9ce410313ef556cb37528c66e0e465faf79fd8c29af4c8284a7232e", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 760 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 760, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "81183011a48053433b6912789f322d778bccd760ec7d7554722bd64cc9e4d96a", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 34 failures / 711 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 711, "failed": 34, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bd380873135d5ced4d383fc325e168cbe4f68b819ea869d34b12993bc25465e4", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=375 failed=22 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 375, "failed": 22, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "64e2e53b95201e588ecb03511921c982651e1d35a92488b06d9e3a14dd738950", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 25 failures (timeout) after 100 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 100, "failed": 25, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "50ca7588aac6d89b5a092040217381aec9ca5288377980c8f9c796ce61bf839d", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 396\u2713 14\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 396, "failed": 14, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f88fa43f9101ec83886afe52911e60fd9ab80498fcd915422cfa00f968ed1146", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 38 successes and 38 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 38, "failed": 38, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "627423fb91984de551a26713636bd33516b5be3a9dff7e3a76937bed45ce18b3", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=866 failed=23 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 866, "failed": 23, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "787c8abf62ffe3eb2375a4848fa097386c487c1ba7f0cf173734468646de8b16", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 526 passing and 20 failing with connection refused. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 526, "failed": 20, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "668510becf3bc6ffdd4eb89a328ead5ead7ffe0e8267851fb09229c0cbdf0309", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 12 failures after 1 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 1, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b70a523b535e6be8b9d12d023c9031d2df0ceff4bbb71f3e6b9010a271053d9b", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 166, \"failed\": 25}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 166, "failed": 25, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e022bf69059366613ccec544775ff192b3754bd3924dbbd8af8d7c7b99cd36fc", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"754\" failed=\"26\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 754, "failed": 26, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b7e5c9c2d9d8f07c82e51202d7fd43ded9c01005ecaf84a34bb9fc1d6c3b870d", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 454 pass, 15 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 454, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1be37543130c2b18b3620439501d06ef5c0fd1fe533611058a2c0b7519d02bfd", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 969 passing, 20 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 969, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "38bfa8c396ab6583e4284f8030f36257b7f0ad685fa40ef376ea56bf2f32dcc0", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 36 failures / 188 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 188, "failed": 36, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "77f88e8bf9319c1d24fd77c8fbb6e808039c7b1bb519e8530dbab2a3703bca93", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=547 failed=22 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 547, "failed": 22, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eb8e9704ccc443bff279585d94b85a03731e0ac79ffd511564fe35323a4dff53", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 12 failures (connection refused) after 130 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 130, "failed": 12, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "971efd80a48433112f5ec2f1fe771e91c734f95cb98f103edf9ba45ad1b10c5b", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 312\u2713 3\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 312, "failed": 3, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e6d7a6297143c30079f930a55efa6e636a1767f89396f657c6c677625bea617b", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 703 successes and 10 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 703, "failed": 10, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9cda99c57dfb259c19d813c6bdddab0f0b56f795722aaf8dbe2fb1bf374e6d00", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=195 failed=2 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 195, "failed": 2, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9a8c97eb14d7fc0b160c310541308fb1314bd15be2b5e38a9103c6d8f1d94a6a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 943 passing and 35 failing with connection refused. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 943, "failed": 35, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3f3bcb1bbdb55e981df0db65a4893f5a2539bc9d497de0de124795392dbac81f", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 37 failures after 864 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 864, "failed": 37, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a5f5ccf8286779b36b6d888d5448206491718c7aebe61e64b62df89aebd2a97d", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 698, \"failed\": 17}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 698, "failed": 17, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4f0c3ea03f8e07ea72a92a772f5bbb63201d8a254deb8c081f236bb39d3d9bef", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"495\" failed=\"38\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 495, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "dfb27fa1181ddcbd6ee9a3d2683a1cd401532ad0951e71ad8ab9af06d5585a9f", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 501 pass, 14 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 501, "failed": 14, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "71c1282ce095034b80fbe4f22e008056586715e6616157ebb03fdcaa7397cbdd", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 686 passing, 38 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 686, "failed": 38, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "92bbb5282987260856825e3de684b0a356a3738c1c968bb36e76d569d38df450", "state": "JIRA-search: 26 failures / 756 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 756, "failed": 26, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f29eec91ba43edc95e4d74ff242c03c9f312894c3cced2512756bebde9bb0823", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=847 failed=17 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 847, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f599ac4406f319fd6636860e6d6d67f6f45ab074e8ac98423a89db012e31b6e6", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 31 failures (unexpected null) after 806 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 806, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e5289dd0a0a37840ead1747b5fefe9f3bd5b45ba3c491a9840eb9def10283ce3", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 266\u2713 12\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 266, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "adee10d84abb9250e21aeab04f3bbfa0fda49c3c991d899a595798894177818f", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 269 successes and 20 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 269, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "353e9697721606f10076493a9eb0f0784c67ca737a84ae692b5e3e99c67e7ff8", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=50 failed=11 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 50, "failed": 11, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7fbf8e208a66be883e29c823e3cbbb68bfeb936edad395b058034fd3a0c3c781", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 992 passing and 31 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 992, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8ef87aeb43ed4fa583769aa51c75b9e654f753dbe4c939d74c4ee33579606309", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 33 failures after 914 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 914, "failed": 33, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4888491a5d058081c4b685e451857ed3fe2043bb3e0f182bf12f54e132993fc9", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 227, \"failed\": 38}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 227, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d8c9d651a137b7bac80cdab609fd3bab8331ca015262ff4554a0388c55d46bc5", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"862\" failed=\"1\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 862, "failed": 1, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "69600d783d61b4ee2947df76867d21954f5c9a949ac08f13fac6507fbfb1da88", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 587 pass, 36 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 587, "failed": 36, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dbc27d6f995a9972971ea18170267ecec9081dd5dbe5ed9542dfb4952c176fa9", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 190 passing, 6 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 190, "failed": 6, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "777d0fdc9c4e56fb176fdfac6eda0e35020569e2177de56b058cc0b2fac4f325", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 13 failures / 360 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 360, "failed": 13, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "57bee2d7ab7839eddccedfb6e2aa26e2ad6827cd995a2ffd698d6a812efb74d6", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=121 failed=2 err=connection refused recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 121, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aaab797ff2b478f0e5d4922d4a0a2f9417a98ba30f572bd1de6d0432bdf02b9b", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 3 failures (timeout) after 149 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nrevert: rejected\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 149, "failed": 3, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "15fa0a8b74d40a5d7d3240160291ffffcb7bd44fbfc9937fcb24e4d915998e98", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 321\u2713 34\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 321, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f1a3393c2551cdfaa4c6c0b3a99822b2ed43b131c8285a7113746ae8f13b4765", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 808 successes and 27 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 808, "failed": 27, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3f8c4c00f2399cdee7adb90f73160928b58f30ecf87a068116bef1fb08890384", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=311 failed=5 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 311, "failed": 5, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "987d37a7ab79c7ac2e25da9fb843f4117d743ae361754f229c74132d3722051d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 387 passing and 31 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 387, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4100b7ad6367c9ee0620a6e9de95cfcfb5d3b2ef120dbfcac07d38496e121631", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 34 failures after 982 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 982, "failed": 34, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c6594e59d24a907a100bd639bb4eca2b4664dceb7aed29c0ba58283ba637e30", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 964, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 964, "failed": 5, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e410a4598b5055c9071ec9e30cddc414c73a654030a9707404d8ef09db83d31a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"702\" failed=\"22\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 702, "failed": 22, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "37ac818b2932a6b401b7b2bc89cb5412d980b5e303467bedc25c1fc9394519aa", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 364 pass, 7 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 364, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "665a4e9d6f33f684103ab51f01b0d78e5f9ed8293d1ca507ed467bd77ba637f8", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 880 passing, 24 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 880, "failed": 24, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4160e7d344efe5afd7843887d1d6c886236425b7e0e955927c4fe657d9b5cfc4", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 33 failures / 924 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 924, "failed": 33, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "235ea4d5ac42a9cd243826663b35576aa612888f6c49699e4f05539039a5fcf9", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=297 failed=5 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 297, "failed": 5, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "951e08bf2e502716cac630658c35ee7c3e1ad83ef0e3bbfd79ef945771c31c1e", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 25 failures (unexpected null) after 565 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks pass | approval: approved", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 565, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eb652dc8bdbbad5a9cf120d20cc7ca5dd34ddb4bc7db02a8a0cf95f3d5a7bb5f", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 898\u2713 15\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 898, "failed": 15, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f7c0d1a36545e665fd167b02c0b02e9e24af99a8d1165b35cf596b967f88d582", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 425 successes and 31 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 425, "failed": 31, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3713c67245b53c844c4e266da3e2764dc2ce23a56e0db24d3f0bacdc926c2df6", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=623 failed=8 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 623, "failed": 8, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b94679cf6d602f6d3fbc5fdf64fd85d5abedf0587ce54c43c5206a116500b9f", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 424 passing and 35 failing with connection refused. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 424, "failed": 35, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "39b5d403afe105cbd1e5110abbdf95cc7146bc6fd60feb14382fb1f25568cd7f", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 2 failures after 653 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 653, "failed": 2, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2ec1fae5151c899e45c02255f52ab5e71cc88105a2cf73bcd3da3f35d65264e4", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 93, \"failed\": 29}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 93, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4bedf7aa3923898d40cb086b9e062e3ea7998fb1f946f8a4b82f75b0d3552263", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"190\" failed=\"11\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 190, "failed": 11, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c96e61cf0d3bb781b1fc802b0b0c313e5438cd256b18e26f29d45546b2e67f14", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 67 pass, 26 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 67, "failed": 26, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "692dc4cc649bee7fc3459b49f037ca1e62727cf50bf5bc1c7bc4616202942ea2", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 908 passing, 22 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 908, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5f29a6110b3928f218d50a0f45c14931c4468cb268ee440a63e5128481bdac23", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 8 failures / 803 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 803, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bed34de193f73cfd84c32d213747cb8c3ce6aaf0b9dd56ef30097a532fa341ce", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=196 failed=2 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 196, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "07b3e184c0708162801fbebbb9e80b4c47305e722ea51c498bdaa61ac6a274c9", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 9 failures (connection refused) after 106 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 106, "failed": 9, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "10d1efdde7f1e7d49dba76adbc705ed2a32e9d96900380bde60986e5fe952055", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 386\u2713 29\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 386, "failed": 29, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d56d88cb4b7b96e338901f20186122043a31bccf0b6d2f42130de3b6b52fd1b7", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 996 successes and 2 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 996, "failed": 2, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "56c6da7d67b007a316a39ccd43346f384cb1b48d48263d875237841c434bbf0a", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=104 failed=15 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 104, "failed": 15, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bcaf5cb2763efdb6ac75ecd1cdae3d496386f251004a79831ff835c4d0a1c17b", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 249 passing and 22 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 249, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a42f2c10dc2193ba3ab606d7d761388aeeee14feb8b418cfd8fcf21da5f6dc11", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 17 failures after 108 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 108, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1a967cc94355d3083ab6435f8c827c1345f534129dd5a9a0b753fcaaf6c42725", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 192, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 192, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ac5f21faf2735ac67d52707e9f482080e6966758d3a69960e6b6b8dbef9a9ed3", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"799\" failed=\"37\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 799, "failed": 37, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "adf79638b9c0a9ab8271b3def661fe326adb282255cc30d4b64acb952868835d", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 515 pass, 18 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 515, "failed": 18, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "150c9b4774efa11cc71a140c52721bb8937543b18f59517e9235f058e0c51bbb", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 369 passing, 10 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 369, "failed": 10, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f27027eb46320dfddefb5bf18dbc796fafed75c3090de88a21065c23f09738b3", "state": "JIRA-caching: 2 failures / 846 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 846, "failed": 2, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fadef09e028faf121caae87d78bfbb26c60ed207835e8c4c6f34ebc6f9a58ac0", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=263 failed=31 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 263, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d9a24f239b40308403911490fda04baf1c15d8da3eb88cea3308e80c1941bd48", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 30 failures (connection refused) after 903 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 903, "failed": 30, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c79398da88c809d8842897e11bb7016f911ea3478ae1e3f0e89f150d54ec5d06", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 221\u2713 26\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 221, "failed": 26, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4cded6ab85be450b4882b9e61db1dd3dc9958fa2f1d1521a2534d99ed8da8658", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 864 successes and 2 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 864, "failed": 2, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6f239c6721569e724a1146589d71c51fc9c9e557936efb5ec92740d0548f0acc", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=140 failed=31 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 140, "failed": 31, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e1ae85206d613f3af11e6c951683726cdcb32bb2ff13faad99f3ee7928ca429d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 192 passing and 32 failing with connection refused. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 192, "failed": 32, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b257f40e4063c3f998d235390b0d7aeab5b36e8066a80e2dd3f20416c76633db", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 23 failures after 215 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 215, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ae57fcd1e521074f5ea2b296845fe4a80d049ff77df79565649a765be3b3d912", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 890, \"failed\": 36}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 890, "failed": 36, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "88f05c24ec4dc2716ebeb1dccd88074b38dae18444e8d2d77a122320e47847f1", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"107\" failed=\"21\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 107, "failed": 21, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3fd04e0688e223cb8129e51c9ff9b25bd607d36daf5eac1d76803830af3b2b97", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 311 pass, 24 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 311, "failed": 24, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e7fd211111f78352ba9be135c2cc874a2093f56a9fbd781096ad3e6d0523c66e", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 169 passing, 8 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 169, "failed": 8, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b65b24a04bfac62b6ec317113c058e0f9feb8fd46b294b641f64da6526577f64", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 31 failures / 719 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 719, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7fc3d4b989e1a5e85796732de557ed029068117ed718f3d2e46261eeac5b2932", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=666 failed=33 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 666, "failed": 33, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fe3148861b3a88b750c280c09c01a7ab618f7d732a0dc8378854114beca7281e", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 2 failures (unexpected null) after 609 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 609, "failed": 2, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c2002e8efc0d9285e23faca10546c95058408d0d9c7c1cb928207e1e0cc4e32", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 107\u2713 19\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 107, "failed": 19, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "96d038f5d73b7d26d32e5eb5a30c2ed2bf65d90847af5c6b67d06b0e3b7b1418", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 149 successes and 23 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 149, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ba648b24d54a2392edf37ca3642b7d50a4a19ed5621e2ef54dabb48baafda962", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=630 failed=31 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 630, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "72bfb7d947f4c11fe6028629a08d602785a3d7d270ff2147e0399f9c94557bbc", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 735 passing and 24 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 735, "failed": 24, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "155a86ae53ccfcd6e73da925504fb7bab58023283801d15a7889e4475919b797", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 31 failures after 770 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 770, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "877f721c06637a44c05c00a2aa23214c98bebc6fba76aed3a5bf09d716ef4b94", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 57, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 57, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e94e9c25937a3501510e155491c2e1da5471f82f1266f227d1f821959bb3b8f2", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"351\" failed=\"12\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 351, "failed": 12, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8c56a2a1c1b30ef06039453c14800ebb8d2b0b79f4f71b1778e7cb5f1e38f18b", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 840 pass, 7 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 840, "failed": 7, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "722680424b8779a29b04f1b239b7ebe5043fcdc8245aafa8b22e9a9c175433d2", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 410 passing, 27 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 410, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d00c05fa75cde045959dbfa844222172ef64fe69eba699c8ce06afe1ebd6a489", "state": "JIRA-search: 21 failures / 779 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 779, "failed": 21, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d235bc2251d0c052e69d455086e26b22a263e7be045b81c45bef30717ef83ef4", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=213 failed=12 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 213, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1edc76f8702614d802213ff01a142c92868705d87a4df712e797b06e4524da37", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 21 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 944 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 944, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5d5abad625f26c405fc896e60d2b367040e02ddb153f7ca5315c7948b700d021", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 407\u2713 3\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 407, "failed": 3, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "abb6c5eeeb5ab2e7d49446c6982557f1b39240b59f7c71b36af29d4e263880cf", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 465 successes and 34 failures (timeout). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 465, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3aa9628537718cc62401d7f2ea56ab62c5bf6f9e61f68b34ceadb99313f5de53", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=479 failed=20 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 479, "failed": 20, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "9c843446f850e2e7355027c394918a90ae07a0dcbbeb667182c0f62af6b394cb", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 454 passing and 33 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 454, "failed": 33, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "af91249a75a23208db3b7b90ecbf50f7e0f0081ab7bc185273a8694a7ecd88ac", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 3 failures after 416 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 416, "failed": 3, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0310b63b2ba8d93e2c964e7a4ed86aafd0378edcc425771e56bf14ae9fc7e117", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 532, \"failed\": 29}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 532, "failed": 29, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "63504b16e4b54a0b9969bee334392d00701d789aba38592ce1b9862c532619e4", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"936\" failed=\"18\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 936, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "51b577ab40c33e12a14552a1c3ad9212a2c2ced65714669dbc85a4cc49c5575f", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 153 pass, 10 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 153, "failed": 10, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa12dc9f2e325094c9f9da8b220166d1aaba9945b661b0146de96b3ba3d889cf", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 281 passing, 12 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 281, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3399191d69db1e38b5b68f35cdb198832e81e6f72e19674babee744cdfcc8b56", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 18 failures / 499 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 499, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c795dffb92c6ac218477bf639094a65d07e20e754811f3917303980387ab06f9", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=342 failed=4 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 342, "failed": 4, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f62f5bd114044333137b4a871e4a2ea6c4708642f306f5d0b714866d135d082c", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 27 failures (ImportError) after 30 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 30, "failed": 27, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0f3179c73367aec0c0c35ed0b2fdee046fdffee2c7a8fdc7bd35a726c8b38840", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 392\u2713 7\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 392, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ae984f8b059cb60dfccaf31450f7d320be26c3ace4af25d3355ca8bccd09d727", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 360 successes and 22 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 360, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "84a317fce47f639478921345d50be370aedc899a394eed0748bdac29e89a023d", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=189 failed=21 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 189, "failed": 21, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f641e1c2b6e3cae0791e113d443205d9708a2f3a19034f4956648bc58416b07b", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 186 passing and 20 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 186, "failed": 20, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e02f49d4093f89fafaf0b648cbdd7ef7bdc3b07bf1e674c38f4d85b82d78c6ca", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 33 failures after 676 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 676, "failed": 33, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d52b86810f2f0d8204abd7d1741ff4b0b64b69d3dc76dfaf5aeb5575a59d8396", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 868, \"failed\": 23}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 868, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "17e052001632ecbccf9bb6ee03dbadeae08ae8105405d4a2b51d64d4571413ab", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"287\" failed=\"30\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 287, "failed": 30, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f0eb8a18a5c266f83ae044b3e9fd6122d67abf8078f87ddd24eb64d8b09ad096", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 208 pass, 2 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 208, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "596aeefda668cd495cf5bdecb6cbad5a9bd14dd2d94148a4fd348f91c988fe5b", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 116 passing, 39 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 116, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c21c77bf4bfd142c6cbd5381cefb1f10f7a225402f0a56cde3b398a67a5c8b1a", "state": "JIRA-billing: 32 failures / 402 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 402, "failed": 32, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7396d0f3bac2a753ca03e0d481da1da9ede2cab5366cba7c2607a7ded3503834", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=755 failed=7 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 755, "failed": 7, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cb5664f44e9f73067c3a4d038d009b5ac4ecc8adacf7e9fa0f4ff109fcbd4824", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 23 failures (unexpected null) after 278 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: rejected\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 278, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b25ea619289417078d95b595289f7f739f96c5d59672c41d17f0b2e1b4273610", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 250\u2713 19\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 250, "failed": 19, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "64892efbdbfec23073af8208dba727f2946733647b4cb532868106c519d887f3", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 227 successes and 16 failures (timeout). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 227, "failed": 16, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b98ae2410d3472af14050c6b910fac8cadf115922e8c549ad189f585ca5afc0a", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=733 failed=20 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 733, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "305ab22bf2100d15effd7bf6327afc699d546f39dedeb0aa29f393f27901dd6d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 740 passing and 13 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 740, "failed": 13, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6e331a9e72a3fce851d4ff8db0523cd476ccd2dd1aec4cc4e7348023fe9a3b0a", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 7 failures after 121 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 121, "failed": 7, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "fae08cb9c630615ea1e980c93a68c26719570cc84e9bfb1bf9463c53668c3a36", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 974, \"failed\": 3}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 974, "failed": 3, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9e5af4fd74228dca87923e6f07150338de90308643878add28424c3e2606638e", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"47\" failed=\"32\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 47, "failed": 32, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bcb24bf4e419dfbc1e3e7b6e37ac53d2be64a658c7d3b4b301537fafdce99d3f", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 440 pass, 2 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 440, "failed": 2, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "07270eb6e79b8e8a70c94911125914fbaacc71aa6b6dd32ce151d4725f969062", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 633 passing, 28 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 633, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2353d1c799ce3eef9bf49396ecda6dae2447c5d3ddcabff18649b0e4fb588698", "state": "JIRA-search: 6 failures / 689 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 689, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "350d64e4430d7cf3b730f51c801cecf84da3e4a8bc6ed5ea3ac9b3fdb44fa488", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=433 failed=8 err=ImportError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 433, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f2f060741bd2b2f6ebbd4d6a18ab8206eee116a5162a4c5958c762798b0f714f", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 28 failures (unexpected null) after 270 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 270, "failed": 28, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5a11be52cdbde1087d937e2800519ed20aedd23413921bb98475d6e791aecedf", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 886\u2713 14\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 886, "failed": 14, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7129947d82fee72da437fd0f941e40099909156b538c845da31d9fdf1371ecdd", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 727 successes and 31 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 727, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ad917e9deec955752249767cddca805af62479feec08839ee396064ec3182f0c", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=306 failed=9 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 306, "failed": 9, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ce0cf66790b216d7d838f68da9a3de95029b561978e28606980d4d3442c17c13", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 867 passing and 16 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 867, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "93dc416509091b8f4e045bbe1a12fe9766f61e6698e10fba4217e8d2ef7ed60e", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 29 failures after 30 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 30, "failed": 29, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1aeea4d3b183e70478b09f04deeeb1bde55f2705dafbb3355f6ff7b48beb3ebc", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 264, \"failed\": 36}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 264, "failed": 36, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a0d9fc09843f6afa36968b0752a7a1a78b0a7a8cec8196a01efd6c160f87b565", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"124\" failed=\"33\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 124, "failed": 33, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f3f054a76f37f2cc17eebbb1dcdc5f7f1d1ac5ae996475dd4ed44c457cc9f2c0", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 347 pass, 27 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 347, "failed": 27, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fc3f063b838e97aa42a3ac405b8031221f89e960ab6dd46aa427e01662281c97", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 496 passing, 11 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 496, "failed": 11, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9766ca56d0eba9a469c56252020acdff87a037f28a05c1df3ead5fd025f954c6", "state": "JIRA-caching: 13 failures / 973 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 973, "failed": 13, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0772bac4615278100bad7bb03fe29b1c618dcf1f3998071b675716d0dfbbc90f", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=553 failed=28 err=unexpected null recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 553, "failed": 28, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "97908eb000c35f171078c2155aae53c78a7f0591ae1807374c2e34cdec03c34f", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 24 failures (ImportError) after 143 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 143, "failed": 24, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3fd49b10e336c816e3c81ef1d4f52b7e2e636de2df0570da20734f9f2ecf34f6", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 708\u2713 35\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 708, "failed": 35, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b2026988439c281c57d755c863c8553312a13d5b076834beb9f8a19ae6e9541d", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 289 successes and 20 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 289, "failed": 20, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e616a64e2871d12f9a863e141b7d7db68ed0d09f2fa345505337de93025c8a16", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=98 failed=15 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 98, "failed": 15, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a276c2d64494e90927319fcb6d8ab83509cb408f1ac25d492eb799bf3076d69d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 491 passing and 39 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 491, "failed": 39, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "27b972f5cbfe79aa15444fe8803b9a9eb23a9cee7bcc983b043f109d1b85e050", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 21 failures after 399 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 399, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ac279fbfea092935541e6d217b201dba9e8b6e87023fb87bdb15e45740e92126", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 373, \"failed\": 3}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 373, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c269420d129448ce0007237798203b33569cecfba70653213ca18320bfcfc689", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"804\" failed=\"38\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 804, "failed": 38, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6e99b88ebc0e38504b4b95e0567b206de74bd8e41fcd5c85961abae6dd17a928", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 537 pass, 28 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 537, "failed": 28, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7b3b808208b771a93d8f1e944731694b15a0b9657a93b13fee5c6d52b70af981", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 565 passing, 27 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 565, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9e4dc227c03b9bbabf52db2893c03a3f3181dc98fa5bb37dd36f8810d584a2ed", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 16 failures / 755 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 755, "failed": 16, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3d5b33c23b30e90773e0d7f225f9e76d18340785a78e80ef56a8d2da3ae29f80", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=699 failed=31 err=assertion mismatch recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 699, "failed": 31, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7efb30caad9fc62fb3e399acdb425ccacde5407ad369743678e65da9766a0660", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 16 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 554 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 554, "failed": 16, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "73ffba34c0b12929960102e7b6bb53dcb31c1972c4f61152188d01fafb34952e", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 470\u2713 35\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 470, "failed": 35, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fb3d57b14ae33ef1d2db9f1bf98704a10068e1763810bc54e9200330a1cd76ca", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 854 successes and 14 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 854, "failed": 14, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b606ddf1fdbf2a811328f29762718572a64e28a7bed30a2ef4e7e6a346a102da", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=371 failed=18 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 371, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "226f4cd2c99a28592a19bd078b16fb8aeac8177c090c485cbddd860692ff6fd5", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 223 passing and 16 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 223, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "92f852779756903db62808a409570decf2960c39048156b9ef12165c02aea872", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 35 failures after 923 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 923, "failed": 35, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3f30726465a50ee3cd3b9de0fc375d0bbd7d164e5f0e95bbb7811d707765d5b2", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 463, \"failed\": 34}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 463, "failed": 34, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8022df1086aa79962d7b550d27da1904eb177f0629861c8ea63f8858e09b62c7", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"386\" failed=\"25\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 386, "failed": 25, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "741db7ea171c3773cc835f637f29f218208bf92c3f9ca8cd7713cd3f2d7d5380", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 528 pass, 7 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 528, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e98be2714121043806257b538ab47b2082e0c6e33b417b1aff864451b60a9ca9", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 360 passing, 26 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 360, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "82bb391cabb6e31508614ed8393c891d4cf691ef818bd2a47c3c59286182d082", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 16 failures / 400 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 400, "failed": 16, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ec79c50f414cccba585ee1d875a2748b1f5075263c0cb949797c959221e4884e", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=619 failed=21 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 619, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f1f059c016c48cba8c279bea6d8b291efd1835ab45d902ee9efd8d5397896bd7", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 28 failures (timeout) after 783 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 783, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "664c64939f037e6c593de60a8ea23452364faa457a4713c11d943108fc5a7049", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 938\u2713 39\u2717 (timeout). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 938, "failed": 39, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ee401e965ef23855f146f7695f964f27881c556c6f360508ba83915c3c93cf3d", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 239 successes and 31 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 239, "failed": 31, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "adde35306834eec97a8dd96ae7ca3b01ad7b2f9dbce60cf768e819ab41fcbe02", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=762 failed=15 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 762, "failed": 15, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "432dffde2448fe4200b532856c7542e0846a6c2f352c42bdec66ecf2af88de3f", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 183 passing and 30 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 183, "failed": 30, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "70eda773017b34f23abd0a9b8e54cc75c626ed674d0c23a92734935ac22f72c2", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 1 failures after 738 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 738, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "819097fd6dd97a2eb51b2acb80c9b551ac377479278d625e5af9e36471c79f82", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 837, \"failed\": 8}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 837, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "10a3fd1a4dc70960813eb0683ee80bebaa42e3a8de87a34df1a8941c42374ee6", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"779\" failed=\"10\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 779, "failed": 10, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2e091d781bac5b7fef36e55d1b1199c14d1cc5c98012fa733029db45de8f2b61", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 12 pass, 9 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 12, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "efdfd596ec051241bf4f8ee562f0cea5ab0b82143c95676d78c0ef8cd74cc70a", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 250 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 250, "failed": 33, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "209588aed4917961006b7e42289983c73ee309ef12ce4ca7a51ca5ebbd7e8e42", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 20 failures / 196 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 196, "failed": 20, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1f4901fa0db8746813532fc2bfba5cc58bcbc3b3794f117ef39c3c8e13d53e1b", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=118 failed=20 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 118, "failed": 20, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "901abacd2b8d4af2d0bab21576823cd161a0404b1e3c17d046a71da60bafeda5", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 3 failures (connection refused) after 690 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 690, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dcd3e3c6fce48d8419bb9502a0de8931b4df69395bcbc757cf93c23434afeb0a", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 181\u2713 26\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 181, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b8d5b853b699c7b89793752a7a9080863ecbe45a3afecad74bf506fb8a8ce7dc", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 828 successes and 24 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 828, "failed": 24, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5deba3cdacc50b89fb716904cbdcefd551a7d59a9d8f875dc9f0e2adfa1f7701", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=335 failed=9 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 335, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa42ed013a82b63c5c0584755d8cf7e14dc20e315e8e53045049a500ce812df3", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 35 passing and 6 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 35, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2737b0790e434cb068539954f44fcd6ca1b5ea9b6ce2f791fa34a3f300d76fef", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 21 failures after 593 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 593, "failed": 21, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fcb8b1b04fec3f6fabfc6c63a3f2d7598aa3cc9e0a95c32ed9c5f2a161709838", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 965, \"failed\": 21}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 965, "failed": 21, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4b3cbd738e5e2531c5dcaf7f17906f7e4f64ba751b248b109b377e1862e8d67d", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"81\" failed=\"38\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 81, "failed": 38, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c59756ee0d77f83f76d75e6b63170817b1e0ab8e78a3092008ac2a148e7a9a8b", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 794 pass, 37 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 794, "failed": 37, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f0b73d120305dbbe139eb4fb2eb451d7809db61a891cf228963edb7b527d2b9e", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 869 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 869, "failed": 15, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "56bcbb2d2732317f0bba4c2ef9779d224c96234fc19fae2e2b893e04e9a40057", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 39 failures / 479 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 479, "failed": 39, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c336b407da0c9735cb73331f04d57cfbef58a401c6baf172c0cbe3f261354adf", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=659 failed=37 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 659, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f3e1d96b7df0d11ca0f67df2876d2bb3bb3f53cb5addd93f362d2da448e5d0ed", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 35 failures (timeout) after 500 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: approved", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 500, "failed": 35, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "32776ccbfbae4efb3756039c198e48bbecc3f0e8349be9867929713969681223", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 40\u2713 14\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 40, "failed": 14, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "09b2f5a21ee1a418b40dbf0b5c9fb75c944a5471ecad7fd0ba665616ad3908f6", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 425 successes and 24 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 425, "failed": 24, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f61a278c75ae78f76b2ff2afba5da16baf46260b81fc8c7e255ec280cd9a5a0b", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=865 failed=6 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 865, "failed": 6, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa6e51739fe27be4d706f3536de359869a24735e2d418cc52ea520624d52161f", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 753 passing and 38 failing with connection refused. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 753, "failed": 38, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b263d6e4496d2735badfd8344a7b7eab510f11e9a0ca5c6ad1bc0d9e99e93f5", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 4 failures after 497 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 497, "failed": 4, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1401abb0a43eace93353a1928c156e8113c354daf6bc316216289b9985d85f91", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 733, \"failed\": 13}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 733, "failed": 13, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "78ef2c88ac586167fa57a725707c4342b720b9d3b1e83560780e6ae6053c3db5", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"784\" failed=\"36\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 784, "failed": 36, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5bd9f86ce7419ff8fdd89ddd369180b3b315a04950d2f0f2e32d393f02bb72fd", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 499 pass, 5 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 499, "failed": 5, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4a9147fc4f5474a4e33dac62b711d8e166d1b5d806010e5d3e04b99142c49bed", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 754 passing, 32 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 754, "failed": 32, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "053f8581ec03d971f308b7ef3f51d070631d15314436418590021727956fd6dd", "state": "JIRA-search: 38 failures / 458 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 458, "failed": 38, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bc354a9987e5983125d4b5056fb59ae0c43cf48f4ea611d048fe6e8731d419b9", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=393 failed=7 err=ImportError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 393, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3cd7b9f424e570dc0a085be97bfebfd8de871dc13e9415808623be0a3a3241c3", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 30 failures (ImportError) after 764 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 764, "failed": 30, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a2a77fc44678145849d33edc27af935406fc07d5c22b6a7e33bd9e968092d91d", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 317\u2713 12\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 317, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "861dc8f5701d75dd6230e4b299ccda4b691d4b99edbd8d8b53315576870ae18c", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 559 successes and 13 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 559, "failed": 13, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "75a24eb32917e1a2a4055451108ee99aa7e59fdf55e368b4f34ba3eb34f08ad6", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=77 failed=20 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 77, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8a5ddeb13ff8d5783fcd970c17cde2a23749f859af869f08c9a96c2d834fb019", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 358 passing and 10 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 358, "failed": 10, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a6a73c27460d54a7254c7a4a53bedf3525d3c873b7d9a2f3d0dd1f3cafdc3ea5", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 38 failures after 37 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 37, "failed": 38, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "985e4306832e58130e8514e68a93a7cfca80f52bed4f8806d4868f1eb6f297a1", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 146, \"failed\": 6}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 146, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0747731af34a1f861ab8fa2e3288a7cc6a71637f4f54b3f95d9e52371e32366c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"150\" failed=\"35\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 150, "failed": 35, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5931a3a0b831ebb83b794c9712f40edf4b12f81767dffb96afb46be316a47062", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 137 pass, 5 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 137, "failed": 5, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "64696ea8517affe5307affaa7870b7ff2814744d5ed3f06b1c32b8b8097d516d", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 928 passing, 16 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 928, "failed": 16, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4596086c6d2b48ccb6b773e21759ad111ec3b2b8efb1373691d92740886853d1", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 22 failures / 708 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 708, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "256a48854f5bfeba9acfb9ee9f10ec0b06daa29106555f9323731fc8e2df9628", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=749 failed=19 err=connection refused recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 749, "failed": 19, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "55fff2820a39f7c4ad6578a72692179d462eaa085a9bcbe0e89f7c0a488f834f", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 15 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 266 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 266, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "01718a4d1b6096ea05d7e32a9f899bcebf11efa10a4bf1641ca7dba6483116cf", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 364\u2713 34\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 364, "failed": 34, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ca774cfa6417586ed8c7f1e8739d0dcfe5ef387b18f477e23474437d45371af4", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 275 successes and 28 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 275, "failed": 28, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "756f2071bb50889e326305122ad284a8fe03908d275eacba01f3fe8ecdda4cc8", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=301 failed=37 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 301, "failed": 37, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "78baf3463045d37932d6f7de49d990168dff742ffe266d27a37f740a23ae2625", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 618 passing and 31 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 618, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a83f82ac5fcb735387d02b9ae6c33fb71a2b21446af6ee22aca308a38b6abce2", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 8 failures after 500 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 500, "failed": 8, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "315d75d8b0b1ab3c7ad919e2d834f8be9e161aba8f684fdcd8649ee0b2e13874", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 317, \"failed\": 9}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 317, "failed": 9, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f89c8fe9a85021bf81b7e2d24623a48afafa964a63f8146f483c84018bbb6d25", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"508\" failed=\"38\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 508, "failed": 38, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cb39d2411a0919340ef92a5f20eae845f5ed4846ac7bf9d5389420a79afee736", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 568 pass, 1 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 568, "failed": 1, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7750dd48760c599e8cd46af2e89ab0079ac3201c7a12b936171be22825ffb3d7", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 281 passing, 25 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 281, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8a310d20777068e99d2179f64dd24065685d822713471a4f031165c0d7ed8fdb", "state": "JIRA-search: 14 failures / 410 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 410, "failed": 14, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a137afce87af49a91e934144785ad76e0dd161d34ae1621c90595e4b40458c3a", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=765 failed=7 err=assertion mismatch recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 765, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2837ae761215e576d29c1a120f5af05b744d8754da7b01d89419b6e71f78baf1", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 12 failures (unexpected null) after 104 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\nrevert: rejected\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 104, "failed": 12, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "edf19175f9c86583077fdbb4ca6429e685bcc4e4fe94ec5c8b0611029a2860f5", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 526\u2713 30\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 526, "failed": 30, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "59dfdc34e1ae47705a487ce71f266d1c0af0ae09c757963ea7a6fa4a9456304f", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 637 successes and 35 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 637, "failed": 35, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cfbf67440a49180754a3198dd2c6af2e1f5f3df1c72e39ba363bdaaf3cb80f76", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=932 failed=39 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 932, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1127923128556335030ca880210075e4e8c55398b8a3fbbf586976f6f914643a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 592 passing and 24 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 592, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cd9355c6affb2b4339c64952b66f853118441e24053ff4c1fe430148f578b820", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 8 failures after 619 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 619, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7fa5a105a93a57170ece13f20518e575babfa706df05a8902644dc53c3f9b17e", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 411, \"failed\": 35}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 411, "failed": 35, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "53940281393c26dabea5f54d526dadec5fea20e9066bf930db97c3ec826b4fad", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"68\" failed=\"26\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 68, "failed": 26, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a9ef39efe1596f5d39d06dde582b9013ff4e8a334dc158783c79df03bc359e73", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 134 pass, 34 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 134, "failed": 34, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "81bf2da20d0ef479fd88055be471ed671cfdce78f9526c588429285795796e91", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 612 passing, 27 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 612, "failed": 27, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "16dfed736f22fed953609daeed8683889b72195eb9cd1be8222648187ee63142", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 4 failures / 549 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 549, "failed": 4, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "698782342a06a132e7cf91cbd2f1f852e1ada9477b61b66c3a604e75fd1bc57a", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=949 failed=15 err=timeout recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 949, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "79b993264c4f71486de35c90583fc1a8d5eb963f85be6882920c4de6c4d595ed", "state": "fix(search): investigate 2 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 670 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 670, "failed": 2, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "39e431297368d98bf773179cc6fbdd8d46d624020e180fb2c300ae7a868bb3d6", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 214\u2713 31\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 214, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e51dfc5827e5084c3e09ab0a31dc81740348e8a7ea5b6640311af5d1fa82c75e", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 80 successes and 23 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 80, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c9af6dd5d1e83325f0cc5a6b3854cfba91f123f1eef11563e5dc95754841d36f", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=296 failed=20 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 296, "failed": 20, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fef07bbb44b7a7119956da2b88fd83fabd8c9a61d0d7285af29e915ca49fdecd", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 120 passing and 6 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 120, "failed": 6, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "034a166e30b69d985de04bbd801073d5483d624a7f1de5d93230b46ed5f3dec4", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 794 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 794, "failed": 10, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "70d4f2a127bf7239ed72347fb7c44d256b010cd6516ed44cc70cfdb8d23f09cc", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 741, \"failed\": 32}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 741, "failed": 32, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4fa26bbc8218f36b5b7b08b7d8fac8d64d7300493968bce585c2d2eb5fc293e5", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"663\" failed=\"22\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 663, "failed": 22, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4496432d44923e3a699ab6c10045ed4e2d958e50af12ebde3f335fd88b0869d8", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 387 pass, 28 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 387, "failed": 28, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3c5df73e87cbe6883add505a1d18c5b61cd9f51672acec1bfd192ff77670dd57", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 34 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 34, "failed": 33, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e8d9842bc2e6011ee124f06cf284a01f7068f608a13a198cf0545ae6db5ffad2", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 29 failures / 148 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 148, "failed": 29, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "57470829992443c24dca757d76dec3fee6b69280c6dc1c72f3fbd45b4495a436", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=968 failed=23 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 968, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d31a4a0758c5c37d54662fc419ac72953d73ded3ebd96dcc7f2beb6e558d28e8", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 31 failures (unexpected null) after 478 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 478, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "702305281d5da775158b127b5ccf176087d790cd235b33268837e19c80837540", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 216\u2713 14\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 216, "failed": 14, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b756d625e3098b0e36fb12dad291f7a4dd84afdcfc07551d81244f9ec0d21192", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 204 successes and 18 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 204, "failed": 18, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "220d7c2df1a3dffae67a27d4855ae587fc221d234e1882126ee2454c23281be3", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=523 failed=15 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 523, "failed": 15, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a814a428b70703aeb205565cd8c3a94428358578dd55452bb1f8a0776e71e6a7", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 221 passing and 7 failing with connection refused. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 221, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "88073c8b2a7b04ebca916b449b855b8e4548c54260a8c00c18148ea346d0b483", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 990 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 990, "failed": 10, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "06e86e0fbed2de2cab11313497817eac4d2713d9cd8f943d0819b9a397d72c4b", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 622, \"failed\": 3}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 622, "failed": 3, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "04cb05e1ec0fcbbf13d832f0971a21d851e41a7decd9c5a4dc1f0420b5827b06", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"450\" failed=\"23\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 450, "failed": 23, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1f3e553ae3cc4463219867ef3b2241f49dccc31b4ef14e51af2454db1bf22a62", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 694 pass, 17 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 694, "failed": 17, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6818485d46bc05f84c309873b9ad062ea1adc7590ed425b3c35d7b626df22965", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 53 passing, 38 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 53, "failed": 38, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "38cb321ee52cc69e8e14a46b6fc4b0e5a4b3e7d61a679903c778c2eb99f8b9b8", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 21 failures / 330 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 330, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c6c7dfb7122743077e6a18e32f2e745b5de658fb91a6497504b4bc0891ea1149", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=254 failed=24 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 254, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e069b32d1cf116a8466cd35dd4c4a4a7f71581f88ce1757c53fcf246d73ee66a", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 27 failures (ImportError) after 429 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 429, "failed": 27, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bc426cf9764a38e302c5d6f1c511ea0482c0c5fc9f7362b2d367929d159746c0", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 858\u2713 13\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 858, "failed": 13, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c328cfa06a8ea4d6feb5cf205b14ba068e7809f60b85b9a0f3b0c01711464849", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 925 successes and 9 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 925, "failed": 9, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "43ccc8344f3d7fc30b0471dadfd2a90cc0b98fa0efdc7dcf624c58a3d670bc4e", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=694 failed=37 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 694, "failed": 37, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6333e0a54458e6fb6783a51272ecebf69a224cc6e0ebb31e6697acd9c1eafac4", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 857 passing and 9 failing with connection refused. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 857, "failed": 9, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a67eabceeb1cd20a71b18c697150b291b7582810f116588d8d333b2a18f20872", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 3 failures after 730 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 730, "failed": 3, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e69687292f702afb0bbff0b892b15cec0fd5c80347f41d442fcd1083620cdbc7", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 315, \"failed\": 36}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 315, "failed": 36, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "105d302207357f5886ed34a42b32652868ef71185f2792e5fdabb6a212364c25", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"622\" failed=\"25\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 622, "failed": 25, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b2e6733737d153faf2492fba70a7ce8201ae3062656b126317c0b6afc761e073", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 333 pass, 39 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 333, "failed": 39, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ab7ba96849ac1ac07345aaee94167b32a66d5f9e02af33a298f068d5b7c084d1", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 162 passing, 2 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 162, "failed": 2, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "32f582a3cdd6848bab3a62dee8f7b9a565819873329814798176077ff1d9a3c2", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 15 failures / 934 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 934, "failed": 15, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "55b50b47d428eda5766c19321cb79fc13a463effbde67b21f2e086d15e795a4d", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=43 failed=5 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 43, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "918b2aae9eab7d8a370f1cf41e743fb509b7553510e4953b7116aba25f4305e5", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 16 failures (unexpected null) after 273 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 273, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8c2fb5a688ac69c00219866e44371da9690dd2bae3bd6341e859652333901b5a", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 664\u2713 21\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 664, "failed": 21, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0a4c9ebec8df84ad8e343e1f72d0110b1a1c0aeb39df54910e4770c62f527ef4", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 523 successes and 12 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 523, "failed": 12, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eb4200c70638e77cb9b225d185e711556389b1e114310199461975ec64f0a49c", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=488 failed=5 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 488, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6a4904200f35f715d33ed3f688fe3bded49d01de895c53beecac748d91cf2bef", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 335 passing and 18 failing with connection refused. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 335, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e71a3e4e1641e7b8a3fa5b367b6378ed62503bc6791104e93febdc25505e071f", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 30 failures after 24 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 24, "failed": 30, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9758330544339168fdd6dfda653335898c6003579902299dc206f75efb22727e", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 310, \"failed\": 13}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 310, "failed": 13, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e406b0d9a3d99105c25b0a77fdac433a967470b55bd790a08eefe9ae51f90eb9", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"299\" failed=\"37\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 299, "failed": 37, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b0279ee4dd43b0be478a2bfdb5bf06c1f1e733d0e01aecb6caab59bddd198d09", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 376 pass, 39 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 376, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3181792b266d39d0785a0738835b8801e500967f4fec65a12710205d515c6f0b", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 79 passing, 9 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 79, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c13897e96f4340d5e5a32cde28546f37ccb362b3892371e6f5f2eb680795cb77", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 28 failures / 351 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 351, "failed": 28, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6375834176112e9392ec2c86145b4a7833a15e5298512ca49f54876503c11136", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=749 failed=35 err=unexpected null recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 749, "failed": 35, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cfcd53920850331e3b607dfb9a667c775427bf4bf1d636c3c916e9d040f080ec", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 10 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 858 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 858, "failed": 10, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "93b0f3472c0cd80dea34dd061dc25eb3f16afce49b58461656cf0c26c79abde0", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 810\u2713 33\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 810, "failed": 33, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "13206a9dae33411e9db65faef1197d27d36f691ef64f011ac73461a017375e89", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 7 successes and 31 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 7, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8b40b2f00b735f1298288bcade1405c2cd9f66ba1ebe61524f0b7fbd69296713", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=806 failed=7 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 806, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dd22054f91e5424364b9fa4fdc88acff6adc68058cca2e4c47a299bcd0f08ebc", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 801 passing and 29 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 801, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7f02afb10f28c98e8913843baeaed83ff74064e23cd74a39d7c23041a86e8383", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 19 failures after 70 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 70, "failed": 19, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "731919f908c564a958edda2a33f3f1adeac35e0e2229e18db50a6ba6e8d809af", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 592, \"failed\": 18}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 592, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1ebea0b94bfb3bf9746f70b5afa296d2e5318614d3086a3581cb21421f6e2af5", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"294\" failed=\"26\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 294, "failed": 26, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9b62f6c1f0413e9d70d7269a1c9c65110ad5be4183b8681f33f30e632fc0da81", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 958 pass, 17 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 958, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e5896856c4d8c4b2daed1099348bd645efd9422b2754c7f945d1b7e3de2b7a1c", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 717 passing, 37 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 717, "failed": 37, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "40e612816732319f207c6d2bc5084d7d105f0403b95b94eab3098bf526077d72", "state": "JIRA-caching: 1 failures / 729 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 729, "failed": 1, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "600789be05a0e935d1d0951908c895e73c877d286d56368c1696a09635919d80", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=633 failed=33 err=unexpected null recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 633, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1a43c20da49855fb094b99acbbd7df985d4373f621419eeeff51b73794232348", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 29 failures (ImportError) after 854 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 854, "failed": 29, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6b7140340b740f5068ba35fef260eda4ce85e8b49f6e55014535b50a2af0b32b", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 3\u2713 39\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 3, "failed": 39, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1526a3c7c46f667b1d95b54feaaa74a36ce5054a206bd560fd216131f49cfae7", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 375 successes and 28 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 375, "failed": 28, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7e353cba685e98626d5718860e36369bdee52f608f71332903503968ce12c21a", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=906 failed=39 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 906, "failed": 39, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ec1630bb91feca54ebd6411b05fdb4c60c0e93f9e1db2c9393abb779c9c37526", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 690 passing and 7 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 690, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3a34bd5c77686ac3ba23ebf716ac9f8464bd19d5c8fc5ef7c8d7563c3b236d5d", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 24 failures after 172 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 172, "failed": 24, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fd645e230d305485d23929c8e0c7d5d8885d27f54dca9d980a0f3209cb5f89a2", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 334, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 334, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "03643660091a114f8a2c8d444392bf860f13cf2d07f5ebfbc4cf199af70e1522", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"60\" failed=\"7\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 60, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c90088d348fa20a981e9db99ab29b47467a7df268e20a56af4f31e48c0b73ce", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 748 pass, 26 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 748, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2d53abdca8681f51d773e05db1c279c7ce5079b84b4a7cdfa89b980030f9be79", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 702 passing, 29 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 702, "failed": 29, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "64c97b73ba688be8e4df57d6ff6004cf2877107aa2b2177b42f6cb073393444c", "state": "JIRA-billing: 30 failures / 430 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 430, "failed": 30, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "42618a19ef652e6414aa6c65667d9a6f05fb2cd33214ee44f297574c3def940b", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=859 failed=25 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 859, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d80bf05c2fb762c23e0e2075429940dd5b48946ca08afa3377d1371ca0dfa7ad", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 3 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 813 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 813, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c932ed47fbb8f6db801df393a0790910c721824034ea9210bf3a392de8328fda", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 635\u2713 34\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 635, "failed": 34, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2b4acc62e66a868486734845e88a257c76788aa1e94e2f5510f7579b38f47183", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 244 successes and 18 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 244, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b6870893cc8aa9abba6355a8137db5c676d9e93b4727aa12e37043d153410bed", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=756 failed=35 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 756, "failed": 35, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2a057d1542e322649e0b6297b66e6b2505a85237381f2cb959537a414a15e7f8", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 770 passing and 25 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 770, "failed": 25, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c0014d888102b05f405d752abaa9c202564a59b4123ed363a2fcbe755278c223", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 2 failures after 541 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 541, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "710556b14bbc5e879ed05683ce2a85a71db188c6b54d91f7e7e76ce8b3a067ad", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 384, \"failed\": 13}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 384, "failed": 13, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e16adaadc17f12e269dcbaa38b283cf7c267eecfbd9bcebaf3a11b19ca4cb4c7", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"111\" failed=\"34\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 111, "failed": 34, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d796289e162b2a3287c424b570f07a7dc5b7e9baf9ba7bd470b0ac7998d0f821", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 682 pass, 27 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 682, "failed": 27, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "29f96ba69c0ced6ddbf8a3a2ed776f41b1937ff927cbbc480f09b9f1291a39cf", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 509 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 509, "failed": 15, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6028547545ee350c0f6a333dc7f1db7bfe3c49824aa6873dcf2abc0c4368b893", "state": "JIRA-caching: 22 failures / 912 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 912, "failed": 22, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "64a57f67d111b714301b203a8e108018f15262160537eea37a8378337131eb9f", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=286 failed=27 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 286, "failed": 27, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "14d523da8ee5f80982b21310417d3e5e68f9d6844f53a26cd3fe721439ae6f24", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 17 failures (assertion mismatch) after 78 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 78, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "36410cdf2d34b4a96f420ee0f8b6448bb8702e2d51feeecc2c98b091b4936449", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 359\u2713 9\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 359, "failed": 9, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0ced5d3cf8f9a27b286a12c66925e664bd094f20ace18c12f7a96fde10227085", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 779 successes and 22 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 779, "failed": 22, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f5be4f707cdad4c9a0c1e3138e040315427a83c7992f846b0133cb9b98bf250b", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=19 failed=19 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 19, "failed": 19, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e5415c77ea29ab86fe675d6f23340b03893df27782a59be0e3d5d8e981c5412f", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 142 passing and 19 failing with connection refused. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 142, "failed": 19, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "547a076921d8f434dcd31402ddca167a947af6d915d89e03d852e3670093ba2c", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 8 failures after 410 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 410, "failed": 8, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "97235e518364bf021ac1a708c0d5d4190e14dc1660d5e6287a1e55908378854e", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 71, \"failed\": 27}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 71, "failed": 27, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f476137414d8838c445d46dac06d09119cfc4ed77473692a8708b0d641c24389", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"550\" failed=\"11\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 550, "failed": 11, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "979a63bc3ad3f39893898bbf1fb65cfbbc4d66a41276793af4fab9bff4d6baf0", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 967 pass, 11 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 967, "failed": 11, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c3ae45f66c9642007c3bce5609a1ab30574d17881d0465539ee5a777c180c5d7", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 817 passing, 37 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 817, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b496130ae5b82a7c0ae5b3665856aab4a288cd479e6d5d3295252288682a9b9", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 36 failures / 419 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 419, "failed": 36, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5dca07fd89f43087b06d4dc73ca63435522df95fa9809fb9a9eb995fb47e0425", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=576 failed=5 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 576, "failed": 5, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9c6d62c8d759e36612ad6b9917be60b7f9e998f720ff61131625663a915565fa", "state": "fix(search): investigate 23 failures (connection refused) after 781 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 781, "failed": 23, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7f39a1fef97714cb233840cceeb3b6c9598b6243826c0a40edbd46b3b8f23675", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 417\u2713 31\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 417, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "71a834113c149639cdbe91178bc54e07de38364f996e0e8eeb821af162941ca0", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 853 successes and 14 failures (timeout). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 853, "failed": 14, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e79dc0b7c635661f3653e2f41b400439c970d3339713578670838e80bf165447", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=212 failed=32 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 212, "failed": 32, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "31ec99de7d0b213867feaafb0eb909277c32d54c9ab1d6552a6fb0fc84144420", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 493 passing and 16 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 493, "failed": 16, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c94c0bec473b05be13e5042123a657eba0464a91232e891338fd6a2328340f4a", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 30 failures after 547 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 547, "failed": 30, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4ec0036b3d860ac15fe4a36a0f26c0b9106a4ddd615e74e7328f184c14debe95", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 945, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 945, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3e5acccc0b6b4664ec4fdb88c6145d8d879461bb59eee09d6efaf2051cdd9e10", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"875\" failed=\"13\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 875, "failed": 13, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f62a4901d9eb207d693a008beb68e88c1a7fdfb0b20250562664d40659a7bdbe", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 185 pass, 34 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 185, "failed": 34, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a16451617efdbab8a1bd81ec8869fc544e91cb826057cd68a19b2f12cf98561a", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 80 passing, 32 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 80, "failed": 32, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d04b003c36e3254be54c488c5bde4b2c84fdfe7bbbe760db2b5b8ce910f9b75d", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 16 failures / 703 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 703, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d45fa737540325bcaa978ce4d706a33527ff8d4caa342ebcca66eda110c3a66f", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=940 failed=27 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 940, "failed": 27, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2fdbd53731548ead4561f7494c7fd877c9f031fdcc9bac1f957aa16c41949f86", "state": "fix(search): investigate 18 failures (timeout) after 551 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 551, "failed": 18, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8b5f0c7a1d20758cd069890e93a6914220e103c676c8d7eb87c3c733d3d0f8ec", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 697\u2713 26\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 697, "failed": 26, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d968483885f5b0c4c89c0fe2d01f57e3cc13f2d78248b64b911f7a7c893d8689", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 243 successes and 30 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 243, "failed": 30, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e58ad3dc4d44f401da057be0253aa5c279f0c1e58a309e04e0d3c1fed0b99c4d", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=165 failed=29 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 165, "failed": 29, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bbebdc51c8856a18db0b49f21adfcf66050fcc2d068b6bd90e94454da6f13fad", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 294 passing and 14 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 294, "failed": 14, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0121e521b5ac737fc2ae638feac5b33280c7360a931c779da7ef845882347348", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 16 failures after 744 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 744, "failed": 16, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8111b0cd797b45c54cae92021ae80055a455cb245d6e11a37fbb2bead61268d6", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 167, \"failed\": 37}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 167, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "54540eb20155515e156db9f581e22d3fe221e62a55e2ce1571a32e0298446db7", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"130\" failed=\"39\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 130, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8dae911e1706b1afb9a4bd5c386a1f4f0631ca7cfa17b13dabc550c518435050", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 844 pass, 26 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 844, "failed": 26, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dfd5c7e566a5402eb80e4662fabe5520c9a3481d738cd10e8b26b06f29a123e4", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 687 passing, 36 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 687, "failed": 36, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e226e91bdf152aef65c9a938e5722319dad8973b200e4996038ca477a66c40eb", "state": "JIRA-uploads: 24 failures / 205 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 205, "failed": 24, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6461fede3659cb2b7ebae10ba4d24077ee9934e7f0af5dbe83471346afb55be4", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=145 failed=6 err=connection refused recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 145, "failed": 6, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "855c5971b554315bc1e2f7837b993f01c7585ad65c28dfbd84ecc83f4b78c21b", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 19 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 598 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 598, "failed": 19, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2e6fe889e9fd51d45c1cca8c74a80a63558642e0d35fd331ed1a168e6f18439c", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 366\u2713 18\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 366, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bcb3311f306906c2447ef69533407d2ea19ba45ca60c8c3e55cfec31d128038d", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 26 successes and 33 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 26, "failed": 33, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "19e11a06cb59e302115caec3748d08c65e3f6ff32907f52c238e01854507d24b", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=991 failed=37 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 991, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0a1351f9a97827a3e6786348aa23393da64095f92d5cec7bbd57a52749fd1338", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 465 passing and 34 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 465, "failed": 34, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ea42467777e43ef5844b42f63a4123af7f820ea6f62950e303a634380069573a", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 822 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 822, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a1fb82cd08dd4219b6a2a67b2430b219957cb488ecc41d9cc2c7d8484e8c1f47", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 962, \"failed\": 23}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 962, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5ce8ef86aa7cfbceaad89db2993a0db27fbad8eed1e64b5f7e3cc552ab0ff683", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"651\" failed=\"25\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 651, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fcda55e9ec3d3293fa32009e1cfa3f5428e69fb4d4363294485c939c134f2c0e", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 371 pass, 17 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 371, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7a93ece08ce6d9a08ca8a3837eb74a0ab8a1830056933975eac3ab7d831084da", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 441 passing, 2 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 441, "failed": 2, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b562d42c105a35966f131aa892be0c896f26098f80ada6e926c58ecd82b3b3ed", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 28 failures / 303 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 303, "failed": 28, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fa33f7ac27ce009bb918cc48bb3cc4fe6edc0e5739366695a275eb9f8850d26a", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=315 failed=21 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 315, "failed": 21, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8827e8d7b2a71e5fe5c8328db6daec4fba8658ab391cdac48a7bb5d61c52c600", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 19 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 152 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 152, "failed": 19, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5420d52a2936556c8e4e64f6a420c8b374a4c04934729ae9def2c08eecca3532", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 848\u2713 11\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 848, "failed": 11, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "804e217db3934c95e72141362250d0ee72e5b8c4f6c7db59dac5c67f681ea1a6", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 20 successes and 6 failures (timeout). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 20, "failed": 6, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "927899947ecc9f63d62bd5d80ed7a30abf4d34bd2531954eabda7f84fad03758", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=872 failed=13 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 872, "failed": 13, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "babab9be884d9e81b7625dd19644cf55c5d05160464774f6faddfc06ac426e5e", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 81 passing and 31 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 81, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c00975c91c91a9fe6a3fe74cd4511080d666f87c886ea2529e9c55d44fe55d65", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 9 failures after 780 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 780, "failed": 9, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bde265a6e3acbf1d0bb0184c2a82f72f1d90ba07e339a9c090b94687337317e2", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 593, \"failed\": 9}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 593, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bf31d0576b5982ee12adb8702bd512e83fed8eca1c56d9f0234871e213ac5129", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"972\" failed=\"9\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 972, "failed": 9, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5bd389319797793dfb30fe5f7a62c6384574ec8c97c11ed916871a7ca9351bd6", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 786 pass, 33 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 786, "failed": 33, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1f2097bda99793caebdd70d68eccc05623b268e1acca52986bb8d43f0900e745", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 982 passing, 29 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 982, "failed": 29, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a7a691a17eabce79eb0e89de830ab386ec1d617dbea60949c5eb28e8efea451b", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 3 failures / 756 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 756, "failed": 3, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "866811c1ab5bd04ace1770eca22d15db99bbc72370a4fdbfd379d8e90b7b19e0", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=301 failed=4 err=timeout recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 301, "failed": 4, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8f343ca092b44721945f0c587b05837b3425df0ae9da342e2f62529e1914b964", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 3 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 720 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 720, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f2586fc9daba30a20ebae9bc83f12bbfc0f245d953ae711cf9860f692e6a48ae", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 380\u2713 7\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 380, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7991c570ca0a6a7aef1b754e70058429d6eead6bda25a5e136d9bd9f36a3a16c", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 272 successes and 28 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 272, "failed": 28, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e3a9af66b6d4c610f15c7d3eb47b71f4a01d0c1ef83ed77cb5e88400cc1ccc41", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=398 failed=37 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 398, "failed": 37, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5fc30c8dc5465d06386424f4722882f6053b262208a9118119e6a865d622e3c4", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 594 passing and 30 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 594, "failed": 30, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "855eff482a5be7a0ba7712e8bf4d36475b4bbea889352918375e3c6f61a1d25f", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 14 failures after 660 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 660, "failed": 14, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "853bd4f77db5a2b9d600e92195b26b947a815e5e963fe07df3ba2abb5ebbb1cf", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 119, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 119, "failed": 5, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cabbeef480981c720339808c3e3e7f13b848d97b78a7dbc5703a7c9e7f32e7f9", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"953\" failed=\"16\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 953, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1929c74c3dfb9a14cda9bd5c69301d6af49bce0561379d88194f9bd927f579f4", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 526 pass, 27 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 526, "failed": 27, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "661f4136a73a0b7cd25280d80a440a3ebe2fc4060f689c9bb9e1864a0e21cffe", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 553 passing, 6 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 553, "failed": 6, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "34558e3c980647154d31ee0923b5d28e5bd36b2dceccf4508a7bd6706ced008f", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 22 failures / 715 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 715, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8a99dbff2486966e3444ebf32fce75d605d097c8050b5fd72ae1bf0fedbfbc71", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=262 failed=33 err=timeout recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 262, "failed": 33, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "08d292f921930bb2ee1e7efd97faf6ccfebf8c7e8d5d8e99cb97c63f1f8b0d70", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 31 failures (timeout) after 650 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 650, "failed": 31, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "238260632f5f241569bb1ab9643011e16e79ef00921589c84960e8a49bc1e3cc", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 596\u2713 18\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 596, "failed": 18, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "872eeee1c2b7bbc683c72d30c11742c30ff74938d20881c6307ae12ba3e2e91f", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 414 successes and 6 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 414, "failed": 6, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9d2cab6729337ad485bca2844b1af3af2e4b260a478af8d2ab4f6efe208534cf", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=509 failed=4 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 509, "failed": 4, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0343ebbf0d3bacb71ddc05d468362e6bae959d6bf154f1499c0fde0cdea3ce65", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 923 passing and 37 failing with ImportError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 923, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "01b9c747e68fba6bf8614debbffdf714c8a063e440eed35c8c886aaf355a8a24", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 24 failures after 65 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 65, "failed": 24, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4c5621c4e152cfcf89bf6bbb0c926c4ebe20895d32e00581362c8d7ad25afaeb", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 589, \"failed\": 38}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 589, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7fae12ac71a4f1ab2157ed283dd749afd2f7217eea8ed64394dbdc73167c622a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"777\" failed=\"23\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 777, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2178829e2099799652ad7ade7ff885ff502eac3795279e0e990cc8d9869339e5", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 657 pass, 18 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 657, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "a9222e352c9cda6e3cc85ef260d5c6223b185a30ffebfa6b03d51a6bf578f9ca", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 851 passing, 34 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: merged.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 851, "failed": 34, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8e7825be90499bcf3443b569292e3e27409fe6a5f7a6d5927a11735f52a76971", "state": "JIRA-search: 12 failures / 374 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 374, "failed": 12, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7622f54004d21bff523fbe02c1bc59a0fe9366ff94bfa2809cf6bb761b19bf8e", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=998 failed=5 err=connection refused recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 998, "failed": 5, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a40fb554e5749615f8b487fdcf8892c119d13b3a2b2b109dfc7299d807621821", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 15 failures (connection refused) after 209 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 209, "failed": 15, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3945afcfd28c70ceeea150784d4e28140a0fa73621acf9a0b70843aa481af1cc", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 489\u2713 21\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 489, "failed": 21, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2b822b823937edb44bf3efc929845950ece7fdeeff24a17113bb10709112015e", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 706 successes and 23 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 706, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8cbf48f9d524c3cec36d461f001f87ab8b537e9b66d34d03acbcf70292b2e13a", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=872 failed=39 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 872, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "57214100108f703b7fb6d1403bce65b29f0833a7e95e7297070b51fa1c1d7626", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 894 passing and 5 failing with ImportError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 894, "failed": 5, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ab321369f29bca8814fcf8aa8a5ab7dab117540878700b7758e73f3e350ba216", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 35 failures after 275 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 275, "failed": 35, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3b1a49c2d63b981cb684dbf3275aee019993d4ab759ba2edd5c5548a61d4c127", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 569, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 569, "failed": 12, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d1505c411aa9616aca980b7a9981dcabaa6b5c3348d0b9b61ba2e86e69843eac", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"170\" failed=\"31\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 170, "failed": 31, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "263251f561f98fab10882cddc4fef5ab044856938bbd3a532823b0068b2e3d99", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 642 pass, 12 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 642, "failed": 12, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9abb0c012fe9ca65dd473b01466cf51a6f252e4257c66ccb4bf271c48cc1f259", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 385 passing, 31 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 385, "failed": 31, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8d6375f828ca3020b4d7c2e9d4ac83bb03c17b7c4169d10faa0abba59b839125", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 30 failures / 723 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 723, "failed": 30, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c88c53020dd5e33e855a46eee376b8be0e19b0a0b9849e03db2bacecf8a60ef8", "state": "TRACE task=caching passed=937 failed=11 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 937, "failed": 11, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7c255647bc95418f260b7ed2a64f5d1d850ec9b69071bd73b425fdcb1d636f91", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 11 failures (ImportError) after 416 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 416, "failed": 11, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4e516caa6a443ded13c6d60227501d1d895ebbb6d78e940e1cf810312e2b3e7b", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 310\u2713 2\u2717 (timeout). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 310, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cf83ab9e1358af8aba8d6f702c5a4aa6fbe0ede44a4b2365d3940086b0e0d75f", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 95 successes and 23 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 95, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ed5682685bc6b6c55a27438bd33d3c8f6e2043c46a23b0ef72b9b7dcd9b567a3", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=53 failed=24 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 53, "failed": 24, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "70766e326427a95b840aebe35abb2a891c2fa5d3daa22eb5e1f455b626684b5e", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 68 passing and 17 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 68, "failed": 17, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "172fe32cb86a95aa11a1cb2d1628c407d5884908041fa2ff39c359c6dc2f7e1d", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 38 failures after 46 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 46, "failed": 38, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "095911917cf532f9ce051c0cf97fa26d559c87163025b801d873382334a1bbbc", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 99, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 99, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bbf4537513c64d9fc38c9f5a371abae08fc17bb92fcaef16d6f98d28eb0c94cb", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"75\" failed=\"7\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 75, "failed": 7, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e303b81f5cf3d2991aa4067ad3c45a43e5331cf45341e507854f0b93775a6fcc", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 957 pass, 30 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 957, "failed": 30, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "debc2f35dd147baa52d477804388b459c2096bbbae7068d38f29725bbb5800d8", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 208 passing, 1 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 208, "failed": 1, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cf7635ec877ccb32d6580ef1122b8daaa967c916d8b10cb1878dfa65e4b5eef4", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 37 failures / 780 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 780, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a27d8cfe062d60d0546b249e6de0fa057e0744209296acafd516ab8856865557", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=300 failed=3 err=ImportError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 300, "failed": 3, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c7b9b97061c59a8c4b549a81464b6070066583e4db84bc1a4e99c6b64b2fb811", "state": "fix(caching): investigate 33 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 547 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 547, "failed": 33, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7676630b3a6c4ba9c6146277801317338ab0a9ee2c62b4d987ee2efe3f328a05", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 756\u2713 25\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 756, "failed": 25, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "32cdd707bcf639efb1e80f5768baf53e920bf891ac7c21605e30d907510cc886", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 120 successes and 20 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 120, "failed": 20, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "618547050d4e97f3a8db9468a544c00e7631989b626a7d62e7f8f86fd63fd848", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=688 failed=23 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 688, "failed": 23, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "44b9f3c4dbc9302b624d02fcf20c75f1c21e08e8f7a07edac8ded0e252eb5d05", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 467 passing and 9 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 467, "failed": 9, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5c5f5114ca3157953ffa791e7ea6aa974022efccff303a59f658977775414a8b", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 31 failures after 279 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 279, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "af87ff9c5053d0b182a06136bd750e30ddffea14b379fe71ab42f95e6d446eb7", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 496, \"failed\": 8}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 496, "failed": 8, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "563a939548a3c0b41622486c70e9a6704fc0e76a36570885c491a8c7746971c2", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"381\" failed=\"11\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 381, "failed": 11, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b4f164157bc70f6949339a547283ec0a5d430c43bc559f2713aca88a84b02161", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 48 pass, 20 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 48, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d8dece2acbd101b854b9d3f793f569518ca87c25a8db2b1b9fc98c23fbf5407b", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 153 passing, 8 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 153, "failed": 8, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a034263edad0c411fdf896d8b0420068c086f83f42a3dbd3abad033e919d94a5", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 22 failures / 405 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 405, "failed": 22, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9defb5c0786efd4d65cdf61471e0146833cf86a3426bbc2817554997ee20e60b", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=55 failed=15 err=ImportError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 55, "failed": 15, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "fbab1bd6391ea7f315f7aa2d9a56d1e48bd23f290c3c8d6f40b955f31b8c0a3f", "state": "fix(search): investigate 22 failures (connection refused) after 794 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 794, "failed": 22, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0bd8b57307816de5144d26c24fc00895a922ba5c3fd51bb91e79c49cf6b979e3", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 949\u2713 29\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 949, "failed": 29, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2066cd0efff101cc2ce03bfbf27a76440e8318ec841e803e50dffc397923951c", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 346 successes and 25 failures (timeout). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 346, "failed": 25, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4264e95ea6a465a768b6857e85c4003bf1cb571776ccb75f8e30e1e48ccd8bdb", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=262 failed=38 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 262, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5c1d864415fb1607b8e7c933056d16f2ddf93e5c57cf0878814233c357117ffb", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 389 passing and 17 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 389, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "84ca2a66b7f05478a7a4297cb617d32a279fd58f9976a0c2df378454b3327674", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 28 failures after 454 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 454, "failed": 28, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b4e3fef48988a7cbc19782260d9b05f9bc0b965d106445ace6235eb4f1c38312", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 62, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 62, "failed": 5, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3492fe2aa1acf6c4558118aa5f23ec41608d7bc67e2fee8fe11a0466322360e6", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"243\" failed=\"13\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 243, "failed": 13, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "cead370243314dc073fb71ef80aec9428ac4cebd3864ea6712c90eba739d0dc1", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 294 pass, 37 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 294, "failed": 37, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "960955d9725d78d1c6d6e42765ca7dbbe8edc7509738fda03dd1c27e3c8352cf", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 841 passing, 26 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 841, "failed": 26, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5c457a17056582059c57777c735af1dbd61b0007a627175385b098325ae23121", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 12 failures / 880 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 880, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "28acc10304c5b7765803d018bc8b186dcfb658643b80363ea18db462243a53a7", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=20 failed=10 err=connection refused recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 20, "failed": 10, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "18a9991aeda74c2ab349fe3855ec15b176f3e4b15707d29e73e37f6313671122", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 19 failures (assertion mismatch) after 708 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 708, "failed": 19, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "828a0cf40c5b3d2e6b7d19e2d73a667f6a14e879c685a44e2136cb746ab7c64d", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 773\u2713 23\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 773, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2a3a0df6a4d03310d3d5068ad409fb4d96d5025ca6396a98248decdfea1fccfd", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 769 successes and 16 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 769, "failed": 16, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b6bdf2037598f09aaf2aa4c90e2d49f1707403ae6a4269e43c1406348776091b", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=91 failed=18 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 91, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "45f73bd637da70992cb1b3edd1dcf4f8dbe40812088a552537e02e623bf0ba93", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 691 passing and 28 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 691, "failed": 28, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f73a3e04e7646d5a0f5994a2ba34238b620bffadfbdc679dc02cd8e0940a5fd3", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 38 failures after 459 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 459, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c9848e8c02e71cf338651a086b3c49e83dcb31808b6e5281e47c6acd70c82134", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 457, \"failed\": 36}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 457, "failed": 36, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4365fc2ecff091b4fc8b7c8c5fcde28a64dd3dc41024f379ea980d5dd5e70674", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"787\" failed=\"7\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 787, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "82aaecd8b9d348d35eebc7559637492288fb67ee95ddb21dec998d66b9ff4e85", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 218 pass, 14 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 218, "failed": 14, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "65140a77d70908bca4e2ba75b15be5921ce7e42abf2a681c5574347224e2b014", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 548 passing, 3 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 548, "failed": 3, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "12a0a22cf5e597ab63e38ff9ff3b9c889e3a3affb31f98dc528058aa42a63414", "state": "JIRA-billing: 18 failures / 805 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 805, "failed": 18, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "deee60ec23f9fb1648a426c5ead83160484df56e9cc4a2a8f06024e42d127b2b", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=818 failed=33 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 818, "failed": 33, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b95fdfe155d65a78e3111abbe997d5fc6fedfe03d50bbdb937f2ecdd9d815591", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 12 failures (timeout) after 349 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 349, "failed": 12, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8a34906338af9fcc116b70500be519f2134c8952c27e72578971fa717b43e650", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 819\u2713 36\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 819, "failed": 36, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bab26a2604b7786999ac1b7b4c1e3ad338453f3de6ac1b64ebbb01ef3651323c", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 509 successes and 20 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 509, "failed": 20, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f945bca9e4ba3519bee6c27d34c50ce6666bd0bf9c6fb772352691c60ab84777", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=511 failed=13 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 511, "failed": 13, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5e226a738d5ac5807b0c8fe7866d67b3e52e5cb0cf3b5d6c0725a246909287d7", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 652 passing and 18 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 652, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "66f2e7f9f7083840b9cadb1b388f594b025d10245b18d2830c0faa39c7d1b90b", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 16 failures after 670 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 670, "failed": 16, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "264136474b122e8b0efbed2f636491069fd30da108ab4bada7a070fd86f9653b", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 185, \"failed\": 30}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 185, "failed": 30, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e01f1b942ed06f38f4d2a9d83591b41af61a57a6096f0adc01bcef24eaa6ad71", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"521\" failed=\"12\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 521, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "77c5b2e4add1523cc8011f7c98f64bc5147d35903c16fc019ad674ce23ee8ae6", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 894 pass, 23 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 894, "failed": 23, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0e3d4f7fc3a52f5368818a9896ffafc85949c4f1557186f3b36ab23817c263a1", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 507 passing, 32 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 507, "failed": 32, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cc5520c104d0157a3f4e717281c9cabea586d3dc2a9d6645c1b3542bddf4135a", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 39 failures / 372 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 372, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4589c36332a4b87f6544aa98c6d18d028beb8d3c215e1e97b6d4b5a353402918", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=208 failed=6 err=unexpected null recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 208, "failed": 6, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aa9570bdeaf79bbcc580a56690dbaaae37658b5cf3232b2dce567d3bc5ed72a1", "state": "fix(search): investigate 20 failures (unexpected null) after 138 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 138, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "15774f273d08d96588478ce760f780d58582ab7a7c2b1a9366e150024af05e4c", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 527\u2713 9\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 527, "failed": 9, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "22c387c563185a99c554b27889ed293289107e1a5eb078850cd3a3deeb3de87d", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 728 successes and 11 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 728, "failed": 11, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bd5324d830ed7e9967b4d64520489b24039196a97ed8788c6e10da4f01420cd0", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=837 failed=20 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 837, "failed": 20, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "bf66db7c6de7a89c058b4e7a4e30ff7673e8afeb734723bde280a515e5523262", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 995 passing and 5 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 995, "failed": 5, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f5dea74098273546d8b42d453f0b4909c20ddc190130590c65c17f9d6b965963", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 25 failures after 525 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 525, "failed": 25, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9210b0280a47defe6815d3522a0eb059c1cd568133f7b0ed2e50b9c2ba334822", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 251, \"failed\": 2}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 251, "failed": 2, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1eefcb5452e98c09fff067c40a60106b88a54dc088511d65fd2ae01dffe7e038", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"712\" failed=\"12\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 712, "failed": 12, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "881d49bff56cc30cd03d9b0a25be4a5451486c45135245ad52e3fdc429248d33", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 332 pass, 2 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 332, "failed": 2, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "da604b570038cc4416ba005806f4664c55070defcb9c141e61c754254dde26c7", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 813 passing, 38 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 813, "failed": 38, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7eee1cfa6cfba6de684659b961518bc3e3d23b79970495db4b394eb2585e2e4a", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 28 failures / 58 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 58, "failed": 28, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e09578409dc64993d546da0ac4be544a01c9ded8a3d3a53f1b278823b917d16a", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=299 failed=24 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 299, "failed": 24, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d45d2b03219b5189b860e25dc633d735a06cce55bdedef436e8541315a39c491", "state": "fix(search): investigate 18 failures (unexpected null) after 235 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: merged\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 235, "failed": 18, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3384a4c0786cab7b74712b217044bb816cc516e9c8aa3e431a88a24a8957d429", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 922\u2713 20\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 922, "failed": 20, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "9711b7a586ec6b8c53ba8891eb9482ee0ea5cb82f96046414908925e5e272409", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 320 successes and 8 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 320, "failed": 8, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "aa1f7c26eff05e49455cf44ed968c317af4638fa2bca49950243745eedfb48ca", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=892 failed=31 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 892, "failed": 31, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fcae483405481281b448a6869ce73604dc1b2109a96b95b47cf892546c6442a5", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 759 passing and 24 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 759, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ffe5d1c472483a3573b10997325633c9e029547e55d8c026b1785e196626350c", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 39 failures after 217 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 217, "failed": 39, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "16145d3af07f5ce4223e367a15a26a5b32a950d7aeb992689085fff959b68df3", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 672, \"failed\": 12}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 672, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "799ee33007f516f6b6a8adf3fc2cb78438cf642370f3ebf32a9a503941a5e51c", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"280\" failed=\"21\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 280, "failed": 21, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4277b0dfa23ffaed13d60017152c2efc9f833122be773d760eb000e48b397757", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 750 pass, 28 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 750, "failed": 28, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4166e8dd16027d70246fb823ab7b9721b961675879854ea89ac0646c728cab0a", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 421 passing, 3 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 421, "failed": 3, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fbc4cb870f269002908ecee36d089cf0eb70220e11f864aa51a0adb7bd7319ad", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 12 failures / 895 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 895, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "60d4e01226d4d9d6c7c1193fca9e1de8b4173bca75df44a2bf1fc20063c1209d", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=400 failed=2 err=assertion mismatch recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 400, "failed": 2, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ffae5c865012519a94a95fbc8fc9949f9ab3fcb58f4041ffb99672136bf14db5", "state": "fix(search): investigate 10 failures (timeout) after 682 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 682, "failed": 10, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e67a85f63d135f0dba5f2aaa9bdaf5011ad90329203d1076b448cb7bc3386db3", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 456\u2713 33\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 456, "failed": 33, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "db46ab7b4a0c5174367d1669d6ba75109f83ce563bc33f6a013a2022c3bee60f", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 629 successes and 16 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 629, "failed": 16, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ebce2bfcbdc77c62ee44721656a9df088eb2b8695b721195e73e71d159862d1a", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=885 failed=33 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 885, "failed": 33, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "75d51c03cb55ed1ad7a26accc2223e717499ff3ef096470cb851bb0aac8b1dc9", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 681 passing and 39 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 681, "failed": 39, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "fa45188f056bbc1ed092af30cf5365b36c7ebb207b9aa5831901995ce2c701b8", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 35 failures after 673 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 673, "failed": 35, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6fd3e770f82b7cb324212ee62de36496d571f91920931fa5feef05a8f7ab40ea", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 884, \"failed\": 33}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 884, "failed": 33, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "fde90c7757904503391066e5ea44e78a071e7eead9587c803e976e5033916d3e", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"74\" failed=\"38\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 74, "failed": 38, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "01cd42d3ca5a73e029bab4d6d4b4153f972a8eff362e127de25d80e2d17b3953", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 32 pass, 30 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 32, "failed": 30, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3b808e30a96f71d0a20071e66b1081e37e93891df5a35b96f676e5c7e13c87e8", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 640 passing, 16 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 640, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b0793e8bc096a9597830946c2c125bd3d504799eb6228963971d4d7cc67150e6", "state": "JIRA-search: 1 failures / 40 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 40, "failed": 1, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "104d82be786bb353547cefdec2d0f33cb55f6131aa1b1954239105fd022b55aa", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=295 failed=9 err=timeout recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 295, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7e697444d0d88efe42a02faa097de1ef6812b19b00b73c8353d631076adf0b73", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 29 failures (connection refused) after 752 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 752, "failed": 29, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a8acf3a34ce31fef95a1139fb58218d66dddffaa3635111270ef1944302aff4a", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 58\u2713 28\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 58, "failed": 28, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fcdf79f246a36e9daee888490dfa9a79bfa312c5adf726c75832a2cc6fb70b2f", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 908 successes and 31 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 908, "failed": 31, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "00008fe2a1864b0c30c45ec613da714a83c484b85df8345ea7d8e248947512c5", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=337 failed=10 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 337, "failed": 10, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f86173a3b330e7d2c751fe9ef001d34009dc21c30e94435dcbb96d1716d1f0a7", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 118 passing and 35 failing with connection refused. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 118, "failed": 35, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1234de21398532648b0dbc998fbb68fe79f6ddaf10f0136f029ebb82f1c8a927", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 31 failures after 443 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 443, "failed": 31, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "44d551aff32f3d758ba55d3fea6ecc0cc40be2ac1099cd3296eb6988e5a2ec50", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 205, \"failed\": 21}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 205, "failed": 21, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5d5659a46555a3800406a5d94a0c104a82fd7659035caaefff5eeb6118c1e891", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"213\" failed=\"10\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 213, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "73fdc9f0358968ad723b3422ed9590c906f23c754ac42ba6cc9f7ba1836dcc9a", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 681 pass, 31 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 681, "failed": 31, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "d0bfc60c92fb09886f43d29bfd40ff38006265fc09f1d98e3879d1cea314c97b", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 647 passing, 6 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 647, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d1cff440428947edfe312dcf2aef43347d87de857fd578d731f284abc375a210", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 22 failures / 100 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 100, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0fd845babe982e56d38a4b17f91f27a6554d5309520de678d968e73197ffc1c6", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=948 failed=24 err=JWTExpiredError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 948, "failed": 24, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "92fcde30482749b10c75cf3c17ba576d0f2659e9fc71db450dfe61b5e8b3391a", "state": "fix(permissions): investigate 38 failures (assertion mismatch) after 64 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 64, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "61f9ce05942ae101f6f50026f4559c0245eb4306638eb8b0445b18dd1b6747ba", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 41\u2713 37\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 41, "failed": 37, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "71aba7cfb4fc9dcd590aede540682ac8ba907b52810118630963e3f68f45c9d3", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 602 successes and 7 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 602, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "eb9a24a4ca645a107b2d4866dc288c6b3477880c6ddb83eb82a1932d6f0536fe", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=29 failed=24 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 29, "failed": 24, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "365e17df347ced5d38a0b56e872cb1fff732e6f11c887c12a210145b13f38a86", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 382 passing and 12 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 382, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "97590a7726b2b93f4423e0c73cbeb65eee7c22331a9efe6001f898a76bc32366", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 816 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 816, "failed": 22, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "25d95791bab042653f8e923c5192dc179e229c45751b87f278b7487c080401ec", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 785, \"failed\": 1}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 785, "failed": 1, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "36cdb07ceece6671cc3e6681e15b17727705a2d59ad28e54b53659b94ef1a0e8", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"790\" failed=\"28\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 790, "failed": 28, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3feb027ccd7c9006c74c5d6477c1e01770f23589f9787ee60ae04cc9530d9140", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 622 pass, 2 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 622, "failed": 2, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "018405f66123f55301c2ecbc22e3e4eedaddeacaa69cd4f5d5a96c00d6486f60", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 454 passing, 27 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 454, "failed": 27, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "25e6c65e5eb476846b7bab10fcf7a64d1a8f3cafccd4d18a91611d9740a073d5", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 16 failures / 802 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 802, "failed": 16, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6a8873ca0a1572044975a9491a1dffb851a4a864117543592fe25cce81dc6ef0", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=688 failed=34 err=assertion mismatch recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 688, "failed": 34, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "409642ffca33cc8a260f548b02d6b8e5aae3800c51a0e4a978fad3e3d298b5e7", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 39 failures (ImportError) after 926 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 926, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "71929ea8b3075f6deb87d1b297091672ca3a92df2ede650684bb94ce0aea03fc", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 648\u2713 27\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 648, "failed": 27, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7f7296af44a0c9c76808e13134640b622fbc5824945d2ae919798950eac7c995", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 813 successes and 16 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 813, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b374edc84850ce2b9c43a7089a37fb3e2ba0a9c593067144aab42106386b01db", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=132 failed=23 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 132, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a694759a049dd298ac60bcc5347a18bb39b4940005ee192ac8a833cc2842dcb6", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 11 passing and 11 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 11, "failed": 11, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "af9aca2a40518b5f17a1043080762a4543b050aa92da049dd287e10a0bd506c6", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 33 failures after 368 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 368, "failed": 33, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "60e363b5798c493bf67ecad637f62b0db631631fe2d30edab70b711bf3b18ab2", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 370, \"failed\": 39}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 370, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b2a9a8d4f398e2c0b82006e74f3c564bc8f4dbbbd669bdc8a65f899d5860c68a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"notifications\"><baseline passed=\"189\" failed=\"3\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 189, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "73bc1fe569bb83d19b6d2eef7fb154f343bd659301b34da020f9c4343b8d18bf", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 463 pass, 39 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 463, "failed": 39, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bf8bfed5a5dc6df5e48b0c4c259934510174a0847df98e332b1a904b4195b09d", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 955 passing, 9 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 955, "failed": 9, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4b6c65feab92678e86a81657767a87e0d2afba5a1804d35b10fd4943e908035d", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 5 failures / 966 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 966, "failed": 5, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e413e621d82b5572026909deb8ecb94ae66aaa97774e2df6c706dd3b81b898b7", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=846 failed=29 err=ImportError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 846, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d8df6844020c875f69daffece56ab0e7caababe8c37d405024ee658aed83e144", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 1 failures (assertion mismatch) after 23 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 23, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "32c43ef68abe61ddccbab6e61e7ab0e623bcd6c95c59632abfbde200402a521b", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 908\u2713 38\u2717 (timeout). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 908, "failed": 38, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0d70d1fb4744452fe05b653742bccb77fc5aed92f05f96d1f9e0d2f9bb93af4f", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 516 successes and 29 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 516, "failed": 29, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ed504539984ac14300514719ad30ab57a5cd62500e5cdd448e78317380983404", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=999 failed=14 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 999, "failed": 14, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a233abb967c1182e49c5f4ba6d5165aa143a3355e2339df5d11b9a6ab73be4e9", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 620 passing and 31 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 620, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f34898c2dca8dbd784578e82d286a58a32947601cd1463e88a4fedc19cf3a0c3", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 23 failures after 778 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 778, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3ac84c782b3ebe08b38497e3ff678f84a8a1836dc943b865741c45d7c15f6fbb", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 751, \"failed\": 15}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 751, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "40837c5a43ac28593f208946009a8a96ec610d64da9a5a2c87c3d7e4ce2b86b5", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"263\" failed=\"17\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 263, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e7cf43247c44426d22afca6b91bafdcdc057ca4a6a6cb20d51d5bf44fac8ad1c", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 433 pass, 16 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 433, "failed": 16, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "57b16e4851585f9a43d9fcef65af65cea03516df74d155d02c2971b29ac225c4", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 213 passing, 3 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 213, "failed": 3, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ae3f501ef11e1255057574e1b75cdf2143b9cb2e4ad05f3ebe35a6e88233807f", "state": "JIRA-caching: 17 failures / 525 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 525, "failed": 17, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9cadea7ed46515d63ffbd97cf68e3586e395d04634becef3db624589e043425a", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=989 failed=9 err=timeout recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 989, "failed": 9, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9210499bb4aa4dfc8759cb8508cf63e993eaf01e57e27ca4788a4a4dbcda59c0", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 13 failures (unexpected null) after 714 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 714, "failed": 13, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b3269adadf92b3b559849b40062295a83ca54b422e0d13f067cb96751f734ff3", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 70\u2713 18\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 70, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "73291e4b416167a0a239c43cfbc51ae1f407dfd1b3fabfaa5f774c32ce0c67e0", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 947 successes and 6 failures (timeout). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 947, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4a4c157b6457134394161802f3012df33a9019797d1777e62200a4471945c678", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=513 failed=17 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 513, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "927e3ad8781e3cb921131b783d7836786a740fe9b2422f5995406d5d0f13bb56", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 674 passing and 22 failing with timeout. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 674, "failed": 22, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1bb07228db512f7c616eb2cc7f5828b5418ca52b4d4f433a287049e9c0dc9fb9", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 901 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 901, "failed": 6, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f8ad56cf8dde6db9da5d6a4ca93b59514e446a0a1581a32c3ecef5750265008e", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 876, \"failed\": 3}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 876, "failed": 3, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b69fcdbbdb0f89123cffdb74f246767e42d5c3e3199f69dc85070e83f1a599f6", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"892\" failed=\"19\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 892, "failed": 19, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7114b6948904f7a21f712497ec7e7b6c79b08d6cf8bb7f3f61e306f5906ca9cd", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 358 pass, 8 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 358, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "fb294d5336a7224e94a90bc0c46792da1e1acd0ff82c0177d1da646833c0d75b", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 528 passing, 6 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 528, "failed": 6, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "09e504a6f22a5bdc41d4a9830e23f32676791508cd7b4864c2a7dce7cdcbf64a", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 28 failures / 605 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 605, "failed": 28, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c98392b6b4cc014b56f472ec677e775808ba9e7a5167650e7a37a911f2c8a0ec", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=661 failed=26 err=ImportError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 661, "failed": 26, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2087ffd068f3d7f47bb1c3ccf72422b6e6b1bbcff9502cf4cd6c5967274d01f8", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 6 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 585 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 585, "failed": 6, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2d21bfcd4a43fd9adeb243aba0e136e2120c893b294522cd0c7e720f4cb25a53", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 707\u2713 36\u2717 (timeout). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 707, "failed": 36, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6b6b9e05e09634031b7a911b8b92e09bf76a4c14f81bb566aae194f498b7c0a4", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 394 successes and 16 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 394, "failed": 16, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7d8761c0b28f117c1c66a30c76161123c8d6a2230f164fadfb2ac3ee38d20d70", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=283 failed=7 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 283, "failed": 7, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "52fd1eee999b1af7f832732256150984d4c85e99f7509132ebe89e46f9f145fb", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 698 passing and 25 failing with timeout. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 698, "failed": 25, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "5520478b0694b1cffd34f9b1ed2064a29c5061f728ec0729f4aeff67843515a8", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 954 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 954, "failed": 10, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "31fca6f93bd685434b10ab9a8a30abe9c16ac024227454892480794cba1e0cbc", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 771, \"failed\": 5}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 771, "failed": 5, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b26137a2c8c7901cd3cfb01ff0ff7aef2d04832dd1c5d21a80cf8c78636bd13", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"731\" failed=\"31\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 731, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8c12a02e7599a23292d2e8133ec7e414b093b1329becd78a13341d2755e3b0bf", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 543 pass, 34 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 543, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ecd4f03b3d43574594da9ba3267a9b939c72bedb1d5111c6ffe9efeaa9174253", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 895 passing, 33 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 895, "failed": 33, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e4e3bdd15df7e100bdaa558282f48267307711ad4401b464b0ddcba8a807dc43", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 9 failures / 373 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 373, "failed": 9, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8855b5e4ccada8a4c6f89d1afc275f13adc75baf8c729ad32f2c7fe1a3539008", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=653 failed=11 err=assertion mismatch recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 653, "failed": 11, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "107e04bb12140b0ed22719c20c0f1ee627ec9af5d08e644578e3bdf5fa4ee0d6", "state": "fix(search): investigate 28 failures (ImportError) after 688 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 688, "failed": 28, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fe8c37f22a9b06cf62dca45a2a78284d56b3601ad5d377b36a590a54e0f1a3c0", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 230\u2713 28\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 230, "failed": 28, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f9d574bc9eafbce980676de47325570963fade6642e289b5a5ae3f3e8fd492ae", "state": "Issue authentication: baseline suite had 862 successes and 11 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 862, "failed": 11, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c2a3c9b565702863a632df5e70c5660a80b4abdab835f45868d0df59b95acf08", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=490 failed=26 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 490, "failed": 26, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d3d16096f4f965b7e98bc920005f25fcf929d531b5ad52eb49ec69742b1c55b6", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 946 passing and 39 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 946, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "688d763a46b83d7245279ca9ab7017f8ef101f480b904cf3331ace0f5a83bb08", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 13 failures after 496 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 496, "failed": 13, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4f1cd2dda1a9c24e5955912c19eb19af9487b40b9ff4548bca5d817f2cfbc405", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 663, \"failed\": 35}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 663, "failed": 35, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3405661b797ec01d0fe46872bad630d22e09746b4bb02a3b079c82699b56f575", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"914\" failed=\"23\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 914, "failed": 23, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aa958d20ca06f11de6d2f3d5e802ae327710dda90bf78e8af5ba93eb5ac23e6d", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 596 pass, 16 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 596, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7f6347b4e5622850caef2beb812180e478f90f6da74a6e079dcfb6f15e80b3d8", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 728 passing, 24 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 728, "failed": 24, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "86f6301594f813809ca7949b86156261f02c12bf45bba4b8dde1961b67fcfe88", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 19 failures / 988 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 988, "failed": 19, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "aafb0f9e70043838698ab951cf4073984051cfa6af2410b2fc71f9d53ff13786", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=301 failed=36 err=unexpected null recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 301, "failed": 36, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "051f736e7fe06f6a9335be1069c6f01c28fbefaa099e25feda35186ec16c8f10", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 17 failures (connection refused) after 927 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 927, "failed": 17, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ee28081c9c2495ce3f551c594d9fc189f376b9ff1bea2f947ce3f5c160a6734e", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 780\u2713 15\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 780, "failed": 15, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "db86ddbd68e615623245da227330cd0e67cd150170c1fc34d30b35952164c48f", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 696 successes and 7 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 696, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ed753564826ad996fea3410146283bd81760dbfdb822ce0c3b900eff30d48a20", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=878 failed=2 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 878, "failed": 2, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7cd6bbadac78fc608afee587cdf0eee1991785f3df957c40bbac837edcb06fc0", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 377 passing and 7 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 377, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aae8b27e8ac3b51531bf7cf191b937e3ef6bb177f9698320d1ea76b1439be12a", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 18 failures after 482 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 482, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1e4829f803d2b15bae8794b0a1fe7653222b35393c8933c3b693d9d8baaa5c42", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 445, \"failed\": 7}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 445, "failed": 7, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8d76a78774d1b233d081863490ac395178026e25c44604223c6ea3d763ffdb57", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"516\" failed=\"6\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 516, "failed": 6, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "18cdc412c9da85b8b360c7f9c20a4ccb058e9a400fca4a23ce10ebd7047e60c2", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 234 pass, 33 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 234, "failed": 33, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d3d69bdae13a822c0263fb17c2d16a0afa49048e382a0e4a1d9cc743409b3571", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 999 passing, 15 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 999, "failed": 15, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8905b0202aeee3392b322920801aa2e97e07334c384ccf45d68aff0ad944967b", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 39 failures / 724 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 724, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8e0958930cf3a0a2d33573f9a19cda349191ebecc44baf7a8db92ac4039ee74b", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=860 failed=29 err=ImportError recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 860, "failed": 29, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "09f1f53ca1f60a647558dcd46034dfa1944cedbe8adb9e6332b1519797571103", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 17 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 815 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: merged", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 815, "failed": 17, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d79bc9f735a78eedece3c71c5b229186dc94af1a5b40d55c3c97759b8c7382b3", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 88\u2713 15\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 88, "failed": 15, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d7d8e2477f0bfb27aebfb4b2d95a97d8c32b43f2a5516bdede2c75bbe1321d79", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 843 successes and 36 failures (assertion mismatch). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 843, "failed": 36, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b08ff8881e21aa3c5763f68a1b7b07c9b99c7f68eacaf20280a0804b05c00d9d", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=448 failed=36 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 448, "failed": 36, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9869f82a33a87e974f982533ec429a242e71f484bb4911725cba67af8dc89ac7", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 723 passing and 17 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 723, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e68b9146398541b93aee0a65a5aa2bdddb262be601ac7d901fb4c0950ac025da", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 18 failures after 663 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 663, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "82e4d0356bf1c9a5ad35cd83b0b6acc94699c3300cd8a107bf74a134ec21fa1f", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 100, \"failed\": 17}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 100, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b2f88948c092157a36169f411c60536ac224b91763b92bacb1c1d8e93c52cfcc", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"878\" failed=\"39\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 878, "failed": 39, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "308a05229505a91cb076b2be3ee5310ae85a54f2218c9a3cf79c28ec584fc570", "state": "@engineer Task: search. First run: 334 pass, 16 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 334, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4db8b9383ee51fdf4620908286d377a60a2e464da1f456d9cfe230244607b711", "state": "## Issue: billing\n**Baseline**: 562 passing, 28 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 562, "failed": 28, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0685ad386f3ff912d93cb7616cf8591b9ac021c6dbdc494ea33fab7431b447b9", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 34 failures / 379 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 379, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8b2204f7c1dc6028af3cced1d2b1f71884e936e78b332f79e69185907dc787b3", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=54 failed=14 err=ImportError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 54, "failed": 14, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "33b2cf99515efcd7d1c179c2a592ee39e150c85740b0c7b0e1587f8aea720b01", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 17 failures (assertion mismatch) after 613 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 613, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ec7ec836d57d4c72c27d6b0555732fce2cebca62f21193736d0f4d6ef9f6ac76", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 832\u2713 35\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 832, "failed": 35, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bd64a4c82f6572b035755f8f073efaf89a1dac7445c71c3591151433f1b33cb2", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 652 successes and 19 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 652, "failed": 19, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e7a82ba175a7ca6fbd21269f514ba8d6fffdf6602f1dbc00ee950dfac4e07ef4", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=51 failed=33 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 51, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "41e1f807bec9a3cd5dc549162ff61c037d4bac28c9302aede9b63f2ce73b884c", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing pagination. The first run was 142 passing and 17 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 142, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1ae52a7adf0efef2d700cfc154611eb6bf0676395f826d5dc0ff212ef4bd65ce", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 13 failures after 552 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 552, "failed": 13, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a696f02d9be0fd6adf03f8fdec3ff33f8329c8584da884a7cb10f315743b0fd7", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 773, \"failed\": 14}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 773, "failed": 14, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ebf46f578031a365a2e5e1a5f5c9a47839c4cb734628467e05e65eb0d6a51d02", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"797\" failed=\"39\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 797, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "be5bcff0273d647e0c75350cbfeedbefaea3c505ff481b55b9f047dc95197e62", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 447 pass, 26 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 447, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7d6003fb0aef00bd1bb36798d49c2ffc9c7cbe6514a46c33b3497dc817badc13", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 721 passing, 32 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 721, "failed": 32, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "86106b994cf996d0148e6e450d327d2705250dd4e8eb370101faaabe92007145", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 12 failures / 869 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 869, "failed": 12, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "472ce443394ecf27f17a7b8f3f5dd348a04e2ae6993c5737dc2bc35e011185bb", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=707 failed=23 err=connection refused recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 707, "failed": 23, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f786494a8efe083a77f541522cfe220739371374dce174992e345d144552f6f9", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 38 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 246 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 246, "failed": 38, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7bdfe57c9c8688174af93eaf678deb33e03c9c6993bffa77afcca815f8b28de3", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 259\u2713 9\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 259, "failed": 9, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cbdaa426a0a10687f1f3d7a6e2cf2bd79d73a11c977f9cbace0fc5e11128540c", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 517 successes and 4 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 517, "failed": 4, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f57abcb980be34ce0937a2932cac1d0bf82f2e41747aeb9934508b0cf4e70501", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=589 failed=23 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 589, "failed": 23, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b29f4d0f83893ff6dc7420e8c9eec8147a65e8422dec82aa4329e1b53597cdd2", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 136 passing and 19 failing with timeout. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 136, "failed": 19, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "96895377280ada5ef7efbf1632afa0f5283b9ea1979dd966280e572c6659b089", "state": "INCIDENT / search\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 790 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 790, "failed": 22, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cc3c9a7a489ae36806ecf4f15b06f38926fce36bdd87b641d1fc78c1faad518b", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 877, \"failed\": 26}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 877, "failed": 26, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5fad45b279012d817483b5491b75bee33c6a80ecf25bf979e6a24c83b21f8665", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"15\" failed=\"36\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 15, "failed": 36, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1a35fb66ad83a6b2f8c4b7fb1d28f10d339b7c43f14b76e07ac5ca1b55df49a9", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 295 pass, 6 fail. Error: timeout. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 295, "failed": 6, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "48b47eec47448592c05ee80dfd092cbb916d258856416cc65bb1ec216bf6573c", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 754 passing, 27 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 754, "failed": 27, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "33ef0f158707ba631437bd8cd77951ee013f979105d2b5be21377d22bcbb3a89", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 29 failures / 986 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 986, "failed": 29, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6b6dec2cfc0da42970a17e7b642c0b21d728c232064903346ed8de0204d6dd20", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=342 failed=33 err=ImportError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 342, "failed": 33, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5c90705a4cfe2e09f751c40e08d275b8e5ab3e06589df5ae37cab7fc30f60a00", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 14 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 34 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\nrevert: merged", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 34, "failed": 14, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ba8cd0b7b6b1a916bd9421f53abf7c2e9571d1dcae259be1aa9fe2c4110d0d18", "state": "PR Review: search \u2014 473\u2713 16\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 473, "failed": 16, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e0422e9ba52a7b2a3287f45eda2db2ab207772b1e6297bbf26df6c532d5547da", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 817 successes and 3 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 817, "failed": 3, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1e9633db5660b030457a05216cfd134bc443ab8aa55159424fba492b6d6984ed", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=781 failed=39 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 781, "failed": 39, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "db2736e0ec8ec2aa20f4361dd93a1bdcd06106729c73e166e973e9d5c748569d", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 968 passing and 13 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 968, "failed": 13, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f905c9c797c01211368e1d82034cb985205662131aa611a5e8d5eb3c318c87fd", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 6 failures after 157 passes; symptom connection refused; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 157, "failed": 6, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c9ebe17fa971e4c987906dc6bad92be5774bd13e1124ea27e07d5b9dab52a597", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 417, \"failed\": 4}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 417, "failed": 4, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7169eddc53d9ba8a36198553176e49a839712ce5899ba4681e4eed7ea7fac991", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"517\" failed=\"36\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 517, "failed": 36, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3af48b2a2e22e8d7a061a3c51503d613be7e02da19386e9952c615f4812385eb", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 895 pass, 11 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 895, "failed": 11, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e510b50200b8d939639d706d21264d0b4489569b2101d1902153c84422a431b9", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 923 passing, 4 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 923, "failed": 4, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "94b4a7b6d2da6e224765e54dcc3d28ae7434de0b1743bb37a0f77b091c87082a", "state": "JIRA-authentication: 2 failures / 499 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 499, "failed": 2, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7b8451671c0e22f16a58ea86ab9761ba75a0da0fd1d5dab348ef8294d62a90f3", "state": "TRACE task=billing passed=795 failed=27 err=timeout recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 795, "failed": 27, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f1360eece6345b1dbdfc62c018cbce1f12e6bdd34d0215184a592ca502a14718", "state": "fix(search): investigate 6 failures (ImportError) after 761 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: rejected\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 761, "failed": 6, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6ff1455eedd4550453ca091753fdefb1776f29759412c41e805a28f3b08230fc", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 410\u2713 23\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 410, "failed": 23, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b62417a2655ba566e3ad420dc272a7e1a61fea5e6217044aa20864c2923dbfde", "state": "Issue notifications: baseline suite had 59 successes and 23 failures (timeout). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 59, "failed": 23, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4f77f3c7253d3cb4408697116eba5054462f87a0cb83ee9db3054311b581e462", "state": "$ diagnose --task authentication\nBASELINE passed=916 failed=10 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 916, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f32528cc2442841ce8e2620c36d6b28b1ed208ef87b4ad0a1e0b61fb67025a9a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 401 passing and 22 failing with ImportError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 401, "failed": 22, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5112b03ed8d527f019469f349d7eb22f72bdcf4e50bb9a98e75e96eca1d86a19", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 10 failures after 949 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified machine configuration (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 949, "failed": 10, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eda986366deb860be376cfed98304909af39a37e35f87749e53dd95d3b884fd6", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 812, \"failed\": 34}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 812, "failed": 34, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "be9a90418d239da432d44bf39744a7cf127cfa62f6dedd6da5762f1b569e4195", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"6\" failed=\"36\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 6, "failed": 36, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8fe3361bd89259586d94996438a9925c4e530a7c595865d77264d83f65b3f5ed", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 632 pass, 10 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 632, "failed": 10, "task": "caching", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7e144faa5880fe99b985e483bb7fe3e662b07e41f87e172caf715b28e2a66f51", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 417 passing, 39 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 417, "failed": 39, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "00ce6c9680433c83fa174aa40870911202477531e29c69465d4041d0ec263e0e", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 11 failures / 202 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 202, "failed": 11, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f848913a6f843832f5a3777423604ff98627880c21661e28c1640c489f7a57b8", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=697 failed=5 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 697, "failed": 5, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "35dd3010dc807a40bb1a925602bb5b59b1209505fffe7c38026016edc30ec2f4", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 15 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 281 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 281, "failed": 15, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "24185f4aab019fc9c43d8958827ec3d3abed896ba46ef6ef2194d332c4cbda76", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 538\u2713 16\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 538, "failed": 16, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ea66b2cf46de71107b229e73ea1bc3751a8ac1191c0e7774bd39c69b9620c4d7", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 279 successes and 8 failures (JWTExpiredError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 279, "failed": 8, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0634b6876eb110909c3b861940daf2e13349e6f21182b83b792cf367e7126490", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=586 failed=26 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 586, "failed": 26, "task": "billing", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5603c1d63c4744839f0f9ecc9a78379e5d4c8d3e00c398e736c7be3f66ac7ce3", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 878 passing and 4 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 878, "failed": 4, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e4b92fda43118ca65040bd8bde47466424d5f04b08d4197d574629e83d8d0b44", "state": "INCIDENT / billing\nInitial evidence: 22 failures after 53 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 53, "failed": 22, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8a14c983d1d60f07e6825e56058733ece6aac5f2e9d541385620fd023405b244", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 850, \"failed\": 6}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 850, "failed": 6, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6e5164918b8f1e148b187db25bfc3593065815dc0920de935f5c7216f5a66d72", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"716\" failed=\"39\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 716, "failed": 39, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "668c6dc1c5e468e8217d2a0f6d51fdb0aba9b954c36f8b24ad87ea3a71aa5eba", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 846 pass, 38 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 846, "failed": 38, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "65bb4c2df595b5c0a5e06dd9788dde24b7dab3a3368cb9749da6807a106152a4", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 933 passing, 34 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 933, "failed": 34, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "71377a4eecdb73f97f051a6680e1c35e80346ffe830a4ba6e83ad174f4801efa", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 36 failures / 934 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: approved.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 934, "failed": 36, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2562ad73ec82dc0857fa3ad0d062fecaae4a8b49522addb079e8b5c180634aba", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=186 failed=21 err=timeout recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 186, "failed": 21, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8fe34838fbc4bfbc8973cb782e4a502d64c35f254cdd865e72569f93661e3ae0", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 7 failures (ImportError) after 735 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\nrevert: rejected\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 735, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "96822c32019bf74e552b3aaa74667de68069ad53a793f8ecc0c4611e4d110006", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 739\u2713 17\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 739, "failed": 17, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "e7c18277ccde5cc1131fbaffc0d33c0b3210ea3c0c16ebcb2f96678cf86bfa09", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 443 successes and 16 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 443, "failed": 16, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "fb48e966194f412d1633f8b23265d4021de6fad47988c91c0ed3b68acea4001a", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=462 failed=20 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 462, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "f878c5f947b4ceef6fa910ad50109141a75b2b1adfcd131a627d7cd22566c96e", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 741 passing and 7 failing with ImportError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 741, "failed": 7, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ebb72f3ebecfd1128eb1664d6420d0d22c7bcf5aeb5fb5a62f9b1ece5cae8787", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 7 failures after 752 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 752, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a5eb79bc8d4e4a3a73c34413227974e42ed31f8394faf0d93cde19dcf09a3316", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 625, \"failed\": 16}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 625, "failed": 16, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "12ed4c05e9c04f2e457999b801d16bdabe5056deded9283578928c0ecd506971", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"657\" failed=\"29\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 657, "failed": 29, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5db7fb1c2e11276fbeb7efb928cfd532a29470abf483c91ff28c5a8e17e22946", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 659 pass, 34 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 659, "failed": 34, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e0bb1b680c96a84325931275a80d6626822d615ce7da792201f5d1610dfb4c22", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 188 passing, 35 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 188, "failed": 35, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a252fafe6276464cc42a6b3d58277757aebd48ad796beb74926f1986733323e9", "state": "JIRA-notifications: 36 failures / 162 passes after regression. Error: timeout. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 162, "failed": 36, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5a3f9405c2724011248162b9e91a1dbd8e68e27035bbd4f7be76c5bc7626b444", "state": "TRACE task=uploads passed=391 failed=14 err=connection refused recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 391, "failed": 14, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6cd6f702646227ac33dad83b59d1edaefc248e5f3e90ed304a0413df344ba4b2", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 17 failures (connection refused) after 486 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 486, "failed": 17, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "39f0c35d420d819d347464b297258905e2c9b572d335ff58eb47e3d8c97879d4", "state": "PR Review: pagination \u2014 356\u2713 12\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 356, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ad06d57ca2db0a77916eb0db0c6dbadd016875648aed580c3afa647188291b4b", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 954 successes and 12 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 954, "failed": 12, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "ca58dfaf0baeb803abcb488a6bd0884eee508d2d7418ac6e8bb7c3bacd212f1a", "state": "$ diagnose --task pagination\nBASELINE passed=612 failed=32 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 612, "failed": 32, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e813a4a1302fef8ec8983d2a2f1e6670228bf7a4ae3c30ad588a7df07a5882fd", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing caching. The first run was 799 passing and 27 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 799, "failed": 27, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4839b9961745c3a64fea99f6964c442673b33e1a811707d3973beac715578045", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 29 failures after 390 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 390, "failed": 29, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2068bdc2122ea90828d08dbf7dba244e80253f447cd7697417cfe26d661c912b", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 732, \"failed\": 1}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 732, "failed": 1, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "84a74d5211ba83d41469f050ce09c2b72daf6fb9af0e2d27858b90452b3a9ce9", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"920\" failed=\"25\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 920, "failed": 25, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "10e55884b56c9792cf94a87b60b48add1169c45745fc6fb44a04975a17946910", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 794 pass, 28 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: machine configuration (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 794, "failed": 28, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4df0ed1921abf814dce20d4c87504d5a973da7176cae8584af03edf60bd45f7a", "state": "## Issue: pagination\n**Baseline**: 897 passing, 14 failing\n**Error**: `ImportError`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 897, "failed": 14, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "864239f1b37a1662995d9223241edaac166c656300f22b45d42e96c0b715bffa", "state": "JIRA-caching: 8 failures / 133 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 133, "failed": 8, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "b9566d7f5d2bb57717090944613b0aa27e52ff5f0e3fe415e9dfb3051b8181e2", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=765 failed=21 err=timeout recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 765, "failed": 21, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9485685c83584f13aed4f9f3a9b260102ff4924fe15566d5f6daaf133d32c8ff", "state": "fix(uploads): investigate 19 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 395 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nrevert: rejected\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 395, "failed": 19, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "07a2234bdee594c0b487424f29105199dd15a72e658cdcde5bb1c2103f2383fc", "state": "PR Review: uploads \u2014 2\u2713 16\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 2, "failed": 16, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4bacd7048b8cbdcceb4fcdde4edb27f2b5c03c3942673459c7f29bc4357d9cac", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 343 successes and 15 failures (ImportError). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 343, "failed": 15, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "06ca66950825965325db6cedaf25375349bde0b6f167ffba87611610a2c69c00", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=60 failed=12 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 60, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "aaf2dc9ab609d4b05827bf11b81911402fff33c643a3d8c75b29e2309e3f3fd4", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing search. The first run was 778 passing and 29 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 778, "failed": 29, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b76da774404de80f6d3a29aab41c25a10e8453cd6b2b26937985dbdf167ad24f", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 1 failures after 19 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 19, "failed": 1, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "861b77fbc4e7348f3123acd219206a84ae8d0b55d798a70dc31f92d436b29c18", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 57, \"failed\": 9}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 57, "failed": 9, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dcceb427ff41114b4596b65d705bd0360579dab304744838a5d675a9be716279", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"search\"><baseline passed=\"438\" failed=\"19\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 438, "failed": 19, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "36d1ef9e02dc8c634e3e1c56e269912deb7e5e780b354f8a4c7446339cae9576", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 833 pass, 31 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 833, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "71501c098e09fde3b7834353f86cbf6998ac7ae14ba4c1d7e99ac7edefab27e4", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 868 passing, 37 failing\n**Error**: `JWTExpiredError`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 868, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "72aa91f9b0a5670da18a76a7079157a943963257b8a7c8ef9f142d99555805da", "state": "JIRA-search: 8 failures / 892 passes after regression. Error: assertion mismatch. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 892, "failed": 8, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "2407cb42bc2e4919198424cf6b9ec2ede6ba5408c320c683ffd5df424755b73e", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=874 failed=18 err=JWTExpiredError recent=machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 874, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "55fb12a1e744f8d9e7eb3777ceeb889f38b4c4c3075eb4e93dcb2582c6554f0a", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 38 failures (assertion mismatch) after 937 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: skipped\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\nrevert: merged\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 937, "failed": 38, "task": "pagination", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0f8bd8b6d765ee60e966c057f75cdcfc4067254439312721e76dc468b57b6fd9", "state": "PR Review: notifications \u2014 38\u2713 1\u2717 (ImportError). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 1, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 38, "failed": 1, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f3f4319a88f18deb87813982915259b0f06be3a91838d8c2c21f5d3ebfef5a29", "state": "Issue search: baseline suite had 746 successes and 23 failures (timeout). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 746, "failed": 23, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "54513b068717dfc270edde964956a8d2c6051aa0259c1fa59895ce9049b1c524", "state": "$ diagnose --task permissions\nBASELINE passed=316 failed=23 exception=connection refused\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 316, "failed": 23, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3e2af6e6bbcc816653c01b685c8bf19692338663cb1a6e8fb15245007c6d9250", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 717 passing and 20 failing with assertion mismatch. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 717, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "03f2e7e43310b8a40059f673c103ef383fda786730c3cf4c6e116d9a3aae7bb8", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 4 failures after 16 passes; symptom unexpected null; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 16, "failed": 4, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "48ee92bbafad554dc7b6822aa7274bfd3f72a505db9e802296f135ce8ca17b1f", "state": "{\"task\": \"permissions\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 311, \"failed\": 25}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 311, "failed": 25, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "820d2b2db8d5c9cd3f7b0e32fa70fb33f8e50eed5ae4f707a79de6f7a0af7728", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"198\" failed=\"6\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>external library</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 198, "failed": 6, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "c61269ca39558ea2b467d891b3181d0e2a5aa6b2658ba2987007eb9259d2abfd", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 36 pass, 7 fail. Error: ImportError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 36, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7f7c260239bf6278bde49d155f90b6fe105dd548e80ba5aa882798e258601d2d", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 70 passing, 29 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 70, "failed": 29, "task": "permissions", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f63f39bf32a6154983bb4994476945df45063637ca13f190afb62cc7174c208c", "state": "JIRA-billing: 3 failures / 63 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: not executed.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 63, "failed": 3, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "44dd77897ab9342d4eeebb3bf19e05387ed296195adc8f42080f194c65ffd940", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=26 failed=14 err=assertion mismatch recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 26, "failed": 14, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dc6d25b02dd2404f192079dad4b0e40ba4805dd92af77bf6529076d998f35c2e", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 37 failures (assertion mismatch) after 325 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nrevert: merged\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 325, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4289b6d357e4454a80e75940b3eecdafa2fedff3496de9fa0c44ee3d73de5dd8", "state": "PR Review: permissions \u2014 421\u2713 18\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 421, "failed": 18, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "530e4740600cb0f9cf0e001f3eb7014420c68b9c35d0d9e6c9eb6bf82ac48a2f", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 596 successes and 36 failures (timeout). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 596, "failed": 36, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "cf3ae3993aeae8531fb99d59bb5dbd2a4b874a236f9e7090909676deb74a46bf", "state": "$ diagnose --task search\nBASELINE passed=213 failed=13 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 213, "failed": 13, "task": "search", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2d00f9663d8721ddac617bcfe8e657c50a1924dd206d91d73adf96afe12b6258", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 582 passing and 7 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched test fixture, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 582, "failed": 7, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a5fab4e6054cda0183cfce2c03cdeb2c6b9383d922d11d43ab33913933aa0122", "state": "INCIDENT / uploads\nInitial evidence: 8 failures after 750 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 750, "failed": 8, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d0f0d902226f017aa5e5ec78c8cffa91cc6a5de6f33f14714dde0c90aeb44e17", "state": "{\"task\": \"pagination\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 784, \"failed\": 3}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 784, "failed": 3, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9b4d58857478f4cd247483cf18a036e446eaf2560e721f30a68a6842fe4e1d9b", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"318\" failed=\"35\"/><error>assertion mismatch</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 318, "failed": 35, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "dfca25774a7af15dc4e17531e98821c5ab728553291c9865714e7a542da613de", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 109 pass, 18 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 109, "failed": 18, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a7badefc6c3ced420a53810296467cdcbeabb7dc76f84c25f9c39c4c54981a86", "state": "## Issue: authentication\n**Baseline**: 314 passing, 30 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 314, "failed": 30, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1ca8c7a0340ec48176c2d6d709b0aed49bbde2cdde8bba19d04210ae82bc5904", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 21 failures / 348 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: pending.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 348, "failed": 21, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a78153342e33ff5f419a9433e621c3b8a49f82a602a134027ab677fbd3f51061", "state": "TRACE task=authentication passed=66 failed=27 err=JWTExpiredError recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=PENDING\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 66, "failed": 27, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "35deae3645fe3061be7b6e0b291e06c0d2802236bc6ca52defc5debcfd4fb91e", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 18 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 982 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 982, "failed": 18, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2e8e1f60370c78f06857850aae3ffa6c4d13f1b389bf316109dea762d2e88283", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 485\u2713 22\u2717 (timeout). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 485, "failed": 22, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "0bea95c5684d4fe7c2f288af7c8c6f3cb135781cd23cdb66af6d31405ba76d12", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 65 successes and 28 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 65, "failed": 28, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "34db6a68afcfc55a3b6131edbcf4313d2d2ceab67e6c94553782a7edfac27748", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=209 failed=1 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 209, "failed": 1, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "345c4d74904dc363342a44f91ab8aefad44b5def2df45e9c534d0fd54f39fbc9", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 848 passing and 13 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 848, "failed": 13, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0db41a7f67dd08a20f9067a34b25a0d3e22fccbb4169dbeac697e84da948c915", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 13 failures after 127 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified test fixture (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is withheld.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 127, "failed": 13, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "eb424812c4a55e193e224147bcb3b1e16581adf24348b666dabae6eee69efb27", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 460, \"failed\": 29}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 460, "failed": 29, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2051085d4eb520209dd86ac6662626e0a6d4c74d16a3644e2d1c1f5fcd41f20e", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"permissions\"><baseline passed=\"449\" failed=\"1\"/><error>timeout</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 449, "failed": 1, "task": "permissions", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "05db8b4db0e681086b0d519c226503d2df395ffb98b01de5199e521d4243172f", "state": "@engineer Task: permissions. First run: 214 pass, 4 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 214, "failed": 4, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "73a7fe5df715c7445ac6c25e17b63f645d50c80604a9dd7f421e65d6f5a15861", "state": "## Issue: permissions\n**Baseline**: 450 passing, 12 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u2705 **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 450, "failed": 12, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0ea2ee0efa56d58c80386cffb7764906511cad649de61e9de95b791f02da3573", "state": "JIRA-search: 22 failures / 630 passes after regression. Error: ImportError. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 630, "failed": 22, "task": "search", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "9783a75df5df6af290d453d0d8f5cd91cd5b9ff7088f7a00830f93e97d39b62b", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=313 failed=37 err=ImportError recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=OK\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 313, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1914495a66ea398168f0bd200b26f8de4bfcd22e2578f7bea102195e43a64123", "state": "fix(billing): investigate 10 failures (assertion mismatch) after 268 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks fail | approval: approved\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 268, "failed": 10, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2c97cd3bda9c4d9371ec1042168e89c765d3c16416607f0bf4ebeb390da2ed72", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 215\u2713 22\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 215, "failed": 22, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1bf4f3ffb2cf0554d9f19d5d13cee9eab09e7211e62800060fb6b2ddbf91365d", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 857 successes and 16 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was test fixture; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 857, "failed": 16, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5d35e89adc24363e7fa7e60567f82f81d7f05e5b8220ecbad741fd79fa099dc9", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=996 failed=27 exception=JWTExpiredError\nNOTICE recent_change=external library (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 996, "failed": 27, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "52b166b94960af30e239c5b30b9d8102dddcde8f1f67382b14395f90e02bd02a", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 747 passing and 10 failing with ImportError. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.", "labels": [0, 1, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 747, "failed": 10, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e147fd6205f40a1d5b4129308c45139864140c660333caafa03ae49c330ecf99", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 24 failures after 972 passes; symptom assertion mismatch; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 972, "failed": 24, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3cfc149dbd9ea2ae3b09de23147218c7a4ecd89d931c4d06a2f45a465f860db4", "state": "{\"task\": \"notifications\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 72, \"failed\": 38}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 72, "failed": 38, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "48ca7117ad1a25172287a6f7f4ddcbdabff13780394927776b6fd9d5226ff905", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"743\" failed=\"3\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 743, "failed": 3, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8cec48e8d57a9a338c11ffba006f54075ef4bc08bcc29f1fe9aba364337ba3de", "state": "@engineer Task: billing. First run: 197 pass, 23 fail. Error: connection refused. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 197, "failed": 23, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4fc1ae6963f25c30b1ba1d101c9f228b7e5a18e3a71c7981f93e5bdeb5daf047", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 304 passing, 36 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u2705 **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 304, "failed": 36, "task": "notifications", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a96566860e8f770ff958e843531761b85ebe9ce089c7002448c6a54ba952018e", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 13 failures / 180 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nRollback approved: rejected.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 180, "failed": 13, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "04d75c29d90ba7e2baea9f7774a15714555c6e865bb9858adb4fa8790f6c6151", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=933 failed=32 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 933, "failed": 32, "task": "search", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "53df3f15fa7fc2f1711feb67017c995a5c542549cb8d948ae21483760c3aae0f", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 31 failures (unexpected null) after 289 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks pass | approval: pending\nblocker: blocked | retry: skipped\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 289, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "6da7d81ee354ea98842d567efa0415364b435fbf6ae0b693a687735fbb7cad26", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 903\u2713 17\u2717 (timeout). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: resolved. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap cleared the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 903, "failed": 17, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6f6106c71a9805bd3005cc545bbb397bcb9926e306a67f766eb242db846a9f97", "state": "Issue pagination: baseline suite had 799 successes and 15 failures (timeout). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 799, "failed": 15, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e7e13569ed7a7585bb83aa7e936e7d7b1e089571b35192a41e5bb20e3cdc7672", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=441 failed=21 exception=assertion mismatch\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 441, "failed": 21, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c1f44df033e1fc6374a53157759017e5d0550ad6d6ab6fa18ea0b1dbd8acc37e", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing billing. The first run was 601 passing and 14 failing with ImportError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 601, "failed": 14, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4431b4d0e933a786e18c97827eeeda4d14faca492472d0da6961ffe9f117ff55", "state": "INCIDENT / permissions\nInitial evidence: 21 failures after 932 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 932, "failed": 21, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a1d30571edd0603b50643fe7c9b06b658db17408039aefc51e5659b56211eba9", "state": "{\"task\": \"caching\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 726, \"failed\": 31}, \"error\": \"unexpected null\", \"recent_change\": \"application implementation\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 726, "failed": 31, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e60ad0ef88de6b41fdf06d633fe380f352e45d0bc9e3cc314189f1992d292e7f", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"492\" failed=\"5\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 492, "failed": 5, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "4a846565035f0645a4bcd6e38cea588bd5809a36b48b5693346c8e134aff9475", "state": "@engineer Task: authentication. First run: 554 pass, 30 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: test fixture (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nEng: Patch revert is no.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 554, "failed": 30, "task": "authentication", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a31a9b9ee7a75d53d4e676076a9ab6aec2e4b9395fd2a7cd3f5c3044283da68d", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 692 passing, 14 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\nRevert permission: closed.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 692, "failed": 14, "task": "uploads", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "89ede54beb5dacdc1a0e8ed047a84264672e4d933c1b75895d1669a18fc70968", "state": "JIRA-search: 11 failures / 773 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: pending.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 773, "failed": 11, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "19619614dd1e0263c72bfb83b49f1b3868fa92279846e02f56a4528073935903", "state": "TRACE task=permissions passed=414 failed=25 err=unexpected null recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK=OK\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=PENDING", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 414, "failed": 25, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5e4c87f26e8998d44ac00c1d5e218b0278e81c27318fb5f5f43a8bb9b236541c", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 20 failures (timeout) after 13 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 13, "failed": 20, "task": "authentication", "error": "timeout", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "76d0d4b641145166d0aab15ebccc543e11e10a3c8ca8bcc9e1fdb6576fa9c786", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 433\u2713 11\u2717 (JWTExpiredError). Changed: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 433, "failed": 11, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "a28f1af270249b958ee4908d8b3940d30df198f431c0d67fd2b7e182aabdabd7", "state": "Issue permissions: baseline suite had 178 successes and 6 failures (connection refused). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 178, "failed": 6, "task": "permissions", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d130cff3735044f182493f1576ca2b767a78363fbae9a681151104a20381c0a1", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=136 failed=35 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=ABSENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nROLLBACK allowed=NO", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 136, "failed": 35, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5cf2a90c3389e49d67de5f827b47f303364d3ca54b1a0ad7dc7590dedc5a1ee6", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 894 passing and 7 failing with connection refused. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 894, "failed": 7, "task": "authentication", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "79e4f962b888491d0a1a5f524ae2cd9c42c8e3c69af016e7879a37c1b638fc89", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 39 failures after 58 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 58, "failed": 39, "task": "notifications", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9fb6e977fa4906c53d6a9b10e71fd2756d0f407673788b5238d4c733f03233a0", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 18, \"failed\": 2}, \"error\": \"timeout\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 18, "failed": 2, "task": "search", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ee3cd673861d5321205ba7aeae4ad758f692fe827dfaa68280dd272ef4830554", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"billing\"><baseline passed=\"869\" failed=\"37\"/><error>JWTExpiredError</error><recent>test fixture</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 869, "failed": 37, "task": "billing", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "4da8ed20dcf454bfeb570071f4338340cd0235e9896367b6349b3da7a79fb7a5", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 408 pass, 19 fail. Error: unexpected null. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 408, "failed": 19, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "3adaecffe8831bfc61f1df6e010d9760c0722c1f8742720e1b36ab857cc4d481", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 789 passing, 34 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: machine configuration (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 789, "failed": 34, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "7def5d60b5fed803c513576533807fe258fef8189503ac8c4e2f39982bb852bd", "state": "JIRA-billing: 39 failures / 531 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: not executed.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 531, "failed": 39, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "806565fa7b2b0c27b9572603b12b82965b1c5cca735df4cd7c48224411802568", "state": "TRACE task=search passed=877 failed=39 err=assertion mismatch recent=application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 877, "failed": 39, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5c3150e8ab166058b3d4c430a286c275c1a00edcfdb55d5e0e596cd958998dbe", "state": "fix(pagination): investigate 7 failures (connection refused) after 741 passes. recent: external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected\nci: checks pass | approval: pending", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 741, "failed": 7, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "155cef74c6b139f7d2f02678543b0d1cc89ace3fc9808096cb38a8cfdf72e715", "state": "PR Review: billing \u2014 813\u2713 20\u2717 (assertion mismatch). Changed: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap cleared the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: changes requested.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 813, "failed": 20, "task": "billing", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b8dc56b418e472678ccca05aa0831014b7f52efa8ae8857294dd7a6cb65dc456", "state": "Issue caching: baseline suite had 14 successes and 20 failures (timeout). The last touched area was machine configuration; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: confirmed.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 14, "failed": 20, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "edb56907dfbc26d6446e01303eddd8d363b0d3f43fecaa87d1541b6461c9384f", "state": "$ diagnose --task caching\nBASELINE passed=595 failed=37 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 595, "failed": 37, "task": "caching", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "6be93650904fdd24ee4d5c30f5a4a702b919142774e22aa54406cabe60923f8b", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing notifications. The first run was 1 passing and 28 failing with ImportError. We recently touched application implementation, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 1, "failed": 28, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e41ae25393dd62f4269cef3368a701c6e5301172aa640d90c5ae76260d9d7bfc", "state": "INCIDENT / notifications\nInitial evidence: 17 failures after 171 passes; symptom ImportError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 171, "failed": 17, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "89f62ffb299c4c9ac7d69fb16dba72bb16076a6171ebdcf36073d21773f352ca", "state": "{\"task\": \"uploads\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 294, \"failed\": 21}, \"error\": \"ImportError\", \"recent_change\": \"external library\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"false\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 294, "failed": 21, "task": "uploads", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "9b0a766db543865286db18ee0163a325b1eeeca9dcdbe6fe329892a5d71a961e", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"pagination\"><baseline passed=\"385\" failed=\"31\"/><error>ImportError</error><recent>application implementation</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<blocker cleared=\"resolved\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<rollback allowed=\"permitted\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 385, "failed": 31, "task": "pagination", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "15405f68401bdb8ef4f81e424e0fe28fc1bc3b4ef870c4129da89e0401bbd666", "state": "@engineer Task: uploads. First run: 10 pass, 31 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 10, "failed": 31, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "be99f8238dd193f37936d7ad1d7d0512febe59f2c7ae70d59f11971bba50aea6", "state": "## Issue: caching\n**Baseline**: 50 passing, 27 failing\n**Error**: `assertion mismatch`\n**Recent change**: test fixture (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: failing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: fixed. Identical re-run: not run.\n\u2705 **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 50, "failed": 27, "task": "caching", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e1ab5e67ee99309ba89e20bfcdd40039f4b2a3b8c5d13e857ec60de5fd77580e", "state": "JIRA-pagination: 3 failures / 273 passes after regression. Error: unexpected null. Touched: application implementation.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRollback approved: approved.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 273, "failed": 3, "task": "pagination", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "5ce6fbebfb96b0b1e58818bbf6a01a1db547fa0ec0eb28f2586740e7b7d764cb", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=493 failed=1 err=connection refused recent=external library\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=YES", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 493, "failed": 1, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "397ecfe90bde575057e6d7666212225dfd8f0508d749981baed7b409bc847dbc", "state": "fix(authentication): investigate 25 failures (JWTExpiredError) after 786 passes. recent: test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\nrevert: rejected\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 786, "failed": 25, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "d3580d599a00bab89c50810aa52ada3cd052a92f378f90bd8175221168e6dab7", "state": "PR Review: authentication \u2014 371\u2713 8\u2717 (unexpected null). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap cleared the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nRevert allowed: approved.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: not run.\nComment: Only external library swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 3, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 371, "failed": 8, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "revert_change", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c7a7731f16194a31f8c0ff3e75f4baefac44c16bbbd706f5db97a1114df6f32d", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 246 successes and 18 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 246, "failed": 18, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "ac7a9d1780bf907808c0af10e3bfa12c36cd005c79fe28a7862001a713f64b5d", "state": "$ diagnose --task uploads\nBASELINE passed=258 failed=2 exception=unexpected null\nNOTICE recent_change=test fixture (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 258, "failed": 2, "task": "uploads", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0ef63f3bc6b7b5c3c040bd4f720a294ffec8d87ad61944961d4596c7b3696d58", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing permissions. The first run was 841 passing and 31 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is still pending.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is gone; the exact same retry is not yet tried.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 841, "failed": 31, "task": "permissions", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b33382b46a113f9431191f8c2baba3ac74667ec4cbe5737ad04619da4b136296", "state": "INCIDENT / caching\nInitial evidence: 9 failures after 987 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nThe short-lived impediment is unresolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nPresent verification is successful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 987, "failed": 9, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "231a2960038853811192217b732773013d6f0753e54b150d17347b3106ee3642", "state": "{\"task\": \"billing\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 910, \"failed\": 1}, \"error\": \"connection refused\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 3, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 910, "failed": 1, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "b5d5678074f726655059e6646906ece6c62acfb894e4c018cec192de061e685a", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"uploads\"><baseline passed=\"534\" failed=\"7\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"failure\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"no\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 534, "failed": 7, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "de1747d312b04967718bb489c13a0bf77ad15002e1e0998c5d49ce76072508ad", "state": "@engineer Task: notifications. First run: 675 pass, 19 fail. Error: assertion mismatch. Recent: external library (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is failed.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is approved.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 675, "failed": 19, "task": "notifications", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "e6298e18f4b86a567c6d4334f7595a41e106738b58d1e89e35adfeda0d9fad88", "state": "## Issue: notifications\n**Baseline**: 551 passing, 35 failing\n**Error**: `timeout`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\nRevert permission: merged.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 551, "failed": 35, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "82d073b8c3e648e5c65d2c847bf359fcbd1ddb4b34c4a96bfb57f9f0aaaa69d3", "state": "JIRA-permissions: 37 failures / 779 passes after regression. Error: JWTExpiredError. Touched: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nImpediment status: blocked. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nQA verification: passed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause eliminated.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [1, 0, 0, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 779, "failed": 37, "task": "permissions", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "f161bc1a55a902ca9a8100ee712d7c2ee4c675087cb6231184cb3bcb0393e335", "state": "TRACE task=pagination passed=754 failed=15 err=connection refused recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nCHECKS=ERR ACCEPTED=NO\nBLOCKER=ACTIVE RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=CLEARED\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nROLLBACK=BLOCKED", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 754, "failed": 15, "task": "pagination", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "2babe6a50734842fe545d2163d5957d0e170f1e69df7cbc1aef02ade3e94d77f", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 12 failures (ImportError) after 603 passes. recent: application implementation\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nblocker: blocked | retry: failed\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: merged\nci: checks pass | approval: approved\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 603, "failed": 12, "task": "notifications", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "763f1a9e9a09fbc4a48e5c764fd3daf4f0ba510204700c922cee596cf9b0752a", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 580\u2713 1\u2717 (timeout). Changed: machine configuration.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nChecks: fail. LGTM: lgtm.\nRevert allowed: denied.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 580, "failed": 1, "task": "caching", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "c95447e2d6c922a389948f33417ae2a908a453d717589fe6fc84a2e7489fb36c", "state": "Issue uploads: baseline suite had 81 successes and 9 failures (timeout). The last touched area was external library; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nCurrent suite: failing. Product acceptance: not confirmed.\nTransient obstruction: not cleared. An identical retry: not been attempted.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nPatch reversal permission: authorized.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 81, "failed": 9, "task": "uploads", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8e2a4f7a75deff513cee4940c7e752703761038c5448ceefdfe69174142c0d3c", "state": "$ diagnose --task billing\nBASELINE passed=28 failed=3 exception=ImportError\nNOTICE recent_change=application implementation (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nROLLBACK allowed=NO\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=YES; SAME_RETRY failed_before=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT\nLATEST checks=PASS; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 28, "failed": 3, "task": "billing", "error": "ImportError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "7879d05f146c4d3a0b35fe938f7a681f06c969a9580ed5d05f0b0456386dd511", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing authentication. The first run was 765 passing and 6 failing with unexpected null. We recently touched external library, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are still failing, and acceptance is confirmed.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is not permitted.", "labels": [0, 0, 0, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [true, false, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 765, "failed": 6, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "code", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "69575dc796d07f4199711a009abecb02325d71d59089cc0e4e92a83803bfbbf4", "state": "INCIDENT / authentication\nInitial evidence: 32 failures after 161 passes; symptom JWTExpiredError; recently modified application implementation (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nAuthority to reverse the change is prohibited.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom ceased.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is not yet been tried.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom continued.", "labels": [0, 1, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 161, "failed": 32, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8136ea1234e48de2210f4072304d950aae23c7eee3f570daf8c57df7dfb04d2b", "state": "{\"task\": \"authentication\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 623, \"failed\": 10}, \"error\": \"JWTExpiredError\", \"recent_change\": \"test fixture\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"true\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"false\", \"retry\": \"true\"}", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 623, "failed": 10, "task": "authentication", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "87a9b6aa0e844ec879ab900fef7a5f469740f251e34c76b3a7c91645e687c630", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"authentication\"><baseline passed=\"617\" failed=\"16\"/><error>unexpected null</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"granted\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [true, true, true, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 617, "failed": 16, "task": "authentication", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "8c69057b6e4611489a578a0a2937568299f7714b8598d2114b29756355dcd609", "state": "@engineer Task: pagination. First run: 199 pass, 23 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Checks are red, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Blocker is active; same retry is failed.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nEng: Patch revert is yes.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 199, "failed": 23, "task": "pagination", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "8ba13541742c7aee7f215523a44b17436e5b36de4abecf189b4bc00d7edc2083", "state": "## Issue: search\n**Baseline**: 52 passing, 17 failing\n**Error**: `unexpected null`\n**Recent change**: application implementation (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: failed.\n\u274c **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: approved.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nRevert permission: closed.", "labels": [1, 0, 4, 4, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 52, "failed": 17, "task": "search", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "1881e10b34ba8a89a8ffd16bd0ef054d0c2e24ea5049250388c9951ebf490e1f", "state": "JIRA-billing: 13 failures / 623 passes after regression. Error: connection refused. Touched: test fixture.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nIsolation test [machine configuration]: Root cause eliminated.\nQA verification: failed. PO sign-off: signed off.\nImpediment status: done. Re-test result: failed.\nIsolation test [application implementation]: Root cause remains.\nRollback approved: rejected.\nIsolation test [test fixture]: Root cause remains.\nIsolation test [external library]: Root cause remains.", "labels": [0, 0, 1, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 623, "failed": 13, "task": "billing", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "jira_ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "69d191ab70b34b4185cda208368fd1a867b8eac249d252aeac376d7d9abfda7c", "state": "TRACE task=notifications passed=240 failed=20 err=unexpected null recent=test fixture\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATE component=application implementation => failure=PERSISTS\nBLOCKER=CLEARED RETRY=FAILED\nISOLATE component=external library => failure=PERSISTS\nISOLATE component=test fixture => failure=PERSISTS\nCHECKS=OK ACCEPTED=YES\nISOLATE component=machine configuration => failure=CLEARED\nROLLBACK=OK", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 240, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "test fixture"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "stack_trace", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "bc20cd5842b6f1f70ef7f979aed0204abb184af395b9ff1401699f9271e7f5f0", "state": "fix(notifications): investigate 20 failures (unexpected null) after 635 passes. recent: machine configuration\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\ntest(external library): restored known-good \u2014 failure eliminated\nblocker: fixed | retry: failed\ntest(machine configuration): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nci: checks fail | approval: pending\ntest(test fixture): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\ntest(application implementation): restored known-good \u2014 failure persists\nrevert: rejected", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 635, "failed": 20, "task": "notifications", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "commit_msg", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "383baf865d1c864332f36c8c0e34cbc760d7297ac791f2ef23ffb3be381b837c", "state": "PR Review: caching \u2014 117\u2713 10\u2717 (connection refused). Changed: external library.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nComment: Only test fixture swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only machine configuration swap did not clear the original failure.\nComment: Only application implementation swap did not clear the original failure.\nChecks: pass. LGTM: changes requested.\nComment: Only external library swap cleared the original failure.\nBlocker: blocked. Re-run: failed.\nRevert allowed: denied.", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 117, "failed": 10, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "pr_review", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "1d68ee4659a99825e3c585f277d37329947d5802aaa7946ec1a904f102919372", "state": "Issue billing: baseline suite had 251 successes and 4 failures (unexpected null). The last touched area was application implementation; that fact alone does not establish blame.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nA clean machine configuration was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault vanished.\nA clean external library was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nPatch reversal permission: not authorized.\nA clean application implementation was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nA clean test fixture was swapped into the original snapshot by itself. The reported fault was still present.\nTransient obstruction: cleared. An identical retry: already failed.\nCurrent suite: passing. Product acceptance: confirmed.", "labels": [1, 0, 1, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, false, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 251, "failed": 4, "task": "billing", "error": "unexpected null", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "ticket", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "environment", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "391ac333ad322e54696f0dea0077fcfbacdf6923eb4eb1075e3077e9e74ae5e8", "state": "$ diagnose --task notifications\nBASELINE passed=585 failed=3 exception=timeout\nNOTICE recent_change=machine configuration (unverified signal)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nISOLATED[external library] => original_failure=ABSENT\nISOLATED[machine configuration] => original_failure=PRESENT\nBLOCKER cleared=NO; SAME_RETRY failed_before=NO\nISOLATED[application implementation] => original_failure=PRESENT\nROLLBACK allowed=YES\nLATEST checks=FAIL; accepted=YES\nISOLATED[test fixture] => original_failure=PRESENT", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 2, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 585, "failed": 3, "task": "notifications", "error": "timeout", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "terminal", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "inspect_environment", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3a4f0b825356ee6723f1cb629bba47c904ccab8a9fef1447107c4d6b2180ec21", "state": "Engineer: We are fixing uploads. The first run was 88 passing and 4 failing with JWTExpiredError. We recently touched machine configuration, but do not infer the cause from that.\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nReviewer: The temporary obstacle is still active; the exact same retry is already known to fail.\nReviewer: When we changed just the external library to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nEngineer: Right now the checks are all green, and acceptance is confirmed.\nEngineer: Reverting the patch is permitted.\nReviewer: When we changed just the machine configuration to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.\nReviewer: When we changed just the test fixture to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could not trigger the issue again.\nReviewer: When we changed just the application implementation to a known-good one from the original failure point, we could still trigger the issue.", "labels": [1, 0, 2, 4, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 88, "failed": 4, "task": "uploads", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "conversation", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "true", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "escalate", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "238602bfa1e45ab64c37d560c9b94a2f0f05e2c11587c8881f581bf0e43d1350", "state": "INCIDENT / pagination\nInitial evidence: 27 failures after 754 passes; symptom timeout; recently modified external library (possible distractor).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nPresent verification is unsuccessful; formal approval is granted.\nControl experiment\u2014only external library restored: the initial symptom continued.\nAuthority to reverse the change is approved.\nControl experiment\u2014only application implementation restored: the initial symptom continued.\nControl experiment\u2014only machine configuration restored: the initial symptom continued.\nThe short-lived impediment is resolved; repeating without changes is already failed once.\nControl experiment\u2014only test fixture restored: the initial symptom ceased.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 0, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": false, "accepted": true, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": true, "passed": 754, "failed": 27, "task": "pagination", "error": "timeout", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "incident", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "inspect_code", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "0220ced0a589fa9feace692a803693385c5a2f5b7a18052c8219b5c6bc3a212a", "state": "{\"task\": \"search\", \"baseline\": {\"passed\": 822, \"failed\": 22}, \"error\": \"assertion mismatch\", \"recent_change\": \"machine configuration\"}\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n{\"component\": \"test fixture\", \"result\": \"original_failure_absent\"}\n{\"blocker\": \"true\", \"retry\": \"false\"}\n{\"component\": \"machine configuration\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"application implementation\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"component\": \"external library\", \"result\": \"original_failure_present\"}\n{\"rollback\": \"true\"}\n{\"checks\": \"true\", \"acceptance\": \"false\"}", "labels": [0, 1, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 822, "failed": 22, "task": "search", "error": "assertion mismatch", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "json_log", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "3e3a7081bb470a0067828ee5f85de30e261e7e336f6823a2fae501021a0bf192", "state": "<diagnosis task=\"caching\"><baseline passed=\"100\" failed=\"15\"/><error>connection refused</error><recent>machine configuration</recent></diagnosis>\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\n<verification checks=\"success\" acceptance=\"denied\"/>\n<trial component=\"test fixture\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"application implementation\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<trial component=\"machine configuration\"><outcome>original_failure_present</outcome></trial>\n<rollback allowed=\"forbidden\"/>\n<blocker cleared=\"active\"/><retry failed_before=\"yes\"/>\n<trial component=\"external library\"><outcome>original_failure_absent</outcome></trial>", "labels": [0, 0, 3, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, false, true], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": true, "rollback": false, "passed": 100, "failed": 15, "task": "caching", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "machine configuration"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "xml_report", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "dependency", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}
{"id": "12ed247c0d9da09fe3e4825df036101b2e27e163b660f37d03fb1e574f7d9c6b", "state": "@engineer Task: caching. First run: 854 pass, 20 fail. Error: JWTExpiredError. Recent: application implementation (don't assume cause).\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nEng: Patch revert is no.\nEng: Checks are green, acceptance is pending.\nReviewer: Swapped only test fixture to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Swapped only machine configuration to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue gone.\nReviewer: Blocker is cleared; same retry is untried.\nReviewer: Swapped only external library to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.\nReviewer: Swapped only application implementation to known-good from failure point \u2014 issue remains.", "labels": [0, 1, 4, 1, 0], "latent": {"cleared": [false, true, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": true, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": false, "passed": 854, "failed": 20, "task": "caching", "error": "JWTExpiredError", "recent": "application implementation"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "slack_thread", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "true", "failure_source": "unknown", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "false"}
{"id": "982818aabfef852f6b7a16902a236349a04848ab11eb27fba47e4138fafe947c", "state": "## Issue: uploads\n**Baseline**: 948 passing, 27 failing\n**Error**: `connection refused`\n**Recent change**: external library (unverified)\nAll component experiments below independently restart from the same initial failure.\nRevert permission: merged.\n\u2705 **test fixture**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **resolved**.\n\u274c **machine configuration**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\n\u274c **application implementation**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nLatest CI: passing. Maintainer approval: rejected.\n\u274c **external library**: Restored to known-good \u2014 original failure **persists**.\nTransient blocker: open. Identical re-run: not run.", "labels": [0, 0, 2, 1, 1], "latent": {"cleared": [false, false, true, false], "latest_pass": true, "accepted": false, "blocker_cleared": false, "retry_failed": false, "rollback": true, "passed": 948, "failed": 27, "task": "uploads", "error": "connection refused", "recent": "external library"}, "provenance": {"generator": "renderer-diversity-v2", "split": "validation", "renderer": "github_issue", "seed": 1729}, "task_complete": "false", "should_retry": "false", "failure_source": "test", "next_action": "rerun_tests", "evidence_sufficient": "true"}